SlideShare a Scribd company logo
VOLUME NO.: LLAT/ 514 OF 2012-13                                                                  DATE: 30th June, 2012
 ­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­ 
 Dear Client,

 We have pleasure in listing below some of the recent legal landmarks.

SR.      AUTHORITY            SECTION / RULES                                         RATIO(S)
NO.      CITATIONS              / SUBJECT                                      CASE(NAME OF ASSESSEE)

1.1   DEL HC I               195, ITA                    If a holding company advances borrowed money to a subsidiary and
                                                         the same is used by the subsidiary for some business purposes, the
                                                         'A' would be entitled to deduction of interest on its borrowed loans.

1.2   2012-TII-25            Busi. Inc                   Telsuo Mitera

2.1   BANG ITAT              147, ITA                    When the 'A' handed over the possession of the land to the developer
                                                         and the developer changed after some work on the same, the gain
                                                         arising on sale of the land will be taxable in the year of original
                                                         agreement entered with the developer as the subsequent agreement
                                                         will be treated only as a supplement agreement and cannot change
                                                         the date of sale.
2.2   12-TIOL-279            Assessment                  Smt Prameela Krishna

3.1   DEL ITAT               17, ITA                     The land which was sold as per an agreement entered before the AY
                                                         under consideration at a pre determined rate and the revenue had
                                                         accepted the arrangement under the income tax proceedings in the
                                                         case of buyer and seller, it cannot take a contrary view that the land
                                                         was wrongly not included in the wealth tax of the seller and the
                                                         agreement was a self serving agreement to save tax on wealth and
                                                         wrongly valued at a rate other than the agreed rate though it was a
                                                         contractual price and the 'A' was under an obligation to transfer the
                                                         same at such price.
3.2   12-TIOL-280            Busi.Inc                    Nachiketa Real Estates (P) Ltd

4.1   MUM ITAT               244A, ITA                   Interest on interest is payable by the Revenue on the refund of
                                                         interest due to the 'A', which remained unpaid following the CIT(A)
                                                         order.
4.2   12-TIOL-282            Interest                    M/s The Development Bank Of Singapore Ltd

5.1   DEL ITAT               72 , ITA                    Income from the sale of shares is taxable as STCG when the
                                                         transactions are delivery based and 'A' has not claimed the available
                                                         STT credit.
5.2   12-TIOL-288            Sp. Provision               Shri Ved Kapoor

6.1   DEL HC                 47, ITA                     As per S 49 of the Companies Act, all investments of the company are
                                                         to be held in the name of the company itself. In case it is held in the
                                                         name of the nominees, the company is under obligation to file a
                                                         declaration in the prescribed form in view of S 187C of the Companies
                                                         Act. The violation of these provision and penalty thereof is one aspect.
                                                         But, the effect of the said violation has to be examined and considered
                                                         by the Income-Tax Authorities. It has to be also examined and
                                                         considered by Revenue Authorities whether violation of the said
                                                         provisions would prevent and bar the respondent 'A' from claiming that
                                                         it was wholly owned subsidiary and the recorded shareholders were
                                                         mere nominees and that accordingly it was eligible for exemption u/s
                                                         47 of Income tax Act

6.2   22 TM 12               Exemption                   Sunaero Limited


Please let us know if you need any further information on these.
Thanking you and assuring you of our best services at all times.
                                                                                                        Yours Faithfully,

                                                                                      For    Anand Mehta & Co ., 
                                                                                                      (CONSULTANTS) PVT. LTD.
                                                                                                         Anand V. Mehta
                                                                                                               DIRECTOR

                      A mind of a consultant with a heart of a friend.
                Mumbai Office- 334, Mulratna 1st Floor Narshi Natha Street Masjid (W) Mumbai 40009
                 Tel -022- 23400882 • Fax-022-23420195 • E-mail: amcon.mumbai@amcount.com
                Pune Office –B/5 Shardaram Park, 34, Sasson Road, Near Jehangir Hospital, Pune - 411 001
                   Tel-020 6401 3124 • Fax 020- 30521223•E-mail: amcon.pune@amcount.com
                                         Gram-MATERPLAN <--> MASTERPLAY
                                        Website:www.amcount.com

