SlideShare a Scribd company logo
ASSESSINGYOUNG CHILDREN BY: DR. CATHY GRACE
Dr. Cathy Grace’sarticle illustratesthe importance of usingcommonsense whenassessing
youngchildren.Herrecommendedmethodsaddressthe dilemmabetweenthe growingemphasisof
standardizedtestingandthe beliefthatchildren’sdevelopmentis,“…continuousandongoing”, and,
“…that other methods may be more accurate than the once-a-year testing event.”
Dr. Grace suggests the implementation of a student portfolio. In this individualized
plan, students create a tangible record of their learning progress. Teacher and student
collaborate to collect samples of work that bring together knowledge and skills used in the real
world with, “…the goals of the educational program…” Elements of the student portfolio
include art work, writing samples and photographs of cooperative work and building structures.
The teacherinformsthe studentabouthow the workis evaluatedagainstastandard. Educator
and pupil discusswhatworkwill orwill notbe includedinthe portfolio. Dr.Grace believesthatchildren
as youngas four yearsoldare capable of thistask. Studentsare encouragedtodemonstrate their
understandingof thisprocessbyexplainingittoothers.
Finally, the portfolio is shared with parents at conference time. The decision is also
made whether to release the portfolio at the end of the school year, or to carry it over for
subsequent school years for a cumulative record.
I found this article unique and informative. While standardized testing has a purpose, I
like the idea of ongoing, meaningful progress for children. I say this because I realize some
students do not test as well as others, and so the “testing session” is not an accurate reflection,
but more of a random “snapshot” of perceived knowledge. In other words, the testing criteria,
while important, can only by design test for but a fraction of the knowledge contained in
anyone’s mind. The testing process is stressful, lengthy (for a day), and temporary. This may
lead to a tendency to “teach to the test”. Dr. Grace’s ideas provide for students whose
strengths lie in a long term framework.
I admire Dr. Grace’s apparent dedication to the learning process, which can be difficult
to measure. I like that there seems to be much student involvement in the model she presents.
As with many things, I think students will benefit more from something they thoroughly
understand and of which they play a major role.
REFERENCES
Grace, Dr. Cathy: Assessing Young Children
www.pbs.org/teachers/earlychildhood/articles/assessing.html

More Related Content

What's hot

Assessment, Planning & Instruction - Supporting Students, Supporting your Pra...
Assessment, Planning & Instruction - Supporting Students, Supporting your Pra...Assessment, Planning & Instruction - Supporting Students, Supporting your Pra...
Assessment, Planning & Instruction - Supporting Students, Supporting your Pra...
Joel Krentz
 
METHODS OF TEACHING
METHODS OF TEACHINGMETHODS OF TEACHING
inductive and deductive method
inductive and deductive methodinductive and deductive method
inductive and deductive method
Aiza delos Reyes
 
Case study
Case studyCase study
Case study
farina nasir
 
Historical & contemporary issues realated to assessment
Historical & contemporary issues realated to assessmentHistorical & contemporary issues realated to assessment
Historical & contemporary issues realated to assessment
jdpal38
 
Feedback and marking
Feedback and markingFeedback and marking
Feedback and marking
Alex Gingell
 
blueprint_for_testing
blueprint_for_testingblueprint_for_testing
blueprint_for_testing
Progyamita Bhattacharya, MA, MLS
 

What's hot (7)

Assessment, Planning & Instruction - Supporting Students, Supporting your Pra...
Assessment, Planning & Instruction - Supporting Students, Supporting your Pra...Assessment, Planning & Instruction - Supporting Students, Supporting your Pra...
Assessment, Planning & Instruction - Supporting Students, Supporting your Pra...
 
METHODS OF TEACHING
METHODS OF TEACHINGMETHODS OF TEACHING
METHODS OF TEACHING
 
inductive and deductive method
inductive and deductive methodinductive and deductive method
inductive and deductive method
 
Case study
Case studyCase study
Case study
 
Historical & contemporary issues realated to assessment
Historical & contemporary issues realated to assessmentHistorical & contemporary issues realated to assessment
Historical & contemporary issues realated to assessment
 
Feedback and marking
Feedback and markingFeedback and marking
Feedback and marking
 
blueprint_for_testing
blueprint_for_testingblueprint_for_testing
blueprint_for_testing
 

Viewers also liked

Biodegradation of insecticidal compounds of Clausena anisata and Plectrant...
Biodegradation of insecticidal compounds of  Clausena anisata  and  Plectrant...Biodegradation of insecticidal compounds of  Clausena anisata  and  Plectrant...
Biodegradation of insecticidal compounds of Clausena anisata and Plectrant...
researchagriculture
 
