This paper involves an experimental investigation on the flexural behaviour of curved beams and comparison of its results with conventional beams. Curved beams of size 1200 x 150 x 100 mm with varying initial curvature as 4000mm, 2000mm and the concrete strength as M40 is considered. Various reinforcement are provided in the curved beams to predict which reinforcement detail would give more resistant over maximum loading. The material properties of cement, fine aggregate, coarse aggregate and the compressive strength of concrete cube were found out. A total of 12 specimens of curved beams were casted with various combination of reinforcement along with three control specimens. The beams are tested under two point loading both horizontally and vertically. The deflection and maximum moment carrying capacity are investigated to understand its strength. Also analytical modelling is done to determine the ultimate moment carrying capacity using Finite Element Software ABAQUS to compare with the experimental model.
Dynamic Analysis of Soft Storey Frame with IsolatorsIJMTST Journal
Soft storey buildings are very common in Indian housing construction and the bottom storey is left open without walls for car parking. Past earthquakes showed that these kinds of buildings performed poor and the damages are also heavy. As the base isolation is a technique developed to prevent or minimize damage to building during an earthquake, this study focuses on the time history analysis of a soft-storey building with and without lead rubber isolator. The soft-storey building with and without isolator is analysed using Elcenrto earthquake data and the dynamic characteristics are compared.
Seismic Vulnerability Assessment of Steel Moment Resisting Frame due to Infil...IDES Editor
Steel moment resisting frame with open first storey
(soft storey) is known to perform well compared with the RC
frames during strong earthquake shaking. The presence of
masonry infill wall influences the overall behavior of the
structure when subjected to lateral forces, when masonry infill
are considered to interact with their surrounding frames the
lateral stiffness and lateral load carrying capacity of structure
largely increase. In this paper, the seismic vulnerability of
building with soft storey is shown with an example of G+10
three dimensional (3D) steel frame. The open first storey is
an important functional requirement of almost all the urban
multi-storey buildings, and hence, cannot be eliminated.
Hence some special measures need to be adopted for this
specific situation. The under-lying principle of any solution
to this problem is in increasing the stiffness’s of the first
storey such that the first storey stiffness is at least 50% as
stiff as the second storey, i.e., soft first storeys are to be avoided,
and providing adequate lateral strength in the first storey. In
this paper, stiffness balancing is proposed between the first
and second storey of a steel moment resisting frame building
with open first storey and brick infills as described in models.
A simple example building is analyzed by modeling it with
nine different methods. The stiffness effect on the first storey
is demonstrated through the lateral displacement profile of
the building.
IJRET : International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology is an international peer reviewed, online journal published by eSAT Publishing House for the enhancement of research in various disciplines of Engineering and Technology. The aim and scope of the journal is to provide an academic medium and an important reference for the advancement and dissemination of research results that support high-level learning, teaching and research in the fields of Engineering and Technology. We bring together Scientists, Academician, Field Engineers, Scholars and Students of related fields of Engineering and Technology
This paper involves an experimental investigation on the flexural behaviour of curved beams and comparison of its results with conventional beams. Curved beams of size 1200 x 150 x 100 mm with varying initial curvature as 4000mm, 2000mm and the concrete strength as M40 is considered. Various reinforcement are provided in the curved beams to predict which reinforcement detail would give more resistant over maximum loading. The material properties of cement, fine aggregate, coarse aggregate and the compressive strength of concrete cube were found out. A total of 12 specimens of curved beams were casted with various combination of reinforcement along with three control specimens. The beams are tested under two point loading both horizontally and vertically. The deflection and maximum moment carrying capacity are investigated to understand its strength. Also analytical modelling is done to determine the ultimate moment carrying capacity using Finite Element Software ABAQUS to compare with the experimental model.
Dynamic Analysis of Soft Storey Frame with IsolatorsIJMTST Journal
Soft storey buildings are very common in Indian housing construction and the bottom storey is left open without walls for car parking. Past earthquakes showed that these kinds of buildings performed poor and the damages are also heavy. As the base isolation is a technique developed to prevent or minimize damage to building during an earthquake, this study focuses on the time history analysis of a soft-storey building with and without lead rubber isolator. The soft-storey building with and without isolator is analysed using Elcenrto earthquake data and the dynamic characteristics are compared.
Seismic Vulnerability Assessment of Steel Moment Resisting Frame due to Infil...IDES Editor
Steel moment resisting frame with open first storey
(soft storey) is known to perform well compared with the RC
frames during strong earthquake shaking. The presence of
masonry infill wall influences the overall behavior of the
structure when subjected to lateral forces, when masonry infill
are considered to interact with their surrounding frames the
lateral stiffness and lateral load carrying capacity of structure
largely increase. In this paper, the seismic vulnerability of
building with soft storey is shown with an example of G+10
three dimensional (3D) steel frame. The open first storey is
an important functional requirement of almost all the urban
multi-storey buildings, and hence, cannot be eliminated.
Hence some special measures need to be adopted for this
specific situation. The under-lying principle of any solution
to this problem is in increasing the stiffness’s of the first
storey such that the first storey stiffness is at least 50% as
stiff as the second storey, i.e., soft first storeys are to be avoided,
and providing adequate lateral strength in the first storey. In
this paper, stiffness balancing is proposed between the first
and second storey of a steel moment resisting frame building
with open first storey and brick infills as described in models.
A simple example building is analyzed by modeling it with
nine different methods. The stiffness effect on the first storey
is demonstrated through the lateral displacement profile of
the building.
IJRET : International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology is an international peer reviewed, online journal published by eSAT Publishing House for the enhancement of research in various disciplines of Engineering and Technology. The aim and scope of the journal is to provide an academic medium and an important reference for the advancement and dissemination of research results that support high-level learning, teaching and research in the fields of Engineering and Technology. We bring together Scientists, Academician, Field Engineers, Scholars and Students of related fields of Engineering and Technology
Effect of prism height on strength of reinforced hollow concrete block masonryeSAT Publishing House
IJRET : International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology is an international peer reviewed, online journal published by eSAT Publishing House for the enhancement of research in various disciplines of Engineering and Technology. The aim and scope of the journal is to provide an academic medium and an important reference for the advancement and dissemination of research results that support high-level learning, teaching and research in the fields of Engineering and Technology. We bring together Scientists, Academician, Field Engineers, Scholars and Students of related fields of Engineering and Technology.
This research devotes to conduct an investigation into the effects of lateral
reinforcement on the flexural behaviour of Straight Reinforced Concrete Beam
(SRCB). The amount of both longitudinal and lateral reinforcement, beam aspect ratio
(h/d) and shear span of concentrated load to depth ratio (a/d), are considered. The
experimental work includes casting and testing of fifteen SRCB of normal strength with
simple ends. The beams divided into three groups according to h/b ratio which taken
equal to (1.5, 2, and 2.5). The experimental results show that for SRCB with h/b equal
to 2 and under concentrated load at mid-span the ultimate load carrying capacity
increased by (30.8%, and 22.23%) when increasing the shear reinforcement by (50%,
and 100%) respectively. Also, the ultimate strength was increased by about 10.38%
and 16.53% with increment in shear reinforcement of 50%, and 100% respectively for
beams with h/b equal to 1.5 and under two-point load at third point. Finally, the results
appear not only increments in the capacity of ultimate load and decrement in the cracks
width when decreasing the shear reinforcement spacing but also the ductility of the
beams has increased observable.
