For firms in the financial industry, especially within regulated organizations such as credit card processors and banks, PCI DSS compliance has become a business and operational necessity. Although the blueprint of a PCI-compliant architecture varies from organization to organization, the mixture of modern Hadoop-based data lakes and legacy systems are a common theme. In this talk, we will discuss recent updates to PCI DSS and how significant portions of PCI DSS compliance controls can be achieved using open source Hadoop security stack and technologies for the Hadoop ecosystem. We will provide a broad overview of implementing key aspects of PCI DSS standards at WorldPay such as encryption management, data protection with anonymization, separation of duties, and deployment considerations regarding securing the Hadoop clusters at the network layer from a practitioner’s perspective. The talk will provide patterns and practices map current Hadoop security capabilities to security controls that a PCI-compliant environment requires. Speaker David Walker, Enterprise Data Platform Programme Director, Worldpay Srikanth Venkat, Senior Director Product Management, Hortonworks

1. 1
© Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.
Not just a necessary evil, it’s good for business:
Implementing PCI DSS controls for the Hadoop
ecosystem at the UK’s largest payment processor
David Walker/Worldpay & Srikanth Venkat/HortonWorks
DataWorks Summit – Berlin
17-19 April 2018

2. 2 © Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.2
Session Synopsis & Your Speakers
David has over 20 years’ technical leadership expertise and
has led the development and management of complex BI
solutions, supporting technical architectures for a wide
range of organisations spanning SME start-ups to large
enterprise. In his role at Worldpay, David specialises in
developing and delivering the Enterprise Data Platform, a
multi-tenant highly secure Hadoop platform for decision
engines, analytics and reporting using his experience and
knowledge in technical architecture, data modelling, ETL
design, data quality, and metadata management. A key
aspect of David’s role also involves acting as the lynchpin
between Worldpay’s commercial and technical business
leaders by regularly engaging at the executive level. David
also manages cross-cultural teams in the analysis of
technical infrastructures and the delivery of innovative and
successful change programmes.
Srikanth Venkat is currently responsible for Security & Governance
portfolio of products at Hortonworks which include Apache Knox,
Apache Ranger, Apache Atlas, Platform wide security and
Hortonworks DataPlane Service. Prior to Hortonworks, Srikanth has
held multiple roles in areas of cloud services, marketplaces, security,
and business applications. His experience includes leadership across
Product Management, Strategy and Operations, and Technical
Architecture with broad experience in startups to global organizations
including Telefonica, Salesforce.com, Cisco-Webex, Proofpoint,
Dataguise, Trilogy Software, and Hewlett-Packard. Srikanth holds a
PhD in Engineering with a focus on Artificial Intelligence from
University of Pittsburgh, and an MBA in General Management from
Indiana University and a Masters in Global Management from
Thunderbird School of Global Management. Srikanth is a Data
Sciences & Machine Learning hobbyist and enjoys tinkering with Big
Data technologies.
For firms in the financial industry, especially within regulated organizations such as credit card processors and banks, PCI DSS compliance has become a business
and operational necessity. Although the blueprint of a PCI-compliant architecture varies from organization to organization, the mixture of modern Hadoop-based
data lakes and legacy systems are a common theme.
In this talk, we will discuss recent updates to PCI DSS and how significant portions of PCI DSS compliance controls can be achieved using open source Hadoop
security stack and technologies for the Hadoop ecosystem. We will provide a broad overview of implementing key aspects of PCI DSS standards at WorldPay such as
encryption management, data protection with anonymization, separation of duties, and deployment considerations regarding securing the Hadoop clusters at the
network layer from a practitioner’s perspective. The talk will provide patterns and practices map current Hadoop security capabilities to security controls that a PCI-
compliant environment requires.

3. 3 © Worldpay 2017. All rights reserved.3
Transactions Daily.
On average that’s per second.
merchants using >
payment methods & currencies
in countries and in the UK we
process % of all non-cash transactions
Worldpay In (Big) Numbers
In Store
Online
Mobile

4. 4 © Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.4
Data Security & Regulatory Compliance are both in the news …
… but in reality they are two sides of the same coin
Payment Card
Industry Data
Security Standards*
General
Data
Protection
Regulations
Payment Services
Directive 2*
Data
Protection
Act(s)
* Other industries have
their own standards but the
principle is the same

5. 5 © Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.5
So why is this good for business ?
• In a digital world the success of our business
(regardless of industry) will be significantly
defined by our organisations ability to handle
and use data responsibly throughout our
business. We must protect our customers and
business partners from both data misuse and
from fraud. In short we need to be trusted by
our customers in the ways that we handle their
information
• Legal & regulatory standards are being set by
governments, regulators and industry bodies in
an attempt to set a minimum sufficient
standard to protect data subjects

