This document provides preliminary findings from an impact evaluation of the RBF4MNH intervention in Malawi. The intervention included supply-side incentives for health facilities and demand-side cash transfers to women for facility deliveries. The study found:
1) No significant impact on utilization of antenatal care, delivery care, or postnatal care services, but more control area women chose to deliver in intervention facilities over time.
2) Mixed results for improvements in health facility quality, with some increases in staff training and equipment but no significant change in medicine availability.
3) Significant improvements in certain incentivized clinical tasks like risk assessment during delivery but no significant change in non-incentivized tasks.
Smarter Social Protection?
presented by Marta Favara, Catherine Porter, Tassew Woldehanna
CSAE Conference Presentation, University of Oxford
March 21, 2016
Behavioral economics approach to reduce injectable contraceptive discontinuat...JSI
This was presented by Ali Karim as part of a preformed panel at the International Conference on Family Planning (ICFP) in Kigali, Rwanda in November 2018.
Contraceptive prevalence in Ethiopia jumped from 6% in 2000 to 35% in 2016, primarily attributed to the increase in injectable contraceptive method use from 3% in 2000 to 23% in 2016. Nonetheless, discontinuation rate among injectable contraceptive users was 38%.
Given that injectable methods are the preferred method among married women of reproductive age in Ethiopia, the Last Ten Kilometers Project (L10K) of JSI Research & Training Institute, Inc. (JSI) in collaboration with ideas42 worked with Ethiopia’s flagship Health Extension Program to apply behavioral economics (BE) approaches to mitigate discontinuation of injectable contraceptives.
Methods: The project followed a BE methodology to conduct a behavioral diagnosis and design an intervention package, consisting of 1) health worker planner calendar, 2) client care checklist, and 3) client appointment cards.
Conclusion: Discontinuation can be influenced by health systems factors like supply issues. Nonetheless, the use of two BE tools—the appointment card and client care checklist—effectively decreased injectable discontinuation in the presence other health system bottlenecks. BE is an effective approach to enhance family planning programs in Ethiopia and elsewhere.
This presentation was developed with support by Global Health Corps and the Infectious Diseases Institute of Makerere University. It was presented at the International conference Mobile Telephony in the Developing World in May 2013.
Is healthcare getting safer? Professor Charles Vincent - Patient safety lead, Oxford AHSN
Presentation from the Patient Safety Collaborative launch event held in London on 14 October 2014
More information at http://www.nhsiq.nhs.uk/improvement-programmes/patient-safety/patient-safety-collaboratives.aspx
PCHAlliance conducted a systematic review of published literature to gather the available data on health outcome measures, reviewing over 1,450 citations. Fifty-three randomized controlled studies and trials were selected for analysis, on topics related to mobile technologies, remote patient monitoring, web-based counseling and other personal connected health technologies. This publication aims to set an initial baseline for the current body of evidence in personal connected health in key areas, namely behavior change and self-care, remote patient monitoring, remote counseling and mental health, as well as more broadly through key condition-specific studies.
Download the paper here: http://www.pchalliance.org/personal-connected-health-state-evidence-and-call-action
Smarter Social Protection?
presented by Marta Favara, Catherine Porter, Tassew Woldehanna
CSAE Conference Presentation, University of Oxford
March 21, 2016
Behavioral economics approach to reduce injectable contraceptive discontinuat...JSI
This was presented by Ali Karim as part of a preformed panel at the International Conference on Family Planning (ICFP) in Kigali, Rwanda in November 2018.
Contraceptive prevalence in Ethiopia jumped from 6% in 2000 to 35% in 2016, primarily attributed to the increase in injectable contraceptive method use from 3% in 2000 to 23% in 2016. Nonetheless, discontinuation rate among injectable contraceptive users was 38%.
Given that injectable methods are the preferred method among married women of reproductive age in Ethiopia, the Last Ten Kilometers Project (L10K) of JSI Research & Training Institute, Inc. (JSI) in collaboration with ideas42 worked with Ethiopia’s flagship Health Extension Program to apply behavioral economics (BE) approaches to mitigate discontinuation of injectable contraceptives.
Methods: The project followed a BE methodology to conduct a behavioral diagnosis and design an intervention package, consisting of 1) health worker planner calendar, 2) client care checklist, and 3) client appointment cards.
Conclusion: Discontinuation can be influenced by health systems factors like supply issues. Nonetheless, the use of two BE tools—the appointment card and client care checklist—effectively decreased injectable discontinuation in the presence other health system bottlenecks. BE is an effective approach to enhance family planning programs in Ethiopia and elsewhere.
