SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Jon Sussex
Nuffield Trust and IFS seminar
13th September 2013
Discussion of Kelly & Stoye “More hips
please. Independent sector provision and
the growth in NHS-funded elective care”
Discussion of Kelly and Stoye
13/09/2013 2
5 results
1. NHS-funded hip replacements per year
up 40% (= +20,000) 2003/04-2010/11
2. Independent sector 62% of the extra
3. Growth faster when new ISP nearer than
any NHS provider of hips
4. Substitution of NHS-funded hips for 1/3-
2/3 privately-funded hips at AQPs
5. Small crowding-out of NHS Trusts by
ISTCs (not significant by AQPs)
Discussion of Kelly and Stoye
13/09/2013 3
3 main issues
Distinguish between effects of:
A. Increased capacity
B. ‘Choice’ and provider (quality)
competition
C. Private ownership of providers


X
Discussion of Kelly and Stoye
13/09/2013 4
A. Capacity
• DH set out to increase capacity and activity and
succeeded because:
• Premium prices (≥+11%) to cover set-up
costs/risks and elective-only (=> lower cost)
ensured new provider interest
• Initial ban on poaching NHS clinical staff, so no
crowding-out NHS capacity
• Initially no private hospital companies already
operating in the UK were awarded ISTC contracts,
so no crowding-out private capacity
• ISTC take or pay contracts meant zero marginal
cost to PCT per patient at ISTC
• Plenty of unmet demand and ISTCs aimed at it
Discussion of Kelly and Stoye
13/09/2013 5
Deadweight loss
• 1/3-2/3 of ‘private payers’ switched to
NHS funded care
• => deadweight loss to the taxpayer:
>4,000 out of 20,000 extra capacity
• In addition to possible (in-)equity
impacts that are mentioned
• [Not sure supply effect vs demand effect
distinction is helpful]
Discussion of Kelly and Stoye
13/09/2013 6
B. ‘Choice’ and competition
• Confirms distance important for choice
• ‘Choice’ of private pay vs NHS funded
already existed
• Cannot tell from the study, but ‘choice’
of NHS funded provider might have
increased deadweight loss by increasing
willingness to opt for NHS-funded care
• Study does not investigate impact on
provider quality
Discussion of Kelly and Stoye
13/09/2013 7
C. Private ownership
• Study says nothing about impact of
ownership
[Would impact of increased capacity
have been the same if all providers had
been NHS owned/nationalised?]
Discussion of Kelly and Stoye
13/09/2013 8
Other questions
• What happened to ISTC activity when
first round contracts expired?
• What happened to NHS Trusts
subcontracting to other providers (and
does HES data reflect this)?
• NHS hospital site vs Trust HQ location?
• ISP hospital site vs company HQ location?

More Related Content

What's hot

Energy Lending Program
Energy Lending ProgramEnergy Lending Program
Joe dalton
Joe daltonJoe dalton
Joe dalton
3GDR
 
Dementia Dwelling Grant Summary
Dementia Dwelling Grant SummaryDementia Dwelling Grant Summary
Dementia Dwelling Grant Summary
Foundations
 
Using benefits data to study employment trends in London
Using benefits data to study employment trends in London Using benefits data to study employment trends in London
Using benefits data to study employment trends in London
Policy in Practice
 
Mayumi Hayashi: Lessons from Japan on social care reform
Mayumi Hayashi: Lessons from Japan on social care reformMayumi Hayashi: Lessons from Japan on social care reform
Mayumi Hayashi: Lessons from Japan on social care reform
Nuffield Trust
 
Jamie reid
Jamie reidJamie reid
Jamie reid
Informa Australia
 
NHS Sustainability Day Nottingham Road Show 2014
NHS Sustainability Day Nottingham Road Show 2014NHS Sustainability Day Nottingham Road Show 2014
NHS Sustainability Day Nottingham Road Show 2014
4 All of Us
 
