SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Polly PeckPolly Peck
Punuan:Punuan:
Silvana GerxhaniSilvana Gerxhani
Alma KurtiAlma Kurti
Valentina MaletajValentina Maletaj
“Corporate governance is the process by
which concern parties in a corporation relate with each other and
promote their interest”
(Armor, 2008 : 23). 
Business bubbles rose out of nowhere and some of them collapsed just as rapidly, taking
small shareholders and their money with them, and shady businessmen sometimes came
to grief ….
Polly Peck: Ngjarjet Kryesore
1941 Asil Nadir u lindnëQipro
1959 FamiljaeNadir emigroj nëLondër
1973 Wearwell u vendosnëBursëneLondres
1980 Nadir mori kontrollinePolly Peck
1982 U ndërtuafabrikaepërpunimit tëujit nëTurqi
1983 U krijuajoint-venturemeVestel
1985 Polly Peck Intl mezyraqëndrorenëBerkeley tëLondrës
1989 Polly Peck bleDel Montedhe51%tëpjesëstëSansui
1990, Shtator Nadir intervistohet ngazyraeAnti-Korrupsionit
1990, Tetor Polly Peck meret nënadministrim
1990, Dhjetor Nadir arestohet
1993 Asil Nadir fluturondrejt veriut tëQipros
Kerkesat e Detyres:
1. Avantazhet dhe disavantazhet e lejimit të postit të presidentit dhe drejtorit
ekzekutiv të një kompanie publike në duart e një individi.
2. A duhej që bankat të ishin më të kujdesshme gjatë kreditimit të Polly Peck
dhe Asil Nadir?
3. Cilat janë mësimet që mund të meren nga kolapsi i Polly Peck?
4. Pretendentët (aktorët, grupet e interesit) që ishin në disavantazh më të madh
nga kolapsi i Polly Peck.
5. Diskuto propozimin se nuk është në interesin e kompanisë së listuar që
drejtori të zotërojë pjesën më të madhe të kapitalit.
6. Si interpretohet teoría e agjensisë në këtë rast? Si mund të zgjidhen
problemet që evidentohen në këtë rast?
Avantazhet dhe disavantazhet:
Avantazhet:
– Duke e bere edhe president edhe Drejtor ekzekutiv, siguron
vemendjen dhe perkushtimin e plote te tij ndaj biznesit,
sepse: njeriu është më shumë i orientuar nga interesi i vet sesa nga
altruizmi.
Dizavantazhet:
– I jep shume fuqi nje individi te vetem, duke i dhene keshtu
mundesine te abuzoje me fondet, me vleren e aksioneve dhe
me gjithe menaxhimin e shoqerise:
– I jep mundesine te kontrolloje te gjithe, por te mos
kontrollohet kurre realisht vete: Who watch the
watchers???
Bankat duhet….
1. Te shqyrtonin vertetesine e pasqyrave financare.
Bankat duhet….
2. Te llogarisnin ROE dhe ROA per zgjerimet e medha qe
po bente kompania.
3. Te llogarisnin mire raportet e borxhit te shoqerise.
Bankat duhet….
• Te dyshonin pak me shume ne suksesin e nje
zgjerimi shume te madh ne nje kohe te shkurter.
• Te hetonin mbi cash flow.
Mesimet….
• Nese nuk e kupton se cfare dikush po ben me parate e
tua, atehere eshte mire te fillosh te hetosh mbi te.
• Nuk i duhen dhene dikujt te gjitha te drejtat, te
kontrolloje kedo, dhe te mos e kontrollosh ate.
• Duhet te jesh i kujdesshem mbi qeverisjen e
koorporates tende, duke mos besuar verberisht te
rregullat, sepse disa mendojne: Rregullat jane bere per
tu thyer
• Duhet te kesh nje Bord te perbere nga persona
inteligjente, te pakten njeri specialist i fushes.
Stakeholders ne disavantazh….
• Investitoret.
Aksioneret e nje kapitali prej
afro 2 miliard pound.
• Kreditoret
- Bankat
- Shteti (tatim taksat)
• Punonjesit
Polly Peck kishte 8.000 te
punesuar.
Drejtori me pjesen me te madhe te kapitalit?
• Ne rastin konkret kjo rezultoi në :
- Blerje te pastudiuara qe cuan ne nje diversifikim
konglomerat te pasuksesshem.
- Manipulime ne tregjet financiare me vleren e
aksioneve.
- Coi ne falimentim te gjithe kompanine duke e
tejkaluar masen e borxheve.
- Nuk u mor vesh asnjehere se ku shkonin
likuiditetet e shoqerise.
Teoria e Agjensise:
1. Informacioni shperndahet ne menyre asimetrike(jo te
plote). (askush nuk dinte ku perfundonte cash, nje kompani me
fitime kolosale dhe me mungesa te theksuara likuiditeti?!!!)
• Sjellje oportunistike. (Nadir kerkoi ta
kthente shoqerine ne koorporate private,
pasi i kishte thare te gjitha likuiditetet.)
Teoria e Agjensise:
Si mund te zgjidhet?
• Kontroll i vazhdueshem mbi menaxheret.
• Vigjilence ne qeverisjen e koorporates.
• Te pakten nje person ekspert te fushes ne bord.
• Ndarje e presidentit nga drejtori ekzekutiv.
Te gjitha keto me koston minimale te
mundshme!
Media dhe Polly
Peck!
“ Elizabeth Forsyth - former
chairperson of Asil Nadir's private
finance company, South Audley
Management, which was raided by the
Serious Fraud Office in 1990 - reveals
the truth about Polly Peck, the FTSE
100 high-flyer that collapsed after the
raid. She tells how the shareholders
were left with nothing, and of the
subsequent vilification and persecution
of both herself and its charismatic
founder, Asil Nadir. This is the inside
story of their dramatic six-year battle
to uncover the dubious activities of the
Serious Fraud Office and to clear their
names. It implicates the SFO, the
Inland Revenue and the Stock
Exchange in a face-saving, political
cover-up. Corruption, collusion and
calumny in the highest strata of the
British establishment involves the
dismissal of a minister and the
compromising of a High Court judge.”

