A webinar discussing an innovative approach to organizational knoledge built on performance models derived using Performance DNA.
This approach leverages the power of role-based outcomes and introduces a learn-do-share paradigm to a performance portal knowledge solution.
2. Agenda
• Introductions and housekeeping
• Key terminology and concepts
• A new approach
• Case study example
• Questions
2
3. Today’s topic
• A performance based approach to knowledge
management is based on identifying the
foundational elements of data and
information required to achieve organizational
objectives and what knowledge is created by
that process
3
5. Objectives
• At the end of this session you will be able to:
– Explain the difference between:
• Information, data and knowledge
• Tacit and explicit knowledge
– Apply a performance based approach to identify
critical job outcomes, knowledge needs and sources
– Learn the various tools and methods to help map job
outcomes, knowledge needs and sources
– Define the appropriate performance portals needed in
a knowledge management system
5
6. Discussion
• How many of you are familiar with and/or have
participated in any of the ASTD HPI courses?
• How many of you work for an organization that
currently has a knowledge management strategy
and/or tool in place?
– What results or changes has your organization’s
knowledge management strategy or tool brought to
the organization?
• Does your organization have a social networking
strategy?
6
8. Key Terminology & Concepts
• Knowledge vs. Information
– Knowledge consists of facts, truths and beliefs,
perspectives and concepts, judgments and
expectations, methodologies and know-how
• Knowledge is accumulated and integrated and held
over time to solve specific challenges and handle
specific situations
– Information consists of facts and data organized
to describe a particular situation or condition
• Knowledge is applied to interpret information about
the situation and how to handle it
8
9. Key Terminology & Concepts
• Knowledge need
– Knowledge and information required to produce a job
outcome
• Knowledge source
– From where the knowledge or information is obtained
– Knowledge sources can be explicit or tacit sources
• Explicit vs. Tacit knowledge
– Explicit knowledge is often times documented knowledge
and information that can be accessed and stored easily
– Tacit knowledge is undocumented experiential knowledge
that exists within people’s heads
9
10. Key Terminology & Concepts
• Human Performance Improvement
– The theory of human performance improvement (HPI)
focuses on the outcomes, results and accomplishments
achieved by a person, group or organization
• Outcome
– The output or end result of a set of actions by a performer
that is directly linked to producing a desired business
result
– Sample outcomes are:
• A strategic plan
• A quarterly report
• A succession plan
• A successful proposal
11. Key Terminology & Concepts
• Example
Outcome Knowledge Need Knowledge Source
Current news
24/7 Crisis Travel Service
Critical current security information
Overseas Security Advisory Council
Security briefings Project staff
Department of Defense
Regulations on security industry operations Department of State
Industry groups
11
12. Key Terminology & Concepts
• Performance portal
– An integrated knowledge solution that allows
users to leverage, capture and share knowledge in
the context of their performance on the job
12
15. A new approach
• A performance based approach
to knowledge management that
links people directly to the
knowledge needs and source
they need to produce critical
job outcomes
• The direct organizing framework
is first on what the performer is
trying to achieve in order to add
value for the organization
15
16. A new approach
• A Learn – Do – Share paradigm
• INSERT IMAGE
16
17. Social media is nothing - an oxymoron at best:
media are simply media, incapable of being at
all social. People are social. Information isn't
social either - but it is everything. With that in
mind, it's important to understand what
information people need and how they access
that information in order to achieve results.
Adapted from Phil Baumann
Social Media Anxiety Disorder
Next Gen Pharma
17
19. A 4-step process
• Identify critical job outcomes, knowledge needs and
knowledge sources from across the organization
– Using a structured interview process and Performance
DNA desktop
• Create knowledge maps for each job role/function
• Develop an organizational knowledge map to identify
to knowledge needs and sources and map the flow and
exchange of knowledge
• Analyze results and identify major centers of
performance, i.e. Performance Portals
19
20. Identify critical job outcomes
• Outcomes link activity to business goal
• Identify outcomes using a structured interview
process
• Sample questions
– What do you produce in your job that is the most
important?
– When your day (and job activities) has gone very
well and everything has fallen into place, what do
you leave behind when you are done with
everything?
