SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Is Christianity Rational?Is Christianity Rational?
from a philosophical standpoint
John S. Wilkins
What does it mean to beWhat does it mean to be
rational?rational?
Doesn’t mean correct – a rational decision can be
false if one starts from the wrong premises
Doesn’t mean agrees with anyone, such as scientists
Doesn’t mean considers all the evidence, for then nobody
would be rational
It means, roughly, to make the right choice with the
best available evidence in a reasonable amount of
time
How could Christianity beHow could Christianity be
rational?rational?
If it was consistent with all the evidence we have
If it had no contradictions in its basic tenets
If it provided a way to continue that consistently
worked out
In a limited, or bounded, sense, if it is the best
epistemic bet one can make given one’s environment
and resources
EvidenceEvidence
Lack of evidence for Christianity (failed prophecies,
obvious interpolations in sacred texts, etc.)
Contradicts evidence we do have (e.g., literalism and
science)
Is question begging about evidence (finds awareness
of sinfulness in societies where it really didn’t exist)
Often uses false “evidence” (e.g., McDowell,
archeology)
ContradictionsContradictions
Is God one or three?
Is God good or powerful? Epicurus’ objection
Is God visible or not?
Is God moved to anger or not?
Why do we need to believe, if God has done the
sacrificial work?
Soteriology in particular seems self contradictory -
saved by God from God himself?
Success
Failure of miracles (why no regrown limbs?)
Failure of self-help (mentally disabled)
Failure, for a substantial proportion, of belief states
Failure of exorcisms
Failure of providence (the flowers in the field fallacy)
Failure of Christian society (Albigensians to Fred
Phelps)
Bounded rationalityBounded rationality
One has to make a decision before the leopard leaps
One never has perfect information
So we follow rules (heuristics) like “Imitate the best”
This means we emulate our peers and authorities
(because they are not dead yet, and we don’t want to
be)
Is this a pathway to truth?
Bounded rationalityBounded rationality
No, it’s not. At best it’s a pathway to what works well
enough in a given context (like suburban Western
democratic society in peacetime)
When we have to make a choice, it pays to be sure
we are exposed to the right conditions
Science education, for example…
So while Christians can be boundedly rational, that
doesn’t make Christianity a rational religion
The hermeneutic circleThe hermeneutic circle
It is often true that a religion appears rational to its
adherents when it looks irrational to those outside
This is because adherents hold ideas that force the
religion to be rational to them (e.g., taking the
scriptures as God’s word) which do not seem so to
nonbelievers
This is the hermeneutic circle – a kind of rational
bubble that when pricked, cannot be reconstituted
Hence...Hence...
“When two principles really do meet which cannot be
reconciled, then each man calls the other a fool and
a heretic” – Ludwig Wittgenstein, On Certainty §611
But that doesn’t put every worldview on an equal
footing (consider a schizophrenic worldview)
What we basically must do is have evidence, or else
we are just making up stories
Do I want Christians toDo I want Christians to
apostasise?apostasise?
No I don’t.
But don’t think what you find compelling is going to
compel anyone else, and especially do not make it
something everyone must agree to [The Secular
Imperative]
And when religion and science conflict, so much the
worse for religion – belief must give way to
knowledge, not vice versa [Knowledge cannot be undercut by
faith]
ThanksThanks
scienceblogs.com/evolvingthoughtsscienceblogs.com/evolvingthoughts
cienceblogs.com/evolvingthoughtscienceblogs.com/evolvingthoughts
EPICURUS’s old questions are yet unanswered. Is he
willing to prevent evil, but not able? then is he impotent. Is
he able, but not willing? then is he malevolent. Is he both
able and willing? whence then is evil?
David Hume, Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, §10
Back

More Related Content

What's hot

The Skeptical Christian
The Skeptical ChristianThe Skeptical Christian
The Skeptical Christian
baronschaaf
 
The Intersection of philosophy, science, and theology
The Intersection of philosophy, science, and theologyThe Intersection of philosophy, science, and theology
The Intersection of philosophy, science, and theology
Sarah Salviander
 
