SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 53
2040 Regional Transportation Plan

Community Advisory Committee
Meeting
October 23, 2012




        Chattanooga-Hamilton County/N. GA Transportation Planning Organization
2040 Regional Transportation Plan

Core Technical Team
Meeting
October 23, 2012




        Chattanooga-Hamilton County/N. GA Transportation Planning Organization
Agenda


•   Overview
•   Results of Public Outreach Activities
•   Review of Goals & Objectives
•   Travel Demand Model Update
•   Needs Identification Exercise
•   Public Workshops
•   Next Steps
Overview




Progress to date
Public Outreach Schedule
                   COMMUNITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE + CORE TECHNICAL TEAM
    Community leaders and technical experts comprise these two committees, whose input will
    help form plan goals and validate recommendations.

           Meeting #1: July 25-26, 2012                     Meeting #3: January 2013
    Status report to committees: Late August                Meeting #4: Mid March 2013
           Meeting #2: Mid October 2012              Status report to committees: April 2013
    Status report to committees: Late November

             LEADERSHIP SYMPOSIUMS                                   WORKSHOPS
    Large forum events where regional initiatives,          Transit Aspirations: August 22, 2012
    strategies, and integration are contemplated
                                                            Visioning: Mid October 2012
    by political and community leaders from
    throughout the region                                   Priorities: January 2013
           Visioning Event: August 23, 2012                 Draft Fiscally Constrained Plan: Mid
                                                            May 2013
           Project Summit: Early December 2012

             STAKEHOLDER INTERVIEWS                                PUBLIC MEETINGS
    One-on-one and small group interviews with              Community Open        House     (kickoff):
    key community figures, agencies, service                August 23, 2012
    providers, and other relevant groups.
                                                            Community   Open           House:   Early
           August 21-24, 2012                               December 2012
           Mid October 2012                                 Final Plan Open House: October 2013
Questionnaire




325 Questionnaires have been completed to date
Transit Aspiration Workshop

• The “Chattanooga Way”   • High Speed Rail to Atlanta
• Multi-modal mobility    • Connectivity
Open House



32 people attended
Leadership Symposium
Over 80 people attended the event




                                    Mobility Chip Game
Leadership Symposium
Stakeholder Interviews


2 stakeholder interviews completed during August
event period

6 interviews scheduled this week, including economic
development, quality of life, and service providers

1 jurisdiction meeting with City of Soddy-Daisy
Defining Goals and Objectives



First critical step in the process
Based on outreach efforts summarized previously
Performance-Based Plan
• TPO advancing previous performance-based planning
  efforts from 2035 RTP
• Performance-based plan process:
  – Supports transparent decision-making
    in competitive funding environment
  – Provides context for plan development




                                                       Quality Data
    and helps balance analysis across
    competing needs
  – Applies key metrics to track positive
    outcomes
  – Ensures investment decisions align with
     long-term goals
  – Allows MPO to manage expectations

                                                  13
Defining Goals and Objectives

• First critical step in the process
• Based on outreach efforts
  conducted summer 2012
   – Community Advisory Committee
     and Core Technical Committee
     meetings
   – Regional leadership symposium
   – Transit visioning workshop
   – Public open house and public
     questionnaires
   – Stakeholder interviews
                                       14
“Community to Region” Framework

                                                                Region to Region
                               Community to Region
  Within Community




                                                                               INVESTMENT NEEDS THAT
                                                                               SUPPORT:
                                               INVESTMENT NEEDS THAT
                                               SUPPORT:                        • Mobility and intermodal
            INVESTMENT NEEDS THAT                                                improvements to ensure
                                               • Strategic, multimodal           region is well connected
            SUPPORT:
                                                 connections between             within the state and the
            • Local, multimodal                  communities and regional         nation
              connections and access to          activity/economic centers     • Support economic
              community resources                to support economic             competitiveness and
            • Advance livability and quality     development                     advance overall economic
              of life principles                                                 development potential



                                                                                                      15
Goals and Objectives
  Within Community     Goal: BUILD AND MAINTAIN SAFE AND HEALTHY
                       COMMUNITIES

                       Objectives:
                       • Support walkable and bicycle-friendly communities that
                          promote safe, connections to community
                          resources
                       • Provide incentives for complete streets project design
                       • Encourage investments anchored in integrated
                         transportation and land use planning, that support
                         desired community character
                       • Improve safety through improved system operations,
                         preventative maintenance, and ADA compliance
                       • Prioritize investments in areas where local land use and
                          development regulations support healthy, safe
                          communities
                       • Prioritize investment that improves multimodal access to
                         existing or planned transit hubs or that fills gaps in
                         existing multimodal system
                       • Encourage connected street network


                                                                            16
Goals and Objectives
 Community to Region   Goal: CONNECT COMMUNITIES IN THE REGION BY
                       PROVIDING MULTIMODAL TRAVEL OPTIONS TO
                       ACTIVITY AND ECONOMIC CENTERS

                       Objectives:
                       • Preserve, maintain and improve existing
                         infrastructure before adding new capacity
                       • Provide incentives for complete streets project
                        design
                       • Encourage corridor improvements anchored in
                         integrated transportation and land use planning, that
                         support desired community character
                       • Improve mobility and support economic
                        development by providing expanded set of travel
                        options, with emphasis on public transit
                       • Improve travel time reliability through improved
                        system operations
                       • Incentive corridor protection plans




                                                                           17
Goals and Objectives
 Region to Region      Goal: GROW ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY
                       THROUGH STRATEGIC INVESTMENT IN CRITICAL
                       REGIONAL INFRASTRUCTURE

                       Objectives:
                       • Preserve, maintain and improve existing
                         infrastructure before adding new capacity
                       • Support continued economic growth of
                          the region by improving intermodal
                         connections that reduce delay for both people
                          and goods
                       • Reduce delay on critical regional thoroughfares
                        with minimal impact to community, historic and
                        environmental resources
                       • Improve the efficiency and reliability of freight,
                        cargo and goods movement by reducing delay
                        on corridors critical to freight movement
                       • Improve travel time reliability through
                         improved system operations




                                                                              18
Performance Framework Outcomes
                                                Region to Region
                         Community to Region
   Within Community