This presentation was developed with support by Global Health Corps and the Infectious Diseases Institute of Makerere University. It was presented at the International conference Mobile Telephony in the Developing World in May 2013.
Is healthcare getting safer? Professor Charles Vincent - Patient safety lead, Oxford AHSN
Presentation from the Patient Safety Collaborative launch event held in London on 14 October 2014
More information at http://www.nhsiq.nhs.uk/improvement-programmes/patient-safety/patient-safety-collaboratives.aspx
PCHAlliance conducted a systematic review of published literature to gather the available data on health outcome measures, reviewing over 1,450 citations. Fifty-three randomized controlled studies and trials were selected for analysis, on topics related to mobile technologies, remote patient monitoring, web-based counseling and other personal connected health technologies. This publication aims to set an initial baseline for the current body of evidence in personal connected health in key areas, namely behavior change and self-care, remote patient monitoring, remote counseling and mental health, as well as more broadly through key condition-specific studies.
Download the paper here: http://www.pchalliance.org/personal-connected-health-state-evidence-and-call-action
Evaluation of the Impact of a Social Support Strategy on Treatment OutcomesMEASURE Evaluation
Shared at a data dissemination and data use workshop on the results of the impact evaluation of the Strengthening Tuberculosis Control in Ukraine project. Access another presentation at https://www.slideshare.net/measureevaluation/evaluation-of-the-tbhiv-integration-strategy-on-treatment-outcomes.
Results of research analysis to assess the impact of CARE Media Holding’s KidCARE TV program; evaluated on Product X on prescribing behavior of participating physicians using a nine month test/post-test period.
With @Atreja at the NODE Health Conference - Digital Medicine http://digitalmedicineconference.com/ on the events and studies which moved the field forward
Evaluation of the TB-HIV Integration Strategy on Treatment OutcomesMEASURE Evaluation
Shared at a data dissemination and data use workshop on the results of the impact evaluation of the Strengthening Tuberculosis Control in Ukraine project. Access another presentation at https://www.slideshare.net/measureevaluation/evaluation-of-the-impact-of-a-social-support-strategy-on-treatment-outcomes/.
Lessons from meta-evaluation of MGNREGA from a gender and equality lens (2014)Ranjani K.Murthy
This slide shares insights form a review of 22 government commissioned evaluations of the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Ac, 2005 from a gender and substantive equality lens. It argues that MGNREGA evaluations and its impact are gendered and reflect social hierarchies (like another evaluation and entitlement).
It points to strategies for negotiating with evaluations and schemes which seek to translate entitlements so as to engender them and make them account for other social identities of women.
Effect of Climate Shock on Cognitive Development of Children in Ethiopiaessp2
International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) and Ethiopian Development Research Institute (EDRI) in collaboration with Ethiopian Economics Association (EEA). Eleventh International Conference on Ethiopian Economy. July 18-20, 2013
Practice-Level Correlates of Patient-Centered Medical Home Characteristics: A...Marion Sills
For more on SAFTINet please see http://www.ucdenver.edu/academics/colleges/medicalschool/programs/outcomes/COHO/saftinet/Pages/default.aspx
Research Objective: Evidence suggests the patient centered medical home (PCMH) model should improve delivery of preventive care services, lower cost, and enhance quality of care. Widespread but varied PCMH implementation offers the opportunity to conduct observational comparative effectiveness research in real-world settings on the impact of specific PCMH functions on clinical outcomes. We examined a series of practice-level characteristics (hypothesized common causes of both PCMH characteristics and clinical outcomes) as possible correlates of PCMH characteristics and confounders of the PCMH- outcomes relationship.
Study Design: Self-report practice-level surveys were administered in 51 primary care practices in the Scalable Architecture for Federated Translational Inquiries Network (SAFTINet), Practice leadership completed (1) the SAFTINet Delivery of Coordinated Care Survey (DoCCS), a measure of multiple PCMH domains including team-based care, panel management, and enhanced access; and (2) a survey of general practice characteristics, including organizational features, patient population, provider/staff characteristics, and health information technology infrastructure. We examined variability in DoCCS total and domain scores and correlations between DoCCS scores and select practice characteristics in 47 practices with complete data.
Population Studied: Participating practices are primarily federally qualified health centers with electronic health records, representing ~260,000 patients (30% covered by Medicaid), 500 primary care providers, and four safety net healthcare organizations in Colorado and Tennessee.