Analysis of the effects of monetary and fiscal policy indicators on agricult...
Analysis of the effects of monetary and fiscal policy indicators on  agricult...Analysis of the effects of monetary and fiscal policy indicators on  agricult...
Analysis of the effects of monetary and fiscal policy indicators on agricult...
researchagriculture
 
Email Marketing: Simple Techniques That Still Work
Email Marketing: Simple Techniques That Still WorkEmail Marketing: Simple Techniques That Still Work
Email Marketing: Simple Techniques That Still Work
frammies
 
Photo's I've Took
Photo's I've TookPhoto's I've Took
Photo's I've Took
CorySmith25
 
Sunset Telcom Holiday Inn Express Case Study
Sunset Telcom Holiday Inn Express Case StudySunset Telcom Holiday Inn Express Case Study
Sunset Telcom Holiday Inn Express Case Study
Ken Tisdale
 
Garcinia cambogia: nuovo estratto miracolose per perdere peso velocemente. Tu...
Garcinia cambogia: nuovo estratto miracolose per perdere peso velocemente. Tu...Garcinia cambogia: nuovo estratto miracolose per perdere peso velocemente. Tu...
Garcinia cambogia: nuovo estratto miracolose per perdere peso velocemente. Tu...
lushbackpack3422
 
Drunk Driving Statistics
Drunk Driving StatisticsDrunk Driving Statistics
Drunk Driving Statistics
scandalouscage895
 
Analysis of adaptation and extent of adaptation to climate variability among ...
Analysis of adaptation and extent of adaptation to climate variability among ...Analysis of adaptation and extent of adaptation to climate variability among ...
Analysis of adaptation and extent of adaptation to climate variability among ...
researchagriculture
 
Beat of My Drum
Beat of My DrumBeat of My Drum
Beat of My Drum
CorySmith25
 
The City of Kingston - Customized Job Search Approach
The City of Kingston - Customized Job Search ApproachThe City of Kingston - Customized Job Search Approach
The City of Kingston - Customized Job Search Approach
St. Lawrence College Career Services
 
Farmers’ Constraints In Rice Production In South - East Nigeria
Farmers’ Constraints In Rice Production In South - East NigeriaFarmers’ Constraints In Rice Production In South - East Nigeria
Farmers’ Constraints In Rice Production In South - East Nigeria
researchagriculture
 
EQ7
EQ7EQ7
Presentación yorleny
Presentación yorlenyPresentación yorleny
Presentación yorleny
Edison Arango
 
Avj -infocity -1-
Avj  -infocity -1-Avj  -infocity -1-
Avj -infocity -1-
Shubh Sh
 
Effects of storage conditions on viability, germination and sugar content of ...
Effects of storage conditions on viability, germination and sugar content of ...Effects of storage conditions on viability, germination and sugar content of ...
Effects of storage conditions on viability, germination and sugar content of ...
researchagriculture
 
Rea en educacion 2
Rea en educacion 2Rea en educacion 2
Rea en educacion 2
Marcia Solis
 
10 kunci-sukses
10 kunci-sukses10 kunci-sukses
10 kunci-sukses
irzakhaira
 
First class Gen c
First class Gen cFirst class Gen c
First class Gen c
Francisco Cruz Guerrero
 
Call the shots
Call the shotsCall the shots
Call the shots
CorySmith25
 
Airwill
AirwillAirwill
Airwill
Shubh Sh
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Biodegradation of insecticidal compounds of Clausena anisata and Plectrant...
Biodegradation of insecticidal compounds of  Clausena anisata  and  Plectrant...Biodegradation of insecticidal compounds of  Clausena anisata  and  Plectrant...
Biodegradation of insecticidal compounds of Clausena anisata and Plectrant...
 
Analysis of the effects of monetary and fiscal policy indicators on agricult...
Analysis of the effects of monetary and fiscal policy indicators on  agricult...Analysis of the effects of monetary and fiscal policy indicators on  agricult...
Analysis of the effects of monetary and fiscal policy indicators on agricult...
 