20
21. Identify critical job outcomes
• Sample outcomes
– Business development
• A completed proposal
• An organizational business plan
• A bid/no bid decision
– Project Director
• A strategy paper
• An analysis of current trends
• A successful country strategy
21
22. Identify knowledge needs and
sources
• Using the critical job outcomes –
– Identify the knowledge needed to produce each
outcome
– Identify the source from which that knowledge is
obtained
Outcome Knowledge Need Knowledge Source
Current news
24/7 Crisis Travel Service
Critical current security information
Overseas Security Advisory Council
Security briefings Project staff
Department of Defense
Regulations on security industry operations Department of State
Industry groups
22
24. Create knowledge maps
• Knowledge maps provide visual representation
of:
– The outcomes, knowledge needs and sources for a
given job role
– Complex relationships
• Use a tool like NodeXL to
– Build the organizational knowledge map to map the
flow and exchange of knowledge
– Identify the top knowledge needs and sources
– Identify the major centers of performance produced
within the organization
24
29. Case Study
The Challenge Facing the challenge of capturing, storing, and reusing critical
knowledge assets, Beacon Performance Group was approached
by a mid-size international development organization whose
major commodity is thoughts, solutions and ideas that help
people around the world realize the positive changes they
desire in their everyday life.
The knowledge within the organization and important ideas
generated often have implications far beyond the numbers on
the balance sheet; they often mean changes in the
fundamental quality of life of entire communities or in some
cases the difference between life and death
The Solution & In order to identify and harness the critical knowledge and
information requirements within the organization, a
Approach performance based approach to knowledge management was
applied.
This performance based approach focuses first on
understanding the important outcomes that are produced by
employees within specific roles across the organization and
second, on identifying the important knowledge requirements
and sources of that knowledge, employees need access to, to
be able to produce those outcomes effectively.
29
30. Case Study
• Knowledge needs
– Knowledge needs align with important
performance portals
• Finding and winning new business
• Implementing and supporting current programs
• Developing and advancing the organization’s
intellectual position within the market
• Managing and supporting the business
• Managing my career (for internal employees)
• Working with the organization (for external partners)
30
31. Case Study
• Additional findings
– Evidence suggests that generally staff are not aware of the
knowledge available to them
• Most notable example is Past Performance Reports (PPRs)
– Roughly 27% of the knowledge sources are tacit knowledge sources
• People rely on other individuals for their knowledge based on past
experiences and their individual expertise in order to
– Develop a technical approach for a proposal
– Locate information on past projects
– Assess what is going on in a country
– Some tacit knowledge sources can easily be transformed into
explicit knowledge sources
• Examples
– Trip reports
– Knowledge of staff education, credentials, past experiences, published articles
or papers
31
32. Case Study
• Results
– A performance based knowledge management system
based on:
• Defined set of employee and organizational performance
requirements
• A detailed map of the flow and exchange of knowledge
throughout the organization
– Top knowledge needs and knowledge sources identified
– Identified choke points to the flow and exchange of information
• A Learn – Do – Share paradigm
• SharePoint 2010
32
33. Additional considerations
• An environment that supports knowledge
sharing has the following characteristics
– Reward structure – recognition for knowledge
sharing with peers
– Openness/transparency – no hidden agendas
– Sharing supported – communication and
coordination between groups
– Trust – shared objectives
– Top management support – upward and
downward communication
Mishra, J. K. 2009. Knowledge Management Complexity, Learning & Sustainable Innovation. Global India Pubns. 33
Today’s topic – a performance based approach to KM A non-traditional approach to KM that links employees to the knowledge needs and sources to perform their critical job outcomes An approach and solution to meet the demands of the high tech – information age we currently are in. It is a solution to manage and harness the valuable knowledge generated and held within your organization and also includes an effective social networking component to help tackle the social networking challenge
ASK – What do you hope to get out of today’s session?
