Volume of Deposits, A determinant of Total Long-term Loans Advanced by Commer...iosrjce
Commercial banks have exponentially increased their total loans advanced over the period 2002-
2013. However commercial banks in Kenya have shown varying long term lending behavior. The main objective
of this study was to establish the effect of determinants of long term lending in the Kenyan banking industry, a
case of Bungoma County. This study was guided by the following specific objective; to determine the effect of
volume of deposit on total loan advanced, of selected commercial banks in Kenya. The target population
comprised 13 commercial banks in Bungoma County with a sample size of 52 respondents. From the findings,
for every unit increase in volume of deposits, a 10.9%, unit increase in total loans advanced is predicted. The
model hypothesizes that there is functional relationship between the dependent variable and the independent
variable. The study then recommends that commercial banks should focus on mobilizing more deposits as this
will enhance their lending performance.
HNW Insight Asia The Future Priority Report for the Wealth Management Sector ...Scorpio Partnership
Views from across Asia on wealth creation and wealth management.
In this study, we have looked around Asia to find what drives each nation and its growing force of wealth creators. To make sure we meet their needs now and into the future, we wanted to ask what motivates them. We wanted to understand their hopes, their expectations and their fears at home and abroad, for the simple reason that as the world changes, we want to continue to meet the needs of our clients – as we have for the last 150 years.
Wealth managment in Asia: The FutureAdvisor Asia report from Scorpio PartnershipScorpio Partnership
Scorpio Partnership in conjunction with SunGard announces the launch of FutureAdvisor Asia. This insight explores the issue of how the wealth management industry can become better connected to the regions wealthy. FutureAdvisor captures the views of 400 HNWIs and 96 wealth advisors and senior managers across China, Hong Kong, Singapore, Indonesia and the Philippines.
Smooth functioning a bank depends on the stability of stream of returns that it gets from its financing decision. This study is an attempt to showcase the reason for idling or shortage of funds and the factors for the case of Islamic banking. This effort will determine the strategy which can boost the financing in the economy, for this, this study has used the panel data of full-fledged Islamic banks from countries Pakistan and Malaysia, spanning to several years and based on several banks. Based on the analysis of internal and external factors of Islamic banks, it can be seen that increase in the market rate leads to decrease in demand of financing while the increase in deposits and equity do not show a proportional increase in financing which hints that there is excess liquidity available in the Islamic banks. On the positive side, it is evident that increase in the economic activity boosts the demand for Islamic financing.
Volume of Deposits, A determinant of Total Long-term Loans Advanced by Commer...iosrjce
Commercial banks have exponentially increased their total loans advanced over the period 2002-
2013. However commercial banks in Kenya have shown varying long term lending behavior. The main objective
of this study was to establish the effect of determinants of long term lending in the Kenyan banking industry, a
case of Bungoma County. This study was guided by the following specific objective; to determine the effect of
volume of deposit on total loan advanced, of selected commercial banks in Kenya. The target population
comprised 13 commercial banks in Bungoma County with a sample size of 52 respondents. From the findings,
for every unit increase in volume of deposits, a 10.9%, unit increase in total loans advanced is predicted. The
model hypothesizes that there is functional relationship between the dependent variable and the independent
variable. The study then recommends that commercial banks should focus on mobilizing more deposits as this
will enhance their lending performance.
HNW Insight Asia The Future Priority Report for the Wealth Management Sector ...Scorpio Partnership
Views from across Asia on wealth creation and wealth management.
In this study, we have looked around Asia to find what drives each nation and its growing force of wealth creators. To make sure we meet their needs now and into the future, we wanted to ask what motivates them. We wanted to understand their hopes, their expectations and their fears at home and abroad, for the simple reason that as the world changes, we want to continue to meet the needs of our clients – as we have for the last 150 years.
Wealth managment in Asia: The FutureAdvisor Asia report from Scorpio PartnershipScorpio Partnership
Scorpio Partnership in conjunction with SunGard announces the launch of FutureAdvisor Asia. This insight explores the issue of how the wealth management industry can become better connected to the regions wealthy. FutureAdvisor captures the views of 400 HNWIs and 96 wealth advisors and senior managers across China, Hong Kong, Singapore, Indonesia and the Philippines.
Smooth functioning a bank depends on the stability of stream of returns that it gets from its financing decision. This study is an attempt to showcase the reason for idling or shortage of funds and the factors for the case of Islamic banking. This effort will determine the strategy which can boost the financing in the economy, for this, this study has used the panel data of full-fledged Islamic banks from countries Pakistan and Malaysia, spanning to several years and based on several banks. Based on the analysis of internal and external factors of Islamic banks, it can be seen that increase in the market rate leads to decrease in demand of financing while the increase in deposits and equity do not show a proportional increase in financing which hints that there is excess liquidity available in the Islamic banks. On the positive side, it is evident that increase in the economic activity boosts the demand for Islamic financing.
This is a brief outline of the conference call held on 13 December 2010 with Mrs Srividhya Rajesh, Fund Manager, Sundaram Mutual Fund. The article covers Sundaram Mutual Fund views on Economy and Markets
The Factors Affecting Mudharabah Deposits of Sharia Banking in Indonesiainventionjournals
Mudharabah deposit is one of main fund resource of sharia bank, teherefore the growth must be maintained. This research is aimed to find whether there are influences of profit-sharing rate of mudharabah saving, interest rate of saving in conventional bank, growth rate of Jakarta Islamic Index (JII), and Gross Domestic Product (GDP) to the amount of mudharabah saving in sharia banks. The sharia banks which are used in this research are all of sharia commercial bank in Indonesia.The method of this research is Ordinary Least Square (OLS) with quarterly panel data from 2006 to 2015 of the twelve sharia banks which are observed. The approach model which is used in this research is Fixed Effect Model. The result of this research showed that profit-sharing rate of mudharabah saving, interest rate of saving, growth rate of Jakarta Islamic Index (JII), and Gross Domestic Product (GDP) have significant influences to the amount of mudharabah saving in sharia banks. Profit-sharing rate of mudharabah saving, growth rate of Jakarta Islamic Index (JII), and Gross Domestic Product (GDP) have positive influences to the amount of mudharabah saving, Meanwhile, interest rate of saving in conventional bank has a negative influence to the amount of mudharabah saving
The most important piece of the need for a better developed bond market in India is access to capital for more firms. Currently only the top-rated borrowers have access to the corporate bond market. To know more @ http://theindianeconomist.com/india-developed-bond-market/
This is a presentation targeted to non-economics major, to understand where does money come from and how to achieve sustainability of bank business. The script is available at http://getthingsright.blogspot.com/2010/05/1-opening-banking-business-is-one-of.html
This is a brief outline of the conference call held on 13 December 2010 with Mrs Srividhya Rajesh, Fund Manager, Sundaram Mutual Fund. The article covers Sundaram Mutual Fund views on Economy and Markets
The Factors Affecting Mudharabah Deposits of Sharia Banking in Indonesiainventionjournals
Mudharabah deposit is one of main fund resource of sharia bank, teherefore the growth must be maintained. This research is aimed to find whether there are influences of profit-sharing rate of mudharabah saving, interest rate of saving in conventional bank, growth rate of Jakarta Islamic Index (JII), and Gross Domestic Product (GDP) to the amount of mudharabah saving in sharia banks. The sharia banks which are used in this research are all of sharia commercial bank in Indonesia.The method of this research is Ordinary Least Square (OLS) with quarterly panel data from 2006 to 2015 of the twelve sharia banks which are observed. The approach model which is used in this research is Fixed Effect Model. The result of this research showed that profit-sharing rate of mudharabah saving, interest rate of saving, growth rate of Jakarta Islamic Index (JII), and Gross Domestic Product (GDP) have significant influences to the amount of mudharabah saving in sharia banks. Profit-sharing rate of mudharabah saving, growth rate of Jakarta Islamic Index (JII), and Gross Domestic Product (GDP) have positive influences to the amount of mudharabah saving, Meanwhile, interest rate of saving in conventional bank has a negative influence to the amount of mudharabah saving
The most important piece of the need for a better developed bond market in India is access to capital for more firms. Currently only the top-rated borrowers have access to the corporate bond market. To know more @ http://theindianeconomist.com/india-developed-bond-market/
This is a presentation targeted to non-economics major, to understand where does money come from and how to achieve sustainability of bank business. The script is available at http://getthingsright.blogspot.com/2010/05/1-opening-banking-business-is-one-of.html
International Journal of Business and Management Invention (IJBMI)inventionjournals
International Journal of Business and Management Invention (IJBMI) is an international journal intended for professionals and researchers in all fields of Business and Management. IJBMI publishes research articles and reviews within the whole field Business and Management, new teaching methods, assessment, validation and the impact of new technologies and it will continue to provide information on the latest trends and developments in this ever-expanding subject. The publications of papers are selected through double peer reviewed to ensure originality, relevance, and readability. The articles published in our journal can be accessed online
Portfolio management and mutual fund analysisSupa Buoy
Hi Friends
This is supa bouy
I am a mentor, Friend for all Management Aspirants, Any query related to anything in Management, Do write me @ supabuoy@gmail.com.
