Product innovation types overview with an example of product ideation using the SCAMPER technique. This sits within a larger product strategy methodology and provides resources for products managers that want to investigate more thorough analytical techniques that are not commonly used in Lean and Agile methodologies. These techniques are worthwhile when there is a defined product roadmap and you have appreciable investment risk in your product and business strategy.
This presentation was delivered for Product Camp Melbourne 2014 by Mark Sokacic - mark@airovate.com.au
Art Nouveau Movement Presentation for Art History.
Product strategy innovation overview
1. Innovation Types Overview
& SCAMPER Ideation:
Have you covered all your bases?
Mark Sokacic – mark@airovate.com.au For Product Camp Melbourne - 4/10/2014
Includes References and an Addendum on Advanced Product Strategy Analysis
2. Innovation Types
I have found four broad systems around categorising Innovation
1 - Moore & Dealing with Darwin – Universe of 16 Innovation Types
2 - Sawhney & his 12 Dimensions
3 – Doblin’s 10 Types
4 – Business Model Innovation Methodologies
Geoffrey Moore in Dealing with Darwin has the most comprehensive set
16 Innovation Types in Four Zones
8. Business Model Innovation Methodologies
These are big picture views around innovation and business model analysis
Blue Ocean Model
Seize the White Space Model
Business Model Ontology & Lean Canvas
E3 Value Model
I would also recommend having a look at “The Wide Lens” by Ron Adner who
explores Ecosystem innovation
He looks at Co-innovation risks, Adoption chains, Ecosystem mapping, Internal
& External ecosystems
9. SCAMPER – Creative Thinking Principles
A sample run-though of how to apply basic ideation techniques at any point in new
product design innovation.
SCAMPER
S = Substitute
C = Combine
A = Adapt
M = Magnify / Modify
P = Put to other use
E = Eliminate
R = Reverse
These ideas are explained in depth in Michael Michalko’s book “Cracking Creativity”
10. SCAMPER - Substitute
Substitute – Can I substitute something?
Think up ways of changing this for that and that for this
You can substitute things, places, procedures, people, ideas and even
emotions
Example – Substitute speech output for visual information
11. SCAMPER - Combine
Much of creative thinking involves combining previously unrelated ideas
What can be combined
Can we combine purpose
Can we combine units, materials
Can we package a combination
Example – Can you integrate a nut and bolt?
12. SCAMPER - Adapt
Keep on the lookout for novel & interesting ideas that have been used
successfully
Can the idea be adapted to your usage?
What other ideas does it suggest?
What idea can I incorporate?
What can I copy?
What different contexts can I put my concept into?
13. SCAMPER – Magnify / Modify
Magnify - An easy way to create a new idea is to take a subject and add
something to it
Example put a notch in a button remote control to aid tactile navigation
Modify – What can be modified? Is there a new twist?
Can you change meaning, colour, motion, odour, shape & form?
What change can be made to the plans, processes, marketing?
14. SCAMPER – Put to other use
A subject takes its meaning from its context. Change the context, and you
change the meaning
What else can this be used for?
Are there new ways to use this as is?
Other uses if modified?
What else can be made from this?
Other extensions? Other markets?
15. SCAMPER - Eliminate
Sometimes subtracting something from your subject yields new ideas. Trimming
down ideas, subjects, objects, and processes may gradually narrow down the
subject to its core function, or spotlight a part that’s appropriate for some other
use.
What if it were smaller, Understated?
What should I omit, delete, subtract, what’s not necessary?
Should I divide it, Split it up? Separate it into different parts?
Streamline? Condense? Compact?
Can the rules be eliminated?
16. SCAMPER – Rearrange / Reverse
Reverse it to see what happens. Reversing your perspective opens your thinking.
Look at opposites and you’ll see things you normally miss. Ask what is the
opposite and you find a new way of looking at things.
What are the opposites?
What are the negatives?
Can I transpose positive & negative?
Should I turn it around? Up instead of down?
Backwards? Do the unexpected?
17. Advanced Product Strategy – key takeaways
Lean Methods and Agile Delivery
These are great for quick experiments, fast feedback and minimising costs
when you are a start-up or have minimal investment risk in your product
experiments.
Investment Risk
What happens when you have already invested significant sums on laying out
a product roadmap and are now committed and building in long term path
dependencies that automatically introduce unknown competitive risks into
your planning?
18. Advanced Product Strategy – key takeaways
Lean Techniques and standard strategic thinking techniques
Standard product analysis techniques such as PRESTO are simply not
sufficient for proper analysis around product and business level strategy
when non trivial investments around your product strategy have been
planned.
Are you sure you have covered all the options in your larger product
strategy?
What comparison methods are you using against your competition now and in
the medium future? What methods can you use to minimise the risks in your
product strategy, identify gaps as well as opportunities, gain strategic
awareness & build competitive advantage?
19. Advanced Product Strategy Methods
The Basic Product Development Process
Ideation
Screening
Conceptual Analysis
Market Analysis & Study
Product Design & Development
Product Validation &Testing
Pre-Commercialisation analysis
Production
Market Launch
20. Advanced Product Strategy Methods
Analytical Tools
Below are a selection of useful tools that are generally multi purpose. They can be
used at various stages of your advanced product strategy analysis in the product
development process.
New Lanchester Strategy
TRIZ
Blitz QFD
Analytical Hierarchical Process (AHP)
Conjoint Analysis
Repertory Grid
Kano Models
Taguchi Methods
Real Options Analysis
More advanced and speculative methods could include evolutionary landscapes and
game theoretical modelling.
21. Questions?
If you would like to learn more about these tools and how they can be
applied in your environment contact Mark Sokacic:
mark@airovate.com.au
www.airovate.com.au
22. References
Innovation & Innovation Analysis
(Book) Dealing with Darwin: How great companies innovate at every phase of their evolution:
Geoffrey Moore, 2008
(Book) Ten Types of Innovation: The Discipline of Building Breakthroughs, Keeley, 2013
(Article) The 12 Different Ways for Companies to Innovate: Sawhney, Wolcott, Arroniz, MIT Sloan
Management Review Vol.47, No.3 Spring 2008
(Article) How Hot is Your Next Innovation?: Geoff Tuff, Harvard Business Review, May 2011
(Book) The Wide Lens: A New Strategy for innovation: Adner, 2013
Business Modelling
E3-Value: Designing and Evaluating E-Business Models – Gordijn, Akkermans IEEE Intelligent Systems,
2001
Business Model Ontology(Canvas) : Setting up an Ontology of Business Models: Osterwalder, A.,
Parent, C., & Pigneur, Y. (2004)
White Space Model: Johnson, M. W. (2010). Seizing the white space: Business model innovation for
growth and renewal. Harvard Business Press.
Blue Ocean Strategy: Chan, K. W., & Renee, M. (2011). Blue ocean strategy.
Ideation
(Book) Cracking Creativity: The secrets of creative genius: Michael Michalko, 2001