SlideShare a Scribd company logo
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
Promoting integration of CSR among actors in supply chain of wild capture
fishery in Vietnam
Jenna Munden - ICAFIS
August 2015
Eco-Labels for Capture Fisheries
Eco-certification schemes for capture fisheries have existed for around 20
years, driven by the growing concern of the state of global fish stocks, increasing
consumption of seafood and a perception that public mechanisms at the regional,
national and international levels are failing in ensuring the sustainable management
of marine resources (OECD, 2012). The intent of eco-certification schemes is to
improve fisheries sustainability through market based incentives. Eco-labels
provide a link between marketing and management and are playing an increasingly
important role in fisheries sustainability. To be able to use an eco-label on capture
fisheries products, the fishery wishing to use the eco-label must be assessed by a
third party on sustainability standards developed by the eco-label organization. If
the fishery is found to comply with the standards after a full assessment, then the
fishery is certified and allowed to use the eco-label on its seafood products.
Benefits of Eco-Labeling Schemes
There are many perceived benefits from eco-labeling schemes, which vary
between actors within the fishery supply chain. The fishing industry gains
immediate benefits from eco-label certification, including; access to new markets,
consolidation of existing positions in market, product differentiation and receiving
a premium price for sustainably certified product. For example, after the MSC
certified an albacore tuna (Thunnus alalunga) fishery in the US, the price fishers
received increased by 32% (Pope, 2009). Retailers benefit from eco-certification
schemes by enhancing their reputation as a responsible buyer through response to
consumer demand, through potential for promotional opportunities and returns
related to better risk management (Washington, 2008). Consumers benefit by
gaining information on the origin of products and how they were produced and
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
reassurance that their consumption habits are not having adverse effects on the
marine environment. Government benefits from eco-labeling by the building of
export credits (OECD, 2012).
For fisheries which achieve sustainability through better management
practices adopted through the eco-certification process, many long term benefits
are gained. Operating costs from a well-managed fishery are reduced as seafood
can be produced cheaper, resulting in greater profits for harvesters. Fish processors,
traders and retailers will benefit from the assurance that their product supply will
be stable through sustainable management. Investing in sustainable harvesting of
fish species ensures job security for fishers, providing a stable livelihood for
citizens and support to the economy. The preservation of native fish species and
the marine ecosystem as a whole also certainly has a great value to citizens.
Although there is a general agreement that eco-certification schemes play a
positive role as an incentive for fisheries management improvement, solid evidence
to support the claims made in terms of business and ocean biodiversity are at this
stage anecdotal.
Eco-labels are not successful in achieving their desired benefits in all
markets. Markets best suited to the sale of eco-labeled products are those countries
where the population is environmentally aware, there is an active civil society and
media, seafood is sold in supermarkets, consumption patterns are based on a
traditionally limited range of fish products and where fish products are commonly
processed/packaged (Washington, 2008).
Weaknesses of Eco-Labeling Schemes
The intent of eco-certification schemes are weakened by; the existence of
multiple systems and assessment methodologies causing consumer confusion,
inconsistent application of criteria or certification of fisheries which have been
deemed unsustainable by government and NGO's, weakening eco-label credibility
and the false belief adopted by consumers that only certified products are
sustainably captured (OECD, 2012).
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
Capture Fisheries Eco-Labels
The Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) is arguably the most trusted,
credible and recognizable certification system for capture fisheries, often referred
to as the โ€œindustry standardโ€ (WWF, 2012). MSC was founded in 1997 by
Unilever and the WWF but become independent in 1999. The core objective of
MSC assessment is determining whether product comes from a sustainably
managed fishery. MSC sustainability criterion included in the Fisheries
Assessment Methodology was developed based on the FAO Guidelines for Eco-
labeling of Fish and Fish Products from Marine Capture Fisheries (FAO, 2009),
focusing on fisheries sustainability and traceability. The MSC evaluation tools rely
on three main pillars, with a range of indicators for each. The pillars include;
independent scientific verification of stock sustainability, ecosystem impact of the
fishery and the effective management of the fishery. Aspects of the exploited
species, harvesting gear and area are all taken into account for assessment. In
response to concerns that MSC certification is not applicable to data deficient
fisheries, often observed in developing countries, a risk-based assessment model
specifically applicable for these fishery types was developed (MSC, 2015). MSC
also offers pre-assessments for those fisheries wishing to improve management
practices, but not yet ready for a full assessment. The pre-assessment can function
to identify gaps and areas of improvement for the fishery, identifying a clear path
to full assessment. Retail giants such as Loblaws and Wal-Mart have committed to
buying only MSC certified seafood and products. Globally, MSC certified fisheries
are dominated by those harvesting white fish (haddock, pollock, cods) and salmon
(WWF, 2012).
The Friend of the Sea (FOS), established in 2006 is a less costly eco-labeling
certification system (Table 1), more accessible for small-scale and artisanal fishers,
whom make up 50% of its certified products (WWF, 2012). FOS incorporates
social accountability principles from Greenpeace and has requirements related to
carbon footprint. It bases its assessment on official stock assessment data and
certification methodology is based on whether the stock itself is sustainable, not
management. FOS will not certify fisheries that have seabed impacts or greater
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
than 8% discards. It is applicable not only to capture fisheries, but also for
aquaculture fish and seafood products (including fishmeal). A great volume of
FOS certified fish come from the Peruvian anchovy (OECD, 2012).
Dolphin Safe is an eco-label developed by the NGO Earth Island Institute in
1990, concerned with dolphin bycatch. It maintains agreements with all major tuna
processors that they will not sell tuna caught by chasing, netting or killing dolphins.
Dolphin Safe is criticized for not addressing issues in tuna fishing other than
dolphin bycatch, such as the sustainability of tuna stocks or other environmental
impacts of tuna fishing (OECD, 2012).
Naturland, a German NGO, originated as an organic farming label but now
has developed framework for the certification of aquaculture and capture fisheries.
It targets small scale; artisanal capture fisheries which are export based and have
high standards for sanitation (Forristall, 2009). Projects are undertaken on the basis
of social, economic and ecological sustainability criteria, often acting as a
development exercise for the whole community as well as a certification process.
Heath care for fishers, social services and education are all part of the certification
process. To date, only one fishery has been certified by Naturland. This was the
nile perch fishery in Buboka, Tanzania, certified through a pilot project led by
Naturland.
Krav, like Naturland was originally established for certifying organic farm
products but now also has a capture fisheries sustainability label. Krav is a
Swedish NGO and its label is only used in Sweden. Fair-Fish is a Swiss label that
merges sustainability issues with concerns regarding animal welfare and principles
of fair trade (Fair-Fish, 2007). The Iceland Responsible Fishing Programme is an
eco-label that identifies product origin as Icelandic and ensures consumers that the
fish product was harvested under sustainable management practices (Iceland
Responsible Fishing, 2015).
Eco-Certification Preparatory Programs
The Sustainable Fisheries Partnership (SFP), Fisheries Improvement
Projects (FIP) is not an eco-certification scheme, but a business-focused NGO that
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
works as an alliance between fishing industry stakeholders; retailers, processors,
traders and harvesters (SFP, 2015). The purpose of FIP is to resolve problems or
improve aspects of the fishery which need attention. To achieve this, FIP has a
highly flexible structure, which can be suited to the fishery and local environment.
In general however there are a number of steps in common for all FIP; formation
of the FIP with fishery stakeholders, data assessment (bringing together the most
current fishery data), fishery assessment (to identify challenges faced by industry),
agreement to a work plan, the creation of a monitoring procedure and
implementation (SFP, 2015). Although not mandatory, the final goal of some FIP
is to guarantee the ability of the fishery to obtain MSC certification. Options for
funding an FIP include commercial organizations, NGOโ€™s, international aid donors
or government. A well-funded FIP is critical for its success.
Recommendation Programs
In addition to certification programs, many recommendation programs exist
including; Seafood Watch, SeaChoice and Ocean Wise. Recommendations
programs assess fisheries using available data and expert advice to assess fisheries
with their standards to help consumers identify sustainably captured seafood.
Seafood Watch is a recommendation program which evaluates the
sustainability of fisheries products based on the guiding principles and
conservation ethic of the Monterey Bay Aquarium in California. Sustainable
seafood is defined as seafood from sources that can maintain or increase
production without compromising the structure and function of ecosystems
(Seafood Watch, 2014). The seafood recommendations apply to a single stock or
species caught in single fishery and are made public through pocket guides,
smartphone apps and online. Fisheries are assessed and classified as green, yellow
or red. Green is the best classification, signifying the fishery product is from a
well-managed fishery, yellow signifies that the choice is a good alternate but
concerns exist with harvesting methods, and red signifies that the consumer should
not purchase the product due to overfishing concerns or detrimental impacts on
non-target species.
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
SeaChoice is a similar seafood program as Seafood Watch, developed for
Canadians in 2006. Assessment criteria are based on those of the Seafood Watch
program, with the same green, yellow red classification scheme used to aid
consumers in choosing to purchase sustainably harvested seafood (Sea Choice,
2013).
Ocean Wise is a conservation program developed by the Vancouver
Aquarium in Canada in 2005 to educate consumers regarding seafood
sustainability. Its assessment criteria are also based on those developed by the
Monterey Bay Aquarium. It works directly with restaurants, marketers, food
services and suppliers to ensure that current scientific information is available to
make eco-friendly seafood buying choices. Its label is used for seafood products
which it has deemed sustainably fished through consultation with the scientific
community and review of existing literature. Unlike Seafood Watch and
SeaChoice seafood products, only two classifications of fisheries are used;
sustainable or unsustainable (Ocean Wise, 2015).
Eco-Label Certified Capture Fisheries in Vietnam
Currently, there is only one MSC certified fishery in Vietnam. It is a small
scale clam (Meretrix lyrata) fishery located in Ben Tre province, harvested by
hand. MSC certification has allowed this fishery to gain access to new markets and
50% price increases for its product (MSC, 2015). Certification was enabled
through support from the WWF and local provincial government (Department of
Agriculture and Rural Development).
In the 2008, Friend of the Sea certified a squid and cuttlefish fishery in
Vietnam. This fishery is harvested via traditional small basket-shaped boats, with
hook and line methods in Phan Thiet (southern Vietnam). Its certification however
has run out and no further audits were conducted (Friend of the Sea, 2008).
The Southeast Asia Fisheries Improvement Project is a joint FIP between
Thailand and Vietnam, for improving fisheries that supply fish meal. For the
Vietnamese portion, the areas of Ben Tre and Kien Giang were selected as areas of
interest. Project support has come from commercial entities within the supply
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
chain of farmed seafood including; retailers, processors, aquaculture producers and
feed manufacturers (Far Eastern Agriculture, 2013).
Way Forward for Vietnam
For developing, tropical countries there are challenges to gaining eco-
certification for capture fisheries products due to social, economic and ecological
factors. Some eco-labels, such as MSC have attempted to address this issue,
through developing risk-based framework for data-deficient fisheries. Fisheries in
developing countries will need management and financial assistance to obtain eco-
certification for their products. Governments and NGOโ€™s have been encouraged by
