This document summarizes a case study of the EasySeva public-private partnership telecenter project in Sri Lanka. The project began as a pilot and is now transitioning to being scaled nationally. The summary examines the project's focus on sustainability and scalability as it expands. Key lessons from the successful pilot include employing a franchise model, providing multiple valuable services, promoting local entrepreneurship and capacity building. The project also aims to support small and medium enterprises, an important sector for economic development. Overall the case provides insights on best practices for transitioning pilots successfully to larger scaled projects.
Knowledge produced in the public sector has been found to be an important ingredient of
economic growth and technological progress. Close links to academic research have further
been shown to be beneficial for innovation performance of the individual firm. As there are
many different channels through which academic science reaches the private sector, most
prominently licensing contracts, joint research and academic consulting, it is important for
the decision making of policy makers and managers to assess their effectiveness. Most of the
existing research has focused on formal university technology transfer mechanisms, i.e. those
that embody or directly lead to a legal instrument like a patent, license or royalty agreement.
Only a few authors have investigated informal university technology transfer mechanisms.
Informal technology transfer focuses on non-contractual interactions of the agents involved,
i.e. on university scientists and industry personnel. Research suggests that formal and
informal technology transfer may go well together in that informal contacts improve the
quality of a formal relationship or that formal contracts are accompanied by an informal
relation of mutual exchange on technology-related aspects.
In this paper, we analyze whether these activities are mutually reinforcing, i.e.
complementary. Our analysis is based on a comprehensive dataset of more than 2,000
German manufacturing firms. We perform direct and indirect tests for the complementarity of
formal and informal technology transfer. Our results confirm a complementary relationship:
using both transfer channels contributes to higher innovation performance. The management
of the firm should therefore strive to maintain close informal relationships with universities to
realize the full potential of formal technology transfer.
Facing the future: Sense-making in Horizon ScanningTotti Könnölä
The document summarizes a conference on horizon scanning and sense-making. It discusses how horizon scanning involves collecting observations of potential future developments and deriving policy implications. Sense-making is inseparable from scanning and involves perceiving, interpreting and constructing meaning from emerging trends. The case study described a horizon scanning exercise where 381 issues were identified, assessed, and synthesized into cross-cutting challenges to inform EU policymaking recommendations on sustainability, social changes, and governance.
Software Sustainability: The Challenges and Opportunities for Enterprises and...Patricia Lago
This is the opening keynote presentation to the 14th IFIP WG 8.1 Working Conference on the Practice of Enterprise Modeling (PoEM) 2021. See at https://poem2021.rtu.lv/program
Sustainability - The Software PerspectivePatricia Lago
This document summarizes a presentation by Patricia Lago on software and sustainability. The key points are:
1) Software can both help and hinder sustainability depending on how it is designed and deployed. The software architecture perspective can provide a "big picture" view of sustainability impacts.
2) Lago's research group at Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam focuses on topics like software architecture for digital sustainability, architectural technical debt, and the software energy footprint.
3) Effective decision making around software and sustainability requires informed strategies using tools like the Sustainability Assessment Framework, which includes decision maps to explore design options and their impacts over time.
The History of Software Architecture: In the eye of the practitionerPatricia Lago
Software architecture (SA) is celebrating 25 years. This is so if we consider the seminal papers establishing SA as a distinct discipline, and scientific publications that have identified cornerstones of both research and practice, like architecture views, architecture description languages, and architecture evaluation.
With the pervasive use of cloud provisioning, the dynamic integration of multi-party distributed services, and the steep increase in the digitalization of business and society, making sound design decisions encompasses an increasingly-large and complex problem space. The role of SA is essential as never before, so much so that no organization undertakes ‘serious’ projects without the support of suitable architecture practices.
But, how did SA practice evolve in the past 25 years? And what are the challenges ahead?
There have been various attempts to summarize the state of research and practice of SA. Still, we miss the practitioners’ view on the questions above.
To fill this gap, we have first extracted the top-10 topics resulting from the analysis of 5,622 scientific papers. Then, we have used such topics to design an online survey filled out by 57 SA practitioners with 5 to 20+ years of experience.
GLOBAL FORESIGHT: LESSONS FROM SCENARIO AND ROADMAPPING EXERCISE ON MANUFACTU...Totti Könnölä
Geographical dispersion, organisational and cultural differences, and numerous participants characterise international foresight exercises. In this paper, the authors develop four principles for the design and management of global foresight exercises building on the experience from designing and managing a foresight process in connection with the Intelligent Management FacturingManufacturing Systems (IMS) 2020 project. The authors reflect and discuss against the exercise the suitability of the four principles for global foresight in general. For instance, understanding interconnected innovation systems is crucial for helping participants to position the exercise and their own activities better in the global context; responsiveness towards diversity of stakeholders strengthen commitment and encourage learning and creative problem solving; embeddedness of foresight in existing international networks benefits from existing organisational structures and facilitates for timely and efficiently mobilisation of stakeholder communities; finally, ‘glocal’ impact orientation connects foresight activities to both local and international decision-making structures. Furthermore, the findings indicate that scalable design is one of the key determinants for succesfulsuccessful adaption of foresight to geographical dispersion and numerous participants.
Innovation diffusion in feature films and episodic television - sept 2011 - ...Dave Litwiller
This document summarizes research on the slow rate of innovation diffusion in project-based industries like film and television production. It identifies several factors that contribute to cautious adoption of new technologies in these fields, such as risk avoidance, the lateral nature of organizations, and teams reconstituting with each new project. It provides recommendations for technology purveyors to accelerate adoption, including showing how early projects using the new technology were successful and de-risked, ensuring a short learning curve, and delivering economic benefits to all ecosystem players. The gold standards for relatively rapid adoption are technologies that significantly reduce costs while expanding creativity or clearly increase revenue.
Knowledge produced in the public sector has been found to be an important ingredient of
economic growth and technological progress. Close links to academic research have further
been shown to be beneficial for innovation performance of the individual firm. As there are
many different channels through which academic science reaches the private sector, most
prominently licensing contracts, joint research and academic consulting, it is important for
the decision making of policy makers and managers to assess their effectiveness. Most of the
existing research has focused on formal university technology transfer mechanisms, i.e. those
that embody or directly lead to a legal instrument like a patent, license or royalty agreement.
Only a few authors have investigated informal university technology transfer mechanisms.
Informal technology transfer focuses on non-contractual interactions of the agents involved,
i.e. on university scientists and industry personnel. Research suggests that formal and
informal technology transfer may go well together in that informal contacts improve the
quality of a formal relationship or that formal contracts are accompanied by an informal
relation of mutual exchange on technology-related aspects.
In this paper, we analyze whether these activities are mutually reinforcing, i.e.
complementary. Our analysis is based on a comprehensive dataset of more than 2,000
German manufacturing firms. We perform direct and indirect tests for the complementarity of
formal and informal technology transfer. Our results confirm a complementary relationship:
using both transfer channels contributes to higher innovation performance. The management
of the firm should therefore strive to maintain close informal relationships with universities to
realize the full potential of formal technology transfer.
Facing the future: Sense-making in Horizon ScanningTotti Könnölä
The document summarizes a conference on horizon scanning and sense-making. It discusses how horizon scanning involves collecting observations of potential future developments and deriving policy implications. Sense-making is inseparable from scanning and involves perceiving, interpreting and constructing meaning from emerging trends. The case study described a horizon scanning exercise where 381 issues were identified, assessed, and synthesized into cross-cutting challenges to inform EU policymaking recommendations on sustainability, social changes, and governance.
Software Sustainability: The Challenges and Opportunities for Enterprises and...Patricia Lago
This is the opening keynote presentation to the 14th IFIP WG 8.1 Working Conference on the Practice of Enterprise Modeling (PoEM) 2021. See at https://poem2021.rtu.lv/program
Sustainability - The Software PerspectivePatricia Lago
This document summarizes a presentation by Patricia Lago on software and sustainability. The key points are:
1) Software can both help and hinder sustainability depending on how it is designed and deployed. The software architecture perspective can provide a "big picture" view of sustainability impacts.
2) Lago's research group at Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam focuses on topics like software architecture for digital sustainability, architectural technical debt, and the software energy footprint.
3) Effective decision making around software and sustainability requires informed strategies using tools like the Sustainability Assessment Framework, which includes decision maps to explore design options and their impacts over time.
The History of Software Architecture: In the eye of the practitionerPatricia Lago
Software architecture (SA) is celebrating 25 years. This is so if we consider the seminal papers establishing SA as a distinct discipline, and scientific publications that have identified cornerstones of both research and practice, like architecture views, architecture description languages, and architecture evaluation.
With the pervasive use of cloud provisioning, the dynamic integration of multi-party distributed services, and the steep increase in the digitalization of business and society, making sound design decisions encompasses an increasingly-large and complex problem space. The role of SA is essential as never before, so much so that no organization undertakes ‘serious’ projects without the support of suitable architecture practices.
But, how did SA practice evolve in the past 25 years? And what are the challenges ahead?
There have been various attempts to summarize the state of research and practice of SA. Still, we miss the practitioners’ view on the questions above.
To fill this gap, we have first extracted the top-10 topics resulting from the analysis of 5,622 scientific papers. Then, we have used such topics to design an online survey filled out by 57 SA practitioners with 5 to 20+ years of experience.
GLOBAL FORESIGHT: LESSONS FROM SCENARIO AND ROADMAPPING EXERCISE ON MANUFACTU...Totti Könnölä
Geographical dispersion, organisational and cultural differences, and numerous participants characterise international foresight exercises. In this paper, the authors develop four principles for the design and management of global foresight exercises building on the experience from designing and managing a foresight process in connection with the Intelligent Management FacturingManufacturing Systems (IMS) 2020 project. The authors reflect and discuss against the exercise the suitability of the four principles for global foresight in general. For instance, understanding interconnected innovation systems is crucial for helping participants to position the exercise and their own activities better in the global context; responsiveness towards diversity of stakeholders strengthen commitment and encourage learning and creative problem solving; embeddedness of foresight in existing international networks benefits from existing organisational structures and facilitates for timely and efficiently mobilisation of stakeholder communities; finally, ‘glocal’ impact orientation connects foresight activities to both local and international decision-making structures. Furthermore, the findings indicate that scalable design is one of the key determinants for succesfulsuccessful adaption of foresight to geographical dispersion and numerous participants.
Innovation diffusion in feature films and episodic television - sept 2011 - ...Dave Litwiller
This document summarizes research on the slow rate of innovation diffusion in project-based industries like film and television production. It identifies several factors that contribute to cautious adoption of new technologies in these fields, such as risk avoidance, the lateral nature of organizations, and teams reconstituting with each new project. It provides recommendations for technology purveyors to accelerate adoption, including showing how early projects using the new technology were successful and de-risked, ensuring a short learning curve, and delivering economic benefits to all ecosystem players. The gold standards for relatively rapid adoption are technologies that significantly reduce costs while expanding creativity or clearly increase revenue.
IS CROWDFUNDING DOOMED IN SWEDEN? WHEN INSTITUTIONAL LOGICS AND AFFORDANCES C...Robin Teigland
Crowdfunding has been embraced by entrepreneurs across the globe as an alternative, and well-publicized, source of start-up financing. In Sweden, despite the apparent benefits of crowdfunding, high levels of internet
connectivity and a reputation for producing global ICT entrepreneurs, crowdfunding has not (yet) been embraced among ICT entrepreneurs. This paper explores this empirical puzzle in light of technology affordances and
institutional entrepreneurship literatures, as well as their complementarity. After presenting the methodology and preliminary findings of this qualitative case study of the crowdfunding phenomenon in Sweden, it concludes with a few salient findings of this ongoing project. These findings suggest that both the design of the platform and existing institutional logics among entrepreneurs shape perceptions of affordances and thus the adoption of this new form of start-up financing.