Email Marketing: Simple Techniques That Still Work
Email Marketing: Simple Techniques That Still WorkEmail Marketing: Simple Techniques That Still Work
Email Marketing: Simple Techniques That Still Work
 
Photo's I've Took
Photo's I've TookPhoto's I've Took
Photo's I've Took
 
Sunset Telcom Holiday Inn Express Case Study
Sunset Telcom Holiday Inn Express Case StudySunset Telcom Holiday Inn Express Case Study
Sunset Telcom Holiday Inn Express Case Study
 
Garcinia cambogia: nuovo estratto miracolose per perdere peso velocemente. Tu...
Garcinia cambogia: nuovo estratto miracolose per perdere peso velocemente. Tu...Garcinia cambogia: nuovo estratto miracolose per perdere peso velocemente. Tu...
Garcinia cambogia: nuovo estratto miracolose per perdere peso velocemente. Tu...
 
Drunk Driving Statistics
Drunk Driving StatisticsDrunk Driving Statistics
Drunk Driving Statistics
 
Analysis of adaptation and extent of adaptation to climate variability among ...
Analysis of adaptation and extent of adaptation to climate variability among ...Analysis of adaptation and extent of adaptation to climate variability among ...
Analysis of adaptation and extent of adaptation to climate variability among ...
 
Beat of My Drum
Beat of My DrumBeat of My Drum
Beat of My Drum
 
The City of Kingston - Customized Job Search Approach
The City of Kingston - Customized Job Search ApproachThe City of Kingston - Customized Job Search Approach
The City of Kingston - Customized Job Search Approach
 
Farmers’ Constraints In Rice Production In South - East Nigeria
Farmers’ Constraints In Rice Production In South - East NigeriaFarmers’ Constraints In Rice Production In South - East Nigeria
Farmers’ Constraints In Rice Production In South - East Nigeria
 
EQ7
EQ7EQ7
EQ7
 
Presentación yorleny
Presentación yorlenyPresentación yorleny
Presentación yorleny
 
Avj -infocity -1-
Avj  -infocity -1-Avj  -infocity -1-
Avj -infocity -1-
 
Effects of storage conditions on viability, germination and sugar content of ...
Effects of storage conditions on viability, germination and sugar content of ...Effects of storage conditions on viability, germination and sugar content of ...
Effects of storage conditions on viability, germination and sugar content of ...
 
Rea en educacion 2
Rea en educacion 2Rea en educacion 2
Rea en educacion 2
 
10 kunci-sukses
10 kunci-sukses10 kunci-sukses
10 kunci-sukses
 
First class Gen c
First class Gen cFirst class Gen c
First class Gen c
 
Call the shots
Call the shotsCall the shots
Call the shots
 
Airwill
AirwillAirwill
Airwill
 

Similar to PORTFOLIOAssessment Article #1 Due 1-26-12

GEB-PHILOSOPHY OF EDUCATION
GEB-PHILOSOPHY OF EDUCATIONGEB-PHILOSOPHY OF EDUCATION
GEB-PHILOSOPHY OF EDUCATION
Gail E. Bentley, Ph.D., M.Ed., LPC-S
 
Using your resoruces in college
Using your resoruces in collegeUsing your resoruces in college
Using your resoruces in college
donaldquixotec
 
Project Method
Project MethodProject Method
Project Method
MeghaAlias
 
Project Method
Project MethodProject Method
Project Method
MeghaAlias
 
Ritchhart (2007) Education Quarterly Australia 1 The.docx
Ritchhart (2007) Education Quarterly Australia   1 The.docxRitchhart (2007) Education Quarterly Australia   1 The.docx
Ritchhart (2007) Education Quarterly Australia 1 The.docx
WilheminaRossi174
 
Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115
Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115
Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115
Ashley Klodt
 
Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115
Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115
Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115
Ashley Klodt
 
Questioning: Assessing how students think. (An interview with John Yeo)
Questioning: Assessing how students think. (An interview with John Yeo)Questioning: Assessing how students think. (An interview with John Yeo)
Questioning: Assessing how students think. (An interview with John Yeo)
John Yeo
 
The Assessment Of Formative Assessment
The Assessment Of Formative AssessmentThe Assessment Of Formative Assessment
The Assessment Of Formative Assessment
Carla Bennington
 
ePortfolio improves 'scientist-based' integrative professional and career dev...
ePortfolio improves 'scientist-based' integrative professional and career dev...ePortfolio improves 'scientist-based' integrative professional and career dev...
ePortfolio improves 'scientist-based' integrative professional and career dev...
ePortfolios Australia
 
C:\Users\Shayne\Documents\Group Assignment Slide Show
C:\Users\Shayne\Documents\Group Assignment   Slide ShowC:\Users\Shayne\Documents\Group Assignment   Slide Show
C:\Users\Shayne\Documents\Group Assignment Slide Show
Shayne Griggs
 
continue assessment test.waheed
continue assessment test.waheedcontinue assessment test.waheed
continue assessment test.waheed
Waheed javed, Student at INDUS COLLEGE OF NURSING
 