Principal Findings: Total DoCCS scores were moderate to high (M = 3.70, SD = 0.54) on a scale of 1 to 5, with no significant mean differences among the four organizations. Domain scores were as follows: Personal clinician (M = 4.43, SD = 0.59), Team-based care (M = 3.34, SD = 1.43), Access (M = 3.82, SD = 0.53), Patient centeredness (M = 3.77, SD = 0.72), Coordinated/Integrated care (M = 3.82, SD = 0.51), Quality Improvement (M = 3.56, SD = 0.58), Evidence-Based Medicine (M = 3.42, SD = 0.91), Engaged Leadership (M = 3.40, SD = 0.89), and Registries (M = 3.98, SD = 1.04). Characteristics of patient population that were positively related to total score include proportion of Caucasian patients and proportion of patients for whom English is their first language. Domain-specific results will also be presented.
Conclusions: Of practices in SAFTINet, there was variability across practices in DoCCS scores, suggesting that the DoCCS can detect variation in PCMH characteristics. Practices caring for more minority and non-English- speakers.
This presentation on research about HIV self-testing in Australia was given by A/Prof Rebecca Guy, The Kirby Institute, at the AFAO Members Forum - May 2015.
The Effect of Implementation Strength of Basic Emergency Obstetric and Newbor...JSI
Strengthening BEmONC is a key priority for providing life-saving services especially in rural areas, and was found to be effective in improving institutional deliveries and may have also improved the met need for MEmONC services.
The Last 10 Kilometers (L10K) project uses a community-based strategy to improve reproductive, maternal, newborn, and child health (RMNCH) care-seeking behavior and practices. The evidence-based practices from L10K informed strategies of the Federal Ministry of Health (FMOH) and have guided scale-up of programs region-wide and nationally.
This poster was presented at the IHI Africa Forum on Quality and Safety in Healthcare in Durban, South Africa.
Evaluation of the Impact of a Social Support Strategy on Treatment OutcomesMEASURE Evaluation
Shared at a data dissemination and data use workshop on the results of the impact evaluation of the Strengthening Tuberculosis Control in Ukraine project. Access another presentation at https://www.slideshare.net/measureevaluation/evaluation-of-the-tbhiv-integration-strategy-on-treatment-outcomes.
Results of research analysis to assess the impact of CARE Media Holding’s KidCARE TV program; evaluated on Product X on prescribing behavior of participating physicians using a nine month test/post-test period.
With @Atreja at the NODE Health Conference - Digital Medicine http://digitalmedicineconference.com/ on the events and studies which moved the field forward
Evaluation of the TB-HIV Integration Strategy on Treatment OutcomesMEASURE Evaluation
Shared at a data dissemination and data use workshop on the results of the impact evaluation of the Strengthening Tuberculosis Control in Ukraine project. Access another presentation at https://www.slideshare.net/measureevaluation/evaluation-of-the-impact-of-a-social-support-strategy-on-treatment-outcomes/.
Lessons from meta-evaluation of MGNREGA from a gender and equality lens (2014)Ranjani K.Murthy
This slide shares insights form a review of 22 government commissioned evaluations of the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Ac, 2005 from a gender and substantive equality lens. It argues that MGNREGA evaluations and its impact are gendered and reflect social hierarchies (like another evaluation and entitlement).
It points to strategies for negotiating with evaluations and schemes which seek to translate entitlements so as to engender them and make them account for other social identities of women.
Effect of Climate Shock on Cognitive Development of Children in Ethiopiaessp2
International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) and Ethiopian Development Research Institute (EDRI) in collaboration with Ethiopian Economics Association (EEA). Eleventh International Conference on Ethiopian Economy. July 18-20, 2013
Practice-Level Correlates of Patient-Centered Medical Home Characteristics: A...Marion Sills
For more on SAFTINet please see http://www.ucdenver.edu/academics/colleges/medicalschool/programs/outcomes/COHO/saftinet/Pages/default.aspx
Research Objective: Evidence suggests the patient centered medical home (PCMH) model should improve delivery of preventive care services, lower cost, and enhance quality of care. Widespread but varied PCMH implementation offers the opportunity to conduct observational comparative effectiveness research in real-world settings on the impact of specific PCMH functions on clinical outcomes. We examined a series of practice-level characteristics (hypothesized common causes of both PCMH characteristics and clinical outcomes) as possible correlates of PCMH characteristics and confounders of the PCMH- outcomes relationship.