6. 6 © Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.6
How do you develop a secure platform
• Compliance is not lip-service to doing security
– the auditing for PCI DSS is rigorous and we
have to continuously review and upgrade our
systems to maintain compliance
• Audit of and compliance with these standards
is a way of demonstrating that we have taken
appropriate steps to protect our data assets –
and in the worst case scenario it is also a way
of mitigating the financial and reputational
impact of an incident.
Either start with a blank piece of paper …. … or adopt and commit to security framework

7. 7 © Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.7
Todays Hadoop Environments Are The Big Targets Within Your Organisation
• If you are building or have built a large successful Hadoop deployment
that contains a large amount of your business data then you have just
created a massive target within your organisation
• PCI DSS only certifies a project or implementation
• No single product can deliver a PCI DSS compliant solution
• As the implementers of a system we are looking to get the
greatest amount of compliance by deploying the smallest number
of products and tools to do the job

8. 8 © Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.8
First Some Historical Context
• The Worldpay journey to build a big data platform started in April 2015
• We started with HortonWorks 2.2
• The Hortonworks Data Platform Security document did not exist
• Apache Ranger was new, Apache Atlas was a concept, HortonWorks DataPlane wasn’t even a
twinkle
• Today we are on 2.6.4 and have applied nearly every release in between
• Across the entire software product stack we did 298 patch sets and upgrades in 2017
• Besides the core platform paying for support and deploying HortonWorks SmartSense
significantly improves your security profile
• We are also interested in:
• https://workbench.cisecurity.org – Center for Internet Security
• http://owasp.org – Open Web Application Security Project

9. 9 © Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.9
Even your fish tank is a risk
to you data platform(s)
• PCI is about putting in place the
• Security
• Logging of activity
• Audit of that security
• Separation of duties
• Patching Cycles
• Etc.
• And then maintaining them
• We are just finishing our 2018 PCI cycle
and start planning 2019 PCI cycle in
September

10. 10 © Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.10
The PCI DSS 3.2 Requirements
Goals PCI DSS 3.2 Requirement
Build and Maintain a Secure Network and
Systems
1. Install and maintain a firewall configuration to protect cardholder data
2. Do not use vendor-supplied defaults for system passwords and other security
parameters
Protect Cardholder Data 3. Protect stored cardholder data
4. Encrypt transmission of cardholder data across open, public networks
Maintain a Vulnerability Management
Program
5. Protect all systems against malware and regularly update antivirus software or programs
6. Develop and maintain secure systems and applications
Implement Strong Access Control
Measures
7. Restrict access to cardholder data by business need to know
8. Identify and authenticate access to system components
9. Restrict physical access to cardholder data
Regularly Monitor and Test Networks 10. Track and monitor all access to network resources and cardholder data
11. Regularly test security systems and processes
Maintain an Information Security Policy 12. Maintain a policy that addresses information security for all personnel

11. 11 © Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.11
Addressing The Requirements
1. Install and maintain a firewall configuration to
protect cardholder data
• The Worldpay network has defence in depth, much more than just firewalls including
virtualised jumpboxes and two factor authentication. Our network traffic is monitored
and logged
• Apache Knox is used to supplement perimeter security
2. Do not use vendor-supplied defaults for system
passwords and other security parameters
• Apache Ambari allows us to install, configure and manage the system passwords,
connection ports, certificates, etc.
• Apache Ambari is used to help implement Kerberos
• Keys stored in HSMs
3. Protect stored cardholder data • Hardware Encrypted Disks
• Apache Atlas is used to ‘tag’ columns as PCI or PII data
• Apache Atlas is used to mask data and/or remove data at run time
• Apache Ranger is used to restrict access to the data based on roles (RBAC)
• Apache Ranger is used to restrict access to the data based on attributes (ABAC)
• Apache Ranger is integrated to our LDAP/Active Directory
• Apache HDFS Transparent Data Encryption enabled
• HDFS ACLs enabled
• Microfocus SecureData (formerly HP Voltage) is used to either Tokenise or Encrypt
sensitive (PCI & PII) data
• Vormetric Disk Protection enabled