More Related Content

What's hot

Business Ethics TYCO Case Study
Business Ethics TYCO Case StudyBusiness Ethics TYCO Case Study
Business Ethics TYCO Case Study
Mizah Khalidi
 
World com || Auditing and Corporate Governance
World com || Auditing and Corporate Governance World com || Auditing and Corporate Governance
World com || Auditing and Corporate Governance
Mohit Chhabra
 
Worldcom scam 2002
Worldcom scam 2002Worldcom scam 2002
Worldcom scam 2002
Sanket Jha
 
The Economic Crisis of 2008 (US Housing Bubble) - Inside Job Movie
 The Economic Crisis of 2008 (US Housing Bubble) - Inside Job Movie The Economic Crisis of 2008 (US Housing Bubble) - Inside Job Movie
The Economic Crisis of 2008 (US Housing Bubble) - Inside Job Movie
valliappan1991
 
Maxwell Collapse
Maxwell Collapse  Maxwell Collapse
Maxwell Collapse
Alim ehsan Dipon
 
New york stockexchange PPT
New york stockexchange PPTNew york stockexchange PPT
New york stockexchange PPT
Vijay Mehta
 
Case Analysis: The Battle for Value, 2004: FedEx Crop vs United Parcel Servic...
Case Analysis: The Battle for Value, 2004: FedEx Crop vs United Parcel Servic...Case Analysis: The Battle for Value, 2004: FedEx Crop vs United Parcel Servic...
Case Analysis: The Battle for Value, 2004: FedEx Crop vs United Parcel Servic...
Afifah Nabilah
 
The Curious Case of WorldCom
The Curious Case of WorldComThe Curious Case of WorldCom
The Curious Case of WorldComArghya Sarkar
 