Lateral Load Analysis of Shear Wall and Concrete Braced Multi-Storeyed R.C Fr...ijsrd.com
Generally RC framed structures are designed without regards to structural action of masonry infill walls present. Masonry infill walls are widely used as partitions. These buildings are generally designed as framed structures without regard to structural action of masonry infill walls. They are considered as non- structural elements. RC frame building with open first storey is known as soft storey, which performs poorly during strong earthquake shaking. Past earthquakes are evident that collapses due to soft storeys are most often in RC buildings. In the soft storey, columns are severely stressed and unable to provide adequate shear resistance during the earthquake. . In this study, 3D analytical model of twelve storeyed buildings have been generated for different buildings Models and analyzed using structural analysis tool 'ETABS'. To study the effect of infill, ground soft, bare frame and models with ground soft having concrete core wall and shear walls and concrete bracings at different positions during earthquake; seismic analysis using both linear static, linear dynamic (response spectrum method) has been performed. The analytical model of the building includes all important components that influence the mass, strength, stiffness and deformability of the structure.
IJERA (International journal of Engineering Research and Applications) is International online, ... peer reviewed journal. For more detail or submit your article, please visit www.ijera.com
Analysis of rc frame with and without masonry infill wall with different stif...eSAT Publishing House
IJRET : International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology is an international peer reviewed, online journal published by eSAT Publishing House for the enhancement of research in various disciplines of Engineering and Technology. The aim and scope of the journal is to provide an academic medium and an important reference for the advancement and dissemination of research results that support high-level learning, teaching and research in the fields of Engineering and Technology. We bring together Scientists, Academician, Field Engineers, Scholars and Students of related fields of Engineering and Technology.
MODELLING OF AN INFILL WALL FOR THE ANALYSIS OF A BUILDING FRAME SUBJECTED TO...IAEME Publication
In general the analysis of a building frame is carried out with a bare frame but the presence of masonry infill in a framed structure results in high stiffness and influence the distribution of lateral load and also the response of the framed buildings. It can be noted that there is a large variation of mechanical properties of bricks. Masonry, a combination of brick and mortar, behaves in a highly nonlinear manner. The infill panel needs to be modelled in the analysis of a structural frame subjected to lateral load to obtain its true behaviour. In order to model the masonry infill, its properties required. In order to determine the properties of brick masonry compression tests were conducted on masonry infill panels and prisms.
Experimental Evaluation of Fatigue Performance of Steel Grid Composite Deck J...IJERDJOURNAL
ABSTRACT:- The steel grid composite deck is a composite structure made of a concrete slab disposed over a steel grid. The joints of the deck segments precast with regular width can be designed by means of lap-spliced rebar or mechanical connection composed of concrete shear key and bolts. This study intends to evaluate comparatively the fatigue performance with respect to the type of joint based upon the results of fatigue tests conducted on deck specimens equipped with such joints. The evaluation reveals that there is practically no change in the stiffness regardless of the type of joint even after 2 million loading cycles and that the safety and serviceability are secured under cyclic loading since the maximum crack widths remained below the allowable values.
Analytical Study of Steel Fibre Reinforced Rigid Pavements under Static Loadijsrd.com
Nowadays, the application of steel fibers in concrete has increased gradually as an engineering material. The knowledge is not only necessary to provide safe, efficient and economic design for the present, but it also to serve as a rational basis for extended future applications. In this study, steel fibre reinforced rigid pavements are analyzed for stresses developed due to Static loads & temperature differentials. All the models are generated and analysis is carried out using the ANSYS software. Comparison of curling stresses in SFRC with conventional concrete is carried out. Parametric study for the effect of change in slab length & slab thickness of pavements on curling stresses is also done. Curling stresses due to Linear & Nonlinear temperature distribution in top & bottom layer of SFRC pavement slabs are also calculated. Frictional stresses in SFRC due to uniform temperature differential are almost same as conventional concrete. Analysis results shows, SFRC develops more stresses as compared to conventional concrete & nonlinear temperature distribution develops more stresses than linear temperature distribution. SFRC pavements are analyzed for Single axle static load for varied thickness and subgrade. Results reveal that the loading stresses are higher, when the load is at the edge region.
Effect of Caging and Swimmer Bars on Flexural Response of RC Deep BeamsIJERA Editor
Beams with shear span to depth ratio (a/d) less than or equal to 2 are considered as deep beams. They have wide
applications in pile caps, water tanks, shear walls, corbels etc. Their strength is controlled by shear. Swimmer
bars are small inclined bars, whose both ends are bent horizontally and welded to both top and bottom flexural
reinforcement. Swimmer bars forming a plane crack interceptor system is effective in carrying shear. Also, a
reinforcement caging provided at the centre of a simply supported beam is supposed to enhance its flexural
capacity. In this study, an experimental investigation on the flexural response of deep beams reinforced with
caging and swimmer bars is done. Various parameters like ultimate load, deflection and failure modes of
different reinforcement patterns are studied.
Under repeated impact composite domes subjected 6 J energy, changes locally with
increasing drop height. The action of the dynamic load generates reactions at the
support and bending moments at points on the surface of the composite. The peak loads
were noted to increase and stabilise about some mean value; and the 150mm diameter
shell was more damage tolerant compared to the 200 mm diameter one.
Effect of Coarse Aggregate Size on the Compressive Strength and the Flexural ...IJERA Editor
Concrete structures deflect, crack, and loose stiffness when subjected to external load. Loss of flexural strength of concrete is largely responsible for cracks in structure. In reinforced concrete structures, the mix proportions of the materials of the concrete and aggregate type determine the compressive strength while the composite action of concrete and steel reinforcement supplies the flexural strength. In occasion of loss of stiffness, steel reinforcement no longer supports flexural stresses; concrete in turn is subjected to flexure. The compressive strength and flexural strength therefore play a crucial role. Effect of varying coarse aggregate size on the flexural and compressive strengths of concrete beam was investigated. Concrete cubes and beams were produced in accordance with BS 1881-108 (1983) and ASTM C293 with varying aggregate sizes 9.0mm, 13.2mm, 19mm, 25.0mm and 37.5mm, using a standard mould of internal dimension 150x150x150 for the concrete cubes and a mould of internal dimension of 150 x 150 x 750mm for the reinforced concrete beam. The water cement ratio was kept at 0.65 with a mix proportion of 1:2:4. The specimen produced were all subjected to curing in water for 28days and were all tested to determine the compressive strength and flexural strength using Universal Testing Machine. Compressive strength of cubes is 21.26N/mm2, 23.41N/mm2, 23.66N/mm2, and 24.31N/mm2 for coarse aggregate sizes 13.2mm, 19mm, 25.0mm and 37.5mm respectively. That of flexural strength of test beams is 4.93N/mm2, 4.78N/mm2, 4.53N/mm2, 4.49N/mm2, 4.40N/mm2 respectively. In conclusion, concrete to be used mostly to resist flexural stresses should be made of finer coarse aggregates.
