The document discusses leveraging technology for community consultation and engagement. It provides an example of how the City of Kingston used technology throughout their LivingKingston2035 consultation process to create broader awareness, increase participation, and manage and derive value from the large amount of data collected. Over 6,000 community members participated, providing over 13,500 ideas. Technology allowed effective sorting and analysis of this data to inform decision making. Lessons from this case study emphasize planning technology use, making data central, and preparing for open data initiatives.
Digital Inclusion and Meaningful Broadband Adoption Initiatives Colin Rhinesm...Ed Dodds
This report presents findings from a national study of digital inclusion organizations that help low-income individuals and families adopt high-speed Internet service. The study looked at eight digital inclusion organizations across the United States that are working at the important intersection between making high-speed Internet available and strengthening digital skills—two essential and interrelated components of digital inclusion, which is focused on increasing digital access, skills, and relevant content.
Innovation Accelerators:
Defining Characteristics Among Startup Assistance Organizations by C. Scott Dempwolf, Jennifer Auer, and
Michelle D’Ippolito
Optimal Solutions Group, LLC
College Park, MD 20740
contract number SBAHQ -13-M-0197
Release Date: October 2014
This report was developed under a contract with the Small Business Administration, Office of Advocacy, and contains information and analysis that were reviewed by officials of the Office of Advocacy. However, the final conclusions of the report do not necessarily reflect the views of the Office of Advocacy.
Cary Technology Task Force (TTF) Final Report December 2012Ian Henshaw
Mission Statement
Determine how the Town’s use of technology services can better serve its citizens. Specifically, the TTF shall review, evaluate, and prioritize new and emerging technologies that will facilitate better engagement, citizen outreach, and service delivery by increasing involvement and lowering costs, with the overall goal of making it easier for citizens to communicate with the Town and consume available information.
From the ideal to the real: Top 20 lessons learned from scaling up innovation...Soren Gigler
Top 20 lessons learned on scaling up innovations from the Open Data Initiative at the World Bank. The Open Data Initiative has transformed the way the World Bank shares and publishes its data enabling users to have free, open and easy access to data instead of a previously mostly proprietary data policy.
How did such a radical change come about? How was it possible that our early very modest endeavors to implement innovations in governance could be scaled up and be replicated across so many different areas at the Bank? How could a vibrant community of innovators from within and outside the Bank come together share experiences, learn from each other and, most important, help to make an important institutional change -- launch an Open Data initiative and empower citizens to provide direct feedback on development programs?
Engaging Times: 20 Years of E-Democracy LessonsSteven Clift
Key lessons from twenty years of e-democracy, open government, civic technology, and citizen participation online.
Extended slide deck combining almost all slides used by Steven Clift across 14 presentations across Taiwan and the Philippines to different audiences.
Digital Inclusion and Meaningful Broadband Adoption Initiatives Colin Rhinesm...Ed Dodds
This report presents findings from a national study of digital inclusion organizations that help low-income individuals and families adopt high-speed Internet service. The study looked at eight digital inclusion organizations across the United States that are working at the important intersection between making high-speed Internet available and strengthening digital skills—two essential and interrelated components of digital inclusion, which is focused on increasing digital access, skills, and relevant content.
Innovation Accelerators:
Defining Characteristics Among Startup Assistance Organizations by C. Scott Dempwolf, Jennifer Auer, and
Michelle D’Ippolito
Optimal Solutions Group, LLC
College Park, MD 20740
contract number SBAHQ -13-M-0197
Release Date: October 2014
This report was developed under a contract with the Small Business Administration, Office of Advocacy, and contains information and analysis that were reviewed by officials of the Office of Advocacy. However, the final conclusions of the report do not necessarily reflect the views of the Office of Advocacy.
Cary Technology Task Force (TTF) Final Report December 2012Ian Henshaw
Mission Statement
Determine how the Town’s use of technology services can better serve its citizens. Specifically, the TTF shall review, evaluate, and prioritize new and emerging technologies that will facilitate better engagement, citizen outreach, and service delivery by increasing involvement and lowering costs, with the overall goal of making it easier for citizens to communicate with the Town and consume available information.