Adel Ben Youssef: Determinants of the adoption of cloud computing by tunisian...CBOD ANR project U-PSUD
Determinants of the adoption of cloud computing by tunisian firms, an exploratory study
Adel Ben Youssef, Walid Hadhri, Téja Maherzi, Université de Sopia Antipolis, ISG Tunis,
-session 6-
International conference on
“DATA, DIGITAL BUSINESS MODELS, CLOUD COMPUTING AND ORGANIZATIONAL DESIGN”
24-25 November 2014 ,
Université Paris–Sud
Green Software: Architecture Decision-making for SustainabilityPatricia Lago
Sustainability is one of the most obvious ethical quality attributes for IT systems.
Patricia Lago is a professor at the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam and leads the Software and Services research group, with a special focus on sustainability and green IT. In this talk at the LAC 2018 (https://www.laccongres.nl), she will explain the notion of sustainability and the choices that architects can make to increase the sustainability of their design.
Adopting sustainability in ICT industry: from the trenchesPatricia Lago
This presentation was given at the 2017 National Sustainability Day in Higher Education, in collaboration with GreenIT Amsterdam.
It presented preliminary results of the GreenServe project, where we measured the sustainability impact of software-intensive systems of IT and software companies and built decision maps to help informed decision making.
All rights reserved (c) Patricia Lago.
Research-To-Impact Canvas - one page planning tool for research, KT and Comme...KBHN KT
The Research to Impact Canvas is an innovative adaptation of the Business Model Canvas, for use by researchers and KT professionals. While the BMC is used as a one-page quick and easily modifiable business plan (before writing the longer 30-40 page business plan) this Research to Impact Canvas provides a one page planning tool for sketching out the integrated research, KT and commercialization activities while budgeting for each activity. Partners, target audiences, and other considerations that are all part of a full KT or Commercialization plan can be planned alongside the research activities. In this way, this tool encourages the user to think about the usefulness (value proposition to the end user, because of the needs they are addressing with the work) of their research, in conjunction with (NOT isolated or separate from) their KT and/or Commercialization plan. This is how we can operationalize the Co-Produced Pathway to Impact, which requires co-production with non-academic stakeholders which could be partners or end-users. The capitalized letters in this tool indicate the stages of the CPPI framework that correspond with it - RESEARCH, DISSEMINATION, UPTAKE, IMPLEMENTATION and IMPACT. In this version of the tool, the spaces are empty and can be typed into directly, or it can be printed on 11x17 paper and posted on the wall for collaborative planning with project team members using post-it notes, or it can be printed on 8.5x11 paper if reduced to 66%.
We have also created an instructional video that will explain and demonstrate how to use it: https://youtu.be/Cz0l1viEFmc
In the video, I mention that you need to write a “Value Proposition” statement for each type of end-user you identify, and that there are different templates online. For convenience, I am providing you with two templates for crafting a value proposition statement:
Template #1:
End User: __________________________ (who is your end-user/target audience)
Problem: _________________________________ (what problem/need you’re solving for the end-user)
Solution:__________________________________ (what is your solution for the problem/need)
Template #2:
For______________________________________________(target audience/end-user)
who______________________________________________(state the problem/need(s))
is a ______________________________________________(your project’s title/name)
that ______________________________________________(benefit statement, explain how your work will provide a solution for these end-user’s needs).
Crowdsourcing vs. Technology Scouting in a B2B settingMichael Heiss
Technology scouting and crowdsourcing are two approaches for technology sourcing. Technology scouting involves systematically searching databases, the internet, and networks to identify relevant technology offerings. Crowdsourcing involves soliciting contributions from a large group of people by making technology needs public. The document discusses the key differences between the approaches and lessons learned from Siemens' experiences using both methods.
WEB 2.0 FOR FORESIGHT: EXPERIENCES ON AN INNOVATION PLATFORM IN EUROPEAN AGEN...Totti Könnölä
The document summarizes a web 2.0 foresight exercise conducted by the European Commission to gather ideas for future Knowledge and Innovation Communities. It describes the 6 steps taken: 1) defining objectives, 2) analysing conditions, 3) scoping the exercise, 4) choosing methods/tools, 5) running the platform, and 6) following up. The exercise involved an online platform where over 100 ideas were posted and commented on over 7 weeks to inform the European Institute of Innovation and Technology's strategic priorities. Key lessons included the need for clear objectives, piloting tools, and planning for data analysis and platform follow-up.
Presentation by Steve Crouch, Software Architect at the Software Sustainability Institute.
Presented at the Digital Social Research: Sustainability Training Workshop at OeRC, Oxford on 12 December 2011.
To better prepare policy and decision makers in today’s complex and inter-dependent environments, FTA methods can play a significant role in enabling early warning signal detection and pro-active policy action. This paper analyses the use of different horizon scanning approaches and methods as applied in the SESTI project. A comparative analysis is provided as well as a brief evaluation of meeting the needs of policy-makers in identify areas of intervention by policy formulation. The paper suggests that the selection of the best scanning approaches and methods is subject to contextual and content issues. At the same time, there are certain issues characterising horizon scanning processes, methods and results that should be kept in mind by both practitioners and policy-makers.
TED Talk – Van der Meulen – EUWIN - Workplace Innovation: Creating a mass mov...Sociotechnical Roundtable
This document discusses workplace innovation and creating a mass movement around it in Europe. It outlines the benefits of workplace innovation for growth in small-and-medium enterprises. While workplace innovation leads to substantial growth, not all companies adopt it due to information problems and slow diffusion. The EUWIN (European Workplace Innovation Network) is proposed as a way to help more companies adopt workplace innovation through five cornerstones: upscaling efforts, collecting ideas, building support systems, focusing messaging, and overcoming barriers. The document requests support and outlines how various stakeholders can help promote and advance workplace innovation.
The document discusses a project called "egosta" which aims to actively involve stakeholders in the development of new e-government applications using a web-based platform. The platform utilizes Web 2.0 technologies like wikis, blogs and forums to facilitate collaboration between stakeholders and project teams. The goal is to develop more user-friendly applications and increase acceptance of new e-government services by incorporating stakeholder input early in the process. Egosta has been tested on the "Virtual Company Dossier" use case in Austria. The document also outlines research questions around measuring how well Web 2.0 can facilitate stakeholder participation and the level of moderation required for an e-participation platform.
Software is being developed since decades without taking sustainability into consideration. This holds for its energy efficiency, that is the amount of energy software consumes while ensuring other system qualities like security, performance, reliability, etc. etc. Software un-sustainability, however, is becoming increasingly evident with the growing interest worldwide. Finally IT specialists are becoming aware that software solutions can, and should, be designed with sustainability concerns in mind. In doing so, they can create solutions that are technically more stable (hence requiring less modifications over time), target societal goals with a higher certainty, or help sustaining the business goals of both developing and consuming organizations. Everything sounds great. The real question is: how? How can we redirect software engineering practices toward sustainable software solutions? And how can we turn sustainability into a business so that companies will finally invest in it? This talk explores results and challenges in engineering software with a sustainability intent.
The current Balanced Score Card for Enterprise Social Networks. The goal was to define actionable metrics which help to steer the internal social media application TechnoWeb at Siemens.The talk was presented at the Knowledge Management Days in Krems, Austria in May 2014.
Self-adaptation Approaches for Energy EfficiencyPatricia Lago
The increasing energy demands of software systems have set an
essential software quality requirement: energy efficiency. At the
same time, the many contextual changes faced by software systems
during execution can hamper their functionality and overall
quality. To address both problems, self-adaptation approaches can
empower software systems, at both design-time and runtime, to
adapt to dynamic conditions. In this way, software systems can
be more resilient to failure, hence more trustful to satisfy the demands
of modern digital society. In this paper, we perform a systematic
literature review to study the state-of-the-art on existing
self-adaptation approaches for energy efficiency. We analyze the
identified approaches from three different perspectives, namely
publication trends, application domains, and types of software systems.
Our findings can help solution providers to make guided
decisions to enable self-adaptability in designing and engineering
software systems.
Lessons Learned from the Siemens Smart Grid Innovation ContestMichael Heiss
The document provides details about the Smart Grid Innovation Contest conducted by Siemens, including lessons learned. The contest occurred in two phases: Phase I was a public idea contest that attracted 35,000 unique visitors and 1,500 registered users. Phase II was a call for research proposals directed at universities, which received 172 abstract submissions and selected 25 for full proposals. Key lessons included crowd ideation being more challenging for complex technologies, the importance of community involvement and IP considerations, and motivating participant submissions through visibility and job opportunities at Siemens.
This document describes a "Research meets Business" matchmaking event organized by a research institution to connect local enterprises with university researchers. The event features:
1) Short presentations by researchers on their projects related to a focused theme (here, instrumentation and health).
2) Individual meetings between enterprises and researchers to discuss potential partnerships.
3) The goal is to trigger technology transfer and collaboration opportunities between the research institution and local businesses.
Designing Software with a Sustainability Intent - The Software Sustainability...Patricia Lago
This talk explains the SoSA method and how it can scope the complexity of the problem of designing for software solutions to realize sustainability goals.
El documento describe las seis fases del método de ciclo de vida para el desarrollo de sistemas: investigación preliminar, determinación de los requerimientos del sistema, diseño del sistema, desarrollo del software, prueba de sistemas e implantación y evaluación. Cada fase involucra actividades específicas para desarrollar e implementar un sistema de información de manera efectiva.
Estrategias para la cosecha espiritualEberto Mejia
Este documento presenta un curso sobre estrategias para la cosecha espiritual dividido en cuatro partes: Visualización, Conceptualización, Objetivación y Expectación. La primera parte, Visualización, se enfoca en identificar la visión espiritual y explica que sin visión las personas perecen espiritualmente. El capítulo uno describe el proceso de nacimiento de una visión espiritual a través de ejemplos bíblicos.
IS CROWDFUNDING DOOMED IN SWEDEN? WHEN INSTITUTIONAL LOGICS AND AFFORDANCES C...Robin Teigland
Crowdfunding has been embraced by entrepreneurs across the globe as an alternative, and well-publicized, source of start-up financing. In Sweden, despite the apparent benefits of crowdfunding, high levels of internet
connectivity and a reputation for producing global ICT entrepreneurs, crowdfunding has not (yet) been embraced among ICT entrepreneurs. This paper explores this empirical puzzle in light of technology affordances and
institutional entrepreneurship literatures, as well as their complementarity. After presenting the methodology and preliminary findings of this qualitative case study of the crowdfunding phenomenon in Sweden, it concludes with a few salient findings of this ongoing project. These findings suggest that both the design of the platform and existing institutional logics among entrepreneurs shape perceptions of affordances and thus the adoption of this new form of start-up financing.
Adel Ben Youssef: Determinants of the adoption of cloud computing by tunisian...CBOD ANR project U-PSUD
Determinants of the adoption of cloud computing by tunisian firms, an exploratory study
Adel Ben Youssef, Walid Hadhri, Téja Maherzi, Université de Sopia Antipolis, ISG Tunis,
-session 6-
International conference on
“DATA, DIGITAL BUSINESS MODELS, CLOUD COMPUTING AND ORGANIZATIONAL DESIGN”
24-25 November 2014 ,
Université Paris–Sud
Green Software: Architecture Decision-making for SustainabilityPatricia Lago
Sustainability is one of the most obvious ethical quality attributes for IT systems.