Philosophy story or something else
Philosophy story or something elsePhilosophy story or something else
Philosophy story or something else
Alister Pate
 
The domain of religion and science
The domain of religion and scienceThe domain of religion and science
The domain of religion and science
Sarah Salviander
 
Augustinian christian philosophy
Augustinian christian philosophyAugustinian christian philosophy
Augustinian christian philosophy
Mandrakbr
 
The Science of Religion
The Science of ReligionThe Science of Religion
The Science of Religion
Maya Bohnhoff
 
Postmodernism vs Christianity
Postmodernism vs ChristianityPostmodernism vs Christianity
Postmodernism vs Christianity
Austin Cords
 
More Process - Evolution
More Process - EvolutionMore Process - Evolution
More Process - Evolution
Trinity Lutheran Church, Stillwater, MN
 
Atheism
AtheismAtheism
Atheism
davidkhanna
 
What Scientists Really Believe
What Scientists Really BelieveWhat Scientists Really Believe
What Scientists Really Believe
Sarah Salviander
 
Obstacles and Opposing Forces to Christianity
Obstacles and Opposing Forces to ChristianityObstacles and Opposing Forces to Christianity
Obstacles and Opposing Forces to Christianity
Sarah Salviander
 
Class #03
Class #03Class #03
Class #03
Joseph Incandela
 
Intro to Process Theology - Science and Religion
Intro to Process Theology - Science and ReligionIntro to Process Theology - Science and Religion
Intro to Process Theology - Science and Religion
Trinity Lutheran Church, Stillwater, MN
 
Class #03
Class #03Class #03
Class #03
Joseph Incandela
 
More Process - Pluralism
More Process - PluralismMore Process - Pluralism
More Process - Pluralism
Trinity Lutheran Church, Stillwater, MN
 
GRAND APOLOGETIC with Hyperlinks
GRAND APOLOGETIC with HyperlinksGRAND APOLOGETIC with Hyperlinks
GRAND APOLOGETIC with Hyperlinks
Bruce Wood
 
History of apologetics
History of apologeticsHistory of apologetics
History of apologetics
Braxton Hunter
 
The Christian Foundation of Modern Science
The Christian Foundation of Modern ScienceThe Christian Foundation of Modern Science
The Christian Foundation of Modern Science
Sarah Salviander
 
Reflections on the origins in the post covid 19
Reflections on the origins in the post covid 19Reflections on the origins in the post covid 19
Reflections on the origins in the post covid 19
Salman Ahmed Shaikh
 

What's hot (19)

The Skeptical Christian
The Skeptical ChristianThe Skeptical Christian
The Skeptical Christian
 
The Intersection of philosophy, science, and theology
The Intersection of philosophy, science, and theologyThe Intersection of philosophy, science, and theology
The Intersection of philosophy, science, and theology
 
Philosophy story or something else
Philosophy story or something elsePhilosophy story or something else
Philosophy story or something else
 
The domain of religion and science
The domain of religion and scienceThe domain of religion and science
The domain of religion and science
 
Augustinian christian philosophy
Augustinian christian philosophyAugustinian christian philosophy
Augustinian christian philosophy
 
The Science of Religion
The Science of ReligionThe Science of Religion
The Science of Religion
 
Postmodernism vs Christianity
Postmodernism vs ChristianityPostmodernism vs Christianity
Postmodernism vs Christianity
 
More Process - Evolution
More Process - EvolutionMore Process - Evolution
More Process - Evolution
 
Atheism
AtheismAtheism
Atheism
 
What Scientists Really Believe
What Scientists Really BelieveWhat Scientists Really Believe
What Scientists Really Believe
 
Obstacles and Opposing Forces to Christianity
Obstacles and Opposing Forces to ChristianityObstacles and Opposing Forces to Christianity
Obstacles and Opposing Forces to Christianity
 
Class #03
Class #03Class #03
Class #03
 
Intro to Process Theology - Science and Religion
Intro to Process Theology - Science and ReligionIntro to Process Theology - Science and Religion
Intro to Process Theology - Science and Religion
 