From the ideal to the real: Top 20 lessons learned from scaling up innovation...Soren Gigler
Top 20 lessons learned on scaling up innovations from the Open Data Initiative at the World Bank. The Open Data Initiative has transformed the way the World Bank shares and publishes its data enabling users to have free, open and easy access to data instead of a previously mostly proprietary data policy.
How did such a radical change come about? How was it possible that our early very modest endeavors to implement innovations in governance could be scaled up and be replicated across so many different areas at the Bank? How could a vibrant community of innovators from within and outside the Bank come together share experiences, learn from each other and, most important, help to make an important institutional change -- launch an Open Data initiative and empower citizens to provide direct feedback on development programs?
Engaging Times: 20 Years of E-Democracy LessonsSteven Clift
Key lessons from twenty years of e-democracy, open government, civic technology, and citizen participation online.
Extended slide deck combining almost all slides used by Steven Clift across 14 presentations across Taiwan and the Philippines to different audiences.
My sCool Server Brochure - Portrait layoutShrenik Bhura
A brief introduction to Recherche Tech and our flagship product, the My sCool Server - Linux powered teaching solution.
Recherche Tech, with its My sCool Server offering aims to usher in a socioeconomic revolution by making computer literacy and therefore digital inclusion affordable and achievable across the social strata.
My sCool Server is a device, primarily for school labs, that makes all computers in the wired network usable and useful instantly.
It is the next generation in computing and learning convenience. It has been custom built and packaged, keeping in mind the challenges faced by schools and students in the ever evolving, fast-paced literary landscape.
It is an optimised combination of hardware and software built upon proven technologies that our core team has command over for more than 20 man years.
Herein are some of the advantages that the MSS presents to its users:
A1 No knowledge of installing, configuring, or updating Linux required. The teaching process can start immediately in conjunction with the textbook content.
A2 Broadcast lessons to each student's desk. Close monitoring, one-to-one communication and attention to every student's progress is possible.
A3 Extends lifespan of existing systems. Save on power and AMC. Channelise funds to infrastructure and training activities.
A4 Now buy many more end user systems for the same budget. Laboratories can be re-laid to accommodate more machines.
A5 Helps create live copies of the Linux OS and applications to practice the lessons at home and explore Linux completely.
A6 Requires no installation of any additional modules or purchasing custom client hardware from a particular vendor.
A7 An integrated platform to host training web-content offline. No internet required to access 5000+ world-class audio-visual resources.
A8 Restore the MSS to its fully functional state with a few button presses without complicated re-installation or re-configuration steps.
A9 No limitations of users who can use the MSS. Delivering high productivity and promoting creativity is the only mission.
A10 Teacher can work in Windows OS and yet simultaneously monitor the students over the Linux environment.
A11 The technologies comprising the product are proven the world across. Recherche team has 20+ man years of open source solutioning expertise.
A12 Internet is rapidly reaching to each corner of the country. MSS is designed to meet the future needs of secure internet access and sharing.
To know more, visit http://www.myscoolserver.com .
Colombia's Colnodo has a strong network of partnerships that allow the organization to diversificate, increase its impact and leverage different technologies. Colnodo's leadership provides a detail explanation of the model, along with recommendations for implementation.
Series of Leading Change slides illustrate an aspect of my resume, namely a range of early professional experiments related to advancing--in small ways--sources of government innovation: transparency, collaboration, public participation and organization design.
Online Communities at EuroPCom - Steven Clift KHub.Net and E-Democracy.orgSteven Clift
Online Communities of Practice presentation at EuroPCom - European Conference for Public Communication by Steven Clift. Mixes lessons from UK-based Knowledge Hub http://khub.net with a few relevant experiences via http://E-Democracy.org
lessons in Gov 2.0: building strategy from the inside outPatrick McCormick
In the seminar, Pat will share his experience and provide an overview of:
the application of social media to the business of government and engagement with citizens
developing a strategic approach to using social media as well as supporting a culture of collaboration.
