SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 7
Download to read offline
1
1 INTRODUCTION
RCC is a new type of lean concrete with the large
technological possibilities not completely realized
and with the wide physical-mechanical properties
ranging from the early first type of lean RCC (< 99
kg/m3
) to the third type of high-paste RCC (with
cementitious content >180 kg/m3
). At the present the
RCC-3 is used widely in the gravity dams in Spain
and China while the RCC-1 is used mainly in RCC
dams in Brazil and Colombia (Dunstan 2003).
The modern high (100 m and more) RCC-3 gravity
dams with the traditional triangle cross-section with
a vertical upstream face and a sloping downstream
face (0,8H/1V) on a rigid (rock) foundation are fre-
quently unsafe solution in the event of an earthquake
with a horizontal acceleration of 0.2g and more. An-
other serious restriction of traditional gravity (TG)
RCC dams is that they are not feasible on a soft
(soil) and even on a weak rock foundation (ICOLD
Bulletin 117, 2000).
These restrictions of RCC dams can be overcome
by changing their TG profile to the symmetrical tri-
angle cross-section with RCC-1 with very low ce-
mentitious content, without horizontal joints treat-
ment and with a watertight upstream concrete
facing. This new type of lean RCC dam (so called
“Faced Symmetrical Hardfill” or FSH dam with both
slopes of about 0,7H/1V) was first introduced by
Londe and Lino. (1992). Owing to the symmetrical
shape of this dam RCC requires neither high shear
nor high compressive strengths and there is no ten-
sile stress whatsoever in the section at least for an
earthquake with a pseudo-static acceleration of
0.20g (ICOLD Bulletin 117, 2000).
2 FSH DAM WITH ZONE OF ROCKFILL
ENRICHED WITH CEMENT (FSH-REC DAM)
Further optimization of the concept of FSH dam led
us to a new type of composed FSH dam with outer
zones of lean RCC-1 and inner wide zone of rockfill,
enriched with cement-flyash mortar (REC) or FSH-
REC dam (Fig.1).
The outer zones of this dam with slopes of about
0.5-0.7 (depending on site conditions) and width of
about (3+0,1H) m (where H – water head in meters)
can be made with very low cement contents (< 70
kg/m3
). By placing the CARPI watertight membrane
on the upstream dam slope (instead of more labor-
consuming and expensive reinforced concrete fac-
ing), the uplift in RCC joints or cracks is eliminated,
thus, with no consequence either on watertightness
or on the safety of the dam. The CARPI membrane
is placed after completion of the dam to overcome
any difficulties with thermal cracking in RCC zones.
The 4-th International Conference on RCC Dams (Madrid, November 2003)
Seismic stability and stress-strain state of a new type of FSH-RCC dams
Yu.P.Liapichev
Dr. (Techn. Sc.), Professor, Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia, Moscow, Russia
ABSTRACT: The finite element seismic (linear spectral and dynamic) analyses of stability and stress-strain
state of a new type of composed Faced Symmetrical Hardfill (FSH) dam with central zone of rockfill enriched
with cement mortar (REC) or FSH-REC dam of different heights (30, 60 and 100 m) and slopes (0.4, 0.5 and
0.7H/1V) on rigid and soft foundations are performed and compared with the traditional gravity RCC dams.
The methodology of seismic response of the system "dam-foundation-reservoir" is considered in brief as well
as the elastoplastic hardening model of RCC taking into account the cohesion and angle of inner friction of
RCC joints. The seismic resistance of the 100 m high FSH-REC dam (with slopes of 0,5H/1H) on rock foun-
dation is considered for action of two strong earthquakes (MDE and MCE) with ground horizontal and verti-
cal accelerograms with peak values of 0,2 and 0,4 g. In the MDE case the dam behavior is quite elastic and
safe with no tension or opening of RCC joints. In the MCE case the dam behavior is elastoplastic with plastic
deformations near the dam crest and partial opening of RCC joints in the lower half of the dam. The upstream
CARPI membrane can provide the water-tightness of the dam in the MDE and MCE cases.
2
This design has been used successfully for the ver-
tical upstream face of RCC dams (Miel in Colombia,
Riou in France, Concepcion in Honduras, etc.).
The wide central zone of the dam can be made with
Figure 1. Section of the 100 m high FSH-REC dam
REC (rockfill of 5-300 mm diameter, enriched
with cement-flyash mortar) in the central zone of the
dam can be placed in 60 cm thick layers while RCC
layers in the outer zones - in 30 cm layers. Than 10-
15 cm thick cement-flyash mortar is spread over a
rockfill layer and penetrates into the coarse pores of
rockfill. The penetration can be facilitated by 1-2
passages of Dynapic sheep roller and subsequent
compaction can be achieved by 2-3 passages of Bo-
maq vibrating roller used also for compaction of
RCC outer zones of the dam.
The separated placing of the wide REC central
zone of the FSH-REC dam permits to replace the
expensive mixing plant for RCC dam with much less
cheap cement mortar facility on the FSH-REC dam
thus achieving the significant economical effect as
well as using rockfill instead of RCC aggregates.
Owing to higher rockfill layers (60 cm) than tra-
ditional 30 cm of RCC and using CARPI membrane
on the upstream slope instead of reinforced concrete
facing the speed of construction of FSH-REC dam
will be higher than homogeneous FSH dam.
Naturally, construction of the FSH-REC dam as
well as FSH dam should be tested on the site. But
the structural (seismic) aspects of a new design of
FSH-REC or FSH dam should be performed in ad-
vance because at the present the required seismic
(dynamic) analyses of these dams are not available.
3 PSEUDO-STATIC STABILITY OF FSH-REC
AND RCC DAMS
According to our stability analysis of the 60 and
100 m high FSH-REC dams during its construction
the minimum cohesion of RCC of outer zones and
REC should be not less than 0.5 and 0,1 MPa, corre-
spondingly, to obtain the required cohesion during
simultaneous placing of outer zones of RCC and
central zone of REC (Liapichev 1998). This RCC
cohesion value of 0,5 MPa corresponds to the mini-
mum cohesion of RCC-1 joints without treatment
(Schrader 1999). For RCC and REC materials the
minimum inner friction angle of 450
is assumed,
which corresponds to the preliminary design of RCC
dams.
Table 1 and 2 show the comparison, in terms of
factors of safety against sliding at the foundation, of
a 100 m high traditional RCC dam with vertical up-
stream and sloping downstream faces (Sd=0.7; 0.8
and 0.9) and an FSH-REC dam of the same height
and both slopes (Su=Sd=0.4; 0.5 and 0.7).
Three types of foundations were considered: tra-
ditional rock foundation (with the angle of inner
friction =450
), alluvial (=350
) and moraine (=300
and cohesion C=0,1MPa) foundations.
Two operation cases were considered: static case
with a maximum reservoir level and seismic (pseudo
static) case with a ground acceleration of 0.2g. In
seismic case the shear wedge method was used for
the calculation of accelerations distribution in both
dam because this method corresponds to the actual
shear movements of RCC dams during earthquakes.
For both dams the uplift was taken at 40% of the
force developed by a straight percolation line from
full reservoir head upstream to no head at the dam.
Table 1. Factors of safety against sliding for 100 m high RCC
dam
Types of
foundation
Factors of safety for downstream slope
(static/seismic cases)
0.7 0.8 0.9
Rock 1.91/1.47 2.14/1.60 2.37/1.73
Alluvium 1.33/1.02 1.50/1.12 1.66/1.21
Moraine 1.24/0.95 1.39/1.04 1.54/1.13
2x0.3=0.6m
2x0.3=0.6m
Detail A
0.4
2x0.3=0.6m
CARPI
membrane
2x0.3=0.6m 1
0.4
RCC-1 1
REC
Detail B
0.5
1
REC
RCC-1
REC
REC
REC
Grout
curtain
Gallery CVC
Detail A
1
0.5
1CARPI
membrane
RCC
1
0.4
Detail B
0.5
1
0.4
0.5
1
dam axis
100.00
0.00
RCC
3
Table 2. Factors of safety against sliding for 100 m high FSH-
REC dam.
Types of
foundation
Factors of safety for both slopes (stat-
ic/seismic cases)
0.4 0.5 0.7
Rock 2.59/1.91 3.15/2.21 4.27/2.74
Alluvium 1.99/1.33 2.20/1.55 2.98/1.92
Moraine 1.65/1.22 2.01/1.41 2.73/1.75
According to Russian design norms for gravity
dams (1987) the minimum allowable factors of safe-
ty against sliding on the contact dam-rock founda-
tion for static and seismic cases are, corresponding-
ly, 1.32 and 1.18. It means that RCC or PG (gravity
dam of conventional concrete) dams aren’t feasible
on soft foundation (alluvium, moraine, etc.).
On the contrary, FSH-REC or FSH dams even
with steep slopes (0.4H/1V) are quite feasible and
safe on rock and soft foundations.
Table 3 and 4 show the comparison, in terms of
normal and principal stresses at the dam base for
static and seismic (pseudo-static with a ground ac-
celeration of 0.2 g) cases of both dams of the same
height (100 m) on a rock foundation.
Table 3. Stresses at the base of 100 high RCC dam.
Stresses in MPa for downstream slope
(seismic case)
Stresses 0.9 0.8 0.7
σy
u
-0.74 -0.42 0.3
σx
u
-1 -1 -1
τxy
u
0 0 0
σ1
u
-0.74 -0.42 0.3
σ3
u
-1 -1 -1
σy
d
-1.67 -2.00 -2.48
σx
d
-1.67 -1.28 -1.21
τxy
d
1.50 1.60 1.73
σ1
d
0 0 0
σ3
d
-3.03 -3.29 -3.69
The upper index u in all stresses in tables 3 and 4
denotes upstream face, d – downstream face. The
sign (-) denotes compression and (+) – tension.
Table 3 shows that the M. Lévy condition is not
satisfied at the RCC dam heel (with the downstream
slope of 0.7) and the base joint is likely to open.
The same is true for the 100 m high FSH-REC
dam with both slopes of 0.4V/1H. But for the same
dam with both slopes of 0.5V/1H and flatter the
RCC base joints are likely to be closed after even a
strong earthquake.
Table 4. Stresses at the base of the 100 m high FSH-REC dam.
Stresses in MPa for both slopes
(static/seismic cases)
Stresses 0.7 0.5 0.4
σy
u
-1.30/-0.94 -0.90/-0.39 -0.48/0.17
σx
u
-1.14/-0.97 -0.97/-0.47 -0.91/-0.82
τxy
u
-0.21/0.03 0.04/-0.30 0.20/0.47
σ1
u
-1.45/-0.91 -0.88/-0.23 -0.39/0.36
σ3
u
-1/-1 -1/-1 -1/-1
σy
d
-1.54/-1.90 -1.95/-2.27 -2.39/-3.0
σx
d
-0.75/-0.93 -0.48/-0.61 -0.38/-0.48
τxy
d
1.08/1.30 0.97/1.23 0.95/1.22
σ1
d
0/0 0/0 0/0
σ3
d
-2.29/-2.80 -2.44/-3.09 -2.77/-3.50
The same static and seismic (pseudo-static) stabil-
ity and stress analyses were performed for the 30
and 60 m high FSH-REC dams on the same founda-
tions. These analyses showed that these FSH-REC
dams with both slopes of 0.4V/1H or flatter are quite
stable and safe on rock and soft foundations even for
action of very strong earthquake with a ground ac-
celeration of 0.4g. In the 30 m high FSH-REC dam
the enrichment of rockfill with cement mortar can be
excluded, thus, creating the composite FSH-RF dam.
4 SEISMIC (PSEUDO-DYNAMIC) STRESS-
STRAIN STATE ANALYSIS OF FSH-REC DAMS
The finite element seismic (linear spectral or pseu-
do-dynamic) analyses of stress-strain state of the
FSH-REC dams of different heights (30, 60 and 100
m) and slopes (0,4; 0,5 and 0,7) on rock (rigid)
foundations were performed for action of a ground
acceleration of 0,20g. The main results of the seis-
mic analysis for the 100 m high FSH-REC dam with
slopes of 0.5 V/1H are shown on Fig. 2-5.
Fig. 2 shows that the M. Lévy condition is satis-
fied at the dam heel and the base RCC joints are
closed. The distribution of maximum principal
stresses 1 in the dam (Fig. 3) is nearly uniform from
upstream to downstream faces reaching only 2.3
MPa at the toe. The same uniform distribution was
obtained for shear normal and maximum stresses
with maximum values, correspondingly, 0.7 and 0.9
MPa in RCC outer zones at the dam base (Fig. 4, 5).
4
Figure 2. Vertical normal stresses y (t/m2
) in the 100 m high
FSH-REC dam with both slopes of 0.5V/1H (seismic case).
Figure 3. Maximum principal stresses 1(t/m2
) in the 100 m
high FSH-REC dam with both slopes of 0.5V/1H (seismic