the FAO (2009) to assist small scale fisheries in developing countries with the
certification process, both with fisheries management capacity and financial aid.
Other components of the value chain, especially retailers, obtain an unfair benefit
from eco-certification schemes, reaping many rewards without contributing to
costs. Retailers and other actors within the value chain should contribute to
programs like FIP and MSC pre-assessments for fisheries in developing countries
which they depend on for product supply.
Action Plan for Eco-certification in Vietnam
For fisheries in Vietnam whom gain appropriate support (from local
government, international donors, NGOโ€™s or commercial entities) steps taken
towards certification may include; use of the MSC pre-assessment to determine
whether a fishery is ready for certification, if the fishery seems to comply fairly
thoroughly to the sustainability criteria, continue to a full assessment in the eco-
certification scheme of choice, if not, engage in a FIP. After following the
recommended steps of an FIP, stakeholders may be satisfied or, eco-certification
can be the final goal, given sufficient funds are available for a full, third party
assessment (Marsh, 2009).
For fisheries where no resources are available to implement a MSC pre-
assessment or FIP, but the fishers are interested in certification in the near-future,
the establishment of a functioning co-management system at the commune level
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
represents an attainable goal. Co-management is the shared responsibility of
resource management by the community and government (Pomeroy, 1995). Co-
management is often the only realistic solution for ensuring sustainable harvest of
marine resources in developing countries (Gutiรฉrrez et al., 2011). Effective
fisheries management is essential to eco-certification schemes thus those
communes that are already managed by a co-management system will be much
more attractive for funders and investors of eco-certification programs. To achieve
this goal, support from the local government is required for forming a Fisheries
Association, developing the fishing right and to legitimize both the association and
right through legal framework. Through these types of initiatives, eco-certification
of fishery products will be much more accessible to a wide range of fisheries
within the country, as well as providing a management system that can be used to
control fishing effort, gears and open up the potential for conservation measures,
such as fish refugia.
Social Responsibility
Social responsibility is defined as a businessโ€™ commitment to contribute to
sustainable economic development, working with employees, their families, the
local community, and society at large to improve their quality of life (Kotler and
Lee, 2005). Social responsibility has become increasingly important for business
success. Capture fisheries eco-certification schemes provide a means to gaining
ecological responsibility credit, however often social aspects of the fishers and
their communities are ignored. Some schemes do offer value in social, in addition
to ecological responsibility, such as the Naturland brand, and to a lesser extent,
FOS. For those eco-certifications that donโ€™t include social aspects, established
social responsibility standards can be used to increase social responsibility credit
(i.e. ISO 26000), or further, social responsibility certifications can be obtained (i.e.
SA 8000 or Fair Trade). Benefits for businesses who practice social responsibility
include; competitive advantage, reputation, ability to attract and retain workers and
buyers, maintenance of employee morale, commitment and productivity, view of
investors, owners, donors, sponsors and the financial community, and lastly its
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
relationship with companies, governments, the media, suppliers, peers, customers
and the community which it operates (ISO, 26000).
Social Responsibility Standards and Certification Boards
ISO (International Organization of Standardization) 26000 is not a
certification board, but provides guidance on how businesses can operate in a
socially responsible way. This includes acting in an ethical and transparent manner,
as well as contributing to the health and welfare of society (ISO, 26000). Standards
were established through 5 years of discussions by government, NGOโ€™s, consumer
and labor groups around the world and are considered to be applicable
internationally. For actors within the supply chain of capture fisheries,
understanding and implementation of ISO 26000 standards can be used to increase
social responsibility.
SA 8000 is the worldโ€™s leading social responsibility certificate board which
aims to protect the basic human rights of workers through improved workplace
conditions and effective management (SAAS, 2015). The standards framework is
based on the UN Declaration of Human Rights, International Labor Organization
Conventions, international human rights norms and national labor laws (SAI,
2014). The certification is applicable for all industries and is based on site-specific
assessments. For marine capture fisheries supply chain, having the processor SA
8000, in addition to an ecological responsible eco-label at the harvesting level
could generate many benefits in international exports.
Buying Fair Trade certified products ensures that producers or harvester
representing the initial stage of the supply chain are getting a fair price for their
raw materials. In addition, products labeled with this trademark ensures safe
working conditions, environmentally sustainable practices, clean water access for
communities, food safety, assurance against child labor, women empowerment and
education. Fair Trade certified products have traditionally included commodities
such as; coffee, chocolate, quinoa and garments (Fair Trade, 2014) but in 2014,
Fair Trade expanded its brand to the fisheries sector with its Capture Fisheries
Program. The four main objectives of this program are to provide empowerment,
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
economic development, social responsibility and environmental stewardship to
small scale fishers. To gain certification of the Fair Trade brand, the fishery must
form a Fisherโ€™s Association and a Fair Trade Committee. A stipulation of this
certification is that a Premium Fund is developed, paid to the harvesters by
importers with every exchange and is used to cover the costs of improvement of
fishery facilities, scholarships for fishers children, community development, with
at least 30% to environmentally focused projects. Currently, only one fishery has
been certified with the Fair Trade brand, the certification was finalized in March
2015 for yellowfin tuna of Ambon and Buru Islands in Indonesia. This fishery was
certified as a pilot project for the brand and the product in now for sale in US
markets (Artanti and Rufiati, 2015).
Social Responsibility Certified Companies Vietnam
As of March 21, 2015, there are 91 Vietnamese companies with SA 8000
certification. Of the 91, 8 companies are seafood processors. Products being
processed include pangasius, tilapia, albacore, shrimps and octopus (SAAS, 2015).
There is one Vietnamese producer (Cudliemnong in Cu Mgar) that has been Fair
Trade certified, however it is in the agriculture sector. No capture fisheries in
Vietnam have been Fair Trade certified (Fair Trade, 2014).
Conclusion
Eco-labels for capture fisheries have existed for the last 20 years, and since
then, the number and diversity of certifying organizations and programs have
grown substantially. From very narrow-minded beginnings concerned solely of
single species bycatch (Dolphin Safe) to, broadly focused ecological eco-labels
(MSC, Friend of the Sea) to all-encompassing labels which include social and
economic aspects of fishers, in addition to strict ecological standards (Naturland
and Fair Trade) representing a significant positive development opportunity for
communities. For actors within the supply chain of fisheries (i.e. processors),
social responsibility standards developed such as ISO 2800 can be adopted, or
social certification programs can be pursued such as SA 8000 to further strengthen
product brand and value. Market based programs have emerged such as Seafood
Watch, SeaChoice and Ocean Wise which act as informative safe guides for
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
consumers who wish to know which seafood to buy based on sustainable
harvesting methods. Now, more than ever there is a strong demand and incentive
for sustainable seafood products and traceability. Developing countries such as
Vietnam wishing to gain benefits from eco-certification schemes face increased
challenges due to a lack of management enforcement, limited financial resources
and having fisheries which are predominantly data-poor and small-scale. To
overcome these challenges, FIP and MSC pre-assessments should be pursued with
the help of local government and donor-funded projects, and at the local level, a
strong effort towards co-management of fisheries resources will help facilitate
these projects in the future
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
Table 1. Eco-label certifications for capture fisheries. The (*) symbol indicates that only a pilot project had been
certified at the time of writing , thus broad scale information on certification was not readily available.
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
Eco-label Founding
Country
and year
Social
Responsibility
Principles
Cost of
Label
Use
Cost of
certification
and audit
Annual
Fee
(USD)
Length of
certification
validity
Time for
accreditation
Marine
Stewardship
Council
United
Kingdom
1997
Ecological 0.05% of
the
wholesale
price of
certified
fish
$15,000-
$120,000
$250-
2,000
5 years 1-2 years
Friend of
the Sea
Italy
2006
Ecological
Social
$1,100 $5,500 N/A 3 years 4 weeks
Naturland* Germany
2007
Ecological
Social
Economic
1 year
Fair Trade* United
States
2014
Ecological
Social
Economic
3 years 6 years
SA 8000 United
States
1997
Social 3% of
revenues
or $5,000
$8,500-
$40,500
N/A 4 years 6 months-1
year
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
References
Artanti, A., Rufiati, I. (March 13, 2015). Fishers in Ambon Island and Buru Island
received the worldโ€™s first tuna fair trade premium fund. MDPI Foundation.
Retrieved from http://mdpi.or.id/index.php/our-program/fair-trade/item/55-
fishers-in-ambon-island- and-buru-island-received-the-world-s-first-tuna-fair-
trade-premium-fund
Fair-Fish (April 4, 2007). Fair-Fish instructions for artisanal fishery. Version 2.3.
11 pg. Retrieved from http://www.fair-fish.ch/files/pdf/english/instructions.pdf
Fair Trade (2014). Capture Fisheries Standard, Draft Version 1.0. 32 p.
FAO (2009). Guidelines for the Ecolabelling of Fish and Fishery Products from
Marine Capture Fisheries.Revision 1. Rome. 97 p.
Far Eastern Agriculture (July 24, 2013). Improving fish meal supplies. Retrieved
from: http://www.fareasternagriculture.com/live-stock/aquaculture/improving-
fishmeal- supplies
Forristall, A. (April 28, 2009). Lake Victoria Fisheries Project Launched.
Retrieved from http://www.seafoodsource.com/news/supply-trade/lake-
victoria-fishery-project- launched
Friend of the Sea (2008). Fishery Checklist. Retrieved from
http://www.friendofthesea.org/public/catalogo/Audit%20Report%20Checkli
st%20Vietn
am%20Squid%20and%20Cuttlefish%20Phuoc%20Hung%20for%20Appetai
s%20and%20 Coop.pdf
Gutiรฉrrez, N.L., Hilborn, R., Defeo, O. (2011). Leadership, social capital and
incentives promote successful fisheries. Nature, 470 (7334), 386-9.
Iceland Responsible Fishing (2015). The Certification Programme. Retrieved from
http://www.responsiblefisheries.is/certification/
ISO 26000. Guidance on Social Responsibility-Introduction
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
Kotler, P., Lee, N (2005). Corporate social responsibility: Doing the most good for
your company and cause. Hoboken, N.J.: Wiley.
MSC (2015). Retrieved from https://www.msc.org/
Marsh, J. (2009). WWF Fishery Improvement Projects. Bali Workshop. Retrieved
from assets.panda.org/.../jessemarsh_wwffisheryimprovementprojects_wwf.ppt
Naturland (2011).Standards Map, Retrieved from
http://search.standardsmap.org/assets/media/Naturland/English/AtAGlance_
EN.pdf
Ocean Wise (2015). Retrieved from http://www.oceanwise.ca/
OECD (2012). Eco-labeling and certification in the fisheries sector: summary
report of the OECD/FAO round table. OECD Review of Fisheries 2011:
Policies and Summary Statistics, OECD Publications.
Pomeroy, R.S. (1995). Community-Based and Co-M anagement Institutions for
Sustainable Coastal Fisheries Management in Southeast Asia. Ocean Coast
Manage 27(3): 143โ€“162.
Pope, F (2009). MSC Scheme Proves a Boon for Fishermen Despite fear Over
Stocks. Times (UK) September 30, 2009.
SAI (2014). Social Accountability 8000, International Standard.
SAAS (2015). Retrieved from http://www.saasaccreditation.org/faq
SeaChoice (2013). Retrieved from http://www.seachoice.org/
Seafood Watch (March 31, 2014). Seafood Watch Criteria for Fisheries. 80 p.
Retrieved from http://www.seafoodwatch.org/-/m/sfw/pdf/criteria/mba-
seafoodwatch-capture- fisheries-methodology.pdf?la=en
SFP (2015). Fishery Improvement Projects. Retrieved from
http://cmsdevelopment.sustainablefish.org.s3.amazonaws.com/2012/01/12/F
IP%20Ov erview%20Jan%202012-d6749f2d.pdf
International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries
Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS)
Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam
| Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/
Washington, S (2008). Ecolabels and marine capture fisheries: current practice and
emerging issues. Globefish Research Programme. Vol. 91. Rome, FAO. 52 p.
WWF (2012). Smart Fishing Initiative: Wild-Capture Fisheries Certification
Schemes. James Sullivan Consulting. Gland, Switzerland.