Class #03
Class #03Class #03
Class #03
 
More Process - Pluralism
More Process - PluralismMore Process - Pluralism
More Process - Pluralism
 
GRAND APOLOGETIC with Hyperlinks
GRAND APOLOGETIC with HyperlinksGRAND APOLOGETIC with Hyperlinks
GRAND APOLOGETIC with Hyperlinks
 
History of apologetics
History of apologeticsHistory of apologetics
History of apologetics
 
The Christian Foundation of Modern Science
The Christian Foundation of Modern ScienceThe Christian Foundation of Modern Science
The Christian Foundation of Modern Science
 
Reflections on the origins in the post covid 19
Reflections on the origins in the post covid 19Reflections on the origins in the post covid 19
Reflections on the origins in the post covid 19
 

Viewers also liked

Winning Your Husband
Winning Your HusbandWinning Your Husband
Winning Your Husband
Dave Stewart
 
Histology of muscle
Histology of muscle Histology of muscle
Histology of muscle
syed shahzaib
 
God's Plan PowerPoint
God's Plan PowerPointGod's Plan PowerPoint
God's Plan PowerPoint
LRMMissions
 
Oral mycotic infections
Oral mycotic infectionsOral mycotic infections
Oral mycotic infections
Prashant Munde
 
Serological, molecular & histopathological diagnosis of fungal
Serological, molecular & histopathological diagnosis of fungalSerological, molecular & histopathological diagnosis of fungal
Serological, molecular & histopathological diagnosis of fungal
Dr. Kanwal Deep Singh Lyall
 
Oral pathology ... fungal infections 2
Oral pathology ... fungal infections 2Oral pathology ... fungal infections 2
Oral pathology ... fungal infections 2
Hafsa Zubair
 
Candidiasis
CandidiasisCandidiasis
Candidiasis
Shweta Meeee
 
Cartilage & bone, mbbs 1st year
Cartilage & bone, mbbs 1st yearCartilage & bone, mbbs 1st year
Cartilage & bone, mbbs 1st year
Mac Rupakheti
 
Cartilage & bone connective tissue
Cartilage & bone connective tissueCartilage & bone connective tissue
Cartilage & bone connective tissue
guesta1e33cdf
 
Fungal infections of the oral cavity
Fungal infections of the oral cavityFungal infections of the oral cavity
Fungal infections of the oral cavity
IAU Dent
 
41. laboratory diagnosis of common fungal diseases
41. laboratory diagnosis of common fungal diseases41. laboratory diagnosis of common fungal diseases
41. laboratory diagnosis of common fungal diseases
sulochan_lohani
 
Histology of bone
Histology of boneHistology of bone
Histology of bone
Addisu Alemu
 
Maxillary sinus
Maxillary sinusMaxillary sinus
Maxillary sinus
debashish karmakar
 
Bone physiology
 Bone physiology Bone physiology
Bone physiology
Pushkar Dwivedi
 

Viewers also liked (14)

Winning Your Husband
Winning Your HusbandWinning Your Husband
Winning Your Husband
 
Histology of muscle
Histology of muscle Histology of muscle
Histology of muscle
 
God's Plan PowerPoint
God's Plan PowerPointGod's Plan PowerPoint
God's Plan PowerPoint
 
Oral mycotic infections
Oral mycotic infectionsOral mycotic infections
Oral mycotic infections
 
Serological, molecular & histopathological diagnosis of fungal
Serological, molecular & histopathological diagnosis of fungalSerological, molecular & histopathological diagnosis of fungal
Serological, molecular & histopathological diagnosis of fungal
 
Oral pathology ... fungal infections 2
Oral pathology ... fungal infections 2Oral pathology ... fungal infections 2
Oral pathology ... fungal infections 2
 
Candidiasis
CandidiasisCandidiasis
Candidiasis
 
Cartilage & bone, mbbs 1st year
Cartilage & bone, mbbs 1st yearCartilage & bone, mbbs 1st year
Cartilage & bone, mbbs 1st year
 