case).
Figure 4. Shear normal stresses xy (t/m2
) in the 100 m high
FSH-REC dam with both slopes of 0.5V/1H (seismic case).
Figure 5. Maximum shear stresses max (t/m2
) in the 100 m high
FSH-REC dam with both slopes of 0.5V/1H (seismic case).
Thus, the stress-strain state of the 100 m high FSH-
REC dam with both slopes of 0.5V/1H for action of
a strong earthquake is much more favorable and safe
than in the 100 m high traditional RCC or PG dam
with the downstream slope of 0.8V/1H.
5 SEISMIC (DYNAMIC) STRESS-STRAIN
STATE ANALYSIS OF HIGH FSH-REC DAM
According to the new Russian anti-seismic design
norms for dams (2003) the seismic (dynamic) analy-
sis are to be performed for high dams (100 m and
higher) located in moderate or high seismic regions.
The dynamic analysis of the 100 m high FSH-
REC dam with slopes of 0.5V/1H was performed by
the method used now in the Geodynamic Center of
Hydroproject Institute (Bronchtein et al. 2002).
The dynamic response of the ‘dam-foundation-
reservoir’ system for action of these accelerations
was considered in the analysis. The influence of
gravity waves in the reservoir was neglected and the
boundary conditions between reservoir and dam and
reservoir and foundation were simplified. The condi-
tion of equal normal displacements on these bounda-
ries was assumed for dam, foundation and reservoir.
The passing of shear stresses through these bounda-
ries was assumed that allows simplify the problem
by abandoning the interface elements (Groshev
2000). As for a mathematic model of RCC and REC
the elastoplastic hardening model with associated
flow rule and shear strength of RCC joints (angle of
the inner friction  and cohesion C) was used
(Fig.6). The hardening parameters of the model are
shear and volume plastic deformations on the maxi-
mum shear plane (Groshev, Shablinsky 1991).
This RCC model simulates well cracking or open-
ing of RCC horizontal joints and their subsequent
reaction only to compression.
-11.39 85.43 194.35 212.09 156.22 176.33
-3.24 74.73 137.61 202.50 113.80 165.49
6.41 63.39 118.39 167.38 99.44 160.39
12.34 54.90 99.42 131.40 86.91 150.77
15.81 47.10 79.75 99.46 74.12135.52
16.1338.6860.7572.91 61.13113.44
13.1529.5744.0750.7347.3386.18
6.7621.2928.1730.8432.8754.83
-2.0311.3110.1513.1417.3119.66
-11.39
-11.39
85.43 194.35 212.09 156.22 176.33 176.33
176.33-3.24
-3.24
165.49
165.496.41
6.41
160.39
160.3912.34
12.34
150.77
150.7715.81
15.81
135.52
135.5216.13
16.13
113.44
113.4413.15
13.15
86.18
86.186.76
6.76
54.83
54.83-2.03
-2.03-2.0311.3110.1513.1417.31
19.66
19.66
95.37 132.99 218.64 224.05 179.63 210.45
101.30 129.18 160.88 220.84 124.01 194.04
93.09 107.13 144.73 184.95 109.02 187.93
81.03 94.19 123.61 146.49 98.43 179.22
71.96 79.08 99.88 113.72 89.16164.21
60.4564.4277.8287.63 79.29139.82
49.3150.8559.2866.2764.70106.56
31.7238.2841.3441.4445.9071.90
22.1324.5922.6225.4025.8128.02
95.37
95.37
132.99 218.64 224.05 179.63 210.45 210.45
210.45101.30
101.30
194.04
194.0493.09
93.09
187.93
187.9381.03
81.03
179.22
179.2271.96
71.96
164.21
164.2160.45
60.45
139.82
139.8249.31
49.31
106.56
106.5631.72
31.72
71.90
71.9022.13
22.1322.1324.5922.6225.4025.81
28.02
28.02
-82.67 -64.93 -61.42 -43.13 -53.04 -73.68
-56.95 -64.77 -53.73 -57.60 -31.25 -66.76
-51.12 -51.38 -52.04 -51.54 -29.15 -65.04
-39.54 -43.15 -45.86 -42.29 -30.03 -64.16
-30.15 -33.43 -36.44 -35.28 -31.47-60.94
-21.70-24.21-27.44-29.52 -30.91-53.19
-16.25-17.27-20.38-23.98-25.92-40.28
-7.53-13.19-14.91-15.27-18.52-30.28
-6.61-8.43-8.37-10.04-9.31-12.43
-82.67
-82.67
-64.93 -61.42 -43.13 -53.04 -73.68 -73.68
-73.68-56.95
-56.95
-66.76
-66.76-51.12
-51.12
-65.04
-65.04-39.54
-39.54
-64.16
-64.16-30.15
-30.15
-60.94
-60.94-21.70
-21.70
-53.19
-53.19-16.25
-16.25
-40.28
-40.28-7.53
-7.53
-30.28
-30.28-6.61
-6.61-6.61-8.43-8.37-10.04-9.31
-12.43
-12.43
85.39 68.09 89.81 83.77 71.79 96.60
67.78 65.75 74.00 99.62 52.94 92.35
58.42 52.05 64.58 84.39 49.12 90.57
45.72 43.33 55.56 66.84 44.89 86.57
36.17 33.47 43.05 50.76 40.4679.07
27.4724.2530.5836.96 35.4066.81
21.7317.6521.2626.2728.0350.00
13.6113.6215.0316.3019.6835.39
12.989.319.0510.249.3513.43
85.39
85.39
68.09 89.81 83.77 71.79 96.60 96.60
96.6067.78
67.78
92.35
92.3558.42
58.42
90.57
90.5745.72
45.72
86.57
86.5736.17
36.17
79.07
79.0727.47
27.47
66.81
66.8121.73
21.73
50.00
50.0013.61
13.61
35.39
35.3912.98
12.9812.989.319.0510.249.35
13.43
13.43
5
Figure 6. Elastoplastic hardening model of RCC.
The synthetic horizontal and vertical accelera-
tions with peak values of 0,8g were normalized as
the Maximum Design Earthquake (MDE) with the
peak ground horizontal and vertical accelerations of
0.2 and 0.14g, correspondingly (Fig.7-a, b) and as
the Maximum Credible Earthquake (MCE) with the
peak ground horizontal and vertical accelerations of
0.4 and 0.28g.
(a)
(b)
Figure 7-a, b. Ground horizontal (a) and vertical (b) accelera-
tions (in m/s2
) for the MDE.
The same shear strength values of RCC-1 and
REC joints were adopted in this dynamic analysis as
in the previous linear spectral analysis: in RCC-1
joints φ=450
, C=0,5 MPa, in REC joints φ=450
,
C=0,1 MPa. Elasticity modulus of RCC-1 E=5000
MPa and REC E=1000 MPa, Poison coefficient of
RCC-1 υ=0.2 and REC υ=0.25. Elasticity modulus
of rock foundation E=10000 MPa and υ=0.2.
The results of dynamical analysis of the 100 m
high FSH-REC dam with slopes of 0.5V/1H for ac-
tion of MDE are presented on Figs. 8 and 9.
Fig. 8 shows the variation of the horizontal dis-
placements of six control points along the upstream
slope: the first one is at the base and the sixth is at
the crest (with 20m vertical spacing between points).
As can be seen from Fig. 8, the dynamic response of
dam is elastic and elastic horizontal displacement are
completely damping by the end of the MDE without
any residual values. The maximum horizontal accel-
eration at the dam crest for the MDE reaches 0.31g.
Fig. 9 shows the finite element mesh of the dam
and rock foundation with only one crack or joint
opening in RCC-1 zone near the dam base during the
MDE. But after the MDE the RCC joint is closed.
Figure 8. Variation of horizontal displacements of six points on
the upstream slope for the MDE.
Figure 9. Finite element mesh and one crack (joint) opening in
RCC near the dam base for the MDE.
6
Thus, it is clear that the FSH-REC dam is safe for
the MDE case, and that there is no development of
tensile stresses or opening of RCC-1 joints.
The results of dynamical analysis of the same
FSH-REC dam for action of MCE with the ground
peak horizontal and vertical accelerations of 0.4 and
0.28g are presented on Figs. 10, 11 and 12.
Fig. 10 shows the variation of the horizontal dis-
placements of six control points along the upstream
slope from the dam base up to its crest. As can be
seen from Fig. 10, the dynamic response of the dam
is elastic and elastic horizontal displacement are,
mainly, damping by the end of the MDE without re-
sidual (plastic) values except the point 6 at the dam
crest. Therefore, the maximum horizontal accelera-
tion at the dam crest for the MCE reaches only 0.28g
(Fig. 11) comparing to 0.31g in the MDE case.
The cracking pattern (Fig. 12) in the dam body
for the MCE case is deteriorated comparing to the
MDE: in the lower part of the dam the cracks (joints
opening) propagated from the upstream slope to-
wards the dam axis. However, owing to the up-
stream impervious CARPI membrane, the uplift
propagation through RCC and RSC joints is impos-
sible and seismic safety of the dam is provided.
Figure 10. Variation of horizontal displacements of six points
on the upstream dam slope for the MCE.
Figure 11. Variation of horizontal accelerations (g) of
six points on the upstream dam slope for the MCE.
Figure 12. The cracking (joints opening) pattern in
the dam body for the MCE.
The cracking or joints opening in the RCC outer
zones during the MCE can be excluded or, at least,
decreased by joints treatment in these zones (bed-
ding mix) that can increase twice or more RCC joint
cohesion. In this case another solution is remained:
to decrease the steepness of both slopes from 0.5 to
0.6 thus excluding any treatment of the RCC joints.
7
The hypothetic maximum earthquake (HME) with
the peak ground horizontal and vertical accelerations
of 0.8 and 0.56g, correspondingly, (twice as much as
the MCE) was applied to the dam to achieve its
complete cracking (joints opening) or hypothetic
failure.
Figure 13. Variation of horizontal displacements of six points
on the upstream dam slope for the hypothetic maximum earth-
quake.
Fig. 13 shows the variation of the horizontal dis-
placements of six control points along the upstream
slope from the dam base up to its crest. As can be
seen from Fig. 13, the dynamic response of the dam
is complex: at the dam crest (point 6) the residual
(plastic) horizontal displacements are developed af-
ter the earthquake while in the major rest part of the
dam (points 1-5) only the elastic displacements are
developed. The maximum horizontal acceleration at
the dam crest for this HME case reaches 0.38g com-
paring to 0.28g in the MCE case.
In this hypothetic case the horizontal cracks or all
horizontal joints in the dam body from the upstream
to downstream faces are opened after the HME.
Thus, the 100 m high FSH-REC dam with both
slopes of 0.5H/1V has, at least, the double seismic
(dynamic) margin against action of the MCE.
6 CONCLUSIONS
It is shown that a new type of composite FSH dam
with the outer zones of lean RCC and inner wide
zone of rockfill enriched with cement mortar (FSH-
REC dam) of height up to 100 m on rock or soil
foundation is a very attractive alternative comparing
to traditional RCC or PG dams. The seismic (dy-
namic) analysis of the 100 m high FSH-REC dam
with both slopes of 0.5H/1V has shown the excellent
behavior of its symmetrical cross-section for action
of very strong earthquake with peak ground horizon-
tal and vertical accelerations, correspondingly, of
0,40 and 0.28g. Owing to the CARPI impervious
membrane placed on the upstream slope there are no
uplift in the lean RCC joints of the dam even for ac-
tion of the hypothetic maximum earthquake with a
peak ground acceleration of 0.80g.
The possible technological problems of construc-
tion of the FSH-REC dam as well as FSH dam can
be checked and solved in advance during construc-
tion of the FSH-REC cofferdam on the site.
REFERENCES
Bronshtein, V.I., Groshev, M.E., Savich, A.I. 2002. Seismic
safety in hydro power sector of Russia. HydroVision
2002.Technical paper 052. HCI Publication. USA.
Groshev, M.E. 1998. Methods and computer programs for
seismic safety assessment of hydropower plants and dams.
Proc. Safety of Energy Structures (in Russian). Publ. NIIES,
Moscow, Issue 7: 130-139.
Groshev, M.E., Shablisky G.E. 1991. Application of the theory
of plastic flow for simulation of deformations and strength
of concrete. Civil Engineering and Architecture (in Rus-
sian). Moscow.
Dunstan, M.R.H. 2003. RCC dams (under construction and
completed) in 2003. Hydropower and Dams. World Atlas
and Industry Guide.
ICOLD Bulletin 117, 2000. The gravity dam – a dam for the
future. Review and recommendations.
Liapichev, Yu. P. 1998. New structures of dam from RCC and
rockfill. Problems of theory and practice in engineering re-
search (in Russian). Proc. Structural Mechanics. Publ. As-
sociation of Civil Engineering Institutes. Moscow. 39-43.
Liapichev, Yu. P. 1998. RCC dams and composite RCC and
rockfill dams. Aspects of design, construction and safety (in
Spanish). Seminar for ESAGEN, Medellin, Colombia.
Londe, P., Lino, M. 1992. The faced symmetrical hardfill dam:
a new concept for RCC. Water Power and Dam Construc-
tion, Vol. 44, Number 2.
Schrader, E.K. 1999. Shear strength and lift joint quality of
RCC. Hydropower and Dams, Vol. 6, Issue 1: 46-55.