Patricia Lago is a professor at the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam and leads the Software and Services research group, with a special focus on sustainability and green IT. In this talk at the LAC 2018 (https://www.laccongres.nl), she will explain the notion of sustainability and the choices that architects can make to increase the sustainability of their design.
Adopting sustainability in ICT industry: from the trenchesPatricia Lago
This presentation was given at the 2017 National Sustainability Day in Higher Education, in collaboration with GreenIT Amsterdam.
It presented preliminary results of the GreenServe project, where we measured the sustainability impact of software-intensive systems of IT and software companies and built decision maps to help informed decision making.
All rights reserved (c) Patricia Lago.
Research-To-Impact Canvas - one page planning tool for research, KT and Comme...KBHN KT
The Research to Impact Canvas is an innovative adaptation of the Business Model Canvas, for use by researchers and KT professionals. While the BMC is used as a one-page quick and easily modifiable business plan (before writing the longer 30-40 page business plan) this Research to Impact Canvas provides a one page planning tool for sketching out the integrated research, KT and commercialization activities while budgeting for each activity. Partners, target audiences, and other considerations that are all part of a full KT or Commercialization plan can be planned alongside the research activities. In this way, this tool encourages the user to think about the usefulness (value proposition to the end user, because of the needs they are addressing with the work) of their research, in conjunction with (NOT isolated or separate from) their KT and/or Commercialization plan. This is how we can operationalize the Co-Produced Pathway to Impact, which requires co-production with non-academic stakeholders which could be partners or end-users. The capitalized letters in this tool indicate the stages of the CPPI framework that correspond with it - RESEARCH, DISSEMINATION, UPTAKE, IMPLEMENTATION and IMPACT. In this version of the tool, the spaces are empty and can be typed into directly, or it can be printed on 11x17 paper and posted on the wall for collaborative planning with project team members using post-it notes, or it can be printed on 8.5x11 paper if reduced to 66%.
We have also created an instructional video that will explain and demonstrate how to use it: https://youtu.be/Cz0l1viEFmc
In the video, I mention that you need to write a “Value Proposition” statement for each type of end-user you identify, and that there are different templates online. For convenience, I am providing you with two templates for crafting a value proposition statement:
Template #1:
End User: __________________________ (who is your end-user/target audience)
Problem: _________________________________ (what problem/need you’re solving for the end-user)
Solution:__________________________________ (what is your solution for the problem/need)
Template #2:
For______________________________________________(target audience/end-user)
who______________________________________________(state the problem/need(s))
is a ______________________________________________(your project’s title/name)
that ______________________________________________(benefit statement, explain how your work will provide a solution for these end-user’s needs).
Crowdsourcing vs. Technology Scouting in a B2B settingMichael Heiss
Technology scouting and crowdsourcing are two approaches for technology sourcing. Technology scouting involves systematically searching databases, the internet, and networks to identify relevant technology offerings. Crowdsourcing involves soliciting contributions from a large group of people by making technology needs public. The document discusses the key differences between the approaches and lessons learned from Siemens' experiences using both methods.
WEB 2.0 FOR FORESIGHT: EXPERIENCES ON AN INNOVATION PLATFORM IN EUROPEAN AGEN...Totti Könnölä
The document summarizes a web 2.0 foresight exercise conducted by the European Commission to gather ideas for future Knowledge and Innovation Communities. It describes the 6 steps taken: 1) defining objectives, 2) analysing conditions, 3) scoping the exercise, 4) choosing methods/tools, 5) running the platform, and 6) following up. The exercise involved an online platform where over 100 ideas were posted and commented on over 7 weeks to inform the European Institute of Innovation and Technology's strategic priorities. Key lessons included the need for clear objectives, piloting tools, and planning for data analysis and platform follow-up.
Presentation by Steve Crouch, Software Architect at the Software Sustainability Institute.
Presented at the Digital Social Research: Sustainability Training Workshop at OeRC, Oxford on 12 December 2011.
To better prepare policy and decision makers in today’s complex and inter-dependent environments, FTA methods can play a significant role in enabling early warning signal detection and pro-active policy action. This paper analyses the use of different horizon scanning approaches and methods as applied in the SESTI project. A comparative analysis is provided as well as a brief evaluation of meeting the needs of policy-makers in identify areas of intervention by policy formulation. The paper suggests that the selection of the best scanning approaches and methods is subject to contextual and content issues. At the same time, there are certain issues characterising horizon scanning processes, methods and results that should be kept in mind by both practitioners and policy-makers.
TED Talk – Van der Meulen – EUWIN - Workplace Innovation: Creating a mass mov...Sociotechnical Roundtable
This document discusses workplace innovation and creating a mass movement around it in Europe. It outlines the benefits of workplace innovation for growth in small-and-medium enterprises. While workplace innovation leads to substantial growth, not all companies adopt it due to information problems and slow diffusion. The EUWIN (European Workplace Innovation Network) is proposed as a way to help more companies adopt workplace innovation through five cornerstones: upscaling efforts, collecting ideas, building support systems, focusing messaging, and overcoming barriers. The document requests support and outlines how various stakeholders can help promote and advance workplace innovation.
The document discusses a project called "egosta" which aims to actively involve stakeholders in the development of new e-government applications using a web-based platform. The platform utilizes Web 2.0 technologies like wikis, blogs and forums to facilitate collaboration between stakeholders and project teams. The goal is to develop more user-friendly applications and increase acceptance of new e-government services by incorporating stakeholder input early in the process. Egosta has been tested on the "Virtual Company Dossier" use case in Austria. The document also outlines research questions around measuring how well Web 2.0 can facilitate stakeholder participation and the level of moderation required for an e-participation platform.
Software is being developed since decades without taking sustainability into consideration. This holds for its energy efficiency, that is the amount of energy software consumes while ensuring other system qualities like security, performance, reliability, etc. etc. Software un-sustainability, however, is becoming increasingly evident with the growing interest worldwide. Finally IT specialists are becoming aware that software solutions can, and should, be designed with sustainability concerns in mind. In doing so, they can create solutions that are technically more stable (hence requiring less modifications over time), target societal goals with a higher certainty, or help sustaining the business goals of both developing and consuming organizations. Everything sounds great. The real question is: how? How can we redirect software engineering practices toward sustainable software solutions? And how can we turn sustainability into a business so that companies will finally invest in it? This talk explores results and challenges in engineering software with a sustainability intent.
The current Balanced Score Card for Enterprise Social Networks. The goal was to define actionable metrics which help to steer the internal social media application TechnoWeb at Siemens.The talk was presented at the Knowledge Management Days in Krems, Austria in May 2014.
Self-adaptation Approaches for Energy EfficiencyPatricia Lago
The increasing energy demands of software systems have set an
essential software quality requirement: energy efficiency. At the
same time, the many contextual changes faced by software systems
during execution can hamper their functionality and overall
quality. To address both problems, self-adaptation approaches can
empower software systems, at both design-time and runtime, to
adapt to dynamic conditions. In this way, software systems can
be more resilient to failure, hence more trustful to satisfy the demands
of modern digital society. In this paper, we perform a systematic
literature review to study the state-of-the-art on existing
self-adaptation approaches for energy efficiency. We analyze the
identified approaches from three different perspectives, namely
publication trends, application domains, and types of software systems.
Our findings can help solution providers to make guided
decisions to enable self-adaptability in designing and engineering
software systems.
Lessons Learned from the Siemens Smart Grid Innovation ContestMichael Heiss
The document provides details about the Smart Grid Innovation Contest conducted by Siemens, including lessons learned. The contest occurred in two phases: Phase I was a public idea contest that attracted 35,000 unique visitors and 1,500 registered users. Phase II was a call for research proposals directed at universities, which received 172 abstract submissions and selected 25 for full proposals. Key lessons included crowd ideation being more challenging for complex technologies, the importance of community involvement and IP considerations, and motivating participant submissions through visibility and job opportunities at Siemens.
This document describes a "Research meets Business" matchmaking event organized by a research institution to connect local enterprises with university researchers. The event features:
1) Short presentations by researchers on their projects related to a focused theme (here, instrumentation and health).
2) Individual meetings between enterprises and researchers to discuss potential partnerships.
3) The goal is to trigger technology transfer and collaboration opportunities between the research institution and local businesses.
Designing Software with a Sustainability Intent - The Software Sustainability...Patricia Lago
This talk explains the SoSA method and how it can scope the complexity of the problem of designing for software solutions to realize sustainability goals.
El documento describe las seis fases del método de ciclo de vida para el desarrollo de sistemas: investigación preliminar, determinación de los requerimientos del sistema, diseño del sistema, desarrollo del software, prueba de sistemas e implantación y evaluación. Cada fase involucra actividades específicas para desarrollar e implementar un sistema de información de manera efectiva.
Estrategias para la cosecha espiritualEberto Mejia
Este documento presenta un curso sobre estrategias para la cosecha espiritual dividido en cuatro partes: Visualización, Conceptualización, Objetivación y Expectación. La primera parte, Visualización, se enfoca en identificar la visión espiritual y explica que sin visión las personas perecen espiritualmente. El capítulo uno describe el proceso de nacimiento de una visión espiritual a través de ejemplos bíblicos.
El documento describe las características de las vértebras torácicas. Estas vértebras son más grandes y resistentes que las cervicales, y se articulan con las costillas a través de carillas y semicarillas. También tienen apófisis espinosas más cortas, anchas y dirigidas ligeramente hacia atrás, en comparación con otras vértebras.
Lenguajesdeprogramacion c nivel1-unidad1_1Facebook
Un programa en C++ está compuesto de funciones, la principal es main. Incluye directivas, declaraciones globales, funciones definidas por el usuario y comentarios. Main contiene las instrucciones principales y las funciones realizan tareas específicas. Las variables se declaran con su tipo y las funciones con su tipo de retorno, parámetros y bloque de instrucciones.
El documento resume conceptos clave sobre comunicación. En menos de 3 oraciones:
La comunicación se define como el proceso mediante el cual se transmite información de un emisor a un receptor. Incluye elementos como el emisor, mensaje y receptor. Existen dos tipos de comunicación - directa que es inmediata, e indirecta que usa herramientas porque emisor y receptor están separados. La comunicación organizacional incluye procesos internos y externos para transmitir mensajes dentro de una organización.
Impact of Migration on "Children left behind" in Tajikistanpmkhojaeva
1) The document reports on a study conducted by UNICEF Tajikistan to examine the impact of labour migration on "children left behind" in Tajikistan. It uses both qualitative and quantitative methods to assess the impact on children's health, education, economic activities, and psycho-social well-being.
2) Key findings include that migration has mixed impacts - access to remittances improves perceived health and nutrition, but separation from parents negatively impacts children's psycho-social well-being, especially for "abandoned households" where children are left without parental care.
3) The report provides policy recommendations to help mitigate negative impacts, such as improving social services, child protection policies, and developing a
Este documento describe un experimento en el que se administró cloruro de cadmio a un cobayo para observar los efectos de la intoxicación por cadmio. El cobayo murió en 6 minutos después de la administración intraperitoneal de 10 ml de cloruro de cadmio, mostrando síntomas como hipoxia, pérdida de equilibrio y convulsiones. Mediante pruebas de reconocimiento como la adición de hidróxido de sodio y amonio se confirmó la presencia de cadmio en las vísceras del animal. El documento
Civil engineering has been a promising field, but economic downturns have affected its outlook. This document discusses solutions that have been implemented to support the field, such as continuing education requirements and raising academic standards. The future of civil engineering looks positive with an expected 11% employment growth in the next 5-7 years and a median salary of $78,000. However, issues around lack of diversity and information flow challenges remain. Overall the career remains important for infrastructure development and quality of life improvements.
