F I N A N C I A L S C R U T I N Y I N T H E
N E W Z E A L A N D P A R L I A M E N T
FINANCE AND
EXPENDITURE COMMITTEE
THE NEW ZEALAND PAC IS DIFFERENT:
THE NEW ZEALAND PAC IS DIFFERENT:
•  It does both “before” and “after” scrutiny
THE NEW ZEALAND PAC IS DIFFERENT:
•  It does both “before” and “after” scrutiny
•  Other select committees also do financial scrutiny –
FE Committee co-ordinates this work
WHAT WE DO
Any business relating to:
•  Audit of the financial statements of the Government and
departments
•  Government finance
•  Revenue
•  Taxation
SPECIAL DUTIES
•  Reporting on the annual Budget Policy Statement, the
Government’s fiscal strategy report and the annual financial
statements of the Government
•  Co-ordinating examination of performance audit reports of
the Auditor-General
•  Examining the Reserve Bank of NZ’s monetary policy
statements and financial stability reports
OTHER ROLES
General select committee business:
•  Examines proposed new legislation
•  Petitions
•  Treaties
•  Any other matter referred to FEC by the House
MEMBERS
SCRUTINY BEFORE EXPENDITURE
HAPPENS: THE ESTIMATES
Budget presented in Parliament
All Votes come to FE Committee
FE keeps and examines – or allocates to another
committee
SCRUTINY AFTER EXPENDITURE
HAPPENS: THE ANNUAL REVIEWS
Departments present annual reports to Parliament
FE considers which departments it wishes to examine,
keeps these and reports to the House on them
FE allocates annual reviews of all other departments and
entities to other committees to examine and report on to
the House
OUR PRACTICES (1)
•  Both “before” and “after” scrutiny
OUR PRACTICES (1)
•  Both “before” and “after” scrutiny
•  Flexibility
OUR PRACTICES (1)
•  Both “before” and “after” scrutiny
•  Flexibility
•  We seek support
OUR PRACTICES (1)
•  Both “before” and “after” scrutiny
•  Flexibility
•  We seek support
•  Staff within Parliament
OUR PRACTICES (1)
•  Both “before” and “after” scrutiny
•  Flexibility
•  We seek support
•  Staff within Parliament
•  The Treasury
OUR PRACTICES (1)
•  Both “before” and “after” scrutiny
•  Flexibility
•  We seek support
•  Staff within Parliament
•  The Treasury
•  The Auditor-General
OUR PRACTICES (2)
•  We investigate and report
OUR PRACTICES (2)
•  We investigate and report
•  We talk to those who are responsible
OUR PRACTICES (2)
•  We investigate and report
•  We talk to those who are responsible
•  Ministers
OUR PRACTICES (2)
•  We investigate and report
•  We talk to those who are responsible
•  Ministers
•  Chief Executives
OUR PRACTICES (2)
•  We investigate and report
•  We talk to those who are responsible
•  Ministers
•  Chief Executives
•  ANYONE!
OUR PRACTICES (3)
•  We ask questions
OUR PRACTICES (3)
•  We ask questions
•  We seek papers
OUR PRACTICES (3)
•  We ask questions
•  We seek papers
•  The process is transparent
OUR PRACTICES (3)
•  We ask questions
•  We seek papers
•  The process is transparent
•  Open to the public
•  Open to the media
OUR PRACTICES (3)
•  We ask questions
•  We seek papers
•  The process is transparent
•  Open to the public
•  Open to the media
•  Everything is published
OUR PRACTICES (4)
•  We write effective reports
OUR PRACTICES (4)
•  We write effective reports
•  There is room for minority views
OUR PRACTICES (4)
•  We write effective reports
•  There is room for minority views
•  We are supported by good staff
AND FINALLY…….
•  Any questions??
•  And let’s talk about your experiences

NZ FEC

  • 1.
