Green Winter
The Basics
• Voice: conversational, slightly sarcastic
• Audience: probably Canadians
• Purpose: warn against Global Warming
• Ideas: Show us that Global Warming will harm Canadian
Identity
• Details: Canadian symbols, typical stereotypes about
weather.
More Details
• Colours – emphasis on greens and browns
• Animals – moose, polar bear
• Canadian symbols: twoonie, Tim Horton’s, French,
hockey, snow
Rhetorical Appeals
• Ethos: credibility as environmental activist, shared values
with audience, fellow Canadian
• Pathos: uses humour to make point; doesn’t use particular
scare tactics.
• Logos: observation, details
• Values: Canadianism, economy
Going Deeper:
Some
Figurative/Symbolic stuff
• Interesting that Green is usually positive term, used
negatively here
• The elephant in the room (is this reference to US,
perhaps?)
• Lots of emphasis on fakeness – fake snow, fake moose,
artificial ice
Deeper Still
• Shared values are somewhat stereotypical, seem focussed
on rural or suburban Ontario. How about West Coast?
• Emotional appeal enhanced by the font. Caps add
sarcastic inflection
• Music in the video reflects changing tone of the
sentences.
Problems
• Missed irony/sarcasm
• Too general
• Telling rather than showing – need for specific examples
and talking about how/why rather than just what.

Green winter

  • 1.
  • 2.
    The Basics • Voice:conversational, slightly sarcastic • Audience: probably Canadians • Purpose: warn against Global Warming • Ideas: Show us that Global Warming will harm Canadian Identity • Details: Canadian symbols, typical stereotypes about weather.
  • 3.
    More Details • Colours– emphasis on greens and browns • Animals – moose, polar bear • Canadian symbols: twoonie, Tim Horton’s, French, hockey, snow
  • 4.
    Rhetorical Appeals • Ethos:credibility as environmental activist, shared values with audience, fellow Canadian • Pathos: uses humour to make point; doesn’t use particular scare tactics. • Logos: observation, details • Values: Canadianism, economy
  • 5.
    Going Deeper: Some Figurative/Symbolic stuff •Interesting that Green is usually positive term, used negatively here • The elephant in the room (is this reference to US, perhaps?) • Lots of emphasis on fakeness – fake snow, fake moose, artificial ice
  • 6.
    Deeper Still • Sharedvalues are somewhat stereotypical, seem focussed on rural or suburban Ontario. How about West Coast? • Emotional appeal enhanced by the font. Caps add sarcastic inflection • Music in the video reflects changing tone of the sentences.
  • 7.
    Problems • Missed irony/sarcasm •Too general • Telling rather than showing – need for specific examples and talking about how/why rather than just what.