Together as one community - Hambleton, Richmondshire and Whitby federation
Together as one community - Hambleton, Richmondshire and Whitby federationTogether as one community - Hambleton, Richmondshire and Whitby federation
Together as one community - Hambleton, Richmondshire and Whitby federation
Primary Care Commissioning (PCC)
 

What's hot (8)

Energy Lending Program
Energy Lending ProgramEnergy Lending Program
Energy Lending Program
 
Joe dalton
Joe daltonJoe dalton
Joe dalton
 
Dementia Dwelling Grant Summary
Dementia Dwelling Grant SummaryDementia Dwelling Grant Summary
Dementia Dwelling Grant Summary
 
Using benefits data to study employment trends in London
Using benefits data to study employment trends in London Using benefits data to study employment trends in London
Using benefits data to study employment trends in London
 
Mayumi Hayashi: Lessons from Japan on social care reform
Mayumi Hayashi: Lessons from Japan on social care reformMayumi Hayashi: Lessons from Japan on social care reform
Mayumi Hayashi: Lessons from Japan on social care reform
 
Jamie reid
Jamie reidJamie reid
Jamie reid
 
NHS Sustainability Day Nottingham Road Show 2014
NHS Sustainability Day Nottingham Road Show 2014NHS Sustainability Day Nottingham Road Show 2014
NHS Sustainability Day Nottingham Road Show 2014
 
Together as one community - Hambleton, Richmondshire and Whitby federation
Together as one community - Hambleton, Richmondshire and Whitby federationTogether as one community - Hambleton, Richmondshire and Whitby federation
Together as one community - Hambleton, Richmondshire and Whitby federation
 

Similar to Jon Sussex: Capacity, choice and private ownership

Elaine kelly public payment and private provision
Elaine kelly public payment and private provisionElaine kelly public payment and private provision
Elaine kelly public payment and private provision
Nuffield Trust
 
Elaine Kelly public payment and private provision
Elaine Kelly public payment and private provisionElaine Kelly public payment and private provision
Elaine Kelly public payment and private provision
Nuffield Trust
 
Benefits of engaging with the Specialised Services Commissioning Innovation Fund
Benefits of engaging with the Specialised Services Commissioning Innovation FundBenefits of engaging with the Specialised Services Commissioning Innovation Fund
Benefits of engaging with the Specialised Services Commissioning Innovation Fund
PM Society
 
Bob Ricketts, NHS England - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Procurem...
Bob Ricketts, NHS England - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Procurem...Bob Ricketts, NHS England - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Procurem...
Bob Ricketts, NHS England - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Procurem...
Alexis May
 
Monitor general practice services 17 09-13
Monitor general practice services 17 09-13Monitor general practice services 17 09-13
Monitor general practice services 17 09-13
howch1961
 
HSJ Intelligence Conference 2015
HSJ Intelligence Conference 2015HSJ Intelligence Conference 2015
HSJ Intelligence Conference 2015
Anthea Antoniou
 
Judith Smith: The future of commissioning
Judith Smith: The future of commissioning Judith Smith: The future of commissioning
Judith Smith: The future of commissioning
Nuffield Trust
 
Local health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costs
Local health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costsLocal health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costs
Local health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costs
Office of Health Economics
 
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-ReadPrimary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
The King's Fund
 
Parallel Session: Achieving High Quality, Financially Sustainable Healthcare
Parallel Session: Achieving High Quality, Financially Sustainable HealthcareParallel Session: Achieving High Quality, Financially Sustainable Healthcare
Parallel Session: Achieving High Quality, Financially Sustainable Healthcare
NHSScotlandEvent2013
 
Provider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and Policy
Provider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and PolicyProvider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and Policy
Provider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and Policy
Office of Health Economics
 
Residential aged care staffing in australia
Residential aged care staffing in australiaResidential aged care staffing in australia
Residential aged care staffing in australia
Dr Rodney Jilek
 
Oxfordshire local optometric committee ppt 2014 final
Oxfordshire local optometric committee ppt 2014 finalOxfordshire local optometric committee ppt 2014 final
Oxfordshire local optometric committee ppt 2014 final
oxfordshireloc
 
