SlideShare a Scribd company logo
February 6, 2013
Public Comments Processing
Attn: FWS-R9-ES-2011-0073
Division of Policy and Directives Management
U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service
4401 N. Fairfax Drive
PDM-2042
Arlington, VA 22203
Re: Docket No. FWS-R9-ES-2011-0073, Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants;
Revisions to the Regulations for Impact Analyses of Critical Habitat.
On behalf of the 5,000 members of the American Road and Transportation Builders Association
(ARTBA), I respectfully offer comments on the joint notice of proposed rulemaking issued by
the United States National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and the United
States Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) regarding revisions to the critical habitat analysis
process.
ARTBA’s membership includes public agencies and private firms and organizations that own,
plan, design, supply and construct transportation projects throughout the country. Our industry
generates more than $380 billion annually in U.S. economic activity and sustains more than 3.3
million American jobs.
Because of the nature of their businesses, ARTBA members undertake a variety of activities that
are subject to Endangered Species Act (ESA) regulations. ARTBA’s public sector members
adopt, approve, or fund transportation plans, programs, or projects which are all subject to
multiple federal regulatory requirements. ARTBA’s private sector members plan, design,
construct and provide supplies for federal-aid transportation improvement projects. This
document represents the collective views of our 5,000 member companies and organizations.
NOAA and FWS propose to alter the process for announcing “critical habitat” for endangered
species. “Critical habitat” is an environment that is necessary for an endangered order threatened
species to subsist. Currently, the agencies issue a determination of critical habitat and
subsequently issue an economic analysis evaluating the decision. The proposed rule would
attempt to streamline this process by having the economic analysis issued at the same time as the
critical habitat designation.
ARTBA appreciates and supports this proposal to streamline the ESA regulatory process. In
general, ARTBA has long championed efforts to reduce process delays that preserve existing
regulatory safeguards. Currently, the environmental review and approval process for
2
transportation projects, which includes ESA considerations, can take anywhere from nine to 19
years to complete. This is simply too long. By taking two segments of the ESA process and
issuing them at the same time, NOAA and FWS will reduce delay while maintaining existing
levels of protection for endangered species.
Proper determination of critical habitat designation is a very important issue for both state and
local governments as well as businesses located in areas impacted by ESA concerns. A
determination of critical habitat can literally remove hundreds of miles from the possibility of
any type of development. In the transportation arena, this is especially relevant as states
promulgate transportation plans year, if not decades, in advance. If an entire area is suddenly put
“off limits” by an overly broad critical habitat designation, carefully designed plans for economic
development might be unnecessarily placed in jeopardy. At a minimum, all economic analysis
necessary for a critical habitat determination should be based on the best economic data available
and incorporate an area’s planned transportation improvements.
Also, it is important that determinations be made in a neutral fashion without any sort of bias for
or against critical habitat designation. For this reason, ARTBA asks NOAA and FWS to ensure
all economic analyses issued include a detailed explanation of how the agencies arrived at their
conclusion. This would include any assumptions made by the agencies in favor of critical habitat
designation and a complete listing of all sources considered when determining the final
economic impact of any recommended imposition of critical habitat. The more thorough the
economic analysis, the better comments received by the agencies will be in response.
In conclusion, ARTBA supports the efforts of NOAA and FWS to reduce delay in the ESA
regulatory process. However, critical habitat designations carry significant impacts and the
agencies should strive to be as thorough and transparent as possible when making these
decisions.
Sincerely,
T. Peter Ruane
President & C.E.O

More Related Content

What's hot

June 11 ARTBA T&I wotus hearing statement
June 11 ARTBA T&I wotus hearing statementJune 11 ARTBA T&I wotus hearing statement
June 11 ARTBA T&I wotus hearing statement
artba
 
01/10: FTA Right of Way Guidance
01/10: FTA Right of Way Guidance01/10: FTA Right of Way Guidance
01/10: FTA Right of Way Guidance
artba
 
Comments on DOT Planning Regulations
Comments on DOT Planning RegulationsComments on DOT Planning Regulations
Comments on DOT Planning Regulations
artba
 
ARTBA Comments Supporting Ohio’s Application for NEPA Delegation Program
ARTBA Comments Supporting Ohio’s Application for NEPA Delegation ProgramARTBA Comments Supporting Ohio’s Application for NEPA Delegation Program
ARTBA Comments Supporting Ohio’s Application for NEPA Delegation Program
artba
 
ARTBA Comments Supporting FHWA and FTA Proposed Streamlining Rule
ARTBA Comments Supporting FHWA and FTA Proposed Streamlining RuleARTBA Comments Supporting FHWA and FTA Proposed Streamlining Rule
ARTBA Comments Supporting FHWA and FTA Proposed Streamlining Rule
artba
 
GrandVictoriaConservationFinance_AnOverview
GrandVictoriaConservationFinance_AnOverviewGrandVictoriaConservationFinance_AnOverview
GrandVictoriaConservationFinance_AnOverview
Brigid Paulson
 
EPA Proposed “Waters of the United States” Rule
EPA Proposed “Waters of the United States” RuleEPA Proposed “Waters of the United States” Rule
EPA Proposed “Waters of the United States” Rule
artba
 
Coalition letter urging withdrawal of EPA/Corps “Waters of the U.S.” propose...
 Coalition letter urging withdrawal of EPA/Corps “Waters of the U.S.” propose... Coalition letter urging withdrawal of EPA/Corps “Waters of the U.S.” propose...
Coalition letter urging withdrawal of EPA/Corps “Waters of the U.S.” propose...
artba
 
ARTBA Comments on FHWA/FTA Environmental Review Process Guidance
ARTBA Comments on FHWA/FTA Environmental Review Process Guidance  ARTBA Comments on FHWA/FTA Environmental Review Process Guidance
ARTBA Comments on FHWA/FTA Environmental Review Process Guidance
artba
 