Cartilage & bone connective tissue
Cartilage & bone connective tissueCartilage & bone connective tissue
Cartilage & bone connective tissue
 
Fungal infections of the oral cavity
Fungal infections of the oral cavityFungal infections of the oral cavity
Fungal infections of the oral cavity
 
41. laboratory diagnosis of common fungal diseases
41. laboratory diagnosis of common fungal diseases41. laboratory diagnosis of common fungal diseases
41. laboratory diagnosis of common fungal diseases
 
Histology of bone
Histology of boneHistology of bone
Histology of bone
 
Maxillary sinus
Maxillary sinusMaxillary sinus
Maxillary sinus
 
Bone physiology
 Bone physiology Bone physiology
Bone physiology
 

Similar to Rationality and christianity

Intentional nonduality
Intentional nondualityIntentional nonduality
Intentional nonduality
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Accommodationism talk
Accommodationism talkAccommodationism talk
Accommodationism talk
John Wilkins
 
Science & Religion: Conflict or Conversation?
Science & Religion: Conflict or Conversation?Science & Religion: Conflict or Conversation?
Science & Religion: Conflict or Conversation?
Maya Bohnhoff
 
Lecture Notes 1 - Intro to POR
Lecture Notes 1 - Intro to PORLecture Notes 1 - Intro to POR
Lecture Notes 1 - Intro to POR
vjmartin
 
Atheist
AtheistAtheist
R&G21st
R&G21stR&G21st
R&G21st
MindWarrior
 
Unlearning in Inter-Religious Dialogue
Unlearning in Inter-Religious DialogueUnlearning in Inter-Religious Dialogue
Unlearning in Inter-Religious Dialogue
Robert Munson
 
Theological Foundations part 1
Theological Foundations part 1Theological Foundations part 1
Theological Foundations part 1
Steve Thomason
 
Christianity in a Postmodern World
Christianity in a Postmodern WorldChristianity in a Postmodern World
Christianity in a Postmodern World
evidenceforchristianity
 
Intentional nonduality
Intentional nondualityIntentional nonduality
Intentional nonduality
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Johnboy musings part1b
Johnboy musings part1bJohnboy musings part1b
Johnboy musings part1b
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Coherency and Worldview
Coherency and WorldviewCoherency and Worldview
Coherency and Worldview
Alliance for Training LLC
 
Religion and ScienceBy Albert Einstein(The following article b.docx
Religion and ScienceBy Albert Einstein(The following article b.docxReligion and ScienceBy Albert Einstein(The following article b.docx
Religion and ScienceBy Albert Einstein(The following article b.docx
debishakespeare
 
The trinity review, a the trinity manifest
The trinity review, a the trinity manifestThe trinity review, a the trinity manifest
The trinity review, a the trinity manifest
Paulo Arieu
 

Similar to Rationality and christianity (14)

Intentional nonduality
Intentional nondualityIntentional nonduality
Intentional nonduality
 
Accommodationism talk
Accommodationism talkAccommodationism talk
Accommodationism talk
 
Science & Religion: Conflict or Conversation?
Science & Religion: Conflict or Conversation?Science & Religion: Conflict or Conversation?
Science & Religion: Conflict or Conversation?
 
Lecture Notes 1 - Intro to POR
Lecture Notes 1 - Intro to PORLecture Notes 1 - Intro to POR
Lecture Notes 1 - Intro to POR
 
Atheist
AtheistAtheist
Atheist
 
R&G21st
R&G21stR&G21st
R&G21st
 
Unlearning in Inter-Religious Dialogue
Unlearning in Inter-Religious DialogueUnlearning in Inter-Religious Dialogue
Unlearning in Inter-Religious Dialogue
 
Theological Foundations part 1
Theological Foundations part 1Theological Foundations part 1
Theological Foundations part 1
 
Christianity in a Postmodern World
Christianity in a Postmodern WorldChristianity in a Postmodern World
Christianity in a Postmodern World
 
Intentional nonduality
Intentional nondualityIntentional nonduality
Intentional nonduality
 
Johnboy musings part1b
Johnboy musings part1bJohnboy musings part1b
Johnboy musings part1b
 
