SPATIAL
VARIABILITY IN
SOIL
PHOSPHORUS
OLIVIA GROVE
MENTORS: DR. ERIN BROOKS &
SCOTT FENNEMA
THE PROBLEM • HIGH PHOSPHORUS (P)
LOADING TO FERNAN LAKE
• TOXIC BLUE-GREEN ALGAE
(CYANOBACTERIA)
• EUTROPHICATION
• CDA EXPERIENCING INCREASED P
LOADING 
• POTENTIAL FOR EUTROPHICATION IN
THE FUTURE
Photo via Idaho DEQ
WHY IS IT
IMPORTANT?
• UNPOTABLE WATER,
CARCINOGENS, FISH KILL
• CYANOBACTERIA &
EUTROPHICATION RESTRICTS
WATER USE
• TOURISM
• HEAVY METALS IN LAKEBED
SEDIMENTS
• 83 MILLION TONS ZINC,
LEAD, ARSENIC, CADMIUM
RESEARCH
• WHERE IS THE PHOSPHORUS
COMING FROM?
• FOREST, AGRICULTURE
• THICK LITTER LAYER, AG
FERTILIZATION APPLICATIONS
• HOW DO WE MANAGE IT?
• IDAHO DEQ AND TRIBE
https://www.usask.ca/agriculture/plantsci/winter_cereals/
P BACKGROUND • PARTICULATE
• P IS ATTACHED TO SOIL MATERIAL
• EROSION DRIVES PARTICULATE P
MOVEMENT
• SOLUBLE
• MOST READILY AVAILABLE TO PLANTS AND
ALGAE (BIOAVAILABLE)
• DIFFICULT TO MANAGE
• RUNOFF DRIVES MOVEMENT
OBJECTIVES
• COMPARE SOIL P CONCENTRATIONS IN FOREST
AND AG LAND TYPES IN THE CDA BASIN
• IDENTIFY DRIVERS OF SPATIAL VARIABILITY OF
PHOSPHORUS WITHIN THESE LAND TYPES
METHODOLOGY
• IDAHO DEQ AND COEUR D’ALENE TRIBE IDENTIFIED
PRIORITY WATERSHEDS
• FOREST: FERNAN, WOLF LODGE
• AG: LAKE CREEK
• FACTORS DRIVING P DISTRIBUTION
• TOPOGRAPHY, LITTER THICKNESS, VEGETATIVE GROWTH,
DEPOSITION (ROADS, CREEKS, BUFFERS)
SAMPLING PROTOCOL
• USED GIS TO DETERMINE KEY
SAMPLING LOCATIONS
• SAMPLED 0-7 CM DEPTH
• MEASURED:
• LITTER THICKNESS, DRY MASS & SOIL
PH AND MOISTURE CONTENT
• ESTIMATED FOREST CANOPY COVER
• ANALYZED SOIL SAMPLES FOR:
TOTAL P
MEHLICH III, WATER EXTRACTIONS
AG SAMPLING
LOCATIONS
16 SAMPLES AT LAKE CREEK
6 -7 YEARS TIMOTHY HAY FOLLOWED BY
2 YEARS OF GRAIN
GROWER APPLIES 20 LB/AC/YR P
FOREST SAMPLING
LOCATIONS
38 SAMPLES AT FERNAN
CREEK
19 SAMPLES AT WOLF
LODGE CREEK
RESULTS
RESULTS
15
16
17
18
Ag Forest
Water Soluble P (mg/kg)
RESULTS
Error bars represent 1 standard deviation
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
All Forest Lake Creek Agriculture
TotalSoilP(mg/kg)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
All Forest Lake Creek Agriculture
MehlichP(mg/kg)
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Forest Ag
TotalSoilP(mg/kg)
Toe slopes
Up slope positions
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Forest Ag
MehlichP(mg/kg)
Toe slopes
Up slope positions
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
Wetlands Grass Roads Forest Creek
TotalPhosphorus(mg/kg)
RESULTS – FERNAN TOTAL PHOSPHORUS
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
Wetlands Grass Roads Forest Creek
MehlichExtractableSoil
Phosphorus(mg/L)
RESULTS – FERNAN MEHLICH III PHOSPHORUS
CONCLUSION
• HIGHER TOTALP CONCENTRATIONS IN FOREST
(NOT STATISTICALLY SIGNIFICANT)
• EXTRACTABLE P TENDS TO BE HIGHER IN AG
SETTINGS COMARED TO FOREST
• P IN FOREST SETTING SHOULD ALSO BE MANAGED
– NOT JUST AG
• FOREST TOE SLOPE HAD HIGHEST TOTAL P CONC
• 1. LAKE CREEK AG VARIABILITY IS LOWER THAN
FOREST
• 2. TOPOGRAPHIC POSITION INFLUENCED P CONC
• 3. MORE SAMPLES NECESSARY TO INCREASE
SIGNIFICANCE
http://www.forestcamping.com/dow/northern/coerinfo.htm
IN RELATION TO CLIMATE CHANGE
• HEIGHTENED DRY SEASON TEMPERATURES
COULD INCREASE FREQUENCY AND
INTENSITY OF FOREST FIRES
• MORE FIRES, MORE ERODIBILITY OF
SOIL
http://www.boiseweekly.com/boise/austin-fire-department-tells-boise-wildfire-is-
everyones-fight/Content?oid=3466162
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
• DR. ERIN BROOKS – BIOLOGICAL ENGINEERING
• SCOTT FENNEMA
• IDAHO DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY, COEUR D’ALENE BRANCH
• COEUR D’ALENE TRIBE
• REGIONAL APPROACHES TO CLIMATE CHANGE
• USDA
REACCH Presentation

REACCH Presentation

  • 1.