Comments Opposing Tightening Federal Ozone Regulations
 Comments Opposing Tightening Federal Ozone Regulations Comments Opposing Tightening Federal Ozone Regulations
Comments Opposing Tightening Federal Ozone Regulations
artba
 
ARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot Program
ARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot ProgramARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot Program
ARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot Program
artba
 
ARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” Rule
ARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” RuleARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” Rule
ARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” Rule
Jenny Fischer
 
FHWA MOU with the State of Alaska Regarding Delegation of CEs.
FHWA MOU with the State of Alaska Regarding Delegation of CEs.FHWA MOU with the State of Alaska Regarding Delegation of CEs.
FHWA MOU with the State of Alaska Regarding Delegation of CEs.
artba
 
Carmel Shachar: "Potential Roadblocks in Healthcare Big Data Collection"
Carmel Shachar: "Potential Roadblocks in Healthcare Big Data Collection"Carmel Shachar: "Potential Roadblocks in Healthcare Big Data Collection"
Carmel Shachar: "Potential Roadblocks in Healthcare Big Data Collection"
The Petrie-Flom Center for Health Law Policy, Biotechnology, and Bioethics
 
03/10: Draft Core Toll Concessions P3 Model Contract Guide
03/10: Draft Core Toll Concessions P3 Model Contract Guide03/10: Draft Core Toll Concessions P3 Model Contract Guide
03/10: Draft Core Toll Concessions P3 Model Contract Guide
artba
 
ARTBA Comments on “Waters of the United States” Proposed Rule
 ARTBA Comments on “Waters of the United States” Proposed Rule ARTBA Comments on “Waters of the United States” Proposed Rule
ARTBA Comments on “Waters of the United States” Proposed Rule
artba
 
Webinar UKTI- Environmental
Webinar UKTI- EnvironmentalWebinar UKTI- Environmental
Webinar UKTI- Environmental
UKinBrazilNetwork
 
02/12/14: Testimony to Senate Environment & Public Works Committee
02/12/14: Testimony to Senate Environment & Public Works Committee02/12/14: Testimony to Senate Environment & Public Works Committee
02/12/14: Testimony to Senate Environment & Public Works Committee
artba
 
LTR Wac For Small Business CMTE Hearing 7-30-14
LTR Wac For Small Business CMTE Hearing 7-30-14LTR Wac For Small Business CMTE Hearing 7-30-14
LTR Wac For Small Business CMTE Hearing 7-30-14
artba
 

What's hot (19)

June 11 ARTBA T&I wotus hearing statement
June 11 ARTBA T&I wotus hearing statementJune 11 ARTBA T&I wotus hearing statement
June 11 ARTBA T&I wotus hearing statement
 
01/10: FTA Right of Way Guidance
01/10: FTA Right of Way Guidance01/10: FTA Right of Way Guidance
01/10: FTA Right of Way Guidance
 
Comments on DOT Planning Regulations
Comments on DOT Planning RegulationsComments on DOT Planning Regulations
Comments on DOT Planning Regulations
 
ARTBA Comments Supporting Ohio’s Application for NEPA Delegation Program
ARTBA Comments Supporting Ohio’s Application for NEPA Delegation ProgramARTBA Comments Supporting Ohio’s Application for NEPA Delegation Program
ARTBA Comments Supporting Ohio’s Application for NEPA Delegation Program
 
ARTBA Comments Supporting FHWA and FTA Proposed Streamlining Rule
ARTBA Comments Supporting FHWA and FTA Proposed Streamlining RuleARTBA Comments Supporting FHWA and FTA Proposed Streamlining Rule
ARTBA Comments Supporting FHWA and FTA Proposed Streamlining Rule
 
GrandVictoriaConservationFinance_AnOverview
GrandVictoriaConservationFinance_AnOverviewGrandVictoriaConservationFinance_AnOverview
GrandVictoriaConservationFinance_AnOverview
 
EPA Proposed “Waters of the United States” Rule
EPA Proposed “Waters of the United States” RuleEPA Proposed “Waters of the United States” Rule
EPA Proposed “Waters of the United States” Rule
 
Coalition letter urging withdrawal of EPA/Corps “Waters of the U.S.” propose...
 Coalition letter urging withdrawal of EPA/Corps “Waters of the U.S.” propose... Coalition letter urging withdrawal of EPA/Corps “Waters of the U.S.” propose...
Coalition letter urging withdrawal of EPA/Corps “Waters of the U.S.” propose...
 
ARTBA Comments on FHWA/FTA Environmental Review Process Guidance
ARTBA Comments on FHWA/FTA Environmental Review Process Guidance  ARTBA Comments on FHWA/FTA Environmental Review Process Guidance
ARTBA Comments on FHWA/FTA Environmental Review Process Guidance
 
Comments Opposing Tightening Federal Ozone Regulations
 Comments Opposing Tightening Federal Ozone Regulations Comments Opposing Tightening Federal Ozone Regulations
Comments Opposing Tightening Federal Ozone Regulations
 
ARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot Program
ARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot ProgramARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot Program
ARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot Program
 
ARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” Rule
ARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” RuleARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” Rule
ARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” Rule
 
FHWA MOU with the State of Alaska Regarding Delegation of CEs.
FHWA MOU with the State of Alaska Regarding Delegation of CEs.FHWA MOU with the State of Alaska Regarding Delegation of CEs.
FHWA MOU with the State of Alaska Regarding Delegation of CEs.
 