I will try to assist the best way I can.
Cheers to lyf…!!!
Supa Bouy
Japan Growth Finance Forum was hosted by HC Asset Management to celebrate the 10th anniversary of its foundation on Tuesday, April 9 2013 at Imperial Hotel Tokyo. The theme of the forum was designing growth finance to revive the Japanese economy. Approximately 300 participants were in attendance.
http://www.investmentinjapan.com/
Indonesian Tech Ecosystem Report - Bits by BricksRama Manusama
Bits x Bricks is MDI Ventures' initial publication on Indonesia's tech startup and corporate innovation ecosystem
- Industry landscape and profile, including the latest investment and M&A activities.
- Corporate perspectives on leading the role to unlock the ecosystem's potential to the next level.
- Case studies on partnerships between startups and corporates in delivering business impact.
Digital Marketing in Disruptive Era. Collaborative Marketing. Cultural Marketing. Spiritual Marketing. Digital Subcultures. Paradox of Marketing. Channel distribution. Zero Marketing Budget
Should 50 questions define the life path of millions of people ?
Should 10 persons define the creation of those 50 questions ?
Should 1 single entity define the criteria of those 10 persons ?
Cheat-proof
Competence
Personalized
Variations
Time Flexible
Instant
Glocal
Efficient
Cheat-proof
Competence
Personalized
Variations
Time Flexible
Instant
Glocal
Efficient
Should 50 questions define the life path of millions of people ?
Should 10 persons define the creation of those 50 questions ?
Should 1 single entity define the criteria of those 10 persons ?
Feasibility Study of Organic Fertilizer Factory in Nanjing-Thesis Proposal based on ENACTUS NUIST Project : Hand a Hand - Converting Waste to Gold - Phase 1
More from Palang Parkir, Indonesia. SIFE - NUIST, Nanjing, China (12)
Adjusting primitives for graph : SHORT REPORT / NOTESSubhajit Sahu
Graph algorithms, like PageRank Compressed Sparse Row (CSR) is an adjacency-list based graph representation that is
Multiply with different modes (map)
1. Performance of sequential execution based vs OpenMP based vector multiply.
2. Comparing various launch configs for CUDA based vector multiply.
Sum with different storage types (reduce)
1. Performance of vector element sum using float vs bfloat16 as the storage type.
Sum with different modes (reduce)
1. Performance of sequential execution based vs OpenMP based vector element sum.
2. Performance of memcpy vs in-place based CUDA based vector element sum.
3. Comparing various launch configs for CUDA based vector element sum (memcpy).
4. Comparing various launch configs for CUDA based vector element sum (in-place).
Sum with in-place strategies of CUDA mode (reduce)
1. Comparing various launch configs for CUDA based vector element sum (in-place).
06-04-2024 - NYC Tech Week - Discussion on Vector Databases, Unstructured Data and AI
Round table discussion of vector databases, unstructured data, ai, big data, real-time, robots and Milvus.
A lively discussion with NJ Gen AI Meetup Lead, Prasad and Procure.FYI's Co-Found
The Building Blocks of QuestDB, a Time Series Databasejavier ramirez
Talk Delivered at Valencia Codes Meetup 2024-06.
Traditionally, databases have treated timestamps just as another data type. However, when performing real-time analytics, timestamps should be first class citizens and we need rich time semantics to get the most out of our data. We also need to deal with ever growing datasets while keeping performant, which is as fun as it sounds.
It is no wonder time-series databases are now more popular than ever before. Join me in this session to learn about the internal architecture and building blocks of QuestDB, an open source time-series database designed for speed. We will also review a history of some of the changes we have gone over the past two years to deal with late and unordered data, non-blocking writes, read-replicas, or faster batch ingestion.
Levelwise PageRank with Loop-Based Dead End Handling Strategy : SHORT REPORT ...Subhajit Sahu
Abstract — Levelwise PageRank is an alternative method of PageRank computation which decomposes the input graph into a directed acyclic block-graph of strongly connected components, and processes them in topological order, one level at a time. This enables calculation for ranks in a distributed fashion without per-iteration communication, unlike the standard method where all vertices are processed in each iteration. It however comes with a precondition of the absence of dead ends in the input graph. Here, the native non-distributed performance of Levelwise PageRank was compared against Monolithic PageRank on a CPU as well as a GPU. To ensure a fair comparison, Monolithic PageRank was also performed on a graph where vertices were split by components. Results indicate that Levelwise PageRank is about as fast as Monolithic PageRank on the CPU, but quite a bit slower on the GPU. Slowdown on the GPU is likely caused by a large submission of small workloads, and expected to be non-issue when the computation is performed on massive graphs.
Chatty Kathy - UNC Bootcamp Final Project Presentation - Final Version - 5.23...John Andrews
SlideShare Description for "Chatty Kathy - UNC Bootcamp Final Project Presentation"
Title: Chatty Kathy: Enhancing Physical Activity Among Older Adults
Description:
Discover how Chatty Kathy, an innovative project developed at the UNC Bootcamp, aims to tackle the challenge of low physical activity among older adults. Our AI-driven solution uses peer interaction to boost and sustain exercise levels, significantly improving health outcomes. This presentation covers our problem statement, the rationale behind Chatty Kathy, synthetic data and persona creation, model performance metrics, a visual demonstration of the project, and potential future developments. Join us for an insightful Q&A session to explore the potential of this groundbreaking project.
Project Team: Jay Requarth, Jana Avery, John Andrews, Dr. Dick Davis II, Nee Buntoum, Nam Yeongjin & Mat Nicholas
Analysis insight about a Flyball dog competition team's performanceroli9797
Insight of my analysis about a Flyball dog competition team's last year performance. Find more: https://github.com/rolandnagy-ds/flyball_race_analysis/tree/main
3. 3KKR INSIGHTS: GLOBAL MACRO TRENDS
After completing a comprehensive deep dive on Indonesia back in
early 2013, my colleague Frances Lim and I authored a report titled
“Indonesia: Turning Potential Into Reality.” The punch line of the re-
port was that, while Indonesia enjoys massive demographic tailwinds,
the country needed to clean up its finances, improve its infrastruc-
ture, and further diversify its economy before it would be ’all clear‘
for increased capital deployment by foreigners.
Whether we were lucky or good when we voiced our concerns, we will
never know. But we do know that the United States Federal Reserve,
by hinting that it would be making a shift in monetary policy, immedi-
ately thereafter shocked Indonesia and many of its emerging market
peers by inspiring what is now called the ‘Taper Tantrum.’