A Review of Masonry Buckling CharacteristicsIJERA Editor
Masonry load bearing wall subjected to vertical concentric and eccentric loading may collapse through instability. In this Paper the buckling behaviour of masonry load bearing wall of different slenderness ratio were investigated by many researcher has been reviewed via testing a series of scale masonry wall subjected to concentric and eccentric vertical loading. It is also observed that buckling behaviour is greatly influenced by the material properties of units, mortar and units-mortar interface. The influence of nonlinear behaviour of interface element, slenderness ratio and various end conditions have been investigated together with the effect of different end eccentricity of vertical load
Effect of prism height on strength of reinforced hollow concrete block masonryeSAT Publishing House
IJRET : International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology is an international peer reviewed, online journal published by eSAT Publishing House for the enhancement of research in various disciplines of Engineering and Technology. The aim and scope of the journal is to provide an academic medium and an important reference for the advancement and dissemination of research results that support high-level learning, teaching and research in the fields of Engineering and Technology. We bring together Scientists, Academician, Field Engineers, Scholars and Students of related fields of Engineering and Technology.
This research devotes to conduct an investigation into the effects of lateral
reinforcement on the flexural behaviour of Straight Reinforced Concrete Beam
(SRCB). The amount of both longitudinal and lateral reinforcement, beam aspect ratio
(h/d) and shear span of concentrated load to depth ratio (a/d), are considered. The
experimental work includes casting and testing of fifteen SRCB of normal strength with
simple ends. The beams divided into three groups according to h/b ratio which taken
equal to (1.5, 2, and 2.5). The experimental results show that for SRCB with h/b equal
to 2 and under concentrated load at mid-span the ultimate load carrying capacity
increased by (30.8%, and 22.23%) when increasing the shear reinforcement by (50%,
and 100%) respectively. Also, the ultimate strength was increased by about 10.38%
and 16.53% with increment in shear reinforcement of 50%, and 100% respectively for
beams with h/b equal to 1.5 and under two-point load at third point. Finally, the results
appear not only increments in the capacity of ultimate load and decrement in the cracks
width when decreasing the shear reinforcement spacing but also the ductility of the
beams has increased observable.
Lateral Load Analysis of Shear Wall and Concrete Braced Multi-Storeyed R.C Fr...ijsrd.com
Generally RC framed structures are designed without regards to structural action of masonry infill walls present. Masonry infill walls are widely used as partitions. These buildings are generally designed as framed structures without regard to structural action of masonry infill walls. They are considered as non- structural elements. RC frame building with open first storey is known as soft storey, which performs poorly during strong earthquake shaking. Past earthquakes are evident that collapses due to soft storeys are most often in RC buildings. In the soft storey, columns are severely stressed and unable to provide adequate shear resistance during the earthquake. . In this study, 3D analytical model of twelve storeyed buildings have been generated for different buildings Models and analyzed using structural analysis tool 'ETABS'. To study the effect of infill, ground soft, bare frame and models with ground soft having concrete core wall and shear walls and concrete bracings at different positions during earthquake; seismic analysis using both linear static, linear dynamic (response spectrum method) has been performed. The analytical model of the building includes all important components that influence the mass, strength, stiffness and deformability of the structure.
IJERA (International journal of Engineering Research and Applications) is International online, ... peer reviewed journal. For more detail or submit your article, please visit www.ijera.com
Analysis of rc frame with and without masonry infill wall with different stif...eSAT Publishing House
IJRET : International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology is an international peer reviewed, online journal published by eSAT Publishing House for the enhancement of research in various disciplines of Engineering and Technology. The aim and scope of the journal is to provide an academic medium and an important reference for the advancement and dissemination of research results that support high-level learning, teaching and research in the fields of Engineering and Technology. We bring together Scientists, Academician, Field Engineers, Scholars and Students of related fields of Engineering and Technology.
MODELLING OF AN INFILL WALL FOR THE ANALYSIS OF A BUILDING FRAME SUBJECTED TO...IAEME Publication
In general the analysis of a building frame is carried out with a bare frame but the presence of masonry infill in a framed structure results in high stiffness and influence the distribution of lateral load and also the response of the framed buildings. It can be noted that there is a large variation of mechanical properties of bricks. Masonry, a combination of brick and mortar, behaves in a highly nonlinear manner. The infill panel needs to be modelled in the analysis of a structural frame subjected to lateral load to obtain its true behaviour. In order to model the masonry infill, its properties required. In order to determine the properties of brick masonry compression tests were conducted on masonry infill panels and prisms.
Experimental Evaluation of Fatigue Performance of Steel Grid Composite Deck J...IJERDJOURNAL
ABSTRACT:- The steel grid composite deck is a composite structure made of a concrete slab disposed over a steel grid. The joints of the deck segments precast with regular width can be designed by means of lap-spliced rebar or mechanical connection composed of concrete shear key and bolts. This study intends to evaluate comparatively the fatigue performance with respect to the type of joint based upon the results of fatigue tests conducted on deck specimens equipped with such joints. The evaluation reveals that there is practically no change in the stiffness regardless of the type of joint even after 2 million loading cycles and that the safety and serviceability are secured under cyclic loading since the maximum crack widths remained below the allowable values.
Analytical Study of Steel Fibre Reinforced Rigid Pavements under Static Loadijsrd.com
Nowadays, the application of steel fibers in concrete has increased gradually as an engineering material. The knowledge is not only necessary to provide safe, efficient and economic design for the present, but it also to serve as a rational basis for extended future applications. In this study, steel fibre reinforced rigid pavements are analyzed for stresses developed due to Static loads & temperature differentials. All the models are generated and analysis is carried out using the ANSYS software. Comparison of curling stresses in SFRC with conventional concrete is carried out. Parametric study for the effect of change in slab length & slab thickness of pavements on curling stresses is also done. Curling stresses due to Linear & Nonlinear temperature distribution in top & bottom layer of SFRC pavement slabs are also calculated. Frictional stresses in SFRC due to uniform temperature differential are almost same as conventional concrete. Analysis results shows, SFRC develops more stresses as compared to conventional concrete & nonlinear temperature distribution develops more stresses than linear temperature distribution. SFRC pavements are analyzed for Single axle static load for varied thickness and subgrade. Results reveal that the loading stresses are higher, when the load is at the edge region.
Effect of Caging and Swimmer Bars on Flexural Response of RC Deep BeamsIJERA Editor
Beams with shear span to depth ratio (a/d) less than or equal to 2 are considered as deep beams. They have wide
applications in pile caps, water tanks, shear walls, corbels etc. Their strength is controlled by shear. Swimmer
bars are small inclined bars, whose both ends are bent horizontally and welded to both top and bottom flexural
reinforcement. Swimmer bars forming a plane crack interceptor system is effective in carrying shear. Also, a
reinforcement caging provided at the centre of a simply supported beam is supposed to enhance its flexural
capacity. In this study, an experimental investigation on the flexural response of deep beams reinforced with
caging and swimmer bars is done. Various parameters like ultimate load, deflection and failure modes of
different reinforcement patterns are studied.
Under repeated impact composite domes subjected 6 J energy, changes locally with
increasing drop height. The action of the dynamic load generates reactions at the
support and bending moments at points on the surface of the composite. The peak loads
were noted to increase and stabilise about some mean value; and the 150mm diameter
shell was more damage tolerant compared to the 200 mm diameter one.