Carmel Shachar: "Potential Roadblocks in Healthcare Big Data Collection"
Carmel Shachar: "Potential Roadblocks in Healthcare Big Data Collection"Carmel Shachar: "Potential Roadblocks in Healthcare Big Data Collection"
Carmel Shachar: "Potential Roadblocks in Healthcare Big Data Collection"
 
03/10: Draft Core Toll Concessions P3 Model Contract Guide
03/10: Draft Core Toll Concessions P3 Model Contract Guide03/10: Draft Core Toll Concessions P3 Model Contract Guide
03/10: Draft Core Toll Concessions P3 Model Contract Guide
 
ARTBA Comments on “Waters of the United States” Proposed Rule
 ARTBA Comments on “Waters of the United States” Proposed Rule ARTBA Comments on “Waters of the United States” Proposed Rule
ARTBA Comments on “Waters of the United States” Proposed Rule
 
Webinar UKTI- Environmental
Webinar UKTI- EnvironmentalWebinar UKTI- Environmental
Webinar UKTI- Environmental
 
02/12/14: Testimony to Senate Environment & Public Works Committee
02/12/14: Testimony to Senate Environment & Public Works Committee02/12/14: Testimony to Senate Environment & Public Works Committee
02/12/14: Testimony to Senate Environment & Public Works Committee
 
LTR Wac For Small Business CMTE Hearing 7-30-14
LTR Wac For Small Business CMTE Hearing 7-30-14LTR Wac For Small Business CMTE Hearing 7-30-14
LTR Wac For Small Business CMTE Hearing 7-30-14
 

Viewers also liked

05/14: WRDA Amendment on CWA Guidance
05/14: WRDA Amendment on CWA Guidance05/14: WRDA Amendment on CWA Guidance
05/14: WRDA Amendment on CWA Guidanceartba
 
02/06: MUTCD Information Request
02/06: MUTCD Information Request02/06: MUTCD Information Request
02/06: MUTCD Information Request
artba
 
Artba Map 21 Re-authorization VS Grow Act
Artba Map 21 Re-authorization VS Grow ActArtba Map 21 Re-authorization VS Grow Act
Artba Map 21 Re-authorization VS Grow Act
artba
 
03/05: State Department Approval of Keystone XL Pipeline
03/05: State Department Approval of Keystone XL Pipeline03/05: State Department Approval of Keystone XL Pipeline
03/05: State Department Approval of Keystone XL Pipeline
artba
 
03/05: Multi-Industry Permit Streamlining Letter
03/05: Multi-Industry Permit Streamlining Letter03/05: Multi-Industry Permit Streamlining Letter
03/05: Multi-Industry Permit Streamlining Letter
artba
 
09/19: NRMCA Hours of Service Exemption
09/19: NRMCA Hours of Service Exemption09/19: NRMCA Hours of Service Exemption
09/19: NRMCA Hours of Service Exemption
artba
 
The Role of Private Investment in Meeting U.S. Transportation Infrastructure ...
The Role of Private Investment in Meeting U.S. Transportation Infrastructure ...The Role of Private Investment in Meeting U.S. Transportation Infrastructure ...
The Role of Private Investment in Meeting U.S. Transportation Infrastructure ...
artba
 
ARTBA EmCap
ARTBA EmCapARTBA EmCap
ARTBA EmCap
artba
 
09/30: Alternative Technical Concepts in Design Build
09/30: Alternative Technical Concepts in Design Build09/30: Alternative Technical Concepts in Design Build
09/30: Alternative Technical Concepts in Design Build
artba
 
09/07/11: Amicus Brief in PPL Montana LLC vs. Montana
09/07/11: Amicus Brief in PPL Montana LLC vs. Montana09/07/11: Amicus Brief in PPL Montana LLC vs. Montana
09/07/11: Amicus Brief in PPL Montana LLC vs. Montana
artba
 
Artba Senate Finance Committee May
Artba Senate Finance Committee MayArtba Senate Finance Committee May
Artba Senate Finance Committee May
artba
 
Artba comments on OSHA workplace injury and illness reporting rule
Artba comments on OSHA workplace injury and illness reporting ruleArtba comments on OSHA workplace injury and illness reporting rule
Artba comments on OSHA workplace injury and illness reporting rule
artba
 
04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency
04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency
04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency
artba
 
05/20: Support for House Keystone Pipeline Bill
05/20: Support for House Keystone Pipeline Bill05/20: Support for House Keystone Pipeline Bill
05/20: Support for House Keystone Pipeline Bill
artba
 
03/12: OSHA Proposed Changes to MUTCD
03/12: OSHA Proposed Changes to MUTCD03/12: OSHA Proposed Changes to MUTCD
03/12: OSHA Proposed Changes to MUTCD
artba
 
Impact of Propsed Cafe Standards on HTF Revenues- William Buencher ARTBA
Impact of Propsed Cafe Standards on HTF Revenues- William Buencher ARTBAImpact of Propsed Cafe Standards on HTF Revenues- William Buencher ARTBA
Impact of Propsed Cafe Standards on HTF Revenues- William Buencher ARTBA
artba
 
Public Transportation
Public TransportationPublic Transportation
Public Transportationartba
 
11/06: EPA Connectivity Report
11/06: EPA Connectivity Report11/06: EPA Connectivity Report
11/06: EPA Connectivity Report
artba
 

Viewers also liked (18)

05/14: WRDA Amendment on CWA Guidance
05/14: WRDA Amendment on CWA Guidance05/14: WRDA Amendment on CWA Guidance
05/14: WRDA Amendment on CWA Guidance
 
02/06: MUTCD Information Request
02/06: MUTCD Information Request02/06: MUTCD Information Request
02/06: MUTCD Information Request
 
Artba Map 21 Re-authorization VS Grow Act
Artba Map 21 Re-authorization VS Grow ActArtba Map 21 Re-authorization VS Grow Act
Artba Map 21 Re-authorization VS Grow Act
 
03/05: State Department Approval of Keystone XL Pipeline
03/05: State Department Approval of Keystone XL Pipeline03/05: State Department Approval of Keystone XL Pipeline
03/05: State Department Approval of Keystone XL Pipeline
 
03/05: Multi-Industry Permit Streamlining Letter
03/05: Multi-Industry Permit Streamlining Letter03/05: Multi-Industry Permit Streamlining Letter
03/05: Multi-Industry Permit Streamlining Letter
 
09/19: NRMCA Hours of Service Exemption
09/19: NRMCA Hours of Service Exemption09/19: NRMCA Hours of Service Exemption
09/19: NRMCA Hours of Service Exemption
 
The Role of Private Investment in Meeting U.S. Transportation Infrastructure ...
The Role of Private Investment in Meeting U.S. Transportation Infrastructure ...The Role of Private Investment in Meeting U.S. Transportation Infrastructure ...
The Role of Private Investment in Meeting U.S. Transportation Infrastructure ...
 
