SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
Mr. Robert Silva M.A
Purpose of Course
The goal of this course is introduce you to the International Relation
field.
How do we do this?
By introducing you to the major components and
theories and methods of Analysis of the International Relation
Field.
This course will be to educate you on how to use empirical
evidence to support arguments about your notions in
International Relations field.
The tools we use
Basic thinking techniques are used,
The Archaic categorizations
Epistemology, reasons and justifications why did they do it?
(Assumptions about reality, )
Phenomenology, What is the situation
(Explaining the situation – physical and metaphysical-)
Ontology, the parts of the situation, to categorize items
(Defining parts of the assumptions)
Phrenology , how did this situation emerge from the past
(Explaining of causes of behavior to the situation)
The basic paragraph and paper format and
cogent argument formula (P.I.E)
Point, Notion about Actuality, Hypothesis,
Information, Empirical Source, Ontology, Phenomenology
Explanation, Epistemology, Phrenology
Phrenology and Epistemology of I.R Theory
We discussed past established patterns of International Relation
behavior-this is called -
Realism, Rational Choice –Military might- Security Power Seeking
Liberalism, Rational Choice- Economic- Leisure Seeking-
Modern Theories- Sociological , Cultural, equal treatment, human
rights
Rational Choice argues human nature motivates policy behavior
Modern Theories argues motivates policy behavior
The Ontology of International
Relation
The parts of International Relations ,
States, Countries i.e Iceland and Turkmenistan
Multi National Corporation, Bechtel , Coca Cola, and Micro-Soft
Ethnic Groups, The Lapp People of Scandinavia , The Flemish
Nations of People, Turkmen Identity
International Governmental Organizations, United Nations,
Non Profit Organizations, Amnesty International, and Oxfam
Treaties, Laws of Nations, Rome Statue, Geneva Convention
Political Economy
Globalization, Multi-state interactions
Environmental Issues, Global Warming, Energy scarcity
International Conflict Mechanisms, International Court of Justice
Phenomenology of International Relations,
Structures of International Relations, relationships of States and actors
World Systems,
Bi-Polar, Cold war, Soviet Union and N.A.T.O
Multi-Polar, World Trade Organization
Hegemony , Domination of other states through economic and military influence
Soft Power- Social, Cultural, and Economic
Hard Power- Military
Levels of Analysis
International – State- Institutions- Leaders
Governance System versus Government Systems
Democracy versus Totalitarianism and its forms
Human Rights: interest versus Necessity
What is expected from the
student?
To listen, to me and others with a “Mindfulness”
All questions are about clarifications of the subject we
are discussing at that moment.
The topics are to thought about in World System and
Basic thinking modes of Analysis.
Opinions are to be logged on you Blackboard discussion
boards, this is were you can debate your fellow students.
( I give extra credit for discourse and cogent arguments)
Be respectful of other emotions, and feelings, We are
here to learn.
What is the course work?
Attendance/ Group analysis
Newspaper Articles: 10 analysis of ontology, phenomenology and an
analysis method.
Mid term: Scan-Tron / analysis of situations : Definition Test
Final: Scan-Tron / analysis of situations : Definition Test
Written Paper is optional, if you want to improve you grade or
replacement of a test.
If you get a passing grade on definition test minimum C grade it is
optional on the final test.
Grading policy
Attendance can have negative effects on grade,
Loosing points, is arbitrary. After three absents
lateness affects everyone.
Midterm test: 35% showing mastery of concepts of
International Relations
Final test : 35% Showing mastery of concepts and
applications of concepts.
Newspaper Articles : 30%
Bonus paper to save grade and boost to A status over B
status. This paper can move you from D to C+.
Newspaper article assignment
The Form of the answer :
Create portfolio
Author , Title of Article, Source , Date Publisher pg # Cite
Who is it? State or Non State Actor? Why
Subject of Article: Hard Power or Soft Power issue; Why?
Levels of Analysis: State, Institution or Individual; Why?
Bonus: Realist, Liberal or Neo Marxist epistemology of actor Why? .5% towards grade.
1 page per article each Article done properly is worth 3% of the grade, Poor:
1% , Competent: 2% , Excellence: 3%
Help me construct an Argument
Kantian Dialectic: Look it up
A=b and if B=C then A=C
Costco is a corporation, Corporations are institutions then Costco is an
institution.
B is in C; C is in A thus B is in A.
Clean water is about Quality of Life, Quality of Life issues are human rights
issue,
Clean Water is a human rights issue.
Is there more to Argument
Building?
Medieval Argumentation: Look it Up
If P is the situation then R is true,
If P is not the situation then R is not true,
If Gaddiffi is buying oil tankers then it is a soft power issue.
If Gaddiffi is not buying tankers then it could be a hard power issue.
The complex model of argumentation.
If A and B is in the situation then G is true,
If they are looking for security and deterrence then they could be a Realist.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Physical Geography Lecture 01 - What Is Geography 092616
Physical Geography Lecture 01 - What Is Geography 092616Physical Geography Lecture 01 - What Is Geography 092616
Physical Geography Lecture 01 - What Is Geography 092616angelaorr
 