PhilosophyofTeachingStatement01
PhilosophyofTeachingStatement01PhilosophyofTeachingStatement01
PhilosophyofTeachingStatement01
Perla Rodriguez Arroyo, B.A
 
Managing the advanced learner - Handouts
Managing the advanced learner - HandoutsManaging the advanced learner - Handouts
Managing the advanced learner - Handouts
Abu Dhabi International Book Fair Professional Program
 
Curriculum Development And Change Essay
Curriculum Development And Change EssayCurriculum Development And Change Essay
Curriculum Development And Change Essay
Write My Paper Cheap Chillicothe
 
Learning Theory Job Aid Paper.docx
Learning Theory Job Aid Paper.docxLearning Theory Job Aid Paper.docx
Learning Theory Job Aid Paper.docx
BethanyClatt
 
Teaching strategies.pptx
Teaching strategies.pptxTeaching strategies.pptx
Teaching strategies.pptx
Aliimtiaz35
 
Using Your Resources in College
Using Your Resources in CollegeUsing Your Resources in College
Using Your Resources in College
donaldquixotec
 
Curriculum and teaching philosophies paper 2016
Curriculum and teaching philosophies paper 2016Curriculum and teaching philosophies paper 2016
Curriculum and teaching philosophies paper 2016
Angela Kiker, MA, PGCE
 
Rules to engage student in learning
Rules to engage student in learningRules to engage student in learning
Rules to engage student in learning
Eduminatti1
 

Similar to PORTFOLIOAssessment Article #1 Due 1-26-12 (20)

GEB-PHILOSOPHY OF EDUCATION
GEB-PHILOSOPHY OF EDUCATIONGEB-PHILOSOPHY OF EDUCATION
GEB-PHILOSOPHY OF EDUCATION
 
Using your resoruces in college
Using your resoruces in collegeUsing your resoruces in college
Using your resoruces in college
 
Project Method
Project MethodProject Method
Project Method
 
Project Method
Project MethodProject Method
Project Method
 
Ritchhart (2007) Education Quarterly Australia 1 The.docx
Ritchhart (2007) Education Quarterly Australia   1 The.docxRitchhart (2007) Education Quarterly Australia   1 The.docx
Ritchhart (2007) Education Quarterly Australia 1 The.docx
 
Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115
Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115
Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115
 
Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115
Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115
Klodt a project_basedlearning_soe115
 
Questioning: Assessing how students think. (An interview with John Yeo)
Questioning: Assessing how students think. (An interview with John Yeo)Questioning: Assessing how students think. (An interview with John Yeo)
Questioning: Assessing how students think. (An interview with John Yeo)
 
The Assessment Of Formative Assessment
The Assessment Of Formative AssessmentThe Assessment Of Formative Assessment
The Assessment Of Formative Assessment
 
ePortfolio improves 'scientist-based' integrative professional and career dev...
ePortfolio improves 'scientist-based' integrative professional and career dev...ePortfolio improves 'scientist-based' integrative professional and career dev...
ePortfolio improves 'scientist-based' integrative professional and career dev...
 
C:\Users\Shayne\Documents\Group Assignment Slide Show
C:\Users\Shayne\Documents\Group Assignment   Slide ShowC:\Users\Shayne\Documents\Group Assignment   Slide Show
C:\Users\Shayne\Documents\Group Assignment Slide Show
 
continue assessment test.waheed
continue assessment test.waheedcontinue assessment test.waheed
continue assessment test.waheed
 
PhilosophyofTeachingStatement01
PhilosophyofTeachingStatement01PhilosophyofTeachingStatement01
PhilosophyofTeachingStatement01
 
Managing the advanced learner - Handouts
Managing the advanced learner - HandoutsManaging the advanced learner - Handouts
Managing the advanced learner - Handouts
 
Curriculum Development And Change Essay
Curriculum Development And Change EssayCurriculum Development And Change Essay
Curriculum Development And Change Essay
 
Learning Theory Job Aid Paper.docx
Learning Theory Job Aid Paper.docxLearning Theory Job Aid Paper.docx
Learning Theory Job Aid Paper.docx
 
Teaching strategies.pptx
Teaching strategies.pptxTeaching strategies.pptx
Teaching strategies.pptx
 
Using Your Resources in College
Using Your Resources in CollegeUsing Your Resources in College
Using Your Resources in College
 