Fast forward to Spring 2017, and the outlook for Indonesia appears
quite different. Deficits are more balanced, the currency is more
stable, and infrastructure outlays are accelerating. Our recent onsite
visit to Indonesia with our local team of KKR professionals confirmed
a similar feeling, and as such, we came away from our trip believ-
ing that Indonesia has — at least on the macro front — finally begun
to visibly turn its long-term potential into near-term economic and
investment realities. We note the following:
• The country’s macro game plan now seems more in synch with
the potential obstacles the country faces. Just consider that
government funding for infrastructure projects jumped by over
20% in the latest 2017 budget, and it now stands at 2.5 times
what was allocated just three years ago. Meanwhile, the country’s
reserve base is now near record levels, and unlike many other EM
countries we visit, there is no excessive credit overhang about
which to worry. Maybe more important, though, is that central
bankers, government officials, and CEOs all now seem more com-
mitted to delivering on the “game plan” that is needed to elevate
Indonesia into one of the EM market’s elite destinations for inves-
tor capital.
• Within our ASEAN footprint, Indonesia has clearly emerged as
one of the most attractive pure-plays on our view that global
capital flows will increasingly migrate towards economies with
large domestic consumption. In Indonesia, GDP-per-capita is still
increasing 8.2% per annum (i.e., 2.5 times as fast as the U.S.),
which represents a distinguishing feature in today’s growth-
starved, geopolitically unsettled world. Indeed, with half its popu-
lation of 260 million under the age of 30, private consumption as
a percentage of GDP already totals 58%, a figure that we think
could increase another five to seven percentage points during the
next decade.
• Within the region, we see several industries in transition where
investors should be buyers when prices become more realistic.
E-commerce, health services, wellness, entertainment, nourish-
ment, education, and even consumer financial services all repre-
sent strong secular growth areas that warrant investor attention.
However, valuation matters, and as good as these opportunities
may be, these secular tailwinds are not worth harnessing unless
investors can partner with the right local entrepreneurs.
• While absolute rates are low in Indonesia relative to history, lo-
cal debt actually looks compelling. Now that Indonesia has been
upgraded to investment grade by all three major ratings agencies,
it is one of the highest yielding sovereign securities in the world
within its ratings designation.
• Consistent with this view on local debt, we are now more
sanguine on EM currencies. This statement is significant, as cur-
rency usually accounts for one-third of the total return equation
during an EM performance cycle. If we are right, then less capital
will need to be allocated towards hedging on a go-forward basis.
• Private Credit in Indonesia represents an opportunity, but deal
sizes are still small and sourcing engines will likely be needed to
boost capital deployment in this product area. From a structural
standpoint, however, Indonesia lacks local deposits, and its bank
executives are increasingly shying away from complexity, particu-
larly in the middle market. Meanwhile, foreign banks have pulled
back, with loans as a percentage of GDP falling to 13% in March
2017, compared to a peak of 16% in September 2015. In our view,
this backdrop could be bullish for private credit, particularly as
there are a growing number of more difficult transactions that
require speed of execution.
• Our research on Indonesian Public Equities suggests that we
are at an inflection point. After a multi-year period of stagnant
growth, earnings are poised to finally reaccelerate, we believe. As
such, we expect the Indonesian Public Equity index to outperform
many of its more prominent EM peers during the next few years.
Not surprisingly, though, within the Indonesian Public Equity index
investors has efficiently bifurcated valuations between banks and
consumer stocks, a gap we do not see closing in the near term.
• Similar to what we have seen in other big EM markets, we
believe that the opportunity for investors to use Private Equity
to arbitrage the Public Equity markets is large and growing. For
example, in Indonesia, the Public Equity benchmark actually has a
zero percent weighting to Technology, one of the areas we find most
compelling in the region. So, if we are right about the growth trajec-
tory of areas like e-commerce, mobile payments, and logistics, then
large institutional investors will want to move beyond the public in-
dexes to gain private exposure to areas of the economy that actually
capture the bullish GDP story that we have been highlighting.
In terms of the bigger picture, we left Southeast Asia (SEA) even
more convinced that the global macro outlook we laid out in Janu-
ary (see Outlook for 2017: Paradigm Shift) has momentum. Indeed,
spending time in the region with CEOs, central bankers, and sell-side
experts only reinforced many of our core investment themes, includ-
ing the following: 1) Emerging Market Equities have turned up and
may have begun a multi-year outperformance run versus Developed
Market Equities (Exhibits 1 and 2), 2) our thesis about performing
private credit over non-performing private credit is a global, not a
specific regional insight (which is good for SEA, including Indonesia),
3) consumer spending on experiences over things is gaining momen-
tum in both developed and developing markets; and 4) we continue
to see investment opportunities on a global basis to buy complex-
ity (e.g., carve-outs, dislocated securities), but sell simplicity (e.g.,
over-priced sovereign debt and high PE consumer staples stocks).
4. 4 KKR INSIGHTS: GLOBAL MACRO TRENDS
EXHIBIT 1
It Has Been a Long, Hard Road in Emerging Markets...
Sep-94
288%
Sep-01
17%
Sep-10
305%
May-17
134%
0%
50%
100%
150%
200%
250%
300%
350%
87 89 91 93 95 97 99 01 03 05 07 09 11 13 15 17
Relative Total Return, MSCI EM/DM
(Feb'87 = 0%)
81
months
84
months
108
months
80
months
Data as at May 30, 2017. Source: MSCI, Bloomberg, Factset.
EXHIBIT 2
...But Our Model Now Suggests EM Has Bottomed
“RULE OF THE
ROAD” MAY’15 JAN’16 AUG’16
CURRENT
SIGNAL
1
BUY WHEN ROE IS
STABLE OR RISING
2
VALUATION: IT’S
NOT DIFFERENT
THIS TIME
3
EM FX FOLLOWS EM
EQUITIES
4
COMMODITIES COR-
RELATION IN EM IS
HIGH
5
MOMENTUM MAT-
TERS IN EM EQUI-
TIES
Data as at May 31, 2017. Source: KKR Global Macro and Asset Allocation
analysis.
Another major macro conclusion from the trip is that Asia’s current
savings glut (e.g., China has a 50% savings rate) is likely to put con-
tinued downward pressure on global interest rates, even if global QE
normalizes. This viewpoint is significant because it likely means that
capital markets return assumptions may need to be further adjusted
downward. In addition, it suggests that investors and corporations
that can lower the cost of their liabilities via cheap funding sources
like Japanese banks or Chinese insurance companies are likely to
earn excess returns relative to those that do not adjust to the new
environment we are now envisioning. In our view, too few investors
in the United States and Europe are taking advantage of regional
funding arbitrage that we believe has emerged in Asia these days.
EXHIBIT 3
China Has Already Had a Crash in Nominal GDP, Which
Is Important for Framing the Asian Opportunity Set
Sep-11
9.4%
6.9%
Jun-11
19.7%
Dec-15
6.4%
Mar-17
11.8%
-0.3%
4.6%
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
China: Quarterly GDP Growth Y/y, %
Real GDP Nominal GDP Y/y GDP Deflator Y/y
Data as at 1Q2017. Source: China National Bureau of Statistics, Haver
Analytics.
EXHIBIT 4
While China’s Economy Is Just $11.2 Trillion vs. $18.6
Trillion for the U.S., It Has 1.6x More Savings
2016
5.5
1.3
3.4
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
'60 '65 '70 '75 '80 '85 '90 '95 '00 '05 '10 '15
Gross Domestic Savings, US$ Trillions
China Japan US
Note: Total savings estimated by deducting final consumption expenditure
from nominal GDP. 2016 number for China’s saving is our own estimate.
Data as at December 31, 2016. Source: Maybank Kim Eng Economics
Research, China’s Rising Wall of Savings, April 2017; CEIC.
“
From a macro investing standpoint
— Indonesia has emerged as
somewhat of a pure-play on
our thesis that large, domestic
economies will prosper in a world
that now favors domestic agendas
over global ones.
“
5. 5KKR INSIGHTS: GLOBAL MACRO TRENDS
If we are wrong about our positive views on the opportunity set that
we now see in Southeast Asia, we think it will be because capital
flight trumps a high savings rate in China, or the end of quantitative
easing leads to a significant flight of institutional and retail capital
from EM bonds (e.g., 38% of Indonesian bonds are held by foreign-
ers). Neither outcome is our base case, but we do think these risks
are worth highlighting, particularly when deploying capital in the
emerging markets.
