SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Narváez and the Feast of Toxcatl
The Narváez distraction Cortés learns of an army led by Panfílo de Narváez with the objective to remove Cortés from command in Mexico. At the beginning of May of that year, Cortés takes a portion of his force to meet Narváez and hopefully defeat his army. He leaves a small garrison of men under Pedro de Alvarado in Tenochtitlan to hold the city and maintain power over the indigenous people. Cortés attacks Narváez' camp, taking Narváezand some of his loyal troops prisoner, while adding the bulk of Narváez' soldiers to his cause1.
The Feast of Toxcatl While Cortés is out dealing with Narváez, many priests, nobles, and warriors gathered in honor of Toxcatl and prepared for a feast and the ceremonies that would follow. Sometime during the ceremony, a fight breaks out, and many of the Mexicans are killed. Cortés then returns to Tenochtitlan and faces the repercussions of the conflict. There are three different accounts of what happened that night, each offering their own version of the truth.
Cortés’ account Cortés' story of the conflict at the Feast of Toxcatl is very brief and vague. Because he has just finished dealing with the Narváez problem, he sends a messenger to Tenochtitlan to tell Alvarado that he is returning as the victor. The messenger arrives twelve days later and tells Cortés that the Mexicans have attacked the small number of troops that Cortés left behind2. We, however, must be very wary of Cortés' account due to the audience of his accounts. Writing for the royalty of Spain, Cortés kept the things that would make him look bad to a minimum. He needed a clean record and justification for all of his actions in order to be in a better position to receive a good portion of the spoils once the conquest was over. He is stated as writing "They were in dire need and I must, for the love of God, come to their aid“3. Obviously exaggerating the importance of himself, Cortés is not one whose words we can take at face value.
Díaz’ account Díaz was with Cortés in the showdown against Narváez, but has a different account of the slaughter at the Feast of Toxcatl. Just after arriving back at Tenochtitlan, Díaz writes of a conversation between Cortés and Alvarado. Alvarado explains that the Mexicans had asked him for permission to hold a festival in honor of Toxcatl, and that Alvarado gave them the authorization to do so. Alvarado says he then got "positive information" that the Mexicans would attack and sacrifice the Spaniards after the festival was completed. In order to gain surprise and prevent the Mexicans from attacking them, Alvarado struck first. Cortés then told Alvarado that he had made a mistake, the result of which is the eventual expulsion of the Spaniards from Tenochtitlan4
Díaz’ account cont. We are allowed to believe more in Díaz' account than Cortés' because Díaz does not just pass this off. He presents his story from the perspective of overhearing the conversation between Cortés and Alvarado. Adding more credit to his side, Díaz writes his account years after the conquest when he was an old man, and stood to gain little from writing the book. Audience is much less important to him than it was for Cortés. Whether the Mexicans attacked the Spanish first or the Spanish attacked the Mexicans first does not affect him at all, so there would be less importance for him to use anything but what he thinks is the truth. What little bias we can assume would be against the Spanish government itself for failing to adequately reward the soldiers in the Conquest of Mexico. It is a small but not unimportant trifle that may have had some effect writing his account.
Mexican account Lastly, we have the Mexican account in the form of the Florentine Codex, compiled by Bernardino de Sahagún. In the Codex, it seems that the Mexicans were singing and dancing when all of a sudden the Spanish walked in dressed for war, sealed all the exits, and started cutting people down like trees5. In the Codex there is no evidence of a plot by the Mexicans to fight the Spanish, contradicting both Díaz and Cortés. The similarity between Díaz and the Florentine Codex is the report that the Spanish initiated the skirmish, which is one of the key events in this period.
Mexican account cont. The Florentine Codex tells a different story, one where the innocent are slaughtered for no reason. This may or may not be true. What we can think about, however, is the reason for the people who contributed to the Florentine Codex to think that way. Since all of those who lent their memories to the Codex were Mexican, one can guess that there would be at least a little anti-Spanish bias in their stories. Also important is the fact that the Mexicans did not "win" in the Conquest. This leads us to believe that they were harboring ill thoughts towards their conquerors, painting the Spanish as ruthless killers.
Endnotes 1 Díaz, 281-283 2 Cortés, 128 3 Cortés, 128 4 Díaz, 285-286 5 Sahagún, 296-297

More Related Content

What's hot

Seven myths of the spanish conquest
Seven myths of the spanish conquestSeven myths of the spanish conquest
Seven myths of the spanish conquest
chelseaengland
 
