Karnataka Engineering Company
A case study: Logistics & Supply Chain Management




       Course: Logistics & Supply Chain Management
               Professor: TAS Vijayaraghavan




                    -:Submitted By:-
                       PGCBM-19


              Rana Sarkar (RB11018/108138)
             Vikrant Singh (RB11014/108825)
            Sangita Sharma (RB11077/108553)
Company Background
       Based in Raichur
       Entered in to two wheeler industry in 1981 with Mopeds
       Started scooter production in 1983
       19 branches all over India managed by Branch Manager
       The minimum throughput that would justify setting up of a branch in any
       state would be 4.25 lakh per month (78 Mopeds or 33 Scooters per
       month or any other combination)
       Marketing offices are located in most of the states
       Mopeds and Scooter are transported by a specially adapted trucks with a
       capacity of either 80 Mopeds or 50 Scooters or combination of both
       Secondary transportation is arranged by marketing offices by LCVs or
       trucks


                        Marketing Offices of KEC Ltd


                                                        Srinagar


       Chandigarh                                            Delhi
                         Srinagar


                                                        Lucknow
         Jaipur
                                                Chan
                                                digar
                                                  h
Ahmadabad

                                                                  J
       Bhopal                                                     ai
                                                                  p Calcutta
                                                                  ur
                                                               Ranchi
            Mumbai
                                             Delhi
                                                        Hyderabad

            Bangalore

                                                        Chennai

                  Cochin
Business in Andhra Pradesh
Marketing office is situated in Hyderabad
Operating with two branch ware houses one at Adoni and other at
Mahbubnagar
Selection criteria: first major town close to production facility




Hyderabad collects orders, communicate to both warehouses
Secondary transportation responsibility with ware house manager
Difficulty in arranging secondary transportation


                      Some Factual data
Sales in Jan-Jul 1998 are 465 Mopeds and 78 Scooters
In Jan-Jul 1998 AP contributed around 5.3 % of KEC’s total moped sales
and 3.6% total scooter sales
Average monthly off take in AP during Jan-Jul 1998 are 1925 Mopeds and
288 Scooters
The current rate of tax : 4 % CST
Current sales in AP Rs.14.33/- million PA
At this rate the money out flow to exchequer Rs.573260/-
Cost for setting up of one branch Rs.17000/- to Rs.21000/- pm ie
Rs.204000/- to Rs.252000/- PA
So up to two branches could be set up in the state at the current rate of
tax and sales


                              Issues
At what volumes is the opening of a warehouse in a state justified
primarily on the grounds of the 4% CST for transaction across states ?
How many warehouses do you think are required of KEC’s products in
Andhra Pradesh? What could the candidate locations of the warehouse
be? What would be the criteria on which to select the candidates?
Determine the optimal selection of warehouse and the best allocation of
the demand points to the selected warehouses.
What are the best choices for the shipment (truck) size from the
warehouses to the demand points? Given the size, what routing would
you recommend for a typical despatch run.
Analysis
    The following table shows the coordinates of the Branch office locations
Sl                     X-          Y            Moped
No Name                Coordinate Coordinate Offtake         Rate
   1 Adoni                    2.2           10            41 4.8
   2 Chittore                   5            4           106 4.8
   3 Nellore                  6.5            7            44 4.8
   4 Ongle                    6.5          9.5            20 4.8
   5 Chirala                    7        10.5           54.8 4.8
   6 Cuddappah                4.5          7.1          61.4 4.8
   7 Hindupur                 2.4          5.8          71.2 4.8
   8 Anantpur                 2.8          7.8            76 4.8
   9 Kurnool                  3.4        10.2           24.8 4.8
 10 Tiupati                   5.5            5          90.6 4.8
 11 Guntur                      7        11.8            119 4.8
 12 Vijaywada                 7.5        12.1            253 4.8
 13 Kammam                    6.9        14.1            104 4.8
 14 Warangal                  6.5        15.8             89 4.8
 15 Rajanundry                9.1        13.3             80 4.8
 16 Kakinada                  9.9           13          76.4 4.8
 17 Vizag                    11.2        15.2         124.6 4.8
 18 Vijayanagarm             11.5           16            38 4.8
 19 Mehboobnagar              3.2        13.2             36 4.8
 20 Hyderabad                 4.2        14.5            728 4.8
 21 Nizamabad                 3.5           18            69 4.8
 22 Karim Nagar               5.1        17.8             79 4.8
Using Logware
Selecting 1 location for warehouse
Selecting 2 location for warehouse
Selecting 3 location for warehouses
Selecting 4 location for warehouses
It is evident from the Screenshots of Logware ……
    3 Ware Houses are required as per Multiple center – of – Gravity Location
    Method , If you increase more than 3 ware houses cost getting increase as
    shown in above MultiCOG Method.
    Best Locations also identified to supply various Demand points mentioned
    in Map of Andhra Pradesh from ware houses and X & Y Coordinates for
    ware houses are also shown in figures (Near to Hyderabad, Vijaywada and
    Cuddappah) .