Effect of Coarse Aggregate Size on the Compressive Strength and the Flexural ...IJERA Editor
Concrete structures deflect, crack, and loose stiffness when subjected to external load. Loss of flexural strength of concrete is largely responsible for cracks in structure. In reinforced concrete structures, the mix proportions of the materials of the concrete and aggregate type determine the compressive strength while the composite action of concrete and steel reinforcement supplies the flexural strength. In occasion of loss of stiffness, steel reinforcement no longer supports flexural stresses; concrete in turn is subjected to flexure. The compressive strength and flexural strength therefore play a crucial role. Effect of varying coarse aggregate size on the flexural and compressive strengths of concrete beam was investigated. Concrete cubes and beams were produced in accordance with BS 1881-108 (1983) and ASTM C293 with varying aggregate sizes 9.0mm, 13.2mm, 19mm, 25.0mm and 37.5mm, using a standard mould of internal dimension 150x150x150 for the concrete cubes and a mould of internal dimension of 150 x 150 x 750mm for the reinforced concrete beam. The water cement ratio was kept at 0.65 with a mix proportion of 1:2:4. The specimen produced were all subjected to curing in water for 28days and were all tested to determine the compressive strength and flexural strength using Universal Testing Machine. Compressive strength of cubes is 21.26N/mm2, 23.41N/mm2, 23.66N/mm2, and 24.31N/mm2 for coarse aggregate sizes 13.2mm, 19mm, 25.0mm and 37.5mm respectively. That of flexural strength of test beams is 4.93N/mm2, 4.78N/mm2, 4.53N/mm2, 4.49N/mm2, 4.40N/mm2 respectively. In conclusion, concrete to be used mostly to resist flexural stresses should be made of finer coarse aggregates.
A Review of Masonry Buckling CharacteristicsIJERA Editor
Masonry load bearing wall subjected to vertical concentric and eccentric loading may collapse through instability. In this Paper the buckling behaviour of masonry load bearing wall of different slenderness ratio were investigated by many researcher has been reviewed via testing a series of scale masonry wall subjected to concentric and eccentric vertical loading. It is also observed that buckling behaviour is greatly influenced by the material properties of units, mortar and units-mortar interface. The influence of nonlinear behaviour of interface element, slenderness ratio and various end conditions have been investigated together with the effect of different end eccentricity of vertical load
Literature Review of Experimental Study on Load Bearing Masonry WallIOSRJMCE
Masonry load bearing wall subjected to vertical concentric and eccentric loading may collapse through instability. In this Paper the buckling behavior of masonry load bearing wall of different slenderness ratio were investigated by many researcher has been reviewed via testing a series of scale masonry wall subjected to concentric and eccentric vertical loading. The influence of nonlinear behavior of interface element, slenderness ratio and various end conditions have been investigated together with the effect of different end eccentricity of vertical load.
EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATIONS ON COMPRESSION BEHAVIOR PARAMETERS OF NSC AND SC...IAEME Publication
A total of six intermediate columns with same cross sectional area of 125mm X 125mm were cast and tested. Experimental study was conducted to know the behavior of intermediate columns under axial load made out of Normal strength concrete (NSC) and Self-compacting concrete (SCC). Main objective of this study was to compare the behavior of NSC intermediate columns and SCC intermediate columns for various percentage of steel. Axial load ratio, stiffness ratio were the main parameters which increased as the axial load increased. However in this study, special attention was given on stiffness degradation, energy absorption, ultimate load carrying capacity, shortening index of each intermediate column. The results showed that shortening index, axial load ratio, stiffness ratio and stiffness degradation increased with increase in axial load.
Influence of reinforcement on the behavior of hollow concrete block masonry p...eSAT Journals
Abstract
Reinforced masonry was developed to exploit the strength potential of masonry and to solve its lack of tensile strength. Experimental
and analytical studies have been carried out to investigate the effect of reinforcement on the behavior of hollow concrete block
masonry prisms under compression and to predict ultimate failure compressive strength. In the numerical program, three dimensional
non-linear finite elements (FE) model based on the micro-modeling approach is developed for both unreinforced and reinforced
masonry prisms using ANSYS (14.5). The proposed FE model uses multi-linear stress-strain relationships to model the non-linear
behavior of hollow concrete block, mortar, and grout. Willam-Warnke’s five parameter failure theory has been adopted to model the
failure of masonry materials. The comparison of the numerical and experimental results indicates that the FE models can successfully
capture the highly nonlinear behavior of the physical specimens and accurately predict their strength and failure mechanisms.
Keywords: Structural masonry, Hollow concrete block prism, grout, Compression failure, Finite element method,
Numerical modeling.
Influence of reinforcement on the behavior of hollow concrete block masonry p...eSAT Journals
Abstract
Reinforced masonry was developed to exploit the strength potential of masonry and to solve its lack of tensile strength. Experimental
and analytical studies have been carried out to investigate the effect of reinforcement on the behavior of hollow concrete block
masonry prisms under compression and to predict ultimate failure compressive strength. In the numerical program, three dimensional
non-linear finite elements (FE) model based on the micro-modeling approach is developed for both unreinforced and reinforced
masonry prisms using ANSYS (14.5). The proposed FE model uses multi-linear stress-strain relationships to model the non-linear
behavior of hollow concrete block, mortar, and grout. Willam-Warnke’s five parameter failure theory has been adopted to model the
failure of masonry materials. The comparison of the numerical and experimental results indicates that the FE models can successfully
capture the highly nonlinear behavior of the physical specimens and accurately predict their strength and failure mechanisms.
Keywords: Structural masonry, Hollow concrete block prism, grout, Compression failure, Finite element method,
Numerical modeling.
“Strengthening Of PCC Beams by Using Different Types of Wire Mesh Jacketing”IJMER
This paper presents the effect of the use of different types of wire mesh jacketing to the PCC
beams. The experimental work is mainly concerned with the study of flexural strength of concrete by
different types of wire mesh jacketing. This study brings out the importance of use of strengthening of
existing structure technology by using locally available wire mesh. In this paper, the beams of plain
cement concrete are bonded with locally available wire mesh to strengthen of structural member for
increase its strength. The method mention in this paper is most suited for strengthening and retrofitting
due to their easy availability, economy and their property of being cast to any shape without needing
significant formwork.
Lateral Load Analysis of Shear Wall and Concrete Braced Multi-Storeyed R.C Fr...ijsrd.com
Generally RC framed structures are designed without regards to structural action of masonry infill walls present. Masonry infill walls are widely used as partitions. These buildings are generally designed as framed structures without regard to structural action of masonry infill walls. They are considered as non- structural elements. RC frame building with open first storey is known as soft storey, which performs poorly during strong earthquake shaking. Past earthquakes are evident that collapses due to soft storeys are most often in RC buildings. In the soft storey, columns are severely stressed and unable to provide adequate shear resistance during the earthquake. . In this study, 3D analytical model of twelve storeyed buildings have been generated for different buildings Models and analyzed using structural analysis tool 'ETABS'. To study the effect of infill, ground soft, bare frame and models with ground soft having concrete core wall and shear walls and concrete bracings at different positions during earthquake; seismic analysis using both linear static, linear dynamic (response spectrum method) has been performed. The analytical model of the building includes all important components that influence the mass, strength, stiffness and deformability of the structure.
Retrofitting Of Reinforced Concrete Column by Steel JacketingIJERA Editor
Reinforced concrete structures often require strengthening to increase their capacity to sustain additional loads,
due to change in use that resulted in additional live loads, deterioration of the load carrying elements, design
errors, construction problems during erection, aging of structure itself or upgrading to confirm to current code
requirements. These situations may require additional concrete elements or the entire concrete structure to be
strengthened, repaired or retrofitted. Common methods for strengthening columns include concrete jacketing,
fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) jacketing and steel jacketing. All these methods have been shown to effectively
increase the axial load capacity of columns.
The experimental study was carried out on RC column on designed and detailed using IS 456:2000 provisions.