More Related Content

What's hot

LL 453
LL 453LL 453
LLAT 497
LLAT 497LLAT 497
Legal landmark 522
Legal landmark 522Legal landmark 522
LL 488
LL 488LL 488
Legal landmark 528
Legal landmark 528Legal landmark 528
Legal landmark 504
Legal landmark 504Legal landmark 504
Llat482
Llat482Llat482
LL 467
LL 467LL 467
LL 476
LL 476LL 476
Legal landmark 516
Legal landmark 516Legal landmark 516
LL 472
LL 472LL 472
LL 473
LL 473LL 473
LL 475
LL 475LL 475
LL 471
LL 471LL 471
Legal landmark 507
Legal landmark 507Legal landmark 507
LL 457
LL 457LL 457
Legal landmark 519
Legal landmark 519Legal landmark 519
LL 459
LL 459LL 459

What's hot (18)

LL 453
LL 453LL 453
LL 453
 
LLAT 497
LLAT 497LLAT 497
LLAT 497
 
Legal landmark 522
Legal landmark 522Legal landmark 522
Legal landmark 522
 
LL 488
LL 488LL 488
LL 488
 
Legal landmark 528
Legal landmark 528Legal landmark 528
Legal landmark 528
 
Legal landmark 504
Legal landmark 504Legal landmark 504
Legal landmark 504
 
Llat482
Llat482Llat482
Llat482
 
LL 467
LL 467LL 467
LL 467
 
LL 476
LL 476LL 476
LL 476
 
Legal landmark 516
Legal landmark 516Legal landmark 516
Legal landmark 516
 
LL 472
LL 472LL 472
LL 472
 
LL 473
LL 473LL 473
LL 473
 
LL 475
LL 475LL 475
LL 475
 
LL 471
LL 471LL 471
LL 471
 
Legal landmark 507
Legal landmark 507Legal landmark 507
Legal landmark 507
 
LL 457
LL 457LL 457
LL 457
 
Legal landmark 519
Legal landmark 519Legal landmark 519
Legal landmark 519
 
LL 459
LL 459LL 459
LL 459
 

Viewers also liked

Previous year Question paper For Guahati University
Previous year Question paper For Guahati University Previous year Question paper For Guahati University
Previous year Question paper For Guahati University Education At The Edge
 
Success
SuccessSuccess
Success
Mike Clayton
 
2.2 Angella Hughes
2.2 Angella Hughes2.2 Angella Hughes
2.2 Angella Hughes
Izabela Popova
 
Legal landmark 527
Legal landmark 527Legal landmark 527
Summit educational guide
Summit educational guideSummit educational guide
Summit educational guide
Mosaic_EFA
 
Foreign Remittance - Procedural Changes
Foreign Remittance - Procedural ChangesForeign Remittance - Procedural Changes
Foreign Remittance - Procedural Changes
Chandan Goyal
 
Pulse Design & Delivery Panel
Pulse Design & Delivery PanelPulse Design & Delivery Panel
Pulse Design & Delivery Panel
Mauricio Godoy
 

Viewers also liked (7)

Previous year Question paper For Guahati University
Previous year Question paper For Guahati University Previous year Question paper For Guahati University
Previous year Question paper For Guahati University
 
Success
SuccessSuccess
Success
 
2.2 Angella Hughes
2.2 Angella Hughes2.2 Angella Hughes
2.2 Angella Hughes
 
Legal landmark 527
Legal landmark 527Legal landmark 527
Legal landmark 527
 
Summit educational guide
Summit educational guideSummit educational guide
Summit educational guide
 
Foreign Remittance - Procedural Changes
Foreign Remittance - Procedural ChangesForeign Remittance - Procedural Changes
Foreign Remittance - Procedural Changes
 
Pulse Design & Delivery Panel
Pulse Design & Delivery PanelPulse Design & Delivery Panel
Pulse Design & Delivery Panel
 