More Related Content

What's hot

Modernising the Albert Canal thanks to SCIA Engineer software
Modernising the Albert Canal thanks to SCIA Engineer softwareModernising the Albert Canal thanks to SCIA Engineer software
Modernising the Albert Canal thanks to SCIA Engineer softwareRudi Vanmechelen ✉ SCIA
 
GROUP_6_YOUNGMAN_L_ANNEX_15-16
GROUP_6_YOUNGMAN_L_ANNEX_15-16GROUP_6_YOUNGMAN_L_ANNEX_15-16
GROUP_6_YOUNGMAN_L_ANNEX_15-16Leo Youngman
 
DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOIL
  DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOIL  DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOIL
DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOILIAEME Publication
 
Back analysis of high tunnel convergences in clayey marls
Back analysis of high tunnel convergences in clayey marlsBack analysis of high tunnel convergences in clayey marls
Back analysis of high tunnel convergences in clayey marlsSYSTRA
 
Assessing the interaction between the excavation of a large cavern and existi...
Assessing the interaction between the excavation of a large cavern and existi...Assessing the interaction between the excavation of a large cavern and existi...
Assessing the interaction between the excavation of a large cavern and existi...SYSTRA
 
Separating underground metro lines under operation in Baku
Separating underground metro lines under operation in BakuSeparating underground metro lines under operation in Baku
Separating underground metro lines under operation in BakuSYSTRA
 
Michalis presentation_2015
Michalis presentation_2015Michalis presentation_2015
Michalis presentation_2015ILIAS MICHALIS
 
Mathematical model ofrcc dam breakbastorarcc dam as a case study
Mathematical model ofrcc dam breakbastorarcc dam as a case studyMathematical model ofrcc dam breakbastorarcc dam as a case study
Mathematical model ofrcc dam breakbastorarcc dam as a case studyIAEME Publication
 
Inspection,Repair and Strengthening of PSC Bridge.
Inspection,Repair and Strengthening of PSC  Bridge.Inspection,Repair and Strengthening of PSC  Bridge.
Inspection,Repair and Strengthening of PSC Bridge.Mohammad Furqan
 
Lecture 6 s.s.iii Design of Steel Structures - Faculty of Civil Engineering Iaşi
Lecture 6 s.s.iii Design of Steel Structures - Faculty of Civil Engineering IaşiLecture 6 s.s.iii Design of Steel Structures - Faculty of Civil Engineering Iaşi
Lecture 6 s.s.iii Design of Steel Structures - Faculty of Civil Engineering IaşiUrsachi Răzvan
 
Design of post tensioned straddle beam for bridge support
Design of post tensioned straddle beam for bridge support  Design of post tensioned straddle beam for bridge support
Design of post tensioned straddle beam for bridge support Amin Zuraiqi
 
DESIGN OF T BEAM BRIDGE PROCEDURE
DESIGN OF T BEAM BRIDGE PROCEDUREDESIGN OF T BEAM BRIDGE PROCEDURE
DESIGN OF T BEAM BRIDGE PROCEDUREbabji syed
 
2001 iabse - Reliability Assessment of Cable-Stayed Bridges
2001 iabse - Reliability Assessment of Cable-Stayed Bridges2001 iabse - Reliability Assessment of Cable-Stayed Bridges
2001 iabse - Reliability Assessment of Cable-Stayed BridgesFranco Bontempi
 
Rigid Pavements Design Part - I
Rigid Pavements Design Part - IRigid Pavements Design Part - I
Rigid Pavements Design Part - ISachin Kulkarni
 

What's hot (18)

Deh Cho Bridge
Deh Cho BridgeDeh Cho Bridge
Deh Cho Bridge
 
Modernising the Albert Canal thanks to SCIA Engineer software
Modernising the Albert Canal thanks to SCIA Engineer softwareModernising the Albert Canal thanks to SCIA Engineer software
Modernising the Albert Canal thanks to SCIA Engineer software
 
GROUP_6_YOUNGMAN_L_ANNEX_15-16
GROUP_6_YOUNGMAN_L_ANNEX_15-16GROUP_6_YOUNGMAN_L_ANNEX_15-16
GROUP_6_YOUNGMAN_L_ANNEX_15-16
 
DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOIL
  DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOIL  DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOIL
DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOIL
 
Back analysis of high tunnel convergences in clayey marls
Back analysis of high tunnel convergences in clayey marlsBack analysis of high tunnel convergences in clayey marls
Back analysis of high tunnel convergences in clayey marls
 
Assessing the interaction between the excavation of a large cavern and existi...
Assessing the interaction between the excavation of a large cavern and existi...Assessing the interaction between the excavation of a large cavern and existi...
Assessing the interaction between the excavation of a large cavern and existi...
 