Nike
NikeNike
Eastboro case analysis
Eastboro case analysisEastboro case analysis
Eastboro case analysisFajar Muhammad
 
COLLAPSE OF SILICON VALLEY BANK.pptx
COLLAPSE OF SILICON VALLEY BANK.pptxCOLLAPSE OF SILICON VALLEY BANK.pptx
COLLAPSE OF SILICON VALLEY BANK.pptx
prasadsalwe
 
Enron - Corporate Governance - Scandal - Nesr
Enron - Corporate Governance - Scandal - NesrEnron - Corporate Governance - Scandal - Nesr
Enron - Corporate Governance - Scandal - NesrAnesr
 
38299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-1
38299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-138299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-1
38299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-1Nantha Kumaran
 
Worldcom,Enron,largest bankruptcy,how worldcom,SOA
Worldcom,Enron,largest bankruptcy,how worldcom,SOAWorldcom,Enron,largest bankruptcy,how worldcom,SOA
Worldcom,Enron,largest bankruptcy,how worldcom,SOA
Advance Business Consulting
 
Case Study: Cisco Acquisition
Case Study: Cisco AcquisitionCase Study: Cisco Acquisition
Case Study: Cisco AcquisitionDjadja Sardjana
 
IMPROPER CORPORATE GOVERNANCE IN DAEWOO GROUP
IMPROPER CORPORATE GOVERNANCE IN DAEWOO GROUPIMPROPER CORPORATE GOVERNANCE IN DAEWOO GROUP
IMPROPER CORPORATE GOVERNANCE IN DAEWOO GROUP
SudharshanE1
 
Parmalat scandal-by abhishek yadav
Parmalat scandal-by abhishek yadavParmalat scandal-by abhishek yadav
Parmalat scandal-by abhishek yadav
Abhishek Yadav
 
How Unethical Practices Almost Destroyed WorldCom
How Unethical Practices Almost Destroyed WorldComHow Unethical Practices Almost Destroyed WorldCom
How Unethical Practices Almost Destroyed WorldCom
Ravindra Kumar
 

What's hot (20)

Business Ethics TYCO Case Study
Business Ethics TYCO Case StudyBusiness Ethics TYCO Case Study
Business Ethics TYCO Case Study
 
Tyco Case Study
Tyco Case StudyTyco Case Study
Tyco Case Study
 
World com || Auditing and Corporate Governance
World com || Auditing and Corporate Governance World com || Auditing and Corporate Governance
World com || Auditing and Corporate Governance
 
Worldcom scam 2002
Worldcom scam 2002Worldcom scam 2002
Worldcom scam 2002
 
The Economic Crisis of 2008 (US Housing Bubble) - Inside Job Movie
 The Economic Crisis of 2008 (US Housing Bubble) - Inside Job Movie The Economic Crisis of 2008 (US Housing Bubble) - Inside Job Movie
The Economic Crisis of 2008 (US Housing Bubble) - Inside Job Movie
 
Maxwell Collapse
Maxwell Collapse  Maxwell Collapse
Maxwell Collapse
 
New york stockexchange PPT
New york stockexchange PPTNew york stockexchange PPT
New york stockexchange PPT
 
Case Analysis: The Battle for Value, 2004: FedEx Crop vs United Parcel Servic...
Case Analysis: The Battle for Value, 2004: FedEx Crop vs United Parcel Servic...Case Analysis: The Battle for Value, 2004: FedEx Crop vs United Parcel Servic...
Case Analysis: The Battle for Value, 2004: FedEx Crop vs United Parcel Servic...
 