Introduction to International Relation 2, hukum intl
Introduction to International Relation 2,  hukum intlIntroduction to International Relation 2,  hukum intl
Introduction to International Relation 2, hukum intlAiu Sofia Rahmi
 
Why International Relation Is Imporatant
Why International Relation Is ImporatantWhy International Relation Is Imporatant
Why International Relation Is Imporatanthadaitullah
 
International relations...intro 1
International relations...intro 1International relations...intro 1
International relations...intro 1hadaitullah
 
C5 - International Relation Theory
C5 - International Relation TheoryC5 - International Relation Theory
C5 - International Relation TheoryFatin Nazihah Aziz
 
Theory of international politics
Theory of international politicsTheory of international politics
Theory of international politicsPaul Alonzo
 
Introduction to International Relations
Introduction to International RelationsIntroduction to International Relations
Introduction to International Relationsaungkokotoe
 
What Is Geography Pics Slideshow
What Is Geography Pics SlideshowWhat Is Geography Pics Slideshow
What Is Geography Pics Slideshowgarcollins
 
Introduction to Physical Geography
Introduction to Physical GeographyIntroduction to Physical Geography
Introduction to Physical GeographyPun Wath
 
International relations(Introduction and its Theories)
International relations(Introduction and its Theories)International relations(Introduction and its Theories)
International relations(Introduction and its Theories)Wathan Lin
 
3 Approaches in International Relations
3 Approaches in International Relations3 Approaches in International Relations
3 Approaches in International RelationsWai-Kwok Wong
 
Theories of international relations ppt
Theories of international relations pptTheories of international relations ppt
Theories of international relations pptVivek Hind
 
Theories of international relations
Theories of international relationsTheories of international relations
Theories of international relationsgravy503
 
2013-2014 International Relations Lecture Slides
2013-2014 International Relations Lecture Slides2013-2014 International Relations Lecture Slides
2013-2014 International Relations Lecture Slidesabhishekmaity
 
03 the main theories in international relations
03 the main theories in international relations03 the main theories in international relations
03 the main theories in international relationsfatima d
 
Theories of International Relations
Theories of International RelationsTheories of International Relations
Theories of International RelationsJeffrey Hart
 
Introduciton to international relation
Introduciton to international relationIntroduciton to international relation
Introduciton to international relationAnjan Kumar Dahal
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Physical Geography Lecture 01 - What Is Geography 092616
Physical Geography Lecture 01 - What Is Geography 092616Physical Geography Lecture 01 - What Is Geography 092616
Physical Geography Lecture 01 - What Is Geography 092616
 
Tagalog Vocabulary Set 4 Alamat ng mga Daliri
Tagalog Vocabulary Set 4 Alamat ng mga DaliriTagalog Vocabulary Set 4 Alamat ng mga Daliri
Tagalog Vocabulary Set 4 Alamat ng mga Daliri
 
Introduction to International Relation 2, hukum intl
Introduction to International Relation 2,  hukum intlIntroduction to International Relation 2,  hukum intl
Introduction to International Relation 2, hukum intl
 
Why International Relation Is Imporatant
Why International Relation Is ImporatantWhy International Relation Is Imporatant
Why International Relation Is Imporatant
 
International relations...intro 1
International relations...intro 1International relations...intro 1
International relations...intro 1
 
C5 - International Relation Theory
C5 - International Relation TheoryC5 - International Relation Theory
C5 - International Relation Theory
 
Theory of international politics
Theory of international politicsTheory of international politics
Theory of international politics
 