Implementing Bundled Payments: A Deeper Dive
Implementing Bundled Payments: A Deeper DiveImplementing Bundled Payments: A Deeper Dive
Implementing Bundled Payments: A Deeper Dive
Wellbe
 
150408 Posters for Evidence Live
150408 Posters for Evidence Live150408 Posters for Evidence Live
150408 Posters for Evidence Live
Alison Turner
 
Evaluating the impact of choice on place of care
Evaluating the impact of choice on place of careEvaluating the impact of choice on place of care
Evaluating the impact of choice on place of care
Nuffield Trust
 
Joan Saddler: Implications for putting patients and the public first
Joan Saddler: Implications for putting patients and the public firstJoan Saddler: Implications for putting patients and the public first
Joan Saddler: Implications for putting patients and the public first
Nuffield Trust
 
Canadian Medical Association March 2010
Canadian Medical Association  March 2010Canadian Medical Association  March 2010
Canadian Medical Association March 2010
mswindells
 
Jamie Reid
Jamie ReidJamie Reid
Jamie Reid
Informa Australia
 
Focus on cataract
Focus on cataractFocus on cataract
Focus on cataract
NHS IQ legacy organisations
 

Similar to Jon Sussex: Capacity, choice and private ownership (20)

Elaine kelly public payment and private provision
Elaine kelly public payment and private provisionElaine kelly public payment and private provision
Elaine kelly public payment and private provision
 
Elaine Kelly public payment and private provision
Elaine Kelly public payment and private provisionElaine Kelly public payment and private provision
Elaine Kelly public payment and private provision
 
Benefits of engaging with the Specialised Services Commissioning Innovation Fund
Benefits of engaging with the Specialised Services Commissioning Innovation FundBenefits of engaging with the Specialised Services Commissioning Innovation Fund
Benefits of engaging with the Specialised Services Commissioning Innovation Fund
 
Bob Ricketts, NHS England - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Procurem...
Bob Ricketts, NHS England - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Procurem...Bob Ricketts, NHS England - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Procurem...
Bob Ricketts, NHS England - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Procurem...
 
Monitor general practice services 17 09-13
Monitor general practice services 17 09-13Monitor general practice services 17 09-13
Monitor general practice services 17 09-13
 
HSJ Intelligence Conference 2015
HSJ Intelligence Conference 2015HSJ Intelligence Conference 2015
HSJ Intelligence Conference 2015
 
Judith Smith: The future of commissioning
Judith Smith: The future of commissioning Judith Smith: The future of commissioning
Judith Smith: The future of commissioning
 
Local health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costs
Local health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costsLocal health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costs
Local health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costs
 
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-ReadPrimary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
 
Parallel Session: Achieving High Quality, Financially Sustainable Healthcare
Parallel Session: Achieving High Quality, Financially Sustainable HealthcareParallel Session: Achieving High Quality, Financially Sustainable Healthcare
Parallel Session: Achieving High Quality, Financially Sustainable Healthcare
 
Provider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and Policy
Provider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and PolicyProvider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and Policy
Provider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and Policy
 
Residential aged care staffing in australia
Residential aged care staffing in australiaResidential aged care staffing in australia
Residential aged care staffing in australia
 
Oxfordshire local optometric committee ppt 2014 final
Oxfordshire local optometric committee ppt 2014 finalOxfordshire local optometric committee ppt 2014 final
Oxfordshire local optometric committee ppt 2014 final
 
Implementing Bundled Payments: A Deeper Dive
Implementing Bundled Payments: A Deeper DiveImplementing Bundled Payments: A Deeper Dive
Implementing Bundled Payments: A Deeper Dive
 
150408 Posters for Evidence Live
150408 Posters for Evidence Live150408 Posters for Evidence Live
150408 Posters for Evidence Live
 
Evaluating the impact of choice on place of care
Evaluating the impact of choice on place of careEvaluating the impact of choice on place of care
Evaluating the impact of choice on place of care
 