Similar to Legal landmark 514

Legal landmark 506
Legal landmark 506Legal landmark 506
LL 463
LL 463LL 463
LL 482
LL 482LL 482
Legal landmark 503
Legal landmark 503Legal landmark 503
Legal landmark 524
Legal landmark 524Legal landmark 524
LL 488
LL 488LL 488
LL 483
LL 483LL 483
Llat483
Llat483Llat483
LL486
LL486LL486
LL 486
LL 486LL 486
LL 489
LL 489LL 489
LL 489
LL 489LL 489
Llat485
Llat485Llat485
LL 485
LL 485LL 485
Legal landmark 534
Legal landmark 534Legal landmark 534
LL 468
LL 468LL 468
Legal landmark 535
Legal landmark 535Legal landmark 535
Legal landmark 521
Legal landmark 521Legal landmark 521
LL 464
LL 464LL 464
LL 452
LL 452LL 452

Similar to Legal landmark 514 (20)

Legal landmark 506
Legal landmark 506Legal landmark 506
Legal landmark 506
 
LL 463
LL 463LL 463
LL 463
 
LL 482
LL 482LL 482
LL 482
 
Legal landmark 503
Legal landmark 503Legal landmark 503
Legal landmark 503
 
Legal landmark 524
Legal landmark 524Legal landmark 524
Legal landmark 524
 
LL 488
LL 488LL 488
LL 488
 
LL 483
LL 483LL 483
LL 483
 
Llat483
Llat483Llat483
Llat483
 
LL486
LL486LL486
LL486
 
LL 486
LL 486LL 486
LL 486
 
LL 489
LL 489LL 489
LL 489
 
LL 489
LL 489LL 489
LL 489
 
Llat485
Llat485Llat485
Llat485
 
LL 485
LL 485LL 485
LL 485
 
Legal landmark 534
Legal landmark 534Legal landmark 534
Legal landmark 534
 
LL 468
LL 468LL 468
LL 468
 
Legal landmark 535
Legal landmark 535Legal landmark 535
Legal landmark 535
 
Legal landmark 521
Legal landmark 521Legal landmark 521
Legal landmark 521
 
LL 464
LL 464LL 464
LL 464
 
LL 452
LL 452LL 452
LL 452
 

More from Anand Mehta & Co., Chartered Accountants

Legal landmark 538
Legal landmark 538Legal landmark 538
Legal landmark 537
Legal landmark 537Legal landmark 537
Legal landmark 536
Legal landmark 536Legal landmark 536
Legal landmark 533
Legal landmark 533Legal landmark 533
Legal landmark 532
Legal landmark 532Legal landmark 532
Legal landmark 531
Legal landmark 531Legal landmark 531
Legal landmark 525
Legal landmark 525Legal landmark 525
Legal landmark 520
Legal landmark 520Legal landmark 520
Legal landmark 518
Legal landmark 518Legal landmark 518
Legal landmark 517
Legal landmark 517Legal landmark 517
Legal landmark 515
Legal landmark 515Legal landmark 515
Legal landmark 514
Legal landmark 514Legal landmark 514
Legal landmark 513
Legal landmark 513Legal landmark 513
Legal landmark 512
Legal landmark 512Legal landmark 512
Legal landmark 511
Legal landmark 511Legal landmark 511
Legal landmark 510
Legal landmark 510Legal landmark 510
Legal landmark 509
Legal landmark 509Legal landmark 509
Legal landmark 508
Legal landmark 508Legal landmark 508

More from Anand Mehta & Co., Chartered Accountants (18)