Introduction to International Relations
Introduction to International RelationsIntroduction to International Relations
Introduction to International Relations
 
What Is Geography Pics Slideshow
What Is Geography Pics SlideshowWhat Is Geography Pics Slideshow
What Is Geography Pics Slideshow
 
Introduction to Physical Geography
Introduction to Physical GeographyIntroduction to Physical Geography
Introduction to Physical Geography
 
International relations(Introduction and its Theories)
International relations(Introduction and its Theories)International relations(Introduction and its Theories)
International relations(Introduction and its Theories)
 
3 Approaches in International Relations
3 Approaches in International Relations3 Approaches in International Relations
3 Approaches in International Relations
 
Theories of international relations ppt
Theories of international relations pptTheories of international relations ppt
Theories of international relations ppt
 
Theories of international relations
Theories of international relationsTheories of international relations
Theories of international relations
 
International relations
International relationsInternational relations
International relations
 
2013-2014 International Relations Lecture Slides
2013-2014 International Relations Lecture Slides2013-2014 International Relations Lecture Slides
2013-2014 International Relations Lecture Slides
 
03 the main theories in international relations
03 the main theories in international relations03 the main theories in international relations
03 the main theories in international relations
 
Theories of International Relations
Theories of International RelationsTheories of International Relations
Theories of International Relations
 
Introduciton to international relation
Introduciton to international relationIntroduciton to international relation
Introduciton to international relation
 
Origin and evolution of international relations
Origin and evolution of international relationsOrigin and evolution of international relations
Origin and evolution of international relations
 

Similar to First_Day_of_Class_International_Relatio

Critical Analysis Essay. 4 Easy Ways to Write a Critical Analysis with Pictures
Critical Analysis Essay. 4 Easy Ways to Write a Critical Analysis with PicturesCritical Analysis Essay. 4 Easy Ways to Write a Critical Analysis with Pictures
Critical Analysis Essay. 4 Easy Ways to Write a Critical Analysis with PicturesRoberta Turner
 
Balanced Scorecard Essay. Balanced scorecard in restaurant Essay Example Top...
Balanced Scorecard Essay. Balanced scorecard in restaurant Essay Example  Top...Balanced Scorecard Essay. Balanced scorecard in restaurant Essay Example  Top...
Balanced Scorecard Essay. Balanced scorecard in restaurant Essay Example Top...Brandy Rose
 
Total Quality Management Essay.pdf
Total Quality Management Essay.pdfTotal Quality Management Essay.pdf
Total Quality Management Essay.pdfAmanda Dahya
 
Essays Helping Others Rewards Your School - 100
Essays Helping Others Rewards Your School - 100Essays Helping Others Rewards Your School - 100
Essays Helping Others Rewards Your School - 100Jessica Hill
 
How To Write A Paper On An Interview
How To Write A Paper On An InterviewHow To Write A Paper On An Interview
How To Write A Paper On An InterviewAlyssa Schulte
 
The Context document explores theories related to gender and commu.docx
The Context document explores theories related to gender and commu.docxThe Context document explores theories related to gender and commu.docx
The Context document explores theories related to gender and commu.docxchristalgrieg
 
PartI DueFriday,38 .docx
PartI  DueFriday,38 .docxPartI  DueFriday,38 .docx
PartI DueFriday,38 .docxadkinspaige22
 
Causes Of Global Warming Essay. Essay on Global Warming- Leverage Edu
Causes Of Global Warming Essay. Essay on Global Warming- Leverage EduCauses Of Global Warming Essay. Essay on Global Warming- Leverage Edu
Causes Of Global Warming Essay. Essay on Global Warming- Leverage EduBria Davis
 
Problem Solution Essay Topics List.pdf
Problem Solution Essay Topics List.pdfProblem Solution Essay Topics List.pdf
Problem Solution Essay Topics List.pdfAmy Hart
 
Write a 3–4-page analysis of the difference between communicatio
Write a 3–4-page analysis of the difference between communicatioWrite a 3–4-page analysis of the difference between communicatio
Write a 3–4-page analysis of the difference between communicatiovickeylintern
 
Community Essay Example
Community Essay ExampleCommunity Essay Example
Community Essay ExampleAnne White
 