Dan Winter introduces himself in his personal portfolio wiki for EDU5315 Technology Applications for the Classroom. He provides a picture and biography, noting that he works as an instructional technology coach and previously taught science. Winter is taking this class as part of an instructional technology program, and hopes to learn new techniques for implementing technology into curriculum to stay current on educational technology trends and strategies. He created a wiki page to post all course assignments.
Este documento presenta la tesis titulada "Diseño de Armaduras para Techo" realizada por Leonilo Santiago Hernández para obtener el título de Ingeniero en Irrigación de la Universidad Autónoma Chapingo. La tesis describe diferentes materiales de construcción como concreto, mampostería, tierra, madera y acero, así como sus propiedades. También analiza conceptos estructurales como cargas, elementos estructurales y tipos de techos. El objetivo principal es diseñar armaduras para techos utilizando diferentes materiales de construcción.
Isère : Listes candidates dans les communes de + 1000 habitantsEntre Nous
Municipales:
Concernant les communes de + de 1000 habitants: 508 listes ont été enregistrées (267 pour l’arrondissement de Grenoble, 135 pour l’arrondissement de La Tour du Pin et 106 pour l’arrondissement de Vienne) pour un total de 11.840 candidats répartis sur 255 communes.
Este documento presenta información sobre conceptos, definiciones y clasificaciones de tributos en el Perú. Explica que los tributos se clasifican en impuestos, tasas y contribuciones. Define cada categoría e identifica sus características distintivas. También describe brevemente la evolución histórica de los tributos y el sistema tributario peruano actual.
El documento explica los conceptos de ángulo en posición normal, sus lados inicial y final, y define las razones trigonométricas (seno, coseno, tangente, cotangente, secante y cosecante) de un ángulo. Además, indica que el signo de las razones trigonométricas depende del cuadrante en el que se ubique el punto terminal del ángulo, proporcionando una tabla resumen.
1) O documento discute padrões de herança genética em populações humanas, incluindo conceitos como alelos, loci, genótipos e fenótipos.
2) Aborda classificações de distúrbios genéticos como monogênicos, cromossômicos e multifatoriais.
3) Fornece exemplos clínicos de distúrbios genéticos monogênicos como distrofia muscular de Duchenne, acondroplasia e fibrose cística.
This document discusses business valuation and provides an overview of its importance for determining tax liability, estate planning, and succession planning. It defines business valuation as assigning a dollar value to all or part of a business. A valuation is important for correctly calculating taxes owed on gifts, inheritance, or sale of a business. The document also outlines different valuation methods, including asset, income, and market approaches, and notes that valuations help ensure sales are not deemed disguised gifts by the IRS.
This guide helps students identify their interests, explore related career pathways and education options, and prepare for careers in growing industries. It encourages students to discover careers that appeal to them, focus on the future by exploring options through extracurricular activities and career technical education courses, and get a head start through hands-on learning. The guide discusses how career planning and technical training can help students pursue certificate or degree programs and secure living-wage jobs.
This document discusses how technology policy has evolved from a linear to a cyclical model. The cyclical policy cycle involves three main phases: analysis, consensus, and implementation. In the analysis phase, needs are assessed and research conducted. The consensus phase involves defining the technology and reaching agreements on standards. In the implementation phase, the technology becomes commercialized. To educate policymakers, it is important to understand this cyclical process and where emerging technologies like intelligent transportation systems currently are in the cycle.
The document discusses the Plan C network in Flanders, which was established in 2006 to promote sustainable materials management. It aimed to transition the waste management system using an approach inspired by transition management. The network helped facilitate communication and studies but faced challenges maintaining momentum. Lessons indicate a need for tailored tools, business involvement, adaptive financing, political embedding, and partnering internationally to strengthen the building blocks of the transition process.
A Strategy Framework For the Risk Assessment And Mitigation For Large E-Gover...ijmvsc
Globally, e-Government has become an effective tool for civic transformation. In the recent years eGovernment development gained significant momentum despite the financial crisis that crippled the world economy. For most of the governments, the crisis was a wakeup call to become more transparent
and efficient. In addition, there is a growing demand for governments to transform from traditional agency/department centric approach to “Citizen-Centric” approach. This transformation is expected to enhance the quality of life of citizens in terms of greater convenience in availing government services. Eventually this would result in higher levels of citizen satisfaction and improved trust in government.
A Strategy Framework For the Risk Assessment And Mitigation For Large E-Gover...ijmvsc
Globally, e-Government has become an effective tool for civic transformation. In the recent years eGovernment development gained significant momentum despite the financial crisis that crippled the world economy. For most of the governments, the crisis was a wakeup call to become more transparent
and efficient. In addition, there is a growing demand for governments to transform from traditional agency/department centric approach to “Citizen-Centric” approach. This transformation is expected to enhance the quality of life of citizens in terms of greater convenience in availing government services. Eventually this would result in higher levels of citizen satisfaction and improved trust in government
A Strategy Framework For the Risk Assessment And Mitigation For Large E-Gover...ijmvsc
Globally, e-Government has become an effective tool for civic transformation. In the recent years eGovernment development gained significant momentum despite the financial crisis that crippled the world economy. For most of the governments, the crisis was a wakeup call to become more transparent and efficient. In addition, there is a growing demand for governments to transform from traditional agency/department centric approach to “Citizen-Centric” approach. This transformation is expected to enhance the quality of life of citizens in terms of greater convenience in availing government services. Eventually this would result in higher levels of citizen satisfaction and improved trust in government. However, projects of such scale and complexity, faces numerous roadblocks which eventually hamper its potential to deliver the intended benefits to the citizens. The success of these programmes calls for strategic direction, policy making and greater coordination among multiple agencies, following a uniform approach in achieving the vision. This necessitates a strategic framework comprehensive enough to visualize and enable the leaders in addressing the potential roadblocks or resistance. This report presents the outcome of a research to define a strategic framework that models the opposing and propelling forces dormant during a project time. This would help the strategic decision makers to visualize each project as a whole and take quick decisions in the areas that need additional thrust, to ensure that the initiatives achieve the envisaged goals.
Rethinking Financial Sustainability in the Context of Telecentre as a Social ...Shipra Sharma
This document discusses the evolving concept of financial sustainability in the context of telecentres. It begins by providing background on how telecentres originated in developed countries as public access points and were later implemented in developing countries through donor-funded pilot projects. Initially, financial sustainability meant being able to cover operating costs after donor funding ended. More recently, some telecentres have adopted a social enterprise model where local entrepreneurs operate telecentres as businesses to generate profit. This has expanded the definition of financial sustainability to include profit-making. The document argues that for long-term viability, telecentres need to be viewed as enterprises that can support the entrepreneur financially through revenue generation and profit.
Research questions revolving around oi in ict industry. psaradis
This document discusses coupled open innovation processes, where companies cooperate and share knowledge to jointly develop innovations. It provides examples of how coupled processes are implemented in the ICT sector. Specifically, it discusses Ericsson's use of coupled processes through strategic alliances and platforms like Ericsson Labs that allow it to combine internal and external ideas. Ericsson participates in standardization initiatives like 3GPP that involve over 300 companies cooperating to develop telecom industry standards through a coupled innovation process. The document analyzes the benefits of coupled processes for value creation and competitive advantage, as well as challenges around intellectual property protection and balancing openness between companies and customers.
Globally, e-Government has become an effective tool for civic transformation. In the recent years, e-Government development gained significant momentum despite the financial crisis that crippled the world economy. For most of the governments, the crisis was a wakeup call to become more transparent and efficient. In addition, there is a growing demand for governments to transform from traditional agency/department centric approach to “Citizen-Centric” approach. This transformation is expected to enhance the quality of life of citizens in terms of greater convenience in availing government services. Eventually this would result in higher levels of citizen satisfaction and improved trust in government.
However, projects of such scale and complexity, faces numerous roadblocks which eventually hamper its potential to deliver the intended benefits to the citizens. The success of these programmes calls for strategic direction, policy making and greater coordination among multiple agencies, following a uniform approach in achieving the vision. This necessitates a strategic framework comprehensive enough to visualize and enable the leaders in addressing the potential roadblocks or resistance. This report presents the outcome of a research to define a strategic framework that models the opposing and propelling forces dormant during a project time. This would help the strategic decision makers to visualize each project as a whole and take quick decisions in the areas that need additional thrust, to ensure that the initiatives achieve the envisaged goals.
This document discusses creating a government-wide enterprise architecture to better integrate business and technology across departments. Currently, most departments operate independently with duplicate processes and systems. The goals of an enterprise architecture are to streamline processes, increase consistency, reduce costs through reuse, and improve services for citizens. It will be a significant challenge to implement due to the large, complex nature of government and need for inter-departmental collaboration.
Organisations often use enterprise architecture (EA) as a bridging method to align their business and Information Technology (IT) strategies. As a result, different available industrial enterprise architecture frameworks are adopted and used by these organisations to facilitate the EA implementation process. However, EA effort is presumed to be very costly and often takes a long time to implement before one can realize its benefits. It is also imperative to indicate that if the deployment of these EA frameworks is not well interpreted, challenges that can lead to the whole architecture implementation process being fruitless can be encountered. This study was conducted with the primary aim to understand the effects of government wide enterprise architecture framework (GWEA) implementation in the South African government departments through the use of diffusion of innovation (DOI) theory.
The document discusses the relationship between technology and project management. It states that technology and project management are closely related, as project management relies on technology. It explores how both fields have evolved over time, with technology advancing rapidly since the 1980s and project management developing methods like PERT and CPM in the 1950s. The conclusion is that technology plays a vital role in project management, and project management cannot be done effectively without technology.
This document discusses balancing the responsibilities of public and private entities in developing intelligent transportation system (ITS) infrastructure. It outlines key considerations for both public sector decision makers seeking to benefit citizens and private businesses aiming to profit. Specifically, the document recommends: (1) engaging public and private stakeholders throughout the process to understand costs, risks, and benefits, (2) combining immediate work with potential for future projects to incentivize private investment, and (3) establishing a symbiotic relationship that maximizes benefits to both public welfare and long-term business opportunities.
The Global Lighthouse Network has grown significantly and now includes 132 sites recognized for leadership in adopting Fourth Industrial Revolution technologies at scale. Lighthouses span various industries and geographies. They have demonstrated impact across key performance indicators like productivity, quality, sustainability, and agility. A dynamic network of lighthouses is helping to advance the next chapter of using advanced technologies to transform production networks and beyond.
The ability to execute virtual projects – projects where the team members seldom or never meet physically – is becoming an increasingly important capability for international organizations. This paper identifies five factors that determine the success or failure of virtual projects, and discusses how to build the capability to execute virtual projects effectively, including those currently thought too small to be viable.
AN APPROACH FOR A BUSINESS-DRIVEN CLOUDCOMPLIANCE ANALYSIS COVERING PUBLIC SE...ijmpict
The need for process improvement is an important target that does affect as well the government processes. Specifically in the public sector there are specific challenges to face .New technology approaches within government processes such as cloud services are necessary to address these challenges. Following the current discussion of „cloudification“of business processes all processes are considered similar in regards to their usability within the cloud. The truth is, that neither all processes have the same usability for cloud services not do they have the same importance for a specific company.
AN APPROACH FOR A BUSINESS-DRIVEN CLOUDCOMPLIANCE ANALYSIS COVERING PUBLIC SE...ijmpict
The need for process improvement is an important target that does affect as well the government processes.
Specifically in the public sector there are specific challenges to face .New technology approaches within
government processes such as cloud services are necessary to address these challenges. Following the
current discussion of „cloudification“of business processes all processes are considered similar in regards
to their usability within the cloud. The truth is, that neither all processes have the same usability for cloud
services not do they have the same importance for a specific company.