More Related Content

What's hot

Linking research and policy in fisheries and aquaculture: recommendations fro...
Linking research and policy in fisheries and aquaculture: recommendations fro...Linking research and policy in fisheries and aquaculture: recommendations fro...
Linking research and policy in fisheries and aquaculture: recommendations fro...
WorldFish
ย 
Aquaculture Certification in Indonesia
Aquaculture Certification in IndonesiaAquaculture Certification in Indonesia
Aquaculture Certification in Indonesia
Asian Food Regulation Information Service
ย 
Perform fish presentation_october17_final
Perform fish presentation_october17_finalPerform fish presentation_october17_final
Perform fish presentation_october17_final
Javier Ojeda Gonzalez-Posada
ย 
Fmi power point fmi deck
Fmi power point fmi deckFmi power point fmi deck
Fmi power point fmi deck
Jeanne von Zastrow
ย 
Sustainable seafood sourcing conference brochure
Sustainable seafood sourcing conference brochureSustainable seafood sourcing conference brochure
Sustainable seafood sourcing conference brochure
Innovation Forum Publishing
ย 
TRANSFORMING AQUACULTURE IN AFRICA THROUGH UPSCALED TECHNOLOGIES
TRANSFORMING AQUACULTURE IN AFRICA THROUGH UPSCALED TECHNOLOGIESTRANSFORMING AQUACULTURE IN AFRICA THROUGH UPSCALED TECHNOLOGIES
TRANSFORMING AQUACULTURE IN AFRICA THROUGH UPSCALED TECHNOLOGIES
International Institute of Tropical Agriculture
ย 
Aquaculture 4 - Food Safety in Post Harvest and Processing 2013
Aquaculture 4 - Food Safety in Post Harvest and Processing 2013Aquaculture 4 - Food Safety in Post Harvest and Processing 2013
Aquaculture 4 - Food Safety in Post Harvest and Processing 2013
Asian Food Regulation Information Service
ย 

What's hot (7)

Linking research and policy in fisheries and aquaculture: recommendations fro...
Linking research and policy in fisheries and aquaculture: recommendations fro...Linking research and policy in fisheries and aquaculture: recommendations fro...
Linking research and policy in fisheries and aquaculture: recommendations fro...
ย 
Aquaculture Certification in Indonesia
Aquaculture Certification in IndonesiaAquaculture Certification in Indonesia
Aquaculture Certification in Indonesia
ย 
Perform fish presentation_october17_final
Perform fish presentation_october17_finalPerform fish presentation_october17_final
Perform fish presentation_october17_final
ย 
Fmi power point fmi deck
Fmi power point fmi deckFmi power point fmi deck
Fmi power point fmi deck
ย 
Sustainable seafood sourcing conference brochure
Sustainable seafood sourcing conference brochureSustainable seafood sourcing conference brochure
Sustainable seafood sourcing conference brochure
ย 
TRANSFORMING AQUACULTURE IN AFRICA THROUGH UPSCALED TECHNOLOGIES
TRANSFORMING AQUACULTURE IN AFRICA THROUGH UPSCALED TECHNOLOGIESTRANSFORMING AQUACULTURE IN AFRICA THROUGH UPSCALED TECHNOLOGIES
TRANSFORMING AQUACULTURE IN AFRICA THROUGH UPSCALED TECHNOLOGIES
ย 
Aquaculture 4 - Food Safety in Post Harvest and Processing 2013
Aquaculture 4 - Food Safety in Post Harvest and Processing 2013Aquaculture 4 - Food Safety in Post Harvest and Processing 2013
Aquaculture 4 - Food Safety in Post Harvest and Processing 2013
ย 

Viewers also liked

MONGOOSE MAILER 2015_LOWRES copy
MONGOOSE MAILER 2015_LOWRES copyMONGOOSE MAILER 2015_LOWRES copy
MONGOOSE MAILER 2015_LOWRES copyJack Newberry
ย 
Panda Security - The Hotel Hijackers
Panda Security - The Hotel HijackersPanda Security - The Hotel Hijackers
Panda Security - The Hotel Hijackers
Panda Security
ย 
Kishore_cv1
Kishore_cv1Kishore_cv1
Kishore_cv1kishore yasam
ย 
Predstavitev izobraลพevanja odraslih v ฤŒrni gori, Slaven ฤ†ipraniฤ‡, Konferenca ...
Predstavitev izobraลพevanja odraslih v ฤŒrni gori, Slaven ฤ†ipraniฤ‡, Konferenca ...Predstavitev izobraลพevanja odraslih v ฤŒrni gori, Slaven ฤ†ipraniฤ‡, Konferenca ...
Predstavitev izobraลพevanja odraslih v ฤŒrni gori, Slaven ฤ†ipraniฤ‡, Konferenca ...
AndragoskiCenterSlovenije
ย 
Evaluation task 1 โ€“ album artwork
Evaluation task 1 โ€“ album artworkEvaluation task 1 โ€“ album artwork
Evaluation task 1 โ€“ album artwork
elizafernandapollock
ย 
Ataques informรกticos contra el sector sanitario -Panda Security
Ataques informรกticos contra el sector sanitario -Panda SecurityAtaques informรกticos contra el sector sanitario -Panda Security
Ataques informรกticos contra el sector sanitario -Panda Security
Panda Security
ย 
Panda Adaptive Defense - La evoluciรณn del malware
Panda Adaptive Defense - La evoluciรณn del malwarePanda Adaptive Defense - La evoluciรณn del malware
Panda Adaptive Defense - La evoluciรณn del malware
Panda Security
ย 
Siyao Liu
Siyao LiuSiyao Liu
Siyao LiuSiyao Liu
ย 
creatividad
creatividadcreatividad
creatividad
jhonleones
ย 

Viewers also liked (11)

Portrait
PortraitPortrait
Portrait
ย 
MONGOOSE MAILER 2015_LOWRES copy
MONGOOSE MAILER 2015_LOWRES copyMONGOOSE MAILER 2015_LOWRES copy
MONGOOSE MAILER 2015_LOWRES copy
ย 
Panda Security - The Hotel Hijackers
Panda Security - The Hotel HijackersPanda Security - The Hotel Hijackers
Panda Security - The Hotel Hijackers
ย 
Kishore_cv1
Kishore_cv1Kishore_cv1
Kishore_cv1
ย 
Predstavitev izobraลพevanja odraslih v ฤŒrni gori, Slaven ฤ†ipraniฤ‡, Konferenca ...
Predstavitev izobraลพevanja odraslih v ฤŒrni gori, Slaven ฤ†ipraniฤ‡, Konferenca ...Predstavitev izobraลพevanja odraslih v ฤŒrni gori, Slaven ฤ†ipraniฤ‡, Konferenca ...
Predstavitev izobraลพevanja odraslih v ฤŒrni gori, Slaven ฤ†ipraniฤ‡, Konferenca ...
ย 
Evaluation task 1 โ€“ album artwork
Evaluation task 1 โ€“ album artworkEvaluation task 1 โ€“ album artwork
Evaluation task 1 โ€“ album artwork
ย 
Support letter
Support letterSupport letter
Support letter
ย 
Ataques informรกticos contra el sector sanitario -Panda Security
Ataques informรกticos contra el sector sanitario -Panda SecurityAtaques informรกticos contra el sector sanitario -Panda Security
Ataques informรกticos contra el sector sanitario -Panda Security
ย 
Panda Adaptive Defense - La evoluciรณn del malware
Panda Adaptive Defense - La evoluciรณn del malwarePanda Adaptive Defense - La evoluciรณn del malware
Panda Adaptive Defense - La evoluciรณn del malware
ย 
Siyao Liu
Siyao LiuSiyao Liu
Siyao Liu
ย 
creatividad
creatividadcreatividad
creatividad
ย 