Coherency and Worldview
Coherency and WorldviewCoherency and Worldview
Coherency and Worldview
 
Religion and ScienceBy Albert Einstein(The following article b.docx
Religion and ScienceBy Albert Einstein(The following article b.docxReligion and ScienceBy Albert Einstein(The following article b.docx
Religion and ScienceBy Albert Einstein(The following article b.docx
 
The trinity review, a the trinity manifest
The trinity review, a the trinity manifestThe trinity review, a the trinity manifest
The trinity review, a the trinity manifest
 

More from John Wilkins

Phylogenetic_method_religion.pdf
Phylogenetic_method_religion.pdfPhylogenetic_method_religion.pdf
Phylogenetic_method_religion.pdf
John Wilkins
 
Mercier_and_Sperber.pdf
Mercier_and_Sperber.pdfMercier_and_Sperber.pdf
Mercier_and_Sperber.pdf
John Wilkins
 
Philosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.pdf
Philosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.pdfPhilosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.pdf
Philosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.pdf
John Wilkins
 
Philosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.ppt
Philosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.pptPhilosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.ppt
Philosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.ppt
John Wilkins
 
How_Would_Darwin_Classify.pdf
How_Would_Darwin_Classify.pdfHow_Would_Darwin_Classify.pdf
How_Would_Darwin_Classify.pdf
John Wilkins
 
The Good species
The Good speciesThe Good species
The Good species
John Wilkins
 
History of Nature 5b Deep Time.pdf
History of Nature 5b Deep Time.pdfHistory of Nature 5b Deep Time.pdf
History of Nature 5b Deep Time.pdf
John Wilkins
 
History of Nature 4a Engineered Landscapes.pdf
History of Nature 4a Engineered Landscapes.pdfHistory of Nature 4a Engineered Landscapes.pdf
History of Nature 4a Engineered Landscapes.pdf
John Wilkins
 
History of Nature 3a Voyages of Discovery.pdf
History of Nature 3a Voyages of Discovery.pdfHistory of Nature 3a Voyages of Discovery.pdf
History of Nature 3a Voyages of Discovery.pdf
John Wilkins
 
History of Nature 9b Anthropocene.pdf
History of Nature 9b Anthropocene.pdfHistory of Nature 9b Anthropocene.pdf
History of Nature 9b Anthropocene.pdf
John Wilkins
 
History of Nature 10a Repairing Nature.pdf
History of Nature 10a Repairing Nature.pdfHistory of Nature 10a Repairing Nature.pdf
History of Nature 10a Repairing Nature.pdf
John Wilkins
 
History of Nature 5a Measuring the World.pdf
History of Nature 5a Measuring the World.pdfHistory of Nature 5a Measuring the World.pdf
History of Nature 5a Measuring the World.pdf
John Wilkins
 
History of Nature 8b Human Nature.pdf
History of Nature 8b Human Nature.pdfHistory of Nature 8b Human Nature.pdf
History of Nature 8b Human Nature.pdf
John Wilkins
 
History of Nature 6a Darwinian Revn.pdf
History of Nature 6a Darwinian Revn.pdfHistory of Nature 6a Darwinian Revn.pdf
History of Nature 6a Darwinian Revn.pdf
John Wilkins
 
History of Nature 7a Invention Environmentalism2.pdf
History of Nature 7a Invention Environmentalism2.pdfHistory of Nature 7a Invention Environmentalism2.pdf
History of Nature 7a Invention Environmentalism2.pdf
John Wilkins
 
History of Nature 8a Human Nature 2.pdf
History of Nature 8a Human Nature 2.pdfHistory of Nature 8a Human Nature 2.pdf
History of Nature 8a Human Nature 2.pdf
John Wilkins
 
History of Nature 21 2b Sacred Nature.pdf
History of Nature 21 2b Sacred Nature.pdfHistory of Nature 21 2b Sacred Nature.pdf
History of Nature 21 2b Sacred Nature.pdf
John Wilkins
 
