Pricing Strategy: A focus on profit, not sales
Supply & DemandPrice supplydemand							Quantity
“Making it up on quantity”Required increase in sales volume (%)       100                                                                      80                                                                      60                                                                      4020% price                                                      20decrease                    20                          40                                    60                      80     20% price                                                       20                             Variable unit costincrease						        as % of price                                                                       40					       60					       80Acceptable decrease in Sales Volume (%)  100
Pricing over Product Life CycleIntroduction     Growth		Maturity		Decline
Differences in pricing strategiesIn a “dumb industry”Operators fight with priceCustomers become more price sensitiveIn a “smart industry”Operators fight with…More complex pricingMore varied pricing plansGreater subtlety of pricing optionsGreater use of techniques from other fields
PRICINGSTRATEGYHow companies make pricing decisions…	“Pricing strategy always has been more of a poker game than a science.”William T. Moran, Admar Research	“Successful pricing is an art, not a science.”John I. Leahy, Black & Decker	“Pricing decisions are not easy to make; they are often inherently ‘soft’.”William E. Johnson, William E. Johnson Assoc.
Pricing StrategyPricing ObjectivesPricing Concerns: 4 C’sPricing ModelsPrice BundlingPrice SegmentationPrice Plan
1. Objectives in Setting PriceIncrease profits Attract new customersMaintain current customersIncrease profit per customerIntroduce new product Generate cashImprove ROI
Attract New CustomersIntroductory coupons / discountsprovide incentivemaintain reference priceTrial offersincrease familiarityreduce riskProblemperceived as unfair
Maintain Current CustomersMeet competitionmatching prices add to bundle (as long as customers want it!)Create barriers to exit contracts / subscriptionsautomatic billingphone numbers (no longer in the U.S.) family plansProvide loyalty programsfrequent flyerStarbuck cards
Increase Profit per CustomerIncrease prices reduce product? (candy bar pricing)justify/ notify / base on costsAdjust product mixsales incentives for more profitable businessAdjust customer mix teenagers vs. seniorsCharge for extras what’s valuable to customer and cheap to companyGet money up frontPrepaid subscriptions
Introduce New ProductSkimming: Adjusts prices down over time:PROS: skims off maximum profit for each segmentestablishes high reference priceCONS: attracts competitiondifficult to administerPenetration: Starts at lowest possible pricePROS: penetrates market quicklykeeps out competitionCONS: creates low reference pricemisses full profit potential
2. Concerns in setting price: 4C’s      Competition                            Customer                  Cost                             Custom
3. Pricing ModelsCost-based PricingValue-based PricingFlat-Rate PricingAla-Carte Pricing Two-Part PricingPeak Load / Congestion PricingDynamic Pricing
Cost-based vs. Value-basedCost-based most common pricing method easiest pricing methodconsidered fairdifficult to allocate fixed costssub-optimal profitsValue-based optimal profits requires researchcomplicated to administercan be considered unfair
Flat-Rate PricingSingle rate per time period: PROS: provides unlimited useincreases usesimple to explain & bill popular with customers / low riskCONS:difficult to predict average price unfair in that some people subsidize othersfair in that charges are predictable
Ala-Carte PricingVariable rate depending on use: PROS: considered fairgreater choicegreater controlCONS:more difficult to explainmore difficult to billmore risk
Two-part Pricing ICombines flat rate plus variable:          e.g., monthly fee plus cost per minute (declining?)PROSspreads costs more fairlyCONSperceived as hassleunpredictable
Two-Part Pricing IICombines down-payment & flat rate per month:PROS:covers fixed costs immediatelyspreads customer’s costsfits customer’s monthly budgetgenerates financing revenuespredictable / low riskCONS:increases total cost to customerrequires long-term billing
Peak Load / Congestion PricingVariable rate depending on time of day or week:PROS: spreads useencourages use in unpopular timeconsidered faireasy to explainCONS:difficult to bill
Dynamic PricingVariable rate for each customer:PROS:maximizes profit per customerCONS: difficult to implementrequires detailed demand schedule difficult to explainconsidered unfair
4. Price Bundling / UnbundlingWith own products / servicesbikini top with bottomseats in cartraining with purchaseMcDonalds’ Happy Mealsseason tickets
With other products / servicesdiscount cost of buns with hot dog purchase“free” parking lot with grocery store“free” Microsoft software with computerinclude airline tickets with tour
Benefits of Bundling/UnbundlingBundlingprovide unique assortmentsell unpopular with popularprovide added incentive to purchase or to stayhide / disguise priceUnbundling competitive defensebetter serve customerincrease revenuesMixed
5. Price SegmentationBig opportunity:Computer allows finer discriminationCustomers want choice but not confusion
SegmentsConsumer typeage
sex
income
education
geography, etc.Use of productsports information

Pricing Strategy - A Focus On Profit, Not Sales

  • 1.
    Pricing Strategy: Afocus on profit, not sales
  • 2.
    Supply & DemandPricesupplydemand Quantity
  • 3.
    “Making it upon quantity”Required increase in sales volume (%) 100 80 60 4020% price 20decrease 20 40 60 80 20% price 20 Variable unit costincrease as % of price 40 60 80Acceptable decrease in Sales Volume (%) 100
  • 4.
    Pricing over ProductLife CycleIntroduction Growth Maturity Decline
  • 5.