 • Enable balanced consideration of investment needs across three
   geographic scales
 • Infuse context into the project evaluation process to better match solutions
   to needs
 • Provide flexible approach to project evaluation to support livability
   considerations at community level without impeding mobility and
   economic considerations at regional level
                                                                             19
Identifying Future Needs

• Addressing congestion
• Preservation of existing system
• Assuring safety and security
• Active transportation: pedestrian
  and bicycle mobility; complete
  streets; health
• Transit alternatives
• Climate resilience


                                      20
Needs: Congestion
•   Air quality                             2010       2040          % Growth
•   Safety impacts            Population   445,000    560,000           26%

•   Cost of congestion
•   Competitiveness                                  Future Year Congested Highways


•   Quality of life

• Future year demand on
  E&C network
    –   Travel demand model
    –   Congested corridors
    –   Hotspots
    –   Managing operations

                                                                              21
Travel Demand Modeling


Purpose
  • To understand future
    transportation demand
  • To test transportation scenarios
  • Inputs to air quality analysis
Travel Demand Modeling


Model Features
 • Standard 4-Step Model
 • Time of Day
 • Mode Choice
 • Truck Model
 • Vehicle Availability
 • High Occupancy Vehicle Lanes
Travel Demand Modeling


Data Inputs
  • Land Use
  • Travel Characteristics
  • Roadway and Transit
     Characteristics
Travel Demand Modeling


Model Operation
 • Trip Generation
 • Trip Distribution
 • Mode Choice
 • Assignment
Travel Demand Modeling

Schedule
  • Base Year
    •   Model Input – approved September 11
    •   Trip Behavior – approved October 15
    •   Trip Assignment – draft for review October 25
    •   Calibration and Validation – draft October 25
Travel Demand Modeling

Schedule
  • Future Year – draft October 31
    •   Future Year on Existing Network
    •   Future Year on Existing and Committed Network
    •   Future Year on Major Route Plan
  • Model Interface – draft October 31
  • Model Training – Mid-December
Needs: Congestion
Transportation Systems Management and
     Operations (TSM&O) includes:
• Traffic Incident Management   • Work Zone Traffic
• Travel Information Services     Management
  (for roadways and for         • Roadway Weather
  transit)                        Information
• Freeway Management            • Electronic Payment (for
• Automatic Vehicle Location      transit, parking, tolling)
  for Transit                   • Freight Management (ports
• Traffic Signal Coordination     and transfer areas)

     Applied individually or in combination
                                                          28
Needs: Congestion
     Why Is TSM&O Important?
    To take back as much of the road as we can !




                                                   TSM&O
   Weather
   Work Zones

   Incidents

                      Recurring congestion
                                                           29
Needs: System Preservation
• Focus of MAP-21
• Impact to National competitiveness
    – 1 in 4 bridges deficient (2009)
    – Wilcox Tunnel (1931)
    – Chickamauga Lock (1940)

 Pavement Analysis                      Bridge Analysis
                                                          3%
           9%                                                        Not Deficient
                           Good               19%

   18%                                                               Functionally Obsolete
                           Fair


                           Poor                                      Structurally Deficient




                     73%
                                                               78%




                                                                                              30
Needs: System Preservation




                             31
Needs: System Preservation
• Data sources:
   – National Bridge Inventory (FHWA)
   – State (TN, GA), County and Municipal
     departments
   – National Transit Database (FTA)


• Develop costs to address
  deficiencies




                                            32
Needs: Safety and Security

• Traffic crashes leading
  cause of death 5-34yo
                            450                                                            80
• 55 deaths; 330 injuries
                                                             71
                            400                                                      62    70
                                          58       56
                            350                                                            60
  annually in region        300
                            250
                                   47
                                                                    44
                                                                              49
                                                                                           50
                                                                                           40
• $1,700 per person         200
                            150
                                                                                           30

                            100                                                            20

                             50                                                            10
                                  404    386      366       319    261        252   332
                              0                                                            0
                                  2003   2004    2005       2006   2007      2008   2009

                                                Serious Injuries     Fatalities




                                                                                           33
Needs: Safety and Security

• Emphasis areas:
  –   Roadway departure        Roadway Departure                                                   33.4%
                                       Aggressive                                                  33.3%
  –   Aggressive driving               Intersection
                                     Seat Belt Use                                        25.2%
                                                                                                  32.6%


  –   Intersection crashes   Young Drivers (15-24)
                                      Motorcycles*                        12.5%
                                                                                  19.1%

                                  Alcohol Impaired                        12.3%
  –   Seat belt use             Older Drivers (65+)
                                     Heavy Trucks
                                                                   8.7%
                                                            3.0%

  –   Young drivers                    Pedestrian*
                                      Work Zone**
                                                         1.3%
                                                       0.5%
                             Pedacylists/Bicyclists*   0.2%

                                                   0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% 30.0% 35.0% 40.0%




                                                                                                           34
Needs: Active Transportation

• Human-power replaced by automobile
  and other powered modes
• Resultant decline in national health
   – Childhood obesity
   – Cost to families
• Lack of suitable facilities
   – Topographic, geographic challenges
   – Average home 1.6 miles from a facility
→ Complete streets

                                              35
Needs: Active Transportation




• Where are the greatest
  needs?
• What facilities are
  needed?