Mesoamerican conquistadors
Mesoamerican conquistadorsMesoamerican conquistadors
Mesoamerican conquistadors
dennis129
 
Seven myths of the spanish conquest
Seven myths of the spanish conquestSeven myths of the spanish conquest
Seven myths of the spanish conquest
Tricia Fonseca
 
Sevenmyths
SevenmythsSevenmyths
Sevenmyths
aaroncito619
 
Seven myths of the spanish conquest
Seven myths of the spanish conquestSeven myths of the spanish conquest
Seven myths of the spanish conquest
tbeez44
 
Indian conqistadors
Indian conqistadorsIndian conqistadors
Indian conqistadors
boldeagle3
 
Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest
Seven Myths of the Spanish ConquestSeven Myths of the Spanish Conquest
Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest
smacedo372
 
Noche Triste
Noche TristeNoche Triste
Noche Triste
Obi
 
Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest
Seven Myths of the Spanish ConquestSeven Myths of the Spanish Conquest
Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest
Palomar College
 
Indian conquistadores
Indian conquistadoresIndian conquistadores
Indian conquistadores
Megan Beaver
 

What's hot (10)

Seven myths of the spanish conquest
Seven myths of the spanish conquestSeven myths of the spanish conquest
Seven myths of the spanish conquest
 
Mesoamerican conquistadors
Mesoamerican conquistadorsMesoamerican conquistadors
Mesoamerican conquistadors
 
Seven myths of the spanish conquest
Seven myths of the spanish conquestSeven myths of the spanish conquest
Seven myths of the spanish conquest
 
Sevenmyths
SevenmythsSevenmyths
Sevenmyths
 
Seven myths of the spanish conquest
Seven myths of the spanish conquestSeven myths of the spanish conquest
Seven myths of the spanish conquest
 
Indian conqistadors
Indian conqistadorsIndian conqistadors
Indian conqistadors
 
Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest
Seven Myths of the Spanish ConquestSeven Myths of the Spanish Conquest
Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest
 
Noche Triste
Noche TristeNoche Triste
Noche Triste
 
Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest
Seven Myths of the Spanish ConquestSeven Myths of the Spanish Conquest
Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest
 
Indian conquistadores
Indian conquistadoresIndian conquistadores
Indian conquistadores
 

Viewers also liked

Plc West Bladen
Plc West BladenPlc West Bladen
Plc West Bladen
aboyette
 
New zealand power point
New zealand power pointNew zealand power point
New zealand power point
knoxmaths
 
Compro absolute eo & ph
Compro absolute eo & phCompro absolute eo & ph
Compro absolute eo & ph
ibenk_nich
 
Headaches: What a Pain!
Headaches: What a Pain!Headaches: What a Pain!
Headaches: What a Pain!
Nia Rennix, MSc, MA, CCN
 
Nothing
NothingNothing
Nothing
Jordan
 
The Three Enduring Laws of Marketing
The Three Enduring Laws of MarketingThe Three Enduring Laws of Marketing
The Three Enduring Laws of Marketing
Manny Garza
 
Australia
AustraliaAustralia
Australia
knoxmaths
 
Conclusion
ConclusionConclusion
Conclusion
Obi
 
Danell Pugh Resume
Danell Pugh ResumeDanell Pugh Resume
Danell Pugh Resume
danellpugh
 
Malaysia
MalaysiaMalaysia
Malaysia
knoxmaths
 
Danell Pugh Crisis Management
Danell Pugh Crisis ManagementDanell Pugh Crisis Management
Danell Pugh Crisis Management
danellpugh
 
Plc West Bladen
Plc West BladenPlc West Bladen
Plc West Bladen
aboyette
 
Danell Pugh Professional Portfolio
Danell Pugh Professional PortfolioDanell Pugh Professional Portfolio
Danell Pugh Professional Portfolio
danellpugh
 
Eating Wisely- Food Choices
Eating Wisely- Food ChoicesEating Wisely- Food Choices
Eating Wisely- Food Choices
Nia Rennix, MSc, MA, CCN
 
Danell Pugh Exposure Therapy Treatment for PTSD
Danell Pugh Exposure Therapy Treatment for PTSDDanell Pugh Exposure Therapy Treatment for PTSD
Danell Pugh Exposure Therapy Treatment for PTSD
danellpugh
 

Viewers also liked (16)

Fotos De Cotxes
Fotos De CotxesFotos De Cotxes
Fotos De Cotxes
 
Plc West Bladen
Plc West BladenPlc West Bladen
Plc West Bladen
 
New zealand power point
New zealand power pointNew zealand power point
New zealand power point
 
Compro absolute eo & ph
Compro absolute eo & phCompro absolute eo & ph
Compro absolute eo & ph
 
Headaches: What a Pain!
Headaches: What a Pain!Headaches: What a Pain!
Headaches: What a Pain!
 