The Curious Case of WorldCom
The Curious Case of WorldComThe Curious Case of WorldCom
The Curious Case of WorldCom
 
Nike
NikeNike
Nike
 
Worldcom scandal
Worldcom scandalWorldcom scandal
Worldcom scandal
 
Eastboro case analysis
Eastboro case analysisEastboro case analysis
Eastboro case analysis
 
COLLAPSE OF SILICON VALLEY BANK.pptx
COLLAPSE OF SILICON VALLEY BANK.pptxCOLLAPSE OF SILICON VALLEY BANK.pptx
COLLAPSE OF SILICON VALLEY BANK.pptx
 
Enron - Corporate Governance - Scandal - Nesr
Enron - Corporate Governance - Scandal - NesrEnron - Corporate Governance - Scandal - Nesr
Enron - Corporate Governance - Scandal - Nesr
 
38299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-1
38299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-138299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-1
38299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-1
 
Worldcom,Enron,largest bankruptcy,how worldcom,SOA
Worldcom,Enron,largest bankruptcy,how worldcom,SOAWorldcom,Enron,largest bankruptcy,how worldcom,SOA
Worldcom,Enron,largest bankruptcy,how worldcom,SOA
 
Case Study: Cisco Acquisition
Case Study: Cisco AcquisitionCase Study: Cisco Acquisition
Case Study: Cisco Acquisition
 
IMPROPER CORPORATE GOVERNANCE IN DAEWOO GROUP
IMPROPER CORPORATE GOVERNANCE IN DAEWOO GROUPIMPROPER CORPORATE GOVERNANCE IN DAEWOO GROUP
IMPROPER CORPORATE GOVERNANCE IN DAEWOO GROUP
 
Parmalat scandal-by abhishek yadav
Parmalat scandal-by abhishek yadavParmalat scandal-by abhishek yadav
Parmalat scandal-by abhishek yadav
 
How Unethical Practices Almost Destroyed WorldCom
How Unethical Practices Almost Destroyed WorldComHow Unethical Practices Almost Destroyed WorldCom
How Unethical Practices Almost Destroyed WorldCom
 

Viewers also liked

Corporate Governance Project
Corporate Governance Project Corporate Governance Project
Corporate Governance Project
riya_thakkar
 
BBC News - Asil Nadir trial: Polly Peck tycoon fled UK 'a broken man'
 BBC News - Asil Nadir trial: Polly Peck tycoon fled UK 'a broken man'  BBC News - Asil Nadir trial: Polly Peck tycoon fled UK 'a broken man'
BBC News - Asil Nadir trial: Polly Peck tycoon fled UK 'a broken man'
mersaberden27
 
BCCI SCAM
BCCI SCAMBCCI SCAM
BCCI SCAM
Mansi Sweet
 
Corporate Governance (Introduction)..
Corporate Governance (Introduction)..Corporate Governance (Introduction)..
Corporate Governance (Introduction)..Nouman Zia
 
ResolveTO - Dr. Andrew Maxwell: Corporate Innovation Stage
ResolveTO - Dr. Andrew Maxwell: Corporate Innovation StageResolveTO - Dr. Andrew Maxwell: Corporate Innovation Stage
ResolveTO - Dr. Andrew Maxwell: Corporate Innovation Stage
ResolveTO
 
Skandalet e kontabilitetit..
Skandalet e kontabilitetit..Skandalet e kontabilitetit..
Skandalet e kontabilitetit..Tringa 001
 
Bcci ob
Bcci obBcci ob
Bcci ob
Nikita Arora
 
Enron scandal
Enron scandalEnron scandal
Enron scandal
Anushka Gupta
 
The worldcom scandal
The worldcom scandalThe worldcom scandal
The worldcom scandal
Srishti Sachan
 
Enron Scandal
Enron ScandalEnron Scandal
Enron Scandal
Niket Ratta
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Fraud & corruption
Fraud & corruptionFraud & corruption
Fraud & corruption
 
Corporate governace
Corporate governaceCorporate governace
Corporate governace
 
Corporate Governance Project
Corporate Governance Project Corporate Governance Project
Corporate Governance Project
 
BBC News - Asil Nadir trial: Polly Peck tycoon fled UK 'a broken man'
 BBC News - Asil Nadir trial: Polly Peck tycoon fled UK 'a broken man'  BBC News - Asil Nadir trial: Polly Peck tycoon fled UK 'a broken man'
BBC News - Asil Nadir trial: Polly Peck tycoon fled UK 'a broken man'
 
BCCI SCAM
BCCI SCAMBCCI SCAM
BCCI SCAM
 
Vivendi case
Vivendi caseVivendi case
Vivendi case
 
Vivendi scandal
Vivendi scandalVivendi scandal
Vivendi scandal
 
Corporate Governance (Introduction)..
Corporate Governance (Introduction)..Corporate Governance (Introduction)..
Corporate Governance (Introduction)..
 