The concrete mix design being performed after conducting numerous material test and cube test to validate
expected strength as per specified grade of concrete. The trial testing conducted to estimate load at 1st crack and
failure load for normal RC column with capturing displacement using dial gauges at regular load increment in
UTM. The loading conditions are decided based on failure load to induce cracks in column under 85% loading
of the failure one. In all fifteen specimen casted and tested with three samples for failure load estimation, three
samples each for plate jacketing & angle battening system and three samples each for plate jacketing & angle
battening with column preloaded to 85% of its failure load. The angle batten system proves to be better
compared to full plate retrofitting in terms of load carrying capacity and enhancing confinement effect.
2. Experimental shear testing of unreinforced masonry
wall panels
2016 NZSEE
Conference
H. Qiu, R. Chin, J. Ingham, and D. Dizhur
The University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand
ABSTRACT: An experimental program was undertaken with the principal aim of
determining the transition point between the stair-step failure mode and diagonal tension
failure mode of eight 1200 mm x 1200 mm URM wall panels when subjected to
simulated earthquake lateral loads. Preparations included the formulation of mortar
compositions and then subsequent pairing with bricks of varying strengths to replicate the
range of material characteristics of existing URM structures found throughout New
Zealand. Diagonal shear tests were conducted with experimental results indicating two
distinct failure mechanisms. It was concluded that the transition between failure modes
occurs when the mortar to brick compressive strength ratio is approximately 0.4. In
addition, following the failure of the wall panels, three panels were repaired using 8 mm
steel wire rope placed in differing orientations and quantities in order to investigate the
feasibility and performance of this repair technique. Steel wire rope proved to be a simple
and cost effective remediation method with improvements in diagonal shear strength and
displacement capacity of up to double and fifty times respectively that of the as-built
counterparts.
1 INTRODUCTION
According to Magenes and Calvi (1997) the in-plane failure modes of unreinforced masonry (URM)
piers can be categorised as either: rocking, diagonal shear, or bed joint sliding. Rocking and bed joint
sliding types of failure modes typically allow for the dispersion of energy in cycles through
displacement. Comparatively, diagonal shear failures are typically more critical and may be relatively
more brittle in nature. Diagonal shear failure may develop as one of two failure mechanisms (see
Figure 1), as cracks may either develop through both brick units and mortar joints or through the
mortar joints alone in a stepping pattern depending on the ratio between mortar and brick strengths
(Dizhur & Ingham, 2013).
Failure through both brick units and mortar joints is recognised as being relatively brittle in nature, as
the shear strength capacity of the wall deteriorates heavily after the maximum shear stress has been
achieved. In the NZSEE (2015) assessment guidelines, URM pier diagonal tension failure modes that
are dominated by brick splitting correspond to a force reduction factor, KR of 1.0. In contrast, stair-
stepped failure though the mortar bed and head joints creates multiple sliding planes analogous to the
bed joint shear sliding failure mode, where additional energy from seismic forces can be subsequently
dispersed through sliding. In the NZSEE (2015) assessment guidelines, the stair-step failure mode in
URM piers corresponds to a force reduction factor, KR of 3.0. When calculating the URM spandrel
capacity in Section 10.8.6.3 (NZSEE, 2015), it is also important to be able to distinguish between
stair-step failure modes and diagonal tension failure modes that are dominated by brick splitting, see
Figure 1. Consequently, determining the transition point between the two mechanisms of diagonal
shear failure is paramount for understanding the behaviour of URM piers and spandrels subjected to
in-plane loading.
Currently limited guidance is provided in the NZSEE (2015) document on distinguishing the
occurrence of the two failure mechanisms. This information would allow engineers to more accurately
assess the seismic vulnerability and shear capacity URM buildings. The experimental program
reported herein was undertaken to address and attempt to provide such valuable information for
3. inclusion in a future revision of the NZSEE (2015) document.
(a) Cracking through
mortar joints only - stair-
step failure
(Kathmandu, Nepal 2015)
(b) Cracking through bricks
and mortar joints
(Christchurch 2011)
(c) Cracking mainly through
bricks - diagonal tension
failure
(Christchurch 2011)
Figure 1. Diagonal shear cracking observed following earthquakes for different wall piers with
different brick to mortar strength ratios
Many URM buildings that were damaged in past earthquakes have been demolished due to a lack of
viable repair options being available, resulting in the loss of building heritage (Moon et al., 2013).
Repair techniques must ensure that the strength of the original building is restored, and that the
remediated building is able to resist forces which may arise from future earthquakes. Near Surface
Mounted (NSM) techniques have previously been proven to be cost-effective with minimal visual
impact, whilst providing protection from environmental impacts (Dizhur et al. 2013). Given the
opportunity to test the viability of remediated wall panels, an additional pilot study was conducted
where the use of NSM Steel Wire Rope (SWR) as a repair technique was explored. As a relatively
inexpensive material with a large surface area for adhesion and a high tensile capacity, SWR has
strength properties comparable to those of Carbon Fibre Reinforced Polymer (CFRP) strips, which
have previously been demonstrated to be successful as a retrofit and/or repair technique for URM
walls (Dizhur et al. 2013).
2 EXPERIMENTAL SET UP
2.1 Materials
Eight URM wall panels were constructed using mortar and solid clay brick units of varying
compressive strengths in order to replicate the material characteristics of vintage URM buildings
found throughout New Zealand. Based on Almesfer et al. (2014), where a wide range of mortar
compressive strengths found in URM buildings was reported, eight different compositions of mortar
were fabricated by changing the ratio of cement, lime and sand as shown in Table 1. Recycled vintage
solid clay bricks were sourced from multiple demolition sites throughout Auckland, with the strengths
estimated on-site by performing a scratch test [as reported in Almesfer et al. (2014)] before being
paired with an appropriate mortar composition in order to construct wall panels with a wide spectrum
of brick to mortar strength ratios.
The compressive strength of individual bricks (f’b) was tested using the half brick compression test
according to ASTM (2003a), while the compressive strength of each mortar composition (f’j) was
determined by loading 50 mm cubes in compression as per ASTM (2008). Masonry prisms (f’m) were
also tested according to ASTM (2003b).
4. Two-leaf thick URM wall panels with approximate dimensions of 1200 mm x 1200 mm were
constructed using the common bond pattern as per ASTM (2010). Once construction was completed,
the mortar was allowed to cure for a minimum of 28 days before tests were conducted. Once the wall
panels were tested in the as-built condition, repairs were carried out using NSM SWR (see Figure 2a).
The diameter of wire was chosen to be 8 mm based on the thickness of the mortar joints and
preliminary pull-out test results. Preliminary pull-out tests (Figure 2b) were conducted to test the bond
strength between SWR and masonry with the results being compared to NSM CFRP retrofits and
repairs that were reported by Dizhur et al. (2013). The NSM SWR reached 30 kN in direct pull-out
(85% of the capacity of CFRP) and exhibited a higher nominal ductility when compared to the
behaviour of CFRP strips (Figure 2c).
