Most experts on technology
utilization in the classroom agree
with the maxim that pedagogy is
more important than technology.
No amount of technology will
substitute for a poorly designed
course.

       Hunter R. Boylan
       What Works: Research-Based Best
       Practices in Development Education
       (2002)
Pre-Redesign Model
The Way it Was
 2001 set up Academic Support Center
 Limited class size to 30 students.
 3 credit M090 Introductory Algebra
 4 credit M095 Intermediate Algebra
 1050 students in program
 Used InterAct Math/MathXL
 Still frustrated with the results
Pictures
Frustrations
• Some students were doing all the homework but they
  weren’t learning.
• Some students didn’t complete the homework but took
  the test anyway and failed.
• Life happened and students missed class and homework.
  They continued to fall further behind and eventually
  withdrew or failed the semester.
• Students, who had seen the material before and thought
  they knew how to do it, didn’t take the class seriously at
  first and fell behind and couldn’t catch up.
• Students who had good skills would answer all the
  questions and intimidate weaker students.
• Attendance
What We Wanted…..
 Mastery Learning
 Retain the classroom environment
 Avoid repeating an entire semester
 Test out of material they already know
 Give students the opportunity to complete the
  developmental math series in one semester
Modularizing &
Accelerating
Time Blocks
                                           Review &
   First Week of Classes                  Assessment

                           Time Block 1                Time Block 2




15-Week
Semester
                           Time Block 3                Time Block 4
60-Minute
 Classes




  Final Exam Week                         Final Exam
Modules
           Module
             A

                    Introductory
                    Algebra
                    Material
           Module
Multiple     B

 Entry
 Points                            Single
           Module
                                    Exit
             C                     Point
                    Intermediate
                    Algebra
                    Material
           Module                  Module
             D                       E
                                   (Final Exam)
How We Use Technology
• Best practices
• Careful assignment design              HW/Quiz/Test
                                         Due Dates
• Limit attempts – problems/quizzes      Difficulty
• Personalized homework before quiz retakes
• Disabled “Example Problem”
• Pooling questions
• Essay format to show work
• Combine with paper/pencil homework & tests
What’s the Verdict?
What do the numbers from our PILOT and our M098 say?
Traditional   Piloted   M098
  Course      Course    Course
   50%         64%       65%

INTRODUCTORY ALG Pass
Rates
Traditional   Piloted   M098
  Course      Course    Course
   70%         58%       70%

INTERMEDIATE ALG Pass
Rates
Traditional   Piloted   M098
  Course      Course    Course
   73%         88%       89%


Final Exam Scores
Intro Alg     Inter Alg
               Portion       Portion
              (< 1 year)   (< 1 semester)
Traditional     n/a           n/a
   Pilot        35%           30%
  M098          46%           24%

Early Completion Rates
What Happens Next?
After 1 year, where are these students?
Intermed.   Piloted   M098
 Algebra    Course    Course
   67%       73%*     70%

Persistence into
College-Level Math
Intermediate   Pilot/
               Algebra     M098
2009-2011      67%         69%
2011-2012      81%         81%
Pass Rates in College-Level
Math
Began In         Intro   Inter   M098
Pass, Persist,
    Pass         19%     38%     38%




Began in Dev. Math,
Passed College-Level Math

NADE 2013 - Math Redesign What Works for Us

  • 1.
    Most experts ontechnology utilization in the classroom agree with the maxim that pedagogy is more important than technology. No amount of technology will substitute for a poorly designed course. Hunter R. Boylan What Works: Research-Based Best Practices in Development Education (2002)
  • 2.
  • 3.
    The Way itWas  2001 set up Academic Support Center  Limited class size to 30 students.  3 credit M090 Introductory Algebra  4 credit M095 Intermediate Algebra  1050 students in program  Used InterAct Math/MathXL  Still frustrated with the results
  • 4.
  • 6.
    Frustrations • Some studentswere doing all the homework but they weren’t learning. • Some students didn’t complete the homework but took the test anyway and failed. • Life happened and students missed class and homework. They continued to fall further behind and eventually withdrew or failed the semester. • Students, who had seen the material before and thought they knew how to do it, didn’t take the class seriously at first and fell behind and couldn’t catch up. • Students who had good skills would answer all the questions and intimidate weaker students. • Attendance
  • 7.
    What We Wanted….. Mastery Learning  Retain the classroom environment  Avoid repeating an entire semester  Test out of material they already know  Give students the opportunity to complete the developmental math series in one semester
  • 8.
  • 9.
    Time Blocks Review & First Week of Classes Assessment Time Block 1 Time Block 2 15-Week Semester Time Block 3 Time Block 4 60-Minute Classes Final Exam Week Final Exam
  • 10.
    Modules Module A Introductory Algebra Material Module Multiple B Entry Points Single Module Exit C Point Intermediate Algebra Material Module Module D E (Final Exam)
  • 13.
    How We UseTechnology • Best practices • Careful assignment design HW/Quiz/Test Due Dates • Limit attempts – problems/quizzes Difficulty • Personalized homework before quiz retakes • Disabled “Example Problem” • Pooling questions • Essay format to show work • Combine with paper/pencil homework & tests
  • 14.
    What’s the Verdict? Whatdo the numbers from our PILOT and our M098 say?
  • 15.
    Traditional Piloted M098 Course Course Course 50% 64% 65% INTRODUCTORY ALG Pass Rates
  • 16.
    Traditional Piloted M098 Course Course Course 70% 58% 70% INTERMEDIATE ALG Pass Rates
  • 17.
    Traditional Piloted M098 Course Course Course 73% 88% 89% Final Exam Scores
  • 18.
    Intro Alg Inter Alg Portion Portion (< 1 year) (< 1 semester) Traditional n/a n/a Pilot 35% 30% M098 46% 24% Early Completion Rates
  • 19.
    What Happens Next? After1 year, where are these students?
  • 20.
    Intermed. Piloted M098 Algebra Course Course 67% 73%* 70% Persistence into College-Level Math
  • 21.
    Intermediate Pilot/ Algebra M098 2009-2011 67% 69% 2011-2012 81% 81% Pass Rates in College-Level Math
  • 22.
    Began In Intro Inter M098 Pass, Persist, Pass 19% 38% 38% Began in Dev. Math, Passed College-Level Math

Editor's Notes

  • #12 M090 Pilot 146/370 M095 Pilot 224/370 1 M090 classes &amp; 2 M095 classes (during Pilot)
  • #13 64.5% in M065 and M090 but 78.7% tested into Mod A
  • #14 Use as a learning aid, not as the mode of learning Pooling questions on quizzes
  • #16 64% From Pearson White Paper 65% of students who would have enrolled in M090 pass at least A &amp; B
  • #17 58% 129/224 F09-S11 70% Make it all the way through in 1 semester (plus bonus); 1 semester only 66% What did we do to raise the pass rates? -&gt; 70 – 79’s
  • #18 065 85% 090 88% 095 91% Un 91.3%
  • #19 From Pearson White Paper
  • #21 Fall 2009 – Spring 12 Highest two semesters – S10 and F11 (changes &amp; instructors) = 88% persistence
  • #22 Thought – College Algebra was re-tooled using unlimited quiz attempts, open book, open note non-proctored tests
  • #23 Using current 81% pass rate Assuming 090 = .50*1.0*.70*.67 Assuming 095 = .70*.67 Assuming 098 = .67*.70  WITH 090 students added in