SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Competitiveness of India Cities
INDIA IS THRIVING – NOW AND WILL IN FUTURE
                   % contribution in World’s GDP

                                                                                         12
                                       2010
                                              European
                       Others                  Union
                        30%                                                                                                            9.82
                                                26%                                      10                             9.32                         9.10
                                                                                                                                                                 8.81
                                                                                                           8.37
                                                                                                                                9.27
                                                United States
                      Japan       China                                                  8




                                                                 GDP growth (annual %)
         India                                      23%                                                                                                                    7.80
          3%           9%          9%                                                                               8.28


                                                                                         6       5.22
                                                                                                                                                                                 5.30

                             2030 Projection                                             4
                                                                                                                                              4.93

                                          European                                            4.03
                    Others                 Union                                                        3.77
                     35%                    18%
                                                 United States                           2
                                                     16%
                     India
                              Japan           China
                      4%
                               9%              18%
                                                                                         0




                                                                                                                                            *value for 2012 and 2011 is for Q1




                                                                                                           Source:- World Bank and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis


Institute for Competitiveness, India
MAIN CONTRIBUTORS IN INDIA’S GROWTH

                                                          Mumbai, Pune


                                                800,000

                                                700,000
    2010-11 nominal GDP (in crores of rupees)




                                                                   Lucknow, Kanpur
                                                600,000
                                                                         Chennai     Hyderabad   Ahmedabad, Surat
                                                500,000
                                                                                                      Kolkata
                                                400,000                                                         Bengaluru
                                                                                                                                            Thiruvananthapuram
                                                                                                                            Jaipur
                                                300,000

                                                200,000

                                                100,000

                                                     0




                                                                                                                      Source:- RBI and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis


Institute for Competitiveness, India
TREND IN POPULATION SIZE AND GROWTH RATE (1901-2011)

                                 1800                                                                                                                                                30
                                                                                                                                                                       1650.62
                                 1600                                                             24.8        24.66                                          1494.63                 25
                                                                                                                            23.85
                                 1400                                               21.51                                                     1338.64
                                                                                                                                      21.34
                                                                                                                                       1210.19                                       20




                                                                                                                                                                                           Decadal Growth Rate (in %)
                                 1200
      Population (in millions)




                                                                                                                              1028.74       17.64
                                                                      14.22                                                                                                          15
                                 1000
                                                                                 13.31                              846.42
                                                               11
                                 800                                                                                                                                                 10
                                                                                                           683.33

                                 600           5.75                                               548.16
                                                                                        439.23                                                                                       5
                                 400                                           361.09
                                                                      318.66
                                        0.1                 278.98
                                        238.4 252.09 251.32
                                                                                                                                                                                     0
                                 200                   -0.03


                                   0                                                                                                                                                 -5
                                        1901   1911   1921     1931   1941     1951      1961      1971     1981      1991      2001      2011      2021       2031      2041

                                                                       Population (in millions)            Decadal Growth rate (in %)


                                                                                                                      Source:- Government of India Census and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis


Institute for Competitiveness, India
THE RURAL-URBAN DIVIDE

         100%

           90%

           80%

           70%
                                                                                                                                     71.5          68.8
                                                                                                         76.7          74.3
           60%                                                       82.7      82.1        80.1
                       89.2            89.7   88.9    88    86.2
           50%

           40%

           30%

           20%
                                                                                                                                    28.5          31.2
                                                                                                                                                  31.2
                                                                                                                      25.7
                                                                                                                      25.7          28.5
           10%                                                                                          23.3
                                                                                                        23.3
                                                                     17.3     17.9
                                                                              17.9        19.9
                                                                                          19.9
                       10.8         10.3      11.1    12    13.8     17.3
                      10.8         10.3       11.1   12     13.8
            0%
                      1901         1911       1921   1931   1941     1951     1961        1971          1981          1991          2001          2011

                                                                   Rural    Urban




                                                                                      Source:- Government of India Census and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis


Institute for Competitiveness, India
INCREASE IN NUMBER OF TOWNS, UAS AND VILLAGES (1971-2011)

                              Towns (in Numbers)                                                                                           UAs (in Numbers)
                    8000                                                    7935                                      400                                    381            382            384
  Number of Towns




                                                                                                      Number of UAs
                    6000                                                                                              300                       276
                                         4689                      5161                                                            231
                                  4029
                    4000   2921                                                                                       200
                    2000                                                                                               100
                       0                                                                                                 0
                           1971   1981                                                                                           1971
                                         1991                                                                                                 1981
                                                                  2001                                                                                     1991
                                                                           2011                                                                                          2001
                                                                                                                                                                                        2011

                                                                                 Villages (in Numbers)

                                                               620000
                                          Number of Villages




                                                                                                                                    608789
                                                               600000                                                 593732
                                                               580000                        579688
                                                                          556561    556014
                                                               560000
                                                               540000
                                                               520000
                                                                          1971
                                                                                   1981
                                                                                             1991
                                                                                                                      2001
                                                                                                                                    2011
*UAs = Urban Agglomerations                                                                                             Source:- Government of India Census and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis


Institute for Competitiveness, India
URBANIZATION: SIGN OF A DEVELOPING EOCONOMY

      90

      80

      70                                                                                                                                                                 74
                                                                                                                                     64.8
      60
                                                                                                          52.21
      50
                                                                                 43.57
      40
                                                        34.45

      30                               28.3

                   18.33
      20

      10

        0
                     1951                1961                 1971                    1981                     1991                     2001                     2011

                            Degree of Urbanization                                         Literacy Rates (%)

                            Registered Motor Vehicles (No.)                                Mobile Cellular Subscription (per 100 people)


                                                         Source:- Government of India Census, World Bank, Road Transport Year Book& Figure and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis


Institute for Competitiveness, India
INDIAN STATES WITH HIGH GROWTH HAVE HIGH URBANIZATION RATE
                                  120.00


                                                                Delhi


                                  100.00




                                   80.00


                                               Goa
                                                                                                                                                Maharashtra
                                                                                           Tamil Nadu
      Urbanization level (in %)




                                   60.00                          Kerala
                                       Mizoram                                               Gujarat
                                                                               Karnataka
                                                                Punjab                      Andhra Pradesh
                                                                  Haryana                  West Bengal

                                   40.00   Uttarakhand     Madhya Pradesh                               Uttar Pradesh
                                                                   Rajasthan
                                        Manipur
                                       Jammu & Kashmir
                                       Nagaland Jharkhand
                                         Tripura   Chhattisgarh
                                        Sikkim
                                   Arunachal Pradesh        Orissa
                                       Meghalaya
                                                   Assam     Bihar
                                   20.00
                                        Himachal Pradesh




                                    0.00
-200000                                    0                  200000                       400000                   600000             800000                 1000000   1200000



                                  -20.00                                                                          GDP (Dec-11) in Rs. Crore



Institute for Competitiveness, India
DISTRIBUTION OF TOWNS BY SIZE CLASS

               Cities
                                       Population            1951    1961   1971           1981                1991              2001             2011
           Classification
                  Class I                > 1,00,000           76     102    148              218                 300               393

                 Class II              50,000-1,00,000        91     129    173              270                 345               401

                 Class III             20,000-50,000          327    437    558              743                 947              1151

                 Class IV              10,000-20,000          608    719    827             1059                1167              1344

                 Class V                5,000-10,000         1124    711    623              758                 740               888

                 Class VI                  < 5,000            567    172    147              253                 197               191



                                                 Greater Mumbai UA
                                                                                            Class I UAs/Towns                       468
                                                      (12.05%)
                                                                                            Million plus UAs/Towns                  53
                                                         Delhi UA                           Mega Cities                             3
                                                         (26.69%)

                                                       Kolkata UA
                                                        (6.87%)


                                                                                   Source:- Government of India Census and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis


Institute for Competitiveness, India
SNAPSHOT OF URBAN INDIA IN 2011




                                                              Cities Size Class By Population

                                                                               10 - 30 million
                                                                                5 - 10 million
                                                                                1 - 5 million
                                                                               0.1 – 1 million




                                       Source:- India Urban Conference 2011: Evidence & Experience - IIHS


Institute for Competitiveness, India
ENHANCING THE PROSPERITY OF URBAN INDIA via COMPETITIVENESS

        Competitiveness is the productivity with which a region utilizes its human, capital, and natural resources
        Productivity determines wages and the standard of living – Productivity growth determines sustainable economic growth
        It is not what industries a nation competes in that matters for prosperity, but how productively it competes in those industries
        Productivity in an economy depends on a combination of domestic and foreign firms
        Innovation in products and processes is necessary to drive productivity growth




        Only productive businesses can create wealth and jobs States compete to offer the most productive environment for business
        The public and private sectors play different but interrelated roles in creating a productive economy




                                                   Leading to the prosperity of the region




Institute for Competitiveness, India
INFLUENCES ON COMPETITIVENESS

                                         Multiple Geographic Levels

                                               WORLD ECONOMY



                                           BROAD ECONOMIC AREAS



                                       GROUP OF NEIGHBOURING NATIONS



                                                  NATIONS



                                              STATES, PROVINCES



                                       METROPOLITAN AREAS, RURAL AREAS [Our   Focus]




                                                                                Source:- Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness


Institute for Competitiveness, India
DRIVERS OF COMPETITIVENESS




                 Quality of overall business   Concentration of resources   Policy Coordination among
                                                                                 Multiple Levels of
                       environment                 and urban growth
                                                                             Geography/Government




Institute for Competitiveness, India
MEASURING COMPETITIVENESS: THE FRAMEWORK

                                                                          Context for Firm
                                                                           Strategy and
                                                                              Rivalry



                                                       •       Local rules and incentives that encourage
                                                               investment and productivity .
                                                               - E.g. performance based salaries,
                                                                  incentives for capital investments,
                                                                  intellectual property protection
                            Factor                                                                                      Demand
                                                       •       Vigorous local competition i.e.,
                          Conditions                           - Openness to foreign and local                         Conditions
                                                                 competition
                                                               - Sophistication of company operations

      Access to high quality business inputs i.e.,                                                               Sophisticated and demanding local
       - Natural endowments                                                                                      customers and needs e.g.,
       - Human resources                                                                                         - Strict quality, safety, and environmental
       - Capital availability                                                                                    standards
       - Physical infrastructure                                                                                 – Consumer protection laws
       - Administrative infrastructure                                                                           – Government procurement of
       - Information infrastructure                                          Related and                         advanced technology
       - Scientific and technological infrastructure                         Supporting                           – Early demand for products and
                                                                                                                 Services.
                                                                              Industries

                                                           •    Local availability of suppliers and supporting
                                                                industries
                                                           •    Presence of clusters instead of isolated firms




Institute for Competitiveness, India
HIERARCHY OF CITY COMPETITIVENESS INDEX

                                                    Overall Competitiveness




                      Factor                 Demand                            Context for Strategy            Related &
                    Conditions              Conditions                              & Rivalry              Supporting Industry


               1. Financial            1. Demographics                         1. Competition              1. Supplier
               2. Physical             2. Income Distribution                      Intensity & Diversity     Sophistication
               3. Communication          and Spending                              of Firms                2. Institutional Support
               4. Administrative         Pattern                               2. Business Incentives
               5. Human Capacity
               6. Innovation




                                                           Nearly 200 Indicators




Institute for Competitiveness, India
CITIES THAT WE STUDY

                                                     Srinagar
                                                 Jammu
                                                            Shimla
                                                  Amritsar
                                                 Ludhiana        Dehradun
                                                       Chandigarh
                                                   FaridabadDelhi Meerut
                                                     Gurgaon
                                                                Noida
                                                                Agra
                                                       Jaipur        Kanpur
                                                                       Lucknow                            Guwahati
                                                                         Allahabad      Patna
                                                                             Varanasi
                                                                                                Asansol
                                                            Jabalpur                       Dhanbad
                                                                Bhopal                Ranchi Kolkata
                                        Ahmedabad                        Indore        Jamshedpur
                                             Vadodara                        Raipur
                                       Rajkot
                                              Surat
                                                            Nagpur                Bhubaneswar
                                                   Nashik
                                                Mumbai
                                                    Pune
                                                                            Vishakhapatnam
                                                                Hyderabad
                                                                     Vijayawada



                                                          Bengaluru
                                                       Mysore       Chennai
                                                        Coimbatore Puducherry
                                                Kozhikod
                                                e           Madurai
                                                      Kochi
                                         Thiruvananthapuram




Institute for Competitiveness, India
EVERY CITY HAS A DIFFERENT STORY

     Crucial to understand each city as what is right for one city will not necessarily be right for the other.