Why is it important to know the difference- We rely greatly on other people’s knowledge and experience to produce critical job outcomes A knowledge worker is 5 times more likely to turn to another person for information rather than an impersonal source such as a database or KM system *When we turn to another person, we not only end up with the information we are looking for but we also get more information and feedback. We learn where it is to be found, how to reformulate our question or query, whether we are on the right track, and where we strayed.Additionally and perhaps most importantly, the information is coming to us from a known and usually trusted, credible source. In other words, people are the best means of getting not only a direct answer but additional critical and important knowledge about the knowledge or information we are seeking. Talking to other people provides a highly valuable learning activity that is primarily tacit-tacit knowledge transfer, for this type of knowledge is seldom rendered explicity, nor is it captured in any form of document. ….learning is a predominantly social event*Taken from Mishra, J. K. 2009. Knowledge Management Complexity, Learning & Sustainable Innovation. Global India Pubns. What this means for our knowledge management solutionClassifying knowledge sources as explicit or tacit helps us to better organize and arrange our KM system (we will talk more about this process later) Will helps us to identify and map the knowledge flows between people to see where people seek and share knowledge
Ask someone for an outcome, kn and ks
Traditional KM systems/solutionsADD Are organized by knowledge ‘type,’ or some other organizational schema, information taxonomy which requires an individual to know all of the various types of knowledge, multiple variations of the schema and taxonomy ASK But what if you are new to the organization – how to you find what you are looking for? ASK How do I find out who are experts in what I need to do – experts are people with valuable tacit knowledge that can teach me more
Why is L-D-S important Individuals only need to know what they are trying to accomplish in order to useThe direct organizing framework is first on what the performer is trying to achieve in order to add value for the organization, instead of on the knowledge ‘type,’ or some other organizational schema, information taxonomy typically used in many other knowledge management systems. Systems built on knowledge types or org schemas, are really just data and information management systems – this LDS paradigm links users directly with the information they need to produce key outcomesConnects people with people and people with information (explicit and tacit knowledge) – includes a social networking component that allows people to share information freely. Remember we said earlier that people are 5x more likely to turn to another person for information – so it is any wonder that social networking, tweeting, blogging etc has taken over the way we exchange information and communicate?
An interesting thought to consider
How many of those who have taken Analyzing HP have access to and or use PDNA?
Review definition of outcomeThe output or end result of a set of actions by a performer that is directly linked to producing a desired business resultThis process to identify critical job outcomes is a core skill taught in ASTDs Analyzing Human Performance class. As a side note: Knowledge Management is one of the many solutions an HPI or performance based approach can help you to solve. It is important to start with the identification of outcomes when building a knowledge management solution, because the outcomes define the critical outputs or artifacts people produce in their job that drive business results. Critical to provide people with the knowledge they need, and easy access to this knowledge so that they are able produce these critical outcomes successfully
ASK – for a volunteer to provide a critical outcome they produce in their job and their knowledge needs and knowledge sources – so we can help connect to this idea of outcomes to our current daily livesASK what are the constraints to the access to the knowledge needs and or sourcesTransition then to discuss the next step – Knowledge Maps
How ID performance portalsTop knowledge needs and knowledge sources – should in theory align with the important job outcomes produced within the organization – these top job outcomes can be categorized into major centers of performance or performance portalsExamples – from one of the worlds largest high tech companies – sample performance portal Delivering world class results on-time – individuals in R&D and engineering, logistics and sales and marketing all have key outcomes to deliver world class results on timeFrom a state DNRPromoting and maintaining health partnerships with other state, federal and private businesses – state foresters as well as scientists and central office staff all have an accountability to produce outcomes related to….
Using a tool like NodeXL you canBuild the organizational knowledge map to map the flow and exchange of knowledgeIdentify the top knowledge needs and sourcesIdentify the major centers of performance produced within the organization – ie the Performance PortalsAll of this information helps to build the KM solution in line with what people need to produceSTOP HERE AND ASK FOR QUESTIONS
Some additional – notable findings we identified were….These were used to help us focus and validate our proposed solution
As with any new system built an introduced into an organization, there is much more that needs to be in place and considered when introducing it – it will likely not be “build it and they will come” It is important that use is measured ie, by some sort of perf management system, rewarded, and supported.Individuals need to see what’s in it for them and trust that using it will be safe and help them to achieve what they need to achieveAll of these are important cultural characteristics – so it’s important to assess your organizations culture and readiness and develop a change management strategy to help introduce a new system like a KM system into your organization