                               36
Needs: Active Transportation

• Pedestrian trips
   –   Short-distance focus
   –   Land use pattern
   –   Generators
   –   Barriers
   –   Topography




                               37
Needs: Active Transportation

• Bicycle trips
   – Longer distance
   – Generators
   – Road and traffic
     conditions
   – Bicycle level of service




                                38
Needs: Active Transportation




                               39
Needs: Transit Alternatives
• Not served by auto travel:
   –   Tourist market
   –   Aging population
   –   Youth less inclined to drive
   –   Zero-car households

                                               Investment                          Job Creation

• Jobs and economic                    Every $1 billion invested in          Creates and supports an
                                      transit capital and operations         average of 36,000 jobs
  development
• Fuel cost and oil
  dependence
• Environment and air quality                   Source: American Public Transportation Association



                                                                                                     40
Transit Benefits: Economy
         Investment                                        Economic Return

   For every $1 invested in                     $4 is generated in economic
    public transportation                                           returns




               Source: American Public Transportation Association             41
Transit Benefits: Quality of Life
                Transit Use                                                  Annual Savings

   Americans living in areas                                796 million hours in travel time
           served by public                                                     +
                                                                    4,400 fewer miles driven
             transportation




                                                                                                                      42
   Source: Texas Transportation Institute (TTI) Report on Congestion and American Public Transportation Association
Transit Benefits: Energy
          Transit Use                                                 Savings
    In 2011, Americans took                    4.2 billion gallons of gasoline
      10.4 billion trips                                              per year
    on public transportation                                              +
                                                  900,000 automobile fill-ups
                                                                      every day




                                                                                  43
                 Source: American Public Transportation Association
Transit Benefits: Environment
            Mode Shift                                                 Savings


  20 mile roundtrip commute                        Decrease CO2 air pollutant
                                                 emissions by 4,800 pounds
                                                           per year
                                                               =
                                                 10% less carbon footprint in a
                                                      two-car household

  from driving         to transit




                                                                                 44
                  Source: American Public Transportation Association
Needs: Transit Alternatives
• What’s in our future?
   – Continued growth in suburban
     residential and employment
   – Aging population
   – Airport growth focus
   – High Speed Rail
   – Limited highway expansion
   – Fuel costs and air quality impacts
   – Impact of new technologies



                                          45
Needs: Transit Alternatives
• Vision for Transit
   – Electric vehicle technology
   – Connect downtown, airport, Enterprise S


• Strategies
   –   Collaboration & Leadership
   –   Private sector; education partners
   –   Technology
   –   Integration with land use
   –   Service levels by area
   –   Funding
                                               46
Needs: Transit Alternatives




                              47
Needs: Climate Resilience
• September Climate Adaptation
  Workshop
• Increasing frequency:
   – Extreme precipitation
   – Extreme temperature
• Potential Climate Impacts:
   –   Flooding, erosion, road closures
   –   Landslides and other earthwork failures
   –   Pavement cracking and rutting
   –   Bridges – Scour critical and expansion
   –   Airport take off and landing issues
Needs: Climate Resilience
• Critical
  Transportation
  Assets
– Chickamauga
  Lock and Dam,
– Chattanooga
  Airport and SR
  153 access,
– Interchange of I-
  75/I-24,
– Enterprise South
  road and rail
  access, and
– Downtown
  bridges.
Needs: Climate Resilience

• Potential Adaptation strategies:
   – More resilient infrastructure design
     and materials
   – Establish network redundancy and
     emergency detours
   – Better maintenance of drainage
     systems
   – Conduct more detailed vulnerability
     and risk assessment of certain assets
• Relation to RTP
   – Performance measure for network
     redundancy
   – Flag RTP projects on identified
     critical/vulnerable assets and work
     with project sponsors on resilient
     design
Needs: What Next?

• Develop alternative scenarios to address
  deficiencies:
   – Spatial component of growth
   – Balance of modal options

   – Focus on systems management?
   – Focus on transit
     and alternative modes?




                                             51
Don’t Forget the Workshops

DISCUSSION
Public Workshop Schedule

OCTOBER 22, 2012 –
    Constitution Hall – 6:00-8:00 p.m.
    Soddy-Daisy High School Cafeteria – 6:00-8:00 p.m.

OCTOBER 23, 2012 –
    Downtown Chattanooga – 4:30-7:00 p.m.
    Collegedale Municipal Building – 6:00-8:00 p.m.

More Related Content

What's hot

Provision of Urban Amenities in Rural Areas(PURA)
 Provision of Urban Amenities in Rural Areas(PURA) Provision of Urban Amenities in Rural Areas(PURA)
Provision of Urban Amenities in Rural Areas(PURA)whatislokpal
 
June 28, 2012 Transportation Advisory Group Presentation
June 28, 2012 Transportation Advisory Group PresentationJune 28, 2012 Transportation Advisory Group Presentation
June 28, 2012 Transportation Advisory Group PresentationJing Zhang, AICP
 
Methods to Achieve Socio-economic Design Goals and Objectives for Future Netw...
Methods to Achieve Socio-economic Design Goals and Objectives for Future Netw...Methods to Achieve Socio-economic Design Goals and Objectives for Future Netw...
Methods to Achieve Socio-economic Design Goals and Objectives for Future Netw...ictseserv
 
Iati open aid presentation march 13 2013
Iati open aid presentation march 13 2013Iati open aid presentation march 13 2013
Iati open aid presentation march 13 2013Aleem Walji
 
ThinkTank Cities - Assignment 4 - Toronto Baseline Case
ThinkTank Cities - Assignment 4  - Toronto Baseline CaseThinkTank Cities - Assignment 4  - Toronto Baseline Case
ThinkTank Cities - Assignment 4 - Toronto Baseline CaseLeuphana Digital School
 
Sustainable Social and Economic Development Ideas For Business Investment, Re...
Sustainable Social and Economic Development Ideas For Business Investment, Re...Sustainable Social and Economic Development Ideas For Business Investment, Re...
Sustainable Social and Economic Development Ideas For Business Investment, Re...Willy Prilles
 
Housing and Neighborhoods Meeting 5 - Theme C
Housing and Neighborhoods Meeting 5 - Theme CHousing and Neighborhoods Meeting 5 - Theme C
Housing and Neighborhoods Meeting 5 - Theme Coneregionforward
 
Tourism United: The Global Partnership on Sustainable Tourism
Tourism United: The Global Partnership on Sustainable TourismTourism United: The Global Partnership on Sustainable Tourism
Tourism United: The Global Partnership on Sustainable TourismStefanos Fotiou, UNESCAP
 
Overcoming islands of disability
Overcoming islands of disabilityOvercoming islands of disability
Overcoming islands of disabilityJumpingJaq
 
APA 2012 General Plan Action Plans - Cincinnati
APA 2012 General Plan Action Plans - CincinnatiAPA 2012 General Plan Action Plans - Cincinnati
APA 2012 General Plan Action Plans - CincinnatiJoseph Horwedel
 

What's hot (16)