Study Design: Self-report practice-level surveys were administered in 51 primary care practices in the Scalable Architecture for Federated Translational Inquiries Network (SAFTINet), Practice leadership completed (1) the SAFTINet Delivery of Coordinated Care Survey (DoCCS), a measure of multiple PCMH domains including team-based care, panel management, and enhanced access; and (2) a survey of general practice characteristics, including organizational features, patient population, provider/staff characteristics, and health information technology infrastructure. We examined variability in DoCCS total and domain scores and correlations between DoCCS scores and select practice characteristics in 47 practices with complete data.
Population Studied: Participating practices are primarily federally qualified health centers with electronic health records, representing ~260,000 patients (30% covered by Medicaid), 500 primary care providers, and four safety net healthcare organizations in Colorado and Tennessee.
Principal Findings: Total DoCCS scores were moderate to high (M = 3.70, SD = 0.54) on a scale of 1 to 5, with no significant mean differences among the four organizations. Domain scores were as follows: Personal clinician (M = 4.43, SD = 0.59), Team-based care (M = 3.34, SD = 1.43), Access (M = 3.82, SD = 0.53), Patient centeredness (M = 3.77, SD = 0.72), Coordinated/Integrated care (M = 3.82, SD = 0.51), Quality Improvement (M = 3.56, SD = 0.58), Evidence-Based Medicine (M = 3.42, SD = 0.91), Engaged Leadership (M = 3.40, SD = 0.89), and Registries (M = 3.98, SD = 1.04). Characteristics of patient population that were positively related to total score include proportion of Caucasian patients and proportion of patients for whom English is their first language. Domain-specific results will also be presented.
Conclusions: Of practices in SAFTINet, there was variability across practices in DoCCS scores, suggesting that the DoCCS can detect variation in PCMH characteristics. Practices caring for more minority and non-English- speakers.
This presentation on research about HIV self-testing in Australia was given by A/Prof Rebecca Guy, The Kirby Institute, at the AFAO Members Forum - May 2015.
The Effect of Implementation Strength of Basic Emergency Obstetric and Newbor...JSI
Strengthening BEmONC is a key priority for providing life-saving services especially in rural areas, and was found to be effective in improving institutional deliveries and may have also improved the met need for MEmONC services.
The Last 10 Kilometers (L10K) project uses a community-based strategy to improve reproductive, maternal, newborn, and child health (RMNCH) care-seeking behavior and practices. The evidence-based practices from L10K informed strategies of the Federal Ministry of Health (FMOH) and have guided scale-up of programs region-wide and nationally.
This poster was presented at the IHI Africa Forum on Quality and Safety in Healthcare in Durban, South Africa.
Insights from the National Diabetes Registry: User SatisfactionArunah Chandran
The National Diabetes Registry (NDR) is a web-based application to register diabetes patients in Malaysia. It is used in all Ministry of Health (MOH) health clinics and selected hospitals.
User satisfaction is an important factor to determine quality and effectiveness of service delivery to clients of a particular product or service.
Our objective was to examine user satisfaction towards NDR system usage.
This presentation was given at the Global Symposium on Health System Research in November 2010. The authors are L P Singh, Olakunle Alonge, Anubhav Agarwal,
Kayhan Natiq, S D Gupta and David Peters.
SM2015 is an ambitious project with the Ministry of Health and local support. This presentation outlines the design and activities around the data collection and analysis of the evaluation, as well as the results, conclusions, and future activities.
Evelyn Torres and Sebastian Branca's update on AACO's Client Services Unit (CSU), Housing Services Program (HSP), and Quality Improvement (QI) programs
Evelyn Torres and Sebastian Branca's update on AACO's Client Services Unit (CSU), Housing Services Program (HSP), and Quality Improvement (QI) programs
The Relationship Between Quality of Care and Choice of Clinical Computing System: Retrospective Analysis of Family Practice Performance Under the UK Quality and Outcomes Framework
Fidelity assessment in cluster randomized trials of public health interventio...valéry ridde
Presentation by Nanor Minoyan and Myriam Cielo (Université de Montréal).
Global Health Workshop: Methods For Implementation Science in Global Health.
http://www.equitesante.org/implementation-science-methods-in-global-health/
Comparative Effectiveness of a Multifaceted Intervention to Improve Adherence to Annual Colorectal Cancer Screening in Community Health Centers (RCT)
Présentation de David W. Baker au colloque "Recherche interventionnelle contre le cancer : Réunir chercheurs, décideurs et acteurs de terrain » - 17 et 18 novembre 2014, BnF, Paris
Title: Sense of Smell
Presenter: Dr. Faiza, Assistant Professor of Physiology
Qualifications:
MBBS (Best Graduate, AIMC Lahore)
FCPS Physiology
ICMT, CHPE, DHPE (STMU)
MPH (GC University, Faisalabad)
MBA (Virtual University of Pakistan)
Learning Objectives:
Describe the primary categories of smells and the concept of odor blindness.