Nothing
NothingNothing
Nothing
 
The Three Enduring Laws of Marketing
The Three Enduring Laws of MarketingThe Three Enduring Laws of Marketing
The Three Enduring Laws of Marketing
 
Australia
AustraliaAustralia
Australia
 
Conclusion
ConclusionConclusion
Conclusion
 
Danell Pugh Resume
Danell Pugh ResumeDanell Pugh Resume
Danell Pugh Resume
 
Malaysia
MalaysiaMalaysia
Malaysia
 
Danell Pugh Crisis Management
Danell Pugh Crisis ManagementDanell Pugh Crisis Management
Danell Pugh Crisis Management
 
Plc West Bladen
Plc West BladenPlc West Bladen
Plc West Bladen
 
Danell Pugh Professional Portfolio
Danell Pugh Professional PortfolioDanell Pugh Professional Portfolio
Danell Pugh Professional Portfolio
 
Eating Wisely- Food Choices
Eating Wisely- Food ChoicesEating Wisely- Food Choices
Eating Wisely- Food Choices
 
Danell Pugh Exposure Therapy Treatment for PTSD
Danell Pugh Exposure Therapy Treatment for PTSDDanell Pugh Exposure Therapy Treatment for PTSD
Danell Pugh Exposure Therapy Treatment for PTSD
 

Similar to Narváez and the Feast of Toxcatl

Spanish empire
Spanish empireSpanish empire
Spanish empire
tydevere
 
Final Siege Part II
Final Siege Part IIFinal Siege Part II
Final Siege Part II
Obi
 
Tlaxcala
TlaxcalaTlaxcala
Tlaxcala
Obi
 
Hernan Cortes y la conquista de Mexico
Hernan Cortes y la conquista de MexicoHernan Cortes y la conquista de Mexico
Hernan Cortes y la conquista de Mexico
Herman Hall
 
Hernan cortes el conquistador de mexico
Hernan cortes   el conquistador de mexicoHernan cortes   el conquistador de mexico
Hernan cortes el conquistador de mexico
Carlos David Maureira Gonzalez
 
Hernan cortes el conquistador de mexico
Hernan cortes   el conquistador de mexicoHernan cortes   el conquistador de mexico
Hernan cortes el conquistador de mexico
Elizabeth Lopez
 
Discussion Question(s)Why do you think that Native Allies and Af.docx
Discussion Question(s)Why do you think that Native Allies and Af.docxDiscussion Question(s)Why do you think that Native Allies and Af.docx
Discussion Question(s)Why do you think that Native Allies and Af.docx
duketjoy27252
 
Aztecs and cortes
Aztecs and cortesAztecs and cortes
Aztecs and cortes
capesociology
 
Theme 3: The Spanish Empire
Theme 3: The Spanish EmpireTheme 3: The Spanish Empire
Theme 3: The Spanish Empire
pinkduckysm
 
Ning posting 4 HIST 140
Ning posting 4 HIST 140Ning posting 4 HIST 140
Ning posting 4 HIST 140
AndrewElsey
 
Aztec Interactive Powerpoint
Aztec Interactive PowerpointAztec Interactive Powerpoint
Aztec Interactive Powerpoint
salvador lopez
 
Theme 5 part 2
Theme 5 part 2Theme 5 part 2
Theme 5 part 2
tysenq
 
American Colonial Empires: Spain
American Colonial Empires: SpainAmerican Colonial Empires: Spain
American Colonial Empires: Spain
ddefatta
 
Theme 3 part 12
Theme 3 part 12Theme 3 part 12
Theme 3 part 12
ddefatta
 
Great Batle Of Otumba
Great Batle Of OtumbaGreat Batle Of Otumba
Great Batle Of Otumba
Michele Thomas
 

Similar to Narváez and the Feast of Toxcatl (15)

Spanish empire
Spanish empireSpanish empire
Spanish empire
 
Final Siege Part II
Final Siege Part IIFinal Siege Part II
Final Siege Part II
 
Tlaxcala
TlaxcalaTlaxcala
Tlaxcala
 
Hernan Cortes y la conquista de Mexico
Hernan Cortes y la conquista de MexicoHernan Cortes y la conquista de Mexico
Hernan Cortes y la conquista de Mexico
 