Pat\'s presentation will draw on a range of practical Gov 2.0 examples in the Department of Justice such as Fire Ready mobile applications, Championship Moves, Cameras Cut Crashes, and the Sentencing Advisory Council.
Digital Routes to Integration : How civic tech innovations are supporting ref...betterplace lab
The arrival of over one million refugees in Germany in 2015-16 sparked an intense wave of civic engagement. Scores of innovative digital projects were created to coordinate this engagement and support the process of refugee integration. Two years on we asked – what has happened to these projects? And what potential do digital approaches have for refugee integration? This report is a product of our research, comprising 78 interviews with digital projects, refugees and volunteers.
Presentation by Andrea Bohn, University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign
In collaboration with:
Mark Bell, University of California at Davis
Shahid Akbar, Bangladesh Institute for ICT in Development
Phil Malone, Access Agriculture
Plenary Session: Extension in ICT Overdrive
on 6 Nov 2013
ICT4Ag, Kigali, Rwanda
Ann Treacy and MIke O'Connor talk about broadband and give advice to the incoming MInnesota Broadband Task Force on planning for broadband in the state from reliability to ubiquity to speed...
London data and digital masterclass for councillors slides 14-Feb-20LG Inform Plus
On 14th February 2020, the Local Government association ran a masterclass discussion day for councillors and elected members on data and digital transformation in local government. It took place in London. This is the slide set that was used to steer discussions
My sCool Server Brochure - Portrait layoutShrenik Bhura
A brief introduction to Recherche Tech and our flagship product, the My sCool Server - Linux powered teaching solution.
Recherche Tech, with its My sCool Server offering aims to usher in a socioeconomic revolution by making computer literacy and therefore digital inclusion affordable and achievable across the social strata.
My sCool Server is a device, primarily for school labs, that makes all computers in the wired network usable and useful instantly.
It is the next generation in computing and learning convenience. It has been custom built and packaged, keeping in mind the challenges faced by schools and students in the ever evolving, fast-paced literary landscape.
It is an optimised combination of hardware and software built upon proven technologies that our core team has command over for more than 20 man years.
Herein are some of the advantages that the MSS presents to its users:
A1 No knowledge of installing, configuring, or updating Linux required. The teaching process can start immediately in conjunction with the textbook content.
A2 Broadcast lessons to each student's desk. Close monitoring, one-to-one communication and attention to every student's progress is possible.
A3 Extends lifespan of existing systems. Save on power and AMC. Channelise funds to infrastructure and training activities.
A4 Now buy many more end user systems for the same budget. Laboratories can be re-laid to accommodate more machines.
A5 Helps create live copies of the Linux OS and applications to practice the lessons at home and explore Linux completely.
A6 Requires no installation of any additional modules or purchasing custom client hardware from a particular vendor.
A7 An integrated platform to host training web-content offline. No internet required to access 5000+ world-class audio-visual resources.
A8 Restore the MSS to its fully functional state with a few button presses without complicated re-installation or re-configuration steps.
A9 No limitations of users who can use the MSS. Delivering high productivity and promoting creativity is the only mission.
A10 Teacher can work in Windows OS and yet simultaneously monitor the students over the Linux environment.
A11 The technologies comprising the product are proven the world across. Recherche team has 20+ man years of open source solutioning expertise.
A12 Internet is rapidly reaching to each corner of the country. MSS is designed to meet the future needs of secure internet access and sharing.
To know more, visit http://www.myscoolserver.com .
Colombia's Colnodo has a strong network of partnerships that allow the organization to diversificate, increase its impact and leverage different technologies. Colnodo's leadership provides a detail explanation of the model, along with recommendations for implementation.
Series of Leading Change slides illustrate an aspect of my resume, namely a range of early professional experiments related to advancing--in small ways--sources of government innovation: transparency, collaboration, public participation and organization design.
Online Communities at EuroPCom - Steven Clift KHub.Net and E-Democracy.orgSteven Clift
Online Communities of Practice presentation at EuroPCom - European Conference for Public Communication by Steven Clift. Mixes lessons from UK-based Knowledge Hub http://khub.net with a few relevant experiences via http://E-Democracy.org
lessons in Gov 2.0: building strategy from the inside outPatrick McCormick
In the seminar, Pat will share his experience and provide an overview of:
the application of social media to the business of government and engagement with citizens
developing a strategic approach to using social media as well as supporting a culture of collaboration.