Explain the structure and location of the olfactory membrane and mucosa, including the types and roles of cells involved in olfaction.
Describe the pathway and mechanisms of olfactory signal transmission from the olfactory receptors to the brain.
Illustrate the biochemical cascade triggered by odorant binding to olfactory receptors, including the role of G-proteins and second messengers in generating an action potential.
Identify different types of olfactory disorders such as anosmia, hyposmia, hyperosmia, and dysosmia, including their potential causes.
Key Topics:
Olfactory Genes:
3% of the human genome accounts for olfactory genes.
400 genes for odorant receptors.
Olfactory Membrane:
Located in the superior part of the nasal cavity.
Medially: Folds downward along the superior septum.
Laterally: Folds over the superior turbinate and upper surface of the middle turbinate.
Total surface area: 5-10 square centimeters.
Olfactory Mucosa:
Olfactory Cells: Bipolar nerve cells derived from the CNS (100 million), with 4-25 olfactory cilia per cell.
Sustentacular Cells: Produce mucus and maintain ionic and molecular environment.
Basal Cells: Replace worn-out olfactory cells with an average lifespan of 1-2 months.
Bowman’s Gland: Secretes mucus.
Stimulation of Olfactory Cells:
Odorant dissolves in mucus and attaches to receptors on olfactory cilia.
Involves a cascade effect through G-proteins and second messengers, leading to depolarization and action potential generation in the olfactory nerve.
Quality of a Good Odorant:
Small (3-20 Carbon atoms), volatile, water-soluble, and lipid-soluble.
Facilitated by odorant-binding proteins in mucus.
Membrane Potential and Action Potential:
Resting membrane potential: -55mV.
Action potential frequency in the olfactory nerve increases with odorant strength.
Adaptation Towards the Sense of Smell:
Rapid adaptation within the first second, with further slow adaptation.
Psychological adaptation greater than receptor adaptation, involving feedback inhibition from the central nervous system.
Primary Sensations of Smell:
Camphoraceous, Musky, Floral, Pepperminty, Ethereal, Pungent, Putrid.
Odor Detection Threshold:
Examples: Hydrogen sulfide (0.0005 ppm), Methyl-mercaptan (0.002 ppm).
Some toxic substances are odorless at lethal concentrations.
Characteristics of Smell:
Odor blindness for single substances due to lack of appropriate receptor protein.
Behavioral and emotional influences of smell.
Transmission of Olfactory Signals:
From olfactory cells to glomeruli in the olfactory bulb, involving lateral inhibition.
Primitive, less old, and new olfactory systems with different path
micro teaching on communication m.sc nursing.pdfAnurag Sharma
Microteaching is a unique model of practice teaching. It is a viable instrument for the. desired change in the teaching behavior or the behavior potential which, in specified types of real. classroom situations, tends to facilitate the achievement of specified types of objectives.
The prostate is an exocrine gland of the male mammalian reproductive system
It is a walnut-sized gland that forms part of the male reproductive system and is located in front of the rectum and just below the urinary bladder
Function is to store and secrete a clear, slightly alkaline fluid that constitutes 10-30% of the volume of the seminal fluid that along with the spermatozoa, constitutes semen
A healthy human prostate measures (4cm-vertical, by 3cm-horizontal, 2cm ant-post ).
It surrounds the urethra just below the urinary bladder. It has anterior, median, posterior and two lateral lobes
It’s work is regulated by androgens which are responsible for male sex characteristics
Generalised disease of the prostate due to hormonal derangement which leads to non malignant enlargement of the gland (increase in the number of epithelial cells and stromal tissue)to cause compression of the urethra leading to symptoms (LUTS
These simplified slides by Dr. Sidra Arshad present an overview of the non-respiratory functions of the respiratory tract.
Learning objectives:
1. Enlist the non-respiratory functions of the respiratory tract
2. Briefly explain how these functions are carried out
3. Discuss the significance of dead space
4. Differentiate between minute ventilation and alveolar ventilation
5. Describe the cough and sneeze reflexes
Study Resources:
1. Chapter 39, Guyton and Hall Textbook of Medical Physiology, 14th edition
2. Chapter 34, Ganong’s Review of Medical Physiology, 26th edition
3. Chapter 17, Human Physiology by Lauralee Sherwood, 9th edition
4. Non-respiratory functions of the lungs https://academic.oup.com/bjaed/article/13/3/98/278874
These lecture slides, by Dr Sidra Arshad, offer a quick overview of physiological basis of a normal electrocardiogram.