Similar to ICAFIS - PROMOTING INTEGRATION OF CSR AMONG ACTORS IN SUPPLY CHAIN OF WILD CAPTURE FISHERY IN VIETNAM

Ecolabelling
EcolabellingEcolabelling
Ecolabelling
Koushik Das
ย 
MSC_Get_Certified_Leaflet
MSC_Get_Certified_LeafletMSC_Get_Certified_Leaflet
MSC_Get_Certified_LeafletRichard Stansfield
ย 
Understanding Sustainability in the Fish and Seafood Industry and the Related...
Understanding Sustainability in the Fish and Seafood Industry and the Related...Understanding Sustainability in the Fish and Seafood Industry and the Related...
Understanding Sustainability in the Fish and Seafood Industry and the Related...
SGS
ย 
pg18-19_ASC_Market Insight
pg18-19_ASC_Market Insightpg18-19_ASC_Market Insight
pg18-19_ASC_Market InsightDonna Richardson
ย 
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
รrni Matthias Mathiesen
ย 
Green Fish Proposal V6 DC
Green Fish Proposal V6 DCGreen Fish Proposal V6 DC
Green Fish Proposal V6 DCDavid Cooper
ย 
A practical guide to the MSC's fishery certification process
A practical guide to the MSC's fishery certification process A practical guide to the MSC's fishery certification process
A practical guide to the MSC's fishery certification process
Marine Stewardship Council
ย 
Towards global sustainable fisheries
Towards global sustainable fisheriesTowards global sustainable fisheries
Towards global sustainable fisheriesMichael Newbold
ย 
Keep momentum to achieve the 2030 agenda
Keep momentum to achieve the 2030 agendaKeep momentum to achieve the 2030 agenda
Keep momentum to achieve the 2030 agenda
รrni Matthias Mathiesen
ย 
Unep fish supply chains report
Unep fish supply chains reportUnep fish supply chains report
Unep fish supply chains reportRaihanul Islam
ย 
FAOโ€™s Blue Growth Initiative
FAOโ€™s Blue Growth InitiativeFAOโ€™s Blue Growth Initiative
FAOโ€™s Blue Growth Initiative
FAO
ย 
Fish
FishFish
Examing Quality Control Practices at the Pangasius Farm Level
Examing Quality Control Practices at the Pangasius Farm LevelExaming Quality Control Practices at the Pangasius Farm Level
Examing Quality Control Practices at the Pangasius Farm Level
ijtsrd
ย 
FAOโ€™s Blue Growth Initiative
FAOโ€™s Blue Growth Initiative FAOโ€™s Blue Growth Initiative
FAOโ€™s Blue Growth Initiative
FAO
ย 
Fish, Food Security and Nutrition: presented at 10th Indian Fisheries and Aqu...
Fish, Food Security and Nutrition: presented at 10th Indian Fisheries and Aqu...Fish, Food Security and Nutrition: presented at 10th Indian Fisheries and Aqu...
Fish, Food Security and Nutrition: presented at 10th Indian Fisheries and Aqu...
AFS Gender in Aquaculture and Fisheries
ย 
Fish
FishFish
Fish
FAO
ย 
Startegic plan for biodiversity
Startegic plan for biodiversityStartegic plan for biodiversity
Startegic plan for biodiversity
L A
ย 
Kiribati Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2019 - Pacific Organic Standards
Kiribati Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2019 - Pacific Organic StandardsKiribati Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2019 - Pacific Organic Standards
Kiribati Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2019 - Pacific Organic Standards
Brussels Briefings (brusselsbriefings.net)
ย 
Aquaculture 3 - Food Safety Practices for Aquaculture Production 2013
Aquaculture 3 - Food Safety Practices for Aquaculture Production 2013Aquaculture 3 - Food Safety Practices for Aquaculture Production 2013
Aquaculture 3 - Food Safety Practices for Aquaculture Production 2013
Asian Food Regulation Information Service
ย 

Similar to ICAFIS - PROMOTING INTEGRATION OF CSR AMONG ACTORS IN SUPPLY CHAIN OF WILD CAPTURE FISHERY IN VIETNAM (20)

Ecolabelling
EcolabellingEcolabelling
Ecolabelling
ย 
MSC_Get_Certified_Leaflet
MSC_Get_Certified_LeafletMSC_Get_Certified_Leaflet
MSC_Get_Certified_Leaflet
ย 
Understanding Sustainability in the Fish and Seafood Industry and the Related...
Understanding Sustainability in the Fish and Seafood Industry and the Related...Understanding Sustainability in the Fish and Seafood Industry and the Related...
Understanding Sustainability in the Fish and Seafood Industry and the Related...
ย 
pg18-19_ASC_Market Insight
pg18-19_ASC_Market Insightpg18-19_ASC_Market Insight
pg18-19_ASC_Market Insight
ย 
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
ย 
Green Fish Proposal V6 DC
Green Fish Proposal V6 DCGreen Fish Proposal V6 DC
Green Fish Proposal V6 DC
ย 
A practical guide to the MSC's fishery certification process
A practical guide to the MSC's fishery certification process A practical guide to the MSC's fishery certification process
A practical guide to the MSC's fishery certification process
ย 
Towards global sustainable fisheries
Towards global sustainable fisheriesTowards global sustainable fisheries
Towards global sustainable fisheries
ย 
Keep momentum to achieve the 2030 agenda
Keep momentum to achieve the 2030 agendaKeep momentum to achieve the 2030 agenda
Keep momentum to achieve the 2030 agenda
ย 
Unep fish supply chains report
Unep fish supply chains reportUnep fish supply chains report
Unep fish supply chains report
ย 
FAOโ€™s Blue Growth Initiative
FAOโ€™s Blue Growth InitiativeFAOโ€™s Blue Growth Initiative
FAOโ€™s Blue Growth Initiative
ย 
Fish
FishFish
Fish
ย 
Examing Quality Control Practices at the Pangasius Farm Level
Examing Quality Control Practices at the Pangasius Farm LevelExaming Quality Control Practices at the Pangasius Farm Level
Examing Quality Control Practices at the Pangasius Farm Level
ย 
FAOโ€™s Blue Growth Initiative
FAOโ€™s Blue Growth Initiative FAOโ€™s Blue Growth Initiative
FAOโ€™s Blue Growth Initiative
ย 
Fish, Food Security and Nutrition: presented at 10th Indian Fisheries and Aqu...
Fish, Food Security and Nutrition: presented at 10th Indian Fisheries and Aqu...Fish, Food Security and Nutrition: presented at 10th Indian Fisheries and Aqu...
Fish, Food Security and Nutrition: presented at 10th Indian Fisheries and Aqu...
ย 
Fish
FishFish
Fish
ย 
Startegic plan for biodiversity
Startegic plan for biodiversityStartegic plan for biodiversity
Startegic plan for biodiversity
ย 
POS (1)
POS (1)POS (1)
POS (1)
ย 
Kiribati Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2019 - Pacific Organic Standards
Kiribati Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2019 - Pacific Organic StandardsKiribati Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2019 - Pacific Organic Standards
Kiribati Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2019 - Pacific Organic Standards
ย 
Aquaculture 3 - Food Safety Practices for Aquaculture Production 2013
Aquaculture 3 - Food Safety Practices for Aquaculture Production 2013Aquaculture 3 - Food Safety Practices for Aquaculture Production 2013
Aquaculture 3 - Food Safety Practices for Aquaculture Production 2013
ย 

More from Lap Dinh

Cho vay theo chuแป—i giรก trแป‹, chiแบฟn lฦฐแปฃc cho vay phรกt triแปƒn nรดng nghiแป‡p hiแป‡u quแบฃ
Cho vay theo chuแป—i giรก trแป‹, chiแบฟn lฦฐแปฃc cho vay phรกt triแปƒn nรดng nghiแป‡p hiแป‡u quแบฃCho vay theo chuแป—i giรก trแป‹, chiแบฟn lฦฐแปฃc cho vay phรกt triแปƒn nรดng nghiแป‡p hiแป‡u quแบฃ
Cho vay theo chuแป—i giรก trแป‹, chiแบฟn lฦฐแปฃc cho vay phรกt triแปƒn nรดng nghiแป‡p hiแป‡u quแบฃ
Lap Dinh
ย 
SINH Kแบพ Bแป€N VแปฎNG CHO NGฦฏแปœI NUร”I Tร”M THร”NG QUA LIรŠN KแบพT CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tแบ I ฤแป’NG...
SINH Kแบพ Bแป€N VแปฎNG CHO NGฦฏแปœI NUร”I Tร”M THร”NG QUA LIรŠN KแบพT CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tแบ I ฤแป’NG...SINH Kแบพ Bแป€N VแปฎNG CHO NGฦฏแปœI NUร”I Tร”M THร”NG QUA LIรŠN KแบพT CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tแบ I ฤแป’NG...
SINH Kแบพ Bแป€N VแปฎNG CHO NGฦฏแปœI NUร”I Tร”M THร”NG QUA LIรŠN KแบพT CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tแบ I ฤแป’NG...
Lap Dinh
ย 
Tร i liแป‡u hฦฐแป›ng dแบซn thแปฑc hร nh sinh kแบฟ
Tร i liแป‡u hฦฐแป›ng dแบซn thแปฑc hร nh sinh kแบฟTร i liแป‡u hฦฐแป›ng dแบซn thแปฑc hร nh sinh kแบฟ
Tร i liแป‡u hฦฐแป›ng dแบซn thแปฑc hร nh sinh kแบฟ
Lap Dinh
ย 
Mรด hรฌnh nuรดi trแป“ng thแปงy sแบฃn thรญch แปฉng biแบฟn ฤ‘แป•i khรญ hแบญu: kแบฟt quแบฃ vร  bร i hแปc ki...
Mรด hรฌnh nuรดi trแป“ng thแปงy sแบฃn thรญch แปฉng biแบฟn ฤ‘แป•i khรญ hแบญu: kแบฟt quแบฃ vร  bร i hแปc ki...Mรด hรฌnh nuรดi trแป“ng thแปงy sแบฃn thรญch แปฉng biแบฟn ฤ‘แป•i khรญ hแบญu: kแบฟt quแบฃ vร  bร i hแปc ki...
Mรด hรฌnh nuรดi trแป“ng thแปงy sแบฃn thรญch แปฉng biแบฟn ฤ‘แป•i khรญ hแบญu: kแบฟt quแบฃ vร  bร i hแปc ki...
Lap Dinh
ย 
Hiแป‡n trแบกng nghแป cรก hแป“ chแปฉa lฦฐu vแปฑc sรดng Mรช Kรดng - Tรขy Nguyรชn
Hiแป‡n trแบกng nghแป cรก hแป“ chแปฉa lฦฐu vแปฑc sรดng Mรช Kรดng - Tรขy NguyรชnHiแป‡n trแบกng nghแป cรก hแป“ chแปฉa lฦฐu vแปฑc sรดng Mรช Kรดng - Tรขy Nguyรชn
Hiแป‡n trแบกng nghแป cรก hแป“ chแปฉa lฦฐu vแปฑc sรดng Mรช Kรดng - Tรขy Nguyรชn
Lap Dinh
ย 
ICAFIS - THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN Vร€ XU THแบพ THแปŠ TRฦฏแปœNG
ICAFIS - THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN Vร€ XU THแบพ THแปŠ TRฦฏแปœNGICAFIS - THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN Vร€ XU THแบพ THแปŠ TRฦฏแปœNG
ICAFIS - THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN Vร€ XU THแบพ THแปŠ TRฦฏแปœNG
Lap Dinh
ย 
ICAFIS - CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tร”M TแปˆNH Sร“C TRฤ‚NG
ICAFIS - CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tร”M TแปˆNH Sร“C TRฤ‚NGICAFIS - CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tร”M TแปˆNH Sร“C TRฤ‚NG
ICAFIS - CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tร”M TแปˆNH Sร“C TRฤ‚NG
Lap Dinh
ย 
ICAFIS - Nรขng cao sแปฉc cแบกnh tranh vร  hรฌnh แบฃnh ngร nh thแปงy sแบฃn thรดng qua thแปฑc hร ...
ICAFIS - Nรขng cao sแปฉc cแบกnh tranh vร  hรฌnh แบฃnh ngร nh thแปงy sแบฃn thรดng qua thแปฑc hร ...ICAFIS - Nรขng cao sแปฉc cแบกnh tranh vร  hรฌnh แบฃnh ngร nh thแปงy sแบฃn thรดng qua thแปฑc hร ...
ICAFIS - Nรขng cao sแปฉc cแบกnh tranh vร  hรฌnh แบฃnh ngร nh thแปงy sแบฃn thรดng qua thแปฑc hร ...
Lap Dinh
ย 
ICAFIS - Sแป” TAY HฦฏแปšNG DแบชN THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I CHO KHแปI Tร€U Cร VIแป†T NAM
ICAFIS - Sแป” TAY HฦฏแปšNG DแบชN THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I CHO KHแปI Tร€U Cร VIแป†T NAMICAFIS - Sแป” TAY HฦฏแปšNG DแบชN THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I CHO KHแปI Tร€U Cร VIแป†T NAM
ICAFIS - Sแป” TAY HฦฏแปšNG DแบชN THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I CHO KHแปI Tร€U Cร VIแป†T NAM
Lap Dinh
ย 
ICAFIS - TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN, Cร‚U CHUYแป†N CแปฆA NGHรŠU BแบพN TRE
ICAFIS - TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN, Cร‚U CHUYแป†N CแปฆA NGHรŠU BแบพN TREICAFIS - TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN, Cร‚U CHUYแป†N CแปฆA NGHรŠU BแบพN TRE
ICAFIS - TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN, Cร‚U CHUYแป†N CแปฆA NGHรŠU BแบพN TRE
Lap Dinh
ย 
ICAFIS - Dแปฐ รN THรšC ฤแบจY THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจ...
ICAFIS - Dแปฐ รN THรšC ฤแบจY THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจ...ICAFIS - Dแปฐ รN THรšC ฤแบจY THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจ...
ICAFIS - Dแปฐ รN THรšC ฤแบจY THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจ...
Lap Dinh
ย 
ICAFIS - HIแป†N TRแบ NG THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจNG K...
ICAFIS - HIแป†N TRแบ NG THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจNG K...ICAFIS - HIแป†N TRแบ NG THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจNG K...
ICAFIS - HIแป†N TRแบ NG THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจNG K...
Lap Dinh
ย 
ICAFIS - KHUNG CHรNH SรCH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN
ICAFIS - KHUNG CHรNH SรCH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขNICAFIS - KHUNG CHรNH SรCH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN
ICAFIS - KHUNG CHรNH SรCH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN
Lap Dinh
ย 
ICAFIS - CรC CHแปจNG NHแบฌN Vแป€ TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN
ICAFIS - CรC CHแปจNG NHแบฌN Vแป€ TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขNICAFIS - CรC CHแปจNG NHแบฌN Vแป€ TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN
ICAFIS - CรC CHแปจNG NHแบฌN Vแป€ TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN
Lap Dinh
ย 
ICAFIS - ฤแป’NG QUแบขN Lร NGHแป€ Cร
ICAFIS - ฤแป’NG QUแบขN Lร NGHแป€ CรICAFIS - ฤแป’NG QUแบขN Lร NGHแป€ Cร
ICAFIS - ฤแป’NG QUแบขN Lร NGHแป€ Cร
Lap Dinh
ย 
ICAFIS - Presentation fisheries co management in viet nam
ICAFIS - Presentation fisheries co management in viet nam ICAFIS - Presentation fisheries co management in viet nam
ICAFIS - Presentation fisheries co management in viet nam
Lap Dinh
ย 