Hernan cortes el conquistador de mexico
Hernan cortes   el conquistador de mexicoHernan cortes   el conquistador de mexico
Hernan cortes el conquistador de mexico
 
Hernan cortes el conquistador de mexico
Hernan cortes   el conquistador de mexicoHernan cortes   el conquistador de mexico
Hernan cortes el conquistador de mexico
 
Discussion Question(s)Why do you think that Native Allies and Af.docx
Discussion Question(s)Why do you think that Native Allies and Af.docxDiscussion Question(s)Why do you think that Native Allies and Af.docx
Discussion Question(s)Why do you think that Native Allies and Af.docx
 
Aztecs and cortes
Aztecs and cortesAztecs and cortes
Aztecs and cortes
 
Theme 3: The Spanish Empire
Theme 3: The Spanish EmpireTheme 3: The Spanish Empire
Theme 3: The Spanish Empire
 
Ning posting 4 HIST 140
Ning posting 4 HIST 140Ning posting 4 HIST 140
Ning posting 4 HIST 140
 
Aztec Interactive Powerpoint
Aztec Interactive PowerpointAztec Interactive Powerpoint
Aztec Interactive Powerpoint
 
Theme 5 part 2
Theme 5 part 2Theme 5 part 2
Theme 5 part 2
 
American Colonial Empires: Spain
American Colonial Empires: SpainAmerican Colonial Empires: Spain
American Colonial Empires: Spain
 
Theme 3 part 12
Theme 3 part 12Theme 3 part 12
Theme 3 part 12
 
Great Batle Of Otumba
Great Batle Of OtumbaGreat Batle Of Otumba
Great Batle Of Otumba
 

More from Obi

Founding of Vera Cruz
Founding of Vera CruzFounding of Vera Cruz
Founding of Vera Cruz
Obi
 
The Rise of the Aztec
The Rise of the AztecThe Rise of the Aztec
The Rise of the Aztec
Obi
 
Narváez and the Feast of Toxcatl
Narváez and the Feast of ToxcatlNarváez and the Feast of Toxcatl
Narváez and the Feast of Toxcatl
Obi
 
Surrender and Aftermath
Surrender and AftermathSurrender and Aftermath
Surrender and Aftermath
Obi
 
Surrender
SurrenderSurrender
Surrender
Obi
 
Surrender and Aftermath
Surrender and AftermathSurrender and Aftermath
Surrender and Aftermath
Obi
 
Narváez and the Feast of Toxcatl
Narváez and the Feast of ToxcatlNarváez and the Feast of Toxcatl
Narváez and the Feast of Toxcatl
Obi
 
Surrender and Aftermath
Surrender and AftermathSurrender and Aftermath
Surrender and Aftermath
Obi
 
Capture of Montezuma
Capture of MontezumaCapture of Montezuma
Capture of Montezuma
Obi
 
Spanish Conquest of Caribbean
Spanish Conquest of CaribbeanSpanish Conquest of Caribbean
Spanish Conquest of Caribbean
Obi
 
Early Voyages + Omens
Early Voyages + OmensEarly Voyages + Omens
Early Voyages + Omens
Obi
 
Adam
AdamAdam
Adam
Obi
 

More from Obi (12)

Founding of Vera Cruz
Founding of Vera CruzFounding of Vera Cruz
Founding of Vera Cruz
 
The Rise of the Aztec
The Rise of the AztecThe Rise of the Aztec
The Rise of the Aztec
 
Narváez and the Feast of Toxcatl
Narváez and the Feast of ToxcatlNarváez and the Feast of Toxcatl
Narváez and the Feast of Toxcatl
 
Surrender and Aftermath
Surrender and AftermathSurrender and Aftermath
Surrender and Aftermath
 
Surrender
SurrenderSurrender
Surrender
 
Surrender and Aftermath
Surrender and AftermathSurrender and Aftermath
Surrender and Aftermath
 
Narváez and the Feast of Toxcatl
Narváez and the Feast of ToxcatlNarváez and the Feast of Toxcatl
Narváez and the Feast of Toxcatl
 
Surrender and Aftermath
Surrender and AftermathSurrender and Aftermath
Surrender and Aftermath
 
Capture of Montezuma
Capture of MontezumaCapture of Montezuma
Capture of Montezuma
 
Spanish Conquest of Caribbean
Spanish Conquest of CaribbeanSpanish Conquest of Caribbean
Spanish Conquest of Caribbean
 
Early Voyages + Omens
Early Voyages + OmensEarly Voyages + Omens
Early Voyages + Omens
 