Learning objectives:
1. Define an electrocardiogram (ECG) and electrocardiography
2. Describe how dipoles generated by the heart produce the waveforms of the ECG
3. Describe the components of a normal electrocardiogram of a typical bipolar leads (limb II)
4. Differentiate between intervals and segments
5. Enlist some common indications for obtaining an ECG
Study Resources:
1. Chapter 11, Guyton and Hall Textbook of Medical Physiology, 14th edition
2. Chapter 9, Human Physiology - From Cells to Systems, Lauralee Sherwood, 9th edition
3. Chapter 29, Ganong’s Review of Medical Physiology, 26th edition
4. Electrocardiogram, StatPearls - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK549803/
5. ECG in Medical Practice by ABM Abdullah, 4th edition
6. ECG Basics, http://www.nataliescasebook.com/tag/e-c-g-basics
Anti ulcer drugs and their Advance pharmacology ||
Anti-ulcer drugs are medications used to prevent and treat ulcers in the stomach and upper part of the small intestine (duodenal ulcers). These ulcers are often caused by an imbalance between stomach acid and the mucosal lining, which protects the stomach lining.
||Scope: Overview of various classes of anti-ulcer drugs, their mechanisms of action, indications, side effects, and clinical considerations.
Prix Galien International 2024 Forum ProgramLevi Shapiro
June 20, 2024, Prix Galien International and Jerusalem Ethics Forum in ROME. Detailed agenda including panels:
- ADVANCES IN CARDIOLOGY: A NEW PARADIGM IS COMING
- WOMEN’S HEALTH: FERTILITY PRESERVATION
- WHAT’S NEW IN THE TREATMENT OF INFECTIOUS,
ONCOLOGICAL AND INFLAMMATORY SKIN DISEASES?
- ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND ETHICS
- GENE THERAPY
- BEYOND BORDERS: GLOBAL INITIATIVES FOR DEMOCRATIZING LIFE SCIENCE TECHNOLOGIES AND PROMOTING ACCESS TO HEALTHCARE
- ETHICAL CHALLENGES IN LIFE SCIENCES
- Prix Galien International Awards Ceremony
Couples presenting to the infertility clinic- Do they really have infertility...Sujoy Dasgupta
Dr Sujoy Dasgupta presented the study on "Couples presenting to the infertility clinic- Do they really have infertility? – The unexplored stories of non-consummation" in the 13th Congress of the Asia Pacific Initiative on Reproduction (ASPIRE 2024) at Manila on 24 May, 2024.
Couples presenting to the infertility clinic- Do they really have infertility...
Pbf malawi preliminary_analysis
1. RBF4MNH Impact Evaluation –
Preliminary Findings
Presenters: Manuela De Allegri & Stephan Brenner
Study team: Adamson Muula, Don Mathanga, Jacob Mazalale,
Christabel Kambala, Julia Lohmann, Danielle Wilhelm,
Jobiba Chinkhumba, Bjarne Robberstad,
Till Baernighausen, Tom Bossert
1
2. Background
• Evidence available on impact of
Performance-Based Financing (PBF)
interventions on health service utilization
• Lack of comparable evidence on impact of
PBF on quality of care
2
4. The RBF4MNH intervention
• Funded by KfW and Norway
• Implemented by Malawi Ministry of Health with
technical support by Options
• Feasibility study completed by 2011
• Intervention launch 2012
• Active in 4 rural districts
• 17-28 Emergency Obstetric Care (EmOC) included
4
5. The RBF4MNH intervention
• Results-based financing intervention which
includes supply-side and demand-side incentives
• Preceded (and accompanied) by infrastructural
upgrade
• Supply-side: quantity and quality indicators
targeting labour and delivery services
• Demand-side: conditional cash transfers to
women upon delivering in health facility
5
6. Research question
What is the impact of a combination of supply-
side and demand-side PBF interventions on
quality of maternal care services?
Scope: ANC, delivery, early PNC, and early neonatal care
Focus: continuity of care around EmONC
Outcome: utilisation and quality indicators
6
7. vPROCESS OUTCOME
Provision of care
Experience of care
INPUT
MIXED METHODS APPROACH within framework of
CONTROLLED BEFORE & AFTER STUDY
Conceptual approach
7
8. Study design
• Controlled before and after study ...