12. 12 © Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.12
Addressing The Requirements
4. Encrypt transmission of cardholder data
across open, public networks
• All of our components are use TLS 1.2 to encrypt network traffic – this has to be
supported by every HortonWorks component to be effective
5. Protect all systems against malware and
regularly update antivirus software or
programs
• Worldpay runs on Linux rather than Windows but we do still have anti-virus
• Worldpay implements File Integrity Management that checks critical files are not
being modified
• Regular patching of entire software stack including OS and all software packages
as patches and releases come out
• Worl;dpay limits what software can be downloaded and in stalled on an servers
• Hortonwork have/are specifically addressed vulnerabilities we have found
• Use Hortonworks SmartSense to ensure optimal configurations
6. Develop and maintain secure systems and
applications
• Worldpay peer reviews our code before deploying
• Worldpay developed code has to be scanned with tools like Vericode
• Worldpay develops to OWASP (Open Web Application Security Project) standards
for interfaces

13. 13 © Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.13
Addressing The Requirements
7. Restrict access to cardholder data by
business need to know
• Apache Ranger is used to restrict access to the data based on roles (RBAC)
• Apache Ranger is used to restrict access to the data based on attributes (ABAC)
8. Identify and authenticate access to system
components
• Kerberos enabled cluster
• Apache Ranger is integrated to our LDAP/Active Directory
• Apache Ranger implements user -> group -> role -> access relationship
9. Restrict physical access to cardholder data • Tightly restricted access to the data centres
• No disks returned on failure to the vendors
• Indirect server access via virtualised jumpboxes

14. 14 © Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.14
Addressing The Requirements
10. Track and monitor all access to network
resources and cardholder data
• Systems Access logged via Apache Ranger to Apache Solr and made available to
auditors
• All other Hortonworks audit functions also enabled
11. Regularly test security systems and
processes
• Worldpay ‘pentests’ systems regularly (i.e. on installation, after major changes
and annually) as part of the certification process
• The EDP Governance team defines and audits policies relating to security (as
well as other data management functions)
12. Maintain a policy that addresses
information security for all personnel
• Worldpay has a set of mandatory compliance training on PCI and other security
issues that has to be renewed each year by all employees

15. 15 © Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.15
Our 2.6.4 Components that help us create a PCI compliant system today

16. 16
Srikanth Venkat – Senior Director, Product Management
Security & Governance in HDP:
From a PCI-DSS Perspective

17. 17 © Hortonworks Inc. 2011 – 2016. All Rights Reserved
Authentication & API Security: Apache
Knox

18. 18
Apache Knox Overview
WebSSO
Authentication
And
Federation
providers
Groovy based
DSL
Client DSL/SDK Services
HTTP
Proxying
Services
UIs
REST
APIs
Web
Sockets
Hive
Ambari
HBase
WebHCa
t
WebHDFS
Authentication Services
Proxying
Services
KnoxShell
SDK
Token
Sessions
REST
API
Classes
KnoxSSO/Token
YARN
Range
r
Zeppeli
n
Oozie
Phoenix
Gremlin
JDBC/
ODBC
SAML
OAuth
LDAP/AD
SPNEGO
Header
Based
YARN
RM
WebHCa
tWebHDF
S
Hive
YARN
RM
HBase
Proxying Services
★ Provide access to Hadoop via proxying of
HTTP resources
★ Ecosystem APIs and UIs + Hadoop oriented
dispatching for Kerberos + doAs
(impersonation) etc.
Authentication Services
★ REST API access, WebSSO flow for UIs
★ LDAP/AD, Header based PreAuth, and
Token Exchange
★ Kerberos, SAML, OAuth
Client DSL/SDK Services
★ Scripting through DSL
★ Using Knox Shell classes directly as SDK
HDP Certified as
of HDP 2.6.4
Community
supported
Atlas
Oozie
Druid

19. 19 © Hortonworks Inc. 2011 – 2016. All Rights Reserved
Authentication: Kerberos

20. 20
Background: Kerberos
⬢ Strongly authenticating and establishing a user’s identity is the basis for secure
access in Hadoop
⬢ Users need to be able to reliably “identify” themselves and have identity
propagated throughout the Hadoop cluster
⬢ Design & implementation of Kerberos security in native Apache Hadoop was
delivered by Hortonworks co-founder Owen O’Malley!
⬢ Why Kerberos?
⬢ Establishes identity for clients, hosts and services
⬢ Prevents impersonation/passwords are never sent over the wire
⬢ Integrates w/ enterprise identity mgmt tools such as LDAP &Active Directory
⬢ More granular auditing of data access/job execution

21. 21
Background: HDP + Kerberos
Service
Component
A
Service
Component
B
HDP Cluster
KDC
keytabkeytab
Service
Component
C
keytab
Service
Component
D
keytab
Service
Component
X
Service
Component
X
keytabkeytab
Service
Component
X
keytab
Service
Component
X
keytab
Kerberos is used to
secure the
Components in the
cluster. Kerberos
identities are
managed via
“keytabs” on the
Component hosts.
Principals
for the
cluster are
managed in
the KDC.