Single-Family Zoning Analysis: Phase One Update
Single-Family Zoning Analysis: Phase One UpdateSingle-Family Zoning Analysis: Phase One Update
Single-Family Zoning Analysis: Phase One Update
 
Provision of Urban Amenities in Rural Areas(PURA)
 Provision of Urban Amenities in Rural Areas(PURA) Provision of Urban Amenities in Rural Areas(PURA)
Provision of Urban Amenities in Rural Areas(PURA)
 
June 28, 2012 Transportation Advisory Group Presentation
June 28, 2012 Transportation Advisory Group PresentationJune 28, 2012 Transportation Advisory Group Presentation
June 28, 2012 Transportation Advisory Group Presentation
 
RoWIP Strategic Review
RoWIP Strategic ReviewRoWIP Strategic Review
RoWIP Strategic Review
 
ENHANCING THE QUALITY OF URBAN INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENTS
ENHANCING THE QUALITY OF URBAN INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENTSENHANCING THE QUALITY OF URBAN INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENTS
ENHANCING THE QUALITY OF URBAN INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENTS
 
Methods to Achieve Socio-economic Design Goals and Objectives for Future Netw...
Methods to Achieve Socio-economic Design Goals and Objectives for Future Netw...Methods to Achieve Socio-economic Design Goals and Objectives for Future Netw...
Methods to Achieve Socio-economic Design Goals and Objectives for Future Netw...
 
Amrut ppt
Amrut pptAmrut ppt
Amrut ppt
 
Iati open aid presentation march 13 2013
Iati open aid presentation march 13 2013Iati open aid presentation march 13 2013
Iati open aid presentation march 13 2013
 
ThinkTank Cities - Assignment 4 - Toronto Baseline Case
ThinkTank Cities - Assignment 4  - Toronto Baseline CaseThinkTank Cities - Assignment 4  - Toronto Baseline Case
ThinkTank Cities - Assignment 4 - Toronto Baseline Case
 
PCAL Developer's Checklist
PCAL Developer's ChecklistPCAL Developer's Checklist
PCAL Developer's Checklist
 
Sustainable Social and Economic Development Ideas For Business Investment, Re...
Sustainable Social and Economic Development Ideas For Business Investment, Re...Sustainable Social and Economic Development Ideas For Business Investment, Re...
Sustainable Social and Economic Development Ideas For Business Investment, Re...
 
Housing and Neighborhoods Meeting 5 - Theme C
Housing and Neighborhoods Meeting 5 - Theme CHousing and Neighborhoods Meeting 5 - Theme C
Housing and Neighborhoods Meeting 5 - Theme C
 
Tourism United: The Global Partnership on Sustainable Tourism
Tourism United: The Global Partnership on Sustainable TourismTourism United: The Global Partnership on Sustainable Tourism
Tourism United: The Global Partnership on Sustainable Tourism
 
Overcoming islands of disability
Overcoming islands of disabilityOvercoming islands of disability
Overcoming islands of disability
 
Tn presentation.pdf2
Tn presentation.pdf2Tn presentation.pdf2
Tn presentation.pdf2
 
APA 2012 General Plan Action Plans - Cincinnati
APA 2012 General Plan Action Plans - CincinnatiAPA 2012 General Plan Action Plans - Cincinnati
APA 2012 General Plan Action Plans - Cincinnati
 

Similar to 2040 RTP Community Advisory Committee/Core Technical Team #2

Theory and Practice of City Development Strategies
Theory and Practice of City Development StrategiesTheory and Practice of City Development Strategies
Theory and Practice of City Development StrategiesRene Peter Hohmann
 
Focused Forward: Growing Economic Vitality
Focused Forward: Growing Economic VitalityFocused Forward: Growing Economic Vitality
Focused Forward: Growing Economic VitalityRPO America
 
2040 RTP Climate Adaptation Workshop (9.17.2012)
2040 RTP Climate Adaptation Workshop (9.17.2012)2040 RTP Climate Adaptation Workshop (9.17.2012)
2040 RTP Climate Adaptation Workshop (9.17.2012)CHCRPA
 
Transit supportive guidelines overview
Transit supportive guidelines   overviewTransit supportive guidelines   overview
Transit supportive guidelines overviewOntarioEast
 
Sidewalk Toronto Quayside Smart City Update Presentation - Meg Davis at Water...
Sidewalk Toronto Quayside Smart City Update Presentation - Meg Davis at Water...Sidewalk Toronto Quayside Smart City Update Presentation - Meg Davis at Water...
Sidewalk Toronto Quayside Smart City Update Presentation - Meg Davis at Water...Waterfront for All
 
Csp coj tod 8 oct 2013 samantha naidu
Csp coj tod 8 oct 2013 samantha naiduCsp coj tod 8 oct 2013 samantha naidu
Csp coj tod 8 oct 2013 samantha naiduReaVaya_KM
 
Finance for Urban Climate Change Resilience
Finance for Urban Climate Change ResilienceFinance for Urban Climate Change Resilience
Finance for Urban Climate Change ResilienceKimberly Junmookda
 
Development plan case study (nagpur & lasvegas)
Development plan  case study (nagpur & lasvegas)Development plan  case study (nagpur & lasvegas)
Development plan case study (nagpur & lasvegas)ABHI PATEL
 
The Benefits for Clients to Engage with Constructing Excellence 21st March 14
The Benefits for Clients to Engage with Constructing Excellence   21st March 14The Benefits for Clients to Engage with Constructing Excellence   21st March 14
The Benefits for Clients to Engage with Constructing Excellence 21st March 14Clarkson Alliance
 
Plan 2040 Online Public Meeting 2
Plan 2040 Online Public Meeting 2Plan 2040 Online Public Meeting 2
Plan 2040 Online Public Meeting 2ARC
 
SPATIAL INTEGRATION IN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT pptx
SPATIAL INTEGRATION IN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT pptxSPATIAL INTEGRATION IN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT pptx
SPATIAL INTEGRATION IN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT pptxShibashisDey1
 
Writing an Effective RED Application
Writing an Effective RED ApplicationWriting an Effective RED Application
Writing an Effective RED ApplicationStephen Morris Ec.D.
 