                                                             “Mega Cities”                           “Million plus Cities”
     Variables                                      DELHI              KOLKATA                 JAMSHEDPUR             KOCHI

     Population                                    16753235            4486679                    2291032            3279860
     No. of Branches of Commercial Banks             2177               1121                         179                634

     Literacy Rate: Female                           80.93              84.98                       67.33              94.27

     No. of GSM users (per lakh)                      265                145                         11                 19
     Molestation Incidence                            550                226                          6                 67

     Ownership of consumer durable-
                                                      23                 25                          19                 31
     Home Theater
     Share of total passenger traffic
                                                     21.8                15.1                        0.7                1.1
     (airways)
     Consumer Price Index for Industrial
                                                      169                178                        103*                158
     Workers
     Starting a business cost (% per capita
                                                     51.1                39.6                       51.5               47.2
     income)




Institute for Competitiveness, India
LOOK AT THE ENTIRE PICTURE
            For instance, Mumbai


                                  Weak Areas                                                                            Strong Areas




                                                          20925                                  Paying Taxes (Time)                   271
                          Population density



             Total-corruption cases registered   1228                        Work Force Participation Rate (per 1000)                        434
Variables




                                                   9093




                                                                          Variables
                 Number of accidental deaths                                                                                 94.28
                                                                                                 Literacy rate: Males


                            Number of slums                       61300
                                                                                                  Media Reach-Press          98.8




Institute for Competitiveness, India
A GLIMPSE: CITY COMPETITIVENESS RANK
     First 25 Cities

                                       Overall Competitiveness                                            Context for Firm    Related & Supporting
        Rank                City                                 Factor Conditions   Demand Conditions
                                                Score                                                    Strategy & Rivalry        Industries

          1       Delhi                        69.732                    1                   1                   1                    10
          2       Mumbai                       67.856                    2                   2                   2                    4
          3       Chennai                      62.323                    4                   5                   5                    2
          4       Hyderabad                    61.782                    3                  12                   7                    1
          5       Kolkata                      61.464                    6                  11                   6                    3
          6       Gurgaon                      61.167                    7                   7                   4                    23
          7       Bengaluru                    61.100                    5                   3                   8                    18
          8       Noida                        60.406                    9                  38                   3                    5
          9       Pune                         59.854                    8                   4                   9                    8
         10       Ahmedabad                    58.036                   15                   8                  15                    7
         11       Nagpur                       56.942                   17                  15                  12                    14
         12       Chandigarh                   56.842                   10                  17                  25                    15
         13       Jaipur                       56.263                   18                   6                  19                    26
         14       Coimbatore                   55.955                   29                  45                  10                    6
         15       Kochi                        55.884                   28                  23                  14                    11
         16       Surat                        55.726                   26                  10                  17                    20
         17       Nashik                       55.651                   33                   9                  21                    9
         18       Indore                       55.637                   11                  35                  22                    37
         19       Thiruvananthapuram           55.434                   22                  18                  18                    28
         20       Kozhikode                    55.212                   35                  19                  11                    32
         21       Mysore                       55.118                   12                  39                  30                    33
         22       Bhubaneswar                  54.642                   13                  42                  27                    43
         23       Vadodara                     54.627                   32                  25                  16                    25
         24       Rajkot                       54.607                   36                  14                  20                    27
         25       Lucknow                      54.584                   23                  16                  39                    22


Institute for Competitiveness, India
A GLIMPSE: CITY COMPETITIVENESS RANK

   Next set of 25 Cities

                                       Overall Competitiveness                                           Context for Firm Strategy   Related & Supporting
     Rank                City                                    Factor Conditions   Demand Conditions
                                                Score                                                           & Rivalry                 Industries
       26       Madurai                        54.570                   38                  36                      13                       24
       27       Bhopal                         54.322                   16                  40                      28                       40
       28       Kanpur                         54.318                   19                  49                      38                       12
       29       Faridabad                      54.097                   20                  32                      36                       34
       30       Ludhiana                       54.022                   27                  28                      23                       42
       31       Vijayawada                     53.964                   30                  20                      32                       30
       32       Guwahati                       53.961                   14                  46                      31                       46
       33       Raipur                         53.849                   25                  31                      26                       38
       34       Vishakhapatnam                 53.741                   34                  22                      33                       31
       35       Patna                          53.580                   37                  21                      42                       21
       36       Jabalpur                       53.249                   24                  50                      34                       35
       37       Agra                           53.157                   39                  29                      46                       16
       38       Varanasi                       53.039                   45                  41                      37                       13
       39       Meerut                         52.975                   43                  34                      40                       17
       40       Puducherry                     52.905                   42                  27                      29                       39
       41       Asansol                        52.813                   47                  13                      35                       36
       42       Dehradun                       52.725                   31                  30                      47                       41
       43       Ranchi                         52.575                   40                  33                      41                       29
       44       Allahabad                      52.573                   46                  26                      48                       19
       45       Shimla                         52.295                   21                  43                      43                       49
       46       Amritsar                       52.181                   41                  24                      24                       47
       47       Jammu                          50.621                   44                  47                      49                       48
       48       Jamshedpur                     50.475                   49                  44                      44                       44
       49       Dhanbad                        49.829                   50                  48                      45                       45
       50       Srinagar                       49.732                   48                  37                      50                       50



Institute for Competitiveness, India
TOTAL POPULATION VERSUS COMPETITIVENESS
                   18000000
                                                                                                                                              Del

                   16000000



                   14000000


                                                                                                                               Mum
                   12000000
                                                                                                                         y = 49162x - 2E+07
                                                                                                                              R² = 0.456
Total Populaiton




                   10000000                                                                         Ben
                                                                                             Pun


                    8000000                             Asa
                                                                            Jai        Ahm
                                                                      Sur
                    6000000                       All           Pat
                                                                          Nas
                                                             Vij Luc
                                                               Kan
                                                       Agr Vis Vad                                    Kol Che
                                                           Rai                   Nag
                                                      Var        Raj
                    4000000                           Mee Lud            Coi
                                                                     ThiKoc
                                                                       Ind
                                                                Mad Koz
                                                                    Mys                                    Hyd
                                  Dha            Ran Jab Bho
                                        Jam   Amr
                    2000000                                 Far Bhu
                                  Sri           Deh                           Cha             Noi    Gur
                                          Jam
                                                       Pud Guw
                                                  Shi
                         0

                          48.00                         53.00                      58.00                         63.00          68.00
                                                                        Microeconomic Competitiveness Score



     Institute for Competitiveness, India
TEACHERS IN GOVERNMENT SCHOOL VERSUS COMPETITIVENESS
                                9000
                                                           All            Vis
                                8000

                                                                                                                   Pun
                                                                   Agr
                                7000                                                         Nas                            Kol

                                                                                Guw
                                                                                Kan
Teachers in Government School




                                6000                                      Pat                                                                                    Del
                                                                   Var            Luc          Jai
                                                                            Vij
                                5000
                                                                  Mee
                                                                   Jab
                                                                                  Vad      Ind
                                4000                                       Lud               Coi
                                                                                                     Cha                                       y = -26.06x + 5060.
                                                          Ran
                                                            Shi
                                                        Amr                                            Nag                                          R² = 0.001
                                3000       Dha   Jam                            Bho
                                                                                     Mys
                                                                                  Mad Thi                                        Hyd
                                                                                   Bhu
                                2000                                                                                Noi
                                                          Deh                                                                                       Mum
                                                  Jam                                                        Ahm
                                                                           Far          Koz Sur
                                                                                             Koc                           Gur
                                                                                                                                    Che
                                                                 Asa                                                      Ben
                                1000
                                           Sri                     Pud
                                                                                  Raj

                                   0
                                   48.00                          53.00                                    58.00                       63.00         68.00

                                                                                              Microeconomic Competitiveness Score



     Institute for Competitiveness, India
FEMALE LITERACY RATE VERSUS COMPETITIVENESS
                       100


                       95                                                         Koc
                                                                      Koz
                                                                                Thi                                                   y = 1.001x + 20.11
                       90                                                                                                                 R² = 0.232
                                                                                                                        Che
                                                                                                                                           Mum
                                                                                                                 Kol
                                                                    Guw                                        Ben
                       85                                                                   Nag
                                                                                Sur      Cha
Female Literacy Rate




                                                                      Bhu                               Pun                                            Del
                                                                                 Coi              Ahm
                       80                           Pud Lud
                                               Deh
                                                           Kan
                                                             Mad
                                                           Bho                                                  Gur
                                                     Jab     Raj            Ind                                       Hyd
                                        Jam     Shi          Vad
                                                         Far Luc
                       75
                                              Amr                                Nas                     Noi
                                                               Vij
                                                   Asa
                       70                           Var
                                       Jam      Ran                       Mys
                                                    Mee Rai
                                                                                   Jai
                       65        Dha                          Pat
                                 Sri
                                                All
                                                              Vis
                                                       Agr
                       60


                       55
                         48.00                        53.00                                   58.00                           63.00         68.00

                                                                                  Microeconomic Competitiveness Score




Institute for Competitiveness, India
EDUCATION DEVELOPMENT INDEX VERSUS COMPETITIVENESS
                                0.8
                                                                                    Koz Koc
                                                                                     Thi

                                                                          Mad           Coi                                   Che         y = 0.010x + 0.020
                               0.75                                    Lud                      Cha
                                                                                                                                              R² = 0.159
                                                       Amr                                                                                                     Del

                                0.7
                                                                      Far                                             Gur
                                                                   Vis Vad
                                                                     Vij Raj
                                                                            Mys Sur
 Education Development Index




                                                                                                              Pun                              Mum
                                                                                  Nas             Nag Ahm            Ben
                               0.65                            Pud                                                          Hyd
                                                         Shi


                                0.6
                                                        Deh

                                                                                          Jai
                               0.55
                                                          Agr Var
                                                             Mee            Kan
                                                                              Luc
                                          Sri            All                                                   Noi
                                                                    Rai                                                Kol
                                                 Jam          AsaJab Bho    Ind
                                0.5
                                                                        Bhu


                               0.45
                                          Dha   Jam      Ran                Guw
                                                                      Pat

                                0.4
                                  48.00                       53.00                                   58.00                       63.00         68.00
                                                                                         Microeconomic Competitiveness Score




Institute for Competitiveness, India
CHEATING INCIDENCE VERSUS COMPETITIVENESS

                        1420                                                                                                  y = 105.8x - 5342.
                                                                                                                                  R² = 0.283
                                                                                                             Kol

                        1220

                                                                    Bhu
                        1020
   Cheating Incidence




                         820                                       Luc
                                                                          Thi
                                                                                                    Pun
                         620
                                                                                                                   Che
                                                              Kan
                                                             Lud
                         420
                                                              Vij
                                                            Vis       Koz Koc
                                                        Agr
                                               Amr Mee                                                      Gur
                                                       Var Rai                    Nag
                                                                Bho                   Ahm
                         220
                                                 Deh
                                                  Ran
                                                            Pat Guw     IndCoi Cha
                                                  All Jab    Far Mad Sur
                                                                  Vad       Nas
                                   Sri   Jam
                                           Jam       Asa          Raj
                                   Dha                  Pud                                          Noi
                          20
                                                   Shi
                           48.00                     53.00                          58.00                             63.00                        68.00
                                                                                Microeconomic Competitiveness Score



Institute for Competitiveness, India
DECADAL GROWTH RATE VERSUS COMPETITIVENESS
                                      60



                                                                                                                    Noi
                                      50
                                                                                                                          Ben
                                                                                          Sur
    % decadal growth rate (2001-11)




                                      40
                                                                             Rai
                                                                                          Ind
                                                              Deh            Far
                                                                               Bho                                 Pun
                                      30                                                        Jai
                                                                                   Luc                                                        y = 0.392x - 1.341
                                                                      Pud                                                                         R² = 0.014
                                               Sri             Ran
                                                                      Agr Pat                            Ahm                                                   Del
                                                               All           Raj       Nas
                                                                            Mad       Coi
                                      20                          Var                      Cha
                                                                  Mee         Bhu
                                                                        LudGuw
                                                     Jam   Amr     Jab       Vad
                                                                               Mys
                                                                       Vis                    Nag
                                               Dha              Asa
                                                       Jam                 Kan
                                                              Shi       Vij                                                       Che
                                      10                                         Koz                                                               Mum
                                                                                     Koc

                                                                                         Thi
                                                                                                                                Hyd
                                       0
                                       48.00                         53.00                              58.00                         63.00         68.00

                                                                                               Microeconomic Competitiveness Score



Institute for Competitiveness, India
OWNERSHIP OF CONSUMER DURABLES - MOBILE VERSUS COMPETITIVENESS
                                         100.5




                                                     Sri                 Jab              Luc        Jai Cha                    Kol
                                                                      Asa                                                     Ben
                                                                                                                               Gur                            Del
                                          100                     Deh   Shi                      IndNas
                                                            Jam         Pud          Guw
Ownership of Consumer Durables- Mobile




                                                                                   Far                                                            Mum
                                                                                  Vis Bho Mys
                                                                                    Vij Mad
                                                                                      Kan                                             Che
                                                                         All
                                                                                                           Nag
                                                                                                                                                 y = 0.016x + 98.61
                                                                  Amr                     Raj    Sur                                                 R² = 0.019
                                                                                                                       Pun        Hyd
                                          99.5                          Var
                                                                                                                 Ahm
                                                                                          Vad Koz Koc
                                                                                               Thi
                                                     Dha   Jam



                                           99
                                                                        Mee Agr


                                                                                   Rai
                                                                                    Lud            Coi
                                                                    Ran           Pat
                                                                                           Bhu
                                          98.5
                                                                                                                        Noi




                                           98
                                             48.00                        53.00                                58.00                     63.00    68.00

                                                                                                   Microeconomic Competitiveness Score



Institute for Competitiveness, India
THE UNTAPPED ASSET OF INDIA: TIER 2-3 CITIES

      Consists of a pool of opportunities
      Avoids the pitfalls of the megacities
      More people are moving towards them as they are facing scarcity of land in Mega cities
      Each city has its own competitive edge
      Preferred by many people



                                                             Growth of organized retail


                                                       50%

                                                       40%
                                       Growth (in %)




                                                       30%                                    50%

                                                                      35%
                                                       20%

                                                       10%

                                                       0%
                                                               Tier I cities    Tier II and III cities


                                                                                  Source:- Report on “India Boarding” by TCS and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis


Institute for Competitiveness, India
URBANIZATION LEVEL OF TIER 2 CITIES

                         Vishakapatnam                                                   47.51
                              Vijaywada                                            41.01
                                Varanasi                                             43.43
                               Vadodara                                                    49.54
                    Thiruvananthapuram                                                         53.80
                                    Surat                                            43.48
                                  Rajkot                                             43.48
                                   Patna                                             43.48
                                  Nashik                                            42.53
                                 Nagpur                                                                         68.30
                                 Meerut                                                       51.13
                                Maduari                                                               60.64
                               Ludhiana                                                              59.14
                                Lucknow                                                                    66.20
                              Kozhikode                                                                     67.15
                                    Kochi                                                                    68.07
                                 Kanpur                                                                    65.93
                            Jamshedpur                                                            55.55
                                   Jaipur                                                      52.51
                                  Indore                                                                                74.09
                               Dhanbad                                                                58.13
                             Coimbatore                                                                                  75.83
                                  Bhopal                                                                                     80.84
                                 Asansol                                                                       66.93
                                     Agra                                              45.87

                                            0.00   10.00   20.00   30.00   40.00      50.00      60.00        70.00     80.00      90.00

                                                                       Urbanization level (in%)
                                                                                                                 Source:- Census 2011 and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis


Institute for Competitiveness, India
UNTANGLING THE LINKAGES BETWEEN CITY, COMPETITIVENESS & ECONOMIC GROWTH

    More advanced economies are more urbanized economies
    Cities tend to be the only place where companies and individuals find opportunities for successful economic activity
    Rise of cities is seen as an inevitable part of development but also as a policy challenge
    Avoid a political schism between metropolitan and rural regions
    Cities have a different role to play in advanced economies
    From the competitiveness perspective, the policy imperative is crucial for cities as well as for rural regions
    Cities and the rural regions around them should cooperate closely




                                                            The case with Mumbai

     Tried to manage the growth by creating artificial boundaries
     The approach failed and made living conditions worse
     Different policy approach is required that focuses on better public services and land use inside the city
     Competitiveness-oriented policy approach can be used that changes the economic fundamentals of where people live and work




Institute for Competitiveness, India
SECTORWISE TOTAL INVESTMENTS IN PPP PROJECTS IN INDIA : 2011

                                                                          99324.61
                       Urban Development


                                         Roads                                                                   244289.176



                                       Railways       3913.03



                                          Ports                    82402.67



                                 Health Care          1887.2



                                        Energy                       85141.18



                                   Education          1922.47



                                       Airports            19131


                                                  0             50000           100000           150000    200000              250000

                                                                                Project Cost (Rs. Crore)



                                                                                                           Source:- PPP Database and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis


Institute for Competitiveness, India
URBAN INFRASTRUCTURE: TRANSPORTATION IN INDIAN CITIES
 Chaotic situation in most cities except the mega cities where the number of commuters is so high that the transportation seems weak
 Challenges:
    - Vast gaps between demand and supply
    - Poor infrastructure such as insufficient routes and roads
    - Increase in private vehicles which leads to congestion and also slows down the speed of other vehicles such as buses etc. to 10-12 km
    - Leads to environmental pollution
    - Absence of comprehensive parking facilities in the city


                                              Operations of Road Transportation in Major Cities: 2010-11
                    7000                                                                                                                                                     300
                                     278.59         6110
                    6000                                                                                                                                  5771
                                                                                                                                                                             250

                    5000                               205.38               4652
                                                                                                                                                                             200




                                                                                                                                                                                   In km/Bus/Day
        In Number




                    4000
                              3414                                               154.02
                                                                                                           152.71                                              138.66        150
                    3000
                                                                                                                                99.9
                                                                                                                                                                             100
                    2000

                                                                                                     942                        956                                          50
                    1000


                      0                                                                                                                                                      0
                            Chennai               Bengaluru               Mumbai                 Ahmedabad                    Kolkata                     Delhi

                                                              Total Fleet Held            Vehicle Productivity (km/Bus/Day)
                                                                                             Source:- Road Transport and highways Ministry, 2010-11 and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis


Institute for Competitiveness, India
OTHER MODES OF TRANSPORTATION
  •      The other major mode of transportation in cities is Railways
  •      Though it is dominant for the inter city transportation only in cities
  •      Also has a different face in every region such as in
            - Delhi – Metro Rapid Transit System (MRTS) is main lifeline but Local Rails are also present
            - Kolkata – The Underground Metro, The Local Rails and the tram, all are widely used by commuters
            - Mumbai – Local Trains however, metro will be operational after short period, as reported by authorities
            - Bengaluru – The introduction of Metro in the city has change the travelling experience of the commuters

                                         Passengers carried by railways (million passenger-km)

                       South Africa    18865

                               India                                                                                        903465

                              China                                                                          791158

                          Germany              78582

                              Japan                     244235

                      United States    9518

                   United Kingdom         55019




                                                                    In million passenger - km
                                                                                                  Source:- World Bank and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis


Institute for Competitiveness, India
URBAN INFRASTRUCTURE: WATER
                                    0.9                                                                                                                                                                                         14


                                    0.8
                                                                                   12                                                                                                                                           12
   Production/Population (m3/d/c)




                                                   11
                                    0.7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                10




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Water Availability (hours)
                                    0.6
                                                                                                                        0.808         8.3

                                    0.5                                                                                                                                                                                         8
                                                                                                                                                                                           7

                                    0.4                                                                                                                                                                                         6
                                                                                                                                6
                                                             4.5                                                                                      5
                                                                                                5                                                                                                                         4.3
                                    0.3                                                                                                       4
                                                                                                                                                                3.5                                                             4
AVERAGE= 0.244
                                    0.2   2                                                                 3                                                                     2.5              3        0.305
                                                                   1.5     0.332
                                                                                                                                    0.246                                                 0.217                        0.244
                                                                                                                0.75                                 0.267                                                                      2
                                    0.1                                                 0.131       0.286                                   0.246             0.248 0.146                          0.22
                                                  0.213   0.185                                                 0.108                                                             0.188
                                          0.168
                                                                   0.182                                                                                                                                           1
                                                                                                                                                                            0.3
                                     0                                                                                                                                                                                          0




                                                                                        Production/Population (m3/d/c)                              Water availability (hours)

                                                                                                                                                       Source:- India Infrastructure Report 2011 and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis


        Institute for Competitiveness, India
URBAN CLUSTERS
                          “Geographical concentrations of industries that gain performance advantage through co-location”


     Brings together companies, suppliers, service providers and associated institutions in a particular field
     The close proximity – by geography and activities - provides economic benefits
     Facilitate commercialization and new business formation through spinoffs and startups
     Cluster initiatives can act as policy catalysts for competitiveness
     Growth of one competitive firm generate demand for other related industries
     Forces firms to improve and innovate
     Facilitate technology and knowledge transfer that strengthens the cluster and promotes future growth

                                   City                  Industrial Cluster
                                   Raipur                Iron & Steel Cluster
                                   Ahmedabad             Chemical Cluster
                                   Surat                 Gem & Jewelry Cluster
                                   Nashik                Engineering cluster
                                   Guwahati              Bamboo Cluster
                                   Vijayawada, Chennai   Auto Components Cluster
                                   Bangalore             Machine Tools Cluster
                                   Hyderabad             Pharma Cluster
                                   Kanpur                Leather Cluster
                                   Ludhiana              Textile Cluster


Institute for Competitiveness, India
SUCCESS STORY OF CLUSTER IN BENGALURU
 The ICT Cluster in Bengaluru has attracted people and is also known as the Silicon Valley of India
 Currently Boasts of over 1500 IT firms out of about 3500 IT firms in India
 Indian companies such as Infosys, Wipro, Iflex have strong presence
 Fully owned subsidiaries of MNCs such as Motorola, Texas Instruments and Hewlett Packard have their base in the city
 Around 1/3rd of all of India’s software exports are from the city
 Ranked 4th in the category of global hub of technological innovation by United Nations Human Development Report


Factors that contribute
 Educational Institutions and training centers (IISC, IIIT, IIM etc.)
 Research Institutions (ISRO)
 Government policies (central and local)
 Y2K Problem (resulted in giving an important impetus to IT development)
 Quality issues
 Jobs creation


                                 “Bengaluru is a model of how an agglomeration can bring prosperity to a poor country”
                                                                                                  - Edward Glaeser, Harvard University




Institute for Competitiveness, India
ESTABLISHED IT/ITES HUBS IN INDIA

Total STPI Registered Units by 2006-07: 1400
IT/ITeS Majors: IBM, Genpact Oracle, American                                                   Total STPI Registered Units by 2006-07: 166
Express, Convergys, HP, General Motors                                                          IT/ITeS Majors: IBM, Cognizant, TCS, Infosys, Wipro


                                                                   NCR Delhi


 Total STPI Registered Units by
 2006-07: 630
 IT/ITeS Majors:
 TCS, Infosys, Wipro, Siemens, Acce
 nture                                                                                               Kolkata
 Total STPI Registered Units by            Mumbai
 2006-07: 635                                                                                               Total STPI Registered Units by 2006-07: 1060
 IT/ITeS Majors: Cognizant,                                 Pune                                            IT/ITeS Majors:
 Convergys, EXL, KPIT, Msource                                          Hyderabad                           Hp, Amazon, Verizon, Convergys, EXL, Infosys, TCS


 Total STPI Registered Units by
 2006-07: 1700                                  Bangalore
 IT/ITeS Majors: Wipro, TCS, HP,                                       Chennai
 Siemens, HSBC, Compaq
  Cumulative software exports from
  Bangalore are estimated to be                                                    Total STPI Registered Units by 2006-07: 900
  US$ 11 billion, positioning it as                                                IT/ITeS Majors: Infosys, Wipro, Accenture, Cognizant

    the leading IT hub of India
                                                                       Source:- Paper on “Knowledge-based Custer Development in India Opportunities and Challenges”, MIT


 Institute for Competitiveness, India
AUTOMOTIVE CLUSTERS IN INDIA

               NORTH
                                                                                                                         EAST
                Maruti
                                                                 Himachal Pradesh                                     TATA, HM
Suzuki, Honda, Hero, Yamaha, LM
                    L                                Haryana
                                                                  DELHI




                                                                                            West
                                                                                           Bengal
                                       Gujarat
                                                                                      Kolkata
                                                        Mumbai
GM, TATA, Fiat, Bajaj, Mahindra,        Maharashtra
              Mercedes                                               Andhra Pradesh
Benz, Volkswagen, Eicher, Force,
      Skoda, Audi, Mahindra                      Karnatak                                            Hyundai, Ford, Mitsubishi Motors,
                                                 a
      Renault, Swaraj Mazda                       Bangalore               Chennai                     TVS, Toyota, Volvo, Royal Enfield,
                                                                                                        BMW, Nissan, Renault Nissan
                                                                  Tamil Naidu




                                                                                                    Source:- Harvard Business School – Spring 2012


Institute for Competitiveness, India
ENHANCING CITY COMPETITIVENESS
   Focus on
                                       - Increases the ease of business, fetches innovative ideas, provide potential for financing
 1. Public-Private Partnerships        - One of the successful model is the Delhi Noida Bridge


                                       - Understand the city challenges & search their solutions, improve internal & external environment
 2. Dealing with Urbanization          - Some Tier-2 & 3 cities like Guwahati, Bhopal, Faridabad, Coimbatore are urbanizing at a fast pace


                                       - Leads to vulnerable conditions, create issues with respect to sanitation, water, health , education etc.
 3. Urban Poverty                      - Government programmes: Swarna Jayanti Shahari Raozgar Yojana (SJSRY), JNNURM, Rajiv Awas Yojana



                                                - Engage major stakeholders in most of the development activities
 4. Transparency and Civic Engagement           - A tool for the betterment of the democracy and thus the city




 5. Other Common Areas                 - Includes basic amenities, infrastructure, facilities etc. required for a decent standard of living




Institute for Competitiveness, India
GOVERNANCE
                                                     Movement of power

                                                            Center

                                                            State

                                                    Urban Local Government


                                                         City Mayor


                                       City Management                       Service Delivery Agencies
   Therefore,
    Clear boundaries between Metropolitan governance body and municipal corporation
    Need to make institutional arrangements
    Empower Local bodies
    Create well defined model for governance structure
    Focus should be on managing the change wherein expectations of all stakeholders is taken into consideration

                                                                       provide quality services in adequate
                                                                       quantities to the residents
       A ‘GOOD’ City = sound political and governance system
                                                                       are responsive towards the requirements of the
                                                                       businesses



Institute for Competitiveness, India
CITY BRANDING FROM WITHIN
   Focus on
                                       - Governed by planning norms, building controls and urban policy
 1. Build Character                    - Immediate spatial and visual impact of city’s “Hardware” positively influence the psyche of people


                                       - Urban contexts of the city strike a deep chord with its residents
 2. Urban identity                     - Characteristics such as historicity, accessibility, multi-vocal qualities and inclusive nature are valued


                                       - It replicates itself in recognizable pattern at multiple scales
 3. Urban behavior                     - Helps to openly engage, individually and collectively



                                         - Adds immeasurable value to the city
 4. Interstitial urbanism                - Vitalizes a city, encourage a sense of belonging amongst residents and their engagement with the city


   Delhi can be branded if following possibilities are looked upon:
    Innovatively utilizing the old structures even when urban infrastructure are being constructed
    Enhancing the inclusiveness of the city via urban villages & historic settlements so as to make them vibrant contributors to Delhi’s
       urban experience
    Improving the basic amenities within the city etc.