More from Lap Dinh (16)

Cho vay theo chuแป—i giรก trแป‹, chiแบฟn lฦฐแปฃc cho vay phรกt triแปƒn nรดng nghiแป‡p hiแป‡u quแบฃ
Cho vay theo chuแป—i giรก trแป‹, chiแบฟn lฦฐแปฃc cho vay phรกt triแปƒn nรดng nghiแป‡p hiแป‡u quแบฃCho vay theo chuแป—i giรก trแป‹, chiแบฟn lฦฐแปฃc cho vay phรกt triแปƒn nรดng nghiแป‡p hiแป‡u quแบฃ
Cho vay theo chuแป—i giรก trแป‹, chiแบฟn lฦฐแปฃc cho vay phรกt triแปƒn nรดng nghiแป‡p hiแป‡u quแบฃ
ย 
SINH Kแบพ Bแป€N VแปฎNG CHO NGฦฏแปœI NUร”I Tร”M THร”NG QUA LIรŠN KแบพT CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tแบ I ฤแป’NG...
SINH Kแบพ Bแป€N VแปฎNG CHO NGฦฏแปœI NUร”I Tร”M THร”NG QUA LIรŠN KแบพT CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tแบ I ฤแป’NG...SINH Kแบพ Bแป€N VแปฎNG CHO NGฦฏแปœI NUร”I Tร”M THร”NG QUA LIรŠN KแบพT CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tแบ I ฤแป’NG...
SINH Kแบพ Bแป€N VแปฎNG CHO NGฦฏแปœI NUร”I Tร”M THร”NG QUA LIรŠN KแบพT CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tแบ I ฤแป’NG...
ย 
Tร i liแป‡u hฦฐแป›ng dแบซn thแปฑc hร nh sinh kแบฟ
Tร i liแป‡u hฦฐแป›ng dแบซn thแปฑc hร nh sinh kแบฟTร i liแป‡u hฦฐแป›ng dแบซn thแปฑc hร nh sinh kแบฟ
Tร i liแป‡u hฦฐแป›ng dแบซn thแปฑc hร nh sinh kแบฟ
ย 
Mรด hรฌnh nuรดi trแป“ng thแปงy sแบฃn thรญch แปฉng biแบฟn ฤ‘แป•i khรญ hแบญu: kแบฟt quแบฃ vร  bร i hแปc ki...
Mรด hรฌnh nuรดi trแป“ng thแปงy sแบฃn thรญch แปฉng biแบฟn ฤ‘แป•i khรญ hแบญu: kแบฟt quแบฃ vร  bร i hแปc ki...Mรด hรฌnh nuรดi trแป“ng thแปงy sแบฃn thรญch แปฉng biแบฟn ฤ‘แป•i khรญ hแบญu: kแบฟt quแบฃ vร  bร i hแปc ki...
Mรด hรฌnh nuรดi trแป“ng thแปงy sแบฃn thรญch แปฉng biแบฟn ฤ‘แป•i khรญ hแบญu: kแบฟt quแบฃ vร  bร i hแปc ki...
ย 
Hiแป‡n trแบกng nghแป cรก hแป“ chแปฉa lฦฐu vแปฑc sรดng Mรช Kรดng - Tรขy Nguyรชn
Hiแป‡n trแบกng nghแป cรก hแป“ chแปฉa lฦฐu vแปฑc sรดng Mรช Kรดng - Tรขy NguyรชnHiแป‡n trแบกng nghแป cรก hแป“ chแปฉa lฦฐu vแปฑc sรดng Mรช Kรดng - Tรขy Nguyรชn
Hiแป‡n trแบกng nghแป cรก hแป“ chแปฉa lฦฐu vแปฑc sรดng Mรช Kรดng - Tรขy Nguyรชn
ย 
ICAFIS - THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN Vร€ XU THแบพ THแปŠ TRฦฏแปœNG
ICAFIS - THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN Vร€ XU THแบพ THแปŠ TRฦฏแปœNGICAFIS - THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN Vร€ XU THแบพ THแปŠ TRฦฏแปœNG
ICAFIS - THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN Vร€ XU THแบพ THแปŠ TRฦฏแปœNG
ย 
ICAFIS - CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tร”M TแปˆNH Sร“C TRฤ‚NG
ICAFIS - CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tร”M TแปˆNH Sร“C TRฤ‚NGICAFIS - CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tร”M TแปˆNH Sร“C TRฤ‚NG
ICAFIS - CHUแป–I GIร TRแปŠ Tร”M TแปˆNH Sร“C TRฤ‚NG
ย 
ICAFIS - Nรขng cao sแปฉc cแบกnh tranh vร  hรฌnh แบฃnh ngร nh thแปงy sแบฃn thรดng qua thแปฑc hร ...
ICAFIS - Nรขng cao sแปฉc cแบกnh tranh vร  hรฌnh แบฃnh ngร nh thแปงy sแบฃn thรดng qua thแปฑc hร ...ICAFIS - Nรขng cao sแปฉc cแบกnh tranh vร  hรฌnh แบฃnh ngร nh thแปงy sแบฃn thรดng qua thแปฑc hร ...
ICAFIS - Nรขng cao sแปฉc cแบกnh tranh vร  hรฌnh แบฃnh ngร nh thแปงy sแบฃn thรดng qua thแปฑc hร ...
ย 
ICAFIS - Sแป” TAY HฦฏแปšNG DแบชN THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I CHO KHแปI Tร€U Cร VIแป†T NAM
ICAFIS - Sแป” TAY HฦฏแปšNG DแบชN THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I CHO KHแปI Tร€U Cร VIแป†T NAMICAFIS - Sแป” TAY HฦฏแปšNG DแบชN THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I CHO KHแปI Tร€U Cร VIแป†T NAM
ICAFIS - Sแป” TAY HฦฏแปšNG DแบชN THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I CHO KHแปI Tร€U Cร VIแป†T NAM
ย 
ICAFIS - TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN, Cร‚U CHUYแป†N CแปฆA NGHรŠU BแบพN TRE
ICAFIS - TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN, Cร‚U CHUYแป†N CแปฆA NGHรŠU BแบพN TREICAFIS - TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN, Cร‚U CHUYแป†N CแปฆA NGHรŠU BแบพN TRE
ICAFIS - TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN, Cร‚U CHUYแป†N CแปฆA NGHรŠU BแบพN TRE
ย 
ICAFIS - Dแปฐ รN THรšC ฤแบจY THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจ...
ICAFIS - Dแปฐ รN THรšC ฤแบจY THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจ...ICAFIS - Dแปฐ รN THรšC ฤแบจY THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจ...
ICAFIS - Dแปฐ รN THรšC ฤแบจY THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจ...
ย 
ICAFIS - HIแป†N TRแบ NG THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจNG K...
ICAFIS - HIแป†N TRแบ NG THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจNG K...ICAFIS - HIแป†N TRแบ NG THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจNG K...
ICAFIS - HIแป†N TRแบ NG THแปฐC Hร€NH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG CHUแป–I CUNG แปจNG K...
ย 
ICAFIS - KHUNG CHรNH SรCH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN
ICAFIS - KHUNG CHรNH SรCH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขNICAFIS - KHUNG CHรNH SรCH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN
ICAFIS - KHUNG CHรNH SรCH TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN
ย 
ICAFIS - CรC CHแปจNG NHแบฌN Vแป€ TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN
ICAFIS - CรC CHแปจNG NHแบฌN Vแป€ TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขNICAFIS - CรC CHแปจNG NHแบฌN Vแป€ TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN
ICAFIS - CรC CHแปจNG NHแบฌN Vแป€ TRรCH NHIแป†M Xรƒ Hแป˜I (CSR) TRONG THแปฆY SแบขN
ย 
ICAFIS - ฤแป’NG QUแบขN Lร NGHแป€ Cร
ICAFIS - ฤแป’NG QUแบขN Lร NGHแป€ CรICAFIS - ฤแป’NG QUแบขN Lร NGHแป€ Cร
ICAFIS - ฤแป’NG QUแบขN Lร NGHแป€ Cร
ย 
ICAFIS - Presentation fisheries co management in viet nam
ICAFIS - Presentation fisheries co management in viet nam ICAFIS - Presentation fisheries co management in viet nam
ICAFIS - Presentation fisheries co management in viet nam
ย 