ARTBA EmCap
ARTBA EmCapARTBA EmCap
ARTBA EmCap
 
09/30: Alternative Technical Concepts in Design Build
09/30: Alternative Technical Concepts in Design Build09/30: Alternative Technical Concepts in Design Build
09/30: Alternative Technical Concepts in Design Build
 
09/07/11: Amicus Brief in PPL Montana LLC vs. Montana
09/07/11: Amicus Brief in PPL Montana LLC vs. Montana09/07/11: Amicus Brief in PPL Montana LLC vs. Montana
09/07/11: Amicus Brief in PPL Montana LLC vs. Montana
 
Artba Senate Finance Committee May
Artba Senate Finance Committee MayArtba Senate Finance Committee May
Artba Senate Finance Committee May
 
Artba comments on OSHA workplace injury and illness reporting rule
Artba comments on OSHA workplace injury and illness reporting ruleArtba comments on OSHA workplace injury and illness reporting rule
Artba comments on OSHA workplace injury and illness reporting rule
 
04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency
04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency
04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency
 
05/20: Support for House Keystone Pipeline Bill
05/20: Support for House Keystone Pipeline Bill05/20: Support for House Keystone Pipeline Bill
05/20: Support for House Keystone Pipeline Bill
 
03/12: OSHA Proposed Changes to MUTCD
03/12: OSHA Proposed Changes to MUTCD03/12: OSHA Proposed Changes to MUTCD
03/12: OSHA Proposed Changes to MUTCD
 
Impact of Propsed Cafe Standards on HTF Revenues- William Buencher ARTBA
Impact of Propsed Cafe Standards on HTF Revenues- William Buencher ARTBAImpact of Propsed Cafe Standards on HTF Revenues- William Buencher ARTBA
Impact of Propsed Cafe Standards on HTF Revenues- William Buencher ARTBA
 
Public Transportation
Public TransportationPublic Transportation
Public Transportation
 
11/06: EPA Connectivity Report
11/06: EPA Connectivity Report11/06: EPA Connectivity Report
11/06: EPA Connectivity Report
 

Similar to Regulatory Legal ARTBA

The Port Authority of New York and New JerseyProposal for .docx
The Port Authority of New York and New JerseyProposal for .docxThe Port Authority of New York and New JerseyProposal for .docx
The Port Authority of New York and New JerseyProposal for .docx
ssusera34210
 
Storm Surge and Flood Protection
Storm Surge and Flood ProtectionStorm Surge and Flood Protection
Storm Surge and Flood Protection
aiahouston
 
08/28: Texas Assumption of CE Responsibilities
08/28: Texas Assumption of CE Responsibilities08/28: Texas Assumption of CE Responsibilities
08/28: Texas Assumption of CE Responsibilities
artba
 
05/08: California Assumption of CE Responsibilities
05/08: California Assumption of CE Responsibilities05/08: California Assumption of CE Responsibilities
05/08: California Assumption of CE Responsibilities
artba
 
August 2021 edition of the NSW Roadside Environment Committee Newsletter
August 2021 edition of the NSW Roadside Environment Committee NewsletterAugust 2021 edition of the NSW Roadside Environment Committee Newsletter
August 2021 edition of the NSW Roadside Environment Committee Newsletter
Neil Dufty
 
Sepa August2011
Sepa August2011Sepa August2011
Sepa August2011
abakalian
 
Department of Agriculture Preliminary Regulatory Reform Plan
Department of Agriculture Preliminary Regulatory Reform PlanDepartment of Agriculture Preliminary Regulatory Reform Plan
Department of Agriculture Preliminary Regulatory Reform Plan
Obama White House
 
FY 2013 R&D REPORT January 6 2014 - National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administ...
FY 2013 R&D REPORT January 6 2014 - National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administ...FY 2013 R&D REPORT January 6 2014 - National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administ...
FY 2013 R&D REPORT January 6 2014 - National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administ...
Lyle Birkey
 
Best Practices for NEPA Compliance and Related Permitting for Projects on In...
Best Practices for NEPA Compliance and Related Permitting for  Projects on In...Best Practices for NEPA Compliance and Related Permitting for  Projects on In...
Best Practices for NEPA Compliance and Related Permitting for Projects on In...
Trihydro Corporation
 
Agriculture Regulatory Reform Plan August 2011
Agriculture Regulatory Reform Plan August 2011Agriculture Regulatory Reform Plan August 2011
Agriculture Regulatory Reform Plan August 2011
Obama White House
 
Indicators_of_dynamics_in_fishery_resource_7.ppt
Indicators_of_dynamics_in_fishery_resource_7.pptIndicators_of_dynamics_in_fishery_resource_7.ppt
Indicators_of_dynamics_in_fishery_resource_7.ppt
AmitSharma3227
 
Utah DEQ State of the Environment 2015
Utah DEQ State of the Environment 2015Utah DEQ State of the Environment 2015
Utah DEQ State of the Environment 2015
State of Utah, Salt Lake City
 
EarthView Brochure - 2
EarthView Brochure - 2EarthView Brochure - 2
EarthView Brochure - 2
Sander Bonvell
 
ARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” Rule
ARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” RuleARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” Rule
ARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” Rule
artba
 
NERO ESA Section 7 presentation to EPA
NERO ESA Section 7 presentation to EPANERO ESA Section 7 presentation to EPA
NERO ESA Section 7 presentation to EPA
wbarnhill3
 