Institute for Competitiveness, India
INDIA CITIES ON GLOBAL BENCHMARK
                                                                                                                                               Delhi (46.7)

                                                                                                                            Ahmedabad (41.9)

                                                                                                                                      Mumbai (46.6)         Kolkata (37.8)

                                                                                                                                                Hyderabad (39.4)
                                                                                                                        Bangalore (44.6)
                                                                                                                                                Chennai (38.1)




                                                   London (70.4)
                                                                    Zurich (66.8)
                      Chicago (65.9)                               Paris(69.3)
                                       New York (71.4)
     Los Angeles (61.5)                                                                                            Shanghai (55.2)          Tokyo (68)

                                                                                                                        Hong Kong (69.3)

                                                                                                                     Singapore (70)




                                                                                    Source:- Economist Intelligence Unit and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis


Institute for Competitiveness, India
KEYS FOR SUCCESSFUL CITIES


                                                                                   ambition for future + desire
                                                                       Vision      + shared value system




             Include principles such
    as, participation, coherency, co                                                                              shaping people and not
    mpetitiveness, subsidiarity, sust          Governance                              Entrepreneurship           merely “shaping
                           ainability                                                                             knowledge”




                            Creative city planning                                                    understand every city’s unique
                    which, addresses social issues   Social cohesion            Specialization         characteristics




Institute for Competitiveness, India
THE CITIES OF FUTURE
   Present cities seems stressed on multiple accounts that is, overpopulation, sketchy resources, exorbitantly high cost of living index,
     mal governance etc.
   So the cities of future would primarily be an itsy-bitsy variation of current cities
   Current cities have built in so many contra forces that they are now leviathan white elephants. However it is being suggested that
     city of future would be fragmentisation of population clusters
   Every employee shall serve many firms
   Geography and power would no longer correlate
   21st century man is absolutely asocial
   Technology will keep on pouring and will make one city advanced and other obsolete
   Therefore, cities needs to see their future and then address the stresses bothering them and should not depend on the vacuous
     pronouncements of politicians




Institute for Competitiveness, India

More Related Content

What's hot

Biosecurity - A Foundational Principle To Poultry Primary Breeders
Biosecurity - A Foundational Principle To Poultry Primary BreedersBiosecurity - A Foundational Principle To Poultry Primary Breeders
Biosecurity - A Foundational Principle To Poultry Primary Breeders
Centre for Environment, Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (Cefas)
 
Public Meeting Presentation
Public Meeting PresentationPublic Meeting Presentation
Public Meeting PresentationJBS RI
 
2006* Farnborough Airshow ApresentaçãO AviaçãO Comercial
2006* Farnborough Airshow   ApresentaçãO AviaçãO Comercial2006* Farnborough Airshow   ApresentaçãO AviaçãO Comercial
2006* Farnborough Airshow ApresentaçãO AviaçãO ComercialEmbraer RI
 
[Challenge:Future] Disrupt your world: The Future of Work
[Challenge:Future] Disrupt your world: The Future of Work[Challenge:Future] Disrupt your world: The Future of Work
[Challenge:Future] Disrupt your world: The Future of WorkChallenge:Future
 
OVERVIEW & OUTLOOK: Brazilian Sugarcane Industry
OVERVIEW & OUTLOOK: Brazilian Sugarcane IndustryOVERVIEW & OUTLOOK: Brazilian Sugarcane Industry
OVERVIEW & OUTLOOK: Brazilian Sugarcane Industry
JohnsonAtCornell
 
June 2009 Global Challenges Resource Booklet
June 2009 Global Challenges Resource BookletJune 2009 Global Challenges Resource Booklet
June 2009 Global Challenges Resource Bookletguest576281
 
Tim meeting with investors - sep 2012
Tim   meeting with investors - sep 2012Tim   meeting with investors - sep 2012
Tim meeting with investors - sep 2012TIM RI
 

What's hot (7)

Biosecurity - A Foundational Principle To Poultry Primary Breeders
Biosecurity - A Foundational Principle To Poultry Primary BreedersBiosecurity - A Foundational Principle To Poultry Primary Breeders
Biosecurity - A Foundational Principle To Poultry Primary Breeders
 
Public Meeting Presentation
Public Meeting PresentationPublic Meeting Presentation
Public Meeting Presentation
 
2006* Farnborough Airshow ApresentaçãO AviaçãO Comercial
2006* Farnborough Airshow   ApresentaçãO AviaçãO Comercial2006* Farnborough Airshow   ApresentaçãO AviaçãO Comercial
2006* Farnborough Airshow ApresentaçãO AviaçãO Comercial
 
[Challenge:Future] Disrupt your world: The Future of Work
[Challenge:Future] Disrupt your world: The Future of Work[Challenge:Future] Disrupt your world: The Future of Work
[Challenge:Future] Disrupt your world: The Future of Work
 
OVERVIEW & OUTLOOK: Brazilian Sugarcane Industry
OVERVIEW & OUTLOOK: Brazilian Sugarcane IndustryOVERVIEW & OUTLOOK: Brazilian Sugarcane Industry
OVERVIEW & OUTLOOK: Brazilian Sugarcane Industry
 
June 2009 Global Challenges Resource Booklet
June 2009 Global Challenges Resource BookletJune 2009 Global Challenges Resource Booklet
June 2009 Global Challenges Resource Booklet
 
Tim meeting with investors - sep 2012
Tim   meeting with investors - sep 2012Tim   meeting with investors - sep 2012
Tim meeting with investors - sep 2012
 

Viewers also liked

Location Analysis: Emerging cities of India
Location Analysis: Emerging cities of IndiaLocation Analysis: Emerging cities of India
Location Analysis: Emerging cities of IndiaZinnov
 
Urban Development
Urban DevelopmentUrban Development
Urban Development
GAURAV. H .TANDON
 
Glimpses into the Indian Economy and Consumers
Glimpses into the Indian Economy and ConsumersGlimpses into the Indian Economy and Consumers
Glimpses into the Indian Economy and Consumers
Amit Sinha
 
Urbanization impacts
Urbanization    impactsUrbanization    impacts
Urbanization impactsMark Okowa
 
Porter Prize Booklet
Porter Prize BookletPorter Prize Booklet
Porter Prize Booklet
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
(GCF2009) Professor Michael E. Porter- "Competitiveness and the State of Entr...
(GCF2009) Professor Michael E. Porter- "Competitiveness and the State of Entr...(GCF2009) Professor Michael E. Porter- "Competitiveness and the State of Entr...
(GCF2009) Professor Michael E. Porter- "Competitiveness and the State of Entr...Global Competitiveness Forum - GCF
 
Institute for competitiveness support us
Institute for competitiveness support usInstitute for competitiveness support us
Institute for competitiveness support usDr. Amit Kapoor
 
Porter Prize Presentation
Porter Prize PresentationPorter Prize Presentation
Porter Prize Presentation
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Presentation done by Matt Kim
Presentation done by Matt KimPresentation done by Matt Kim
Presentation done by Matt Kim
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Market Research Report: K12 Education Market In India 2010
Market Research Report: K12 Education Market In India 2010 Market Research Report: K12 Education Market In India 2010
Market Research Report: K12 Education Market In India 2010
Netscribes, Inc.
 
Consumer behavior towards leading organized f&g retail.
Consumer behavior towards leading organized f&g retail.Consumer behavior towards leading organized f&g retail.
Consumer behavior towards leading organized f&g retail.
Devriti's share.
 
Scm competitiveness-sgd-2013-iii econvention-nagpur (2)
Scm competitiveness-sgd-2013-iii econvention-nagpur (2)Scm competitiveness-sgd-2013-iii econvention-nagpur (2)
Scm competitiveness-sgd-2013-iii econvention-nagpur (2)
Sanjeev Deshmukh
 
Presentation done by Joan Marti
Presentation done by Joan MartiPresentation done by Joan Marti
Presentation done by Joan Marti
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Water - 12th Five Year Plan (2012 - 2017)
Water - 12th Five Year Plan (2012 - 2017)Water - 12th Five Year Plan (2012 - 2017)
Water - 12th Five Year Plan (2012 - 2017)NITI Aayog
 
Land Resources and Mineral resources
Land Resources and Mineral resources Land Resources and Mineral resources
Land Resources and Mineral resources
Dr. Tanuja Nautiyal
 
Water pollution
Water pollutionWater pollution
Effects of water pollution
Effects of water pollutionEffects of water pollution
Effects of water pollution
Adarsh Bimod
 
Rank size rule and primate city concept
Rank size rule and primate city conceptRank size rule and primate city concept
Rank size rule and primate city concept
Tryambakesh Shukla
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Location Analysis: Emerging cities of India
Location Analysis: Emerging cities of IndiaLocation Analysis: Emerging cities of India
Location Analysis: Emerging cities of India
 
Urbanization impacts
Urbanization    impactsUrbanization    impacts
Urbanization impacts
 
Urban Development
Urban DevelopmentUrban Development
Urban Development
 
Glimpses into the Indian Economy and Consumers
Glimpses into the Indian Economy and ConsumersGlimpses into the Indian Economy and Consumers
Glimpses into the Indian Economy and Consumers
 
Urbanization impacts
Urbanization    impactsUrbanization    impacts
Urbanization impacts
 
Porter Prize Booklet
Porter Prize BookletPorter Prize Booklet
Porter Prize Booklet
 
(GCF2009) Professor Michael E. Porter- "Competitiveness and the State of Entr...
(GCF2009) Professor Michael E. Porter- "Competitiveness and the State of Entr...(GCF2009) Professor Michael E. Porter- "Competitiveness and the State of Entr...
(GCF2009) Professor Michael E. Porter- "Competitiveness and the State of Entr...
 
Institute for competitiveness support us
Institute for competitiveness support usInstitute for competitiveness support us
Institute for competitiveness support us
 
GCF 2012 Proceeding
GCF 2012 Proceeding GCF 2012 Proceeding
GCF 2012 Proceeding
 
Porter Prize Presentation
Porter Prize PresentationPorter Prize Presentation
Porter Prize Presentation
 
Presentation done by Matt Kim
Presentation done by Matt KimPresentation done by Matt Kim
Presentation done by Matt Kim
 
Market Research Report: K12 Education Market In India 2010
Market Research Report: K12 Education Market In India 2010 Market Research Report: K12 Education Market In India 2010
Market Research Report: K12 Education Market In India 2010
 
Consumer behavior towards leading organized f&g retail.
Consumer behavior towards leading organized f&g retail.Consumer behavior towards leading organized f&g retail.
Consumer behavior towards leading organized f&g retail.
 
Scm competitiveness-sgd-2013-iii econvention-nagpur (2)
Scm competitiveness-sgd-2013-iii econvention-nagpur (2)Scm competitiveness-sgd-2013-iii econvention-nagpur (2)
Scm competitiveness-sgd-2013-iii econvention-nagpur (2)
 
Presentation done by Joan Marti
Presentation done by Joan MartiPresentation done by Joan Marti
Presentation done by Joan Marti
 
Water - 12th Five Year Plan (2012 - 2017)
Water - 12th Five Year Plan (2012 - 2017)Water - 12th Five Year Plan (2012 - 2017)
Water - 12th Five Year Plan (2012 - 2017)
 
Land Resources and Mineral resources
Land Resources and Mineral resources Land Resources and Mineral resources
Land Resources and Mineral resources
 
Water pollution
Water pollutionWater pollution
Water pollution
 
Effects of water pollution
Effects of water pollutionEffects of water pollution
Effects of water pollution
 
Rank size rule and primate city concept
Rank size rule and primate city conceptRank size rule and primate city concept
Rank size rule and primate city concept
 

Similar to India City Competitiveness Report 2012

TATA Telecom Represented at The Mobile VAS SUMMIT 2009 by Virtue Insight
TATA Telecom Represented at The Mobile VAS SUMMIT 2009 by Virtue InsightTATA Telecom Represented at The Mobile VAS SUMMIT 2009 by Virtue Insight
TATA Telecom Represented at The Mobile VAS SUMMIT 2009 by Virtue Insight
Paritosh Sharma
 
RUSNANO's CEO Anatoly Chubais' presentation for Asian investors
RUSNANO's CEO Anatoly Chubais' presentation for Asian investorsRUSNANO's CEO Anatoly Chubais' presentation for Asian investors
RUSNANO's CEO Anatoly Chubais' presentation for Asian investors
Sergey Lourie
 
Neli Vacheva - IDC
Neli Vacheva - IDCNeli Vacheva - IDC
Neli Vacheva - IDCIvo_Dreshkov
 
2013 02 sub saharan africa economy
2013 02 sub saharan africa economy2013 02 sub saharan africa economy
2013 02 sub saharan africa economyaugustin59
 
Regional and urban competitiveness a case study for india
Regional and urban competitiveness   a case study for indiaRegional and urban competitiveness   a case study for india
Regional and urban competitiveness a case study for india
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Lee Cooper Russia
Lee Cooper RussiaLee Cooper Russia
Lee Cooper Russia
Roseleen D'Souza
 
CAD integrated automatic DFM analysis
CAD integrated automatic DFM analysisCAD integrated automatic DFM analysis
CAD integrated automatic DFM analysis
bhaskars
 
Automotive Thailand September 2012
Automotive Thailand September 2012Automotive Thailand September 2012
Automotive Thailand September 2012
Uli Kaiser
 
R&D Operations Cost 2010
R&D Operations Cost 2010R&D Operations Cost 2010
R&D Operations Cost 2010Zinnov
 
APAC Recruiter 2012: Aki Kakko on Talent Communities
APAC Recruiter 2012: Aki Kakko on Talent CommunitiesAPAC Recruiter 2012: Aki Kakko on Talent Communities
APAC Recruiter 2012: Aki Kakko on Talent Communities
Steven Yeong
 
12.02.07 Retail Overview Turkey E&amp;Y Presentation
12.02.07 Retail Overview Turkey E&amp;Y Presentation12.02.07 Retail Overview Turkey E&amp;Y Presentation
12.02.07 Retail Overview Turkey E&amp;Y Presentationm_gill
 
Paper and Pulp Machinery Industry in China
Paper and Pulp Machinery Industry in ChinaPaper and Pulp Machinery Industry in China
Paper and Pulp Machinery Industry in China
Business Finland
 
Resource efficiency and resource-policy aspects of the electro-mobility syste...
Resource efficiency and resource-policy aspects of the electro-mobility syste...Resource efficiency and resource-policy aspects of the electro-mobility syste...
Resource efficiency and resource-policy aspects of the electro-mobility syste...
Oeko-Institut
 