Recently uploaded

Role of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in Mining
Role of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in MiningRole of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in Mining
Role of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in Mining
Naaraayani Minerals Pvt.Ltd
ย 
Attending a job Interview for B1 and B2 Englsih learners
Attending a job Interview for B1 and B2 Englsih learnersAttending a job Interview for B1 and B2 Englsih learners
Attending a job Interview for B1 and B2 Englsih learners
Erika906060
ย 
Affordable Stationery Printing Services in Jaipur | Navpack n Print
Affordable Stationery Printing Services in Jaipur | Navpack n PrintAffordable Stationery Printing Services in Jaipur | Navpack n Print
Affordable Stationery Printing Services in Jaipur | Navpack n Print
Navpack & Print
ย 
ไธ€ๆฏ”ไธ€ๅŽŸ็‰ˆๅŠ ๆ‹ฟๅคงๆธฅๅคชๅŽๅคงๅญฆๆฏ•ไธš่ฏ๏ผˆuottawaๆฏ•ไธš่ฏไนฆ๏ผ‰ๅฆ‚ไฝ•ๅŠž็†
ไธ€ๆฏ”ไธ€ๅŽŸ็‰ˆๅŠ ๆ‹ฟๅคงๆธฅๅคชๅŽๅคงๅญฆๆฏ•ไธš่ฏ๏ผˆuottawaๆฏ•ไธš่ฏไนฆ๏ผ‰ๅฆ‚ไฝ•ๅŠž็†ไธ€ๆฏ”ไธ€ๅŽŸ็‰ˆๅŠ ๆ‹ฟๅคงๆธฅๅคชๅŽๅคงๅญฆๆฏ•ไธš่ฏ๏ผˆuottawaๆฏ•ไธš่ฏไนฆ๏ผ‰ๅฆ‚ไฝ•ๅŠž็†
ไธ€ๆฏ”ไธ€ๅŽŸ็‰ˆๅŠ ๆ‹ฟๅคงๆธฅๅคชๅŽๅคงๅญฆๆฏ•ไธš่ฏ๏ผˆuottawaๆฏ•ไธš่ฏไนฆ๏ผ‰ๅฆ‚ไฝ•ๅŠž็†
taqyed
ย 
Cree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBd
Cree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBdCree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBd
Cree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBd
creerey
ย 
The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...
The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...
The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...
awaisafdar
ย 
The-McKinsey-7S-Framework. strategic management
The-McKinsey-7S-Framework. strategic managementThe-McKinsey-7S-Framework. strategic management
The-McKinsey-7S-Framework. strategic management
Bojamma2
ย 
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
tjcomstrang
ย 
Skye Residences | Extended Stay Residences Near Toronto Airport
Skye Residences | Extended Stay Residences Near Toronto AirportSkye Residences | Extended Stay Residences Near Toronto Airport
Skye Residences | Extended Stay Residences Near Toronto Airport
marketingjdass
ย 
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptxSet off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
HARSHITHV26
ย 
Filing Your Delaware Franchise Tax A Detailed Guide
Filing Your Delaware Franchise Tax A Detailed GuideFiling Your Delaware Franchise Tax A Detailed Guide
Filing Your Delaware Franchise Tax A Detailed Guide
YourLegal Accounting
ย 
falcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-india
falcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-indiafalcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-india
falcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-india
Falcon Invoice Discounting
ย 
3.0 Project 2_ Developing My Brand Identity Kit.pptx
3.0 Project 2_ Developing My Brand Identity Kit.pptx3.0 Project 2_ Developing My Brand Identity Kit.pptx
3.0 Project 2_ Developing My Brand Identity Kit.pptx
tanyjahb
ย 
Pitch Deck Teardown: RAW Dating App's $3M Angel deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: RAW Dating App's $3M Angel deckPitch Deck Teardown: RAW Dating App's $3M Angel deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: RAW Dating App's $3M Angel deck
HajeJanKamps
ย 
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social DreamingExploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Nicola Wreford-Howard
ย 
Digital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdf
Digital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdfDigital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdf
Digital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdf
Jos Voskuil
ย 
FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134
FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134
FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134
LR1709MUSIC
ย 
Memorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.ppt
Memorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.pptMemorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.ppt
Memorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.ppt
seri bangash
ย 
Premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern Businesses
Premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern BusinessesPremium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern Businesses
Premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern Businesses
SynapseIndia
ย 
BeMetals Presentation_May_22_2024 .pdf
BeMetals Presentation_May_22_2024   .pdfBeMetals Presentation_May_22_2024   .pdf
BeMetals Presentation_May_22_2024 .pdf
DerekIwanaka1
ย 

Recently uploaded (20)

Role of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in Mining
Role of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in MiningRole of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in Mining
Role of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in Mining
ย 
Attending a job Interview for B1 and B2 Englsih learners
Attending a job Interview for B1 and B2 Englsih learnersAttending a job Interview for B1 and B2 Englsih learners
Attending a job Interview for B1 and B2 Englsih learners
ย 
Affordable Stationery Printing Services in Jaipur | Navpack n Print
Affordable Stationery Printing Services in Jaipur | Navpack n PrintAffordable Stationery Printing Services in Jaipur | Navpack n Print
Affordable Stationery Printing Services in Jaipur | Navpack n Print
ย 
ไธ€ๆฏ”ไธ€ๅŽŸ็‰ˆๅŠ ๆ‹ฟๅคงๆธฅๅคชๅŽๅคงๅญฆๆฏ•ไธš่ฏ๏ผˆuottawaๆฏ•ไธš่ฏไนฆ๏ผ‰ๅฆ‚ไฝ•ๅŠž็†
ไธ€ๆฏ”ไธ€ๅŽŸ็‰ˆๅŠ ๆ‹ฟๅคงๆธฅๅคชๅŽๅคงๅญฆๆฏ•ไธš่ฏ๏ผˆuottawaๆฏ•ไธš่ฏไนฆ๏ผ‰ๅฆ‚ไฝ•ๅŠž็†ไธ€ๆฏ”ไธ€ๅŽŸ็‰ˆๅŠ ๆ‹ฟๅคงๆธฅๅคชๅŽๅคงๅญฆๆฏ•ไธš่ฏ๏ผˆuottawaๆฏ•ไธš่ฏไนฆ๏ผ‰ๅฆ‚ไฝ•ๅŠž็†
ไธ€ๆฏ”ไธ€ๅŽŸ็‰ˆๅŠ ๆ‹ฟๅคงๆธฅๅคชๅŽๅคงๅญฆๆฏ•ไธš่ฏ๏ผˆuottawaๆฏ•ไธš่ฏไนฆ๏ผ‰ๅฆ‚ไฝ•ๅŠž็†
ย 
Cree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBd
Cree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBdCree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBd
Cree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBd
ย 
The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...
The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...
The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...
ย 
The-McKinsey-7S-Framework. strategic management
The-McKinsey-7S-Framework. strategic managementThe-McKinsey-7S-Framework. strategic management
The-McKinsey-7S-Framework. strategic management
ย 
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
ย 
Skye Residences | Extended Stay Residences Near Toronto Airport
Skye Residences | Extended Stay Residences Near Toronto AirportSkye Residences | Extended Stay Residences Near Toronto Airport
Skye Residences | Extended Stay Residences Near Toronto Airport
ย 
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptxSet off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
ย 
Filing Your Delaware Franchise Tax A Detailed Guide
Filing Your Delaware Franchise Tax A Detailed GuideFiling Your Delaware Franchise Tax A Detailed Guide
Filing Your Delaware Franchise Tax A Detailed Guide
ย 
falcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-india
falcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-indiafalcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-india
falcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-india
ย 
3.0 Project 2_ Developing My Brand Identity Kit.pptx
3.0 Project 2_ Developing My Brand Identity Kit.pptx3.0 Project 2_ Developing My Brand Identity Kit.pptx
3.0 Project 2_ Developing My Brand Identity Kit.pptx
ย 
Pitch Deck Teardown: RAW Dating App's $3M Angel deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: RAW Dating App's $3M Angel deckPitch Deck Teardown: RAW Dating App's $3M Angel deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: RAW Dating App's $3M Angel deck
ย 
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social DreamingExploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
ย 
Digital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdf
Digital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdfDigital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdf
Digital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdf
ย 
FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134
FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134
FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134
ย 
Memorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.ppt
Memorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.pptMemorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.ppt
Memorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.ppt
ย 
Premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern Businesses
Premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern BusinessesPremium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern Businesses
Premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern Businesses
ย 
BeMetals Presentation_May_22_2024 .pdf
BeMetals Presentation_May_22_2024   .pdfBeMetals Presentation_May_22_2024   .pdf
BeMetals Presentation_May_22_2024 .pdf
ย 