Joan Saddler: Implications for putting patients and the public first
Joan Saddler: Implications for putting patients and the public firstJoan Saddler: Implications for putting patients and the public first
Joan Saddler: Implications for putting patients and the public first
 
Canadian Medical Association March 2010
Canadian Medical Association  March 2010Canadian Medical Association  March 2010
Canadian Medical Association March 2010
 
Jamie Reid
Jamie ReidJamie Reid
Jamie Reid
 
Focus on cataract
Focus on cataractFocus on cataract
Focus on cataract
 

More from Nuffield Trust

Transforming outpatient services - Nuffield Trust/NHS Improvement Event
Transforming outpatient services - Nuffield Trust/NHS Improvement EventTransforming outpatient services - Nuffield Trust/NHS Improvement Event
Transforming outpatient services - Nuffield Trust/NHS Improvement Event
Nuffield Trust
 
13 reasons to spend more on health and social care
13 reasons to spend more on health and social care 13 reasons to spend more on health and social care
13 reasons to spend more on health and social care
Nuffield Trust
 
Energising your workforce in the face of adversity
Energising your workforce in the face of adversityEnergising your workforce in the face of adversity
Energising your workforce in the face of adversity
Nuffield Trust
 
Shifting the balance of care: great expectations
Shifting the balance of care: great expectations Shifting the balance of care: great expectations
Shifting the balance of care: great expectations
Nuffield Trust
 
Automation, Employment, and Health Care
Automation, Employment, and Health Care Automation, Employment, and Health Care
Automation, Employment, and Health Care
Nuffield Trust
 
Public perspectives on the NHS and social care
Public perspectives on the NHS and social carePublic perspectives on the NHS and social care
Public perspectives on the NHS and social care
Nuffield Trust
 
Evaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneers Programme
Evaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneers ProgrammeEvaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneers Programme
Evaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneers Programme
Nuffield Trust
 
Ensuring success for new models of care
Ensuring success for new models of careEnsuring success for new models of care
Ensuring success for new models of care
Nuffield Trust
 
Effectiveness of the current dominant approach to integrated care in the NHS
Effectiveness of the current dominant approach to integrated care in the NHSEffectiveness of the current dominant approach to integrated care in the NHS
Effectiveness of the current dominant approach to integrated care in the NHS
Nuffield Trust
 
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Understanding improvement...
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Understanding improvement...Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Understanding improvement...
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Understanding improvement...
Nuffield Trust
 
Local and national uses of data
Local and national uses of dataLocal and national uses of data
Local and national uses of data
Nuffield Trust
 
Applied use of CUSUMs in surveillance
Applied use of CUSUMs in surveillanceApplied use of CUSUMs in surveillance
Applied use of CUSUMs in surveillance
Nuffield Trust
 
Engaging with data
Engaging with dataEngaging with data
Engaging with data
Nuffield Trust
 
Evaluating new models of care: Improvement Analytics Unit
Evaluating new models of care: Improvement Analytics UnitEvaluating new models of care: Improvement Analytics Unit
Evaluating new models of care: Improvement Analytics Unit
Nuffield Trust
 
Learning from the Care Quality Commission
Learning from the Care Quality CommissionLearning from the Care Quality Commission
Learning from the Care Quality Commission
Nuffield Trust
 
Real-time monitoring and the data trap
Real-time monitoring and the data trapReal-time monitoring and the data trap
Real-time monitoring and the data trap
Nuffield Trust
 
Monitoring quality of care: making the most of data
Monitoring quality of care: making the most of dataMonitoring quality of care: making the most of data
Monitoring quality of care: making the most of data
Nuffield Trust
 
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Insights from the Nationa...
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Insights from the Nationa...Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Insights from the Nationa...
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Insights from the Nationa...
Nuffield Trust
 
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: A perspective from stroke...
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: A perspective from stroke...Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: A perspective from stroke...
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: A perspective from stroke...
Nuffield Trust
 
New Models of General Practice: Practical and policy lessons
New Models of General Practice: Practical and policy lessonsNew Models of General Practice: Practical and policy lessons
New Models of General Practice: Practical and policy lessons
Nuffield Trust
 