Table 1. Material properties
Wall Mortar Mix Mortar Strength Brick Strength Masonry Strength
(cement:lime:sand) f'j (MPa) Samples COV f'b(MPa) Samples COV f'm(MPa) Samples COV
W1 1:2:15 1.19 5 0.05 9.59 3 0.16 4.05 1 n/a
W2 1:3:15 2.19 5 0.13 8.41 4 0.17 4.73 2 0.13
W3 1:2:9 3.35 5 0.08 8.34 5 0.15 4.09 3 0.25
W4 1:1:10 2.11 5 0.14 7.23 4 0.21 6.49 3 0.77
W5 1:1:8 4.07 5 0.07 9.59 4 0.17 6.88 2 0.24
W6 1:0:6 5.91 5 0.12 13.02 3 0.35 7.50 2 0.55
W7 1:1:6 6.55 5 0.06 13.02 3 0.35 8.76 1 n/a
W8 1:1:6 6.55 5 0.10 8.81 4 0.45 4.71 2 0.08
Note: COV = coefficient of variance, n/a = not applicable
(a) Steel wire rope (SWR) (b) Pull-out test set-up (c) Pull-out test results
Figure 2. SWR used in repair and preliminary pull-out test results
2.2 Diagonal Shear Test Set-up
The test method utilised in this series of experiments was a reapplication of that adopted by Dizhur &
Ingham (2013), which is a variation of the test set-up outlined in ASTM (2010). The wall panels were
tested horizontally instead of at a 45o
angle, in order to prevent the premature cracking of weaker
mortar compositions while the wall panels were being rotated. In this variation of the standard test,
custom designed and fabricated loading shoes were placed on diagonally opposite corners of each
specimen and connected by two 30 mm steel tension rods. A hydraulic jack, load cell and a
rectangular steel channel were placed on the top loading shoe, as shown in Figure 3. A diagonal
compression force was applied through the hydraulic jack and continuously increased until a
significant drop in load was registered by a load cell, indicating that the wall panel had failed. Two
portal strain gauges were attached diagonally on both sides of each wall panel to measure
displacements arising from tension and compression, which were then converted to a percentage of
lateral drift.
0
10
20
30
40
0 5 10 15
Load(kN)
Displacement (mm)
CFRP
SWR
5. (a) Schematic of the test set-up showing
individual components
(b) Photograph of a typical test set-up
Figure 3. Test set-up
2.3 Repair Procedure
Once the wall panels had undergone diagonal shear failure, wall panels W1, W3 and W5 were repaired
using SWR. Grooves measuring 15 mm x 15 mm were cut into the faces of the wall panels using a
circular saw. Each wall panel was repaired using a configuration of the SWR, see Figure 4. Grooves
and the SWR were thoroughly cleaned with compressed air and acetone to remove any dust and oil
based lubricants. Two-part epoxy was then applied into the groves followed by the insertion of the
SWR. The epoxy was left to cure for at least 3 days prior to testing in order to reach a minimum of
90% of full strength (Sika, 2015).
W1 W3 W5
Figure 4. Layout of NSM SWR in repaired wall panels (also showing cracking in light grey that was
observed following testing of repaired wall panels)
3 RESULTS
3.1 Failure Mechanisms of As-Built Wall Panels
The diagonal shear failure mechanisms observed from the series of eight diagonal shear tests were
consistent with those reported previously (Dizhur & Ingham, 2013; Russell, 2010 and others).
Generally, wall panels constructed with low mortar to brick strength ratios (f’j/f’b) failed through
mortar joints only, whereas wall panels constructed with relatively higher mortar to brick strength
ratios underwent failure by cracking through both mortar joints and brick units.
It was observed that wall panels W1, W2 and W3, which were constructed with relatively low mortar
to brick compressive strength ratios (f’j/f’b), failed as a result of cracking through the mortar joints as
shown in Figure 5a. The cracking occurred in a stepping pattern around the brick units, with the
bricks remaining visually undamaged. When the peak shear stress for each wall panel was actualised,
the wall panels experienced a reduction in load carrying capacity while cracks began to form in the
stepping pattern. Upon further loading, sliding failure was induced as the interface between cracks
began to slide past one another. Similar behaviour was reported by Dizhur & Ingham (2013).
Due to suspected poor construction, the behaviour of W4 was predominately governed by bed-joint
6. sliding failure as opposed to diagonal shear, as shown by Figure 5b. The wall panel was constructed
with a slight out-of-plane curvature which resulted in an uneven stress distribution when diagonal
compression was applied. Therefore, upon loading in diagonal compression, the cracked upper section
of the wall panel began to slide horizontally, as exemplified in Table 2. The maximum load occurred
at 1.28% drift, which was substantially higher than for the wall panels which failed in a diagonal shear
mode.
Wall panels W5-W8 had significantly higher ratios of mortar to brick compressive strength (f’j/f’b)
than W1-W4. As a result, diagonal shear failure occurred through a combination of both mortar joints
and brick units, with the number of cracked bricks increasing with an increasing mortar to brick
compressive strength ratio, as shown in Figure 6. This particular failure mechanism was of an
explosive nature, as energy was rapidly released in the form of sound and displacement. Upon failure,
wall panels W5-W8 lost almost all of their lateral load carrying capacity. Figure 5c shows the failure
which occurred for W7, where the upper half of the wall panel was dislodged upon cracking.
(a) Cracking through
mortar (W1)
(b) Sliding failure (W4)
(c) Cracking through
bricks and mortar,
explosive in nature
(W7)
(d) Lack of adhesion
between mortar and
brick interface
(W6)
Figure 5. Observed failure mechanisms (cracks outlined for clarity)
W1 W2 W3 W4
W5 W6 W7 W8
Figure 6. Crack patterns of as-built wall panels
Apart from cracking failure through mortar and brick units, wall panels W6 and W8 also experienced
failure due to a lack of adhesion between brick units and mortar joints at several interfaces, as shown
in Figure 5d. This behaviour was exhibited by clean surfaces on bricks where mortar had been
completely separated. As the walls were built using recycled bricks, the pores on numerous bricks
were filled from previous use. Because the bricks for W6 and W8 were not cleaned adequately, mortar
was unable to adhere sufficiently which resulted in premature failure.
7. 3.2 Failure of Repaired Walls
In wall panels W1, W3 and W5, cracks propagated predominantly through mortar, whilst
simultaneously enlarging pre-existing cracks. For the wall panels (W1 and W5) repaired with
vertically oriented SWR, the load appeared to be resisted by shear friction between the faces of the
original cracks as the cracks began to slowly dilate. New diagonally stepped cracks formed shortly
thereafter (see Figure 7). When the load-time graph began to plateau, the SWR and epoxy were
engaged. Upon the onset of strength loss, the epoxy began to crack, thus exhibiting sequential failure
modes. Hence, the vertically repaired wall panels initially failed in diagonal shear followed by sliding
shear. W3 showed minimal change in crack pattern as it experienced localized crushing of the bricks
directly adjacent to the loading shoes. The epoxy and SWR that resisted the shear stress assisted in
restricting further dilation along the as-built failure planes.
(a) Significant lateral
deformation of repaired W1
following testing
(b) Close up of NSM SWR
repair following partial
demolition of W5
Figure 7. Crack pattern observations for repaired wall panels
3.3 Shear Stress – Drift Response
3.3.1 As-built wall panels
According to ASTM (2010), URM walls fail through diagonal cracking when the applied diagonal
shear stress (τs) exceeds the diagonal tension strength of masonry (fdt). Under the assumption that the
specimen experiences pure shear and that shear stress is uniformly distributed throughout the section,
ASTM (2010) implies that the diagonal tension strength (fdt) can be calculated by the following
equation, where P is the force applied in diagonal compression and An is the area of the mortared
section:
(1)
The diagonal shear capacity (Vdt) of URM walls has been provided by NZSEE (2015) as an important
check for practicing structural engineers, where it represents a horizontal force which acts at the
top of the wall. As a comparison with the ultimate shear stress, the shear force capacity of URM walls
is calculated using Equation 2 below, where β is a factor for correcting the nonlinear stress distribution
and fa is the axial compression due to gravity loads.