Separating underground metro lines under operation in Baku
Separating underground metro lines under operation in BakuSeparating underground metro lines under operation in Baku
Separating underground metro lines under operation in Baku
 
Michalis presentation_2015
Michalis presentation_2015Michalis presentation_2015
Michalis presentation_2015
 
Mathematical model ofrcc dam breakbastorarcc dam as a case study
Mathematical model ofrcc dam breakbastorarcc dam as a case studyMathematical model ofrcc dam breakbastorarcc dam as a case study
Mathematical model ofrcc dam breakbastorarcc dam as a case study
 
Df31729732
Df31729732Df31729732
Df31729732
 
Inspection,Repair and Strengthening of PSC Bridge.
Inspection,Repair and Strengthening of PSC  Bridge.Inspection,Repair and Strengthening of PSC  Bridge.
Inspection,Repair and Strengthening of PSC Bridge.
 
S7
S7S7
S7
 
Lecture 6 s.s.iii Design of Steel Structures - Faculty of Civil Engineering Iaşi
Lecture 6 s.s.iii Design of Steel Structures - Faculty of Civil Engineering IaşiLecture 6 s.s.iii Design of Steel Structures - Faculty of Civil Engineering Iaşi
Lecture 6 s.s.iii Design of Steel Structures - Faculty of Civil Engineering Iaşi
 
Design of post tensioned straddle beam for bridge support
Design of post tensioned straddle beam for bridge support  Design of post tensioned straddle beam for bridge support
Design of post tensioned straddle beam for bridge support
 
DESIGN OF T BEAM BRIDGE PROCEDURE
DESIGN OF T BEAM BRIDGE PROCEDUREDESIGN OF T BEAM BRIDGE PROCEDURE
DESIGN OF T BEAM BRIDGE PROCEDURE
 
Auckland
AucklandAuckland
Auckland
 
2001 iabse - Reliability Assessment of Cable-Stayed Bridges
2001 iabse - Reliability Assessment of Cable-Stayed Bridges2001 iabse - Reliability Assessment of Cable-Stayed Bridges
2001 iabse - Reliability Assessment of Cable-Stayed Bridges
 
Rigid Pavements Design Part - I
Rigid Pavements Design Part - IRigid Pavements Design Part - I
Rigid Pavements Design Part - I
 

Similar to Lyapichev. New RCC dams (Inter. Conf. on RCC, 2003)

Lyapichev. Modern structural & technological solutions for new projects of hi...
Lyapichev. Modern structural & technological solutions for new projects of hi...Lyapichev. Modern structural & technological solutions for new projects of hi...
Lyapichev. Modern structural & technological solutions for new projects of hi...Yury Lyapichev
 
Safety problem of Boguchansk rockfill dam with asphalt concrete core
Safety problem of Boguchansk rockfill dam with asphalt concrete coreSafety problem of Boguchansk rockfill dam with asphalt concrete core
Safety problem of Boguchansk rockfill dam with asphalt concrete coreYury Lyapichev
 
Nurek rockfill dam (300 m). Problem of seismic safety of dam (4 p.)
Nurek rockfill dam (300 m). Problem of seismic safety of dam (4 p.)Nurek rockfill dam (300 m). Problem of seismic safety of dam (4 p.)
Nurek rockfill dam (300 m). Problem of seismic safety of dam (4 p.)Yury Lyapichev
 
Analysis and Design Aspects of Support Measures of Main Caverns of Karuma Hyd...
Analysis and Design Aspects of Support Measures of Main Caverns of Karuma Hyd...Analysis and Design Aspects of Support Measures of Main Caverns of Karuma Hyd...
Analysis and Design Aspects of Support Measures of Main Caverns of Karuma Hyd...IOSRJMCE
 
Pillar design - a case study
Pillar design - a case studyPillar design - a case study
Pillar design - a case studyTIKESHWAR MAHTO
 
Mba admission in india
Mba admission in indiaMba admission in india
Mba admission in indiaEdhole.com
 
Rion antirion - yerevan - oct 2003
Rion antirion - yerevan  - oct 2003Rion antirion - yerevan  - oct 2003
Rion antirion - yerevan - oct 2003gefyra-rion
 
Design of earth dam at gorukallu
Design of earth dam at gorukalluDesign of earth dam at gorukallu
Design of earth dam at gorukallurohinibjn
 
03 azamat the experience of industrial processing of an uranium deposit of ak...
03 azamat the experience of industrial processing of an uranium deposit of ak...03 azamat the experience of industrial processing of an uranium deposit of ak...
03 azamat the experience of industrial processing of an uranium deposit of ak...Monatom Mgl
 
Geo trans2004 pecker
Geo trans2004 peckerGeo trans2004 pecker
Geo trans2004 peckergefyra-rion
 
A STUDY ON THE SEISMIC RESPONSE OF ELEVATED WATER TANK
A STUDY ON THE SEISMIC RESPONSE OF ELEVATED WATER TANKA STUDY ON THE SEISMIC RESPONSE OF ELEVATED WATER TANK
A STUDY ON THE SEISMIC RESPONSE OF ELEVATED WATER TANKIRJET Journal
 
about dam of archi that is cost effective
about dam of archi that is cost effectiveabout dam of archi that is cost effective
about dam of archi that is cost effectiveFikaduDebiso
 
Underground Coal Mining Study
Underground Coal Mining StudyUnderground Coal Mining Study
Underground Coal Mining StudyOnur Tuncay
 

Similar to Lyapichev. New RCC dams (Inter. Conf. on RCC, 2003) (20)

Lyapichev. Modern structural & technological solutions for new projects of hi...
Lyapichev. Modern structural & technological solutions for new projects of hi...Lyapichev. Modern structural & technological solutions for new projects of hi...
Lyapichev. Modern structural & technological solutions for new projects of hi...
 
Safety problem of Boguchansk rockfill dam with asphalt concrete core
Safety problem of Boguchansk rockfill dam with asphalt concrete coreSafety problem of Boguchansk rockfill dam with asphalt concrete core
Safety problem of Boguchansk rockfill dam with asphalt concrete core
 
Nurek rockfill dam (300 m). Problem of seismic safety of dam (4 p.)
Nurek rockfill dam (300 m). Problem of seismic safety of dam (4 p.)Nurek rockfill dam (300 m). Problem of seismic safety of dam (4 p.)
Nurek rockfill dam (300 m). Problem of seismic safety of dam (4 p.)
 
Cv15 nalisis method
Cv15 nalisis methodCv15 nalisis method
Cv15 nalisis method
 
Analysis and Design Aspects of Support Measures of Main Caverns of Karuma Hyd...
Analysis and Design Aspects of Support Measures of Main Caverns of Karuma Hyd...Analysis and Design Aspects of Support Measures of Main Caverns of Karuma Hyd...
Analysis and Design Aspects of Support Measures of Main Caverns of Karuma Hyd...
 
Pillar design
Pillar designPillar design
Pillar design
 
Pillar design - a case study
Pillar design - a case studyPillar design - a case study
Pillar design - a case study
 
Mba admission in india
Mba admission in indiaMba admission in india
Mba admission in india
 
Pile foundation
Pile foundationPile foundation
Pile foundation
 
Dfi2005 pecker
Dfi2005 peckerDfi2005 pecker
Dfi2005 pecker
 
Rion antirion - yerevan - oct 2003
Rion antirion - yerevan  - oct 2003Rion antirion - yerevan  - oct 2003
Rion antirion - yerevan - oct 2003
 
1. Tunnelling.pptx
1. Tunnelling.pptx1. Tunnelling.pptx
1. Tunnelling.pptx
 
Design of earth dam at gorukallu
Design of earth dam at gorukalluDesign of earth dam at gorukallu
Design of earth dam at gorukallu
 
03 azamat the experience of industrial processing of an uranium deposit of ak...
03 azamat the experience of industrial processing of an uranium deposit of ak...03 azamat the experience of industrial processing of an uranium deposit of ak...
03 azamat the experience of industrial processing of an uranium deposit of ak...
 
1115
11151115
1115
 
Geo trans2004 pecker
Geo trans2004 peckerGeo trans2004 pecker
Geo trans2004 pecker
 
A STUDY ON THE SEISMIC RESPONSE OF ELEVATED WATER TANK
A STUDY ON THE SEISMIC RESPONSE OF ELEVATED WATER TANKA STUDY ON THE SEISMIC RESPONSE OF ELEVATED WATER TANK
A STUDY ON THE SEISMIC RESPONSE OF ELEVATED WATER TANK
 
about dam of archi that is cost effective
about dam of archi that is cost effectiveabout dam of archi that is cost effective
about dam of archi that is cost effective
 
Underground Coal Mining Study
Underground Coal Mining StudyUnderground Coal Mining Study
Underground Coal Mining Study
 
Dams
DamsDams
Dams
 

More from Yury Lyapichev

Lyapichev: Analysis, design & behavior of CFRDs
Lyapichev: Analysis, design & behavior of CFRDsLyapichev: Analysis, design & behavior of CFRDs
Lyapichev: Analysis, design & behavior of CFRDsYury Lyapichev
 
Soluciones nuevas en presas en paises con alta sismisidad
Soluciones nuevas en presas en paises con alta sismisidadSoluciones nuevas en presas en paises con alta sismisidad
Soluciones nuevas en presas en paises con alta sismisidadYury Lyapichev
 
Curso postgrado internacional
Curso postgrado internacionalCurso postgrado internacional
Curso postgrado internacionalYury Lyapichev
 
Boletin inicial del curso internacional (Lyapichev)
Boletin inicial del curso internacional (Lyapichev)Boletin inicial del curso internacional (Lyapichev)
Boletin inicial del curso internacional (Lyapichev)Yury Lyapichev
 
Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...
Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...
Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...Yury Lyapichev
 
Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...
Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...
Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...Yury Lyapichev
 
Ляпичев. Проблема безопасности Богучанской КНП (HydroVision Russia, 2010)
Ляпичев. Проблема безопасности Богучанской КНП (HydroVision Russia, 2010)Ляпичев. Проблема безопасности Богучанской КНП (HydroVision Russia, 2010)
Ляпичев. Проблема безопасности Богучанской КНП (HydroVision Russia, 2010)Yury Lyapichev
 
