The document provides analysis and feedback for several short films in different genres. For the film "The edge", the credits and variety of shots worked well but a voiceover may have improved it. Feedback suggested better matching jump cuts to the beats for more intensity. The drama "Karma" had clear camerawork but a confusing plot and needed more editing work. The rom-com "Roses are red" effectively showed its genre through colors and setup while music matched the scene. Feedback was to use a tripod for more professionalism. "Deception" as a film noir benefited from flickering editing and monotone effects though its music was too loud. "Made man" a British mob film used voiceover and variety