History of Nature 10b Houston we have a problem.pdf
History of Nature 10b Houston we have a problem.pdfHistory of Nature 10b Houston we have a problem.pdf
History of Nature 10b Houston we have a problem.pdf
John Wilkins
 
History of Nature 9a Anthropocene.pdf
History of Nature 9a Anthropocene.pdfHistory of Nature 9a Anthropocene.pdf
History of Nature 9a Anthropocene.pdf
John Wilkins
 
History of Nature 7b Spaceship Earth.pdf
History of Nature 7b Spaceship Earth.pdfHistory of Nature 7b Spaceship Earth.pdf
History of Nature 7b Spaceship Earth.pdf
John Wilkins
 

More from John Wilkins (20)

Phylogenetic_method_religion.pdf
Phylogenetic_method_religion.pdfPhylogenetic_method_religion.pdf
Phylogenetic_method_religion.pdf
 
Mercier_and_Sperber.pdf
Mercier_and_Sperber.pdfMercier_and_Sperber.pdf
Mercier_and_Sperber.pdf
 
Philosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.pdf
Philosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.pdfPhilosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.pdf
Philosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.pdf
 
Philosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.ppt
Philosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.pptPhilosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.ppt
Philosophical_Origins_of_Essentialism_talk.ppt
 
How_Would_Darwin_Classify.pdf
How_Would_Darwin_Classify.pdfHow_Would_Darwin_Classify.pdf
How_Would_Darwin_Classify.pdf
 
The Good species
The Good speciesThe Good species
The Good species
 
History of Nature 5b Deep Time.pdf
History of Nature 5b Deep Time.pdfHistory of Nature 5b Deep Time.pdf
History of Nature 5b Deep Time.pdf
 
History of Nature 4a Engineered Landscapes.pdf
History of Nature 4a Engineered Landscapes.pdfHistory of Nature 4a Engineered Landscapes.pdf
History of Nature 4a Engineered Landscapes.pdf
 
History of Nature 3a Voyages of Discovery.pdf
History of Nature 3a Voyages of Discovery.pdfHistory of Nature 3a Voyages of Discovery.pdf
History of Nature 3a Voyages of Discovery.pdf
 
History of Nature 9b Anthropocene.pdf
History of Nature 9b Anthropocene.pdfHistory of Nature 9b Anthropocene.pdf
History of Nature 9b Anthropocene.pdf
 
History of Nature 10a Repairing Nature.pdf
History of Nature 10a Repairing Nature.pdfHistory of Nature 10a Repairing Nature.pdf
History of Nature 10a Repairing Nature.pdf
 
History of Nature 5a Measuring the World.pdf
History of Nature 5a Measuring the World.pdfHistory of Nature 5a Measuring the World.pdf
History of Nature 5a Measuring the World.pdf
 
History of Nature 8b Human Nature.pdf
History of Nature 8b Human Nature.pdfHistory of Nature 8b Human Nature.pdf
History of Nature 8b Human Nature.pdf
 
History of Nature 6a Darwinian Revn.pdf
History of Nature 6a Darwinian Revn.pdfHistory of Nature 6a Darwinian Revn.pdf
History of Nature 6a Darwinian Revn.pdf
 
History of Nature 7a Invention Environmentalism2.pdf
History of Nature 7a Invention Environmentalism2.pdfHistory of Nature 7a Invention Environmentalism2.pdf
History of Nature 7a Invention Environmentalism2.pdf
 
History of Nature 8a Human Nature 2.pdf
History of Nature 8a Human Nature 2.pdfHistory of Nature 8a Human Nature 2.pdf
History of Nature 8a Human Nature 2.pdf
 
History of Nature 21 2b Sacred Nature.pdf
History of Nature 21 2b Sacred Nature.pdfHistory of Nature 21 2b Sacred Nature.pdf
History of Nature 21 2b Sacred Nature.pdf
 
History of Nature 10b Houston we have a problem.pdf
History of Nature 10b Houston we have a problem.pdfHistory of Nature 10b Houston we have a problem.pdf
History of Nature 10b Houston we have a problem.pdf
 