Community Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPD
Community Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPDCommunity Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPD
Community Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPDDesign South East
 
India addressing the other water ciris
India addressing the other water cirisIndia addressing the other water ciris
India addressing the other water cirisVeettal Kurian
 

Similar to 2040 RTP Community Advisory Committee/Core Technical Team #2 (20)

Theory and Practice of City Development Strategies
Theory and Practice of City Development StrategiesTheory and Practice of City Development Strategies
Theory and Practice of City Development Strategies
 
Focused Forward: Growing Economic Vitality
Focused Forward: Growing Economic VitalityFocused Forward: Growing Economic Vitality
Focused Forward: Growing Economic Vitality
 
2040 RTP Climate Adaptation Workshop (9.17.2012)
2040 RTP Climate Adaptation Workshop (9.17.2012)2040 RTP Climate Adaptation Workshop (9.17.2012)
2040 RTP Climate Adaptation Workshop (9.17.2012)
 
Transit supportive guidelines overview
Transit supportive guidelines   overviewTransit supportive guidelines   overview
Transit supportive guidelines overview
 
Sidewalk Toronto Quayside Smart City Update Presentation - Meg Davis at Water...
Sidewalk Toronto Quayside Smart City Update Presentation - Meg Davis at Water...Sidewalk Toronto Quayside Smart City Update Presentation - Meg Davis at Water...
Sidewalk Toronto Quayside Smart City Update Presentation - Meg Davis at Water...
 
URBAN DESIGN COMPENDIUM 1 & 2..(IMPLEMENTATION AND DELIVERY}
URBAN DESIGN COMPENDIUM 1 & 2..(IMPLEMENTATION AND  DELIVERY}URBAN DESIGN COMPENDIUM 1 & 2..(IMPLEMENTATION AND  DELIVERY}
URBAN DESIGN COMPENDIUM 1 & 2..(IMPLEMENTATION AND DELIVERY}
 
Csp coj tod 8 oct 2013 samantha naidu
Csp coj tod 8 oct 2013 samantha naiduCsp coj tod 8 oct 2013 samantha naidu
Csp coj tod 8 oct 2013 samantha naidu
 
Finance for Urban Climate Change Resilience
Finance for Urban Climate Change ResilienceFinance for Urban Climate Change Resilience
Finance for Urban Climate Change Resilience
 
2021 City Council Strategic Plan
2021 City Council Strategic Plan2021 City Council Strategic Plan
2021 City Council Strategic Plan
 
Development plan case study (nagpur & lasvegas)
Development plan  case study (nagpur & lasvegas)Development plan  case study (nagpur & lasvegas)
Development plan case study (nagpur & lasvegas)
 
The Benefits for Clients to Engage with Constructing Excellence 21st March 14
The Benefits for Clients to Engage with Constructing Excellence   21st March 14The Benefits for Clients to Engage with Constructing Excellence   21st March 14
The Benefits for Clients to Engage with Constructing Excellence 21st March 14
 
Plan 2040 Online Public Meeting 2
Plan 2040 Online Public Meeting 2Plan 2040 Online Public Meeting 2
Plan 2040 Online Public Meeting 2
 
SPATIAL INTEGRATION IN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT pptx
SPATIAL INTEGRATION IN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT pptxSPATIAL INTEGRATION IN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT pptx
SPATIAL INTEGRATION IN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT pptx
 
Brooklyn Master Plan Presentation
Brooklyn Master Plan PresentationBrooklyn Master Plan Presentation
Brooklyn Master Plan Presentation
 
Middleburg Heights Community Master Plan presentation
Middleburg Heights Community Master Plan presentationMiddleburg Heights Community Master Plan presentation
Middleburg Heights Community Master Plan presentation
 
Writing an Effective RED Application
Writing an Effective RED ApplicationWriting an Effective RED Application
Writing an Effective RED Application
 
Session 46 Merritt Polk
Session 46 Merritt PolkSession 46 Merritt Polk
Session 46 Merritt Polk
 
Community Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPD
Community Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPDCommunity Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPD
Community Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPD
 
India addressing the other water ciris
India addressing the other water cirisIndia addressing the other water ciris
India addressing the other water ciris
 
Project mangement
Project mangementProject mangement
Project mangement
 

More from CHCRPA

Current trends and innovations 5310 program and mod sandbox overview
Current trends and innovations 5310 program and mod sandbox overviewCurrent trends and innovations 5310 program and mod sandbox overview
Current trends and innovations 5310 program and mod sandbox overviewCHCRPA
 
Renewing Our Vision - Trends analysis
Renewing Our Vision - Trends analysis Renewing Our Vision - Trends analysis
Renewing Our Vision - Trends analysis CHCRPA
 
Project Maps & List: Draft 2040 Regional Transportation Plan
 Project Maps & List: Draft 2040 Regional Transportation Plan Project Maps & List: Draft 2040 Regional Transportation Plan
Project Maps & List: Draft 2040 Regional Transportation PlanCHCRPA
 
2040RTP Committees Final Presentation
2040RTP Committees Final Presentation2040RTP Committees Final Presentation
2040RTP Committees Final PresentationCHCRPA
 
2040 RTP Highlights
2040 RTP Highlights2040 RTP Highlights
2040 RTP HighlightsCHCRPA
 
Community to Region Framework
Community to Region FrameworkCommunity to Region Framework
Community to Region FrameworkCHCRPA
 
ThinkBike Chattanooga 9.24.13
ThinkBike Chattanooga 9.24.13ThinkBike Chattanooga 9.24.13
ThinkBike Chattanooga 9.24.13CHCRPA
 
DRAFT 2014-2017 Transportation Improvement Program (TIP)
DRAFT 2014-2017 Transportation Improvement Program (TIP)DRAFT 2014-2017 Transportation Improvement Program (TIP)
DRAFT 2014-2017 Transportation Improvement Program (TIP)CHCRPA
 
Housing Study Panel Presentation 11.19.12
Housing Study Panel Presentation 11.19.12Housing Study Panel Presentation 11.19.12
Housing Study Panel Presentation 11.19.12CHCRPA
 
1.23.13 Green Trips Advisory Committee Meeting
1.23.13 Green Trips Advisory Committee Meeting1.23.13 Green Trips Advisory Committee Meeting
1.23.13 Green Trips Advisory Committee MeetingCHCRPA
 