DETAILS
The Structural Backdrop in Indonesia Remains Extremely Com-
pelling After multiple visits throughout Indonesia during the past
22 years, we retain our long-held view that Indonesia has one of
the most compelling demographic stories that we see across KKR’s
global footprint, with working age population not peaking for several
decades (Exhibits 5 and 6). By 2050, Indonesia will have the third
largest middle class population in the world, trailing only China and
India (Exhibit 7). Without question, these trends are constructive for
investments in sectors like healthcare, education, e-commerce, food
safety, transportation, payments and housing/financial services.
Maybe more important in the near term, though, is that — from a
macro investing standpoint — Indonesia has emerged as somewhat
of a pure-play on our thesis that large, domestic economies will pros-
per in a world that now favors domestic agendas over global ones.
With half its population of 260 million under the age of 30, consump-
tion as a percentage of GDP now totals 58%, ahead of China’s 38%
and nearly on par with India’s 56% (Exhibit 9). Against this backdrop,
household consumption reached $500 billion in 2015, up 167% from
2005, and we look for GDP-per-capita to expand another 49%, or
8.2% per annum during the 2017-2022 period (Exhibit 8). If we are
right, then household consumption could total at least $740 billion by
the end of the decade.
EXHIBIT 5
Indonesia Has One of the Most Compelling
Demographic Stories Across KKR’s Global Footprint…
Cambodia
Spain
Russia
Australia
U.S.
China
Turkey
Indonesia
Hong Kong
Vietnam
Brazil
Mexico
India
Philippines
Japan
Germany
Singapore
-20
-10
0
10
20
30
40
50
20 30 40 50 60 70
WorkingAgePopulationGrowth2030vs2010(%)
Percent of Population Under Age 30 (%)
52% below age 30
Data as at July 30, 2015. Source: United Nations World Population
Prospects, Haver Analytics.
EXHIBIT 6
…Its Working Age Population Is Already the Fourth
Largest in the World and Will Only Peak in 2060
2060
2016
2052
2036
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
1990
1995
2000
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
2035
2040
2045
2050
2055
2060
2065
2070
2075
2080
2085
2090
2095
2100
Working Age Population Indexed: 2000 = 100
Indonesia China India Brazil
Indonesia’s working
age population will
only peak in 2060
Data as at December 19, 2016. Source: United Nations World Population
Prospects, Haver Analytics.
EXHIBIT 7
By 2050, Indonesia Will Have the Third Largest Middle
Class Among Emerging Markets
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
Poland
Argentina
Malaysia
SaudiArabia
Peru
Turkey
Colombia
Pakistan
Thailand
Mexico
Russia
Philippines
Egypt
Brazil
Indonesia
China
India
2050: Size of Middle Class Population, Millions
Third largest middle
income population
among emerging markets
Source: HSBC report “Consumer in 2050” dated October 2012.
6. 6 KKR INSIGHTS: GLOBAL MACRO TRENDS
EXHIBIT 8
GDP-Per-Capita Should Grow by 49%, or 8.2% Annually,
Over the Next Five Years
1998
582
2011
3,688
0
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
7,000
70 73 76 79 82 85 88 91 94 97 00 03 06 09 12 15 18 21
Indonesia: GDP-per-capita, US$
Indonesia Estimate
1998-2011
15.3% CAGR
2017-2022
8.2% CAGR
Data as at April 18, 2017. Source: Biro Pusat Statistik, IMF, Haver
Analytics.
EXHIBIT 9
Consumption in Indonesia Is Higher Than India’s
Economy...
-0.6
57.7
55.9
38.0
9.4
10.613.8
32.6
0.8 3.4
34.1
44.7
Private
Consumption Government Investment Net Exports
2016 GDP Composition, %
Indonesia India China
China data as at 2015. Data as May 5, 2017. Source: India Central
Statistical Organization, Biro Pusat Statistik, and China National Bureau
of Statistics.
EXHIBIT 10
…As Household Consumption Grew 167% from 2005 to
2015
COUNTRY
HOUSEHOLD
CONSUMPTION IN $
TRILLIONS % CHANGE
FROM 2005
TO 2015
CONSUMP-
TION AS A
% OF GDP,
20152005 2015
CHINA 0.9 4.3 363% 38%
PHILIPPINES 0.1 0.2 179% 74%
INDONESIA 0.2 0.5 167% 56%
INDIA 0.5 1.2 156% 59%
U.S. 8.8 12.3 40% 68%
Data as at April 17, 2017. Source: World Bank, Haver Analytics.
Interestingly, when we talk to U.S. and European investors about
both the absolute and relative size of the Indonesian consumer op-
portunity, many are unfamiliar. Rather, they are more focused on
higher profile BRIC countries like India and China. In our view, this
more narrow focus is a mistake. China’s working age population is
now contracting the equivalent of the total population of Singapore
per year, while Brazil continues to struggle with declining productiv-
ity, political discord, and excess credit. India does have a compelling
demographic profile with good growth, but there are times when its
highly democratic approach can slow down the reform process. As
such, our advice continues to be that participation/diversification
across all these countries, particularly those with large consumption
economies, is likely the best way to generate top-tier returns in the
emerging markets throughout this cycle.
Importantly, the Near-Term Macro Backdrop Looks Pretty Good
After getting negatively repriced during the Taper Tantrum fallout
in 2013 and then suffering through the China slowdown/commod-
ity bust in 2014 (and subsequent increase in NPLs), the Indonesia
macro story appears to be more stable. At $116 billion (Exhibit 11),
reserves are near record levels, the country is enjoying the benefits
of a cyclical rebound in commodity prices, and President Widodo’s
government has focused more on increasing infrastructure spending
as well as broadening the tax base.
From a political standpoint, there is now enough growth to boost
local morale towards optimistic levels, but not so much that the gov-
ernment has lost its focus on reforms and structural improvements.
“
Indonesia’s macro game
plan now seems more in synch
with the potential obstacles the
country faces.
“
7. 7KKR INSIGHTS: GLOBAL MACRO TRENDS
EXHIBIT 11
Indonesia’s FX Reserves Are at the Highest Levels Since
August 2011
Aug-11
117
Jul-13
86
Mar-17
116
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
99 01 03 05 07 09 11 13 15 17
Indonesia: Foreign Exchange Reserves, US$B
Data as at March 31, 2017. Source: Bloomberg.
EXHIBIT 12
A Synchronized ASEAN Export Recovery Has Now
Occurred, Though It Has Been Mainly Due to Higher
Prices, Not Volumes
3mma
-40%
-30%
-20%
-10%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
'06 '07 '08 '09 '10 '11 '12 '13 '14 '15 '16 '17 '18
Indonesia Malaysia Philippines
Singapore Thailand ASEAN-5
Data as at April 30, 2017. Source: Bloomberg.
Budget allocations for priority areas such as infrastructure, educa-
tion and healthcare have increased significantly under Indonesia’s
seventh president, Joko Widodo. All told, central government fund-
ing for infrastructure, an area that we have traditionally viewed as
notably inadequate in Indonesia, jumped by over 20% in the latest
2017 budget, and it now stands at 2.5 times what was allocated just
three years ago (Exhibit 13). The other piece of good news is that the
government’s infrastructure plans (~$370 billion over 2015-19) are
backed by diverse funding sources (Exhibit 14.) Previously, infrastruc-
ture spend was not only low but also highly concentrated in energy
and subsidies (Exhibit 13).
We view the president’s game plan as quite favorable, and we were
encouraged by what we heard on the ground in the country’s capital,
Jakarta. CEOs appear content to invest in the current environment,
and when the local banks are unwilling to lend on key infrastructure
projects, China clearly has a mandate from Beijing to step in and
serve as the marginal capital provider.
However, as the country turns towards the election season in 2019,
investors need to ensure that the government does not lose its
long-term focus in favor of more short-term growth to boost political
sentiment. There is also risk that religious tensions flare up heading
into election season in 2019. Both of the aforementioned risks (i.e.,
budgetary and sectarian) are manageable, but do warrant investor
attention in the coming months, in our view.