ICAFIS - PROMOTING INTEGRATION OF CSR AMONG ACTORS IN SUPPLY CHAIN OF WILD CAPTURE FISHERY IN VIETNAM

  • 1. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ Promoting integration of CSR among actors in supply chain of wild capture fishery in Vietnam Jenna Munden - ICAFIS August 2015 Eco-Labels for Capture Fisheries Eco-certification schemes for capture fisheries have existed for around 20 years, driven by the growing concern of the state of global fish stocks, increasing consumption of seafood and a perception that public mechanisms at the regional, national and international levels are failing in ensuring the sustainable management of marine resources (OECD, 2012). The intent of eco-certification schemes is to improve fisheries sustainability through market based incentives. Eco-labels provide a link between marketing and management and are playing an increasingly important role in fisheries sustainability. To be able to use an eco-label on capture fisheries products, the fishery wishing to use the eco-label must be assessed by a third party on sustainability standards developed by the eco-label organization. If the fishery is found to comply with the standards after a full assessment, then the fishery is certified and allowed to use the eco-label on its seafood products. Benefits of Eco-Labeling Schemes There are many perceived benefits from eco-labeling schemes, which vary between actors within the fishery supply chain. The fishing industry gains immediate benefits from eco-label certification, including; access to new markets, consolidation of existing positions in market, product differentiation and receiving a premium price for sustainably certified product. For example, after the MSC certified an albacore tuna (Thunnus alalunga) fishery in the US, the price fishers received increased by 32% (Pope, 2009). Retailers benefit from eco-certification schemes by enhancing their reputation as a responsible buyer through response to consumer demand, through potential for promotional opportunities and returns related to better risk management (Washington, 2008). Consumers benefit by gaining information on the origin of products and how they were produced and
  • 2. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ reassurance that their consumption habits are not having adverse effects on the marine environment. Government benefits from eco-labeling by the building of export credits (OECD, 2012). For fisheries which achieve sustainability through better management practices adopted through the eco-certification process, many long term benefits are gained. Operating costs from a well-managed fishery are reduced as seafood can be produced cheaper, resulting in greater profits for harvesters. Fish processors, traders and retailers will benefit from the assurance that their product supply will be stable through sustainable management. Investing in sustainable harvesting of fish species ensures job security for fishers, providing a stable livelihood for citizens and support to the economy. The preservation of native fish species and the marine ecosystem as a whole also certainly has a great value to citizens. Although there is a general agreement that eco-certification schemes play a positive role as an incentive for fisheries management improvement, solid evidence to support the claims made in terms of business and ocean biodiversity are at this stage anecdotal. Eco-labels are not successful in achieving their desired benefits in all markets. Markets best suited to the sale of eco-labeled products are those countries where the population is environmentally aware, there is an active civil society and media, seafood is sold in supermarkets, consumption patterns are based on a traditionally limited range of fish products and where fish products are commonly processed/packaged (Washington, 2008). Weaknesses of Eco-Labeling Schemes The intent of eco-certification schemes are weakened by; the existence of multiple systems and assessment methodologies causing consumer confusion, inconsistent application of criteria or certification of fisheries which have been deemed unsustainable by government and NGO's, weakening eco-label credibility and the false belief adopted by consumers that only certified products are sustainably captured (OECD, 2012).
  • 3. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ Capture Fisheries Eco-Labels The Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) is arguably the most trusted, credible and recognizable certification system for capture fisheries, often referred to as the โ€œindustry standardโ€ (WWF, 2012). MSC was founded in 1997 by Unilever and the WWF but become independent in 1999. The core objective of MSC assessment is determining whether product comes from a sustainably managed fishery. MSC sustainability criterion included in the Fisheries Assessment Methodology was developed based on the FAO Guidelines for Eco- labeling of Fish and Fish Products from Marine Capture Fisheries (FAO, 2009), focusing on fisheries sustainability and traceability. The MSC evaluation tools rely on three main pillars, with a range of indicators for each. The pillars include; independent scientific verification of stock sustainability, ecosystem impact of the fishery and the effective management of the fishery. Aspects of the exploited species, harvesting gear and area are all taken into account for assessment. In response to concerns that MSC certification is not applicable to data deficient fisheries, often observed in developing countries, a risk-based assessment model specifically applicable for these fishery types was developed (MSC, 2015). MSC also offers pre-assessments for those fisheries wishing to improve management practices, but not yet ready for a full assessment. The pre-assessment can function to identify gaps and areas of improvement for the fishery, identifying a clear path to full assessment. Retail giants such as Loblaws and Wal-Mart have committed to buying only MSC certified seafood and products. Globally, MSC certified fisheries are dominated by those harvesting white fish (haddock, pollock, cods) and salmon (WWF, 2012). The Friend of the Sea (FOS), established in 2006 is a less costly eco-labeling certification system (Table 1), more accessible for small-scale and artisanal fishers, whom make up 50% of its certified products (WWF, 2012). FOS incorporates social accountability principles from Greenpeace and has requirements related to carbon footprint. It bases its assessment on official stock assessment data and certification methodology is based on whether the stock itself is sustainable, not management. FOS will not certify fisheries that have seabed impacts or greater
  • 4. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ than 8% discards. It is applicable not only to capture fisheries, but also for aquaculture fish and seafood products (including fishmeal). A great volume of FOS certified fish come from the Peruvian anchovy (OECD, 2012). Dolphin Safe is an eco-label developed by the NGO Earth Island Institute in 1990, concerned with dolphin bycatch. It maintains agreements with all major tuna processors that they will not sell tuna caught by chasing, netting or killing dolphins. Dolphin Safe is criticized for not addressing issues in tuna fishing other than dolphin bycatch, such as the sustainability of tuna stocks or other environmental impacts of tuna fishing (OECD, 2012). Naturland, a German NGO, originated as an organic farming label but now has developed framework for the certification of aquaculture and capture fisheries. It targets small scale; artisanal capture fisheries which are export based and have high standards for sanitation (Forristall, 2009). Projects are undertaken on the basis of social, economic and ecological sustainability criteria, often acting as a development exercise for the whole community as well as a certification process. Heath care for fishers, social services and education are all part of the certification process. To date, only one fishery has been certified by Naturland. This was the nile perch fishery in Buboka, Tanzania, certified through a pilot project led by Naturland. Krav, like Naturland was originally established for certifying organic farm products but now also has a capture fisheries sustainability label. Krav is a Swedish NGO and its label is only used in Sweden. Fair-Fish is a Swiss label that merges sustainability issues with concerns regarding animal welfare and principles of fair trade (Fair-Fish, 2007). The Iceland Responsible Fishing Programme is an eco-label that identifies product origin as Icelandic and ensures consumers that the fish product was harvested under sustainable management practices (Iceland Responsible Fishing, 2015). Eco-Certification Preparatory Programs The Sustainable Fisheries Partnership (SFP), Fisheries Improvement Projects (FIP) is not an eco-certification scheme, but a business-focused NGO that
  • 5. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ works as an alliance between fishing industry stakeholders; retailers, processors, traders and harvesters (SFP, 2015). The purpose of FIP is to resolve problems or improve aspects of the fishery which need attention. To achieve this, FIP has a highly flexible structure, which can be suited to the fishery and local environment. In general however there are a number of steps in common for all FIP; formation of the FIP with fishery stakeholders, data assessment (bringing together the most current fishery data), fishery assessment (to identify challenges faced by industry), agreement to a work plan, the creation of a monitoring procedure and implementation (SFP, 2015). Although not mandatory, the final goal of some FIP is to guarantee the ability of the fishery to obtain MSC certification. Options for funding an FIP include commercial organizations, NGOโ€™s, international aid donors or government. A well-funded FIP is critical for its success. Recommendation Programs In addition to certification programs, many recommendation programs exist including; Seafood Watch, SeaChoice and Ocean Wise. Recommendations programs assess fisheries using available data and expert advice to assess fisheries with their standards to help consumers identify sustainably captured seafood. Seafood Watch is a recommendation program which evaluates the sustainability of fisheries products based on the guiding principles and conservation ethic of the Monterey Bay Aquarium in California. Sustainable seafood is defined as seafood from sources that can maintain or increase production without compromising the structure and function of ecosystems (Seafood Watch, 2014). The seafood recommendations apply to a single stock or species caught in single fishery and are made public through pocket guides, smartphone apps and online. Fisheries are assessed and classified as green, yellow or red. Green is the best classification, signifying the fishery product is from a well-managed fishery, yellow signifies that the choice is a good alternate but concerns exist with harvesting methods, and red signifies that the consumer should not purchase the product due to overfishing concerns or detrimental impacts on non-target species.
  • 6. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ SeaChoice is a similar seafood program as Seafood Watch, developed for Canadians in 2006. Assessment criteria are based on those of the Seafood Watch program, with the same green, yellow red classification scheme used to aid consumers in choosing to purchase sustainably harvested seafood (Sea Choice, 2013). Ocean Wise is a conservation program developed by the Vancouver Aquarium in Canada in 2005 to educate consumers regarding seafood sustainability. Its assessment criteria are also based on those developed by the Monterey Bay Aquarium. It works directly with restaurants, marketers, food services and suppliers to ensure that current scientific information is available to make eco-friendly seafood buying choices. Its label is used for seafood products which it has deemed sustainably fished through consultation with the scientific community and review of existing literature. Unlike Seafood Watch and SeaChoice seafood products, only two classifications of fisheries are used; sustainable or unsustainable (Ocean Wise, 2015). Eco-Label Certified Capture Fisheries in Vietnam Currently, there is only one MSC certified fishery in Vietnam. It is a small scale clam (Meretrix lyrata) fishery located in Ben Tre province, harvested by hand. MSC certification has allowed this fishery to gain access to new markets and 50% price increases for its product (MSC, 2015). Certification was enabled through support from the WWF and local provincial government (Department of Agriculture and Rural Development). In the 2008, Friend of the Sea certified a squid and cuttlefish fishery in Vietnam. This fishery is harvested via traditional small basket-shaped boats, with hook and line methods in Phan Thiet (southern Vietnam). Its certification however has run out and no further audits were conducted (Friend of the Sea, 2008). The Southeast Asia Fisheries Improvement Project is a joint FIP between Thailand and Vietnam, for improving fisheries that supply fish meal. For the Vietnamese portion, the areas of Ben Tre and Kien Giang were selected as areas of interest. Project support has come from commercial entities within the supply