Thurston County In-Lieu Fee Mitigation Program
Thurston County In-Lieu Fee Mitigation ProgramThurston County In-Lieu Fee Mitigation Program
Thurston County In-Lieu Fee Mitigation Program
Nisqually River Council
 
SAFE Final Report_12-07_Final_Corrected
SAFE Final Report_12-07_Final_CorrectedSAFE Final Report_12-07_Final_Corrected
SAFE Final Report_12-07_Final_Corrected
Shira Yashphe
 
SAFE Final Report_12-07_Final
SAFE Final Report_12-07_FinalSAFE Final Report_12-07_Final
SAFE Final Report_12-07_Final
Nina Gyourgis
 
2013 Managing the Risk
2013 Managing the Risk2013 Managing the Risk
2013 Managing the Risk
Jamie Schwartz
 
Testimony Of ARTBA July 15 EPA Veto Hearing
Testimony Of ARTBA  July 15 EPA Veto HearingTestimony Of ARTBA  July 15 EPA Veto Hearing
Testimony Of ARTBA July 15 EPA Veto Hearing
artba
 

Similar to Regulatory Legal ARTBA (20)

The Port Authority of New York and New JerseyProposal for .docx
The Port Authority of New York and New JerseyProposal for .docxThe Port Authority of New York and New JerseyProposal for .docx
The Port Authority of New York and New JerseyProposal for .docx
 
Storm Surge and Flood Protection
Storm Surge and Flood ProtectionStorm Surge and Flood Protection
Storm Surge and Flood Protection
 
08/28: Texas Assumption of CE Responsibilities
08/28: Texas Assumption of CE Responsibilities08/28: Texas Assumption of CE Responsibilities
08/28: Texas Assumption of CE Responsibilities
 
05/08: California Assumption of CE Responsibilities
05/08: California Assumption of CE Responsibilities05/08: California Assumption of CE Responsibilities
05/08: California Assumption of CE Responsibilities
 
August 2021 edition of the NSW Roadside Environment Committee Newsletter
August 2021 edition of the NSW Roadside Environment Committee NewsletterAugust 2021 edition of the NSW Roadside Environment Committee Newsletter
August 2021 edition of the NSW Roadside Environment Committee Newsletter
 
Sepa August2011
Sepa August2011Sepa August2011
Sepa August2011
 
Department of Agriculture Preliminary Regulatory Reform Plan
Department of Agriculture Preliminary Regulatory Reform PlanDepartment of Agriculture Preliminary Regulatory Reform Plan
Department of Agriculture Preliminary Regulatory Reform Plan
 
FY 2013 R&D REPORT January 6 2014 - National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administ...
FY 2013 R&D REPORT January 6 2014 - National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administ...FY 2013 R&D REPORT January 6 2014 - National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administ...
FY 2013 R&D REPORT January 6 2014 - National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administ...
 
Best Practices for NEPA Compliance and Related Permitting for Projects on In...
Best Practices for NEPA Compliance and Related Permitting for  Projects on In...Best Practices for NEPA Compliance and Related Permitting for  Projects on In...
Best Practices for NEPA Compliance and Related Permitting for Projects on In...
 
Agriculture Regulatory Reform Plan August 2011
Agriculture Regulatory Reform Plan August 2011Agriculture Regulatory Reform Plan August 2011
Agriculture Regulatory Reform Plan August 2011
 
Indicators_of_dynamics_in_fishery_resource_7.ppt
Indicators_of_dynamics_in_fishery_resource_7.pptIndicators_of_dynamics_in_fishery_resource_7.ppt
Indicators_of_dynamics_in_fishery_resource_7.ppt
 
Utah DEQ State of the Environment 2015
Utah DEQ State of the Environment 2015Utah DEQ State of the Environment 2015
Utah DEQ State of the Environment 2015
 
EarthView Brochure - 2
EarthView Brochure - 2EarthView Brochure - 2
EarthView Brochure - 2
 
ARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” Rule
ARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” RuleARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” Rule
ARTBA Comments on EPA “Exceptional Events” Rule
 
NERO ESA Section 7 presentation to EPA
NERO ESA Section 7 presentation to EPANERO ESA Section 7 presentation to EPA
NERO ESA Section 7 presentation to EPA
 
Thurston County In-Lieu Fee Mitigation Program
Thurston County In-Lieu Fee Mitigation ProgramThurston County In-Lieu Fee Mitigation Program
Thurston County In-Lieu Fee Mitigation Program
 
SAFE Final Report_12-07_Final_Corrected
SAFE Final Report_12-07_Final_CorrectedSAFE Final Report_12-07_Final_Corrected
SAFE Final Report_12-07_Final_Corrected
 
SAFE Final Report_12-07_Final
SAFE Final Report_12-07_FinalSAFE Final Report_12-07_Final
SAFE Final Report_12-07_Final
 
2013 Managing the Risk
2013 Managing the Risk2013 Managing the Risk
2013 Managing the Risk
 
Testimony Of ARTBA July 15 EPA Veto Hearing
Testimony Of ARTBA  July 15 EPA Veto HearingTestimony Of ARTBA  July 15 EPA Veto Hearing
Testimony Of ARTBA July 15 EPA Veto Hearing
 

More from artba

2017 media kit
2017 media kit2017 media kit
2017 media kit
artba
 
September October tb_2016
September October tb_2016September October tb_2016
September October tb_2016
artba
 
Transportation Builder July/August 2016
Transportation Builder July/August 2016Transportation Builder July/August 2016
Transportation Builder July/August 2016
artba
 
The National Work Zone Management Conference Agenda 2016
The National Work Zone Management Conference Agenda 2016The National Work Zone Management Conference Agenda 2016
The National Work Zone Management Conference Agenda 2016
artba
 
ARTBA 2016 National Convention Program
ARTBA 2016 National Convention ProgramARTBA 2016 National Convention Program
ARTBA 2016 National Convention Program
artba
 