1 Q08 Results Presentation
1 Q08 Results Presentation1 Q08 Results Presentation
1 Q08 Results PresentationLocaliza
 
1 Q08 Results Presentation
1 Q08 Results Presentation1 Q08 Results Presentation
1 Q08 Results PresentationLocaliza
 
Overview of Pak Suzuki Motors
Overview of Pak Suzuki MotorsOverview of Pak Suzuki Motors
Overview of Pak Suzuki MotorsMohammedEmad1987
 
Social Infrastructure and Technology in India
Social Infrastructure and Technology in IndiaSocial Infrastructure and Technology in India
Social Infrastructure and Technology in India
ZinnovLLC
 
Bazaarvoice - The Conversation Index, Volume 1
Bazaarvoice - The Conversation Index, Volume 1Bazaarvoice - The Conversation Index, Volume 1
Bazaarvoice - The Conversation Index, Volume 1Brett Hurt
 
DCD Census Key Findings India 2011-2012
DCD Census Key Findings India 2011-2012DCD Census Key Findings India 2011-2012
DCD Census Key Findings India 2011-2012Anixter
 

Similar to India City Competitiveness Report 2012 (20)

TATA Telecom Represented at The Mobile VAS SUMMIT 2009 by Virtue Insight
TATA Telecom Represented at The Mobile VAS SUMMIT 2009 by Virtue InsightTATA Telecom Represented at The Mobile VAS SUMMIT 2009 by Virtue Insight
TATA Telecom Represented at The Mobile VAS SUMMIT 2009 by Virtue Insight
 
RUSNANO's CEO Anatoly Chubais' presentation for Asian investors
RUSNANO's CEO Anatoly Chubais' presentation for Asian investorsRUSNANO's CEO Anatoly Chubais' presentation for Asian investors
RUSNANO's CEO Anatoly Chubais' presentation for Asian investors
 
Neli Vacheva - IDC
Neli Vacheva - IDCNeli Vacheva - IDC
Neli Vacheva - IDC
 
2013 02 sub saharan africa economy
2013 02 sub saharan africa economy2013 02 sub saharan africa economy
2013 02 sub saharan africa economy
 
Regional and urban competitiveness a case study for india
Regional and urban competitiveness   a case study for indiaRegional and urban competitiveness   a case study for india
Regional and urban competitiveness a case study for india
 
Lee Cooper Russia
Lee Cooper RussiaLee Cooper Russia
Lee Cooper Russia
 
CAD integrated automatic DFM analysis
CAD integrated automatic DFM analysisCAD integrated automatic DFM analysis
CAD integrated automatic DFM analysis
 
Automotive Thailand September 2012
Automotive Thailand September 2012Automotive Thailand September 2012
Automotive Thailand September 2012
 
Economia global
Economia globalEconomia global
Economia global
 
R&D Operations Cost 2010
R&D Operations Cost 2010R&D Operations Cost 2010
R&D Operations Cost 2010
 
APAC Recruiter 2012: Aki Kakko on Talent Communities
APAC Recruiter 2012: Aki Kakko on Talent CommunitiesAPAC Recruiter 2012: Aki Kakko on Talent Communities
APAC Recruiter 2012: Aki Kakko on Talent Communities
 
12.02.07 Retail Overview Turkey E&amp;Y Presentation
12.02.07 Retail Overview Turkey E&amp;Y Presentation12.02.07 Retail Overview Turkey E&amp;Y Presentation
12.02.07 Retail Overview Turkey E&amp;Y Presentation
 
Paper and Pulp Machinery Industry in China
Paper and Pulp Machinery Industry in ChinaPaper and Pulp Machinery Industry in China
Paper and Pulp Machinery Industry in China
 
Resource efficiency and resource-policy aspects of the electro-mobility syste...
Resource efficiency and resource-policy aspects of the electro-mobility syste...Resource efficiency and resource-policy aspects of the electro-mobility syste...
Resource efficiency and resource-policy aspects of the electro-mobility syste...
 
1 Q08 Results Presentation
1 Q08 Results Presentation1 Q08 Results Presentation
1 Q08 Results Presentation
 
1 Q08 Results Presentation
1 Q08 Results Presentation1 Q08 Results Presentation
1 Q08 Results Presentation
 
Overview of Pak Suzuki Motors
Overview of Pak Suzuki MotorsOverview of Pak Suzuki Motors
Overview of Pak Suzuki Motors
 
Social Infrastructure and Technology in India
Social Infrastructure and Technology in IndiaSocial Infrastructure and Technology in India
Social Infrastructure and Technology in India
 
Bazaarvoice - The Conversation Index, Volume 1
Bazaarvoice - The Conversation Index, Volume 1Bazaarvoice - The Conversation Index, Volume 1
Bazaarvoice - The Conversation Index, Volume 1
 
DCD Census Key Findings India 2011-2012
DCD Census Key Findings India 2011-2012DCD Census Key Findings India 2011-2012
DCD Census Key Findings India 2011-2012
 

More from Dr. Amit Kapoor

Sanjeev_Sanyal_Process_Reforms_The_India_dialog_2024.pdf
Sanjeev_Sanyal_Process_Reforms_The_India_dialog_2024.pdfSanjeev_Sanyal_Process_Reforms_The_India_dialog_2024.pdf
Sanjeev_Sanyal_Process_Reforms_The_India_dialog_2024.pdf
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Michael_Green_Social_Progress_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdf
Michael_Green_Social_Progress_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdfMichael_Green_Social_Progress_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdf
Michael_Green_Social_Progress_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdf
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
James_Crabtree_The_Billionaire_Raj_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
James_Crabtree_The_Billionaire_Raj_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxJames_Crabtree_The_Billionaire_Raj_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
James_Crabtree_The_Billionaire_Raj_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Anil_Chalamalasetty_New_India_New_Energy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdf
Anil_Chalamalasetty_New_India_New_Energy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdfAnil_Chalamalasetty_New_India_New_Energy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdf
Anil_Chalamalasetty_New_India_New_Energy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdf
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Vibhav_Conor_Jyotirlingams_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Vibhav_Conor_Jyotirlingams_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxVibhav_Conor_Jyotirlingams_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Vibhav_Conor_Jyotirlingams_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Veer_Munshi_Visual_Dialog_on_Conflict_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Veer_Munshi_Visual_Dialog_on_Conflict_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxVeer_Munshi_Visual_Dialog_on_Conflict_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Veer_Munshi_Visual_Dialog_on_Conflict_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Pranjal_Sharma_Inclusive_Growth_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Pranjal_Sharma_Inclusive_Growth_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxPranjal_Sharma_Inclusive_Growth_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Pranjal_Sharma_Inclusive_Growth_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Pranab_Bardhan_Reflections_on_the_political_Economy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Pranab_Bardhan_Reflections_on_the_political_Economy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxPranab_Bardhan_Reflections_on_the_political_Economy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Pranab_Bardhan_Reflections_on_the_political_Economy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Michael_Enright_India_and_the_world_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Michael_Enright_India_and_the_world_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxMichael_Enright_India_and_the_world_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Michael_Enright_India_and_the_world_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Arun_Majumdar_Energy_Climate_Sustainability_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Arun_Majumdar_Energy_Climate_Sustainability_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxArun_Majumdar_Energy_Climate_Sustainability_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Arun_Majumdar_Energy_Climate_Sustainability_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Ramesh_Chand_Agriculture_Stanford_Idea_India_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Ramesh_Chand_Agriculture_Stanford_Idea_India_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxRamesh_Chand_Agriculture_Stanford_Idea_India_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Ramesh_Chand_Agriculture_Stanford_Idea_India_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Christian_ Ketels_Will_the_Indian_Giant_Emerge_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Christian_ Ketels_Will_the_Indian_Giant_Emerge_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxChristian_ Ketels_Will_the_Indian_Giant_Emerge_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Christian_ Ketels_Will_the_Indian_Giant_Emerge_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Mann_ki_Baat_Presentation.pdf
Mann_ki_Baat_Presentation.pdfMann_ki_Baat_Presentation.pdf
Mann_ki_Baat_Presentation.pdf
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
IFC_Presentation_April_2023.pdf
IFC_Presentation_April_2023.pdfIFC_Presentation_April_2023.pdf
IFC_Presentation_April_2023.pdf
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Steven_Vogel_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Steven_Vogel_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdfSteven_Vogel_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Steven_Vogel_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Stephen_Ezell_Redefining Healthcare_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Stephen_Ezell_Redefining Healthcare_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdfStephen_Ezell_Redefining Healthcare_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Stephen_Ezell_Redefining Healthcare_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Robert_Eberhert_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Robert_Eberhert_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdfRobert_Eberhert_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Robert_Eberhert_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Mathew_Bishop_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Mathew_Bishop_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdfMathew_Bishop_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Mathew_Bishop_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
E-Somanathan_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
E-Somanathan_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdfE-Somanathan_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
E-Somanathan_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 
Arvind_Virmani_India_LMIC_HIC_staanford_2023_feb.pdf
Arvind_Virmani_India_LMIC_HIC_staanford_2023_feb.pdfArvind_Virmani_India_LMIC_HIC_staanford_2023_feb.pdf
Arvind_Virmani_India_LMIC_HIC_staanford_2023_feb.pdf
Dr. Amit Kapoor
 

More from Dr. Amit Kapoor (20)

Sanjeev_Sanyal_Process_Reforms_The_India_dialog_2024.pdf
Sanjeev_Sanyal_Process_Reforms_The_India_dialog_2024.pdfSanjeev_Sanyal_Process_Reforms_The_India_dialog_2024.pdf
Sanjeev_Sanyal_Process_Reforms_The_India_dialog_2024.pdf
 
Michael_Green_Social_Progress_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdf
Michael_Green_Social_Progress_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdfMichael_Green_Social_Progress_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdf
Michael_Green_Social_Progress_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdf
 
James_Crabtree_The_Billionaire_Raj_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
James_Crabtree_The_Billionaire_Raj_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxJames_Crabtree_The_Billionaire_Raj_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
James_Crabtree_The_Billionaire_Raj_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
 
Anil_Chalamalasetty_New_India_New_Energy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdf
Anil_Chalamalasetty_New_India_New_Energy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdfAnil_Chalamalasetty_New_India_New_Energy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdf
Anil_Chalamalasetty_New_India_New_Energy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pdf
 
Vibhav_Conor_Jyotirlingams_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Vibhav_Conor_Jyotirlingams_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxVibhav_Conor_Jyotirlingams_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Vibhav_Conor_Jyotirlingams_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
 
Veer_Munshi_Visual_Dialog_on_Conflict_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Veer_Munshi_Visual_Dialog_on_Conflict_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxVeer_Munshi_Visual_Dialog_on_Conflict_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Veer_Munshi_Visual_Dialog_on_Conflict_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
 
Pranjal_Sharma_Inclusive_Growth_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Pranjal_Sharma_Inclusive_Growth_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxPranjal_Sharma_Inclusive_Growth_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Pranjal_Sharma_Inclusive_Growth_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
 
Pranab_Bardhan_Reflections_on_the_political_Economy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Pranab_Bardhan_Reflections_on_the_political_Economy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxPranab_Bardhan_Reflections_on_the_political_Economy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Pranab_Bardhan_Reflections_on_the_political_Economy_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
 
Michael_Enright_India_and_the_world_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Michael_Enright_India_and_the_world_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxMichael_Enright_India_and_the_world_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Michael_Enright_India_and_the_world_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
 
Arun_Majumdar_Energy_Climate_Sustainability_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Arun_Majumdar_Energy_Climate_Sustainability_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxArun_Majumdar_Energy_Climate_Sustainability_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Arun_Majumdar_Energy_Climate_Sustainability_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
 
Ramesh_Chand_Agriculture_Stanford_Idea_India_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Ramesh_Chand_Agriculture_Stanford_Idea_India_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxRamesh_Chand_Agriculture_Stanford_Idea_India_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Ramesh_Chand_Agriculture_Stanford_Idea_India_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
 
Christian_ Ketels_Will_the_Indian_Giant_Emerge_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Christian_ Ketels_Will_the_Indian_Giant_Emerge_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptxChristian_ Ketels_Will_the_Indian_Giant_Emerge_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
Christian_ Ketels_Will_the_Indian_Giant_Emerge_The_India_Dialog_2024.pptx
 
Mann_ki_Baat_Presentation.pdf
Mann_ki_Baat_Presentation.pdfMann_ki_Baat_Presentation.pdf
Mann_ki_Baat_Presentation.pdf
 
IFC_Presentation_April_2023.pdf
IFC_Presentation_April_2023.pdfIFC_Presentation_April_2023.pdf
IFC_Presentation_April_2023.pdf
 
Steven_Vogel_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Steven_Vogel_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdfSteven_Vogel_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Steven_Vogel_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
 
Stephen_Ezell_Redefining Healthcare_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Stephen_Ezell_Redefining Healthcare_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdfStephen_Ezell_Redefining Healthcare_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Stephen_Ezell_Redefining Healthcare_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
 
Robert_Eberhert_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Robert_Eberhert_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdfRobert_Eberhert_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Robert_Eberhert_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
 
Mathew_Bishop_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Mathew_Bishop_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdfMathew_Bishop_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
Mathew_Bishop_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
 
E-Somanathan_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
E-Somanathan_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdfE-Somanathan_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
E-Somanathan_#theindiadialogue Feb 2023.pdf
 
Arvind_Virmani_India_LMIC_HIC_staanford_2023_feb.pdf
Arvind_Virmani_India_LMIC_HIC_staanford_2023_feb.pdfArvind_Virmani_India_LMIC_HIC_staanford_2023_feb.pdf
Arvind_Virmani_India_LMIC_HIC_staanford_2023_feb.pdf
 