Pat\'s presentation will draw on a range of practical Gov 2.0 examples in the Department of Justice such as Fire Ready mobile applications, Championship Moves, Cameras Cut Crashes, and the Sentencing Advisory Council.
Digital Routes to Integration : How civic tech innovations are supporting ref...betterplace lab
The arrival of over one million refugees in Germany in 2015-16 sparked an intense wave of civic engagement. Scores of innovative digital projects were created to coordinate this engagement and support the process of refugee integration. Two years on we asked – what has happened to these projects? And what potential do digital approaches have for refugee integration? This report is a product of our research, comprising 78 interviews with digital projects, refugees and volunteers.
Presentation by Andrea Bohn, University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign
In collaboration with:
Mark Bell, University of California at Davis
Shahid Akbar, Bangladesh Institute for ICT in Development
Phil Malone, Access Agriculture
Plenary Session: Extension in ICT Overdrive
on 6 Nov 2013
ICT4Ag, Kigali, Rwanda
Ann Treacy and MIke O'Connor talk about broadband and give advice to the incoming MInnesota Broadband Task Force on planning for broadband in the state from reliability to ubiquity to speed...
London data and digital masterclass for councillors slides 14-Feb-20LG Inform Plus
On 14th February 2020, the Local Government association ran a masterclass discussion day for councillors and elected members on data and digital transformation in local government. It took place in London. This is the slide set that was used to steer discussions
Una guia de coses importants que cal recordar i que permeten que la creació i la gestió d'una empresa tinguin moltes probabilitats de tenir èxit.
Recull a partir de formació pròpia i d'experiència d'altres usuaris.
Road to Government 2.0: Technological Problems and Solutions for Transparency...Daniel X. O'Neil
See more at: http://www.aspeninstitute.org/publications/road-government-20-technological-problems-solutions-transparency-efficiency
Greg Ferenstein
March 14, 2013
The 2012 FOCAS convened 38 leaders and developers from government, media and communications enterprises, localities, consumer/user groups and academia to define the problems of open and innovative governance and develop solutions. Road to Government 2.0: Technological Problems and Solutions for Transparency, Efficiency and Participation, summarizes the insights, initiatives and recommendations emanating from the Forum. The report, written by Forum rapporteur Greg Ferenstein, describes the origins of the open government movement, provides a discussion of the meaningful open governance efforts around the world and then addresses a number of serious shortcomings and subsequent solutions in open government. The recommendations include measures to enhance public awareness and media engagement, modifications to the government procurement process and an emphasis on useful participatory government to help improve information flow, communication and citizen interactions.
- See more at: http://www.aspeninstitute.org/publications/road-government-20-technological-problems-solutions-transparency-efficiency#sthash.tRU6v1Qu.dpuf
National e-participation environment presentation by Niklas Wilhelmsson, Ministry of Justice, Finland - Unit for Democracy, Language Affairs and Fundamental Rights. Steven Clit's slides from the same event here: https://db.tt/BOhhQ0Ex
1. Session One: Leveraging Technology, Thursday 1 May, 2014
Robyn Cochrane, Fergal Coleman and Sarah Bishop
1
New Voices, Better Communities
Leveraging Technology to Enhance Community Consultation and Engagement
With an ever evolving demand for service provision at the Local Government level and the
continued push to do more with less, there has never been a more critical time to engage the
community in decision making.
Community engagement professionals recognise that effective consultation is often labour-
intensive, involves substantial costs and presents a variety of challenges. However,
advances in technology over the last five years have provided the sector with opportunities
to engage and consult faster and broader than ever before – and reach the people beyond
just the ‘loudest’ voices.
Traditional public meetings and written submissions alone are becoming less and less
relevant to communities today that are digitally enabled, time-poor and increasingly mobile.
The convenience of technology provides more opportunities to participate at any time, from
any place.