     Based on our analysis on demand and rate per km, we have identified the
     old and new distribution method as shown in given below table.
                 OLD                            NEW
Place            BIG        MED     SMALL       BIG        MED      SMALL
Adoni            0          0       0           0          0        0
Anantpur         1          0       0           1          0        0
Chirala          0          1       0           0          1        0
Chittore         1          1       0           1          1        0
Cuddapah         1          0       0           1          0        0
Guntur           1          1       0           1          1        0
Hindupur         1          0       0           1          0        0
Hyderabad        9          0       0           9          0        0
Kakinada         1          0       0           1          0        0
Karimnagar       1          0       0           1          0        0
Khammam          1          1       0           1          1        0
Kurnool          0          1       0           0          1        0
Mehbubnagar      0          0       0           0          0        0
Nellore          0          1       0           0          1        0
Nizamabad        1          0       0           1          0        0
Ongole           0          0       1           0          0        1
Rajamundry       1          0       0           1          0        0
Tirupati         0          2       0           0          2        0
Vijayawada       3          0       1           0          0        0
Vizag            1          1       0           1          1        0
Vijayanagaram 0             1       0           0          1        0
Warangal         1          0       1           1          0        1
Total Trucks     24         10      3           21         10       2
Conclusion

The company should have 3 ware houses and the points
to where it has to supply is shown in the screenshot
below.




The no of truck required will be reduced by 3 big truck
and 1 small truck.

The warehousing decisions will ensure better response
times to satisfy customers requirement and lower the
total cost by optimized cost related to distribution.