WorldCom Fraud
WorldCom FraudWorldCom Fraud
WorldCom Fraud
 
Itc fraud case
Itc fraud caseItc fraud case
Itc fraud case
 
ResolveTO - Dr. Andrew Maxwell: Corporate Innovation Stage
ResolveTO - Dr. Andrew Maxwell: Corporate Innovation StageResolveTO - Dr. Andrew Maxwell: Corporate Innovation Stage
ResolveTO - Dr. Andrew Maxwell: Corporate Innovation Stage
 
Bcci
BcciBcci
Bcci
 
Skandalet e kontabilitetit..
Skandalet e kontabilitetit..Skandalet e kontabilitetit..
Skandalet e kontabilitetit..
 
BCCI Fiasco
BCCI FiascoBCCI Fiasco
BCCI Fiasco
 
Bcci ob
Bcci obBcci ob
Bcci ob
 
Bcci
BcciBcci
Bcci
 
Enron scandal
Enron scandalEnron scandal
Enron scandal
 
The worldcom scandal
The worldcom scandalThe worldcom scandal
The worldcom scandal
 
Enron Scandal
Enron ScandalEnron Scandal
Enron Scandal
 
Enron
EnronEnron
Enron
 

Polly Peck - Corporate governance

  • 1. Polly PeckPolly Peck Punuan:Punuan: Silvana GerxhaniSilvana Gerxhani Alma KurtiAlma Kurti Valentina MaletajValentina Maletaj
  • 2. “Corporate governance is the process by which concern parties in a corporation relate with each other and promote their interest” (Armor, 2008 : 23).  Business bubbles rose out of nowhere and some of them collapsed just as rapidly, taking small shareholders and their money with them, and shady businessmen sometimes came to grief ….
  • 3. Polly Peck: Ngjarjet Kryesore 1941 Asil Nadir u lindnëQipro 1959 FamiljaeNadir emigroj nëLondër 1973 Wearwell u vendosnëBursëneLondres 1980 Nadir mori kontrollinePolly Peck 1982 U ndërtuafabrikaepërpunimit tëujit nëTurqi 1983 U krijuajoint-venturemeVestel 1985 Polly Peck Intl mezyraqëndrorenëBerkeley tëLondrës 1989 Polly Peck bleDel Montedhe51%tëpjesëstëSansui 1990, Shtator Nadir intervistohet ngazyraeAnti-Korrupsionit 1990, Tetor Polly Peck meret nënadministrim 1990, Dhjetor Nadir arestohet 1993 Asil Nadir fluturondrejt veriut tëQipros
  • 4. Kerkesat e Detyres: 1. Avantazhet dhe disavantazhet e lejimit të postit të presidentit dhe drejtorit ekzekutiv të një kompanie publike në duart e një individi. 2. A duhej që bankat të ishin më të kujdesshme gjatë kreditimit të Polly Peck dhe Asil Nadir? 3. Cilat janë mësimet që mund të meren nga kolapsi i Polly Peck? 4. Pretendentët (aktorët, grupet e interesit) që ishin në disavantazh më të madh nga kolapsi i Polly Peck. 5. Diskuto propozimin se nuk është në interesin e kompanisë së listuar që drejtori të zotërojë pjesën më të madhe të kapitalit. 6. Si interpretohet teoría e agjensisë në këtë rast? Si mund të zgjidhen problemet që evidentohen në këtë rast?
  • 5. Avantazhet dhe disavantazhet: Avantazhet: – Duke e bere edhe president edhe Drejtor ekzekutiv, siguron vemendjen dhe perkushtimin e plote te tij ndaj biznesit, sepse: njeriu është më shumë i orientuar nga interesi i vet sesa nga altruizmi. Dizavantazhet: – I jep shume fuqi nje individi te vetem, duke i dhene keshtu mundesine te abuzoje me fondet, me vleren e aksioneve dhe me gjithe menaxhimin e shoqerise: – I jep mundesine te kontrolloje te gjithe, por te mos kontrollohet kurre realisht vete: Who watch the watchers???