2040 RTP Outcomes Summary
2040 RTP Outcomes Summary2040 RTP Outcomes Summary
2040 RTP Outcomes SummaryCHCRPA
 
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium MAPS
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium MAPS2040 RTP Leadership Symposium MAPS
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium MAPSCHCRPA
 
2040 RTP Community Advisory Committee/Core Technical Team #1
2040 RTP Community Advisory Committee/Core Technical Team #12040 RTP Community Advisory Committee/Core Technical Team #1
2040 RTP Community Advisory Committee/Core Technical Team #1CHCRPA
 
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.12
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.122040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.12
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.12CHCRPA
 

More from CHCRPA (14)

Current trends and innovations 5310 program and mod sandbox overview
Current trends and innovations 5310 program and mod sandbox overviewCurrent trends and innovations 5310 program and mod sandbox overview
Current trends and innovations 5310 program and mod sandbox overview
 
Renewing Our Vision - Trends analysis
Renewing Our Vision - Trends analysis Renewing Our Vision - Trends analysis
Renewing Our Vision - Trends analysis
 
Project Maps & List: Draft 2040 Regional Transportation Plan
 Project Maps & List: Draft 2040 Regional Transportation Plan Project Maps & List: Draft 2040 Regional Transportation Plan
Project Maps & List: Draft 2040 Regional Transportation Plan
 
2040RTP Committees Final Presentation
2040RTP Committees Final Presentation2040RTP Committees Final Presentation
2040RTP Committees Final Presentation
 
2040 RTP Highlights
2040 RTP Highlights2040 RTP Highlights
2040 RTP Highlights
 
Community to Region Framework
Community to Region FrameworkCommunity to Region Framework
Community to Region Framework
 
ThinkBike Chattanooga 9.24.13
ThinkBike Chattanooga 9.24.13ThinkBike Chattanooga 9.24.13
ThinkBike Chattanooga 9.24.13
 
DRAFT 2014-2017 Transportation Improvement Program (TIP)
DRAFT 2014-2017 Transportation Improvement Program (TIP)DRAFT 2014-2017 Transportation Improvement Program (TIP)
DRAFT 2014-2017 Transportation Improvement Program (TIP)
 
Housing Study Panel Presentation 11.19.12
Housing Study Panel Presentation 11.19.12Housing Study Panel Presentation 11.19.12
Housing Study Panel Presentation 11.19.12
 
1.23.13 Green Trips Advisory Committee Meeting
1.23.13 Green Trips Advisory Committee Meeting1.23.13 Green Trips Advisory Committee Meeting
1.23.13 Green Trips Advisory Committee Meeting
 
2040 RTP Outcomes Summary
2040 RTP Outcomes Summary2040 RTP Outcomes Summary
2040 RTP Outcomes Summary
 
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium MAPS
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium MAPS2040 RTP Leadership Symposium MAPS
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium MAPS
 
2040 RTP Community Advisory Committee/Core Technical Team #1
2040 RTP Community Advisory Committee/Core Technical Team #12040 RTP Community Advisory Committee/Core Technical Team #1
2040 RTP Community Advisory Committee/Core Technical Team #1
 
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.12
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.122040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.12
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.12
 