√ (2)
8. 0 50 100
0
100
200
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0 0.5 1
0 5 10
0
100
200
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0 0.5 1
0 5 10
0
100
200
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0 0.5 1
Table 2. Experimental results for as-built wall panels
Wall
Mortar
(C:L:S)
f'j/f'b P (kN)
τs
(MPa)
Vdt
(KN)
Drift (%)
G
(GPa)
E
(GPa)
Failure Type
W1 1:2:15 0.14 62.9 0.16 37.4 0.14 0.29 0.72 Mortar
W2 1:3:12 0.26 69.9 0.16 36.7 0.45 0.07 0.17 Mortar
W3 1:2:9 0.40 95.0 0.24 58.3 0.42 0.11 0.27 Mortar
W4 1:1:10 0.29 56.9 0.15 35.7 1.28 0.06 0.14 Sliding
W5 1:1:8 0.42 115.9 0.31 71.2 0.47 0.15 0.38 Mortar/Brick
W6 1:0:6 0.45 188.5 0.49 113.5 0.26 0.52 1.31 Mortar/Brick
W7 1:1:6 0.50 257.7 0.67 154.4 0.43 0.33 0.84 Mortar/Brick
W8 1:1:6 0.74 158.5 0.39 96.0 0.34 0.42 1.04 Mortar/Brick
.
3.3.2 Repaired Wall Panels
Wall panels W1 and W3, which were both repaired using six steel ropes, experienced increased load
carrying capacities. Ultimate loads increased from 63 kN to 86 kN and from 46 kN to 96 kN
respectively, while the maximum drift for both walls was significantly increased. This improved
capacity was due to the dissipation of energy through friction in the mortar bed joints being resisted by
the SWR in tension. Shear stress (τs) and drift were plotted to a maximum of 3% drift to emphasize the
0 5 10
0
100
200
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0 0.5 1
0 5 10
0
100
200
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0 0.5 1
0 5 10
0
100
200
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0 0.5 1
0 5 10
0
100
200
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0 0.5 1
0 5 10
0
100
200
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0 0.5 1
Figure 8. Shear stress - drift response of tested as-built wall panels
Wall 1
Shear Strain (γx1000)
Stress(MPa)
Load(kN)
Drift (%)
Wall 2
Shear Strain (γx1000)
Stress(MPa)
Load(kN)
Drift (%)
Wall 3
Shear Strain (γx1000)
Stress(MPa)
Load(kN)
Drift (%)
Wall 5
Stress(MPa)
Load(kN)
Drift (%)
Shear Strain (γx1000)
Wall 4
Stress(MPa)
Load(kN)
Drift (%)
Shear Strain (γx1000)
Wall 6
Shear Strain (γx1000)
Stress(MPa)
Load(kN)
Drift (%)
Wall 7
Shear Strain (γx1000)
Stress(MPa)
Load(kN)
Drift (%)
Wall 8
Stress(MPa)
Load(kN)
Drift (%)
Shear Strain (γx1000)
9. increase in the initial loading stages relative to the as-built counterparts, as shown in Figure 9.
However, the portal gauges for W3 malfunctioned mid-test resulting in an unreliable result for drift.
For W1 and W5, drift responses of the repaired walls showed a 50 times and 2 times increase
compared to their as-built state. W5, despite showing a drift increase 2 times that of its original,
exhibited a strength reduction of approximately 50%. It is recommended that more tests be conducted
to establish whether there is possibly a linear relationship relating the number of vertical SWR and
shear strength.
Table 3. Experimental results for repaired wall panels
Wall P (kN) τs (MPa) Drift (%) G (GPa) E (GPa)
W1 85.8 0.23 6.87 0.01 0.02
W3 45.7 0.12 1.97 0.02 0.04
W5 226.6 0.61 0.18 1.68 4.21
Figure 9. Shear stress - drift response of tested repaired wall panels
3.4 Distinction Between Diagonal Shear Failure Mechanisms
A transition point was established between cracking through mortar and cracking through both bricks
and mortar joints for the tested wall panels. By examining the failure mechanisms in the series of
diagonal shear tests as well as the tests conducted by previous researchers as shown in Table 4, a
demarcation was identified when the mortar to brick strength ratio (f’j/f’b) was equal to approximately
0.4, as shown in Figure 10. It was observed that as-built walls constructed using mortar to brick
strength ratios of less than 0.4 failed through mortar joints alone. Comparatively, walls built with
mortar to brick strength ratios of above 0.4 experienced failures through both bricks and mortar joints.
Aside from the premature failure of W4 and W8 due to lack of adhesion, it was observed that more
bricks were cracked when the ratio was increased. This diagonal tension failure mode was more
explosive as the upper failure plane displaced significantly after the ultimate shear stress was reached.
Based on the reported results, it is suggested that Table 10.14: Recommended force reduction factors
for linear static method of NZSEE (2015) can be updated where a distinction between stair-step failure
modes (force reduction factor, KR equals to 3 when f’j/f’b ≤ 0.4) and pier diagonal tension failure
modes (dominated by brick splitting, KR equals to 1 when f’j/f’b ≥ 0.4) can now be quantified.
Section 10.8 of NZSEE (2015) can be updated in regards to the peak shear strength of URM spandrels.
It is recommended that Equation 10.47 is to be used when f’j/f’b ≤ 0.4, and otherwise Equation 10.48
should be used.
0 10 20 30
0
100
200
0
0.3
0.6
0 1 2 3
0 10 20 30
0
100
200
0
0.3
0.6
0 1 2 3
As-built
Repaired
Wall 1
Shear Strain (γx1000)
Stress(MPa)
Load(kN)
Drift (%)
Wall 3
Shear Strain (γx1000)
Stress(MPa)
Load(kN)
Drift (%)
Wall 5
Shear Strain (γx1000)
Stress(MPa)
Load(kN)
Drift (%)
0 10 20 30
0
100
200
0
0.3
0.6
0 1 2 3
10. Table 4. Previously conducted diagonal shear tests of wall panels
* - Compressive strength recommended by ASTM C 270 - 08a (2008a), Mortar mix - cement:lime:sand ratio by
volume; f’j – mortar compression strength; f'b – brick compression strength; νmax – maximum shear stress;
Figure 10. Demarcation between diagonal shear failure mechanisms (data from Table 2 and
Table 4 with W4 and W8 excluded)
3.5 Relationship between Maximum Shear Stress and Mortar Strength
It has previously been reported that as mortar compressive strength increases, the diagonal shear
strength of URM walls also increases proportionally. As reported by Dizhur and Ingham (2013),
results obtained by previous researchers as shown in Table 4 were found to have a relationship where
the maximum diagonal shear stress of URM wall panels is estimated to be 0.1 of the mortar
compressive strength with a statistical R2
value of 0.76. When the results from this experiment in
Tables 1 and 2 are plotted alongside the results obtained by previous researchers as shown in Table 4,
it is evident that there is an approximately linear correlation between the maximum diagonal shear
stress and the mortar compressive strength. As shown by Figure 11, the maximum diagonal shear
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
0.00 0.10 0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80
ShearStressτs(MPa)
f'j/f'b
Failure through mortar Failure through brick/mortar
Wall
panel
Mortar
mix
f’j
(MPa)
f’b
(MPa)
f'j/f'b
νmax
(MPa)
Failure
Type
Russell (2010) AP1 2:1:9 12.4*
23.3 0.53 0.71 Brick/mortar
AP3 0:1:3 1.1 24.3 0.05 0.06 Mortar
AP6 1:2:9 2.6 23.6 0.11 0.14 Mortar
AP7 1:2:9 2.3 20.4 0.11 0.13 Mortar
AP8 1:2:9 2.2 20.1 0.11 0.14 Mortar
AP9 1:2:9 2.6 23.4 0.11 0.12 Mortar
Dizhur et al.