More from Nuffield Trust (20)

Transforming outpatient services - Nuffield Trust/NHS Improvement Event
Transforming outpatient services - Nuffield Trust/NHS Improvement EventTransforming outpatient services - Nuffield Trust/NHS Improvement Event
Transforming outpatient services - Nuffield Trust/NHS Improvement Event
 
13 reasons to spend more on health and social care
13 reasons to spend more on health and social care 13 reasons to spend more on health and social care
13 reasons to spend more on health and social care
 
Energising your workforce in the face of adversity
Energising your workforce in the face of adversityEnergising your workforce in the face of adversity
Energising your workforce in the face of adversity
 
Shifting the balance of care: great expectations
Shifting the balance of care: great expectations Shifting the balance of care: great expectations
Shifting the balance of care: great expectations
 
Automation, Employment, and Health Care
Automation, Employment, and Health Care Automation, Employment, and Health Care
Automation, Employment, and Health Care
 
Public perspectives on the NHS and social care
Public perspectives on the NHS and social carePublic perspectives on the NHS and social care
Public perspectives on the NHS and social care
 
Evaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneers Programme
Evaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneers ProgrammeEvaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneers Programme
Evaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneers Programme
 
Ensuring success for new models of care
Ensuring success for new models of careEnsuring success for new models of care
Ensuring success for new models of care
 
Effectiveness of the current dominant approach to integrated care in the NHS
Effectiveness of the current dominant approach to integrated care in the NHSEffectiveness of the current dominant approach to integrated care in the NHS
Effectiveness of the current dominant approach to integrated care in the NHS
 
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Understanding improvement...
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Understanding improvement...Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Understanding improvement...
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Understanding improvement...
 
Local and national uses of data
Local and national uses of dataLocal and national uses of data
Local and national uses of data
 
Applied use of CUSUMs in surveillance
Applied use of CUSUMs in surveillanceApplied use of CUSUMs in surveillance
Applied use of CUSUMs in surveillance
 
Engaging with data
Engaging with dataEngaging with data
Engaging with data
 
Evaluating new models of care: Improvement Analytics Unit
Evaluating new models of care: Improvement Analytics UnitEvaluating new models of care: Improvement Analytics Unit
Evaluating new models of care: Improvement Analytics Unit
 
Learning from the Care Quality Commission
Learning from the Care Quality CommissionLearning from the Care Quality Commission
Learning from the Care Quality Commission
 
Real-time monitoring and the data trap
Real-time monitoring and the data trapReal-time monitoring and the data trap
Real-time monitoring and the data trap
 
Monitoring quality of care: making the most of data
Monitoring quality of care: making the most of dataMonitoring quality of care: making the most of data
Monitoring quality of care: making the most of data
 
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Insights from the Nationa...
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Insights from the Nationa...Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Insights from the Nationa...
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: Insights from the Nationa...
 
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: A perspective from stroke...
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: A perspective from stroke...Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: A perspective from stroke...
Providing actionable healthcare analytics at scale: A perspective from stroke...
 
New Models of General Practice: Practical and policy lessons
New Models of General Practice: Practical and policy lessonsNew Models of General Practice: Practical and policy lessons
New Models of General Practice: Practical and policy lessons
 

Recently uploaded

Local Advanced Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex Sys...
Local Advanced Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex Sys...Local Advanced Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex Sys...
Local Advanced Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex Sys...
Oleg Kshivets
 
Physical demands in sports - WCSPT Oslo 2024
Physical demands in sports - WCSPT Oslo 2024Physical demands in sports - WCSPT Oslo 2024
Physical demands in sports - WCSPT Oslo 2024
Torstein Dalen-Lorentsen
 
Artificial Intelligence Symposium (THAIS)
Artificial Intelligence Symposium (THAIS)Artificial Intelligence Symposium (THAIS)
Artificial Intelligence Symposium (THAIS)
Josep Vidal-Alaball
 