EXHIBIT 13
Government Funding for Infrastructure Projects Is 2.5x
More Than What Was Allocated Three Years Ago
0
100
200
300
400
500
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
2011-2017 Indonesian Government Funding by Project Type
Infrastructure Education Health
Subsidies Energy Subsidy
IDR Tr
Data as at January 2017. Source: BofAML Global Research estimates,
CEIC.
“
Within our ASEAN footprint,
Indonesia has clearly emerged as
one of the most attractive pure-
plays on our view that global
capital flows will increasingly
migrate towards economies with
large domestic consumption.
“
8. 8 KKR INSIGHTS: GLOBAL MACRO TRENDS
EXHIBIT 14
Indonesia Is Now Funding Its Infrastructure Spending
Through a Wider Variety of Sources
State Budget
30%
Regional
Budget
11%
SOE
22%
Private / PPP
37%
Funding Source for US$370B of Infrastructure Projects (2015-2019)
Data as at January 2017. Source: BofAML Global Research estimates,
CEIC.
Achilles Heel: Indonesia Still Runs With Twin Deficits, Finances
Itself With Foreign Capital, and Is Still Dependent on Commodity
Exports In what is an unusual set-up for an Asian country, Indonesia
actually runs both a current account and a fiscal deficit. One can see
this graphically in Exhibit 16. What’s the problem? While the country
has a decent commodity export franchise, it has not been as suc-
cessful in the traditional manufacturing space as some other emerg-
ing market countries. As a result, its large consumption economy
often creates demands for imports that its export economy can’t
always offset.
Another macro issue for investors to consider is that fully 38% of
the country’s bonds are held by foreigners (Exhibit 15), which makes
it more vulnerable to sudden capital outflows in the case of a global
shock. From what we can tell, lax tax collection, particularly as it
relates to the country’s sizeable informal economy, remains a major
issue. Finally, most of its exports are commodity related, while many
of its imports are non-commodity related (Exhibits 17 and 18).
The offsets to these potentially precarious macro statistics include
a low debt-to-GDP ratio (at just 31%) and a notable increase in
reserves (to $116 billion – the highest since August 2011). Also, the
government has a self-imposed fiscal deficit cap of three percent,
which we believe is prudent policy to keep its current account in
check. However, we note that this is at the expense of more rapid
growth funded by government spending.
Also, as we mentioned earlier, there are cyclical tailwinds in Indo-
nesia’s favor. For example, there has been a major acceleration in
regional trade, with ASEAN-5 exports now growing at the strongest
pace in six years. Moreover, unlike in the U.S., Indonesia has followed
through on a successful tax amnesty program (yielding $10 billion in
tax-related revenues linked to $365 billion of previously undeclared
assets).
EXHIBIT 15
High Foreign Ownership of Indonesian Bonds Leaves the
Economy Vulnerable to Sudden Capital Outflows
3.9
5.2
13.3
13.5
13.9
15.0
19.9
28.4
29.4
30.1
31.9
38.2
38.3
64.5
China
Israel
Brazil
Korea
Philippines
Thailand
Turkey
Malaysia
Hungary
Russia
Poland
Indonesia
South Africa
Mexico
% Foreign Holding of Government Domestic Debt
Data as at March 31, 2017 or latest available. Source: Respective national
security agencies, Haver Analytics.
EXHIBIT 16
Unlike Most Asian Countries, Indonesia Has Twin Deficits
Philippines
India
Indonesia
China
Vietnam
Korea
Thailand
Taiwan
Singapore
Malaysia
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
-5 0 5 10 15 20
FiscalSurplus(Deifict)asa%ofGDP
Current Account Surplus (Deficit) as a % of GDP
Twin
deficits
Data as at March 31, 2017 or latest available. Source: Respective national
statistical agencies, Haver Analytics.
“
We are now more sanguine on
EM currencies and if we are right,
then less capital will need to be
allocated towards hedging on a
go-forward basis.
“
9. 9KKR INSIGHTS: GLOBAL MACRO TRENDS
EXHIBIT 17
Indonesia’s Export Basket Is Changing for the Positive, as
It Becomes Less Reliant on Commodities...
65 66 66 65 67 68
63 62
58
54
51
35 34 34 35
33 31
35 37
42
45
48
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Indonesia: Export Composition, % of Total
Commodity Related Products Other
Data as at April 18, 2017. Source: Bank Indonesia, Haver Analytics.
Our bottom line: We want to keep an eye on foreign ownership
of bonds as well as encourage a further broadening of the export
economy via improved manufacturing capacity. However, we do not
think a limited increase in the country’s current account deficit or the
ongoing Fed tightening campaign will cause ‘Taper Tantrum II.’ This
sentiment is noteworthy, as it reflects a 180 degree change (i.e., a
major improvement) in our opinion versus the more cautionary macro
outlook that we laid out during our last visit in 2013.
Longer-term, though, Indonesia needs to leverage the inherent ben-
efits of its resource-rich heritage to develop more robust manufac-
turing and services offerings that can compete on both a regional
and a global basis. In order to achieve this, the country must continue
to upgrade its human capital by investing in education and training.
This economic transition will not happen overnight, we acknowledge,
but we do view it as a critical next step in helping to prevent the
country’s duel deficits from becoming more problematic. Importantly,
if the government can help the country’s private sector to broaden
its base of output, it would provide a compelling addition to what is
already one of the strongest consumption stories across the emerg-
ing markets.
EXHIBIT 18
…While Its Imports Are Generally Non-Commodity Based
33 35
33
29
34
38
34
36 37
29 28
67 65
67
71
66
62
66
64 63
71 72
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Indonesia: Import Composition, % of Total
Commodity Related Other
Data as at April 18, 2017. Source: Bank Indonesia, Haver Analytics.
Public Equity Valuations: A Tale of Two Cities After heavily re-
searching the outlook for local Indonesian public equities, we came
away thinking of the current regime as somewhat of ’A Tale of Two
Cities.’ On the one hand, Indonesian equities are now trading in-line
with their long-term uptrend on a price-to-earnings basis, despite the
market’s ROE falling 35% to 15% from 23% in 2011. On the other
hand, Indonesian stocks appear more compelling a price-to-book
basis, trading at more than one standard deviation below trend in
EXHIBIT 19
Indonesian Valuations Suggest That Stocks Are Trading at a Discount Relative to Trend on a P/B Basis, But Not From a
P/E Perspective
-1%
-7%
-22% -20%
-40%
-30%
-20%
-10%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
Forward P/E Relative to EM
Forward P/E
Price-to-Book Relative to EM Price-
to-Book
Indonesia Valuation: Discount/Premium Relative To Trend
Max Min Current
Indonesia trades at discount
Indonesia trades at premium
Data as at April 27, 2017. Source: Factset Aggregates.
10. 10 KKR INSIGHTS: GLOBAL MACRO TRENDS
absolute terms and relative to other emerging markets (Exhibit 19).
We link the discrepancy between an upward moving price-to-earn-
ings ratio and a downward moving price-to-book ratio to two factors.
First, 12-month forward EPS growth – until recently – has been
essentially flat since 2011. Second, book value growth has been in a
steady uptrend during this same period, driven largely by what we
believe to be additional equity issuance, some dividend cuts, etc.
Also, intertwined in the aforementioned valuation anomaly across
Indonesian equities is that there is a large and growing valuation
differential between consumer stocks and bank stocks. All told, dur-
ing the past six years, consumer stocks (staples, discretionary and
healthcare) have experienced the lion’s share of re-rating, with PE
multiples expanding by a full 36% from 15.1x to 20.5x (Exhibit 20). On
the other hand, bank stocks, which account for fully 36% of the total
index, have actually de-rated over this period, with multiples con-
tracting 7% from 14.1x to 13.2x today.
EXHIBIT 20
There Are Currently Big Valuation Differentials Between
Consumer Stocks and Bank Stocks in Indonesia
16.0x
20.5x
13.2x
5
7
9
11
13
15
17
19
21
23
'04 '06 '08 '10 '12 '14 '16 '18
12-month Forward P/E Ratio
Indonesia Consumer Banks
Note: Consumer = Staples, Discretionary and Healthcare stocks. Data as
at April 30, 2017. Source: MSCI, Factset.