Legal landmark 538
Legal landmark 538Legal landmark 538
Legal landmark 538
 
Legal landmark 537
Legal landmark 537Legal landmark 537
Legal landmark 537
 
Legal landmark 536
Legal landmark 536Legal landmark 536
Legal landmark 536
 
Legal landmark 533
Legal landmark 533Legal landmark 533
Legal landmark 533
 
Legal landmark 532
Legal landmark 532Legal landmark 532
Legal landmark 532
 
Legal landmark 531
Legal landmark 531Legal landmark 531
Legal landmark 531
 
Legal landmark 525
Legal landmark 525Legal landmark 525
Legal landmark 525
 
Legal landmark 520
Legal landmark 520Legal landmark 520
Legal landmark 520
 
Legal landmark 518
Legal landmark 518Legal landmark 518
Legal landmark 518
 
Legal landmark 517
Legal landmark 517Legal landmark 517
Legal landmark 517
 
Legal landmark 515
Legal landmark 515Legal landmark 515
Legal landmark 515
 
Legal landmark 514
Legal landmark 514Legal landmark 514
Legal landmark 514
 
Legal landmark 513
Legal landmark 513Legal landmark 513
Legal landmark 513
 
Legal landmark 512
Legal landmark 512Legal landmark 512
Legal landmark 512
 
Legal landmark 511
Legal landmark 511Legal landmark 511
Legal landmark 511
 
Legal landmark 510
Legal landmark 510Legal landmark 510
Legal landmark 510
 
Legal landmark 509
Legal landmark 509Legal landmark 509
Legal landmark 509
 
Legal landmark 508
Legal landmark 508Legal landmark 508
Legal landmark 508
 

Legal landmark 514

  • 1. VOLUME NO.: LLAT/ 514 OF 2012-13 DATE: 30th June, 2012 ­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­  Dear Client, We have pleasure in listing below some of the recent legal landmarks. SR. AUTHORITY SECTION / RULES RATIO(S) NO. CITATIONS / SUBJECT CASE(NAME OF ASSESSEE) 1.1 DEL HC I 195, ITA If a holding company advances borrowed money to a subsidiary and the same is used by the subsidiary for some business purposes, the 'A' would be entitled to deduction of interest on its borrowed loans. 1.2 2012-TII-25 Busi. Inc Telsuo Mitera 2.1 BANG ITAT 147, ITA When the 'A' handed over the possession of the land to the developer and the developer changed after some work on the same, the gain arising on sale of the land will be taxable in the year of original agreement entered with the developer as the subsequent agreement will be treated only as a supplement agreement and cannot change the date of sale. 2.2 12-TIOL-279 Assessment Smt Prameela Krishna 3.1 DEL ITAT 17, ITA The land which was sold as per an agreement entered before the AY under consideration at a pre determined rate and the revenue had accepted the arrangement under the income tax proceedings in the case of buyer and seller, it cannot take a contrary view that the land was wrongly not included in the wealth tax of the seller and the agreement was a self serving agreement to save tax on wealth and wrongly valued at a rate other than the agreed rate though it was a contractual price and the 'A' was under an obligation to transfer the same at such price. 3.2 12-TIOL-280 Busi.Inc Nachiketa Real Estates (P) Ltd 4.1 MUM ITAT 244A, ITA Interest on interest is payable by the Revenue on the refund of interest due to the 'A', which remained unpaid following the CIT(A) order. 4.2 12-TIOL-282 Interest M/s The Development Bank Of Singapore Ltd 5.1 DEL ITAT 72 , ITA Income from the sale of shares is taxable as STCG when the transactions are delivery based and 'A' has not claimed the available STT credit. 5.2 12-TIOL-288 Sp. Provision Shri Ved Kapoor 6.1 DEL HC 47, ITA As per S 49 of the Companies Act, all investments of the company are to be held in the name of the company itself. In case it is held in the name of the nominees, the company is under obligation to file a declaration in the prescribed form in view of S 187C of the Companies Act. The violation of these provision and penalty thereof is one aspect. But, the effect of the said violation has to be examined and considered by the Income-Tax Authorities. It has to be also examined and considered by Revenue Authorities whether violation of the said provisions would prevent and bar the respondent 'A' from claiming that it was wholly owned subsidiary and the recorded shareholders were mere nominees and that accordingly it was eligible for exemption u/s 47 of Income tax Act 6.2 22 TM 12 Exemption Sunaero Limited Please let us know if you need any further information on these. Thanking you and assuring you of our best services at all times. Yours Faithfully, For  Anand Mehta & Co .,  (CONSULTANTS) PVT. LTD. Anand V. Mehta DIRECTOR A mind of a consultant with a heart of a friend. Mumbai Office- 334, Mulratna 1st Floor Narshi Natha Street Masjid (W) Mumbai 40009 Tel -022- 23400882 • Fax-022-23420195 • E-mail: amcon.mumbai@amcount.com Pune Office –B/5 Shardaram Park, 34, Sasson Road, Near Jehangir Hospital, Pune - 411 001 Tel-020 6401 3124 • Fax 020- 30521223•E-mail: amcon.pune@amcount.com Gram-MATERPLAN <--> MASTERPLAY Website:www.amcount.com