Hiranandani Hospital Powai News [Read Now].pdf
Hiranandani Hospital Powai News [Read Now].pdfHiranandani Hospital Powai News [Read Now].pdf
Hiranandani Hospital Powai News [Read Now].pdf
Dr. Sujit Chatterjee CEO Hiranandani Hospital
 
Outbreak management including quarantine, isolation, contact.pptx
Outbreak management including quarantine, isolation, contact.pptxOutbreak management including quarantine, isolation, contact.pptx
Outbreak management including quarantine, isolation, contact.pptx
Pratik328635
 
Does Over-Masturbation Contribute to Chronic Prostatitis.pptx
Does Over-Masturbation Contribute to Chronic Prostatitis.pptxDoes Over-Masturbation Contribute to Chronic Prostatitis.pptx
Does Over-Masturbation Contribute to Chronic Prostatitis.pptx
walterHu5
 
Role of Mukta Pishti in the Management of Hyperthyroidism
Role of Mukta Pishti in the Management of HyperthyroidismRole of Mukta Pishti in the Management of Hyperthyroidism
Role of Mukta Pishti in the Management of Hyperthyroidism
Dr. Jyothirmai Paindla
 
Cell Therapy Expansion and Challenges in Autoimmune Disease
Cell Therapy Expansion and Challenges in Autoimmune DiseaseCell Therapy Expansion and Challenges in Autoimmune Disease
Cell Therapy Expansion and Challenges in Autoimmune Disease
Health Advances
 
Netter's Atlas of Human Anatomy 7.ed.pdf
Netter's Atlas of Human Anatomy 7.ed.pdfNetter's Atlas of Human Anatomy 7.ed.pdf
Netter's Atlas of Human Anatomy 7.ed.pdf
BrissaOrtiz3
 
OCT Training Course for clinical practice Part 1
OCT Training Course for clinical practice Part 1OCT Training Course for clinical practice Part 1
OCT Training Course for clinical practice Part 1
KafrELShiekh University
 
Tests for analysis of different pharmaceutical.pptx
Tests for analysis of different pharmaceutical.pptxTests for analysis of different pharmaceutical.pptx
Tests for analysis of different pharmaceutical.pptx
taiba qazi
 
The Electrocardiogram - Physiologic Principles
The Electrocardiogram - Physiologic PrinciplesThe Electrocardiogram - Physiologic Principles
The Electrocardiogram - Physiologic Principles
MedicoseAcademics
 
CHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 2 _LEPROSY.pdf1
CHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 2 _LEPROSY.pdf1CHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 2 _LEPROSY.pdf1
CHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 2 _LEPROSY.pdf1
rishi2789
 
Histopathology of Rheumatoid Arthritis: Visual treat
Histopathology of Rheumatoid Arthritis: Visual treatHistopathology of Rheumatoid Arthritis: Visual treat
Histopathology of Rheumatoid Arthritis: Visual treat
DIVYANSHU740006
 
CHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 6_Anti Malarial Drugs.pdf
CHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 6_Anti Malarial Drugs.pdfCHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 6_Anti Malarial Drugs.pdf
CHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 6_Anti Malarial Drugs.pdf
rishi2789
 
share - Lions, tigers, AI and health misinformation, oh my!.pptx
share - Lions, tigers, AI and health misinformation, oh my!.pptxshare - Lions, tigers, AI and health misinformation, oh my!.pptx
share - Lions, tigers, AI and health misinformation, oh my!.pptx
Tina Purnat
 
Promoting Wellbeing - Applied Social Psychology - Psychology SuperNotes
Promoting Wellbeing - Applied Social Psychology - Psychology SuperNotesPromoting Wellbeing - Applied Social Psychology - Psychology SuperNotes
Promoting Wellbeing - Applied Social Psychology - Psychology SuperNotes
PsychoTech Services
 
Chapter 11 Nutrition and Chronic Diseases.pptx
Chapter 11 Nutrition and Chronic Diseases.pptxChapter 11 Nutrition and Chronic Diseases.pptx
Chapter 11 Nutrition and Chronic Diseases.pptx
Earlene McNair
 