Recently uploaded

Understanding the Running Costs of Electric Scooters.pptx
Understanding the Running Costs of Electric Scooters.pptxUnderstanding the Running Costs of Electric Scooters.pptx
Understanding the Running Costs of Electric Scooters.pptx
Zivah ElectriVa Private Limited
 
How To Talk To a Live Person at American Airlines
How To Talk To a Live Person at American AirlinesHow To Talk To a Live Person at American Airlines
How To Talk To a Live Person at American Airlines
flyn goo
 
4 DAYS MASAI MARA WILDEBEEST MIGRATION SAFARI TOUR PACKAGE KENYA
4 DAYS MASAI MARA WILDEBEEST MIGRATION SAFARI TOUR PACKAGE KENYA4 DAYS MASAI MARA WILDEBEEST MIGRATION SAFARI TOUR PACKAGE KENYA
4 DAYS MASAI MARA WILDEBEEST MIGRATION SAFARI TOUR PACKAGE KENYA
Bush Troop Safari
 
Jose RIZAL History and his travel Paris to berlin
Jose RIZAL History and his travel Paris to berlinJose RIZAL History and his travel Paris to berlin
Jose RIZAL History and his travel Paris to berlin
MaryGraceArdalesLope
 
TOP 10 Historic Places To See in Kuruskhetra.
TOP 10 Historic Places To See in Kuruskhetra.TOP 10 Historic Places To See in Kuruskhetra.
TOP 10 Historic Places To See in Kuruskhetra.
ujjwalsethi113
 
Exploring Montreal's Artistic Heritage Top Art Galleries and Museums to Visit
Exploring Montreal's Artistic Heritage Top Art Galleries and Museums to VisitExploring Montreal's Artistic Heritage Top Art Galleries and Museums to Visit
Exploring Montreal's Artistic Heritage Top Art Galleries and Museums to Visit
Spade & Palacio Tours
 
Uk Visa Complete Guide and application process
Uk Visa Complete Guide and application processUk Visa Complete Guide and application process
Uk Visa Complete Guide and application process
pandeypratikwgblindi
 
How To Change Name On Volaris Ticket.pdf
How To Change Name On Volaris Ticket.pdfHow To Change Name On Volaris Ticket.pdf
How To Change Name On Volaris Ticket.pdf
namechange763
 
欧洲杯开户-信誉的欧洲杯开户-正规欧洲杯开户|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】
欧洲杯开户-信誉的欧洲杯开户-正规欧洲杯开户|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】欧洲杯开户-信誉的欧洲杯开户-正规欧洲杯开户|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】
欧洲杯开户-信誉的欧洲杯开户-正规欧洲杯开户|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】
bljeremy734
 
The Power of a Glamping Go-To-Market Accelerator Plan.pptx
The Power of a Glamping Go-To-Market Accelerator Plan.pptxThe Power of a Glamping Go-To-Market Accelerator Plan.pptx
The Power of a Glamping Go-To-Market Accelerator Plan.pptx
RezStream
 
Exploring Heritage The Ultimate Cultural Tour in Palmer, Puerto Rico
Exploring Heritage The Ultimate Cultural Tour in Palmer, Puerto RicoExploring Heritage The Ultimate Cultural Tour in Palmer, Puerto Rico
Exploring Heritage The Ultimate Cultural Tour in Palmer, Puerto Rico
Caribbean Breeze Adventures
 
Get tailored experience with Stonehenge tours from London
Get tailored experience with Stonehenge tours from LondonGet tailored experience with Stonehenge tours from London
Get tailored experience with Stonehenge tours from London
London Country Tours
 
Hunza Cherry Blossom tour 2025- Hunza Adventure Tours
Hunza Cherry Blossom tour 2025- Hunza Adventure ToursHunza Cherry Blossom tour 2025- Hunza Adventure Tours
Hunza Cherry Blossom tour 2025- Hunza Adventure Tours
Hunza Adventure Tours
 
Antarctica- Icy wilderness of extremes and wonder
Antarctica- Icy wilderness of extremes and wonderAntarctica- Icy wilderness of extremes and wonder
Antarctica- Icy wilderness of extremes and wonder
tahreemzahra82
 
MC INTERNATIONALS | TRAVEL COMPANY IN JHANG
MC INTERNATIONALS | TRAVEL COMPANY IN JHANGMC INTERNATIONALS | TRAVEL COMPANY IN JHANG
MC INTERNATIONALS | TRAVEL COMPANY IN JHANG
AshBhatt4
 
LUXURY TRAVEL THE ULTIMATE TOKYO EXPERIENCE FROM SINGAPORE.pdf
LUXURY TRAVEL THE ULTIMATE TOKYO EXPERIENCE FROM SINGAPORE.pdfLUXURY TRAVEL THE ULTIMATE TOKYO EXPERIENCE FROM SINGAPORE.pdf
LUXURY TRAVEL THE ULTIMATE TOKYO EXPERIENCE FROM SINGAPORE.pdf
Diper Tour
 
Paddle, Float, and Explore The Ultimate River Tour Experience in Monitor, WA
Paddle, Float, and Explore The Ultimate River Tour Experience in Monitor, WAPaddle, Float, and Explore The Ultimate River Tour Experience in Monitor, WA
Paddle, Float, and Explore The Ultimate River Tour Experience in Monitor, WA
River Recreation - Washington Whitewater Rafting
 
Winter Festivities in Italy
Winter Festivities in ItalyWinter Festivities in Italy
Winter Festivities in Italy
Time for Sicily
 
Agence Régionale du Tourisme Grand Est - brochure MICE 2024.pdf
Agence Régionale du Tourisme Grand Est - brochure MICE 2024.pdfAgence Régionale du Tourisme Grand Est - brochure MICE 2024.pdf
Agence Régionale du Tourisme Grand Est - brochure MICE 2024.pdf
MICEboard
 

Recently uploaded (19)

Understanding the Running Costs of Electric Scooters.pptx
Understanding the Running Costs of Electric Scooters.pptxUnderstanding the Running Costs of Electric Scooters.pptx
Understanding the Running Costs of Electric Scooters.pptx
 
How To Talk To a Live Person at American Airlines
How To Talk To a Live Person at American AirlinesHow To Talk To a Live Person at American Airlines
How To Talk To a Live Person at American Airlines
 
4 DAYS MASAI MARA WILDEBEEST MIGRATION SAFARI TOUR PACKAGE KENYA
4 DAYS MASAI MARA WILDEBEEST MIGRATION SAFARI TOUR PACKAGE KENYA4 DAYS MASAI MARA WILDEBEEST MIGRATION SAFARI TOUR PACKAGE KENYA
4 DAYS MASAI MARA WILDEBEEST MIGRATION SAFARI TOUR PACKAGE KENYA
 
Jose RIZAL History and his travel Paris to berlin
Jose RIZAL History and his travel Paris to berlinJose RIZAL History and his travel Paris to berlin
Jose RIZAL History and his travel Paris to berlin
 
TOP 10 Historic Places To See in Kuruskhetra.
TOP 10 Historic Places To See in Kuruskhetra.TOP 10 Historic Places To See in Kuruskhetra.
TOP 10 Historic Places To See in Kuruskhetra.
 
Exploring Montreal's Artistic Heritage Top Art Galleries and Museums to Visit
Exploring Montreal's Artistic Heritage Top Art Galleries and Museums to VisitExploring Montreal's Artistic Heritage Top Art Galleries and Museums to Visit
Exploring Montreal's Artistic Heritage Top Art Galleries and Museums to Visit
 
Uk Visa Complete Guide and application process
Uk Visa Complete Guide and application processUk Visa Complete Guide and application process
Uk Visa Complete Guide and application process
 
How To Change Name On Volaris Ticket.pdf
How To Change Name On Volaris Ticket.pdfHow To Change Name On Volaris Ticket.pdf
How To Change Name On Volaris Ticket.pdf
 
欧洲杯开户-信誉的欧洲杯开户-正规欧洲杯开户|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】
欧洲杯开户-信誉的欧洲杯开户-正规欧洲杯开户|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】欧洲杯开户-信誉的欧洲杯开户-正规欧洲杯开户|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】
欧洲杯开户-信誉的欧洲杯开户-正规欧洲杯开户|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】
 
The Power of a Glamping Go-To-Market Accelerator Plan.pptx
The Power of a Glamping Go-To-Market Accelerator Plan.pptxThe Power of a Glamping Go-To-Market Accelerator Plan.pptx
The Power of a Glamping Go-To-Market Accelerator Plan.pptx
 
Exploring Heritage The Ultimate Cultural Tour in Palmer, Puerto Rico
Exploring Heritage The Ultimate Cultural Tour in Palmer, Puerto RicoExploring Heritage The Ultimate Cultural Tour in Palmer, Puerto Rico
Exploring Heritage The Ultimate Cultural Tour in Palmer, Puerto Rico
 
Get tailored experience with Stonehenge tours from London
Get tailored experience with Stonehenge tours from LondonGet tailored experience with Stonehenge tours from London
Get tailored experience with Stonehenge tours from London
 
Hunza Cherry Blossom tour 2025- Hunza Adventure Tours
Hunza Cherry Blossom tour 2025- Hunza Adventure ToursHunza Cherry Blossom tour 2025- Hunza Adventure Tours
Hunza Cherry Blossom tour 2025- Hunza Adventure Tours
 
Antarctica- Icy wilderness of extremes and wonder
Antarctica- Icy wilderness of extremes and wonderAntarctica- Icy wilderness of extremes and wonder
Antarctica- Icy wilderness of extremes and wonder
 
MC INTERNATIONALS | TRAVEL COMPANY IN JHANG
MC INTERNATIONALS | TRAVEL COMPANY IN JHANGMC INTERNATIONALS | TRAVEL COMPANY IN JHANG
MC INTERNATIONALS | TRAVEL COMPANY IN JHANG
 
LUXURY TRAVEL THE ULTIMATE TOKYO EXPERIENCE FROM SINGAPORE.pdf
LUXURY TRAVEL THE ULTIMATE TOKYO EXPERIENCE FROM SINGAPORE.pdfLUXURY TRAVEL THE ULTIMATE TOKYO EXPERIENCE FROM SINGAPORE.pdf
LUXURY TRAVEL THE ULTIMATE TOKYO EXPERIENCE FROM SINGAPORE.pdf
 
Paddle, Float, and Explore The Ultimate River Tour Experience in Monitor, WA
Paddle, Float, and Explore The Ultimate River Tour Experience in Monitor, WAPaddle, Float, and Explore The Ultimate River Tour Experience in Monitor, WA
Paddle, Float, and Explore The Ultimate River Tour Experience in Monitor, WA
 
Winter Festivities in Italy
Winter Festivities in ItalyWinter Festivities in Italy
Winter Festivities in Italy
 
Agence Régionale du Tourisme Grand Est - brochure MICE 2024.pdf
Agence Régionale du Tourisme Grand Est - brochure MICE 2024.pdfAgence Régionale du Tourisme Grand Est - brochure MICE 2024.pdf
Agence Régionale du Tourisme Grand Est - brochure MICE 2024.pdf
 