EXHIBIT 21
An Analysis of Earnings Yields Tells a Similar Story
6.3%
5.5%
4%
5%
6%
7%
8%
9%
10%
11%
12%
13%
'04 '06 '08 '10 '12 '14 '16 '18
12-month Forward Earnings Yield
Indonesia Indonesia ex-Financials
Data as at April 30, 2017. Source: MSCI, Factset.
Based on a continued improvement in fundamentals across the
Indonesian macro and micro landscapes, we expect the valuation dif-
ferential between the country and the rest of its EM peers to narrow
in the coming quarters. However, we actually do not expect the gap
between consumer and bank stocks to follow a similar path. First, we
expect consumer earnings to inflect upward in 2H17. Already, several
consumer businesses with which we spoke are seeing upticks in
sales, albeit we do not think that we are going back to levels experi-
enced during the China Growth Miracle period (2000-2013). On the
other hand, we think that the regulator’s decision to cap the rates that
banks can charge customers is increasingly crimping net interest
margins, while loan-to-deposit ratios remain extended (Exhibit 22).
This latter point is significant, and as we discuss below, it bodes well
for our positive thesis around private credit in Indonesia.
“
Another major macro conclusion
from the trip is that Asia’s current
savings glut (e.g., China has a
50% savings rate) is likely to put
continued downward pressure on
global interest rates, even if global
QE normalizes. This viewpoint
is significant because it likely
means that capital markets return
assumptions may need to be
further adjusted downward.
“
11. 11KKR INSIGHTS: GLOBAL MACRO TRENDS
EXHIBIT 22
Indonesia Suffers from Too Few Deposits, Not Too Many
Loans
37%
195%
142%
65%
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
Deposits as a % of GDP
Indonesia China Singapore India
No growth in deposits as a % of GDP
Data as at March 31, 2017. Source: Bank Indonesia, Biro Pusat Statistik,
People’s Bank of China, China National Bureau of Statistics, Monetary
Authority of Singapore, Singapore Department of Statistics, Reserve
Bank of India, India Central Statistical Organization, Haver Analytics.
EXHIBIT 23
Interest Rates Have Moved to 4.75% from 12.75% in 2005,
Reflecting Both a Better Macro Backdrop as Well as the
Global Effects of Quantitative Easing
Dec-05
12.75
5.75
Apr-17
4.75
Oct-05
14.68
Feb-12
4.25
4.91
B3
B2
B1
Ba3
Ba2
Moody's
Upgrade to
Baa3
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
Bank Indonesia Policy Rate (%)
Jakarta Interbank Rate (JIBOR) 3-Month (%)
Data as at April 30, 2017. Source: Bank Indonesia, Bloomberg, Haver
Analytics.
We See an Excellent Opportunity for Private Equity Arbitrages
Relative to the Public Markets Similar to the message we have laid
out in other large economies like China (e.g., where state-owned
banks largely dominate the local index’s weightings), the public mar-
ket indices are often not the appropriate investment vehicles for in-
vestors to actually gain access to compelling GDP-per-capita stories.
Without question, this investment conundrum exists in Indonesia.
Just consider that the MSCI Indonesia index has a zero weighting to
technology, compared to a full 24% for the aggregate MSCI EM equity
index (Exhibits 24 and 25). As a result, there are essentially no liquid
public securities to gain access to the significant change in consumer
behavior that is happening because of the growth of e-commerce,
mobile payments, etc.
EXHIBIT 24
Public Markets May Not Always Be the Appropriate
Vehicle to Play Indonesia’s Compelling GDP-per-Capita
Story
35.7%
15.7%
15.5%
14.6%
5.0%
3.8%
3.4%
2.3%
2.2%
1.8%
0.0%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40%
Financials
Telecom
Cons. Disc.
Staples
Energy
REITs
Materials
Industrials
Healthcare
Utilities
Tech
MSCI Indonesia Equity Sector Weights
Data as at April 30, 2017. Source: MSCI, Factset.
EXHIBIT 25
MSCI Indonesia Index Has Zero Exposure to Tech vs. a
Nearly 25% for MSCI EM Index
11.7pp
10.1pp
7.6pp
5.0pp
1.2pp
-0.2pp
-1.0pp
-2.3pp
-3.6pp
-3.9pp
-24.5pp
-30% -20% -10% 0% 10% 20%
Financials
Telecom
Staples
Cons. Disc.
REITs
Healthcare
Utilities
Energy
Industrials
Materials
Tech
MSCI Indonesia vs. MSCI EM Equity Sector Weights
Data as at April 30, 2017. Source: MSCI, Factset.
“
We expect the Indonesian Public
Equity index to outperform many
of its more prominent EM peers
during the next few years.
“
12. 12 KKR INSIGHTS: GLOBAL MACRO TRENDS
Without question, the growth opportunity for both local and for-
eign firms with technology industry expertise is significant. Indeed,
Indonesia’s Internet penetration significantly lags behind its peers in
Asia, with just 22 Internet users per 100 people vs. 50 users per 100
people in China and 90 users per 100 people in Korea. Meanwhile,
while mobile payments are growing in favor, Indonesia’s e-commerce
efforts appear much more nascent than what we see in more ’ma-
ture’ EM economies such as China.
EXHIBIT 26
Indonesia Lags Its Asia Pacific Peers in Internet and
Broadband Usage
1 1
9
20
8 12 12
29 32
40
31
22 26
39
50 53 57 59
85 85
90 93
Indonesia
India
Thailand
China
Vietnam
Mexico
Brazil
Australia
HongKong
Korea
Japan
2015 Broadband and Internet Subscribers (per 100 People)
Broadband Users Internet Users
Data as at October 5, 2016. Source: World Bank, Haver Analytics.
EXHIBIT 27
Indonesia Trails Many EM Economies in the Ease of
Doing Business
2
4
8
23
46
78
82
91
99
130
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140
Singapore
Hong Kong
U.S.
Malaysia
Thailand
China
Vietnam
Indonesia
Philippines
India
Ease of Doing Business Index
1 = Most Business Friendly Regulations; 189=Worst
Data as at April 19, 2017. Source: World Bank, Haver Analytics.
Unlike our last visit, however, there are now large and growing local
technology companies as well as mobile payment players that need
access to capital. Beyond capital, the thought leaders overseeing
these companies are seeking counsel around key business priorities,
including scaling, operations, and employee incentives. Importantly,
many of the local operators with whom we met now appear more
receptive to embracing a partnership with private equity investors.
Indeed, many of the second generation family members of these
businesses are Western-educated and have had exposure to the
value that private equity investing can offer on financial, operational,
and governance issues.
Importantly, though, this viewpoint is not restricted to just the
technology sector. In fact, we left Jakarta — amongst other places
we visited — believing strongly that there are several other growth
industries where private equity can actually play a more meaning-
ful role in attractive sectors that are not well represented in the
traditional public market indexes. Indeed, across health services,
wellness, entertainment, nourishment, education, and even financial
services, we see huge growth in GDP-per-capita, particularly as it
relates to accelerating urbanization trends.
One lingering issue, however, is that Indonesia lags behind other
Asian economies when it comes to the ease of doing business. It is
currently ranked 91, ahead of the Philippines (99) and India (130), but
well behind China (78), Thailand (46), and Malaysia (23). While this
ranking represents an improvement versus some prior years, both
locals and foreigners expressed concerns around permitting, legal
processes, and corruption.
Our bottom line: Similar to what we have seen unfold in major
markets like China and India, we expect private equity to serve as
an important vehicle for investors to actually gain direct exposure to
compelling GDP-per-capita stories during the next three to five years.
Over time, however, as the public markets become deeper and broad-
er (i.e., some of these GDP-per-capita stories do already enjoy pub-
lic listings), these public securities will represent a more competitive
alternative to the notable benefits that direct investing now provides
to foreign investors seeking to access the country’s strong underlying
growth trajectory across several high value-added sectors.
