Marina Hatsopoulos. Entrepreneur, Director at Cynosure and Levitronix Technologies; Advisor, MIT Enterprise Forum Greece, The EGG accelerator, OK!Thess
1. Key Elements of a
Successful Startup
Marina Hatsopoulos
Entrepreneur
Director at Cynosure and Levitronix Technologies
Advisor, MIT Enterprise Forum Greece, The EGG accelerator, OK!Thess
2. Agenda
My Story
Entrepreneurship
Intellectual Property
Market
Competition
Team
Culture
Board of Directors
Financing
3. My Story
Background
Chase Manhattan Bank - Wall Street - finance
Thermo Electron - technology conglomerate
MIT – Masters, Mechanical Engineering
Pivot: search for job>turnaround>technology
MIT technology licensing office > Inventors
Z Corporation (early 3D printing leader) - Founder, CEO
Cynosure ($340M public company) & Levitronix Technologies – Director
Director on other boards
Investor in startups based in US and Greece, as well as startup funds
4. My Story
Z Corporation
MIT Technology
Early leader in 3D printing
No venture capital (hardware)
Focus on Profits and Cash Flow
Fastest-growing business in New England in 2001
Raised $11M from angels and strategic corporates
$9M in bank when we sold
$30M in revenues
125 employees
5. My Story
My involvement with Greece/Cyprus
Invited to MIT Enterprise Forum Greece
Inspired by Israel: “Startup Nation”
Why can’t we do what they’ve done?
Israeli-founded businesses generate $9B in Massachusetts
Israeli model: CEO & Sales in Boston, Development in Israel
6. Entrepreneurship
What’s the point?
Jobs
Upward social mobility & economic opportunity
Independence
In today’s environment, startups require very little capital to get off the ground & go global
7. MIT
Culture of Entrepreneurship
30K Active Companies from MIT Alumni
5 million jobs, $2 Trillion Annual Revenues
10th Economy in the World
100K Competition has created >60 companies valued at $10.5B
8. MIT
Technology Commercialization Model
Sandbox grants $1K for students to explore their startup idea
Grants of $25K-$250K at Deshpande Center, to get research out of the lab &
connect to professional investors
$100K Startup Competition
Venture Mentoring Service
Technology Licensing Office patents inventions & licenses it
Patent Fees paid by startup
Royalty (about 5%) on Revenues paid by startup
Equity (about 5%) of startup granted to MIT
9. MIT Enterprise Forum Greece (mitefgreece.org)
MITEF is a global organization
Focus on early-stage technology entrepreneurship
Turn ideas in to world-changing companies
Events for inspiration and networking
Diaspora Group to connect Greeks to thriving tech ecosystem in Boston
StartSmart Conference-Sat. Nov. 5 in Athens (Attend!)
Startup Competition and Accelerator (Enter now!)
International partners, mentors, judges
Global visibility through MIT Technology Review
One-week Bootcamp at MIT
Sponsorships available
10. Idea
Cocktail Napkin Spreadsheet
# Units
Revenues
Time and investment to get to revenues and profitability
Development, Manufacturing, Sales & Marketing higher than you expect
Pricing is critical! We would have gone out of business
Talk with 20 prospective customers
Does anyone care?
How much would they pay for this?
How big is their pain today?
Who would be better positioned to do this?
A great idea is necessary but not sufficient
You have much more to lose by not talking than you have to gain
11. Intellectual Property
Patents
Difficult to invent, Easy to copy
Trade Secrets
Easy to invent, Difficult to copy
Know-how
Processes, Ingredients, etc.
Use all for competitive advantage
12. Market
Market is big enough
Try to sell product, before it even exists
Early prospects help guide development
Customers may fund research and development
Don’t worry about people stealing your ideas!
Get prepayments from customers-20% up front
Clear Value Proposition
My Company
Product A
Competitor
#1
Product X
Competitor
#2
Product Y
Price $45K $30K $55K
Speed Fast Slow Medium
Resolution 2 mm 3 mm 5 mm
Quality High Medium Low
13. Competition
Competition is good: they pay to educate the market
Easier to have a benchmark to sell against than nothing
100-pound Gorilla competition (or potential competition) is bad
Who is perfectly positioned in terms of customers or technology
Why haven’t they done it already?
What will keep them from entering the market?
Will they have an unfair advantage or will you?
The important thing is product differentiation over the competition
What is the one thing that makes your product significantly better than anything else?
What do you have as a company that makes you uniquely positioned to do this?