The most comprehensive process within a company is the corporate value chain. In this article one key
proposition is to use the corporate value chain as the fundamental structuring backbone for all business
process analysis and improvement activities. It is a pre-requisite to identify the core elements of the value
chain that are essential for the individual company’s business and the root cause for any company success.
In this paper we propose to use the company-specific value-creation for the “cloud-affinity” and the
“cloud-usability” of a business process in public sector considering the specific challenges of addressing
processes in cloud services. Therefor it is necessary to formalize the way the processes with its
interdependencies are documented in context of their company-specific value chain (as part of the various
deployment- and governance alternatives (e.g. security, compliance, quality, adaptability)). Moreover, it is
essential in the public sector to describe in detail the environmental / external restrictions of processes..
With the use of this proposed methodology it becomes relatively easy to identify cloud-suitable processes
within the public sector and thus optimize the public companies value generation tightly focused with the
use of this new technology.
This document discusses engaging youth to help choose corporate responsibility initiatives. It describes the Youth Encounter on Sustainability (YES) forum, which develops recommendations for CR initiatives related to climate change. The YES forum members are young academics and professionals interested in sustainability. The document presents a table outlining 9 CR initiative ideas in education/awareness, stakeholder engagement, and best practices categories. It describes the initiatives and provides reasoning and potential evaluation metrics. The initiatives are aimed at engaging future stakeholders, addressing climate change, and improving business factors like costs, reputation and recruiting.
A Research Agenda For Highly Effective Human-Computer InteractionMonica Waters
This document outlines a proposed research agenda to improve human-computer interaction (HCI). It identifies three key areas of focus: useful interaction, usable interaction, and universal interaction. For each area, it discusses challenges and proposes research to address them. The overarching goal is to make technology more useful, usable, and accessible to all users through improved design, evaluation methods, predictive models, and support for diverse abilities and contexts of use. The proposed agenda calls for substantial increases in HCI research funding across scientific, design, and engineering disciplines.
Literature review on the impact of public access to information and communica...Dr Lendy Spires
This document summarizes a literature review of research on the impacts of public access to information and communication technologies. The review found limited conclusive evidence on the downstream impacts of public access to ICTs. Some studies found impacts in areas like skill development and job creation, while others found limited impacts. More research is needed that quantifies impacts across different contexts using consistent methodologies.
Similar to Pilot Takes Off Easy Seva Sri Lanka Nz Hosman (20)
Discovering Egypt A Step-by-Step Guide to Planning Your Trip.pptImperial Egypt
Travelling to Egypt is like stepping into a time capsule where the past and present coexist, offering a unique blend of history, culture, and stunning landscapes.
See more: https://imperialegypt.com/tour-packages/
What Challenges Await Beginners in SnowshoeingSnowshoe Tahoe
Discover the exhilarating world of snowshoeing through our presentation, highlighting the challenges faced by beginners. From physical exertion to technical finesse and braving harsh winter conditions, each step in the snow brings new obstacles and unforgettable adventures. Embrace the challenge and conquer the winter wonderland with confidence!
Beyond the mountains, a tour in Nepal reveals a vibrant tapestry of cultural heritage. The Kathmandu Valley, a UNESCO World Heritage Site, boasts an array of ancient temples, stupas, and palaces. Durbar Squares in Kathmandu, Bhaktapur, and Patan are treasure troves of medieval art and architecture.
bangalore metro routes, stations, timingsnarinav14
Bangalore Metro, also known as Namma Metro, is a rapid transit system serving the city of Bangalore, Karnataka, India. It is the second longest operational metro network in India after the Delhi Metro.
How do I plan a Kilimanjaro Climb?
Planning to climb Mount Kilimanjaro is an exciting yet detailed process. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you prepare for this incredible adventure.
Our excursions in tahiti offer stunning lagoon tours, vibrant marine life encounters, and cultural experiences. We ensure unforgettable adventures amidst breathtaking landscapes and serene waters. For more information, mail us at tracey@uniquetahiti.com.
What Outdoor Adventures Await Young Adults in Montreal's Surrounding NatureSpade & Palacio Tours
Experience Montreal's vibrant culture and thrilling outdoor adventures. From hiking scenic trails at Mont-Saint-Bruno to kayaking the Saint Lawrence River, there's something for every adventurous young adult. Explore street art, camp under the stars, and immerse yourself in nature's beauty just beyond the city's bustling streets.
Prepare for cold weather rafting with proper gear: layering for warmth, insulated headgear, gloves, waterproof footwear, and essential accessories like sunglasses and sunscreen. Prioritize safety with a life jacket and maintain gear for optimal performance. Stay warm, dry, and ready for adventure on the rapids!
Nature of the task 1. write a paragraph about your trip to dubai and what ar...solutionaia
1. write a paragraph about your trip to dubai and what are the facts responsible for the heavy rainfall in dubai that caused havec ?
2. mention any five major tourist attaction of dubai
Mathematics: a student a visit her family her father converted Rs. 1,15,000 inr currency for dubai airport theexpedite in the trip is given below
1. Curreny name of India and dubai
2. Conversions amount
3. Total Converted amount
4. cost of food
5. cost of sightseeing
6. cost of shoping
7. cost of saving
Un viaje a Buenos Aires y sus alrededoresJudy Hochberg
A travelogue of my recent trip to Argentina, most to Buenos Aires, but including excursion to Iguazú waterfalls, Tigre, and Colonia del Sacramento in Uruguay
You can easily change/correct a name on your flight ticket under the American Airlines name change policy. The airline provides multiple online and offline modes to place a name change request. To learn more about how to change a name on American Airlines ticket, you can directly approach the airline’s customer support. Moreover, you can connect with a flight expert at +1-866-738-0741 for quick assistance.
Golden Gate Bridge: Magnificent Architecture in San Francisco | CIO Women Mag...CIOWomenMagazine
The famous suspension bridge connects the city of San Francisco to Marin County in California. Golden Gate Bridge carries both U.S. Route 101 and California State Route 1 across the strait and is about one mile wide. In this article, we will explore the history and significance that have shaped the iconic monument it is known as today.
Explore Architectural Wonders and Vibrant Culture With Naples ToursNaples Tours
Discover the historical gems and vivid culture of Naples with our guided tours. From the vivid narrow streets of Spaccanapoli to the ancient ruins of Pompeii, the city offers a mixed bag of adventurous experiences. Book your tickets today https://www.naples.tours/ and experience the best of Naples!
How To Change Your Name On American Airlines Aadvantage.pptxedqour001namechange
American Airlines permits passengers to change/correct names on their AAdvantage account. Also, you can request a name change both online via a web portal and offline over the phone. For further information on how to change your name on American Airlines Advantage, get in touch with the airline’s customer service. Also, you can reach out to a consolidation desk at +1-866-738-0741 for quick assistance.
The Ultimate Travel Guide to Hawaii Island Hopping in 2024adventuressabifn
island hopping in Hawaii. This magical place offers a number of experiences, as each island has its own charm. Do you love adventure? Then, hike through volcanoes or kayak along an amazing coastline. If you want relaxation, then Hawaii is perfect because it has the most amazing beaches. In this blog, I will help you make an itinerary for your Hawaii Island Hopping. Every island offers something special. The Big Island offers some of the most perfect volcanoes as well as stargazing. Maui will pamper you with beaches and luxury. Kauai has some of the most lush rainforests with dramatic cliffs, and Oahu can offer a taste of city life and historical significance.
The Ultimate Travel Guide to Hawaii Island Hopping in 2024
Pilot Takes Off Easy Seva Sri Lanka Nz Hosman
1. 19th Australasian Conference on Information Systems A Pilot Takes Off: Sustainability and Scalability
3-5 Dec 2008, Christchurch Hosman
A Pilot Takes Off: Examining Sustainability and Scalability in the Context
of a Sri Lankan Public-Private Partnership Telecenter Project
Laura Hosman
Department of Environmental Science, Policy & Management
University of California
Berkeley, CA 94720
United States
Email: hosman@berkeley.edu
Abstract
Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) are being looked to as a promising method for bringing the benefits of
information and communications technology (ICT) to the developing world, particularly in the case of shared
access (telecenter) models, but questions remain as to how best to pursue sustainability and scalability with such
initiatives. This paper provides a “snapshot” of an innovative, franchise-model partnership, captured at a unique
point in time: the transition period from completion of pilot stage to project scaling stage. The paper thus
identifies both challenges and success factors arising at this pivotal point, often not addressed in the literature on
such projects. Going beyond what makes a successful pilot to the question of what is important for scaling, this
case provides insight on the critical topics of sustainability and scalability. The project also promotes the
development of small and medium sized enterprises, which has been identified as crucial for sustainable
development in emerging economies.
Keywords
Telecenters, Public-Private Partnerships, Development, Sustainability, Scaling
INTRODUCTION
The past decade has witnessed a veritable explosion in shared-access model information communication
technology (ICT) deployments in the developing world, with the goal of bringing the benefits of ICT to the
underserved. Whether referred to as information kiosks, telecenters, or Internet cafes, what these shared-access
models have in common is that they shift from the individual level to the business, community, or government the
various burdens and costs associated with bringing technology to where it did not exist before and making it
function (Salvador et al. 2005). These burdens, which can include outlays for equipment, infrastructure, and
connectivity, as well as investments of time and effort to gain the technological expertise to make everything
work (and then work together), can be prohibitively high for an individual. Yet when these costs are spread to a
larger group, or when technology experts can be brought in, the shared access model represents a more efficient
way to disseminate ICT. Governments and agencies concerned with development recognized the benefits of this
model, and began to fund such deployments to the point where the process has been termed the “telecenter
movement” (Roman and Colle 2002).
Thus, the first wave of the telecenter movement was donor-driven: billions of dollars were allocated by
development organizations, governments, and NGOs to set up and fund these projects. Yet, after a few years, as
donor funds began to dry up and the telecenters that had been expected to become self-sustaining instead
generally failed with no income stream, the realization set in that this model in fact had not been designed to be
profitable or financially sustainable in the long term—or, if this had been the intention, this model was not
working. Thus, an alternate business plan for the shared-access model was sought; one that could promote long-
term sustainability for these projects.
One business model widely recognized to hold promise in this area is the public-private partnership (PPP), as
ideally it takes advantage of the financial capital, profit-seeking motive, and technological expertise of the private
partner, and combines this with the public partner’s drive to improve citizens’ quality of life. The main reason for
forming such partnerships is to achieve goals that could not be realized by a single party acting alone. Today,
multi-actor public-private partnerships are held in extremely high esteem by those seeking ICT-oriented solutions
to development challenges. These partnerships enjoy wide-ranging support and are promoted by governments,
international organizations, non-governmental organizations (NGOs), and private firms alike. In fact, the United
Nations Millennium Declaration specifically recommends the creation of public private partnerships to “ensure
2. 19th Australasian Conference on Information Systems A Pilot Takes Off: Sustainability and Scalability
3-5 Dec 2008, Christchurch Hosman
that the benefits of new technologies, especially information and communications technologies… are available to
all,” (Weigel and Waldburger 2004:XV).
Even so, PPPs have not proven to be a panacea for technology-related development projects: there have been a
large number of unsuccessful initiatives (Angerer and Hammerschmid 2005). The fact that many failed cases go
unreported does not help the learning process, either. Thus, the search for sustainable models continues, with the
dual recognition that the impact of any technology-related development project depends on the long-term
viability of such a project, and that the stakes are high in the developing world, given the scarcity of funds
available to devote to development projects of any kind.