Within Fixed Income, Credit Spreads Appear Tight Relative to His-
tory, Particularly USD Denominated Indonesian Securities With
strong investor appetite for higher yielding EM debt securities of late,
Indonesia’s credit spreads have collapsed in recent months. Indeed,
USD-denominated sovereign bonds, high yield corporate bonds and
investment grade corporate bonds in Indonesia all trade at least one
standard deviation below average relative to US Treasuries1
(Exhibit
28).
1 Spreads are based on Government option-adjusted spread, i.e., comparing
Indonesian bonds to their equivalent duration in US Treasuries. In this case,
average duration is 8.75 years for Indonesia IG and 4.77 years for Indonesia
HY.
13. 13KKR INSIGHTS: GLOBAL MACRO TRENDS
EXHIBIT 28
Indonesian Local Currency Sovereign Debt Still Appears
to Have Room for Spread Compression
Indonesia IG Corporate
Indonesia HY Corporate
Indonesia Sovereign (USD)
Indonesia Sovereign (LDM)
US High Yield
Leveraged Loan
Comparable Spread Products, Basis Points
Max/Min Based on Trailing 5 Years
212
307
167
507
416
369
212
307
146
376 739
375
936
447
MaxMin
864336
611386
Data as at May 31, 2017. Source: Bloomberg, BofAML Bond Indices.
Against this backdrop, it appears that Indonesian local currency
sovereign debt is the only sector to still offer attractive “carry” and
some room for spread compression (Exhibit 28). Now that S&P has
upgraded Indonesia’s sovereign debt to BBB-, its local bonds are
some of the highest yielding investment grade securities in the world.
Moreover, with an investment grade rating from all three rating agen-
cies (Moody’s upgraded in 2012, Fitch in 2011), Indonesia sovereign
debt could see additional sources of inflows, particularly from yield
hungry Japanese institutional investors. Indeed, Japanese allocation
to Indonesia’s local currency bond market is still very small at $2.2
billion, compared to Mexico at $17 billion. Hence, the investment bank
Goldman Sachs estimates $5 billion of potential inflows into Indonesia
from Japan over the next year on the back of the S&P upgrade.
Another point that global asset allocators must consider is that
Indonesia local bonds appear quite attractive relative to their eq-
uity counterparts. One can see this in Exhibit 30. Given Indonesia’s
strong macro backdrop, we find this arbitrage particularly compel-
ling. Indeed, we generally prefer local debt in countries like India and
Indonesia, both of which have strong nominal growth, compelling
demographics, and less mature fixed income markets.
EXHIBIT 29
While Indonesia’s Local Sovereigns Are Trading at
the Tightest Level Since October 2013 Relative to U.S.
Treasuries, the 7.0% Yield Remains High in Absolute
Terms
Indonesia 7.0%
-1% 1% 3% 5% 7% 9% 11%
Brazil
Russia
Mexico
India
Italy
Spain
Malaysia
US
Korea
UK
Australia
Singapore
Canada
Germany
10-year Government Bond Yield, %
AAA
AA and A
BBB
BB
Data as at May 31, 2017. Source: Bloomberg.
EXHIBIT 30
Equity Earnings Yields in Indonesia Are Still Lower Than
Bond Yields
-1.0%
-3% -1% 1% 3% 5% 7% 9%
South Africa
India
Mexico
Brazil
Indonesia
Philippines
Turkey
Colombia
Malaysia
Chile
Peru
Thailand
China
Poland
Hungary
Russia
Earnings Yield Less Local Currency Sovereign Bond Yield, %
Credit looks relatively
inexpensive vs Equities
Equities look relatively
inexpensive vs Credit
Note: 12 month forward earnigs yield of MSCI Indices vs. JPM GBI-EM
YTM. Data as at May 31, 2017. Source: Bloomberg.
“
Based on a continued improvement
in fundamentals across the
Indonesian macro and micro
landscapes, we expect the
valuation differential between the
country and the rest of its EM peers
to narrow in the coming quarters.
“
14. 14 KKR INSIGHTS: GLOBAL MACRO TRENDS
Private Credit Is Also Emerging as an Interesting Opportunity in In-
donesia While not as sizeable as what we are seeing across the U.S.
and Europe, there is a small but growing opportunity in performing
private credit in Indonesia, particularly as credit growth through the
traditional banking channel has slowed significantly. Not surprisingly,
many of the companies seeking credit solutions from non-traditional
sources are skewed to the mid-size market, though we did speak
with several large, successful entrepreneurs who prefer private
credit solutions versus more vanilla bank offerings.
The pullback in local bank lending is a combination of tighter bank-
ing regulation, weak bank balance sheets, limited deposit growth,
and a preference for lending to large corporations. Foreign banks
too have pulled back, with loans as a percentage of GDP falling to
13% in March 2017 from 16% in September 2015. Our on the ground
conversations also reminded us that there have essentially been
no bond offerings in the $100-$200 million range since the Great
Financial Crisis, and as such, private credit mandates have increas-
ingly emerged as the ‘go to’ solution in this area of the market versus
a more traditional bond offering.
EXHIBIT 31
Foreign Banks Have Pulled Back From Indonesia
Sep-15
16%
Mar-17
13%
10%
11%
12%
13%
14%
15%
16%
Mar-10
Sep-10
Mar-11
Sep-11
Mar-12
Sep-12
Mar-13
Sep-13
Mar-14
Sep-14
Mar-15
Sep-15
Mar-16
Sep-16
Mar-17
Loans By Foreign/Joint Venture Banksin Indonesia as a % of GDP
Data as at March 31, 2017. Source: Badan Pusat Statistik, Haver
Analytics.
The key, of course, is to get compensated for the risk taken for
extending non-traditional corporate credit in an emerging market.
So, how should one think about absolute and relative returns for
investors who may want to pursue these opportunities across Asia?
In India, for example, performing private credit earns a rupee yield
of 10-12%, while structured loans earn closer to a 14-18% local
coupon (Exhibit 32). As a result, when one adjusts for the hedging
cost against potential depreciation (i.e., approximately four percent),
the USD returns on Indian hedged performing private credit of six
to eight percent still appear attractive versus U.S. Investment Grade
yields of just 3.8%. So too is the Indian hedged structured credit
yield of 11-13%.
As we show in Exhibit 32, gross yields in Indonesia appear equally as
compelling. A key difference, however, is that the credit is transacted
in USD in Indonesia as opposed to local currency in India. Given the
nascent nature of the private credit business in Indonesia, foreign in-
vestors are still less comfortable taking both currency risk and credit
risk. Over time, though, we expect – similar to what we have seen in
other EM countries – for returns to move to 100% local currency.
EXHIBIT 32
Indonesian Private Credit Is Another Interesting Play
on Our Illiquidity Premium Thesis. Importantly, Many
Transactions in Indonesia Provide Investors With Dollar-
Based Structures
0.0
0.4
2.3
3.6
3.8
3.8
4.2
5.1
5–8
6.1
6.2
6.9
7.1
8.5
9–12
10–12
12.0
14–18
15–18
Japan: Govt Bond 10 Yr.
Germany: Govt Bond 10 Yr.
US: Govt Bond 10 Yr.
China: Gov 10 Yr.
Indonesia: USD Govt 10 Yr.
US: Investment Grade
US: Bank Loans
Europe: Bank Loans
Indonesia: Perf. USD Bank Loans
EM High Yield
US High Yield
India: Govt Bond 10 Yr.
Indonesia: Govt Bond 10 Yr.
US: Direct Lending (Unlevered)
Indonesia: Perf. IDR Bank Loans
India: Perf. INR Bank Loans
Mezzanine (Unlevered)
India: High Yld INR Loans
Indonesia: Struct.USD Loans
Yields as at May 5, 2017, %
Data as at May 5, 2017Source: Bloomberg, KKR Estimates.
“
Just consider that the MSCI
Indonesia index has a zero
weighting to technology,
compared to nearly 25% for the
aggregate MSCI EM equity
index. As a result, there are
essentially no public securities
to gain access to the significant
change in consumer behavior
that is happening because of the
growth of e-commerce, mobile
payments, etc.