• ... which evolved into a stepped wedge design
• Data from 33 EmOC facilities and their catchment
areas
• 18(23) intervention and 15(10) control
8
9. INPUT PROCESS OUTCOME
Infrastructural
assessment
Interviews with
healthcare
workers
Assessment
of clinical
records
Provider-
patient direct
observations
Exit interviews
Clinical records
Household
survey
Interviews with
healthcare
workers
Experience of care
FGD & in-depth interviews with all stakeholders
Provision of care
9
11. Household survey: methods
• Strategy: repeated cross-sectional: 2013 (baseline – BL),
2014 (midline – ML), 2015 (endline – EL)
• Objective: assess impact on health service utilization
• Sample: 2 Enumeration Areas (EA) from each facility
catchment area & 25 women with delivery in past 24
months within each EA; 4 EAs from second-level facilities
• Analysis: DID regression model accounting for clustering
at facility level and for covariates (age, literacy, wealth,
gravidity, SES, switch)
11
14. Household survey: results (3)
Means & DID estimates
BL mean
control
BL mean
interventi
on
EL mean
control
EL mean
interventi
on
DID BL-EL
DID BL-EL
est.
Sig.
ANC
ANC
utilization
96,2% 96,9% 98,7% 98,9% -0,005 -0,002 0,892
ANC in
first
trimester
15,1% 15,1% 22,2% 21,8% -0,005 0,013 0,770
ANC 4+
visits
44,1% 44,0% 52,4% 50,6% -0,017 0,046 0,419
Delivery
Delivery at
facility
91,4% 91,1% 96,7% 94,9% -0,015 -0,006 0,819
PNC
PNC
utilization
84,9% 81,9% 82,6% 75,7% -0,040 -0,016 0,811
Timley
PNC within
7 days
45,8% 42,0% 38,0% 35,6% 0,013 0,031 0,715
Timely
PNC with
6 weeks
83,3% 79,3% 83,2% 76,1% -0,031 -0,004 0,948
14
15. Household survey: results (4)
Control women using delivery services in
intervention facilities
BL EL
% %
Non-movers 84.1 77.6
Movers 15.9 22.4
Total 100.0 100.0
Bonferroni multiple comparison test p-value = 0.019
15
16. Health facility assessment: methods
• Strategy: repeated cross-sectional:
• BL – 2013, ML - 2014, EL - 2015
• Objective: assess impact on service
readiness for facility-based delivery
• Sample: full sample of all 28 health clinics
in intervention and control arms
• Analysis: DID regression model, accounting
for covariates (switch)
16
17. Definition service readiness
• Based on WHO SARA domains for facility-based
delivery:
• staff & training (2 indicators)
• equipment (10 indicators)
• medicines & commodities (6 indicators)
• Percentage of meeting basic service readiness
requirements
– Domain scores: mean availability of items per domain for each
facility in percent
– Readiness index: mean of domain scores for each facility in
percent
• DID: comparison of average scores and indices across
facilities in each study arm
17
18. Health facility assessment: results (1)
BASELINE MIDLINE ENDLINE
N % N % N %
Total sample: 26 100 26 100 28 100
Distribution by district:
Balaka 7 26.9 7 26.9 7 25.0
Dedza 5 19.3 5 19.3 6 21.4
Mchinji 7 26.9 7 26.9 7 25.0
Ntcheu 7 26.9 7 26.9 8 28.6
Distribution by study arm:
Control 13 50.0 12 46.2 10 35.7
Intervention 13 50.0 14 53.8 18 64.3
Sample distribution
19. Health facility assessment: results (2)
Average percentage service readiness & DID estimates
19
BL mean
control
BL mean
interventi
on
EL mean
control
EL mean
interventi
on
DID BL-EL
DID BL-EL
est.
Sig.