The majority of telecenter projects and most public-private partnerships start out as pilot programs. This makes
sense from an investor’s point of view. The proof-of-concept provided by a promising or successful pilot project
is helpful for convincing stakeholders to invest in larger projects. However, due to a number of factors, including
the lack of a proven business model for success, the high failure rate of such projects, and the small number of
projects that have in fact scaled, little has been written about the sustainability or scalability of such projects
(Roman and Colle 2005; Walsham and Sahay 2005). This paper specifically addresses both issues in the context
of a case that is making the transition from successful pilot to scaled project.
This paper presents firsthand evidence from EasySeva in Sri Lanka, an innovative, franchise-model telecenter
project involving multiple local and international partners. The project is distinctive in that it employs a unique
venture capital-type business model, has demonstrated sufficient promise and/or success at the pilot stage to
obtain additional funding that has allowed the project to begin scaling, and promotes SME development in the
wider Sri Lankan economy. Additionally, the fieldwork informing the paper was carried out at a unique point in
time: the transition period from the completion of the pilot stage to the project scaling stage. Since few cases
have been reported on at this crucial juncture, the examination of such a case is valuable, since numerous new
issues present themselves as projects enter the scaling stage.
This paper thus provides an in-depth report of the features and best practices at the completion of the pilot stage
of the project, based on fieldwork observation, surveys, and interviews. The paper also addresses numerous
lessons learned that have already been incorporated into the design and implementation of this project that have
contributed to its initial success, and will bring up new challenges to be addressed in the next stage of the project.
The paper proceeds with a discussion of the dual concepts of sustainability and scalability within the context of
public-private partnerships and ICT-and-development. This is followed by a discussion of the importance of
small and medium sized enterprises in the context of promoting nationwide economic development. After this, a
brief methodology section appears, followed by the case study of EasySeva in Sri Lanka. The case description is
followed by a discussion of best practices and new challenges that may be applicable and informative for other
ICT-and-development projects, particularly as they face the scaling process.
SUSTAINABILITY AND SCALABILITY
Because there are numerous potential benefits to be realized when public and private actors join forces, these
types of partnerships are coming to be seen as one of the most efficient methods for bringing technology to
underserved areas. Yet, in order to realize the full, long-term potential benefits that the technology can bring, so
that people realize a new technology’s usefulness and incorporate it into their lives, a focus on planning for
sustainability has emerged as an important factor for project success. Another related emphasis is on scalability.
As mentioned above, most ICT-related development projects start as pilots, and while they may serve a valuable
function in the specific locales into which they are introduced, in order to ensure that the maximum number of
people will benefit and to take advantage of economies of scale, projects that can be expanded and scaled, on a
sustainable basis, are highly valued.
Little is known about the operation of the public-private model, as systematic evaluation is difficult. This may be
due to the uncoordinated dynamic of public-private partnerships: there is no central organizing body, projects
may be non-comparable on a global scale, and there are no standard metrics for assessment—perhaps due to
resistance to evaluation processes in general (Rosenau 1999). Further, benchmarking is seldom done prior to the
commencement of a project, and long-term evaluation is most often not a part of the overall budget. The
academic community reports mixed results for such undertakings. One major concern regarding PPPs in the
developing world is that they will not address the larger issues of socio-economic development and poverty
eradication if they are not sustainable or relevant in the daily lives of their intended beneficiaries. Kanungo
(2004) reports that private sector participation in such projects has not demonstrated better results than previous
public sector-only initiatives. Yet, this paper will assert that when public-private initiatives are well thought out,
technologically appropriate, and designed with long term sustainability and the empowerment of the localities in
mind, they have the potential to enable real socio-economic benefit.
3. 19th Australasian Conference on Information Systems A Pilot Takes Off: Sustainability and Scalability
3-5 Dec 2008, Christchurch Hosman
Of course, for a given ICT project to be successful, locally appropriate technology must be deployed. “Locally
appropriate” in this case refers both to the stated wants and needs of the technology recipients as well as to what
is possible given the physical, geographical, and/or infrastructural reality on the ground. Since the Sri Lankan
literacy rate in the local languages is 91 percent, a telecenter deployment involving Internet use is a locally
appropriate technology application. The high literacy rate within the state also bodes well for Internet uptake and
adoption in general, as many of the more advanced technology applications, such as email and information
gathering, require the ability to read and write. In this respect, Sri Lankans are better poised to realize a wide
range of ICT-related benefits than many others in developing countries, and the expectations of this project
regarding their abilities for and interests in using the Internet and taking computer training courses appear to be
in line with goals of the project detailed in this paper. In addition, Sri Lanka’s physical infrastructure is
appropriate for such a project, with, for instance: a liberalized, competitive telecom sector providing service
across the nation; dependable and affordable electricity; and paved roads to most areas in the country—all of
these features facilitate deployment of a telecenter project across the state.
The case presented here possesses many characteristics that will be addressed in the paper and gives evidence of
both of the success factors identified above: sustainability and scalability. It is already employing a number of
best practices that have been identified in the literature. To give a few examples, it employs a franchising model,
which has been recognized as a proven and effective telecenter strategy (Proenza 2001). The project is focused
on providing services of multiple kinds, as a strategy to add value to its offerings (Jensen 2005), which both
differentiates its services from competitors and promotes revenue generation. It is both driven by and promoting
domestic entrepreneurship (Kusakabe 2005), while also building local capacity: the EasySeva staff is training the
local telecenter owners to be able to handle smaller technical issues on their own. Finally, it is promoting new
methods for doing business locally—most notably in this case, networking.
This project boasts multiple potential benefits for the private sector in Sri Lanka, among them the promotion of
SMEs in the business sector and of new ways of doing business, as well as bringing wider availability of the
Internet to customers and providing new on-line services for citizens in general. The project boasts a unique
partnership that resembles a venture capital model, wherein the public partner provides start-up funds to get the
project off the ground and to enable completion of the pilot stage or proof of concept (although because the
partner is a public entity, the investment funds are not repaid). At that point, the public monies stop, and the
private partners are expected to take over as the project scales. Because the project becomes (mainly) a private-
sector concern, its success depends upon it being financially sustainable in the long-term, and this was a part of
the project’s design from the outset. Though it started as a pilot project, the business model was designed to be
scaled and expanded on a nation-wide and even international basis, even while encouraging local
entrepreneurship. The project has already been recognized as successful by its private corporate partners (Dialog
Telekom and Qualcomm) in terms of reinvestment for expansion, and as such, is currently being scaled across the
country.
ICT AND THE SMALL AND MEDIUM SIZED ENTERPRISE (SME) SECTOR
The concept of microfinance—making small loans mainly to poor entrepreneurs in developing countries—has
received a great deal of public attention and support lately. Yet, microfinance tends to support individual, or
survival entrepreneurs, and such individualized investments do not in fact contribute to the building of a
diversified economy, in terms of the range and size of participants. One of the economic challenges facing many
developing country economies is a “missing middle” (Kaufmann 2005): a term that describes an economy
consisting of both micro- and macro-sized participants (often dominated by foreign-based multinationals), but
lacking a robust sector of small and medium sized enterprises (SMEs).
The SME sector is important, because it has the potential to contribute to a country’s economy in the form of job
creation, public and private revenue generation, and overall economic competitiveness in a country. In developed
countries, SMEs provide more than 60 percent of private sector employment and are the principal creator of new
jobs (de Ferranti and Ody 2007; Suroweicki 2008), so their absence in developing country economies can signal
underemployment, as well as a general business environment where revenue generation, competition, and
innovation and are all underdeveloped. The SME sector has the potential to contribute to national economic
development strategies by facilitating flows of information, capital, ideas, people, and products (Alampay, 2007).
SMEs can also serve as seedbeds of innovation (de Ferranti and Ody 2007). The use of information and
communication technologies by SMEs has the potential to increase efficiency, reduce costs, and broaden market
reach (Alampay 2007). However, ICTs are less likely to be adopted by SMEs when the overall business climate
is not transparent and dependable, or where there is no competition. In the EasySeva case, ICT is the business
being practiced, so the adoption of it or switching to it from other forms of doing business is not the main issue.
However, the EasySeva centers will provide ICT capabilities—comprising the physical hardware, as well as
training and skills development—to their local communities, so it remains to be seen whether their service
offerings will help to promote ICT uptake and adoption on a wider scale, including by local small businesses.
4. 19th Australasian Conference on Information Systems A Pilot Takes Off: Sustainability and Scalability
3-5 Dec 2008, Christchurch Hosman
One of the main obstacles identified in the literature and by SME entrepreneurs in interviews, is the lack of
access to finance, or capital (de Ferranti and Ody 2007; Kauffmann 2005; Newberry 2006). In the case presented
here, the local finance partner has proven to be the most problematic stakeholder in the project. At a certain
point, it became clear that this partner was more interested in processing loans of much larger amounts than the
individual telecenter entrepreneurs required, and simply placed the processing of these smaller loans on hold.
Thus, at the time of writing, all of the current EasySeva partners stood ready to expand the project, with
corporate funding in place and employees and entrepreneurs ready to move forward, but the momentum was
temporarily stalled because of the local finance partner. This reality is in line with the challenges identified in the
literature, and also highlights the importance of starting at the pilot level, and being flexible in terms of which
partners will continue as the project progresses—although in this case there may not be an alternative. Though it
may seem cart-before-the-horse, it will likely take the presence of a healthy small-and-medium-enterprise sector
within a national economy to encourage the development of local finance institutions aimed at serving SMEs’
needs. Because there are currently few SME-targeted development interventions, the lack of finance options will
remain a challenge for them. However, as recognition of the “missing middle” problem grows, so too may
attempts to ameliorate it. Surowiecki (2008) reports that some progress is being made: Google.org, the Soros
Economic Development Fund, and the Omidyar Network are setting up a firm in India that will invest only in
small-to-medium businesses—a sort of high-profile pilot partnership project formed precisely to target the
“missing middle.”
METHODOLOGY
This paper employs a qualitative, case study methodology, which is particularly relevant for researchers
examining strategies in emerging economies. In addition, the case study is the most appropriate method for
studying the “many variables-small N” type of subject presented herein (Lijphart 1971). The case study is best
employed when there are a limited number of cases for analysis, as it allows the researcher to examine the study
intensively. An additional strength of the case study methodology is the contribution it can make to theory
building, and to best practices identification. We adopt Gerring’s definition of a case study as “an intensive study
of a single unit for the purpose of understanding a larger class of similar units” (2004:342).
There is not (yet) a theoretical framework that focuses specifically on public-private or international partnerships
(Stewart and Gray 2006). Since it is beyond the scope of this paper to propose such a framework, our focus will
remain on the case at hand, which will be utilized to identify best practices, and to enumerate issues not
previously identified in the literature, but which will become increasingly relevant as similar projects begin to
scale in the future.
The research findings presented herein are based on a combination of field methods such as interviews, surveys,
and participant observation and interaction. The fieldwork took place between January-February, 2008. The
findings consist of interviews with the owners of the EasySeva centers and of a 38-question survey that was given
to customers at the centers and to customers at the Dialog Telecom stores which are adjacent to the centers.
Multiple interviews also took place with the EasySeva project director, managers, and staff over the entire
duration of the fieldwork.
At the time of research, there were 18 EasySeva centers operational. Interviews were conducted with nine of the
owners of these centers, while a visit was made to their store. There were 96 completed surveys in total, with as
representative a sample as possible coming from each of the different centers visited. The customer surveys were
available in both Sinhalese and English. The interviews were conducted in English. EasySeva staff provided
assistance with both interpretation (when needed) and translation.