  • 6. Bankat duhet…. 1. Te shqyrtonin vertetesine e pasqyrave financare.
  • 7. Bankat duhet…. 2. Te llogarisnin ROE dhe ROA per zgjerimet e medha qe po bente kompania. 3. Te llogarisnin mire raportet e borxhit te shoqerise.
  • 8. Bankat duhet…. • Te dyshonin pak me shume ne suksesin e nje zgjerimi shume te madh ne nje kohe te shkurter. • Te hetonin mbi cash flow.
  • 9. Mesimet…. • Nese nuk e kupton se cfare dikush po ben me parate e tua, atehere eshte mire te fillosh te hetosh mbi te. • Nuk i duhen dhene dikujt te gjitha te drejtat, te kontrolloje kedo, dhe te mos e kontrollosh ate. • Duhet te jesh i kujdesshem mbi qeverisjen e koorporates tende, duke mos besuar verberisht te rregullat, sepse disa mendojne: Rregullat jane bere per tu thyer • Duhet te kesh nje Bord te perbere nga persona inteligjente, te pakten njeri specialist i fushes.
  • 10. Stakeholders ne disavantazh…. • Investitoret. Aksioneret e nje kapitali prej afro 2 miliard pound. • Kreditoret - Bankat - Shteti (tatim taksat) • Punonjesit Polly Peck kishte 8.000 te punesuar.
  • 11. Drejtori me pjesen me te madhe te kapitalit? • Ne rastin konkret kjo rezultoi në : - Blerje te pastudiuara qe cuan ne nje diversifikim konglomerat te pasuksesshem. - Manipulime ne tregjet financiare me vleren e aksioneve. - Coi ne falimentim te gjithe kompanine duke e tejkaluar masen e borxheve. - Nuk u mor vesh asnjehere se ku shkonin likuiditetet e shoqerise.
  • 12. Teoria e Agjensise: 1. Informacioni shperndahet ne menyre asimetrike(jo te plote). (askush nuk dinte ku perfundonte cash, nje kompani me fitime kolosale dhe me mungesa te theksuara likuiditeti?!!!)
  • 13. • Sjellje oportunistike. (Nadir kerkoi ta kthente shoqerine ne koorporate private, pasi i kishte thare te gjitha likuiditetet.) Teoria e Agjensise:
  • 14. Si mund te zgjidhet? • Kontroll i vazhdueshem mbi menaxheret. • Vigjilence ne qeverisjen e koorporates. • Te pakten nje person ekspert te fushes ne bord. • Ndarje e presidentit nga drejtori ekzekutiv. Te gjitha keto me koston minimale te mundshme!
  • 16.
  • 17. “ Elizabeth Forsyth - former chairperson of Asil Nadir's private finance company, South Audley Management, which was raided by the Serious Fraud Office in 1990 - reveals the truth about Polly Peck, the FTSE 100 high-flyer that collapsed after the raid. She tells how the shareholders were left with nothing, and of the subsequent vilification and persecution of both herself and its charismatic founder, Asil Nadir. This is the inside story of their dramatic six-year battle to uncover the dubious activities of the Serious Fraud Office and to clear their names. It implicates the SFO, the Inland Revenue and the Stock Exchange in a face-saving, political cover-up. Corruption, collusion and calumny in the highest strata of the British establishment involves the dismissal of a minister and the compromising of a High Court judge.”