The Nervous and Chemical Regulation of Respiration
The Nervous and Chemical Regulation of RespirationThe Nervous and Chemical Regulation of Respiration
The Nervous and Chemical Regulation of Respiration
MedicoseAcademics
 
pathology MCQS introduction to pathology general pathology
pathology MCQS introduction to pathology general pathologypathology MCQS introduction to pathology general pathology
pathology MCQS introduction to pathology general pathology
ZayedKhan38
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Local Advanced Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex Sys...
Local Advanced Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex Sys...Local Advanced Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex Sys...
Local Advanced Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex Sys...
 
Physical demands in sports - WCSPT Oslo 2024
Physical demands in sports - WCSPT Oslo 2024Physical demands in sports - WCSPT Oslo 2024
Physical demands in sports - WCSPT Oslo 2024
 
Artificial Intelligence Symposium (THAIS)
Artificial Intelligence Symposium (THAIS)Artificial Intelligence Symposium (THAIS)
Artificial Intelligence Symposium (THAIS)
 
Hiranandani Hospital Powai News [Read Now].pdf
Hiranandani Hospital Powai News [Read Now].pdfHiranandani Hospital Powai News [Read Now].pdf
Hiranandani Hospital Powai News [Read Now].pdf
 
Outbreak management including quarantine, isolation, contact.pptx
Outbreak management including quarantine, isolation, contact.pptxOutbreak management including quarantine, isolation, contact.pptx
Outbreak management including quarantine, isolation, contact.pptx
 
Does Over-Masturbation Contribute to Chronic Prostatitis.pptx
Does Over-Masturbation Contribute to Chronic Prostatitis.pptxDoes Over-Masturbation Contribute to Chronic Prostatitis.pptx
Does Over-Masturbation Contribute to Chronic Prostatitis.pptx
 
Role of Mukta Pishti in the Management of Hyperthyroidism
Role of Mukta Pishti in the Management of HyperthyroidismRole of Mukta Pishti in the Management of Hyperthyroidism
Role of Mukta Pishti in the Management of Hyperthyroidism
 
Cell Therapy Expansion and Challenges in Autoimmune Disease
Cell Therapy Expansion and Challenges in Autoimmune DiseaseCell Therapy Expansion and Challenges in Autoimmune Disease
Cell Therapy Expansion and Challenges in Autoimmune Disease
 
Netter's Atlas of Human Anatomy 7.ed.pdf
Netter's Atlas of Human Anatomy 7.ed.pdfNetter's Atlas of Human Anatomy 7.ed.pdf
Netter's Atlas of Human Anatomy 7.ed.pdf
 
OCT Training Course for clinical practice Part 1
OCT Training Course for clinical practice Part 1OCT Training Course for clinical practice Part 1
OCT Training Course for clinical practice Part 1
 
Tests for analysis of different pharmaceutical.pptx
Tests for analysis of different pharmaceutical.pptxTests for analysis of different pharmaceutical.pptx
Tests for analysis of different pharmaceutical.pptx
 
The Electrocardiogram - Physiologic Principles
The Electrocardiogram - Physiologic PrinciplesThe Electrocardiogram - Physiologic Principles
The Electrocardiogram - Physiologic Principles
 
CHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 2 _LEPROSY.pdf1
CHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 2 _LEPROSY.pdf1CHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 2 _LEPROSY.pdf1
CHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 2 _LEPROSY.pdf1
 
Histopathology of Rheumatoid Arthritis: Visual treat
Histopathology of Rheumatoid Arthritis: Visual treatHistopathology of Rheumatoid Arthritis: Visual treat
Histopathology of Rheumatoid Arthritis: Visual treat
 
CHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 6_Anti Malarial Drugs.pdf
CHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 6_Anti Malarial Drugs.pdfCHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 6_Anti Malarial Drugs.pdf
CHEMOTHERAPY_RDP_CHAPTER 6_Anti Malarial Drugs.pdf
 
share - Lions, tigers, AI and health misinformation, oh my!.pptx
share - Lions, tigers, AI and health misinformation, oh my!.pptxshare - Lions, tigers, AI and health misinformation, oh my!.pptx
share - Lions, tigers, AI and health misinformation, oh my!.pptx
 
