Certain personality traits, derailment risks, and values of ratees are associated with their multi-rater feedback outcomes. Day-to-day personality traits explained the most variance in ratings, followed by derailment risks and values. Ratees who were more emotionally stable, agreeable, and achievement-oriented tended to receive higher ratings, while those who were more volatile or socially interactive received lower ratings. The findings suggest a more holistic examination of personality is needed to understand multi-rater feedback and that not all derailment risks negatively impact outcomes.