May/June Transportation Builder
May/June Transportation BuilderMay/June Transportation Builder
May/June Transportation Builder
artba
 
Northeastern regional meeting
Northeastern regional meetingNortheastern regional meeting
Northeastern regional meeting
artba
 
Southern regional meeting
Southern regional meetingSouthern regional meeting
Southern regional meeting
artba
 
Central regional meeting
Central regional meetingCentral regional meeting
Central regional meeting
artba
 
Western regional meeting
Western regional meetingWestern regional meeting
Western regional meeting
artba
 
Western regional meeting
Western regional meetingWestern regional meeting
Western regional meeting
artba
 
July/August 2015 TB magazine
July/August 2015 TB magazineJuly/August 2015 TB magazine
July/August 2015 TB magazine
artba
 
September/October 2015 TB magazine
September/October 2015 TB magazineSeptember/October 2015 TB magazine
September/October 2015 TB magazine
artba
 
November/December 2015 TB
November/December 2015 TBNovember/December 2015 TB
November/December 2015 TB
artba
 
January/February 2016 TB
January/February 2016 TBJanuary/February 2016 TB
January/February 2016 TB
artba
 
March/April 2016 TB
March/April 2016 TBMarch/April 2016 TB
March/April 2016 TB
artba
 
2016 ­ARTBA FIP Schedule
2016 ­ARTBA FIP Schedule2016 ­ARTBA FIP Schedule
2016 ­ARTBA FIP Schedule
artba
 
2016 ARTBA FIP Program
2016 ARTBA FIP Program2016 ARTBA FIP Program
2016 ARTBA FIP Program
artba
 
2016 ILDP Agenda
2016 ILDP Agenda2016 ILDP Agenda
2016 ILDP Agenda
artba
 
P3 Agenda 2016
P3 Agenda 2016P3 Agenda 2016
P3 Agenda 2016
artba
 

More from artba (20)

2017 media kit
2017 media kit2017 media kit
2017 media kit
 
September October tb_2016
September October tb_2016September October tb_2016
September October tb_2016
 
Transportation Builder July/August 2016
Transportation Builder July/August 2016Transportation Builder July/August 2016
Transportation Builder July/August 2016
 
The National Work Zone Management Conference Agenda 2016
The National Work Zone Management Conference Agenda 2016The National Work Zone Management Conference Agenda 2016
The National Work Zone Management Conference Agenda 2016
 
ARTBA 2016 National Convention Program
ARTBA 2016 National Convention ProgramARTBA 2016 National Convention Program
ARTBA 2016 National Convention Program
 
May/June Transportation Builder
May/June Transportation BuilderMay/June Transportation Builder
May/June Transportation Builder
 
Northeastern regional meeting
Northeastern regional meetingNortheastern regional meeting
Northeastern regional meeting
 
Southern regional meeting
Southern regional meetingSouthern regional meeting
Southern regional meeting
 
Central regional meeting
Central regional meetingCentral regional meeting
Central regional meeting
 
Western regional meeting
Western regional meetingWestern regional meeting
Western regional meeting
 
Western regional meeting
Western regional meetingWestern regional meeting
Western regional meeting
 
July/August 2015 TB magazine
July/August 2015 TB magazineJuly/August 2015 TB magazine
July/August 2015 TB magazine
 
September/October 2015 TB magazine
September/October 2015 TB magazineSeptember/October 2015 TB magazine
September/October 2015 TB magazine
 
November/December 2015 TB
November/December 2015 TBNovember/December 2015 TB
November/December 2015 TB
 
January/February 2016 TB
January/February 2016 TBJanuary/February 2016 TB
January/February 2016 TB
 
March/April 2016 TB
March/April 2016 TBMarch/April 2016 TB
March/April 2016 TB
 
2016 ­ARTBA FIP Schedule
2016 ­ARTBA FIP Schedule2016 ­ARTBA FIP Schedule
2016 ­ARTBA FIP Schedule
 
2016 ARTBA FIP Program
2016 ARTBA FIP Program2016 ARTBA FIP Program
2016 ARTBA FIP Program
 
2016 ILDP Agenda
2016 ILDP Agenda2016 ILDP Agenda
2016 ILDP Agenda
 
P3 Agenda 2016
P3 Agenda 2016P3 Agenda 2016
P3 Agenda 2016
 

Recently uploaded

Company Valuation webinar series - Tuesday, 4 June 2024
Company Valuation webinar series - Tuesday, 4 June 2024Company Valuation webinar series - Tuesday, 4 June 2024
Company Valuation webinar series - Tuesday, 4 June 2024
FelixPerez547899
 
Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431
Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431
Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431
ecamare2
 
Part 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 Slowdown
Part 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 SlowdownPart 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 Slowdown
Part 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 Slowdown
jeffkluth1
 
Building Your Employer Brand with Social Media
Building Your Employer Brand with Social MediaBuilding Your Employer Brand with Social Media
Building Your Employer Brand with Social Media
LuanWise
 
Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta Matta Matka Kalyan Chart Satta Matka
Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta Matta Matka Kalyan Chart Satta MatkaDpboss Matka Guessing Satta Matta Matka Kalyan Chart Satta Matka
Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta Matta Matka Kalyan Chart Satta Matka
➒➌➎➏➑➐➋➑➐➐Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta Matka Kalyan Chart Indian Matka
 
Best Forex Brokers Comparison in INDIA 2024
Best Forex Brokers Comparison in INDIA 2024Best Forex Brokers Comparison in INDIA 2024
Best Forex Brokers Comparison in INDIA 2024
Top Forex Brokers Review
 
Satta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Kalyan Chart Indian Matka Kalyan panel Chart
Satta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Kalyan Chart Indian Matka Kalyan panel ChartSatta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Kalyan Chart Indian Matka Kalyan panel Chart
Satta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Kalyan Chart Indian Matka Kalyan panel Chart
➒➌➎➏➑➐➋➑➐➐Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta Matka Kalyan Chart Indian Matka
 