“
15. 15KKR INSIGHTS: GLOBAL MACRO TRENDS
EXHIBIT 33
Indonesia Needs to Make Sure That Real Rates Do Not
Go Too Low; Otherwise, It Could Subject Itself to Poor
Capital Allocation and/or Capital Flight
Apr-17
0.6
Apr-17
4.2
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
CPI Target 4.0±1
Indonesia: Real Policy Rate (Left)
Indonesia: CPI Y/y, Reverse (Right)
%
Real policy yield should be about 2%
to get inflation within the target range
%
Data as at April 30, 2017. Source: Bank Indonesia, Bloomberg, Haver
Analytics.
CONCLUSION:
We left Indonesia feeling better about the macro backdrop. Indeed,
unlike in past trips, we are now confident stating that we think that
Indonesia is now effectively harnessing its long-term potential into
near-term economic and investment realities. In particular, President
Widodo’s commitment to infrastructure development is beginning to
yield results, and we feel that the central bank is now more aware of
the threats that Indonesia faces from a structurally slowing China as
well as a Federal Reserve committed to raising interest rates.
Importantly, the economy is not growing so fast that the government
can turn a blind eye towards some of the ongoing structural reform
that is still needed. Also, while China’s economy has bounced of late,
we – and the CEOs with whom we spoke – do not believe that it is
again on a sustained upward trajectory. This viewpoint is significant
as China accounts for one-third of global growth (and nearly 60-70%
if one includes its trading partners).
Within Indonesia, though, the macro alone is not enough to ensure
success; patience is required. Indeed, we hold strongly to our view
that operators in the private markets need to embrace at least a
five-to-seven year view to be successful. Local partnerships are also
critical, and we think that one will likely need to be active across real
estate, private equity, and private credit to justify the effort as Indo-
nesia remains a tough place to do business.
In terms of key themes, we remain structurally bullish on GDP-per-
capita stories across a variety of industries within Indonesia. In our
view, the macro backdrop represents a significant opportunity for
private equity. However, we fully acknowledge that valuations are
currently expensive in many segments, and as such, a long-term
focus is warranted. The good news, though, is that valuations and
sentiment can change quickly in emerging markets.
The investment community must also appreciate that the macroeco-
nomic landscape in Indonesia remains dynamic, as there are impor-
tant changes occurring underneath the surface that warrant investor
attention. For example, we met with a variety of executives who
confirmed that several large industries, including retail, payments,
and logistics, are all transitioning towards more of an e-commerce
direction. In our view, these changes represent important opportuni-
ties to ‘get ahead of the puck.’ On the other hand, the risk of disinter-
mediation and/or displacement across many of these industries has
increased too, raising the risk of capital impairment if an investor is
not fully up to speed on these important changes.
Where do we go from here and what would we like to see to sustain
the country’s current momentum? First, continued progress on the
reform front is a prerequisite for achieving higher productivity and
potential GDP growth. In order to facilitate this transition, however,
the political backdrop must remain constant through elections in
2019. Second, we would need to see continued commitment to keep
inflation under control. In our view, this initiative will entail posi-
tive real rates, restraint on government consumption spending (e.g.,
government wages, fuel and food subsidies), and continued focus
on addressing supply side constraints (i.e., infrastructure). Finally,
as most economies are credit and external capital driven, there is a
risk of capital flight if the European Central Bank, the Bank of Japan
or the Federal Reserve tightens monetary policy sharply or if anti-
corruption policies cause a sudden rush of domestic capital flight. As
such, we would like to see Indonesia continue to diversify somewhat
its large base of foreigners who own its bonds, given what we be-
lieve is an attractive cost of capital at the moment.
To be sure, there are still risks, but our research and our visits lead
us to conclude that Southeast Asia, Indonesia in particular, may be
one of the areas where investors are not fully up to speed on the
compelling macro backdrop. In our view, therein lies the opportunity.
“
Unlike in past trips, we are now
confident stating that we think
that Indonesia is now effectively
harnessing its long-term potential
into near-term economic and
investment realities.
“
16. www.kkr.com
Important Information
References to “we”, “us,” and “our” refer to Mr. McVey
and/or KKR’s Global Macro and Asset Allocation team, as
context requires, and not of KKR. The views expressed
reflect the current views of Mr. McVey as of the date
hereof and neither Mr. McVey nor KKR undertakes
to advise you of any changes in the views expressed
herein. Opinions or statements regarding financial
market trends are based on current market conditions
and are subject to change without notice. References to
a target portfolio and allocations of such a portfolio refer
to a hypothetical allocation of assets and not an actual
portfolio. The views expressed herein and discussion of
any target portfolio or allocations may not be reflected
in the strategies and products that KKR offers or invests,
including strategies and products to which Mr. McVey
provides investment advice to or on behalf of KKR. It
should not be assumed that Mr. McVey has made or will
make investment recommendations in the future that are
consistent with the views expressed herein, or use any
or all of the techniques or methods of analysis described
herein in managing client or proprietary accounts. Fur-
ther, Mr. McVey may make investment recommendations
and KKR and its affiliates may have positions (long or
short) or engage in securities transactions that are not
consistent with the information and views expressed in
this document.
The views expressed in this publication are the personal
views of Henry McVey of Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co.
L.P. (together with its affiliates, “KKR”) and do not nec-
essarily reflect the views of KKR itself or any investment
professional at KKR. This document is not research and
should not be treated as research. This document does
not represent valuation judgments with respect to any
financial instrument, issuer, security or sector that may
be described or referenced herein and does not repre-
sent a formal or official view of KKR. This document is
not intended to, and does not, relate specifically to any
investment strategy or product that KKR offers. It is be-
ing provided merely to provide a framework to assist in
the implementation of an investor’s own analysis and an
investor’s own views on the topic discussed herein.
This publication has been prepared solely for informa-
tional purposes. The information contained herein is
only as current as of the date indicated, and may be
superseded by subsequent market events or for other
reasons. Charts and graphs provided herein are for
illustrative purposes only. The information in this docu-
ment has been developed internally and/or obtained
from sources believed to be reliable; however, neither
KKR nor Mr. McVey guarantees the accuracy, adequacy
or completeness of such information. Nothing contained
herein constitutes investment, legal, tax or other advice
nor is it to be relied on in making an investment or other
decision.
There can be no assurance that an investment strategy
will be successful. Historic market trends are not reliable
indicators of actual future market behavior or future per-
formance of any particular investment which may differ
materially, and should not be relied upon as such. Target
allocations contained herein are subject to change.
There is no assurance that the target allocations will
be achieved, and actual allocations may be significantly
different than that shown here. This publication should
not be viewed as a current or past recommendation or a
solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any securities or to
adopt any investment strategy.
The information in this publication may contain projec-
tions or other forward‐looking statements regarding
future events, targets, forecasts or expectations regard-
ing the strategies described herein, and is only current
as of the date indicated. There is no assurance that such
events or targets will be achieved, and may be signifi-
cantly different from that shown here. The information in
this document, including statements concerning financial
market trends, is based on current market conditions,
which will fluctuate and may be superseded by subse-
quent market events or for other reasons. Performance
of all cited indices is calculated on a total return basis
with dividends reinvested. The indices do not include
any expenses, fees or charges and are unmanaged and
should not be considered investments.
The investment strategy and themes discussed herein
may be unsuitable for investors depending on their spe-
cific investment objectives and financial situation. Please
note that changes in the rate of exchange of a currency
may affect the value, price or income of an investment
adversely.
Neither KKR nor Mr. McVey assumes any duty to, nor
undertakes to update forward looking statements. No
representation or warranty, express or implied, is made
or given by or on behalf of KKR, Mr. McVey or any other
person as to the accuracy and completeness or fairness
of the information contained in this publication and
no responsibility or liability is accepted for any such
information. By accepting this document, the recipient
acknowledges its understanding and acceptance of the
foregoing statement.
The MSCI sourced information in this document is the
exclusive property of MSCI Inc. (MSCI). MSCI makes no
express or implied warranties or representations and
shall have no liability whatsoever with respect to any
MSCI data contained herein. The MSCI data may not be
further redistributed or used as a basis for other indices
or any securities or financial products. This report is not
approved, reviewed or produced by MSCI.