Pay For An Essay To Be Written Essay Writing Service 0 Pay For Essay ...
Pay For An Essay To Be Written  Essay Writing Service 0 Pay For Essay ...Pay For An Essay To Be Written  Essay Writing Service 0 Pay For Essay ...
Pay For An Essay To Be Written Essay Writing Service 0 Pay For Essay ...Tina Williams
 
Assignment DetailsYou have been working on your Unit 9 Assig.docx
Assignment DetailsYou have been working on your Unit 9 Assig.docxAssignment DetailsYou have been working on your Unit 9 Assig.docx
Assignment DetailsYou have been working on your Unit 9 Assig.docxfaithxdunce63732
 
Essay About New Yorker In Tondo. Online assignment writing service.
Essay About New Yorker In Tondo. Online assignment writing service.Essay About New Yorker In Tondo. Online assignment writing service.
Essay About New Yorker In Tondo. Online assignment writing service.Melissa Lofton
 
Social science homework help
Social science homework helpSocial science homework help
Social science homework helpandrey_milev
 
Social science homework help
Social science homework helpSocial science homework help
Social science homework helproman nnelson
 
Unemployment Essay. YouthUnemployment Essay PDF Labour Economics Unemployment
Unemployment Essay. YouthUnemployment Essay  PDF  Labour Economics  UnemploymentUnemployment Essay. YouthUnemployment Essay  PDF  Labour Economics  Unemployment
Unemployment Essay. YouthUnemployment Essay PDF Labour Economics UnemploymentKelly Simon
 
etting StartedRevised Final Proposal - Internal and External
etting StartedRevised Final Proposal - Internal and Externaletting StartedRevised Final Proposal - Internal and External
etting StartedRevised Final Proposal - Internal and ExternalBetseyCalderon89
 
Crazy Argumentative Essay Topics. Online assignment writing service.
Crazy Argumentative Essay Topics. Online assignment writing service.Crazy Argumentative Essay Topics. Online assignment writing service.
Crazy Argumentative Essay Topics. Online assignment writing service.Amanda Love
 

Similar to First_Day_of_Class_International_Relatio (20)

Critical Analysis Essay. 4 Easy Ways to Write a Critical Analysis with Pictures
Critical Analysis Essay. 4 Easy Ways to Write a Critical Analysis with PicturesCritical Analysis Essay. 4 Easy Ways to Write a Critical Analysis with Pictures
Critical Analysis Essay. 4 Easy Ways to Write a Critical Analysis with Pictures
 
Balanced Scorecard Essay. Balanced scorecard in restaurant Essay Example Top...
Balanced Scorecard Essay. Balanced scorecard in restaurant Essay Example  Top...Balanced Scorecard Essay. Balanced scorecard in restaurant Essay Example  Top...
Balanced Scorecard Essay. Balanced scorecard in restaurant Essay Example Top...
 
Total Quality Management Essay.pdf
Total Quality Management Essay.pdfTotal Quality Management Essay.pdf
Total Quality Management Essay.pdf
 
Essays Helping Others Rewards Your School - 100
Essays Helping Others Rewards Your School - 100Essays Helping Others Rewards Your School - 100
Essays Helping Others Rewards Your School - 100
 
How To Write A Paper On An Interview
How To Write A Paper On An InterviewHow To Write A Paper On An Interview
How To Write A Paper On An Interview
 
The Context document explores theories related to gender and commu.docx
The Context document explores theories related to gender and commu.docxThe Context document explores theories related to gender and commu.docx
The Context document explores theories related to gender and commu.docx
 
PartI DueFriday,38 .docx
PartI  DueFriday,38 .docxPartI  DueFriday,38 .docx
PartI DueFriday,38 .docx
 
PartI DueFriday,38 .docx
 PartI  DueFriday,38 .docx PartI  DueFriday,38 .docx
PartI DueFriday,38 .docx
 
Causes Of Global Warming Essay. Essay on Global Warming- Leverage Edu
Causes Of Global Warming Essay. Essay on Global Warming- Leverage EduCauses Of Global Warming Essay. Essay on Global Warming- Leverage Edu
Causes Of Global Warming Essay. Essay on Global Warming- Leverage Edu
 
Problem Solution Essay Topics List.pdf
Problem Solution Essay Topics List.pdfProblem Solution Essay Topics List.pdf
Problem Solution Essay Topics List.pdf
 
Write a 3–4-page analysis of the difference between communicatio
Write a 3–4-page analysis of the difference between communicatioWrite a 3–4-page analysis of the difference between communicatio
Write a 3–4-page analysis of the difference between communicatio
 
Community Essay Example
Community Essay ExampleCommunity Essay Example
Community Essay Example
 
Pay For An Essay To Be Written Essay Writing Service 0 Pay For Essay ...
Pay For An Essay To Be Written  Essay Writing Service 0 Pay For Essay ...Pay For An Essay To Be Written  Essay Writing Service 0 Pay For Essay ...
Pay For An Essay To Be Written Essay Writing Service 0 Pay For Essay ...
 