❼❷⓿❺❻❷❽❷❼❽ Dpboss Matka Result Satta Matka Guessing Satta Fix jodi Kalyan Fin...
❼❷⓿❺❻❷❽❷❼❽ Dpboss Matka Result Satta Matka Guessing Satta Fix jodi Kalyan Fin...❼❷⓿❺❻❷❽❷❼❽ Dpboss Matka Result Satta Matka Guessing Satta Fix jodi Kalyan Fin...
❼❷⓿❺❻❷❽❷❼❽ Dpboss Matka Result Satta Matka Guessing Satta Fix jodi Kalyan Fin...
❼❷⓿❺❻❷❽❷❼❽ Dpboss Kalyan Satta Matka Guessing Matka Result Main Bazar chart
 
Mastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnap
Mastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnapMastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnap
Mastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnap
Norma Mushkat Gaffin
 
Lundin Gold Corporate Presentation - June 2024
Lundin Gold Corporate Presentation - June 2024Lundin Gold Corporate Presentation - June 2024
Lundin Gold Corporate Presentation - June 2024
Adnet Communications
 
Digital Transformation Frameworks: Driving Digital Excellence
Digital Transformation Frameworks: Driving Digital ExcellenceDigital Transformation Frameworks: Driving Digital Excellence
Digital Transformation Frameworks: Driving Digital Excellence
Operational Excellence Consulting
 
HOW TO START UP A COMPANY A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE.pdf
HOW TO START UP A COMPANY A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE.pdfHOW TO START UP A COMPANY A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE.pdf
HOW TO START UP A COMPANY A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE.pdf
46adnanshahzad
 
Brian Fitzsimmons on the Business Strategy and Content Flywheel of Barstool S...
Brian Fitzsimmons on the Business Strategy and Content Flywheel of Barstool S...Brian Fitzsimmons on the Business Strategy and Content Flywheel of Barstool S...
Brian Fitzsimmons on the Business Strategy and Content Flywheel of Barstool S...
Neil Horowitz
 
Creative Web Design Company in Singapore
Creative Web Design Company in SingaporeCreative Web Design Company in Singapore
Creative Web Design Company in Singapore
techboxsqauremedia
 
Best practices for project execution and delivery
Best practices for project execution and deliveryBest practices for project execution and delivery
Best practices for project execution and delivery
CLIVE MINCHIN
 
The Genesis of BriansClub.cm Famous Dark WEb Platform
The Genesis of BriansClub.cm Famous Dark WEb PlatformThe Genesis of BriansClub.cm Famous Dark WEb Platform
The Genesis of BriansClub.cm Famous Dark WEb Platform
SabaaSudozai
 
Call 8867766396 Satta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta batta Matka 420 Satta...
Call 8867766396 Satta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta batta Matka 420 Satta...Call 8867766396 Satta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta batta Matka 420 Satta...
Call 8867766396 Satta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta batta Matka 420 Satta...
bosssp10
 
Unveiling the Dynamic Personalities, Key Dates, and Horoscope Insights: Gemin...
Unveiling the Dynamic Personalities, Key Dates, and Horoscope Insights: Gemin...Unveiling the Dynamic Personalities, Key Dates, and Horoscope Insights: Gemin...
Unveiling the Dynamic Personalities, Key Dates, and Horoscope Insights: Gemin...
my Pandit
 
Chapter 7 Final business management sciences .ppt
Chapter 7 Final business management sciences .pptChapter 7 Final business management sciences .ppt
Chapter 7 Final business management sciences .ppt
ssuser567e2d
 
Industrial Tech SW: Category Renewal and Creation
Industrial Tech SW:  Category Renewal and CreationIndustrial Tech SW:  Category Renewal and Creation
Industrial Tech SW: Category Renewal and Creation
Christian Dahlen
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Company Valuation webinar series - Tuesday, 4 June 2024
Company Valuation webinar series - Tuesday, 4 June 2024Company Valuation webinar series - Tuesday, 4 June 2024
Company Valuation webinar series - Tuesday, 4 June 2024
 
Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431
Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431
Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431
 
Part 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 Slowdown
Part 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 SlowdownPart 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 Slowdown
Part 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 Slowdown
 
Building Your Employer Brand with Social Media
Building Your Employer Brand with Social MediaBuilding Your Employer Brand with Social Media
Building Your Employer Brand with Social Media
 
Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta Matta Matka Kalyan Chart Satta Matka
Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta Matta Matka Kalyan Chart Satta MatkaDpboss Matka Guessing Satta Matta Matka Kalyan Chart Satta Matka
Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta Matta Matka Kalyan Chart Satta Matka
 
Best Forex Brokers Comparison in INDIA 2024
Best Forex Brokers Comparison in INDIA 2024Best Forex Brokers Comparison in INDIA 2024
Best Forex Brokers Comparison in INDIA 2024
 
Satta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Kalyan Chart Indian Matka Kalyan panel Chart
Satta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Kalyan Chart Indian Matka Kalyan panel ChartSatta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Kalyan Chart Indian Matka Kalyan panel Chart
Satta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Kalyan Chart Indian Matka Kalyan panel Chart
 
❼❷⓿❺❻❷❽❷❼❽ Dpboss Matka Result Satta Matka Guessing Satta Fix jodi Kalyan Fin...
❼❷⓿❺❻❷❽❷❼❽ Dpboss Matka Result Satta Matka Guessing Satta Fix jodi Kalyan Fin...❼❷⓿❺❻❷❽❷❼❽ Dpboss Matka Result Satta Matka Guessing Satta Fix jodi Kalyan Fin...
❼❷⓿❺❻❷❽❷❼❽ Dpboss Matka Result Satta Matka Guessing Satta Fix jodi Kalyan Fin...
 
Mastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnap
Mastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnapMastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnap
Mastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnap
 
Lundin Gold Corporate Presentation - June 2024
Lundin Gold Corporate Presentation - June 2024Lundin Gold Corporate Presentation - June 2024
Lundin Gold Corporate Presentation - June 2024
 
Digital Transformation Frameworks: Driving Digital Excellence
Digital Transformation Frameworks: Driving Digital ExcellenceDigital Transformation Frameworks: Driving Digital Excellence
Digital Transformation Frameworks: Driving Digital Excellence
 
HOW TO START UP A COMPANY A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE.pdf
HOW TO START UP A COMPANY A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE.pdfHOW TO START UP A COMPANY A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE.pdf
HOW TO START UP A COMPANY A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE.pdf
 
Brian Fitzsimmons on the Business Strategy and Content Flywheel of Barstool S...
Brian Fitzsimmons on the Business Strategy and Content Flywheel of Barstool S...Brian Fitzsimmons on the Business Strategy and Content Flywheel of Barstool S...
Brian Fitzsimmons on the Business Strategy and Content Flywheel of Barstool S...
 
Creative Web Design Company in Singapore
Creative Web Design Company in SingaporeCreative Web Design Company in Singapore
Creative Web Design Company in Singapore
 
Best practices for project execution and delivery
Best practices for project execution and deliveryBest practices for project execution and delivery
Best practices for project execution and delivery
 
The Genesis of BriansClub.cm Famous Dark WEb Platform
The Genesis of BriansClub.cm Famous Dark WEb PlatformThe Genesis of BriansClub.cm Famous Dark WEb Platform
The Genesis of BriansClub.cm Famous Dark WEb Platform
 
Call 8867766396 Satta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta batta Matka 420 Satta...
Call 8867766396 Satta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta batta Matka 420 Satta...Call 8867766396 Satta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta batta Matka 420 Satta...
Call 8867766396 Satta Matka Dpboss Matka Guessing Satta batta Matka 420 Satta...
 
Unveiling the Dynamic Personalities, Key Dates, and Horoscope Insights: Gemin...
Unveiling the Dynamic Personalities, Key Dates, and Horoscope Insights: Gemin...Unveiling the Dynamic Personalities, Key Dates, and Horoscope Insights: Gemin...
Unveiling the Dynamic Personalities, Key Dates, and Horoscope Insights: Gemin...
 
Chapter 7 Final business management sciences .ppt
Chapter 7 Final business management sciences .pptChapter 7 Final business management sciences .ppt
Chapter 7 Final business management sciences .ppt
 
Industrial Tech SW: Category Renewal and Creation
Industrial Tech SW:  Category Renewal and CreationIndustrial Tech SW:  Category Renewal and Creation
Industrial Tech SW: Category Renewal and Creation
 

Regulatory Legal ARTBA

  • 1. February 6, 2013 Public Comments Processing Attn: FWS-R9-ES-2011-0073 Division of Policy and Directives Management U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service 4401 N. Fairfax Drive PDM-2042 Arlington, VA 22203 Re: Docket No. FWS-R9-ES-2011-0073, Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Revisions to the Regulations for Impact Analyses of Critical Habitat. On behalf of the 5,000 members of the American Road and Transportation Builders Association (ARTBA), I respectfully offer comments on the joint notice of proposed rulemaking issued by the United States National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and the United States Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) regarding revisions to the critical habitat analysis process. ARTBA’s membership includes public agencies and private firms and organizations that own, plan, design, supply and construct transportation projects throughout the country. Our industry generates more than $380 billion annually in U.S. economic activity and sustains more than 3.3 million American jobs. Because of the nature of their businesses, ARTBA members undertake a variety of activities that are subject to Endangered Species Act (ESA) regulations. ARTBA’s public sector members adopt, approve, or fund transportation plans, programs, or projects which are all subject to multiple federal regulatory requirements. ARTBA’s private sector members plan, design, construct and provide supplies for federal-aid transportation improvement projects. This document represents the collective views of our 5,000 member companies and organizations. NOAA and FWS propose to alter the process for announcing “critical habitat” for endangered species. “Critical habitat” is an environment that is necessary for an endangered order threatened species to subsist. Currently, the agencies issue a determination of critical habitat and subsequently issue an economic analysis evaluating the decision. The proposed rule would attempt to streamline this process by having the economic analysis issued at the same time as the critical habitat designation. ARTBA appreciates and supports this proposal to streamline the ESA regulatory process. In general, ARTBA has long championed efforts to reduce process delays that preserve existing regulatory safeguards. Currently, the environmental review and approval process for
  • 2. 2 transportation projects, which includes ESA considerations, can take anywhere from nine to 19 years to complete. This is simply too long. By taking two segments of the ESA process and issuing them at the same time, NOAA and FWS will reduce delay while maintaining existing levels of protection for endangered species. Proper determination of critical habitat designation is a very important issue for both state and local governments as well as businesses located in areas impacted by ESA concerns. A determination of critical habitat can literally remove hundreds of miles from the possibility of any type of development. In the transportation arena, this is especially relevant as states promulgate transportation plans year, if not decades, in advance. If an entire area is suddenly put “off limits” by an overly broad critical habitat designation, carefully designed plans for economic development might be unnecessarily placed in jeopardy. At a minimum, all economic analysis necessary for a critical habitat determination should be based on the best economic data available and incorporate an area’s planned transportation improvements. Also, it is important that determinations be made in a neutral fashion without any sort of bias for or against critical habitat designation. For this reason, ARTBA asks NOAA and FWS to ensure all economic analyses issued include a detailed explanation of how the agencies arrived at their conclusion. This would include any assumptions made by the agencies in favor of critical habitat designation and a complete listing of all sources considered when determining the final economic impact of any recommended imposition of critical habitat. The more thorough the economic analysis, the better comments received by the agencies will be in response. In conclusion, ARTBA supports the efforts of NOAA and FWS to reduce delay in the ESA regulatory process. However, critical habitat designations carry significant impacts and the agencies should strive to be as thorough and transparent as possible when making these decisions. Sincerely, T. Peter Ruane President & C.E.O