  • 7. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ chain of farmed seafood including; retailers, processors, aquaculture producers and feed manufacturers (Far Eastern Agriculture, 2013). Way Forward for Vietnam For developing, tropical countries there are challenges to gaining eco- certification for capture fisheries products due to social, economic and ecological factors. Some eco-labels, such as MSC have attempted to address this issue, through developing risk-based framework for data-deficient fisheries. Fisheries in developing countries will need management and financial assistance to obtain eco- certification for their products. Governments and NGOโ€™s have been encouraged by the FAO (2009) to assist small scale fisheries in developing countries with the certification process, both with fisheries management capacity and financial aid. Other components of the value chain, especially retailers, obtain an unfair benefit from eco-certification schemes, reaping many rewards without contributing to costs. Retailers and other actors within the value chain should contribute to programs like FIP and MSC pre-assessments for fisheries in developing countries which they depend on for product supply. Action Plan for Eco-certification in Vietnam For fisheries in Vietnam whom gain appropriate support (from local government, international donors, NGOโ€™s or commercial entities) steps taken towards certification may include; use of the MSC pre-assessment to determine whether a fishery is ready for certification, if the fishery seems to comply fairly thoroughly to the sustainability criteria, continue to a full assessment in the eco- certification scheme of choice, if not, engage in a FIP. After following the recommended steps of an FIP, stakeholders may be satisfied or, eco-certification can be the final goal, given sufficient funds are available for a full, third party assessment (Marsh, 2009). For fisheries where no resources are available to implement a MSC pre- assessment or FIP, but the fishers are interested in certification in the near-future, the establishment of a functioning co-management system at the commune level
  • 8. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ represents an attainable goal. Co-management is the shared responsibility of resource management by the community and government (Pomeroy, 1995). Co- management is often the only realistic solution for ensuring sustainable harvest of marine resources in developing countries (Gutiรฉrrez et al., 2011). Effective fisheries management is essential to eco-certification schemes thus those communes that are already managed by a co-management system will be much more attractive for funders and investors of eco-certification programs. To achieve this goal, support from the local government is required for forming a Fisheries Association, developing the fishing right and to legitimize both the association and right through legal framework. Through these types of initiatives, eco-certification of fishery products will be much more accessible to a wide range of fisheries within the country, as well as providing a management system that can be used to control fishing effort, gears and open up the potential for conservation measures, such as fish refugia. Social Responsibility Social responsibility is defined as a businessโ€™ commitment to contribute to sustainable economic development, working with employees, their families, the local community, and society at large to improve their quality of life (Kotler and Lee, 2005). Social responsibility has become increasingly important for business success. Capture fisheries eco-certification schemes provide a means to gaining ecological responsibility credit, however often social aspects of the fishers and their communities are ignored. Some schemes do offer value in social, in addition to ecological responsibility, such as the Naturland brand, and to a lesser extent, FOS. For those eco-certifications that donโ€™t include social aspects, established social responsibility standards can be used to increase social responsibility credit (i.e. ISO 26000), or further, social responsibility certifications can be obtained (i.e. SA 8000 or Fair Trade). Benefits for businesses who practice social responsibility include; competitive advantage, reputation, ability to attract and retain workers and buyers, maintenance of employee morale, commitment and productivity, view of investors, owners, donors, sponsors and the financial community, and lastly its
  • 9. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ relationship with companies, governments, the media, suppliers, peers, customers and the community which it operates (ISO, 26000). Social Responsibility Standards and Certification Boards ISO (International Organization of Standardization) 26000 is not a certification board, but provides guidance on how businesses can operate in a socially responsible way. This includes acting in an ethical and transparent manner, as well as contributing to the health and welfare of society (ISO, 26000). Standards were established through 5 years of discussions by government, NGOโ€™s, consumer and labor groups around the world and are considered to be applicable internationally. For actors within the supply chain of capture fisheries, understanding and implementation of ISO 26000 standards can be used to increase social responsibility. SA 8000 is the worldโ€™s leading social responsibility certificate board which aims to protect the basic human rights of workers through improved workplace conditions and effective management (SAAS, 2015). The standards framework is based on the UN Declaration of Human Rights, International Labor Organization Conventions, international human rights norms and national labor laws (SAI, 2014). The certification is applicable for all industries and is based on site-specific assessments. For marine capture fisheries supply chain, having the processor SA 8000, in addition to an ecological responsible eco-label at the harvesting level could generate many benefits in international exports. Buying Fair Trade certified products ensures that producers or harvester representing the initial stage of the supply chain are getting a fair price for their raw materials. In addition, products labeled with this trademark ensures safe working conditions, environmentally sustainable practices, clean water access for communities, food safety, assurance against child labor, women empowerment and education. Fair Trade certified products have traditionally included commodities such as; coffee, chocolate, quinoa and garments (Fair Trade, 2014) but in 2014, Fair Trade expanded its brand to the fisheries sector with its Capture Fisheries Program. The four main objectives of this program are to provide empowerment,
  • 10. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ economic development, social responsibility and environmental stewardship to small scale fishers. To gain certification of the Fair Trade brand, the fishery must form a Fisherโ€™s Association and a Fair Trade Committee. A stipulation of this certification is that a Premium Fund is developed, paid to the harvesters by importers with every exchange and is used to cover the costs of improvement of fishery facilities, scholarships for fishers children, community development, with at least 30% to environmentally focused projects. Currently, only one fishery has been certified with the Fair Trade brand, the certification was finalized in March 2015 for yellowfin tuna of Ambon and Buru Islands in Indonesia. This fishery was certified as a pilot project for the brand and the product in now for sale in US markets (Artanti and Rufiati, 2015). Social Responsibility Certified Companies Vietnam As of March 21, 2015, there are 91 Vietnamese companies with SA 8000 certification. Of the 91, 8 companies are seafood processors. Products being processed include pangasius, tilapia, albacore, shrimps and octopus (SAAS, 2015). There is one Vietnamese producer (Cudliemnong in Cu Mgar) that has been Fair Trade certified, however it is in the agriculture sector. No capture fisheries in Vietnam have been Fair Trade certified (Fair Trade, 2014). Conclusion Eco-labels for capture fisheries have existed for the last 20 years, and since then, the number and diversity of certifying organizations and programs have grown substantially. From very narrow-minded beginnings concerned solely of single species bycatch (Dolphin Safe) to, broadly focused ecological eco-labels (MSC, Friend of the Sea) to all-encompassing labels which include social and economic aspects of fishers, in addition to strict ecological standards (Naturland and Fair Trade) representing a significant positive development opportunity for communities. For actors within the supply chain of fisheries (i.e. processors), social responsibility standards developed such as ISO 2800 can be adopted, or social certification programs can be pursued such as SA 8000 to further strengthen product brand and value. Market based programs have emerged such as Seafood Watch, SeaChoice and Ocean Wise which act as informative safe guides for
  • 11. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ consumers who wish to know which seafood to buy based on sustainable harvesting methods. Now, more than ever there is a strong demand and incentive for sustainable seafood products and traceability. Developing countries such as Vietnam wishing to gain benefits from eco-certification schemes face increased challenges due to a lack of management enforcement, limited financial resources and having fisheries which are predominantly data-poor and small-scale. To overcome these challenges, FIP and MSC pre-assessments should be pursued with the help of local government and donor-funded projects, and at the local level, a strong effort towards co-management of fisheries resources will help facilitate these projects in the future
  • 12. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ Table 1. Eco-label certifications for capture fisheries. The (*) symbol indicates that only a pilot project had been certified at the time of writing , thus broad scale information on certification was not readily available.
  • 13. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ Eco-label Founding Country and year Social Responsibility Principles Cost of Label Use Cost of certification and audit Annual Fee (USD) Length of certification validity Time for accreditation Marine Stewardship Council United Kingdom 1997 Ecological 0.05% of the wholesale price of certified fish $15,000- $120,000 $250- 2,000 5 years 1-2 years Friend of the Sea Italy 2006 Ecological Social $1,100 $5,500 N/A 3 years 4 weeks Naturland* Germany 2007 Ecological Social Economic 1 year Fair Trade* United States 2014 Ecological Social Economic 3 years 6 years SA 8000 United States 1997 Social 3% of revenues or $5,000 $8,500- $40,500 N/A 4 years 6 months-1 year
  • 14. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ References Artanti, A., Rufiati, I. (March 13, 2015). Fishers in Ambon Island and Buru Island received the worldโ€™s first tuna fair trade premium fund. MDPI Foundation. Retrieved from http://mdpi.or.id/index.php/our-program/fair-trade/item/55- fishers-in-ambon-island- and-buru-island-received-the-world-s-first-tuna-fair- trade-premium-fund Fair-Fish (April 4, 2007). Fair-Fish instructions for artisanal fishery. Version 2.3. 11 pg. Retrieved from http://www.fair-fish.ch/files/pdf/english/instructions.pdf Fair Trade (2014). Capture Fisheries Standard, Draft Version 1.0. 32 p. FAO (2009). Guidelines for the Ecolabelling of Fish and Fishery Products from Marine Capture Fisheries.Revision 1. Rome. 97 p. Far Eastern Agriculture (July 24, 2013). Improving fish meal supplies. Retrieved from: http://www.fareasternagriculture.com/live-stock/aquaculture/improving- fishmeal- supplies Forristall, A. (April 28, 2009). Lake Victoria Fisheries Project Launched. Retrieved from http://www.seafoodsource.com/news/supply-trade/lake- victoria-fishery-project- launched Friend of the Sea (2008). Fishery Checklist. Retrieved from http://www.friendofthesea.org/public/catalogo/Audit%20Report%20Checkli st%20Vietn am%20Squid%20and%20Cuttlefish%20Phuoc%20Hung%20for%20Appetai s%20and%20 Coop.pdf Gutiรฉrrez, N.L., Hilborn, R., Defeo, O. (2011). Leadership, social capital and incentives promote successful fisheries. Nature, 470 (7334), 386-9. Iceland Responsible Fishing (2015). The Certification Programme. Retrieved from http://www.responsiblefisheries.is/certification/ ISO 26000. Guidance on Social Responsibility-Introduction
  • 15. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ Kotler, P., Lee, N (2005). Corporate social responsibility: Doing the most good for your company and cause. Hoboken, N.J.: Wiley. MSC (2015). Retrieved from https://www.msc.org/ Marsh, J. (2009). WWF Fishery Improvement Projects. Bali Workshop. Retrieved from assets.panda.org/.../jessemarsh_wwffisheryimprovementprojects_wwf.ppt Naturland (2011).Standards Map, Retrieved from http://search.standardsmap.org/assets/media/Naturland/English/AtAGlance_ EN.pdf Ocean Wise (2015). Retrieved from http://www.oceanwise.ca/ OECD (2012). Eco-labeling and certification in the fisheries sector: summary report of the OECD/FAO round table. OECD Review of Fisheries 2011: Policies and Summary Statistics, OECD Publications. Pomeroy, R.S. (1995). Community-Based and Co-M anagement Institutions for Sustainable Coastal Fisheries Management in Southeast Asia. Ocean Coast Manage 27(3): 143โ€“162. Pope, F (2009). MSC Scheme Proves a Boon for Fishermen Despite fear Over Stocks. Times (UK) September 30, 2009. SAI (2014). Social Accountability 8000, International Standard. SAAS (2015). Retrieved from http://www.saasaccreditation.org/faq SeaChoice (2013). Retrieved from http://www.seachoice.org/ Seafood Watch (March 31, 2014). Seafood Watch Criteria for Fisheries. 80 p. Retrieved from http://www.seafoodwatch.org/-/m/sfw/pdf/criteria/mba- seafoodwatch-capture- fisheries-methodology.pdf?la=en SFP (2015). Fishery Improvement Projects. Retrieved from http://cmsdevelopment.sustainablefish.org.s3.amazonaws.com/2012/01/12/F IP%20Ov erview%20Jan%202012-d6749f2d.pdf
  • 16. International Collaborating Centre for Aquaculture and Fisheries Sustainability (ICAFIS) | Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) Floor 3, Block A7, No. 10 Nguyen Cong Hoan St, Ba Dinh, Hanoi, Vietnam | Office/Fax: +84-43-7245121 | Website: http://icafis.vn/ Washington, S (2008). Ecolabels and marine capture fisheries: current practice and emerging issues. Globefish Research Programme. Vol. 91. Rome, FAO. 52 p. WWF (2012). Smart Fishing Initiative: Wild-Capture Fisheries Certification Schemes. James Sullivan Consulting. Gland, Switzerland.