ремонт центрального водосброса Саяно-Шушенской ГЭС
ремонт центрального водосброса Саяно-Шушенской ГЭС ремонт центрального водосброса Саяно-Шушенской ГЭС
ремонт центрального водосброса Саяно-Шушенской ГЭС Yury Lyapichev
 
Lyapichev. Laboratorio de segiridad de obras hidraulicas
Lyapichev. Laboratorio de segiridad de obras hidraulicasLyapichev. Laboratorio de segiridad de obras hidraulicas
Lyapichev. Laboratorio de segiridad de obras hidraulicasYury Lyapichev
 
Lyapichev. Research & teaching laboratory Safety of hydraulic structures (29 ...
Lyapichev. Research & teaching laboratory Safety of hydraulic structures (29 ...Lyapichev. Research & teaching laboratory Safety of hydraulic structures (29 ...
Lyapichev. Research & teaching laboratory Safety of hydraulic structures (29 ...Yury Lyapichev
 
Ляпичев. Программа школы Оценка рисков в гидротехнике (РУДН)
Ляпичев. Программа школы Оценка рисков в гидротехнике (РУДН)Ляпичев. Программа школы Оценка рисков в гидротехнике (РУДН)
Ляпичев. Программа школы Оценка рисков в гидротехнике (РУДН)Yury Lyapichev
 
Guidelines of Intern. Society for design of high CFRDs
Guidelines of Intern. Society for design of high CFRDsGuidelines of Intern. Society for design of high CFRDs
Guidelines of Intern. Society for design of high CFRDsYury Lyapichev
 
Seguridad de presas (Banco Mundial)
Seguridad de presas (Banco Mundial)Seguridad de presas (Banco Mundial)
Seguridad de presas (Banco Mundial)Yury Lyapichev
 
Lyapichev. Curso seguridad sismica de presas según de ICOLD
Lyapichev. Curso seguridad sismica de presas según de ICOLDLyapichev. Curso seguridad sismica de presas según de ICOLD
Lyapichev. Curso seguridad sismica de presas según de ICOLDYury Lyapichev
 
Lyapichev. Seguridad sismica de presas (ICOLD Congreso, 2003)
Lyapichev. Seguridad sismica de presas (ICOLD Congreso, 2003)Lyapichev. Seguridad sismica de presas (ICOLD Congreso, 2003)
Lyapichev. Seguridad sismica de presas (ICOLD Congreso, 2003)Yury Lyapichev
 
Lyapichev. Direcciones para gestión de seguridad de grandes presas y obras hi...
Lyapichev. Direcciones para gestión de seguridad de grandes presas y obras hi...Lyapichev. Direcciones para gestión de seguridad de grandes presas y obras hi...
Lyapichev. Direcciones para gestión de seguridad de grandes presas y obras hi...Yury Lyapichev
 
Lyapichev. Soluciones nuevas para grandes presas en Rusia y países con alta s...
Lyapichev. Soluciones nuevas para grandes presas en Rusia y países con alta s...Lyapichev. Soluciones nuevas para grandes presas en Rusia y países con alta s...
Lyapichev. Soluciones nuevas para grandes presas en Rusia y países con alta s...Yury Lyapichev
 
Ляпичев. Достоверность численных расчетов плотин
Ляпичев. Достоверность численных расчетов плотин Ляпичев. Достоверность численных расчетов плотин
Ляпичев. Достоверность численных расчетов плотин Yury Lyapichev
 
Ляпичев. Оценка банковского отчета ТЭО фирмы Коин и Белье по Богучанской ГЭС
Ляпичев. Оценка банковского отчета ТЭО фирмы Коин и Белье по Богучанской ГЭСЛяпичев. Оценка банковского отчета ТЭО фирмы Коин и Белье по Богучанской ГЭС
Ляпичев. Оценка банковского отчета ТЭО фирмы Коин и Белье по Богучанской ГЭСYury Lyapichev
 

More from Yury Lyapichev (20)

My abstracts
My abstractsMy abstracts
My abstracts
 
Lyapichev: Analysis, design & behavior of CFRDs
Lyapichev: Analysis, design & behavior of CFRDsLyapichev: Analysis, design & behavior of CFRDs
Lyapichev: Analysis, design & behavior of CFRDs
 
Soluciones nuevas en presas en paises con alta sismisidad
Soluciones nuevas en presas en paises con alta sismisidadSoluciones nuevas en presas en paises con alta sismisidad
Soluciones nuevas en presas en paises con alta sismisidad
 
Curso postgrado internacional
Curso postgrado internacionalCurso postgrado internacional
Curso postgrado internacional
 
Boletin inicial del curso internacional (Lyapichev)
Boletin inicial del curso internacional (Lyapichev)Boletin inicial del curso internacional (Lyapichev)
Boletin inicial del curso internacional (Lyapichev)
 
Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...
Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...
Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...
 
Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...
Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...
Ляпичев. Проектирование, строительство и поведение современных высоких плотин...
 
Ляпичев. Проблема безопасности Богучанской КНП (HydroVision Russia, 2010)
Ляпичев. Проблема безопасности Богучанской КНП (HydroVision Russia, 2010)Ляпичев. Проблема безопасности Богучанской КНП (HydroVision Russia, 2010)
Ляпичев. Проблема безопасности Богучанской КНП (HydroVision Russia, 2010)
 
ремонт центрального водосброса Саяно-Шушенской ГЭС
ремонт центрального водосброса Саяно-Шушенской ГЭС ремонт центрального водосброса Саяно-Шушенской ГЭС
ремонт центрального водосброса Саяно-Шушенской ГЭС
 
Lyapichev. Laboratorio de segiridad de obras hidraulicas
Lyapichev. Laboratorio de segiridad de obras hidraulicasLyapichev. Laboratorio de segiridad de obras hidraulicas
Lyapichev. Laboratorio de segiridad de obras hidraulicas
 
Lyapichev. Research & teaching laboratory Safety of hydraulic structures (29 ...
Lyapichev. Research & teaching laboratory Safety of hydraulic structures (29 ...Lyapichev. Research & teaching laboratory Safety of hydraulic structures (29 ...
Lyapichev. Research & teaching laboratory Safety of hydraulic structures (29 ...
 
Ляпичев. Программа школы Оценка рисков в гидротехнике (РУДН)
Ляпичев. Программа школы Оценка рисков в гидротехнике (РУДН)Ляпичев. Программа школы Оценка рисков в гидротехнике (РУДН)
Ляпичев. Программа школы Оценка рисков в гидротехнике (РУДН)
 
Guidelines of Intern. Society for design of high CFRDs
Guidelines of Intern. Society for design of high CFRDsGuidelines of Intern. Society for design of high CFRDs
Guidelines of Intern. Society for design of high CFRDs
 
Seguridad de presas (Banco Mundial)
Seguridad de presas (Banco Mundial)Seguridad de presas (Banco Mundial)
Seguridad de presas (Banco Mundial)
 
Lyapichev. Curso seguridad sismica de presas según de ICOLD
Lyapichev. Curso seguridad sismica de presas según de ICOLDLyapichev. Curso seguridad sismica de presas según de ICOLD
Lyapichev. Curso seguridad sismica de presas según de ICOLD
 
Lyapichev. Seguridad sismica de presas (ICOLD Congreso, 2003)
Lyapichev. Seguridad sismica de presas (ICOLD Congreso, 2003)Lyapichev. Seguridad sismica de presas (ICOLD Congreso, 2003)
Lyapichev. Seguridad sismica de presas (ICOLD Congreso, 2003)
 
Lyapichev. Direcciones para gestión de seguridad de grandes presas y obras hi...
Lyapichev. Direcciones para gestión de seguridad de grandes presas y obras hi...Lyapichev. Direcciones para gestión de seguridad de grandes presas y obras hi...
Lyapichev. Direcciones para gestión de seguridad de grandes presas y obras hi...
 
Lyapichev. Soluciones nuevas para grandes presas en Rusia y países con alta s...
Lyapichev. Soluciones nuevas para grandes presas en Rusia y países con alta s...Lyapichev. Soluciones nuevas para grandes presas en Rusia y países con alta s...
Lyapichev. Soluciones nuevas para grandes presas en Rusia y países con alta s...
 
Ляпичев. Достоверность численных расчетов плотин
Ляпичев. Достоверность численных расчетов плотин Ляпичев. Достоверность численных расчетов плотин
Ляпичев. Достоверность численных расчетов плотин
 
Ляпичев. Оценка банковского отчета ТЭО фирмы Коин и Белье по Богучанской ГЭС
Ляпичев. Оценка банковского отчета ТЭО фирмы Коин и Белье по Богучанской ГЭСЛяпичев. Оценка банковского отчета ТЭО фирмы Коин и Белье по Богучанской ГЭС
Ляпичев. Оценка банковского отчета ТЭО фирмы Коин и Белье по Богучанской ГЭС
 

Recently uploaded

(RIA) Call Girls Bhosari ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(RIA) Call Girls Bhosari ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(RIA) Call Girls Bhosari ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(RIA) Call Girls Bhosari ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
247267395-1-Symmetric-and-distributed-shared-memory-architectures-ppt (1).ppt
247267395-1-Symmetric-and-distributed-shared-memory-architectures-ppt (1).ppt247267395-1-Symmetric-and-distributed-shared-memory-architectures-ppt (1).ppt
247267395-1-Symmetric-and-distributed-shared-memory-architectures-ppt (1).pptssuser5c9d4b1
 
Call Girls Service Nagpur Tanvi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Tanvi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls Service Nagpur Tanvi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Tanvi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
Call Girls Service Nashik Vaishnavi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
Call Girls Service Nashik Vaishnavi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikCall Girls Service Nashik Vaishnavi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
Call Girls Service Nashik Vaishnavi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikCall Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...ranjana rawat
 
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...ranjana rawat
 
KubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghly
KubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghlyKubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghly
KubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghlysanyuktamishra911
 
SPICE PARK APR2024 ( 6,793 SPICE Models )
SPICE PARK APR2024 ( 6,793 SPICE Models )SPICE PARK APR2024 ( 6,793 SPICE Models )
SPICE PARK APR2024 ( 6,793 SPICE Models )Tsuyoshi Horigome
 