  • 2.
    THE PROBLEM •HIGH PHOSPHORUS (P) LOADING TO FERNAN LAKE • TOXIC BLUE-GREEN ALGAE (CYANOBACTERIA) • EUTROPHICATION • CDA EXPERIENCING INCREASED P LOADING  • POTENTIAL FOR EUTROPHICATION IN THE FUTURE Photo via Idaho DEQ
  • 3.
    WHY IS IT IMPORTANT? •UNPOTABLE WATER, CARCINOGENS, FISH KILL • CYANOBACTERIA & EUTROPHICATION RESTRICTS WATER USE • TOURISM • HEAVY METALS IN LAKEBED SEDIMENTS • 83 MILLION TONS ZINC, LEAD, ARSENIC, CADMIUM
  • 4.
    RESEARCH • WHERE ISTHE PHOSPHORUS COMING FROM? • FOREST, AGRICULTURE • THICK LITTER LAYER, AG FERTILIZATION APPLICATIONS • HOW DO WE MANAGE IT? • IDAHO DEQ AND TRIBE https://www.usask.ca/agriculture/plantsci/winter_cereals/
  • 5.
    P BACKGROUND •PARTICULATE • P IS ATTACHED TO SOIL MATERIAL • EROSION DRIVES PARTICULATE P MOVEMENT • SOLUBLE • MOST READILY AVAILABLE TO PLANTS AND ALGAE (BIOAVAILABLE) • DIFFICULT TO MANAGE • RUNOFF DRIVES MOVEMENT
  • 6.
    OBJECTIVES • COMPARE SOILP CONCENTRATIONS IN FOREST AND AG LAND TYPES IN THE CDA BASIN • IDENTIFY DRIVERS OF SPATIAL VARIABILITY OF PHOSPHORUS WITHIN THESE LAND TYPES
  • 7.
    METHODOLOGY • IDAHO DEQAND COEUR D’ALENE TRIBE IDENTIFIED PRIORITY WATERSHEDS • FOREST: FERNAN, WOLF LODGE • AG: LAKE CREEK • FACTORS DRIVING P DISTRIBUTION • TOPOGRAPHY, LITTER THICKNESS, VEGETATIVE GROWTH, DEPOSITION (ROADS, CREEKS, BUFFERS)
  • 8.
    SAMPLING PROTOCOL • USEDGIS TO DETERMINE KEY SAMPLING LOCATIONS • SAMPLED 0-7 CM DEPTH • MEASURED: • LITTER THICKNESS, DRY MASS & SOIL PH AND MOISTURE CONTENT • ESTIMATED FOREST CANOPY COVER • ANALYZED SOIL SAMPLES FOR: TOTAL P MEHLICH III, WATER EXTRACTIONS
  • 9.
    AG SAMPLING LOCATIONS 16 SAMPLESAT LAKE CREEK 6 -7 YEARS TIMOTHY HAY FOLLOWED BY 2 YEARS OF GRAIN GROWER APPLIES 20 LB/AC/YR P
  • 10.
    FOREST SAMPLING LOCATIONS 38 SAMPLESAT FERNAN CREEK 19 SAMPLES AT WOLF LODGE CREEK
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
    Error bars represent1 standard deviation 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 All Forest Lake Creek Agriculture TotalSoilP(mg/kg)
  • 15.
    0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 All Forest LakeCreek Agriculture MehlichP(mg/kg)
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
    0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 Wetlands Grass RoadsForest Creek TotalPhosphorus(mg/kg) RESULTS – FERNAN TOTAL PHOSPHORUS
  • 19.
    0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 Wetlands Grass RoadsForest Creek MehlichExtractableSoil Phosphorus(mg/L) RESULTS – FERNAN MEHLICH III PHOSPHORUS
  • 20.
    CONCLUSION • HIGHER TOTALPCONCENTRATIONS IN FOREST (NOT STATISTICALLY SIGNIFICANT) • EXTRACTABLE P TENDS TO BE HIGHER IN AG SETTINGS COMARED TO FOREST • P IN FOREST SETTING SHOULD ALSO BE MANAGED – NOT JUST AG • FOREST TOE SLOPE HAD HIGHEST TOTAL P CONC • 1. LAKE CREEK AG VARIABILITY IS LOWER THAN FOREST • 2. TOPOGRAPHIC POSITION INFLUENCED P CONC • 3. MORE SAMPLES NECESSARY TO INCREASE SIGNIFICANCE http://www.forestcamping.com/dow/northern/coerinfo.htm
  • 21.
    IN RELATION TOCLIMATE CHANGE • HEIGHTENED DRY SEASON TEMPERATURES COULD INCREASE FREQUENCY AND INTENSITY OF FOREST FIRES • MORE FIRES, MORE ERODIBILITY OF SOIL http://www.boiseweekly.com/boise/austin-fire-department-tells-boise-wildfire-is- everyones-fight/Content?oid=3466162
  • 22.
    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS • DR. ERINBROOKS – BIOLOGICAL ENGINEERING • SCOTT FENNEMA • IDAHO DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY, COEUR D’ALENE BRANCH • COEUR D’ALENE TRIBE • REGIONAL APPROACHES TO CLIMATE CHANGE • USDA