22. 22
Automated Kerberos Setup with Ambari
 Wizard driven and automated Kerberos
support (kerberos principal creation for service
accounts, keytab generation and distribution
for appropriate hosts, permissions, etc.)
 Removes cumbersome, time consuming and
error prone administration of Kerberos
 Works with existing Kerberos infrastructure,
including Active Directory to automate
common tasks, removing the burden from the
operator:
• Add/Delete Host
• Add Service
• Add/Delete Component
• Regenerate Keytabs
• Disable Kerberos

23. 23
Kerberos + Active Directory
Page 23
Cross Realm Trust
Client
Hadoop Cluster
AD /
LDAP KDC
Users: smith@EXAMPLE.COM
Hosts: host1@HADOOP.EXAMPLE.COM
Services: hdfs/host1@HADOOP.EXAMPLE.COM
User Store
Use existing directory
tools to manage users
Use Kerberos tools to
manage host + service
principals
Authentication

24. 24 © Hortonworks Inc. 2011 – 2016. All Rights Reserved
Authorization & Audits: Apache Ranger

25. 25
Apache Ranger
• Central audit location for all
access requests
• Support multiple destination
sources (HDFS, Solr, etc.)
• Real-time visual query
interface
AuditingAuthorization
• Store and manage encryption
keys
• Support HDFS Transparent Data
Encryption
• Integration with HSM
• Safenet LUNA
Ranger KMS
• Centralized platform to define, administer
and manage security policies consistently
across Hadoop components
• HDFS, Hive, HBase, YARN, Kafka, Solr,
Storm, Knox, NiFi, Atlas
• Extensible Architecture
• Custom policy conditions, user
context enrichers
• Easy to add new component types
for authorization

26. 26
Ranger – ABAC Model
 ABAC Model
 Combination of the subject, action,
resource, and environment
 Uses descriptive attributes: AD group,
Apache Atlas-based tags or
classifications, geo-location, etc.
 Ranger approach is consistent with NIST
800-162
 Avoid role proliferation and
manageability issues

27. 27
Dynamic Row Filtering & Column Masking: Apache Ranger with Apache Hive
User 2: Ivanna
Location : EU
Group: HRUser 1: Joe
Location : US
Group: Analyst
Original Query:
SELECT country, nationalid,
ccnumber, mrn, name FROM
ww_customers
Country National
ID
CC No DOB MRN Name Policy ID
US 232323233 4539067047629850 9/12/1969 8233054331 John Doe nj23j424
US 333287465 5391304868205600 8/13/1979 3736885376 Jane Doe cadsd984
Germany T22000129 4532786256545550 3/5/1963 876452830A Ernie Schwarz KK-2345909
Country National ID CC No MR
N
Name
US xxxxx3233 4539 xxxx xxxx xxxx null John Doe
US xxxxx7465 5391 xxxx xxxx xxxx null Jane Doe
Ranger Policy Enforcement
Query Rewritten based on Dynamic Ranger
Policies: Filter rows by region & apply
relevant column masking
Users from US Analyst group see data
for US persons with CC and National ID
(SSN) as masked values and MRN is
nullified
Country National ID Name MRN
Germany T22000129 Ernie
Schwarz
876452830A
EU HR Policy Admins can see
unmasked but are restricted
by row filtering policies to
see data for EU persons only
Original Query:
SELECT country, nationalid,
name, mrn FROM
ww_customers
Analysts
HR Marketing

28. 28 © Hortonworks Inc. 2011 – 2016. All Rights Reserved
Data Protection

29. 29
Data Protection in Hadoop
must be applied at three different layers in
Apache Hadoop
Storage: encrypt data while it is at rest
Transparent Data Encryption in HDFS, Ranger KMS + HSM, Partner
Products (HPE Voltage, Protegrity, Dataguise)
Transmission: encrypt data as it is in motion
Native Apache Hadoop 2.0 provides wire encryption.
Upon Access: apply restrictions when accessed
Ranger (Dynamic Column Masking + Row Filtering), Partner Masking +
Encryption
Data Protection