(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escortsranjana rawat
 
Call for Papers - Educational Administration: Theory and Practice, E-ISSN: 21...
Call for Papers - Educational Administration: Theory and Practice, E-ISSN: 21...Call for Papers - Educational Administration: Theory and Practice, E-ISSN: 21...
Call for Papers - Educational Administration: Theory and Practice, E-ISSN: 21...Christo Ananth
 
UNIT-II FMM-Flow Through Circular Conduits
UNIT-II FMM-Flow Through Circular ConduitsUNIT-II FMM-Flow Through Circular Conduits
UNIT-II FMM-Flow Through Circular Conduitsrknatarajan
 
VIP Call Girls Service Hitech City Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Hitech City Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130VIP Call Girls Service Hitech City Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Hitech City Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130Suhani Kapoor
 
Processing & Properties of Floor and Wall Tiles.pptx
Processing & Properties of Floor and Wall Tiles.pptxProcessing & Properties of Floor and Wall Tiles.pptx
Processing & Properties of Floor and Wall Tiles.pptxpranjaldaimarysona
 
Call Girls in Nagpur Suman Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls in Nagpur Suman Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls in Nagpur Suman Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls in Nagpur Suman Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
Introduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptx
Introduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptxIntroduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptx
Introduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptxupamatechverse
 
(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...
(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...
(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...ranjana rawat
 
UNIT - IV - Air Compressors and its Performance
UNIT - IV - Air Compressors and its PerformanceUNIT - IV - Air Compressors and its Performance
UNIT - IV - Air Compressors and its Performancesivaprakash250
 
CCS335 _ Neural Networks and Deep Learning Laboratory_Lab Complete Record
CCS335 _ Neural Networks and Deep Learning Laboratory_Lab Complete RecordCCS335 _ Neural Networks and Deep Learning Laboratory_Lab Complete Record
CCS335 _ Neural Networks and Deep Learning Laboratory_Lab Complete RecordAsst.prof M.Gokilavani
 
Call Girls Pimpri Chinchwad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Boo...
Call Girls Pimpri Chinchwad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Boo...Call Girls Pimpri Chinchwad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Boo...
Call Girls Pimpri Chinchwad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Boo...roncy bisnoi
 

Recently uploaded (20)

(RIA) Call Girls Bhosari ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(RIA) Call Girls Bhosari ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(RIA) Call Girls Bhosari ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(RIA) Call Girls Bhosari ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
247267395-1-Symmetric-and-distributed-shared-memory-architectures-ppt (1).ppt
247267395-1-Symmetric-and-distributed-shared-memory-architectures-ppt (1).ppt247267395-1-Symmetric-and-distributed-shared-memory-architectures-ppt (1).ppt
247267395-1-Symmetric-and-distributed-shared-memory-architectures-ppt (1).ppt
 
Call Girls Service Nagpur Tanvi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Tanvi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls Service Nagpur Tanvi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Tanvi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
 
Call Girls Service Nashik Vaishnavi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
Call Girls Service Nashik Vaishnavi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikCall Girls Service Nashik Vaishnavi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
Call Girls Service Nashik Vaishnavi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
 
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...
 
(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
 
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...
 
KubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghly
KubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghlyKubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghly
KubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghly
 
SPICE PARK APR2024 ( 6,793 SPICE Models )
SPICE PARK APR2024 ( 6,793 SPICE Models )SPICE PARK APR2024 ( 6,793 SPICE Models )
SPICE PARK APR2024 ( 6,793 SPICE Models )
 
(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
 
Call for Papers - Educational Administration: Theory and Practice, E-ISSN: 21...
Call for Papers - Educational Administration: Theory and Practice, E-ISSN: 21...Call for Papers - Educational Administration: Theory and Practice, E-ISSN: 21...
Call for Papers - Educational Administration: Theory and Practice, E-ISSN: 21...
 
UNIT-II FMM-Flow Through Circular Conduits
UNIT-II FMM-Flow Through Circular ConduitsUNIT-II FMM-Flow Through Circular Conduits
UNIT-II FMM-Flow Through Circular Conduits
 
VIP Call Girls Service Hitech City Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Hitech City Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130VIP Call Girls Service Hitech City Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Hitech City Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
 
Processing & Properties of Floor and Wall Tiles.pptx
Processing & Properties of Floor and Wall Tiles.pptxProcessing & Properties of Floor and Wall Tiles.pptx
Processing & Properties of Floor and Wall Tiles.pptx
 
Call Girls in Nagpur Suman Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls in Nagpur Suman Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls in Nagpur Suman Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls in Nagpur Suman Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
 
Introduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptx
Introduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptxIntroduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptx
Introduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptx
 
(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...
(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...
(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...
 
UNIT - IV - Air Compressors and its Performance
UNIT - IV - Air Compressors and its PerformanceUNIT - IV - Air Compressors and its Performance
UNIT - IV - Air Compressors and its Performance
 
CCS335 _ Neural Networks and Deep Learning Laboratory_Lab Complete Record
CCS335 _ Neural Networks and Deep Learning Laboratory_Lab Complete RecordCCS335 _ Neural Networks and Deep Learning Laboratory_Lab Complete Record
CCS335 _ Neural Networks and Deep Learning Laboratory_Lab Complete Record
 
Call Girls Pimpri Chinchwad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Boo...
Call Girls Pimpri Chinchwad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Boo...Call Girls Pimpri Chinchwad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Boo...
Call Girls Pimpri Chinchwad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Boo...
 

Lyapichev. New RCC dams (Inter. Conf. on RCC, 2003)