CASE STUDY: EASYSEVA
EasySeva (or Easy Service in the local languages) is the name given to a for-profit franchise service center
project to bring affordable broadband wireless telecommunications and Internet technology to underserved areas
of Sri Lanka. It is a public-private partnership with multiple local and international partners from numerous
sectors of relevant industries. The aim of the EasySeva project is to empower communities across Sri Lanka to
avail themselves of ICT in order to improve their quality of life, as well as their economic status (Synergy
Strategies Group [SSG] 2007).
The EasySeva business strategy is built around a franchising model. Local entrepreneurs—generally those
already employed in founding partner Dialog Telekom’s mobile phone stores—are identified, interviewed, and
recruited to establish village-level EasySeva telecenter franchises that provide Internet and telephone access, as
well as many Internet-enabled services to the local population. Through EasySeva, the potential franchisees are
offered the opportunity to start a business by purchasing a “Center-in-a-box,” which consists of four
reconditioned personal computers (PCs) with a licensed suite of Microsoft Office products, an all-in-one
5. 19th Australasian Conference on Information Systems A Pilot Takes Off: Sustainability and Scalability
3-5 Dec 2008, Christchurch Hosman
printer/copier/fax machine, and a broadband connection via Dialog Telekom, which is a leading telecom service
provider in Sri Lanka (SSG 2007).
In addition to the equipment, setup, and connectivity, the franchise package also includes IT/business training,
business plan support, a micro-loan and lease program, marketing support, and a 24/7 help desk. The majority of
these items and services are provided directly by the numerous partners in the EasySeva project, which benefits
from economy of scale and buying in bulk: it is able to provide technology, support, and prices/rates well below
those which any single operator, entrepreneur, or company could negotiate by itself. Additionally, the
franchisee’s required capital outlay (obtained through a start-up cost loan) reduces the up-front capital outlay
burden for the main project partner, Synergy Strategies Group (SSG 2007).
While EasySeva provides kiosk owners with training, support, technical assistance, and access to financial
assistance they otherwise would not have, in the end, the local franchise owners themselves are responsible for
generating the income and profit to pay back their initial loan in a timely fashion (30 months). In other words,
they are responsible for putting into practice the marketing strategies they are provided as part of their assistance,
and for developing additional product and service offerings of their own. This is intended to challenge and
stimulate the creative, entrepreneurial spirit.
The implementing partner of the EasySeva project is Synergy Strategies Group (SSG), a small, Vermont-based
American firm. In the summer of 2006, SSG beat out a considerable number of established competitors for a
USAID-sponsored Last Mile Initiative grant. USAID’s Last Mile Initiative (LMI) is its global program, launched
in 2003, to bring modern telecommunications infrastructure to traditionally underserved areas.
In the Sri Lanka Last Mile Initiative, USAID stipulated a number of project requirements with an eye to
promoting long-term sustainability. Among these was 2-to-1 matching of project funds, wherein for every dollar
provided by USAID the private sector partner had to match it with $0.50—with either its own or partner funds.
In order to promote project scalability, USAID required that a minimum of 20 centers had to be fully operational
within one year of the project award date, to ensure a “proof of concept” for scalability. In addition, USAID
encouraged and facilitated SSG’s forming of alliances with both public and private sector partners.
At the end of September, 2006, SSG was awarded the contract and began implementation, which involved
partnering with numerous organizations. From the beginning, SSG has viewed this project as a scalable business
development opportunity. The USAID funds were utilized to enable the pilot project’s deployment. After that
stage, they will need to attract sufficient private financing, which, in this case, means that the current partners
must realize a sufficient profit to remain involved and to expand their involvement as the project is scaled (SSG
2007). Growth in involvement on the part of the private partners has indeed already been the case for EasySeva,
as corporate partners Qualcomm and Dialog have increased their initial levels of investment/stake in the project,
which has provided the necessary financing for the project to begin the scaling process. Not only does this
business model provide SSG a true long-term stake in the project, it also creates the incentives for contracted
partners to realize profitability as well, promoting desire for continued participation in the project’s expansion.
All of these characteristics contribute to the potential for the project’s long-term sustainability. This performance-
based contract model marks a shift on the part of USAID, which now recognizes that correct incentives should be
in place for aid-based funding to be effective; a project is more likely to be a success once all parties have a
(financial) stake in the outcome.
This particular PPP model is unique in that it resembles a venture capital model, where the main role for the
public partners was to provide seed money to get the project off the ground, but the incentives built in to the
business model are designed to promote the project’s sustainability and scalability in the long-run. In fact, such
incentivizing represents a radical departure for USAID: traditionally, US firms merely extracted aid fees from the
initial implementation of a project, and had little-to-no interest in the impact or sustainability of the project after
implementation, once the funding stopped.
Synergy Strategies Group registered EasySeva, the franchisor, as a Sri Lankan Private company in early 2007. As
mentioned above, fieldwork took place at the completion of the pilot stage in January/February, 2008. At the
time of this paper’s writing, the number of centers had nearly doubled, from 18 to 35 in less than four months.
The company plans to open 400-500 centers within Sri Lanka over the next 3-4 years, and an additional 1000
centers around the South Asian region in the future.
RESEARCH FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION
The following section provides an overview and discussion of findings from firsthand research undertaken on the
EasySeva project carried out during the transition period from pilot to scale. Both challenges and success factors
are highlighted.
6. 19th Australasian Conference on Information Systems A Pilot Takes Off: Sustainability and Scalability
3-5 Dec 2008, Christchurch Hosman
In addition to a proof of concept promoting additional investment, there are numerous other reasons why starting
small can be valuable. The pilot stage gives the project leaders an opportunity to figure out which partners are
truly interested in the well-being of the project, and are committed for the long-term. Those that are not may need
to be replaced, if this is possible. Alternately, incentives could be adjusted to inspire greater commitment by
partners. In EasySeva’s case, there were challenges early-on with the local hardware equipment provider. This
partner was replaced, as there are numerous other local businesses performing the same service. However, there
also have been ongoing challenges with the local financing partner, yet this partner is less simple to replace,
because of the lack of financing alternatives as described above—there are few, if any, alternative partners in Sri
Lanka to provide local, small-scale financing for the individual entrepreneurs. Thus the project has had to work
with the same company, even though ideally it would be more efficient to replace this partner. At the time of
writing, inaction by the local finance partner was temporarily slowing down the project’s scaling.
At the time the surveys were administered, Internet and email comprised the most commonly used applications at
the centers, with 78 and 46 percent of respondents reporting use of these, respectively. However, in order to
differentiate its offerings from those of other Internet cafes, EasySeva is uniquely focused on being service-
oriented, in order to provide added value to its customers. One aspect of this value-add is person-to-person
customer service, where the client feels comfortable going in to the center and asking for help. Customer service
seemed to be uniformly carried out in the centers, where employees appeared to be ready to help customers with
anything they knew how to do, and in the surveys, customers unanimously (100 percent) reported that they were
satisfied with their experience. From the interviews conducted with the center owners as well, this appears to be
an area in which EasySeva stands out as unique from other telecenter businesses. Thus, distinguishing a business
from potential competition—in this case as a “service center,” as opposed to a telecenter or internet café that
simply provides computers with a connection to the Internet—may be identified as a best practice that becomes
increasingly relevant as a project starts to scale.
Another form of value-adding is providing innovative services on-line that are not yet available elsewhere, or that
can be accessed at a more competitive rate than elsewhere. Planned services unique to EasySeva include the
following: online banking, money transfer, loan applications, bill-payment, appointment booking, technical skills
courses, and small-group training. The fact that EasySeva is working on developing and offering these services
will be a distinct value-add for the Sri Lankan population in general (and for EasySeva customers in particular)
because such services likely would not be developed and offered as quickly on a nation-wide basis without a
coordinated effort such as EasySeva is making. It also represents an additional business strategy by which
EasySeva is differentiating itself from other telecenters.
At the completion of the pilot stage, a number of anticipated service offerings were not yet available. Some of
these services have since come on-line: in particular, International Direct Dial calling. This is a valuable service,
as the Sri Lankan expatriate workforce is extremely large. While estimates vary, in 1999 the Central Bank of Sri
Lanka estimated that there were over 788 million expatriate workers, 90 percent of whom are employed in the
Middle East (Central Bank 1999; this statistic is no longer officially reported). Given the high rate of depression
and even suicide among these workers (Toumi 2007), affordable overseas communication may truly be said to
provide a “lifeline” between loved ones. Another service anticipated to be available shortly is making doctor
appointments and arranging hospital visits which take place in the capital city of Colombo, where the major
hospitals and specialist physicians are located. People will also be able to receive paperwork regarding these
appointments over the Internet. All of these services will save patrons the time and travel costs of multiple
journeys to distant hospitals.
As a general point, telecenter projects will need to focus their business strategy to provide services that are not
provided by mobile phones, which are becoming more and more ubiquitous across the developing world. Since
90 percent of respondents to the survey distributed at the EasySeva centers reported that they owned their own
mobile phone, it will be important to for EasySeva to keep its focus on providing services not readily available
over mobiles. At the same time, the majority of people in Sri Lanka cannot yet afford to have computers with
broadband Internet connections in their homes, yet the majority of people are aware of the Internet (including 80
percent of survey respondents), so there is a large potential customer base.
Another overall success factor that is virtually absent from the ICTD literature is the importance of the level of
experience, motivation, and commitment of the project’s staff. In fact, it would be difficult to overstate how
central to the success or failure of any such project those responsible for its implementation are. Practitioners
navigate the interplay between the top-down and bottom-up aspects of a project. They are responsible for
carrying out the project deployment on a day-to-day basis, reacting when plans do not play out as anticipated,
and formulating alternate methods for moving forward. They frequently work long hours, and their motivation is
most often inspired by a belief in the project’s ability to enable positive change and foster development. The fact
that all of the people involved in EasySeva’s design and implementation, including the entire project
management team, have experience with planning and deployment of previous ICT-and-development projects
means that EasySeva has benefited significantly from its staff’s ability to actively apply the lessons they have
7. 19th Australasian Conference on Information Systems A Pilot Takes Off: Sustainability and Scalability
3-5 Dec 2008, Christchurch Hosman
learned, drawing on their understanding of what worked and what did not in the past, to make (and continue to
revise, as necessary) EasySeva’s working plan of action. Firsthand observation and interviews also revealed the
staff’s commitment to and belief in the project, as well as their flexibility in navigating the challenges that arose,
and the long hours that they worked in order to move the project forward. Further scholarly review of this crucial
aspect of such projects—on the practitioners and their vital role in carrying out project implementation—is
certainly warranted.
Many of the issues faced by the project practitioners presented somewhat of a chicken-and-egg dilemma. This
may be seen most notably with the availability of services and in the awareness campaigns. It can be difficult to
put innovative services in place without a critical mass of users, yet it is also difficult to cultivate a critical mass
of users for services if they are not yet available. In a similar vein, it is difficult to conceive of a nation-wide
advertising campaign for the project when just 20 centers exist across the country. On the other hand, the 20
centers that do exist face difficulty in the early days, if they are depending on the central organization to carry out
the publicity.
This particular point in fact raises a few questions: At what point in the scaling process does it become
appropriate to launch a large-scale or nation-wide publicity campaign? To what degree should the owners be
dependent on the central offices to provide their advertising if they themselves are considered entrepreneurs? In
fact, entrepreneurial drive among owners varied widely. During the interviews, the distinction became quite clear
between those with visions for the future of their centers and those without; between those with an
entrepreneurial drive and those that just wanted to run a telecenter. This variance was already noted by the staff
during the pilot stage, and should in fact change in the future, as more competitive methods were already going
into effect at pilot-stage completion, for identifying and selecting future center owners that markedly demonstrate
entrepreneurship—another example of making adjustments at the crucial stage between pilot and scaling.