History of Nature 9a Anthropocene.pdf
History of Nature 9a Anthropocene.pdfHistory of Nature 9a Anthropocene.pdf
History of Nature 9a Anthropocene.pdf
 
History of Nature 7b Spaceship Earth.pdf
History of Nature 7b Spaceship Earth.pdfHistory of Nature 7b Spaceship Earth.pdf
History of Nature 7b Spaceship Earth.pdf
 

Recently uploaded

A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons to Learn ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...
A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons    to Learn   ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons    to Learn   ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...
A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons to Learn ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...
OH TEIK BIN
 
Why is this So? ~ Do Seek to KNOW (English & Chinese).pptx
Why is this So? ~ Do Seek to KNOW (English & Chinese).pptxWhy is this So? ~ Do Seek to KNOW (English & Chinese).pptx
Why is this So? ~ Do Seek to KNOW (English & Chinese).pptx
OH TEIK BIN
 
The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...
The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...
The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...
Phoenix O
 
Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...
Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...
Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...
makhmalhalaaay
 
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_Restoration
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_RestorationThe_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_Restoration
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_Restoration
Network Bible Fellowship
 
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24
deerfootcoc
 
The Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - Message
The Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - MessageThe Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - Message
The Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - Message
Cole Hartman
 
yadadri temple history seva's list and timings
yadadri temple history seva's list and  timingsyadadri temple history seva's list and  timings
yadadri temple history seva's list and timings
knav9398
 
A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord, the taste of the Lord The taste of...
A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord,  the taste of the Lord The taste of...A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord,  the taste of the Lord The taste of...
A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord, the taste of the Lord The taste of...
franktsao4
 
312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town
312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town
312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town
Rick Peterson
 
快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样
快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样
快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样
cfk7atz3
 
English - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdf
English - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdfEnglish - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdf
English - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdf
Filipino Tracts and Literature Society Inc.
 
2. The Book of Psalms: Recognition of the kingship and sovereignty of God
2. The Book of Psalms: Recognition of the kingship and sovereignty of God2. The Book of Psalms: Recognition of the kingship and sovereignty of God
2. The Book of Psalms: Recognition of the kingship and sovereignty of God
COACH International Ministries
 
How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...
How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...
How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...
Traditional Healer, Love Spells Caster and Money Spells That Work Fast
 
Vertical Church Kyiv Report 2022-2023: Church at war
Vertical Church Kyiv Report 2022-2023: Church at warVertical Church Kyiv Report 2022-2023: Church at war
Vertical Church Kyiv Report 2022-2023: Church at war
Olena Tyshchenko-Tyshkovets
 
Sanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu Expert
Sanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu ExpertSanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu Expert
Sanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu Expert
Sanatan Vastu
 
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 9 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 9 24Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 9 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 9 24
deerfootcoc
 

Recently uploaded (17)

A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons to Learn ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...
A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons    to Learn   ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons    to Learn   ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...
A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons to Learn ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...
 
Why is this So? ~ Do Seek to KNOW (English & Chinese).pptx
Why is this So? ~ Do Seek to KNOW (English & Chinese).pptxWhy is this So? ~ Do Seek to KNOW (English & Chinese).pptx
Why is this So? ~ Do Seek to KNOW (English & Chinese).pptx
 
The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...
The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...
The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...
 
Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...
Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...
Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...
 
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_Restoration
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_RestorationThe_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_Restoration
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_Restoration
 
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24
 
The Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - Message
The Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - MessageThe Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - Message
The Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - Message
 
yadadri temple history seva's list and timings
yadadri temple history seva's list and  timingsyadadri temple history seva's list and  timings
yadadri temple history seva's list and timings
 
A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord, the taste of the Lord The taste of...
A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord,  the taste of the Lord The taste of...A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord,  the taste of the Lord The taste of...
A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord, the taste of the Lord The taste of...
 
312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town
312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town
312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town
 
快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样
快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样
快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样
 
English - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdf
English - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdfEnglish - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdf
English - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdf
 
2. The Book of Psalms: Recognition of the kingship and sovereignty of God
2. The Book of Psalms: Recognition of the kingship and sovereignty of God2. The Book of Psalms: Recognition of the kingship and sovereignty of God
2. The Book of Psalms: Recognition of the kingship and sovereignty of God
 
How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...
How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...
How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...
 