  • 1. 1 1 INTRODUCTION RCC is a new type of lean concrete with the large technological possibilities not completely realized and with the wide physical-mechanical properties ranging from the early first type of lean RCC (< 99 kg/m3 ) to the third type of high-paste RCC (with cementitious content >180 kg/m3 ). At the present the RCC-3 is used widely in the gravity dams in Spain and China while the RCC-1 is used mainly in RCC dams in Brazil and Colombia (Dunstan 2003). The modern high (100 m and more) RCC-3 gravity dams with the traditional triangle cross-section with a vertical upstream face and a sloping downstream face (0,8H/1V) on a rigid (rock) foundation are fre- quently unsafe solution in the event of an earthquake with a horizontal acceleration of 0.2g and more. An- other serious restriction of traditional gravity (TG) RCC dams is that they are not feasible on a soft (soil) and even on a weak rock foundation (ICOLD Bulletin 117, 2000). These restrictions of RCC dams can be overcome by changing their TG profile to the symmetrical tri- angle cross-section with RCC-1 with very low ce- mentitious content, without horizontal joints treat- ment and with a watertight upstream concrete facing. This new type of lean RCC dam (so called “Faced Symmetrical Hardfill” or FSH dam with both slopes of about 0,7H/1V) was first introduced by Londe and Lino. (1992). Owing to the symmetrical shape of this dam RCC requires neither high shear nor high compressive strengths and there is no ten- sile stress whatsoever in the section at least for an earthquake with a pseudo-static acceleration of 0.20g (ICOLD Bulletin 117, 2000). 2 FSH DAM WITH ZONE OF ROCKFILL ENRICHED WITH CEMENT (FSH-REC DAM) Further optimization of the concept of FSH dam led us to a new type of composed FSH dam with outer zones of lean RCC-1 and inner wide zone of rockfill, enriched with cement-flyash mortar (REC) or FSH- REC dam (Fig.1). The outer zones of this dam with slopes of about 0.5-0.7 (depending on site conditions) and width of about (3+0,1H) m (where H – water head in meters) can be made with very low cement contents (< 70 kg/m3 ). By placing the CARPI watertight membrane on the upstream dam slope (instead of more labor- consuming and expensive reinforced concrete fac- ing), the uplift in RCC joints or cracks is eliminated, thus, with no consequence either on watertightness or on the safety of the dam. The CARPI membrane is placed after completion of the dam to overcome any difficulties with thermal cracking in RCC zones. The 4-th International Conference on RCC Dams (Madrid, November 2003) Seismic stability and stress-strain state of a new type of FSH-RCC dams Yu.P.Liapichev Dr. (Techn. Sc.), Professor, Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia, Moscow, Russia ABSTRACT: The finite element seismic (linear spectral and dynamic) analyses of stability and stress-strain state of a new type of composed Faced Symmetrical Hardfill (FSH) dam with central zone of rockfill enriched with cement mortar (REC) or FSH-REC dam of different heights (30, 60 and 100 m) and slopes (0.4, 0.5 and 0.7H/1V) on rigid and soft foundations are performed and compared with the traditional gravity RCC dams. The methodology of seismic response of the system "dam-foundation-reservoir" is considered in brief as well as the elastoplastic hardening model of RCC taking into account the cohesion and angle of inner friction of RCC joints. The seismic resistance of the 100 m high FSH-REC dam (with slopes of 0,5H/1H) on rock foun- dation is considered for action of two strong earthquakes (MDE and MCE) with ground horizontal and verti- cal accelerograms with peak values of 0,2 and 0,4 g. In the MDE case the dam behavior is quite elastic and safe with no tension or opening of RCC joints. In the MCE case the dam behavior is elastoplastic with plastic deformations near the dam crest and partial opening of RCC joints in the lower half of the dam. The upstream CARPI membrane can provide the water-tightness of the dam in the MDE and MCE cases.
  • 2. 2 This design has been used successfully for the ver- tical upstream face of RCC dams (Miel in Colombia, Riou in France, Concepcion in Honduras, etc.). The wide central zone of the dam can be made with Figure 1. Section of the 100 m high FSH-REC dam REC (rockfill of 5-300 mm diameter, enriched with cement-flyash mortar) in the central zone of the dam can be placed in 60 cm thick layers while RCC layers in the outer zones - in 30 cm layers. Than 10- 15 cm thick cement-flyash mortar is spread over a rockfill layer and penetrates into the coarse pores of rockfill. The penetration can be facilitated by 1-2 passages of Dynapic sheep roller and subsequent compaction can be achieved by 2-3 passages of Bo- maq vibrating roller used also for compaction of RCC outer zones of the dam. The separated placing of the wide REC central zone of the FSH-REC dam permits to replace the expensive mixing plant for RCC dam with much less cheap cement mortar facility on the FSH-REC dam thus achieving the significant economical effect as well as using rockfill instead of RCC aggregates. Owing to higher rockfill layers (60 cm) than tra- ditional 30 cm of RCC and using CARPI membrane on the upstream slope instead of reinforced concrete facing the speed of construction of FSH-REC dam will be higher than homogeneous FSH dam. Naturally, construction of the FSH-REC dam as well as FSH dam should be tested on the site. But the structural (seismic) aspects of a new design of FSH-REC or FSH dam should be performed in ad- vance because at the present the required seismic (dynamic) analyses of these dams are not available. 3 PSEUDO-STATIC STABILITY OF FSH-REC AND RCC DAMS According to our stability analysis of the 60 and 100 m high FSH-REC dams during its construction the minimum cohesion of RCC of outer zones and REC should be not less than 0.5 and 0,1 MPa, corre- spondingly, to obtain the required cohesion during simultaneous placing of outer zones of RCC and central zone of REC (Liapichev 1998). This RCC cohesion value of 0,5 MPa corresponds to the mini- mum cohesion of RCC-1 joints without treatment (Schrader 1999). For RCC and REC materials the minimum inner friction angle of 450 is assumed, which corresponds to the preliminary design of RCC dams. Table 1 and 2 show the comparison, in terms of factors of safety against sliding at the foundation, of a 100 m high traditional RCC dam with vertical up- stream and sloping downstream faces (Sd=0.7; 0.8 and 0.9) and an FSH-REC dam of the same height and both slopes (Su=Sd=0.4; 0.5 and 0.7). Three types of foundations were considered: tra- ditional rock foundation (with the angle of inner friction =450 ), alluvial (=350 ) and moraine (=300 and cohesion C=0,1MPa) foundations. Two operation cases were considered: static case with a maximum reservoir level and seismic (pseudo static) case with a ground acceleration of 0.2g. In seismic case the shear wedge method was used for the calculation of accelerations distribution in both dam because this method corresponds to the actual shear movements of RCC dams during earthquakes. For both dams the uplift was taken at 40% of the force developed by a straight percolation line from full reservoir head upstream to no head at the dam. Table 1. Factors of safety against sliding for 100 m high RCC dam Types of foundation Factors of safety for downstream slope (static/seismic cases) 0.7 0.8 0.9 Rock 1.91/1.47 2.14/1.60 2.37/1.73 Alluvium 1.33/1.02 1.50/1.12 1.66/1.21 Moraine 1.24/0.95 1.39/1.04 1.54/1.13 2x0.3=0.6m 2x0.3=0.6m Detail A 0.4 2x0.3=0.6m CARPI membrane 2x0.3=0.6m 1 0.4 RCC-1 1 REC Detail B 0.5 1 REC RCC-1 REC REC REC Grout curtain Gallery CVC Detail A 1 0.5 1CARPI membrane RCC 1 0.4 Detail B 0.5 1 0.4 0.5 1 dam axis 100.00 0.00 RCC
  • 3. 3 Table 2. Factors of safety against sliding for 100 m high FSH- REC dam. Types of foundation Factors of safety for both slopes (stat- ic/seismic cases) 0.4 0.5 0.7 Rock 2.59/1.91 3.15/2.21 4.27/2.74 Alluvium 1.99/1.33 2.20/1.55 2.98/1.92 Moraine 1.65/1.22 2.01/1.41 2.73/1.75 According to Russian design norms for gravity dams (1987) the minimum allowable factors of safe- ty against sliding on the contact dam-rock founda- tion for static and seismic cases are, corresponding- ly, 1.32 and 1.18. It means that RCC or PG (gravity dam of conventional concrete) dams aren’t feasible on soft foundation (alluvium, moraine, etc.). On the contrary, FSH-REC or FSH dams even with steep slopes (0.4H/1V) are quite feasible and safe on rock and soft foundations. Table 3 and 4 show the comparison, in terms of normal and principal stresses at the dam base for static and seismic (pseudo-static with a ground ac- celeration of 0.2 g) cases of both dams of the same height (100 m) on a rock foundation. Table 3. Stresses at the base of 100 high RCC dam. Stresses in MPa for downstream slope (seismic case) Stresses 0.9 0.8 0.7 σy u -0.74 -0.42 0.3 σx u -1 -1 -1 τxy u 0 0 0 σ1 u -0.74 -0.42 0.3 σ3 u -1 -1 -1 σy d -1.67 -2.00 -2.48 σx d -1.67 -1.28 -1.21 τxy d 1.50 1.60 1.73 σ1 d 0 0 0 σ3 d -3.03 -3.29 -3.69 The upper index u in all stresses in tables 3 and 4 denotes upstream face, d – downstream face. The sign (-) denotes compression and (+) – tension. Table 3 shows that the M. Lévy condition is not satisfied at the RCC dam heel (with the downstream slope of 0.7) and the base joint is likely to open. The same is true for the 100 m high FSH-REC dam with both slopes of 0.4V/1H. But for the same dam with both slopes of 0.5V/1H and flatter the RCC base joints are likely to be closed after even a strong earthquake. Table 4. Stresses at the base of the 100 m high FSH-REC dam. Stresses in MPa for both slopes (static/seismic cases) Stresses 0.7 0.5 0.4 σy u -1.30/-0.94 -0.90/-0.39 -0.48/0.17 σx u -1.14/-0.97 -0.97/-0.47 -0.91/-0.82 τxy u -0.21/0.03 0.04/-0.30 0.20/0.47 σ1 u -1.45/-0.91 -0.88/-0.23 -0.39/0.36 σ3 u -1/-1 -1/-1 -1/-1 σy d -1.54/-1.90 -1.95/-2.27 -2.39/-3.0 σx d -0.75/-0.93 -0.48/-0.61 -0.38/-0.48 τxy d 1.08/1.30 0.97/1.23 0.95/1.22 σ1 d 0/0 0/0 0/0 σ3 d -2.29/-2.80 -2.44/-3.09 -2.77/-3.50 The same static and seismic (pseudo-static) stabil- ity and stress analyses were performed for the 30 and 60 m high FSH-REC dams on the same founda- tions. These analyses showed that these FSH-REC dams with both slopes of 0.4V/1H or flatter are quite stable and safe on rock and soft foundations even for action of very strong earthquake with a ground ac- celeration of 0.4g. In the 30 m high FSH-REC dam the enrichment of rockfill with cement mortar can be excluded, thus, creating the composite FSH-RF dam. 4 SEISMIC (PSEUDO-DYNAMIC) STRESS- STRAIN STATE ANALYSIS OF FSH-REC DAMS The finite element seismic (linear spectral or pseu- do-dynamic) analyses of stress-strain state of the FSH-REC dams of different heights (30, 60 and 100 m) and slopes (0,4; 0,5 and 0,7) on rock (rigid) foundations were performed for action of a ground acceleration of 0,20g. The main results of the seis- mic analysis for the 100 m high FSH-REC dam with slopes of 0.5 V/1H are shown on Fig. 2-5. Fig. 2 shows that the M. Lévy condition is satis- fied at the dam heel and the base RCC joints are closed. The distribution of maximum principal stresses 1 in the dam (Fig. 3) is nearly uniform from upstream to downstream faces reaching only 2.3 MPa at the toe. The same uniform distribution was obtained for shear normal and maximum stresses with maximum values, correspondingly, 0.7 and 0.9 MPa in RCC outer zones at the dam base (Fig. 4, 5).