Curriculum and teaching philosophies paper 2016
Curriculum and teaching philosophies paper 2016Curriculum and teaching philosophies paper 2016
Curriculum and teaching philosophies paper 2016
 
Rules to engage student in learning
Rules to engage student in learningRules to engage student in learning
Rules to engage student in learning
 

More from Christine M. Schmitt

PORTFOLIOText%20Sets[1]
PORTFOLIOText%20Sets[1]PORTFOLIOText%20Sets[1]
PORTFOLIOText%20Sets[1]
Christine M. Schmitt
 
SAMPLE LESSON PLAN
SAMPLE LESSON PLANSAMPLE LESSON PLAN
SAMPLE LESSON PLAN
Christine M. Schmitt
 
EDUCATION PHILOSOPHY
EDUCATION PHILOSOPHYEDUCATION PHILOSOPHY
EDUCATION PHILOSOPHY
Christine M. Schmitt
 
Schmitt_Resume_43015
Schmitt_Resume_43015Schmitt_Resume_43015
Schmitt_Resume_43015
Christine M. Schmitt
 
Teaching Certificate
Teaching CertificateTeaching Certificate
Teaching Certificate
Christine M. Schmitt
 
ODD presentation
ODD presentationODD presentation
ODD presentation
Christine M. Schmitt
 
The art of slow reading presentation
The art of slow reading presentationThe art of slow reading presentation
The art of slow reading presentation
Christine M. Schmitt
 

More from Christine M. Schmitt (7)

PORTFOLIOText%20Sets[1]
PORTFOLIOText%20Sets[1]PORTFOLIOText%20Sets[1]
PORTFOLIOText%20Sets[1]
 
SAMPLE LESSON PLAN
SAMPLE LESSON PLANSAMPLE LESSON PLAN
SAMPLE LESSON PLAN
 
EDUCATION PHILOSOPHY
EDUCATION PHILOSOPHYEDUCATION PHILOSOPHY
EDUCATION PHILOSOPHY
 
Schmitt_Resume_43015
Schmitt_Resume_43015Schmitt_Resume_43015
Schmitt_Resume_43015
 
Teaching Certificate
Teaching CertificateTeaching Certificate
Teaching Certificate
 
ODD presentation
ODD presentationODD presentation
ODD presentation
 
The art of slow reading presentation
The art of slow reading presentationThe art of slow reading presentation
The art of slow reading presentation
 

PORTFOLIOAssessment Article #1 Due 1-26-12

  • 1. ASSESSINGYOUNG CHILDREN BY: DR. CATHY GRACE
  • 2. Dr. Cathy Grace’sarticle illustratesthe importance of usingcommonsense whenassessing youngchildren.Herrecommendedmethodsaddressthe dilemmabetweenthe growingemphasisof standardizedtestingandthe beliefthatchildren’sdevelopmentis,“…continuousandongoing”, and, “…that other methods may be more accurate than the once-a-year testing event.” Dr. Grace suggests the implementation of a student portfolio. In this individualized plan, students create a tangible record of their learning progress. Teacher and student collaborate to collect samples of work that bring together knowledge and skills used in the real world with, “…the goals of the educational program…” Elements of the student portfolio include art work, writing samples and photographs of cooperative work and building structures. The teacherinformsthe studentabouthow the workis evaluatedagainstastandard. Educator and pupil discusswhatworkwill orwill notbe includedinthe portfolio. Dr.Grace believesthatchildren as youngas four yearsoldare capable of thistask. Studentsare encouragedtodemonstrate their understandingof thisprocessbyexplainingittoothers. Finally, the portfolio is shared with parents at conference time. The decision is also made whether to release the portfolio at the end of the school year, or to carry it over for subsequent school years for a cumulative record. I found this article unique and informative. While standardized testing has a purpose, I like the idea of ongoing, meaningful progress for children. I say this because I realize some students do not test as well as others, and so the “testing session” is not an accurate reflection, but more of a random “snapshot” of perceived knowledge. In other words, the testing criteria, while important, can only by design test for but a fraction of the knowledge contained in
  • 3. anyone’s mind. The testing process is stressful, lengthy (for a day), and temporary. This may lead to a tendency to “teach to the test”. Dr. Grace’s ideas provide for students whose strengths lie in a long term framework. I admire Dr. Grace’s apparent dedication to the learning process, which can be difficult to measure. I like that there seems to be much student involvement in the model she presents. As with many things, I think students will benefit more from something they thoroughly understand and of which they play a major role.
  • 4. REFERENCES Grace, Dr. Cathy: Assessing Young Children www.pbs.org/teachers/earlychildhood/articles/assessing.html