The community’s expectations are changing…
The private sector is leading the way when it comes to harnessing the power of digital
innovation, for example Michael Hart, CIO of the Commonwealth Bank has been quoted
saying that the CBA now conducts 95 percent of its transactions over the Internet.1
Similarly,
sites like Amazon.com allow people to buy and sell anywhere, anytime, make user-specific
product recommendations and provide 24 hour online assistance. Services are constantly
evolving to meet the expectations of their customers.
As a result, people now expect to have the same online experience with their Council,
whether it is customer service, program and service delivery or community consultation.
This presents challenges for Local Government trying to keep up with the community’s
changing expectations, the pace of technological change and how to manage and get the
most value from the large volumes of data now being generated.
“In the past we (local government) told the community what we were doing, we have now
evolved to engaging the community in what we propose to do, but the expectation of the
community today is that not only will they be engaged but they will directly influence and will
have control over what happens. This is not an unreasonable expectation.”
– John Nevins, CEO, City of Kingston.
How do we use technology to effectively reach our community, harness their insight
and use it to enhance productivity and deliver ongoing value?
Experience with the LivingKingston2035 project demonstrates three ways technology can
enhance consultation and engagement:
1. To create broader awareness about issues or consultations;
2. To increase reach and opportunities for participation; and
3. To manage, draw meaning and derive ongoing value from data.
1 Malcolm Turnbull, Minister for Communications. AIIA Speech: Navigating Analytics Summit, 20 March,
2014.
2. Session One: Leveraging Technology, Thursday 1 May, 2014
Robyn Cochrane, Fergal Coleman and Sarah Bishop
2
Case Study: LivingKingston2035
Throughout 2012, the City of Kingston undertook the most significant community
consultation in its history to inform the development of a shared vision for the municipality of
Kingston (located in Victoria) looking towards 2035. The project, Living Kingston 2035,
involved a 12-month staged consultation period from 1 January to 31 December 2012.
Key goals from the outset were to work in a genuine partnership with the community to
create a shared vision; embrace best practice public participation principles - inform, consult,
involve, collaborate and empower; and to embed technology throughout the entire
consultation.
Creating awareness and increasing participation
Technology was utilised to enhance the consultation at every stage:
By the end of the project over 6,000 community
members had participated. In total over 13,500
individual Like, Improve and Wish ideas were
submitted.
The use of technology in the consultation period
significantly increased the level of awareness and
participation, but also presented the
challenge of how to manage and draw
meaning from all the data.
3. Session One: Leveraging Technology, Thursday 1 May, 2014
Robyn Cochrane, Fergal Coleman and Sarah Bishop
3
Deriving ongoing value from the data
Using technology, a special data-management
software called NVivo, every one of the 13,500
ideas were accurately recorded and coded.
This allowed the data to be sorted and
analysed by a range of segments and
demographics.
Not only did this inform the development of the
25 year vision narrative and four-year Council
Plan, but now provides the City of Kingston with
ongoing access to an interactive community
knowledge bank.
Today this resource is still being used to inform other operational and planning processes
thereby maximising the organisational return on investment in the consultation.
Using the technology, a series of reports with varying levels of detail were also generated
and released to the community, as is best practice in the public participation sphere. Making
the data publicly accessible empowers individuals, government agencies, local service
providers, private industry and community organisations with information to develop products
and services that the community wants and needs. This is in line with State and Federal
Government open data initiatives (e.g. http://data.gov.au).
Lessons from LivingKingston2035:
Tips for Conducting a Successful Technology Enabled Consultation
1. Think people first, just in new channels
Design the consultation approach to suit the people you want to hear from. It’s no longer
realistic to expect people to come to a physical meeting or use a single online tool of
your choice. Find the online channels they are using and develop a technology plan in
tandem with the overall project plan to align online and offline activities to broaden
participation.
2. Personalise for your community, take them on your journey
Use branding, language and images that appeal to your community and consider the use
of community ambassadors to give a local face to the consultation. Video content works
well to add a more personal and conversational tone and can significantly improve
understanding. Relentlessly market the project via a broad range of communication
channels through every stage of the project to keep momentum.