2040 RTP Community Advisory Committee/Core Technical Team #2

  • 1. 2040 Regional Transportation Plan Community Advisory Committee Meeting October 23, 2012 Chattanooga-Hamilton County/N. GA Transportation Planning Organization
  • 2. 2040 Regional Transportation Plan Core Technical Team Meeting October 23, 2012 Chattanooga-Hamilton County/N. GA Transportation Planning Organization
  • 3. Agenda • Overview • Results of Public Outreach Activities • Review of Goals & Objectives • Travel Demand Model Update • Needs Identification Exercise • Public Workshops • Next Steps
  • 5. Public Outreach Schedule COMMUNITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE + CORE TECHNICAL TEAM Community leaders and technical experts comprise these two committees, whose input will help form plan goals and validate recommendations. Meeting #1: July 25-26, 2012 Meeting #3: January 2013 Status report to committees: Late August Meeting #4: Mid March 2013 Meeting #2: Mid October 2012 Status report to committees: April 2013 Status report to committees: Late November LEADERSHIP SYMPOSIUMS WORKSHOPS Large forum events where regional initiatives, Transit Aspirations: August 22, 2012 strategies, and integration are contemplated Visioning: Mid October 2012 by political and community leaders from throughout the region Priorities: January 2013 Visioning Event: August 23, 2012 Draft Fiscally Constrained Plan: Mid May 2013 Project Summit: Early December 2012 STAKEHOLDER INTERVIEWS PUBLIC MEETINGS One-on-one and small group interviews with Community Open House (kickoff): key community figures, agencies, service August 23, 2012 providers, and other relevant groups. Community Open House: Early August 21-24, 2012 December 2012 Mid October 2012 Final Plan Open House: October 2013
  • 6. Questionnaire 325 Questionnaires have been completed to date
  • 7. Transit Aspiration Workshop • The “Chattanooga Way” • High Speed Rail to Atlanta • Multi-modal mobility • Connectivity
  • 9. Leadership Symposium Over 80 people attended the event Mobility Chip Game
  • 11. Stakeholder Interviews 2 stakeholder interviews completed during August event period 6 interviews scheduled this week, including economic development, quality of life, and service providers 1 jurisdiction meeting with City of Soddy-Daisy
  • 12. Defining Goals and Objectives First critical step in the process Based on outreach efforts summarized previously
  • 13. Performance-Based Plan • TPO advancing previous performance-based planning efforts from 2035 RTP • Performance-based plan process: – Supports transparent decision-making in competitive funding environment – Provides context for plan development Quality Data and helps balance analysis across competing needs – Applies key metrics to track positive outcomes – Ensures investment decisions align with long-term goals – Allows MPO to manage expectations 13
  • 14. Defining Goals and Objectives • First critical step in the process • Based on outreach efforts conducted summer 2012 – Community Advisory Committee and Core Technical Committee meetings – Regional leadership symposium – Transit visioning workshop – Public open house and public questionnaires – Stakeholder interviews 14
  • 15. “Community to Region” Framework Region to Region Community to Region Within Community INVESTMENT NEEDS THAT SUPPORT: INVESTMENT NEEDS THAT SUPPORT: • Mobility and intermodal INVESTMENT NEEDS THAT improvements to ensure • Strategic, multimodal region is well connected SUPPORT: connections between within the state and the • Local, multimodal communities and regional nation connections and access to activity/economic centers • Support economic community resources to support economic competitiveness and • Advance livability and quality development advance overall economic of life principles development potential 15
  • 16. Goals and Objectives Within Community Goal: BUILD AND MAINTAIN SAFE AND HEALTHY COMMUNITIES Objectives: • Support walkable and bicycle-friendly communities that promote safe, connections to community resources • Provide incentives for complete streets project design • Encourage investments anchored in integrated transportation and land use planning, that support desired community character • Improve safety through improved system operations, preventative maintenance, and ADA compliance • Prioritize investments in areas where local land use and development regulations support healthy, safe communities • Prioritize investment that improves multimodal access to existing or planned transit hubs or that fills gaps in existing multimodal system • Encourage connected street network 16
  • 17. Goals and Objectives Community to Region Goal: CONNECT COMMUNITIES IN THE REGION BY PROVIDING MULTIMODAL TRAVEL OPTIONS TO ACTIVITY AND ECONOMIC CENTERS Objectives: • Preserve, maintain and improve existing infrastructure before adding new capacity • Provide incentives for complete streets project design • Encourage corridor improvements anchored in integrated transportation and land use planning, that support desired community character • Improve mobility and support economic development by providing expanded set of travel options, with emphasis on public transit • Improve travel time reliability through improved system operations • Incentive corridor protection plans 17
  • 18. Goals and Objectives Region to Region Goal: GROW ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY THROUGH STRATEGIC INVESTMENT IN CRITICAL REGIONAL INFRASTRUCTURE Objectives: • Preserve, maintain and improve existing infrastructure before adding new capacity • Support continued economic growth of the region by improving intermodal connections that reduce delay for both people and goods • Reduce delay on critical regional thoroughfares with minimal impact to community, historic and environmental resources • Improve the efficiency and reliability of freight, cargo and goods movement by reducing delay on corridors critical to freight movement • Improve travel time reliability through improved system operations 18
  • 19. Performance Framework Outcomes Region to Region Community to Region Within Community • Enable balanced consideration of investment needs across three geographic scales • Infuse context into the project evaluation process to better match solutions to needs • Provide flexible approach to project evaluation to support livability considerations at community level without impeding mobility and economic considerations at regional level 19
  • 20. Identifying Future Needs • Addressing congestion • Preservation of existing system • Assuring safety and security • Active transportation: pedestrian and bicycle mobility; complete streets; health • Transit alternatives • Climate resilience 20
  • 21. Needs: Congestion • Air quality 2010 2040 % Growth • Safety impacts Population 445,000 560,000 26% • Cost of congestion • Competitiveness Future Year Congested Highways • Quality of life • Future year demand on E&C network – Travel demand model – Congested corridors – Hotspots – Managing operations 21
  • 22. Travel Demand Modeling Purpose • To understand future transportation demand • To test transportation scenarios • Inputs to air quality analysis
  • 23. Travel Demand Modeling Model Features • Standard 4-Step Model • Time of Day • Mode Choice • Truck Model • Vehicle Availability • High Occupancy Vehicle Lanes
  • 24. Travel Demand Modeling Data Inputs • Land Use • Travel Characteristics • Roadway and Transit Characteristics
  • 25. Travel Demand Modeling Model Operation • Trip Generation • Trip Distribution • Mode Choice • Assignment
  • 26. Travel Demand Modeling Schedule • Base Year • Model Input – approved September 11 • Trip Behavior – approved October 15 • Trip Assignment – draft for review October 25 • Calibration and Validation – draft October 25
  • 27. Travel Demand Modeling Schedule • Future Year – draft October 31 • Future Year on Existing Network • Future Year on Existing and Committed Network • Future Year on Major Route Plan • Model Interface – draft October 31 • Model Training – Mid-December
  • 28. Needs: Congestion Transportation Systems Management and Operations (TSM&O) includes: • Traffic Incident Management • Work Zone Traffic • Travel Information Services Management (for roadways and for • Roadway Weather transit) Information • Freeway Management • Electronic Payment (for • Automatic Vehicle Location transit, parking, tolling) for Transit • Freight Management (ports • Traffic Signal Coordination and transfer areas) Applied individually or in combination 28
  • 29. Needs: Congestion Why Is TSM&O Important? To take back as much of the road as we can ! TSM&O Weather Work Zones Incidents Recurring congestion 29
  • 30. Needs: System Preservation • Focus of MAP-21 • Impact to National competitiveness – 1 in 4 bridges deficient (2009) – Wilcox Tunnel (1931) – Chickamauga Lock (1940) Pavement Analysis Bridge Analysis 3% 9% Not Deficient Good 19% 18% Functionally Obsolete Fair Poor Structurally Deficient 73% 78% 30
  • 32. Needs: System Preservation • Data sources: – National Bridge Inventory (FHWA) – State (TN, GA), County and Municipal departments – National Transit Database (FTA) • Develop costs to address deficiencies 32
  • 33. Needs: Safety and Security • Traffic crashes leading cause of death 5-34yo 450 80 • 55 deaths; 330 injuries 71 400 62 70 58 56 350 60 annually in region 300 250 47 44 49 50 40 • $1,700 per person 200 150 30 100 20 50 10 404 386 366 319 261 252 332 0 0 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Serious Injuries Fatalities 33
  • 34. Needs: Safety and Security • Emphasis areas: – Roadway departure Roadway Departure 33.4% Aggressive 33.3% – Aggressive driving Intersection Seat Belt Use 25.2% 32.6% – Intersection crashes Young Drivers (15-24) Motorcycles* 12.5% 19.1% Alcohol Impaired 12.3% – Seat belt use Older Drivers (65+) Heavy Trucks 8.7% 3.0% – Young drivers Pedestrian* Work Zone** 1.3% 0.5% Pedacylists/Bicyclists* 0.2% 0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% 30.0% 35.0% 40.0% 34
  • 35. Needs: Active Transportation • Human-power replaced by automobile and other powered modes • Resultant decline in national health – Childhood obesity – Cost to families • Lack of suitable facilities – Topographic, geographic challenges – Average home 1.6 miles from a facility → Complete streets 35
  • 36. Needs: Active Transportation • Where are the greatest needs? • What facilities are needed? 36
  • 37. Needs: Active Transportation • Pedestrian trips – Short-distance focus – Land use pattern – Generators – Barriers – Topography 37
  • 38. Needs: Active Transportation • Bicycle trips – Longer distance – Generators – Road and traffic conditions – Bicycle level of service 38
  • 40. Needs: Transit Alternatives • Not served by auto travel: – Tourist market – Aging population – Youth less inclined to drive – Zero-car households Investment Job Creation • Jobs and economic Every $1 billion invested in Creates and supports an transit capital and operations average of 36,000 jobs development • Fuel cost and oil dependence • Environment and air quality Source: American Public Transportation Association 40
  • 41. Transit Benefits: Economy Investment Economic Return For every $1 invested in $4 is generated in economic public transportation returns Source: American Public Transportation Association 41
  • 42. Transit Benefits: Quality of Life Transit Use Annual Savings Americans living in areas 796 million hours in travel time served by public + 4,400 fewer miles driven transportation 42 Source: Texas Transportation Institute (TTI) Report on Congestion and American Public Transportation Association
  • 43. Transit Benefits: Energy Transit Use Savings In 2011, Americans took 4.2 billion gallons of gasoline 10.4 billion trips per year on public transportation + 900,000 automobile fill-ups every day 43 Source: American Public Transportation Association
  • 44. Transit Benefits: Environment Mode Shift Savings 20 mile roundtrip commute Decrease CO2 air pollutant emissions by 4,800 pounds per year = 10% less carbon footprint in a two-car household from driving to transit 44 Source: American Public Transportation Association
  • 45. Needs: Transit Alternatives • What’s in our future? – Continued growth in suburban residential and employment – Aging population – Airport growth focus – High Speed Rail – Limited highway expansion – Fuel costs and air quality impacts – Impact of new technologies 45
  • 46. Needs: Transit Alternatives • Vision for Transit – Electric vehicle technology – Connect downtown, airport, Enterprise S • Strategies – Collaboration & Leadership – Private sector; education partners – Technology – Integration with land use – Service levels by area – Funding 46
  • 48. Needs: Climate Resilience • September Climate Adaptation Workshop • Increasing frequency: – Extreme precipitation – Extreme temperature • Potential Climate Impacts: – Flooding, erosion, road closures – Landslides and other earthwork failures – Pavement cracking and rutting – Bridges – Scour critical and expansion – Airport take off and landing issues
  • 49. Needs: Climate Resilience • Critical Transportation Assets – Chickamauga Lock and Dam, – Chattanooga Airport and SR 153 access, – Interchange of I- 75/I-24, – Enterprise South road and rail access, and – Downtown bridges.
  • 50. Needs: Climate Resilience • Potential Adaptation strategies: – More resilient infrastructure design and materials – Establish network redundancy and emergency detours – Better maintenance of drainage systems – Conduct more detailed vulnerability and risk assessment of certain assets • Relation to RTP – Performance measure for network redundancy – Flag RTP projects on identified critical/vulnerable assets and work with project sponsors on resilient design
  • 51. Needs: What Next? • Develop alternative scenarios to address deficiencies: – Spatial component of growth – Balance of modal options – Focus on systems management? – Focus on transit and alternative modes? 51
  • 52. Don’t Forget the Workshops DISCUSSION
  • 53. Public Workshop Schedule OCTOBER 22, 2012 – Constitution Hall – 6:00-8:00 p.m. Soddy-Daisy High School Cafeteria – 6:00-8:00 p.m. OCTOBER 23, 2012 – Downtown Chattanooga – 4:30-7:00 p.m. Collegedale Municipal Building – 6:00-8:00 p.m.