  • 4. 4 Figure 2. Vertical normal stresses y (t/m2 ) in the 100 m high FSH-REC dam with both slopes of 0.5V/1H (seismic case). Figure 3. Maximum principal stresses 1(t/m2 ) in the 100 m high FSH-REC dam with both slopes of 0.5V/1H (seismic case). Figure 4. Shear normal stresses xy (t/m2 ) in the 100 m high FSH-REC dam with both slopes of 0.5V/1H (seismic case). Figure 5. Maximum shear stresses max (t/m2 ) in the 100 m high FSH-REC dam with both slopes of 0.5V/1H (seismic case). Thus, the stress-strain state of the 100 m high FSH- REC dam with both slopes of 0.5V/1H for action of a strong earthquake is much more favorable and safe than in the 100 m high traditional RCC or PG dam with the downstream slope of 0.8V/1H. 5 SEISMIC (DYNAMIC) STRESS-STRAIN STATE ANALYSIS OF HIGH FSH-REC DAM According to the new Russian anti-seismic design norms for dams (2003) the seismic (dynamic) analy- sis are to be performed for high dams (100 m and higher) located in moderate or high seismic regions. The dynamic analysis of the 100 m high FSH- REC dam with slopes of 0.5V/1H was performed by the method used now in the Geodynamic Center of Hydroproject Institute (Bronchtein et al. 2002). The dynamic response of the ‘dam-foundation- reservoir’ system for action of these accelerations was considered in the analysis. The influence of gravity waves in the reservoir was neglected and the boundary conditions between reservoir and dam and reservoir and foundation were simplified. The condi- tion of equal normal displacements on these bounda- ries was assumed for dam, foundation and reservoir. The passing of shear stresses through these bounda- ries was assumed that allows simplify the problem by abandoning the interface elements (Groshev 2000). As for a mathematic model of RCC and REC the elastoplastic hardening model with associated flow rule and shear strength of RCC joints (angle of the inner friction  and cohesion C) was used (Fig.6). The hardening parameters of the model are shear and volume plastic deformations on the maxi- mum shear plane (Groshev, Shablinsky 1991). This RCC model simulates well cracking or open- ing of RCC horizontal joints and their subsequent reaction only to compression. -11.39 85.43 194.35 212.09 156.22 176.33 -3.24 74.73 137.61 202.50 113.80 165.49 6.41 63.39 118.39 167.38 99.44 160.39 12.34 54.90 99.42 131.40 86.91 150.77 15.81 47.10 79.75 99.46 74.12135.52 16.1338.6860.7572.91 61.13113.44 13.1529.5744.0750.7347.3386.18 6.7621.2928.1730.8432.8754.83 -2.0311.3110.1513.1417.3119.66 -11.39 -11.39 85.43 194.35 212.09 156.22 176.33 176.33 176.33-3.24 -3.24 165.49 165.496.41 6.41 160.39 160.3912.34 12.34 150.77 150.7715.81 15.81 135.52 135.5216.13 16.13 113.44 113.4413.15 13.15 86.18 86.186.76 6.76 54.83 54.83-2.03 -2.03-2.0311.3110.1513.1417.31 19.66 19.66 95.37 132.99 218.64 224.05 179.63 210.45 101.30 129.18 160.88 220.84 124.01 194.04 93.09 107.13 144.73 184.95 109.02 187.93 81.03 94.19 123.61 146.49 98.43 179.22 71.96 79.08 99.88 113.72 89.16164.21 60.4564.4277.8287.63 79.29139.82 49.3150.8559.2866.2764.70106.56 31.7238.2841.3441.4445.9071.90 22.1324.5922.6225.4025.8128.02 95.37 95.37 132.99 218.64 224.05 179.63 210.45 210.45 210.45101.30 101.30 194.04 194.0493.09 93.09 187.93 187.9381.03 81.03 179.22 179.2271.96 71.96 164.21 164.2160.45 60.45 139.82 139.8249.31 49.31 106.56 106.5631.72 31.72 71.90 71.9022.13 22.1322.1324.5922.6225.4025.81 28.02 28.02 -82.67 -64.93 -61.42 -43.13 -53.04 -73.68 -56.95 -64.77 -53.73 -57.60 -31.25 -66.76 -51.12 -51.38 -52.04 -51.54 -29.15 -65.04 -39.54 -43.15 -45.86 -42.29 -30.03 -64.16 -30.15 -33.43 -36.44 -35.28 -31.47-60.94 -21.70-24.21-27.44-29.52 -30.91-53.19 -16.25-17.27-20.38-23.98-25.92-40.28 -7.53-13.19-14.91-15.27-18.52-30.28 -6.61-8.43-8.37-10.04-9.31-12.43 -82.67 -82.67 -64.93 -61.42 -43.13 -53.04 -73.68 -73.68 -73.68-56.95 -56.95 -66.76 -66.76-51.12 -51.12 -65.04 -65.04-39.54 -39.54 -64.16 -64.16-30.15 -30.15 -60.94 -60.94-21.70 -21.70 -53.19 -53.19-16.25 -16.25 -40.28 -40.28-7.53 -7.53 -30.28 -30.28-6.61 -6.61-6.61-8.43-8.37-10.04-9.31 -12.43 -12.43 85.39 68.09 89.81 83.77 71.79 96.60 67.78 65.75 74.00 99.62 52.94 92.35 58.42 52.05 64.58 84.39 49.12 90.57 45.72 43.33 55.56 66.84 44.89 86.57 36.17 33.47 43.05 50.76 40.4679.07 27.4724.2530.5836.96 35.4066.81 21.7317.6521.2626.2728.0350.00 13.6113.6215.0316.3019.6835.39 12.989.319.0510.249.3513.43 85.39 85.39 68.09 89.81 83.77 71.79 96.60 96.60 96.6067.78 67.78 92.35 92.3558.42 58.42 90.57 90.5745.72 45.72 86.57 86.5736.17 36.17 79.07 79.0727.47 27.47 66.81 66.8121.73 21.73 50.00 50.0013.61 13.61 35.39 35.3912.98 12.9812.989.319.0510.249.35 13.43 13.43
  • 5. 5 Figure 6. Elastoplastic hardening model of RCC. The synthetic horizontal and vertical accelera- tions with peak values of 0,8g were normalized as the Maximum Design Earthquake (MDE) with the peak ground horizontal and vertical accelerations of 0.2 and 0.14g, correspondingly (Fig.7-a, b) and as the Maximum Credible Earthquake (MCE) with the peak ground horizontal and vertical accelerations of 0.4 and 0.28g. (a) (b) Figure 7-a, b. Ground horizontal (a) and vertical (b) accelera- tions (in m/s2 ) for the MDE. The same shear strength values of RCC-1 and REC joints were adopted in this dynamic analysis as in the previous linear spectral analysis: in RCC-1 joints φ=450 , C=0,5 MPa, in REC joints φ=450 , C=0,1 MPa. Elasticity modulus of RCC-1 E=5000 MPa and REC E=1000 MPa, Poison coefficient of RCC-1 υ=0.2 and REC υ=0.25. Elasticity modulus of rock foundation E=10000 MPa and υ=0.2. The results of dynamical analysis of the 100 m high FSH-REC dam with slopes of 0.5V/1H for ac- tion of MDE are presented on Figs. 8 and 9. Fig. 8 shows the variation of the horizontal dis- placements of six control points along the upstream slope: the first one is at the base and the sixth is at the crest (with 20m vertical spacing between points). As can be seen from Fig. 8, the dynamic response of dam is elastic and elastic horizontal displacement are completely damping by the end of the MDE without any residual values. The maximum horizontal accel- eration at the dam crest for the MDE reaches 0.31g. Fig. 9 shows the finite element mesh of the dam and rock foundation with only one crack or joint opening in RCC-1 zone near the dam base during the MDE. But after the MDE the RCC joint is closed. Figure 8. Variation of horizontal displacements of six points on the upstream slope for the MDE. Figure 9. Finite element mesh and one crack (joint) opening in RCC near the dam base for the MDE.
  • 6. 6 Thus, it is clear that the FSH-REC dam is safe for the MDE case, and that there is no development of tensile stresses or opening of RCC-1 joints. The results of dynamical analysis of the same FSH-REC dam for action of MCE with the ground peak horizontal and vertical accelerations of 0.4 and 0.28g are presented on Figs. 10, 11 and 12. Fig. 10 shows the variation of the horizontal dis- placements of six control points along the upstream slope from the dam base up to its crest. As can be seen from Fig. 10, the dynamic response of the dam is elastic and elastic horizontal displacement are, mainly, damping by the end of the MDE without re- sidual (plastic) values except the point 6 at the dam crest. Therefore, the maximum horizontal accelera- tion at the dam crest for the MCE reaches only 0.28g (Fig. 11) comparing to 0.31g in the MDE case. The cracking pattern (Fig. 12) in the dam body for the MCE case is deteriorated comparing to the MDE: in the lower part of the dam the cracks (joints opening) propagated from the upstream slope to- wards the dam axis. However, owing to the up- stream impervious CARPI membrane, the uplift propagation through RCC and RSC joints is impos- sible and seismic safety of the dam is provided. Figure 10. Variation of horizontal displacements of six points on the upstream dam slope for the MCE. Figure 11. Variation of horizontal accelerations (g) of six points on the upstream dam slope for the MCE. Figure 12. The cracking (joints opening) pattern in the dam body for the MCE. The cracking or joints opening in the RCC outer zones during the MCE can be excluded or, at least, decreased by joints treatment in these zones (bed- ding mix) that can increase twice or more RCC joint cohesion. In this case another solution is remained: to decrease the steepness of both slopes from 0.5 to 0.6 thus excluding any treatment of the RCC joints.
  • 7. 7 The hypothetic maximum earthquake (HME) with the peak ground horizontal and vertical accelerations of 0.8 and 0.56g, correspondingly, (twice as much as the MCE) was applied to the dam to achieve its complete cracking (joints opening) or hypothetic failure. Figure 13. Variation of horizontal displacements of six points on the upstream dam slope for the hypothetic maximum earth- quake. Fig. 13 shows the variation of the horizontal dis- placements of six control points along the upstream slope from the dam base up to its crest. As can be seen from Fig. 13, the dynamic response of the dam is complex: at the dam crest (point 6) the residual (plastic) horizontal displacements are developed af- ter the earthquake while in the major rest part of the dam (points 1-5) only the elastic displacements are developed. The maximum horizontal acceleration at the dam crest for this HME case reaches 0.38g com- paring to 0.28g in the MCE case. In this hypothetic case the horizontal cracks or all horizontal joints in the dam body from the upstream to downstream faces are opened after the HME. Thus, the 100 m high FSH-REC dam with both slopes of 0.5H/1V has, at least, the double seismic (dynamic) margin against action of the MCE. 6 CONCLUSIONS It is shown that a new type of composite FSH dam with the outer zones of lean RCC and inner wide zone of rockfill enriched with cement mortar (FSH- REC dam) of height up to 100 m on rock or soil foundation is a very attractive alternative comparing to traditional RCC or PG dams. The seismic (dy- namic) analysis of the 100 m high FSH-REC dam with both slopes of 0.5H/1V has shown the excellent behavior of its symmetrical cross-section for action of very strong earthquake with peak ground horizon- tal and vertical accelerations, correspondingly, of 0,40 and 0.28g. Owing to the CARPI impervious membrane placed on the upstream slope there are no uplift in the lean RCC joints of the dam even for ac- tion of the hypothetic maximum earthquake with a peak ground acceleration of 0.80g. The possible technological problems of construc- tion of the FSH-REC dam as well as FSH dam can be checked and solved in advance during construc- tion of the FSH-REC cofferdam on the site. REFERENCES Bronshtein, V.I., Groshev, M.E., Savich, A.I. 2002. Seismic safety in hydro power sector of Russia. HydroVision 2002.Technical paper 052. HCI Publication. USA. Groshev, M.E. 1998. Methods and computer programs for seismic safety assessment of hydropower plants and dams. Proc. Safety of Energy Structures (in Russian). Publ. NIIES, Moscow, Issue 7: 130-139. Groshev, M.E., Shablisky G.E. 1991. Application of the theory of plastic flow for simulation of deformations and strength of concrete. Civil Engineering and Architecture (in Rus- sian). Moscow. Dunstan, M.R.H. 2003. RCC dams (under construction and completed) in 2003. Hydropower and Dams. World Atlas and Industry Guide. ICOLD Bulletin 117, 2000. The gravity dam – a dam for the future. Review and recommendations. Liapichev, Yu. P. 1998. New structures of dam from RCC and rockfill. Problems of theory and practice in engineering re- search (in Russian). Proc. Structural Mechanics. Publ. As- sociation of Civil Engineering Institutes. Moscow. 39-43. Liapichev, Yu. P. 1998. RCC dams and composite RCC and rockfill dams. Aspects of design, construction and safety (in Spanish). Seminar for ESAGEN, Medellin, Colombia. Londe, P., Lino, M. 1992. The faced symmetrical hardfill dam: a new concept for RCC. Water Power and Dam Construc- tion, Vol. 44, Number 2. Schrader, E.K. 1999. Shear strength and lift joint quality of RCC. Hydropower and Dams, Vol. 6, Issue 1: 46-55.