Staff & Training 96.2 % 69.2 % 85.0 % 86.1 % 28.0 % 27.8 % 0.07
Equipment 72.3 % 76.9 % 75.0 % 88.3 % 8.7 % 4.6 % 0.63
Medicines &
commodities
79.5 % 88.5 % 86.7 % 87.0 % -8.6 % -14.7 % 0.09
Service Readiness
Index
82.7 % 78.2 % 82.2 % 87.2 % 9.4 % 5.9 % 0.44
20. Clinical performance: methods
• Strategy: repeated cross-sectional:
• BL – 2013, ML - 2014, EL - 2015
• Objective: assess impact on clinical service
provision during facility-based delivery
• Sample: convenience sample of all non-
complicated labor cases at health clinics
during 5-day observation period
• Analysis: DID regression model accounting for
clustering at birth assistant level and for
covariates (time period between initial case
presentation and entry of stage 2, switch)
20
21. Definition clinical performance
• Observed performance measured against clinical
standards (IMPAC, national QA guidelines):
• Complete assessment eclampsia risk (5)
• Correct partograph use (7)
• Correct performance infection prevention (7)
• Correct performance AMTSL (5)
• Percentage of meeting routine care standards
– Performance scores: mean of observed routine care
processes per domain for each observed labor case
• DID: comparison of average performance scores
across birth assistants in each study arm
21
22. Clinical performance: results (1)
Sample distribution
BASELINE MIDLINE ENDLINE
N % N % N %
Total sample: 45 100 102 100 87 100
Distribution by district:
Balaka 11 24.5 26 25.5 22 25.3
Dedza 179 20.0 24 23.5 14 16.1
Mchinji 15 33.3 33 32.4 28 32.2
Ntcheu 10 22.2 19 18.6 23 26.4
Distribution by study arm:
Control 16 35.6 51 50.0 38 43.7
Intervention 29 64.4 51 50.0 49 56.3
23. Clinical performance: results (2)
Average percentage clinical performance & DID estimates
23
BL mean
control
BL mean
interventi
on
EL mean
control
EL mean
interventi
on
DID BL-EL
DID BL-EL
est.
Sig.
Eclampsia risk
assessment
31.3 % 19.3 % 31.1 % 40.9 % 21.7 % 35.3 % 0.01
Correct partograph
use
40.0 % 24.4 % 44.5 % 57.6 % 28.7 % 21.9 0.13
Infection prevention 50.9 % 51.2 % 54.0 % 72.3 % 18.0 % 27.8 % 0.05
AMTSL 66.3 % 77.9 % 91.1 % 94.8 % -8.0 % 14.4 % 0.18
24. Perception of care: methods
• Strategy: repeated cross-sectional:
• BL – 2013, ML - 2014, EL - 2015
• Objective: assess impact on client’s
experience of care delivered during labor
• Sample: convenience sample of women
exiting health clinics after facility-based
delivery
• Analysis: DID regression model accounting for
clustering at facility level and for covariates
(age, literacy, wealth, gravidity, SES, switch)
24
25. Definition satisfaction with care
• Satisfaction with aspects of care received:
• Interpersonal interaction with birth assistant (13)
• Technical performance of birth assistant (7)
• Structural/organizational set-up of labour service (11)
• Average satisfaction for each dimension
– satisfaction scores: lowest-highest satisfaction on 10-
point scale for each dimension
• DID: comparison of average 10-point satisfaction
scores across clients in each study arm
25
26. Perception of care: results (1)
Sample distribution
BASELINE MIDLINE ENDLINE
N % N % N %
Total sample: 203 100 333 100 230 100
Distribution by district:
Balaka 36 17.7 52 15.6 45 19.6
Dedza 64 31.5 100 30.0 52 22.6
Mchinji 59 29.1 103 30.9 76 33.0
Ntcheu 44 21.7 78 23.4 57 24.8
Distribution by study arm:
Control 67 33.0 109 32.7 40 17.4
Intervention 136 67.0 224 67.3 190 82.6
Distribution by level of care:
BEmOC 121 59.6 209 62.8 147 63.9
CEmOC 82 40.4 124 37.2 83 36.1
27. Perception of care: results (2)
Average satisfaction with care received & DID estimates
27
BL mean
control
BL mean
interventi
on
EL mean
control
EL mean
interventi
on
DID BL-EL
DID BL-EL
est.
Sig.
Satisfaction with
interpersonal
aspects
9.3 9.2 9.2 8.9 -0.2 -0.1 0.86
Satisfaction with
clinical/technical
aspects
9.4 9.3 9.4 9.1 -0.2 -0.1 0.69
Satisfaction with
organizational/
structural aspects
9.2 9.3 9.1 8.8 -0.4 -0.2 0.57
28. Conclusions
• No measurable effect on utilization of delivery services,
but important effect in redirecting demand/women’s
choice
• No effect on ANC and PNC services – need for incentives
that address the continuum of care?
• Weak effects on service readiness in spite of additional
input upgrades
• Strong effects on incentivized clinical tasks – no
measurable effect on non-incentivized tasks
• No measureable effect on client satisfaction – high
satisfaction independent of intervention, satisfaction
measures not sufficiently specific?
28