Assignment DetailsYou have been working on your Unit 9 Assig.docx
Assignment DetailsYou have been working on your Unit 9 Assig.docxAssignment DetailsYou have been working on your Unit 9 Assig.docx
Assignment DetailsYou have been working on your Unit 9 Assig.docx
 
Essay About New Yorker In Tondo. Online assignment writing service.
Essay About New Yorker In Tondo. Online assignment writing service.Essay About New Yorker In Tondo. Online assignment writing service.
Essay About New Yorker In Tondo. Online assignment writing service.
 
Social science homework help
Social science homework helpSocial science homework help
Social science homework help
 
Social science homework help
Social science homework helpSocial science homework help
Social science homework help
 
Unemployment Essay. YouthUnemployment Essay PDF Labour Economics Unemployment
Unemployment Essay. YouthUnemployment Essay  PDF  Labour Economics  UnemploymentUnemployment Essay. YouthUnemployment Essay  PDF  Labour Economics  Unemployment
Unemployment Essay. YouthUnemployment Essay PDF Labour Economics Unemployment
 
etting StartedRevised Final Proposal - Internal and External
etting StartedRevised Final Proposal - Internal and Externaletting StartedRevised Final Proposal - Internal and External
etting StartedRevised Final Proposal - Internal and External
 
Crazy Argumentative Essay Topics. Online assignment writing service.
Crazy Argumentative Essay Topics. Online assignment writing service.Crazy Argumentative Essay Topics. Online assignment writing service.
Crazy Argumentative Essay Topics. Online assignment writing service.
 

More from Dr. Robert L Silva II MA (10)

IranianRights
IranianRightsIranianRights
IranianRights
 
JapaneseEnergy
JapaneseEnergyJapaneseEnergy
JapaneseEnergy
 
Myth_of_Peak_Oil
Myth_of_Peak_OilMyth_of_Peak_Oil
Myth_of_Peak_Oil
 
Psychology_of_Terrorism
Psychology_of_TerrorismPsychology_of_Terrorism
Psychology_of_Terrorism
 
Red_Faction_Brigade_Law_Manual
Red_Faction_Brigade_Law_ManualRed_Faction_Brigade_Law_Manual
Red_Faction_Brigade_Law_Manual
 
Mercenaries_Freedom_Fighters_and_Self_De
Mercenaries_Freedom_Fighters_and_Self_DeMercenaries_Freedom_Fighters_and_Self_De
Mercenaries_Freedom_Fighters_and_Self_De
 
Al_Qaeda_Global_Revolution
Al_Qaeda_Global_RevolutionAl_Qaeda_Global_Revolution
Al_Qaeda_Global_Revolution
 
MasterThesis2010abcd
MasterThesis2010abcdMasterThesis2010abcd
MasterThesis2010abcd
 
Democracy_is_a_Morality_or_Ideology
Democracy_is_a_Morality_or_IdeologyDemocracy_is_a_Morality_or_Ideology
Democracy_is_a_Morality_or_Ideology
 
Post_Jungian_Analysis_of_Sudanese_Ethnic
Post_Jungian_Analysis_of_Sudanese_EthnicPost_Jungian_Analysis_of_Sudanese_Ethnic
Post_Jungian_Analysis_of_Sudanese_Ethnic
 