Promoting Wellbeing - Applied Social Psychology - Psychology SuperNotes
Promoting Wellbeing - Applied Social Psychology - Psychology SuperNotesPromoting Wellbeing - Applied Social Psychology - Psychology SuperNotes
Promoting Wellbeing - Applied Social Psychology - Psychology SuperNotes
 
Chapter 11 Nutrition and Chronic Diseases.pptx
Chapter 11 Nutrition and Chronic Diseases.pptxChapter 11 Nutrition and Chronic Diseases.pptx
Chapter 11 Nutrition and Chronic Diseases.pptx
 
The Nervous and Chemical Regulation of Respiration
The Nervous and Chemical Regulation of RespirationThe Nervous and Chemical Regulation of Respiration
The Nervous and Chemical Regulation of Respiration
 
pathology MCQS introduction to pathology general pathology
pathology MCQS introduction to pathology general pathologypathology MCQS introduction to pathology general pathology
pathology MCQS introduction to pathology general pathology
 

Jon Sussex: Capacity, choice and private ownership

  • 1. Jon Sussex Nuffield Trust and IFS seminar 13th September 2013 Discussion of Kelly & Stoye “More hips please. Independent sector provision and the growth in NHS-funded elective care”
  • 2. Discussion of Kelly and Stoye 13/09/2013 2 5 results 1. NHS-funded hip replacements per year up 40% (= +20,000) 2003/04-2010/11 2. Independent sector 62% of the extra 3. Growth faster when new ISP nearer than any NHS provider of hips 4. Substitution of NHS-funded hips for 1/3- 2/3 privately-funded hips at AQPs 5. Small crowding-out of NHS Trusts by ISTCs (not significant by AQPs)
  • 3. Discussion of Kelly and Stoye 13/09/2013 3 3 main issues Distinguish between effects of: A. Increased capacity B. ‘Choice’ and provider (quality) competition C. Private ownership of providers   X
  • 4. Discussion of Kelly and Stoye 13/09/2013 4 A. Capacity • DH set out to increase capacity and activity and succeeded because: • Premium prices (≥+11%) to cover set-up costs/risks and elective-only (=> lower cost) ensured new provider interest • Initial ban on poaching NHS clinical staff, so no crowding-out NHS capacity • Initially no private hospital companies already operating in the UK were awarded ISTC contracts, so no crowding-out private capacity • ISTC take or pay contracts meant zero marginal cost to PCT per patient at ISTC • Plenty of unmet demand and ISTCs aimed at it
  • 5. Discussion of Kelly and Stoye 13/09/2013 5 Deadweight loss • 1/3-2/3 of ‘private payers’ switched to NHS funded care • => deadweight loss to the taxpayer: >4,000 out of 20,000 extra capacity • In addition to possible (in-)equity impacts that are mentioned • [Not sure supply effect vs demand effect distinction is helpful]
  • 6. Discussion of Kelly and Stoye 13/09/2013 6 B. ‘Choice’ and competition • Confirms distance important for choice • ‘Choice’ of private pay vs NHS funded already existed • Cannot tell from the study, but ‘choice’ of NHS funded provider might have increased deadweight loss by increasing willingness to opt for NHS-funded care • Study does not investigate impact on provider quality
  • 7. Discussion of Kelly and Stoye 13/09/2013 7 C. Private ownership • Study says nothing about impact of ownership [Would impact of increased capacity have been the same if all providers had been NHS owned/nationalised?]
  • 8. Discussion of Kelly and Stoye 13/09/2013 8 Other questions • What happened to ISTC activity when first round contracts expired? • What happened to NHS Trusts subcontracting to other providers (and does HES data reflect this)? • NHS hospital site vs Trust HQ location? • ISP hospital site vs company HQ location?