Karnataka Engineering Case Analysis

  • 1.
    Karnataka Engineering Company Acase study: Logistics & Supply Chain Management Course: Logistics & Supply Chain Management Professor: TAS Vijayaraghavan -:Submitted By:- PGCBM-19 Rana Sarkar (RB11018/108138) Vikrant Singh (RB11014/108825) Sangita Sharma (RB11077/108553)
  • 2.
    Company Background Based in Raichur Entered in to two wheeler industry in 1981 with Mopeds Started scooter production in 1983 19 branches all over India managed by Branch Manager The minimum throughput that would justify setting up of a branch in any state would be 4.25 lakh per month (78 Mopeds or 33 Scooters per month or any other combination) Marketing offices are located in most of the states Mopeds and Scooter are transported by a specially adapted trucks with a capacity of either 80 Mopeds or 50 Scooters or combination of both Secondary transportation is arranged by marketing offices by LCVs or trucks Marketing Offices of KEC Ltd Srinagar Chandigarh Delhi Srinagar Lucknow Jaipur Chan digar h Ahmadabad J Bhopal ai p Calcutta ur Ranchi Mumbai Delhi Hyderabad Bangalore Chennai Cochin
  • 3.
    Business in AndhraPradesh Marketing office is situated in Hyderabad Operating with two branch ware houses one at Adoni and other at Mahbubnagar Selection criteria: first major town close to production facility Hyderabad collects orders, communicate to both warehouses Secondary transportation responsibility with ware house manager Difficulty in arranging secondary transportation Some Factual data Sales in Jan-Jul 1998 are 465 Mopeds and 78 Scooters
  • 4.
    In Jan-Jul 1998AP contributed around 5.3 % of KEC’s total moped sales and 3.6% total scooter sales Average monthly off take in AP during Jan-Jul 1998 are 1925 Mopeds and 288 Scooters The current rate of tax : 4 % CST Current sales in AP Rs.14.33/- million PA At this rate the money out flow to exchequer Rs.573260/- Cost for setting up of one branch Rs.17000/- to Rs.21000/- pm ie Rs.204000/- to Rs.252000/- PA So up to two branches could be set up in the state at the current rate of tax and sales Issues At what volumes is the opening of a warehouse in a state justified primarily on the grounds of the 4% CST for transaction across states ? How many warehouses do you think are required of KEC’s products in Andhra Pradesh? What could the candidate locations of the warehouse be? What would be the criteria on which to select the candidates? Determine the optimal selection of warehouse and the best allocation of the demand points to the selected warehouses. What are the best choices for the shipment (truck) size from the warehouses to the demand points? Given the size, what routing would you recommend for a typical despatch run.
  • 5.
    Analysis The following table shows the coordinates of the Branch office locations Sl X- Y Moped No Name Coordinate Coordinate Offtake Rate 1 Adoni 2.2 10 41 4.8 2 Chittore 5 4 106 4.8 3 Nellore 6.5 7 44 4.8 4 Ongle 6.5 9.5 20 4.8 5 Chirala 7 10.5 54.8 4.8 6 Cuddappah 4.5 7.1 61.4 4.8 7 Hindupur 2.4 5.8 71.2 4.8 8 Anantpur 2.8 7.8 76 4.8 9 Kurnool 3.4 10.2 24.8 4.8 10 Tiupati 5.5 5 90.6 4.8 11 Guntur 7 11.8 119 4.8 12 Vijaywada 7.5 12.1 253 4.8 13 Kammam 6.9 14.1 104 4.8 14 Warangal 6.5 15.8 89 4.8 15 Rajanundry 9.1 13.3 80 4.8 16 Kakinada 9.9 13 76.4 4.8 17 Vizag 11.2 15.2 124.6 4.8 18 Vijayanagarm 11.5 16 38 4.8 19 Mehboobnagar 3.2 13.2 36 4.8 20 Hyderabad 4.2 14.5 728 4.8 21 Nizamabad 3.5 18 69 4.8 22 Karim Nagar 5.1 17.8 79 4.8
  • 6.
  • 7.
    Selecting 1 locationfor warehouse
  • 8.
    Selecting 2 locationfor warehouse
  • 9.
    Selecting 3 locationfor warehouses
  • 10.
    Selecting 4 locationfor warehouses
  • 11.
    It is evidentfrom the Screenshots of Logware …… 3 Ware Houses are required as per Multiple center – of – Gravity Location Method , If you increase more than 3 ware houses cost getting increase as shown in above MultiCOG Method. Best Locations also identified to supply various Demand points mentioned in Map of Andhra Pradesh from ware houses and X & Y Coordinates for ware houses are also shown in figures (Near to Hyderabad, Vijaywada and Cuddappah) . Based on our analysis on demand and rate per km, we have identified the old and new distribution method as shown in given below table. OLD NEW Place BIG MED SMALL BIG MED SMALL Adoni 0 0 0 0 0 0 Anantpur 1 0 0 1 0 0 Chirala 0 1 0 0 1 0 Chittore 1 1 0 1 1 0 Cuddapah 1 0 0 1 0 0 Guntur 1 1 0 1 1 0 Hindupur 1 0 0 1 0 0 Hyderabad 9 0 0 9 0 0 Kakinada 1 0 0 1 0 0 Karimnagar 1 0 0 1 0 0 Khammam 1 1 0 1 1 0 Kurnool 0 1 0 0 1 0 Mehbubnagar 0 0 0 0 0 0 Nellore 0 1 0 0 1 0 Nizamabad 1 0 0 1 0 0 Ongole 0 0 1 0 0 1 Rajamundry 1 0 0 1 0 0 Tirupati 0 2 0 0 2 0 Vijayawada 3 0 1 0 0 0 Vizag 1 1 0 1 1 0 Vijayanagaram 0 1 0 0 1 0 Warangal 1 0 1 1 0 1 Total Trucks 24 10 3 21 10 2
  • 12.
    Conclusion The company shouldhave 3 ware houses and the points to where it has to supply is shown in the screenshot below. The no of truck required will be reduced by 3 big truck and 1 small truck. The warehousing decisions will ensure better response times to satisfy customers requirement and lower the total cost by optimized cost related to distribution.