First_Day_of_Class_International_Relatio

  • 2. Purpose of Course The goal of this course is introduce you to the International Relation field. How do we do this? By introducing you to the major components and theories and methods of Analysis of the International Relation Field. This course will be to educate you on how to use empirical evidence to support arguments about your notions in International Relations field.
  • 3. The tools we use Basic thinking techniques are used, The Archaic categorizations Epistemology, reasons and justifications why did they do it? (Assumptions about reality, ) Phenomenology, What is the situation (Explaining the situation – physical and metaphysical-) Ontology, the parts of the situation, to categorize items (Defining parts of the assumptions) Phrenology , how did this situation emerge from the past (Explaining of causes of behavior to the situation) The basic paragraph and paper format and cogent argument formula (P.I.E) Point, Notion about Actuality, Hypothesis, Information, Empirical Source, Ontology, Phenomenology Explanation, Epistemology, Phrenology
  • 4. Phrenology and Epistemology of I.R Theory We discussed past established patterns of International Relation behavior-this is called - Realism, Rational Choice –Military might- Security Power Seeking Liberalism, Rational Choice- Economic- Leisure Seeking- Modern Theories- Sociological , Cultural, equal treatment, human rights Rational Choice argues human nature motivates policy behavior Modern Theories argues motivates policy behavior
  • 5. The Ontology of International Relation The parts of International Relations , States, Countries i.e Iceland and Turkmenistan Multi National Corporation, Bechtel , Coca Cola, and Micro-Soft Ethnic Groups, The Lapp People of Scandinavia , The Flemish Nations of People, Turkmen Identity International Governmental Organizations, United Nations, Non Profit Organizations, Amnesty International, and Oxfam Treaties, Laws of Nations, Rome Statue, Geneva Convention Political Economy Globalization, Multi-state interactions Environmental Issues, Global Warming, Energy scarcity International Conflict Mechanisms, International Court of Justice
  • 6. Phenomenology of International Relations, Structures of International Relations, relationships of States and actors World Systems, Bi-Polar, Cold war, Soviet Union and N.A.T.O Multi-Polar, World Trade Organization Hegemony , Domination of other states through economic and military influence Soft Power- Social, Cultural, and Economic Hard Power- Military Levels of Analysis International – State- Institutions- Leaders Governance System versus Government Systems Democracy versus Totalitarianism and its forms Human Rights: interest versus Necessity
  • 7. What is expected from the student? To listen, to me and others with a “Mindfulness” All questions are about clarifications of the subject we are discussing at that moment. The topics are to thought about in World System and Basic thinking modes of Analysis. Opinions are to be logged on you Blackboard discussion boards, this is were you can debate your fellow students. ( I give extra credit for discourse and cogent arguments) Be respectful of other emotions, and feelings, We are here to learn.
  • 8. What is the course work? Attendance/ Group analysis Newspaper Articles: 10 analysis of ontology, phenomenology and an analysis method. Mid term: Scan-Tron / analysis of situations : Definition Test Final: Scan-Tron / analysis of situations : Definition Test Written Paper is optional, if you want to improve you grade or replacement of a test. If you get a passing grade on definition test minimum C grade it is optional on the final test.
  • 9. Grading policy Attendance can have negative effects on grade, Loosing points, is arbitrary. After three absents lateness affects everyone. Midterm test: 35% showing mastery of concepts of International Relations Final test : 35% Showing mastery of concepts and applications of concepts. Newspaper Articles : 30% Bonus paper to save grade and boost to A status over B status. This paper can move you from D to C+.
  • 10. Newspaper article assignment The Form of the answer : Create portfolio Author , Title of Article, Source , Date Publisher pg # Cite Who is it? State or Non State Actor? Why Subject of Article: Hard Power or Soft Power issue; Why? Levels of Analysis: State, Institution or Individual; Why? Bonus: Realist, Liberal or Neo Marxist epistemology of actor Why? .5% towards grade. 1 page per article each Article done properly is worth 3% of the grade, Poor: 1% , Competent: 2% , Excellence: 3%
  • 11. Help me construct an Argument Kantian Dialectic: Look it up A=b and if B=C then A=C Costco is a corporation, Corporations are institutions then Costco is an institution. B is in C; C is in A thus B is in A. Clean water is about Quality of Life, Quality of Life issues are human rights issue, Clean Water is a human rights issue.
  • 12. Is there more to Argument Building? Medieval Argumentation: Look it Up If P is the situation then R is true, If P is not the situation then R is not true, If Gaddiffi is buying oil tankers then it is a soft power issue. If Gaddiffi is not buying tankers then it could be a hard power issue. The complex model of argumentation. If A and B is in the situation then G is true, If they are looking for security and deterrence then they could be a Realist.