India City Competitiveness Report 2012

  • 2. INDIA IS THRIVING – NOW AND WILL IN FUTURE % contribution in World’s GDP 12 2010 European Others Union 30% 9.82 26% 10 9.32 9.10 8.81 8.37 9.27 United States Japan China 8 GDP growth (annual %) India 23% 7.80 3% 9% 9% 8.28 6 5.22 5.30 2030 Projection 4 4.93 European 4.03 Others Union 3.77 35% 18% United States 2 16% India Japan China 4% 9% 18% 0 *value for 2012 and 2011 is for Q1 Source:- World Bank and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 3. MAIN CONTRIBUTORS IN INDIA’S GROWTH Mumbai, Pune 800,000 700,000 2010-11 nominal GDP (in crores of rupees) Lucknow, Kanpur 600,000 Chennai Hyderabad Ahmedabad, Surat 500,000 Kolkata 400,000 Bengaluru Thiruvananthapuram Jaipur 300,000 200,000 100,000 0 Source:- RBI and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 4. TREND IN POPULATION SIZE AND GROWTH RATE (1901-2011) 1800 30 1650.62 1600 24.8 24.66 1494.63 25 23.85 1400 21.51 1338.64 21.34 1210.19 20 Decadal Growth Rate (in %) 1200 Population (in millions) 1028.74 17.64 14.22 15 1000 13.31 846.42 11 800 10 683.33 600 5.75 548.16 439.23 5 400 361.09 318.66 0.1 278.98 238.4 252.09 251.32 0 200 -0.03 0 -5 1901 1911 1921 1931 1941 1951 1961 1971 1981 1991 2001 2011 2021 2031 2041 Population (in millions) Decadal Growth rate (in %) Source:- Government of India Census and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 5. THE RURAL-URBAN DIVIDE 100% 90% 80% 70% 71.5 68.8 76.7 74.3 60% 82.7 82.1 80.1 89.2 89.7 88.9 88 86.2 50% 40% 30% 20% 28.5 31.2 31.2 25.7 25.7 28.5 10% 23.3 23.3 17.3 17.9 17.9 19.9 19.9 10.8 10.3 11.1 12 13.8 17.3 10.8 10.3 11.1 12 13.8 0% 1901 1911 1921 1931 1941 1951 1961 1971 1981 1991 2001 2011 Rural Urban Source:- Government of India Census and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 6. INCREASE IN NUMBER OF TOWNS, UAS AND VILLAGES (1971-2011) Towns (in Numbers) UAs (in Numbers) 8000 7935 400 381 382 384 Number of Towns Number of UAs 6000 300 276 4689 5161 231 4029 4000 2921 200 2000 100 0 0 1971 1981 1971 1991 1981 2001 1991 2011 2001 2011 Villages (in Numbers) 620000 Number of Villages 608789 600000 593732 580000 579688 556561 556014 560000 540000 520000 1971 1981 1991 2001 2011 *UAs = Urban Agglomerations Source:- Government of India Census and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 7. URBANIZATION: SIGN OF A DEVELOPING EOCONOMY 90 80 70 74 64.8 60 52.21 50 43.57 40 34.45 30 28.3 18.33 20 10 0 1951 1961 1971 1981 1991 2001 2011 Degree of Urbanization Literacy Rates (%) Registered Motor Vehicles (No.) Mobile Cellular Subscription (per 100 people) Source:- Government of India Census, World Bank, Road Transport Year Book& Figure and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 8. INDIAN STATES WITH HIGH GROWTH HAVE HIGH URBANIZATION RATE 120.00 Delhi 100.00 80.00 Goa Maharashtra Tamil Nadu Urbanization level (in %) 60.00 Kerala Mizoram Gujarat Karnataka Punjab Andhra Pradesh Haryana West Bengal 40.00 Uttarakhand Madhya Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Rajasthan Manipur Jammu & Kashmir Nagaland Jharkhand Tripura Chhattisgarh Sikkim Arunachal Pradesh Orissa Meghalaya Assam Bihar 20.00 Himachal Pradesh 0.00 -200000 0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1000000 1200000 -20.00 GDP (Dec-11) in Rs. Crore Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 9. DISTRIBUTION OF TOWNS BY SIZE CLASS Cities Population 1951 1961 1971 1981 1991 2001 2011 Classification Class I > 1,00,000 76 102 148 218 300 393 Class II 50,000-1,00,000 91 129 173 270 345 401 Class III 20,000-50,000 327 437 558 743 947 1151 Class IV 10,000-20,000 608 719 827 1059 1167 1344 Class V 5,000-10,000 1124 711 623 758 740 888 Class VI < 5,000 567 172 147 253 197 191 Greater Mumbai UA Class I UAs/Towns 468 (12.05%) Million plus UAs/Towns 53 Delhi UA Mega Cities 3 (26.69%) Kolkata UA (6.87%) Source:- Government of India Census and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 10. SNAPSHOT OF URBAN INDIA IN 2011 Cities Size Class By Population 10 - 30 million 5 - 10 million 1 - 5 million 0.1 – 1 million Source:- India Urban Conference 2011: Evidence & Experience - IIHS Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 11. ENHANCING THE PROSPERITY OF URBAN INDIA via COMPETITIVENESS  Competitiveness is the productivity with which a region utilizes its human, capital, and natural resources  Productivity determines wages and the standard of living – Productivity growth determines sustainable economic growth  It is not what industries a nation competes in that matters for prosperity, but how productively it competes in those industries  Productivity in an economy depends on a combination of domestic and foreign firms  Innovation in products and processes is necessary to drive productivity growth  Only productive businesses can create wealth and jobs States compete to offer the most productive environment for business  The public and private sectors play different but interrelated roles in creating a productive economy Leading to the prosperity of the region Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 12. INFLUENCES ON COMPETITIVENESS Multiple Geographic Levels WORLD ECONOMY BROAD ECONOMIC AREAS GROUP OF NEIGHBOURING NATIONS NATIONS STATES, PROVINCES METROPOLITAN AREAS, RURAL AREAS [Our Focus] Source:- Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 13. DRIVERS OF COMPETITIVENESS Quality of overall business Concentration of resources Policy Coordination among Multiple Levels of environment and urban growth Geography/Government Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 14. MEASURING COMPETITIVENESS: THE FRAMEWORK Context for Firm Strategy and Rivalry • Local rules and incentives that encourage investment and productivity . - E.g. performance based salaries, incentives for capital investments, intellectual property protection Factor Demand • Vigorous local competition i.e., Conditions - Openness to foreign and local Conditions competition - Sophistication of company operations Access to high quality business inputs i.e., Sophisticated and demanding local - Natural endowments customers and needs e.g., - Human resources - Strict quality, safety, and environmental - Capital availability standards - Physical infrastructure – Consumer protection laws - Administrative infrastructure – Government procurement of - Information infrastructure Related and advanced technology - Scientific and technological infrastructure Supporting – Early demand for products and Services. Industries • Local availability of suppliers and supporting industries • Presence of clusters instead of isolated firms Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 15. HIERARCHY OF CITY COMPETITIVENESS INDEX Overall Competitiveness Factor Demand Context for Strategy Related & Conditions Conditions & Rivalry Supporting Industry 1. Financial 1. Demographics 1. Competition 1. Supplier 2. Physical 2. Income Distribution Intensity & Diversity Sophistication 3. Communication and Spending of Firms 2. Institutional Support 4. Administrative Pattern 2. Business Incentives 5. Human Capacity 6. Innovation Nearly 200 Indicators Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 16. CITIES THAT WE STUDY Srinagar Jammu Shimla Amritsar Ludhiana Dehradun Chandigarh FaridabadDelhi Meerut Gurgaon Noida Agra Jaipur Kanpur Lucknow Guwahati Allahabad Patna Varanasi Asansol Jabalpur Dhanbad Bhopal Ranchi Kolkata Ahmedabad Indore Jamshedpur Vadodara Raipur Rajkot Surat Nagpur Bhubaneswar Nashik Mumbai Pune Vishakhapatnam Hyderabad Vijayawada Bengaluru Mysore Chennai Coimbatore Puducherry Kozhikod e Madurai Kochi Thiruvananthapuram Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 17. EVERY CITY HAS A DIFFERENT STORY Crucial to understand each city as what is right for one city will not necessarily be right for the other. “Mega Cities” “Million plus Cities” Variables DELHI KOLKATA JAMSHEDPUR KOCHI Population 16753235 4486679 2291032 3279860 No. of Branches of Commercial Banks 2177 1121 179 634 Literacy Rate: Female 80.93 84.98 67.33 94.27 No. of GSM users (per lakh) 265 145 11 19 Molestation Incidence 550 226 6 67 Ownership of consumer durable- 23 25 19 31 Home Theater Share of total passenger traffic 21.8 15.1 0.7 1.1 (airways) Consumer Price Index for Industrial 169 178 103* 158 Workers Starting a business cost (% per capita 51.1 39.6 51.5 47.2 income) Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 18. LOOK AT THE ENTIRE PICTURE For instance, Mumbai Weak Areas Strong Areas 20925 Paying Taxes (Time) 271 Population density Total-corruption cases registered 1228 Work Force Participation Rate (per 1000) 434 Variables 9093 Variables Number of accidental deaths 94.28 Literacy rate: Males Number of slums 61300 Media Reach-Press 98.8 Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 19. A GLIMPSE: CITY COMPETITIVENESS RANK First 25 Cities Overall Competitiveness Context for Firm Related & Supporting Rank City Factor Conditions Demand Conditions Score Strategy & Rivalry Industries 1 Delhi 69.732 1 1 1 10 2 Mumbai 67.856 2 2 2 4 3 Chennai 62.323 4 5 5 2 4 Hyderabad 61.782 3 12 7 1 5 Kolkata 61.464 6 11 6 3 6 Gurgaon 61.167 7 7 4 23 7 Bengaluru 61.100 5 3 8 18 8 Noida 60.406 9 38 3 5 9 Pune 59.854 8 4 9 8 10 Ahmedabad 58.036 15 8 15 7 11 Nagpur 56.942 17 15 12 14 12 Chandigarh 56.842 10 17 25 15 13 Jaipur 56.263 18 6 19 26 14 Coimbatore 55.955 29 45 10 6 15 Kochi 55.884 28 23 14 11 16 Surat 55.726 26 10 17 20 17 Nashik 55.651 33 9 21 9 18 Indore 55.637 11 35 22 37 19 Thiruvananthapuram 55.434 22 18 18 28 20 Kozhikode 55.212 35 19 11 32 21 Mysore 55.118 12 39 30 33 22 Bhubaneswar 54.642 13 42 27 43 23 Vadodara 54.627 32 25 16 25 24 Rajkot 54.607 36 14 20 27 25 Lucknow 54.584 23 16 39 22 Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 20. A GLIMPSE: CITY COMPETITIVENESS RANK Next set of 25 Cities Overall Competitiveness Context for Firm Strategy Related & Supporting Rank City Factor Conditions Demand Conditions Score & Rivalry Industries 26 Madurai 54.570 38 36 13 24 27 Bhopal 54.322 16 40 28 40 28 Kanpur 54.318 19 49 38 12 29 Faridabad 54.097 20 32 36 34 30 Ludhiana 54.022 27 28 23 42 31 Vijayawada 53.964 30 20 32 30 32 Guwahati 53.961 14 46 31 46 33 Raipur 53.849 25 31 26 38 34 Vishakhapatnam 53.741 34 22 33 31 35 Patna 53.580 37 21 42 21 36 Jabalpur 53.249 24 50 34 35 37 Agra 53.157 39 29 46 16 38 Varanasi 53.039 45 41 37 13 39 Meerut 52.975 43 34 40 17 40 Puducherry 52.905 42 27 29 39 41 Asansol 52.813 47 13 35 36 42 Dehradun 52.725 31 30 47 41 43 Ranchi 52.575 40 33 41 29 44 Allahabad 52.573 46 26 48 19 45 Shimla 52.295 21 43 43 49 46 Amritsar 52.181 41 24 24 47 47 Jammu 50.621 44 47 49 48 48 Jamshedpur 50.475 49 44 44 44 49 Dhanbad 49.829 50 48 45 45 50 Srinagar 49.732 48 37 50 50 Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 21. TOTAL POPULATION VERSUS COMPETITIVENESS 18000000 Del 16000000 14000000 Mum 12000000 y = 49162x - 2E+07 R² = 0.456 Total Populaiton 10000000 Ben Pun 8000000 Asa Jai Ahm Sur 6000000 All Pat Nas Vij Luc Kan Agr Vis Vad Kol Che Rai Nag Var Raj 4000000 Mee Lud Coi ThiKoc Ind Mad Koz Mys Hyd Dha Ran Jab Bho Jam Amr 2000000 Far Bhu Sri Deh Cha Noi Gur Jam Pud Guw Shi 0 48.00 53.00 58.00 63.00 68.00 Microeconomic Competitiveness Score Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 22. TEACHERS IN GOVERNMENT SCHOOL VERSUS COMPETITIVENESS 9000 All Vis 8000 Pun Agr 7000 Nas Kol Guw Kan Teachers in Government School 6000 Pat Del Var Luc Jai Vij 5000 Mee Jab Vad Ind 4000 Lud Coi Cha y = -26.06x + 5060. Ran Shi Amr Nag R² = 0.001 3000 Dha Jam Bho Mys Mad Thi Hyd Bhu 2000 Noi Deh Mum Jam Ahm Far Koz Sur Koc Gur Che Asa Ben 1000 Sri Pud Raj 0 48.00 53.00 58.00 63.00 68.00 Microeconomic Competitiveness Score Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 23. FEMALE LITERACY RATE VERSUS COMPETITIVENESS 100 95 Koc Koz Thi y = 1.001x + 20.11 90 R² = 0.232 Che Mum Kol Guw Ben 85 Nag Sur Cha Female Literacy Rate Bhu Pun Del Coi Ahm 80 Pud Lud Deh Kan Mad Bho Gur Jab Raj Ind Hyd Jam Shi Vad Far Luc 75 Amr Nas Noi Vij Asa 70 Var Jam Ran Mys Mee Rai Jai 65 Dha Pat Sri All Vis Agr 60 55 48.00 53.00 58.00 63.00 68.00 Microeconomic Competitiveness Score Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 24. EDUCATION DEVELOPMENT INDEX VERSUS COMPETITIVENESS 0.8 Koz Koc Thi Mad Coi Che y = 0.010x + 0.020 0.75 Lud Cha R² = 0.159 Amr Del 0.7 Far Gur Vis Vad Vij Raj Mys Sur Education Development Index Pun Mum Nas Nag Ahm Ben 0.65 Pud Hyd Shi 0.6 Deh Jai 0.55 Agr Var Mee Kan Luc Sri All Noi Rai Kol Jam AsaJab Bho Ind 0.5 Bhu 0.45 Dha Jam Ran Guw Pat 0.4 48.00 53.00 58.00 63.00 68.00 Microeconomic Competitiveness Score Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 25. CHEATING INCIDENCE VERSUS COMPETITIVENESS 1420 y = 105.8x - 5342. R² = 0.283 Kol 1220 Bhu 1020 Cheating Incidence 820 Luc Thi Pun 620 Che Kan Lud 420 Vij Vis Koz Koc Agr Amr Mee Gur Var Rai Nag Bho Ahm 220 Deh Ran Pat Guw IndCoi Cha All Jab Far Mad Sur Vad Nas Sri Jam Jam Asa Raj Dha Pud Noi 20 Shi 48.00 53.00 58.00 63.00 68.00 Microeconomic Competitiveness Score Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 26. DECADAL GROWTH RATE VERSUS COMPETITIVENESS 60 Noi 50 Ben Sur % decadal growth rate (2001-11) 40 Rai Ind Deh Far Bho Pun 30 Jai Luc y = 0.392x - 1.341 Pud R² = 0.014 Sri Ran Agr Pat Ahm Del All Raj Nas Mad Coi 20 Var Cha Mee Bhu LudGuw Jam Amr Jab Vad Mys Vis Nag Dha Asa Jam Kan Shi Vij Che 10 Koz Mum Koc Thi Hyd 0 48.00 53.00 58.00 63.00 68.00 Microeconomic Competitiveness Score Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 27. OWNERSHIP OF CONSUMER DURABLES - MOBILE VERSUS COMPETITIVENESS 100.5 Sri Jab Luc Jai Cha Kol Asa Ben Gur Del 100 Deh Shi IndNas Jam Pud Guw Ownership of Consumer Durables- Mobile Far Mum Vis Bho Mys Vij Mad Kan Che All Nag y = 0.016x + 98.61 Amr Raj Sur R² = 0.019 Pun Hyd 99.5 Var Ahm Vad Koz Koc Thi Dha Jam 99 Mee Agr Rai Lud Coi Ran Pat Bhu 98.5 Noi 98 48.00 53.00 58.00 63.00 68.00 Microeconomic Competitiveness Score Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 28. THE UNTAPPED ASSET OF INDIA: TIER 2-3 CITIES  