30. 30
Data Protection – Layered
Approach
• Encryption of Data at Rest
– OS Level Encryption (LUKS)
– Certified Partners for volume encryption (e.g: Vormetric (Thales) Protegrity, HPE Voltage Security)
– HDFS TDE file/folder level encryption with keys managed by Ranger KMS, External HSM integration
• Encryption of Data on the Wire
– All wire protocols can be encrypted by HDP platform
– Wire-level encryption enhancements (SSL).
• Granular Data Protection
– Dynamic Masking + Row Filtering for Hive with Ranger
– Classification Based Security with Ranger + Atlas
– Element level encryption/masking from certified partners (HPE Voltage, Protegrity)

31. 31
Ranger KMS
Transparent Data Encryption in HDFS
NN
A B
C D
HDFS Client
A B
C D
A B
C D
DN DN DN
Benefits
 Selective encryption of relevant files/folders
 Prevent rogue admin access to sensitive data
 Fine grained access controls
 Transparent to end application w/o changes
 Ranger KMS integrated to external HSM
(Safenet Luna) adding to reliability/security of
KMS
SafeNet-
Luna HSM

32. 32
HSM integration with Ranger KMS
 HSM client needs to be setup in
KMS nodes
 When installing Ranger KMS, HSM
parameters can be specified
 If KMS is already installed with DB,
Master key can be migrated to HSM
 All other TDE functionality remains
unchanged

33. 33
HSM integration with Ranger KMS
Only master key
will be in HSM
Other keys stored
in Ranger KMS DB

34. 34 © Hortonworks Inc. 2011 – 2016. All Rights Reserved
Governance with Apache Atlas

35. 35
Apache Atlas Vision: Open Metadata & Governance Services
STRUCTURED
TRADITIONAL
RDBMS
METADATA
MPP
APPLIANCES
Kafka Storm
Sqoop
Hive
ATLAS
METADATA
Falcon
RANGER
Custom
Partners
Comprehensive Enterprise Data Catalog
• Lists all of your data, where it is located, its origin (lineage), owner, structure,
meaning, classification and quality
• Integrate both on-premise and cloud platforms to provide enterprise wide view
Open Enterprise Data Connectors
• Interoperable connector framework to connect to your data catalog out of the
box with many vendor technologies
• No expensive population of proprietary siloed metadata repositories
Dynamic Metadata Discovery
• Metadata is added automatically to the catalog as new data is created or data is
updated
• Extensible discovery processes that characterize and classify the data
Enabling Collaboration & Workflows
• Subject matter experts locate the data they need quickly and efficiently, share
their knowledge about the data and its usage to help others
• Interested parties and processes are notified automatically
Automated Governance Processes
• Metadata-driven access control
• Auditing, metering, and monitoring
• Quality control and exception management
• Rights (entitlement) management
Predefined standards for glossaries, data schemas, rules and regulations
Vision:
Metadata-driven foundational
governance services for enterprise data
ecosystem
• Open frameworks and APIs
• Agile and secure collaboration around data and advanced
analytics
• Reduce operational costs while extracting economic value
of data

36. 36
HDP – Security & Governance
Classification
Prohibition
Time
Location
Policies
PDP
Resource
Cache
Ranger
Manage Access Policies
and Audit Logs
Track Metadata
and Lineage
Atlas Client
Subscribers
to Topic
Gets Metadata
Updates
Atlas
Metastore
Tags
Assets
Entitles
Streams
Pipelines
Feeds
Hive
Tables
HDFS
Files
HBase
Tables
Entities
in Data
Lake
Industry First: Dynamic Tag-based Security Policies

37. 37
Walk Through

38. 38
Walk Through Items
⬢ Ranger
⬢ ABAC Fine Grained Security
⬢ Resource/Masking/Row Filtering Policies
⬢ Audits – self audits/access/plugin audits, logins
⬢ User/Group/Roles in Ranger
⬢ Atlas
⬢ Search and tag assets
⬢ Tag Attributes
⬢ Tag based policies in Ranger

39. 39 © Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.39
WorldPay – Hortonworks Partnership
• WorldPay has partnered closely with Hortonworks to
improve security and governance features across HDP and
to certify their internal platforms for PCI-DSS
• Collaboration has resulted in the community enhancements
via Apache Knox, Apache Ranger, and Apache Atlas, wire
encryption & TDE
• Ongoing collaboration on HDP platform security fixes from
external audits
• Key learnings incorporated into Hortonworks DataPlane
Service – Data Steward Studio (DSS)

40. 40
© Worldpay 2018. All rights reserved.
Leaders in Modern Money
Innovating In Secure Modern Data Analytics
Thank You
David M Walker (david.walker@worldpay.com)
Enterprise Data Platform Programme Director, Worldpay
Srikanth Venkat
Senior Director, Product Management, Hortonworks