Marketing and advertising in general on the EasySeva project remains limited. Not many of the owners had yet
begun advertising initiatives on their own. Some expected this to be done by the EasySeva headquarters staff.
Others had begun their own publicity initiatives, and were seeing demonstratable results. This issue will need to
be addressed and clarified as EasySeva moves forward.
The publicity or awareness-raising campaign is another topic rarely addressed in the literature dealing with pilot
projects, for it arguably does not become necessary until a project scales. Yet, if people are not aware of a new
technology or how it can benefit them, they are unlikely to take advantage of it, which decreases the likelihood of
project success. The awareness campaign of a project is, in fact, of equal importance as is the availability of
innovative services. While the services planned to be offered in the context of this project are original, and will
be invaluable across the entire country when they become available, a concerted, coordinated marketing or
awareness-raising campaign to coincide with the scaling of the EasySeva project will also be essential at the
nation-wide level. It would be possible for EasySeva to capitalize on the existing nation-wide marketing
capabilities of project partner Dialog Telekom to lead or facilitate this campaign. These capabilities already exist
for Dialog, as one of the nation’s leading service providers. Since Dialog has a financial stake in the success of
the project, it would be in their best interests to work together with EasySeva to facilitate such a publicity
campaign—another example of how partnering provides incentives that are aligned in the best interests of the
project. There are already plans underway to capitalize on Dialog’s brand-recognition by revising the EasySeva
logo to match or become similar to the nationally-recognizable Dialog E-Z logo.
Still another area of focus that rarely receives mention in the literature because it is not yet relevant at the pilot
stage is the concept of introducing new ways of doing business, made possible because of the scaling process. In
this case, the concept being introduced is networking among EasySeva entrepreneurs. It will be useful for the
entrepreneurs to share their innovative ideas, the challenges they have faced, and the solutions they have devised,
with other people who are in the same situation as they are, without feeling the need to view these others as
competition. In fact, the more information shared, the stronger the network and better chances of success for
all—this is one of the main features of the franchising model. Such networking is not yet a part of the business
mindset in Sri Lanka, however. EasySeva is actively promoting networking among the entrepreneurs at regularly-
scheduled workshops, where numerous business-promoting concepts are covered. These workshops also provide
the opportunity for the owners to meet one another in person, which can build levels of interpersonal trust and
counter the perception of competition among owners. At the time of the interviews (which took place before the
workshops), divergent views were in evidence: some of those working in the EasySeva centers did not yet grasp
the usefulness of networking and still saw other owners as their competition, while some had already begun
contacting other owners to exchange ideas and information with them.
At some point in the future, EasySeva plans to expand these workshop offerings to include employees of the
centers as well. At this time however, there remains a challenge—one that is by no means unique to EasySeva—
in that workers that have received (free) IT training often seek higher-paying jobs elsewhere after the training has
8. 19th Australasian Conference on Information Systems A Pilot Takes Off: Sustainability and Scalability
3-5 Dec 2008, Christchurch Hosman
taken place and their skill levels have increased. There is thus a problem with worker retention. Yet, this is a
challenge for businesses of every kind, all over the world.
Another issue rarely noted concerning pilot projects that have not faced the challenges of scaling is that regional
differences will dictate local usage patterns in the individual telecenters, and thus also how the entrepreneurs will
need to target or advertise their services. One owner pointed out that in his area, local schoolchildren did not
have enough disposable income available to them to come in and make use of his telecenter, while this clearly
was not the case for other telecenters, where schoolchildren were occupying every available computer.
Additionally, in some of the cities where the EasySeva centers were located, they represented the only public
Internet access. In other cities, there were already multiple Internet cafes with which the EasySeva centers needed
to compete. These examples underscore the fact that each store owner will need to design a business plan that is
locally appropriate—whether it will include raising Internet-awareness in general, or focusing on differentiating
his services from that of a competitor. One center noted that most people who lived in his area were not yet aware
of the Internet, so he will need to focus on raising awareness of how the Internet can be useful. Another owner
competes with a handful of Internet cafes nearby, so he has attempted to differentiate his center by making it the
most modern-looking in the city.
There is currently a drive to involve more females at the EasySeva centers. Yet, use of EasySeva centers by
females is still comparatively low. There were fewer female than male customers at every store that was visited.
Females comprised just 25 percent of survey respondents. Many of the center owners expressed the desire to
increase the female customer base, but how to do so remains rather elusive. Two owners mentioned that
employing a female in the store helps other females to feel comfortable coming in to the store and becoming
EasySeva customers, therefore hiring female employees represents one strategy for addressing this issue.
However, it is also important to remember that ICT is always and everywhere introduced into a society, and this
society does not change as quickly as technology might enable it to. There are simply not as many females as
males in Sri Lanka at this moment in time who see technology as being relevant or important for their lives. This
may change over time, and certainly encouraging females to become involved at the EasySeva centers is a step in
the right direction for encouraging equality of technology use.
Reported use of computers for school-related tasks in the surveys was lower than expected (at 17 percent),
particularly when comparing these responses with what customers would like to use computers for (71 percent of
respondents indicated that they would like to use computers for educational purposes). This may be an important
area to focus on in the future, for the earlier in life one starts using technology, the more likely that technology is
to be adopted and incorporated into people’s activities, so that its potential benefits have a better chance of being
realized. Perhaps if there were more school-related reasons to make use of the EasySeva centers, more females
would come in and become comfortable with technology and begin to see its value, as well.
On a related note concerning social values, since the EasySeva owners have the prerogative to do so, they are
actively preventing the use of their centers for what are deemed societally negative purposes. Three of the owners
mentioned in interviews that they have stopped customers from using computers and the Internet for watching
pornography (which may also contribute to females being more comfortable coming in to the centers).
Center satisfaction among survey respondents was uniformly positive. Not a single survey respondent reported
dissatisfaction with their overall experience at EasySeva centers. Owner satisfaction is uniformly positive as well:
when the owners were asked directly: “Are you satisfied (so far) with EasySeva?” each one answered in the
affirmative. It may be worth noting that the unanimous satisfaction rate evident in the survey is even more robust
than those from the interviews, as the surveys were anonymous in nature, while the interviewees had to answer
the question directly to the researcher and often in front of an EasySeva employee. Centers also appear to be
conveniently located and to have opening hours of operation that are convenient for customers, with positive
survey responses to each of the above questions rating over 95 percent.
Finally, as noted above, EasySeva supports and promotes small and medium enterprise (SME) development in
the private sector in Sri Lanka. In addition to business creation in general and to the owners themselves being
employed, most centers also employ multiple operators, creating job opportunities in addition to offering
valuable services to the community as well as to other local businesses. The degree to which EasySeva will
contribute to small business-promotion across the country will become evident over time, and as the project
scales.
CONCLUSION
Public-private partnerships can offer great opportunities for technological advancement in the developing world.
Still, there is a need for careful study of these initiatives, in order to ensure successful projects and to encourage
the use of ICTs to further human development. Sustainability and scalability of such projects have been identified
as important success factors for technology-enabled endeavors, but few pilots have successfully reached the
scaling stage, and thus the opportunity for scholarly analysis of these has been limited. Additionally, the
9. 19th Australasian Conference on Information Systems A Pilot Takes Off: Sustainability and Scalability
3-5 Dec 2008, Christchurch Hosman
development of small and medium sized enterprises has been identified as crucial for sustainable development in
emerging economies. Public-private partnerships can play a central role in promoting such development.
This paper presented a case study of a public-private partnership designed with scalability and sustainability as
main goals from the very beginning. It also plays a role in promoting development in the SME sector of the Sri
Lankan economy. The project has been considered successful enough at the pilot stage that it has obtained
additional investment funds enabling it to begin the scaling process. The fieldwork informing the study was
carried out at a unique point in time: the transition point between the completion of the pilot project and the
commencement of the project’s scaling. As such, a number of challenges and success factors were identified that
are rarely addressed in the literature, which mirrors the fact that since few pilot projects progress to the scaling
stage, rarely do they face the issues associated with such growth and transition. The paper presented a number of
issues that the EasySeva project is successfully addressing, as well as some challenges that remain. There is a
great potential for lessons to be learned from EasySeva by other ICT-related development projects, both from the
best practices exhibited and from the challenges encountered in the planning and implementation stages of the
project. This work is also intended to serve as a baseline, of sorts, as there will be further value in revisiting the
issues addressed above, as the project continues to scale.
REFERENCES
Alampay, G. 2007. “The Role of Governments in Promoting ICT Access and Use by SMEs: Considerations for
Public Policy,” APDIP e-Note 12. Retrieved 6 June, 2008, from www.apdip.net/apdipenote/12.pdf
Angerer, D. J., & Hammerschmid, G. 2005. “Public Private Partnership Between Euphoria and Disillusionment.
Recent Experiences from Austria and Implications for Countries in Transformation,” Romanian Journal of
Political Science, (5 :1), pp 129-159.
Central Bank of Sri Lanka 1999. Key Economic Indicators, Central Bank of Sri Lanka Printing Press.
de Ferranti, D. and Ody, A.J. 2007. “Beyond Microfinance: Getting Capital to Small and Medium Enterprises to
Fuel Faster Development,” The Brookings Institution Policy Brief #159, March. Retrieved 6 June, 2008, from
http://www.brookings.edu/papers/2007/03development_de_ferranti.aspx
Gerring, J. 2004. “What is a Case Study and What is it Good for?” American Political Science Review, (98:2),
pp 341-354.
Jensen, M. 2005. “Information Kiosks and Sustainability: Key Components for Success,” in Connected for
Development: Information Kiosks and Sustainability, A. Badshah, S. Kahn, and M. Garrido (eds.), United
Nations ICT Task Force Series 4, pp 43-47.
Kanungo, S. 2004. “On the Emancipatory Role of Rural Information Systems,” Information Technology &
People, (17: 4), pp 407-422.
Kauffmann, C. 2005. “Financing SMEs in Africa,” Policy Insights 7. Retrieved 6 June, 2008, from
www.oecd.org/dataoecd/57/59/34908457.pdf
Kusakabe, M. 2005. “Knowledge Sharing and Capacity Building: Scaling up Information Kiosks, in Connected
for Development: Information Kiosks and Sustainability, A. Badshah, S. Kahn, and M. Garrido (eds.), United
Nations ICT Task Force Series 4, pp 51-56.
Lijphart, A. 1971. “Comparative Politics and the Comparative Method,” The American Political Science Review,
(65) pp 682-693.
Newberry, D. 2006. “The Role of Small- and Medium-Sized Enterprises in the Futures of Emerging Economies,”
Earthtrends Featured Topic, World Resources Institute, December. Retrieved 6 June, 2008, from
earthtrends.wri.org/features/view_feature.php?fid=69&theme=5
Proenza, F.J. 2001. “Telecenter Sustainability—Myths and Opportunities,” in Bridging the Rural Knowledge
Gap: Information Systems for Improved Livelihoods, J. Dixon and H. Wittenbach (eds.), Internet publication.
Retrieved 6 June, 2008, from http://ict.developmentgateway.org/Content-item-
view.10976+M5f98b9cc86b.0.html
Rosenau, P. 1999. “The Strengths and Weaknesses of Public-Private Policy Partnerships,” American Behavioral
Scientist, (43:1), September, pp 10-34.
Roman, R. and Colle, R. 2002. “Themes and Issues in Telecenter Sustainability, Development Informatics,”
Working Paper Series, Paper No. 10, Institute for Development Policy and Management, University of
Manchester. Retrieved 29 June, 2008, from
unpan1.un.org/intradoc/groups/public/documents/nispacee/unpan015544.pdf