Editor's Notes

  1. Developed set of goals/objectives based on extensive public outreach conducted summer 2012.We heard a lot about transportation needs, challenges, frustrations, opportunities.Much of the time, needs were presented from two rather distinct perspectives; one perspective driven by a broad set of stakeholders approaching the 2040 RTP from a more local, community-oriented perspective (focused on advancing livability, quality of life principles, and healhty, multimodal travel options for broad set of users), and the other from stakeholders focused on more systems-level, regional investments (focused on reducing congestion, improving mobility for people and goods … e.g., the “bypass” crowd) to ensure region is well-positioned and competitive from economic standpoint.Difference in perspectives is not unique to the plan process. TPO has developed a performance-framework to help strike the right balance, in terms of addressing needs of both (community/regional). Presented here as the “community to region” transect which is intended to help illustrate the transition in perspectives related to transportation needs as you move from community scale up to regional scale. This “community to region” approach is the foundation for our 2040 RTP performance framework and has been used to guide development of goals and objectives.
  2. Developed set of goals/objectives based on extensive public outreach conducted summer 2012.We heard a lot about transportation needs, challenges, frustrations, opportunities.Much of the time, needs were presented from two rather distinct perspectives; one perspective driven by a broad set of stakeholders approaching the 2040 RTP from a more local, community-oriented perspective (focused on advancing livability, quality of life principles, and healhty, multimodal travel options for broad set of users), and the other from stakeholders focused on more systems-level, regional investments (focused on reducing congestion, improving mobility for people and goods … e.g., the “bypass” crowd) to ensure region is well-positioned and competitive from economic standpoint.Difference in perspectives is not unique to the plan process. TPO has developed a performance-framework to help strike the right balance, in terms of addressing needs of both (community/regional). Presented here as the “community to region” transect which is intended to help illustrate the transition in perspectives related to transportation needs as you move from community scale up to regional scale. This “community to region” approach is the foundation for our 2040 RTP performance framework and has been used to guide development of goals and objectives.
  3. Historically this was the primary focus of the LRTP processExplain E+C
  4. Significant portion of overall funds available
  5. Significant portion of overall funds available
  6. (you will see this contrasts later with just over $5 based on regional research)