Vertical Church Kyiv Report 2022-2023: Church at war
Vertical Church Kyiv Report 2022-2023: Church at warVertical Church Kyiv Report 2022-2023: Church at war
Vertical Church Kyiv Report 2022-2023: Church at war
 
Sanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu Expert
Sanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu ExpertSanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu Expert
Sanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu Expert
 
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 9 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 9 24Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 9 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 9 24
 

Rationality and christianity

  • 1. Is Christianity Rational?Is Christianity Rational? from a philosophical standpoint John S. Wilkins
  • 2. What does it mean to beWhat does it mean to be rational?rational? Doesn’t mean correct – a rational decision can be false if one starts from the wrong premises Doesn’t mean agrees with anyone, such as scientists Doesn’t mean considers all the evidence, for then nobody would be rational It means, roughly, to make the right choice with the best available evidence in a reasonable amount of time
  • 3. How could Christianity beHow could Christianity be rational?rational? If it was consistent with all the evidence we have If it had no contradictions in its basic tenets If it provided a way to continue that consistently worked out In a limited, or bounded, sense, if it is the best epistemic bet one can make given one’s environment and resources
  • 4. EvidenceEvidence Lack of evidence for Christianity (failed prophecies, obvious interpolations in sacred texts, etc.) Contradicts evidence we do have (e.g., literalism and science) Is question begging about evidence (finds awareness of sinfulness in societies where it really didn’t exist) Often uses false “evidence” (e.g., McDowell, archeology)
  • 5. ContradictionsContradictions Is God one or three? Is God good or powerful? Epicurus’ objection Is God visible or not? Is God moved to anger or not? Why do we need to believe, if God has done the sacrificial work? Soteriology in particular seems self contradictory - saved by God from God himself?
  • 6. Success Failure of miracles (why no regrown limbs?) Failure of self-help (mentally disabled) Failure, for a substantial proportion, of belief states Failure of exorcisms Failure of providence (the flowers in the field fallacy) Failure of Christian society (Albigensians to Fred Phelps)
  • 7. Bounded rationalityBounded rationality One has to make a decision before the leopard leaps One never has perfect information So we follow rules (heuristics) like “Imitate the best” This means we emulate our peers and authorities (because they are not dead yet, and we don’t want to be) Is this a pathway to truth?
  • 8. Bounded rationalityBounded rationality No, it’s not. At best it’s a pathway to what works well enough in a given context (like suburban Western democratic society in peacetime) When we have to make a choice, it pays to be sure we are exposed to the right conditions Science education, for example… So while Christians can be boundedly rational, that doesn’t make Christianity a rational religion
  • 9. The hermeneutic circleThe hermeneutic circle It is often true that a religion appears rational to its adherents when it looks irrational to those outside This is because adherents hold ideas that force the religion to be rational to them (e.g., taking the scriptures as God’s word) which do not seem so to nonbelievers This is the hermeneutic circle – a kind of rational bubble that when pricked, cannot be reconstituted
  • 10. Hence...Hence... “When two principles really do meet which cannot be reconciled, then each man calls the other a fool and a heretic” – Ludwig Wittgenstein, On Certainty §611 But that doesn’t put every worldview on an equal footing (consider a schizophrenic worldview) What we basically must do is have evidence, or else we are just making up stories
  • 11. Do I want Christians toDo I want Christians to apostasise?apostasise? No I don’t. But don’t think what you find compelling is going to compel anyone else, and especially do not make it something everyone must agree to [The Secular Imperative] And when religion and science conflict, so much the worse for religion – belief must give way to knowledge, not vice versa [Knowledge cannot be undercut by faith]
  • 13.
  • 14. EPICURUS’s old questions are yet unanswered. Is he willing to prevent evil, but not able? then is he impotent. Is he able, but not willing? then is he malevolent. Is he both able and willing? whence then is evil? David Hume, Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, §10 Back