3. Take time to plan and scope each step
Carefully consider each step in the online consultation process, take the time to map the
journey from the users perspective, is it easy to understand and simple to use? Ensure
security of personal details and privacy and use analytics to measure and understand
what works. Carefully investigate technology suppliers, open source or industry standard
solutions are preferable.
4. Make data central to every consultation
Plan how you will collect, store, analyse and use the data. Capture participant
demographic data to describe and profile participants (online and offline), re-use the
consultation data for other planning and decision-making purposes, and adopt a practice
of ‘open data’ by making the data publicly available.
4. Session One: Leveraging Technology, Thursday 1 May, 2014
Robyn Cochrane, Fergal Coleman and Sarah Bishop
4
5. Prepare for the future: open source, open data, open standards
The open government world is growing worldwide. It can save your organisation a lot of
money and allow you to harness the skills of a worldwide community for the benefit of
your stakeholders. Make sure you start developing your understanding of open source,
open data and open standards within your IT and communication departments.
Questions to consider
How well is your organisation leveraging technology in consultation to enhance
productivity?
How much will your organisation spend on community consultation in 2013-14? Do you
have an organisation-wide online consultation model?
Are your consultations reaching enough people and providing a mix of participation
options? Are you gathering a broad range of views and confidently making decisions
based on solid community evidence?
Is data central to every consultation with the community? What happens with the data–
how are you collecting, analysing and storing it? Are you deriving ongoing value
internally or releasing it to the community?
Further information and resources
Detailed information about how technology was embedded in every
stage of the LivingKingston2035 project is available in the working
paper “Best Practice Community Consultation: How to embed
technology in consultation to broaden participation”.
Further information about how NVivo was used to manage, sort and
generate reports from the LivingKingston2035 consultation data is
available in the working paper “LivingKingston2035: Creating an
informed vision with NVivo”.
Please contact Robyn, Fergal or Sarah for a copy, or connect with us on
LinkedIn.
Other useful resources
Living Kingston 2035: www.livingkingston.com.au
Australian Government (open public datasets): www.data.gov.au
Idea Scale (online crowd sourcing): www.ideascale.com
International Association of Public Participation (IAP2): www.iap2.org.au
NVivo data analysis software program: www.qsrinternational.com
5. Session One: Leveraging Technology, Thursday 1 May, 2014
Robyn Cochrane, Fergal Coleman and Sarah Bishop
5
Contact us
Sarah Bishop was the Communications and Public Affairs Manager at the City of Kingston
during the LivingKingston2035 project. She is now Director of Activate Consulting
specialising in strategic communications, community engagement and reputation
management. Sarah is passionate about helping organisations achieve their objectives by
improving communication with their people, key stakeholders and community.
Contact:
sarah@activatepeople.com
au.linkedin.com/in/sarahbishopau/
0403 214 449
Dr. Robyn Cochrane led the City of Kingston’s Living Kingston 2035 project. Robyn is Lead
Researcher for Cochrane Research Solutions, currently works with Monash University and
has a background in local government, vocational education and training and community
sectors. Robyn’s strengths include: qualitative and quantitative research; online and
traditional community consultation approaches and employee engagement.
Contact:
robyncoc@bigpond.net.au
au.linkedin.com/in/robyncochrane
0438 072 280
Fergal Coleman is a Director of Symphony3, a Melbourne based IT Consulting Firm. He
specialises in digital strategy and communications and is passionate about helping his
government clients to create successful digital strategies and develop social media
strategies that deliver community outcomes. Fergal has extensive experience facilitating
workshops and delivering training on digital strategy, social media and online business.
Contact:
Fergal.coleman@symphony3.com
au.linkedin.com/in/fergalcoleman/
0423 198 184
Acknowledgment
We would like to acknowledge the City of Kingston for granting permission to use its material
in this paper and commend the community inspired leadership shown by the City of Kingston
in undertaking this project.
For further information about the ongoing implementation of the LivingKingston2035 vision,
please contact the Performance Planning Department at the City of Kingston on 1300 356
653.