(2013)
A2L - 5.3 17.1 0.31 0.21
Mortar
A3L - 5.3 17.1 0.31 0.24
Lin et al. (2013) S0-2L-1
- 1.0 26.5 0.04
0.08
Mortar
S0-2L-2 0.09
S0-3L-1 0.09
S0-3L-2 0.09
S0-4L-1 0.07
S0-4L-2 0.08
Ismail (2012)
W2C-3
-
1.4 39.4 0.04 0.14
MortarABI-01 1.4 16.4 0.09 0.15
ABI-02 0.7 18.8 0.04 0.098
11. stress of URM wall panels can be estimated as 0.09 of the mortar compressive strength, with a
relatively higher statistical R2
value of 0.84. The results gained from W4 and W8 have not been
included in the analysis due to these wall panels failing prematurely due to the lack of adhesion.
Figure 11. Relationship between maximum diagonal shear stress and mortar compression
strength
3.6 Stiffness
In order to determine the stiffness of each tested wall panel, the shear modulus (G) was determined as
the ratio of shear stress (τs) to shear strain (γ) between 0.05 and 0.33 of the ultimate shear strength as
per ASTM (2004). As shown in Table 3, the shear modulus for each wall panel varied significantly
from 0.06 GPa to 0.52 GPa with no identifiable trend. Previous researchers (Dizhur & Ingham, 2013)
also observed large variations in shear modulus without any clear relationships during their
experiments. Similarly, as the modulus of elasticity (E) is a direct function of the shear modulus, the
modulus of elasticity also exhibits a large range of values with no identifiable trend.
4 CONCLUSIONS
Experimental testing was conducted on eight URM wall panels with the aim of determining the
demarcation between diagonal shear failure mechanisms occurring through mortar joints only and
occurring through a combination of brick/mortar. Also, three wall panels were repaired in order to
undertake a pilot study investigating the feasibility of using NSM SWR as a possible repair technique.
The following conclusions were drawn -
Significant load carrying capacity is sustained after the peak shear stress is reached when wall
panels undergo diagonal shear failure through mortar joints in a stair-step pattern.
Diagonal shear failure of wall panels occurring through brick/mortar joints resulted in a sud-
den and brittle failure with substantial reductions in load carrying capacity once the peak shear
stress was reached.
The transition point between the two distinctive diagonal shear failure mechanisms (cracking
through mortar joints alone and cracking through both bricks and mortar) was established as
occurring at a ratio of mortar to brick compressive strength of 0.4. Wall panels with a ratio be-
low 0.4 resulted in cracking through mortar joints, while wall panels with a ratio greater than
0.4 resulted in cracking through both brick and mortar joints.
Based on the attained results herein, Table 10.14: Recommended force reduction factors for
linear static method of NZSEE (2015) can be updated where a distinction between stair-step
failure modes (force reduction factor, KR equals to 3 when f’j/f’b ≤ 0.4) and pier diagonal ten-
sion failure modes (dominated by brick splitting, KR equals to 1 when f’j/f’b ≥ 0.4) can now be
quantified.
Section 10.8 of NZSEE (2015) can be updated in regards to the peak shear strength of URM
spandrels. It is recommended that Equation 10.47 be used when f’j/f’b ≤ 0.4, otherwise Equa-
tion 10.48 should be used.
y = 0.09x
R² = 0.84
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Maximum
DiagonalShear
Stress,τs(MPa)
Mortar Compression Strength, f'j (MPa)
12. The maximum diagonal shear stress of URM wall panels is able to be estimated as 0.09 of the
mortar compression strength.
Wall panels W1 and W3 which were repaired using SWR had increases in both load carrying
capacity and maximum drift compared to their as-built counterparts. Further experimentation
is required in order to assess effectiveness of this repair/retrofit technique.
5 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to thank Marta Giaretton, Peter Inman, Melissa Brisacque and the engineering
lab technicians at the University of Auckland. The authors would also like to acknowledge our
sponsors Sika Ltd. and D. M. Standen for supplying materials for this experiment.
6 REFERENCES
Almesfer, N., Dizhur, D. Y., Lumantarna, R., & Ingham, J. M. (2014). Material properties of existing unreinforced clay brick
masonry buildings in New Zealand. Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, 47(2), 75-96.
ASTM. (2003a). Standard test methods for sampling and testing brick and structural clay tile. C 67 - 03a, ASTM Interna-
tional, Pennsylvania, United States
ASTM. (2003b). Standard test method for compressive strength of masonry prisms. C 1314-03b, ASTM International, Penn-
sylvania, United States
ASTM. (2004). Standard test method for young’s modulus, tangent modulus, and chord modulus. E 111/E111 - 04, ASTM
International, Pennsylvania, United States
ASTM. (2008). Standard test method for compressive strength of hydraulic cement mortars. C109/C109M–08, ASTM
International, Pennsylvania, United States
ASTM. (2010). Standard test method for diagonal tension (shear) in masonry assemblages. E 519-10, ASTM International,
Pennsylvania, United States
Dizhur, D., & Ingham, J. M. (2013). Diagonal tension strength of vintage unreinforced clay brick masonry wall panels.
Construction and Building Materials, 43, 418-427.
Moon, L., Dizhur, D., Senaldi, I., Derakhshan, H., Griffith, M., Magenes, G., Ingham, J. M. ‘The demise of the URM
building stock in Christchurch during the 2010/2011 Canterbury earthquake sequence’, Earthquake Spectra, 30, 1, 253-
276.
Dizhur, D., Griffith, M., & Ingham, J. (2013). In-plane shear improvement of unreinforced masonry wall panels using NSM
CFRP strips. Journal of Composites for Construction, 17(6), 04013010
Griffith, M., & Ingham, J. (2011). Performance of unreinforced masonry buildings during the 2010 Darfield (Christchurch,
NZ) earthquake, Australian Journal of Structural Engineering, 11, 3, 207-224.
Ismail N. (2012). Selected strengthening techniques for the seismic retrofit of unreinforced masonry buildings. Doctoral
Dissertation. The University of Auckland.
Lin Y, Wotherspoon L, Scott A, Ingham JM. (2013). In-plane strengthening of clay brick unreinforced masonry wallettes
using ECC shotcrete. ASCE Journal of Structural Engineering, 140, 11, 04014081
Magenes, G., & Calvi, G. M. (1997). In-plane seismic response of brick masonry walls. Earthquake Engineering & Structural
Dynamics, 26(11), 1091-1112.
NZSEE (2015). Assessment and improvement of the structural performance of buildings in earthquakes. New Zealand Socie-
ty for Earthquake Engineering, Wellington, New Zealand
Russell, A. P. (2010). Characterisation and seismic assessment of unreinforced masonry buildings. Doctoral dissertation. The
University of Auckland.
Sika (2015). Sikadur 30 Product Data Sheet. Edition 9.23.2014