Adam
AdamAdam
Adam
 

Narváez and the Feast of Toxcatl

  • 1. Narváez and the Feast of Toxcatl
  • 2. The Narváez distraction Cortés learns of an army led by Panfílo de Narváez with the objective to remove Cortés from command in Mexico. At the beginning of May of that year, Cortés takes a portion of his force to meet Narváez and hopefully defeat his army. He leaves a small garrison of men under Pedro de Alvarado in Tenochtitlan to hold the city and maintain power over the indigenous people. Cortés attacks Narváez' camp, taking Narváezand some of his loyal troops prisoner, while adding the bulk of Narváez' soldiers to his cause1.
  • 3. The Feast of Toxcatl While Cortés is out dealing with Narváez, many priests, nobles, and warriors gathered in honor of Toxcatl and prepared for a feast and the ceremonies that would follow. Sometime during the ceremony, a fight breaks out, and many of the Mexicans are killed. Cortés then returns to Tenochtitlan and faces the repercussions of the conflict. There are three different accounts of what happened that night, each offering their own version of the truth.
  • 4. Cortés’ account Cortés' story of the conflict at the Feast of Toxcatl is very brief and vague. Because he has just finished dealing with the Narváez problem, he sends a messenger to Tenochtitlan to tell Alvarado that he is returning as the victor. The messenger arrives twelve days later and tells Cortés that the Mexicans have attacked the small number of troops that Cortés left behind2. We, however, must be very wary of Cortés' account due to the audience of his accounts. Writing for the royalty of Spain, Cortés kept the things that would make him look bad to a minimum. He needed a clean record and justification for all of his actions in order to be in a better position to receive a good portion of the spoils once the conquest was over. He is stated as writing "They were in dire need and I must, for the love of God, come to their aid“3. Obviously exaggerating the importance of himself, Cortés is not one whose words we can take at face value.
  • 5. Díaz’ account Díaz was with Cortés in the showdown against Narváez, but has a different account of the slaughter at the Feast of Toxcatl. Just after arriving back at Tenochtitlan, Díaz writes of a conversation between Cortés and Alvarado. Alvarado explains that the Mexicans had asked him for permission to hold a festival in honor of Toxcatl, and that Alvarado gave them the authorization to do so. Alvarado says he then got "positive information" that the Mexicans would attack and sacrifice the Spaniards after the festival was completed. In order to gain surprise and prevent the Mexicans from attacking them, Alvarado struck first. Cortés then told Alvarado that he had made a mistake, the result of which is the eventual expulsion of the Spaniards from Tenochtitlan4
  • 6. Díaz’ account cont. We are allowed to believe more in Díaz' account than Cortés' because Díaz does not just pass this off. He presents his story from the perspective of overhearing the conversation between Cortés and Alvarado. Adding more credit to his side, Díaz writes his account years after the conquest when he was an old man, and stood to gain little from writing the book. Audience is much less important to him than it was for Cortés. Whether the Mexicans attacked the Spanish first or the Spanish attacked the Mexicans first does not affect him at all, so there would be less importance for him to use anything but what he thinks is the truth. What little bias we can assume would be against the Spanish government itself for failing to adequately reward the soldiers in the Conquest of Mexico. It is a small but not unimportant trifle that may have had some effect writing his account.
  • 7. Mexican account Lastly, we have the Mexican account in the form of the Florentine Codex, compiled by Bernardino de Sahagún. In the Codex, it seems that the Mexicans were singing and dancing when all of a sudden the Spanish walked in dressed for war, sealed all the exits, and started cutting people down like trees5. In the Codex there is no evidence of a plot by the Mexicans to fight the Spanish, contradicting both Díaz and Cortés. The similarity between Díaz and the Florentine Codex is the report that the Spanish initiated the skirmish, which is one of the key events in this period.
  • 8. Mexican account cont. The Florentine Codex tells a different story, one where the innocent are slaughtered for no reason. This may or may not be true. What we can think about, however, is the reason for the people who contributed to the Florentine Codex to think that way. Since all of those who lent their memories to the Codex were Mexican, one can guess that there would be at least a little anti-Spanish bias in their stories. Also important is the fact that the Mexicans did not "win" in the Conquest. This leads us to believe that they were harboring ill thoughts towards their conquerors, painting the Spanish as ruthless killers.
  • 9. Endnotes 1 Díaz, 281-283 2 Cortés, 128 3 Cortés, 128 4 Díaz, 285-286 5 Sahagún, 296-297