Consists of a pool of opportunities  Avoids the pitfalls of the megacities  More people are moving towards them as they are facing scarcity of land in Mega cities  Each city has its own competitive edge  Preferred by many people Growth of organized retail 50% 40% Growth (in %) 30% 50% 35% 20% 10% 0% Tier I cities Tier II and III cities Source:- Report on “India Boarding” by TCS and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 29. URBANIZATION LEVEL OF TIER 2 CITIES Vishakapatnam 47.51 Vijaywada 41.01 Varanasi 43.43 Vadodara 49.54 Thiruvananthapuram 53.80 Surat 43.48 Rajkot 43.48 Patna 43.48 Nashik 42.53 Nagpur 68.30 Meerut 51.13 Maduari 60.64 Ludhiana 59.14 Lucknow 66.20 Kozhikode 67.15 Kochi 68.07 Kanpur 65.93 Jamshedpur 55.55 Jaipur 52.51 Indore 74.09 Dhanbad 58.13 Coimbatore 75.83 Bhopal 80.84 Asansol 66.93 Agra 45.87 0.00 10.00 20.00 30.00 40.00 50.00 60.00 70.00 80.00 90.00 Urbanization level (in%) Source:- Census 2011 and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 30. UNTANGLING THE LINKAGES BETWEEN CITY, COMPETITIVENESS & ECONOMIC GROWTH  More advanced economies are more urbanized economies  Cities tend to be the only place where companies and individuals find opportunities for successful economic activity  Rise of cities is seen as an inevitable part of development but also as a policy challenge  Avoid a political schism between metropolitan and rural regions  Cities have a different role to play in advanced economies  From the competitiveness perspective, the policy imperative is crucial for cities as well as for rural regions  Cities and the rural regions around them should cooperate closely The case with Mumbai  Tried to manage the growth by creating artificial boundaries  The approach failed and made living conditions worse  Different policy approach is required that focuses on better public services and land use inside the city  Competitiveness-oriented policy approach can be used that changes the economic fundamentals of where people live and work Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 31. SECTORWISE TOTAL INVESTMENTS IN PPP PROJECTS IN INDIA : 2011 99324.61 Urban Development Roads 244289.176 Railways 3913.03 Ports 82402.67 Health Care 1887.2 Energy 85141.18 Education 1922.47 Airports 19131 0 50000 100000 150000 200000 250000 Project Cost (Rs. Crore) Source:- PPP Database and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 32. URBAN INFRASTRUCTURE: TRANSPORTATION IN INDIAN CITIES  Chaotic situation in most cities except the mega cities where the number of commuters is so high that the transportation seems weak  Challenges: - Vast gaps between demand and supply - Poor infrastructure such as insufficient routes and roads - Increase in private vehicles which leads to congestion and also slows down the speed of other vehicles such as buses etc. to 10-12 km - Leads to environmental pollution - Absence of comprehensive parking facilities in the city Operations of Road Transportation in Major Cities: 2010-11 7000 300 278.59 6110 6000 5771 250 5000 205.38 4652 200 In km/Bus/Day In Number 4000 3414 154.02 152.71 138.66 150 3000 99.9 100 2000 942 956 50 1000 0 0 Chennai Bengaluru Mumbai Ahmedabad Kolkata Delhi Total Fleet Held Vehicle Productivity (km/Bus/Day) Source:- Road Transport and highways Ministry, 2010-11 and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 33. OTHER MODES OF TRANSPORTATION • The other major mode of transportation in cities is Railways • Though it is dominant for the inter city transportation only in cities • Also has a different face in every region such as in - Delhi – Metro Rapid Transit System (MRTS) is main lifeline but Local Rails are also present - Kolkata – The Underground Metro, The Local Rails and the tram, all are widely used by commuters - Mumbai – Local Trains however, metro will be operational after short period, as reported by authorities - Bengaluru – The introduction of Metro in the city has change the travelling experience of the commuters Passengers carried by railways (million passenger-km) South Africa 18865 India 903465 China 791158 Germany 78582 Japan 244235 United States 9518 United Kingdom 55019 In million passenger - km Source:- World Bank and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 34. URBAN INFRASTRUCTURE: WATER 0.9 14 0.8 12 12 Production/Population (m3/d/c) 11 0.7 10 Water Availability (hours) 0.6 0.808 8.3 0.5 8 7 0.4 6 6 4.5 5 5 4.3 0.3 4 3.5 4 AVERAGE= 0.244 0.2 2 3 2.5 3 0.305 1.5 0.332 0.246 0.217 0.244 0.75 0.267 2 0.1 0.131 0.286 0.246 0.248 0.146 0.22 0.213 0.185 0.108 0.188 0.168 0.182 1 0.3 0 0 Production/Population (m3/d/c) Water availability (hours) Source:- India Infrastructure Report 2011 and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 35. URBAN CLUSTERS “Geographical concentrations of industries that gain performance advantage through co-location”  Brings together companies, suppliers, service providers and associated institutions in a particular field  The close proximity – by geography and activities - provides economic benefits  Facilitate commercialization and new business formation through spinoffs and startups  Cluster initiatives can act as policy catalysts for competitiveness  Growth of one competitive firm generate demand for other related industries  Forces firms to improve and innovate  Facilitate technology and knowledge transfer that strengthens the cluster and promotes future growth City Industrial Cluster Raipur Iron & Steel Cluster Ahmedabad Chemical Cluster Surat Gem & Jewelry Cluster Nashik Engineering cluster Guwahati Bamboo Cluster Vijayawada, Chennai Auto Components Cluster Bangalore Machine Tools Cluster Hyderabad Pharma Cluster Kanpur Leather Cluster Ludhiana Textile Cluster Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 36. SUCCESS STORY OF CLUSTER IN BENGALURU  The ICT Cluster in Bengaluru has attracted people and is also known as the Silicon Valley of India  Currently Boasts of over 1500 IT firms out of about 3500 IT firms in India  Indian companies such as Infosys, Wipro, Iflex have strong presence  Fully owned subsidiaries of MNCs such as Motorola, Texas Instruments and Hewlett Packard have their base in the city  Around 1/3rd of all of India’s software exports are from the city  Ranked 4th in the category of global hub of technological innovation by United Nations Human Development Report Factors that contribute  Educational Institutions and training centers (IISC, IIIT, IIM etc.)  Research Institutions (ISRO)  Government policies (central and local)  Y2K Problem (resulted in giving an important impetus to IT development)  Quality issues  Jobs creation “Bengaluru is a model of how an agglomeration can bring prosperity to a poor country” - Edward Glaeser, Harvard University Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 37. ESTABLISHED IT/ITES HUBS IN INDIA Total STPI Registered Units by 2006-07: 1400 IT/ITeS Majors: IBM, Genpact Oracle, American Total STPI Registered Units by 2006-07: 166 Express, Convergys, HP, General Motors IT/ITeS Majors: IBM, Cognizant, TCS, Infosys, Wipro NCR Delhi Total STPI Registered Units by 2006-07: 630 IT/ITeS Majors: TCS, Infosys, Wipro, Siemens, Acce nture Kolkata Total STPI Registered Units by Mumbai 2006-07: 635 Total STPI Registered Units by 2006-07: 1060 IT/ITeS Majors: Cognizant, Pune IT/ITeS Majors: Convergys, EXL, KPIT, Msource Hyderabad Hp, Amazon, Verizon, Convergys, EXL, Infosys, TCS Total STPI Registered Units by 2006-07: 1700 Bangalore IT/ITeS Majors: Wipro, TCS, HP, Chennai Siemens, HSBC, Compaq Cumulative software exports from Bangalore are estimated to be Total STPI Registered Units by 2006-07: 900 US$ 11 billion, positioning it as IT/ITeS Majors: Infosys, Wipro, Accenture, Cognizant the leading IT hub of India Source:- Paper on “Knowledge-based Custer Development in India Opportunities and Challenges”, MIT Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 38. AUTOMOTIVE CLUSTERS IN INDIA NORTH EAST Maruti Himachal Pradesh TATA, HM Suzuki, Honda, Hero, Yamaha, LM L Haryana DELHI West Bengal Gujarat Kolkata Mumbai GM, TATA, Fiat, Bajaj, Mahindra, Maharashtra Mercedes Andhra Pradesh Benz, Volkswagen, Eicher, Force, Skoda, Audi, Mahindra Karnatak Hyundai, Ford, Mitsubishi Motors, a Renault, Swaraj Mazda Bangalore Chennai TVS, Toyota, Volvo, Royal Enfield, BMW, Nissan, Renault Nissan Tamil Naidu Source:- Harvard Business School – Spring 2012 Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 39. ENHANCING CITY COMPETITIVENESS Focus on - Increases the ease of business, fetches innovative ideas, provide potential for financing 1. Public-Private Partnerships - One of the successful model is the Delhi Noida Bridge - Understand the city challenges & search their solutions, improve internal & external environment 2. Dealing with Urbanization - Some Tier-2 & 3 cities like Guwahati, Bhopal, Faridabad, Coimbatore are urbanizing at a fast pace - Leads to vulnerable conditions, create issues with respect to sanitation, water, health , education etc. 3. Urban Poverty - Government programmes: Swarna Jayanti Shahari Raozgar Yojana (SJSRY), JNNURM, Rajiv Awas Yojana - Engage major stakeholders in most of the development activities 4. Transparency and Civic Engagement - A tool for the betterment of the democracy and thus the city 5. Other Common Areas - Includes basic amenities, infrastructure, facilities etc. required for a decent standard of living Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 40. GOVERNANCE Movement of power Center State Urban Local Government City Mayor City Management Service Delivery Agencies Therefore,  Clear boundaries between Metropolitan governance body and municipal corporation  Need to make institutional arrangements  Empower Local bodies  Create well defined model for governance structure  Focus should be on managing the change wherein expectations of all stakeholders is taken into consideration provide quality services in adequate quantities to the residents A ‘GOOD’ City = sound political and governance system are responsive towards the requirements of the businesses Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 41. CITY BRANDING FROM WITHIN Focus on - Governed by planning norms, building controls and urban policy 1. Build Character - Immediate spatial and visual impact of city’s “Hardware” positively influence the psyche of people - Urban contexts of the city strike a deep chord with its residents 2. Urban identity - Characteristics such as historicity, accessibility, multi-vocal qualities and inclusive nature are valued - It replicates itself in recognizable pattern at multiple scales 3. Urban behavior - Helps to openly engage, individually and collectively - Adds immeasurable value to the city 4. Interstitial urbanism - Vitalizes a city, encourage a sense of belonging amongst residents and their engagement with the city Delhi can be branded if following possibilities are looked upon:  Innovatively utilizing the old structures even when urban infrastructure are being constructed  Enhancing the inclusiveness of the city via urban villages & historic settlements so as to make them vibrant contributors to Delhi’s urban experience  Improving the basic amenities within the city etc. Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 42. INDIA CITIES ON GLOBAL BENCHMARK Delhi (46.7) Ahmedabad (41.9) Mumbai (46.6) Kolkata (37.8) Hyderabad (39.4) Bangalore (44.6) Chennai (38.1) London (70.4) Zurich (66.8) Chicago (65.9) Paris(69.3) New York (71.4) Los Angeles (61.5) Shanghai (55.2) Tokyo (68) Hong Kong (69.3) Singapore (70) Source:- Economist Intelligence Unit and Institute for Competitiveness Analysis Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 43. KEYS FOR SUCCESSFUL CITIES ambition for future + desire Vision + shared value system Include principles such as, participation, coherency, co shaping people and not mpetitiveness, subsidiarity, sust Governance Entrepreneurship merely “shaping ainability knowledge” Creative city planning understand every city’s unique which, addresses social issues Social cohesion Specialization characteristics Institute for Competitiveness, India
  • 44. THE CITIES OF FUTURE  Present cities seems stressed on multiple accounts that is, overpopulation, sketchy resources, exorbitantly high cost of living index, mal governance etc.  So the cities of future would primarily be an itsy-bitsy variation of current cities  Current cities have built in so many contra forces that they are now leviathan white elephants. However it is being suggested that city of future would be fragmentisation of population clusters  Every employee shall serve many firms  Geography and power would no longer correlate  21st century man is absolutely asocial  Technology will keep on pouring and will make one city advanced and other obsolete  Therefore, cities needs to see their future and then address the stresses bothering them and should not depend on the vacuous pronouncements of politicians Institute for Competitiveness, India

Editor's Notes

  1. 1. India’s contribution in world’s GDP (in 2010 and in 2030)2. It’s GDP increase over a period
  2. Top 10 States that are major contributors in India’s GDPRegions/cities of these states that are among the top 15 GDP contributorsThe diagram on the second page of the report that details on our area of focus
  3. Graph depicting population size and growth rateGraph with urban population and rural population (rural-urban divide)
  4. Like the graph on slide 7, make one for towns, urban agglomerations, districts, villages over years
  5. - With level of urbanization grows many other factors such as literacy rate, income level factories, transportation, etc.
  6. City I, II, III and the % of urban population, with the number of units
  7. -talk about competitiveness
  8. Mumbai slum versus growth
  9. Rise in diff. occupationWorking populationIncrease in opportunity
  10. Urban Poverty: 25.7% of the total urban population still lives below the poverty line as defined officially by the Planning commission based on survey data from the NSSO