14. Team
Most important factor for investors
Companies with Salesperson on Founding Team have 3x chance of success
Capitalize on your stars, even if they have holes
Set up founders equity-consider stock options
Leverage network but don’t hire someone you can’t fire
Hiring philosophy
Some employees are OK, not great: opportunity cost
We all make mistakes. Deal with them & move on
Articulate your direction and stay focused
15. Culture
Focus; can’t do everything
All that matters is results, not face time or experience
Time to market is critical and urgent; this is not time for a cafedaki
80/20 Rule: Perfection is your enemy
Make concrete milestones-and deliver!
16. Monthly Dashboard
Average Sale Price
Revenues
Gross Margin
Net Income
Cash
Service Calls
Repeat Sales
17. Board of Directors
Selected passionate board members who invested in us through several rounds
Find a mentor with relevant success who is willing to tell you what you don’t
want to hear
Find investors who understand your business, believe in it and have deep
pockets to invest
Find missing areas of expertise and fill those roles
Start with a small board-hard to remove them
Use your board; don’t just report to them. LISTEN! Half the answer is the
question.
18. Financing
Seed Capital and Series A
Angels
Venture Capital
Equity
Debt
Strategic investors
Equity
R&D Contracts
Customer Deposits
19. Financing
Angels
Individuals or groups which meet monthly to hear pitches & share diligence efforts
Small investments: $25K to $500K
Less control provisions
Seed investments made as convertible debt
Converts to equity in Series A at a 20% discount
Postpones valuation until there’s more information
Advantage:
Better terms: control, valuation
Disadvantage:
May not have capital or appetite to invest through multiple rounds
20. Financing
Venture Capital
Lots of capital to put to work; same work to invest a little or a lot, so they invest
a lot: $1M-$25M
VC’s expect dead, living dead, but they’re in it for the very few “unicorns” with
30x-100x returns
Board seat
Control
Have access to larger pool of capital, so can invest through multiple rounds
Advantage:
Can carry credibility to be funded by a top VC
Disadvantage:
Pressure to grow fast, which can be good or risky
Give up control
21. Financing
Strategic Investors
Corporate investors with interest in your success:
Customers
Distributors
Suppliers
Advantages:
Give up very little control
Access to large partner who can help grow business
Validates business for outside investors
Credibility
Disadvantages :
May limit ability to form partnerships with their competitors
May reduce chance of selling business to their competitors
May give them information you’d rather keep secret (eg, gross margins)
22. Financing
Pitching to Investors
Website & Pitch should be clear and simple: WHAT DO YOU SELL?
Practice elevator pitch
Forget about the quick flip
Forget about the billion-dollar sale in a related area
Find investors who have invested (with success) in related businesses
23. Financing
Considerations for the Entrepreneur
Capital vs. Control
Low capital investment means higher ownership & control
Lower growth can be lower risk or higher risk, depending on the business and who
the competition is
Growth vs. Profitability
Some businesses need to reach critical mass before anyone else, in which case
growth is paramount
Other businesses take time to educate the market, so there’s no way to accelerate
it in a way that can generate a return to the investors
Some businesses require lots of capital. If you’ll need over $3M, might as well
go to VC’s early. Otherwise, could retain more control and higher ownership
Most businesses are not unicorns. You can make good money as an entrepreneur
without building a unicorn, as long as you don’t raise too much money
24. Financing
Acquisition
Don’t mess up a business to “look pretty”
Don’t plan on acquisition-many issues out of your control
Don’t sell into a buyer’s market
Don’t put your startup in a situation where you have to sell
Build a strong business and acquirors will come
If they don’t, you won’t care
25. Financing
Moments of Crisis
Competition came out with similar product before our product launch
Zero sales month
We tripled our burn rate just before sales plummeted
Failure is information. Use it to move forward.
26. Doing Business with Americans
Respond immediately—a few hours, or at the latest within the day
Plan ahead-hard to get meetings at the last minute
Follow through on anything you say you’re going to do
Network using Linkedin, not Facebook & use a professional photo
Mr. or Ms. (not Mrs.) for introductions, but shift to first name immediately
27. Entrepreneurship in Cyprus
Political, economic and legislative stability, free of bureaucracy, and
business-friendly
Must go global early
Bootstrap to early profitability
Access to strong, well-educated technical talent
Think bigger: commercialize university research
What are problems you see that could be solved by innovation?
28. Parting Words
Controlling your own destiny is enriching and fulfilling
Persevere. It’s hard. No “life balance.” This isn’t a Disney movie.
Celebrate milestones and have fun!