    F I NA N C I A L S C R U T I N Y I N T H E N E W Z E A L A N D P A R L I A M E N T FINANCE AND EXPENDITURE COMMITTEE
  • 2.
    THE NEW ZEALANDPAC IS DIFFERENT:
  • 3.
    THE NEW ZEALANDPAC IS DIFFERENT: •  It does both “before” and “after” scrutiny
  • 4.
    THE NEW ZEALANDPAC IS DIFFERENT: •  It does both “before” and “after” scrutiny •  Other select committees also do financial scrutiny – FE Committee co-ordinates this work
  • 5.
    WHAT WE DO Anybusiness relating to: •  Audit of the financial statements of the Government and departments •  Government finance •  Revenue •  Taxation
  • 6.
    SPECIAL DUTIES •  Reportingon the annual Budget Policy Statement, the Government’s fiscal strategy report and the annual financial statements of the Government •  Co-ordinating examination of performance audit reports of the Auditor-General •  Examining the Reserve Bank of NZ’s monetary policy statements and financial stability reports
  • 7.
    OTHER ROLES General selectcommittee business: •  Examines proposed new legislation •  Petitions •  Treaties •  Any other matter referred to FEC by the House
  • 8.
  • 9.
    SCRUTINY BEFORE EXPENDITURE HAPPENS:THE ESTIMATES Budget presented in Parliament All Votes come to FE Committee FE keeps and examines – or allocates to another committee
  • 10.
    SCRUTINY AFTER EXPENDITURE HAPPENS:THE ANNUAL REVIEWS Departments present annual reports to Parliament FE considers which departments it wishes to examine, keeps these and reports to the House on them FE allocates annual reviews of all other departments and entities to other committees to examine and report on to the House
  • 11.
    OUR PRACTICES (1) • Both “before” and “after” scrutiny
  • 12.
    OUR PRACTICES (1) • Both “before” and “after” scrutiny •  Flexibility
  • 13.
    OUR PRACTICES (1) • Both “before” and “after” scrutiny •  Flexibility •  We seek support
  • 14.
    OUR PRACTICES (1) • Both “before” and “after” scrutiny •  Flexibility •  We seek support •  Staff within Parliament
  • 15.
    OUR PRACTICES (1) • Both “before” and “after” scrutiny •  Flexibility •  We seek support •  Staff within Parliament •  The Treasury
  • 16.
    OUR PRACTICES (1) • Both “before” and “after” scrutiny •  Flexibility •  We seek support •  Staff within Parliament •  The Treasury •  The Auditor-General
  • 17.
    OUR PRACTICES (2) • We investigate and report
  • 18.
    OUR PRACTICES (2) • We investigate and report •  We talk to those who are responsible
  • 19.
    OUR PRACTICES (2) • We investigate and report •  We talk to those who are responsible •  Ministers
  • 20.
    OUR PRACTICES (2) • We investigate and report •  We talk to those who are responsible •  Ministers •  Chief Executives
  • 21.
    OUR PRACTICES (2) • We investigate and report •  We talk to those who are responsible •  Ministers •  Chief Executives •  ANYONE!
  • 22.
    OUR PRACTICES (3) • We ask questions
  • 23.
    OUR PRACTICES (3) • We ask questions •  We seek papers
  • 24.
    OUR PRACTICES (3) • We ask questions •  We seek papers •  The process is transparent
  • 25.
    OUR PRACTICES (3) • We ask questions •  We seek papers •  The process is transparent •  Open to the public •  Open to the media
  • 26.
    OUR PRACTICES (3) • We ask questions •  We seek papers •  The process is transparent •  Open to the public •  Open to the media •  Everything is published
  • 27.
    OUR PRACTICES (4) • We write effective reports
  • 28.
    OUR PRACTICES (4) • We write effective reports •  There is room for minority views
  • 29.
    OUR PRACTICES (4) • We write effective reports •  There is room for minority views •  We are supported by good staff
  • 30.
    AND FINALLY……. •  Anyquestions?? •  And let’s talk about your experiences