    Differences in pricingstrategiesIn a “dumb industry”Operators fight with priceCustomers become more price sensitiveIn a “smart industry”Operators fight with…More complex pricingMore varied pricing plansGreater subtlety of pricing optionsGreater use of techniques from other fields
  • 6.
    PRICINGSTRATEGYHow companies makepricing decisions… “Pricing strategy always has been more of a poker game than a science.”William T. Moran, Admar Research “Successful pricing is an art, not a science.”John I. Leahy, Black & Decker “Pricing decisions are not easy to make; they are often inherently ‘soft’.”William E. Johnson, William E. Johnson Assoc.
  • 7.
    Pricing StrategyPricing ObjectivesPricingConcerns: 4 C’sPricing ModelsPrice BundlingPrice SegmentationPrice Plan
  • 8.
    1. Objectives inSetting PriceIncrease profits Attract new customersMaintain current customersIncrease profit per customerIntroduce new product Generate cashImprove ROI
  • 9.
    Attract New CustomersIntroductorycoupons / discountsprovide incentivemaintain reference priceTrial offersincrease familiarityreduce riskProblemperceived as unfair
  • 10.
    Maintain Current CustomersMeetcompetitionmatching prices add to bundle (as long as customers want it!)Create barriers to exit contracts / subscriptionsautomatic billingphone numbers (no longer in the U.S.) family plansProvide loyalty programsfrequent flyerStarbuck cards
  • 11.
    Increase Profit perCustomerIncrease prices reduce product? (candy bar pricing)justify/ notify / base on costsAdjust product mixsales incentives for more profitable businessAdjust customer mix teenagers vs. seniorsCharge for extras what’s valuable to customer and cheap to companyGet money up frontPrepaid subscriptions
  • 12.
    Introduce New ProductSkimming:Adjusts prices down over time:PROS: skims off maximum profit for each segmentestablishes high reference priceCONS: attracts competitiondifficult to administerPenetration: Starts at lowest possible pricePROS: penetrates market quicklykeeps out competitionCONS: creates low reference pricemisses full profit potential
  • 13.
    2. Concerns insetting price: 4C’s Competition Customer Cost Custom
  • 14.
    3. Pricing ModelsCost-basedPricingValue-based PricingFlat-Rate PricingAla-Carte Pricing Two-Part PricingPeak Load / Congestion PricingDynamic Pricing
  • 15.
    Cost-based vs. Value-basedCost-basedmost common pricing method easiest pricing methodconsidered fairdifficult to allocate fixed costssub-optimal profitsValue-based optimal profits requires researchcomplicated to administercan be considered unfair
  • 16.
    Flat-Rate PricingSingle rateper time period: PROS: provides unlimited useincreases usesimple to explain & bill popular with customers / low riskCONS:difficult to predict average price unfair in that some people subsidize othersfair in that charges are predictable
  • 17.
    Ala-Carte PricingVariable ratedepending on use: PROS: considered fairgreater choicegreater controlCONS:more difficult to explainmore difficult to billmore risk
  • 18.
    Two-part Pricing ICombinesflat rate plus variable: e.g., monthly fee plus cost per minute (declining?)PROSspreads costs more fairlyCONSperceived as hassleunpredictable
  • 19.
    Two-Part Pricing IICombinesdown-payment & flat rate per month:PROS:covers fixed costs immediatelyspreads customer’s costsfits customer’s monthly budgetgenerates financing revenuespredictable / low riskCONS:increases total cost to customerrequires long-term billing
  • 20.
    Peak Load /Congestion PricingVariable rate depending on time of day or week:PROS: spreads useencourages use in unpopular timeconsidered faireasy to explainCONS:difficult to bill
  • 21.
    Dynamic PricingVariable ratefor each customer:PROS:maximizes profit per customerCONS: difficult to implementrequires detailed demand schedule difficult to explainconsidered unfair
  • 22.
    4. Price Bundling/ UnbundlingWith own products / servicesbikini top with bottomseats in cartraining with purchaseMcDonalds’ Happy Mealsseason tickets
  • 23.
    With other products/ servicesdiscount cost of buns with hot dog purchase“free” parking lot with grocery store“free” Microsoft software with computerinclude airline tickets with tour
  • 24.
    Benefits of Bundling/UnbundlingBundlingprovideunique assortmentsell unpopular with popularprovide added incentive to purchase or to stayhide / disguise priceUnbundling competitive defensebetter serve customerincrease revenuesMixed
  • 25.
    5. Price SegmentationBigopportunity:Computer allows finer discriminationCustomers want choice but not confusion
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
    geography, etc.Use ofproductsports information
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34.
  • 35.
  • 36.
  • 37.
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41.
    overnightSegmentsVolume of use:emergencyonlylimited usagequantity discountunlimited usageTime of use:off-peaknormal working hoursunrestrictedLongevity of customer
  • 42.
  • 43.
  • 44.
  • 45.
    1, 2, 3year sliding scale
  • 46.
  • 47.
  • 48.
  • 49.
  • 50.
  • 51.
    tight6. Pricing PlanDeterminetarget market(s).What do those consumers want?What can you give them that competitors cannot? (or haven’t thought of yet)What are their financial impediments?How can you structure your pricing to solve their problems?How profitable will that be?
  • 52.
    Summary of StrategyObjectivesof price vary; profit is #1Pricing concerns are the 4C’scost / competition / customer / customPricing models can be mixed and matched Bundling can be with both self & othersSegmentation should be fine tunedPlan should be based on each market segment
  • 53.