THE FIRST
AMENDMENT
       The Basics
CHAPTER 13 QUIZ
Rights From Amendment I

•   Speech
•   Press
•   Religion
•   Assembly
•   Petition the Government
Freedom of Speech
• “Congress shall make no law
  …abridging the freedom of
  speech…”
• Pure speech v. symbolic speech
• Is this an absolute right?
• When can it be LEGALLY taken
  away
   – Endangering public safety
   – Advocating illegal activity
     Overthrow of Government (esp.
     wartime)
      • Alien & Sedition Acts (1787)
      • Espionage Act (1917)
      • Schenck v. United States
When Can It Be Regulated?
            • Flag burning in a protest?
               – YES (Texas v. Johnson)
            • Burning Draft Card?
               – No (US v. O'Brien)
            • Picketing a private residence?
               – NO (Frisby v. Schultz)
            • Three part test to uphold:
               – Within powers of
                 government
               – Regulation must be
                 unrelated to free speech
               – Other channels of speech
                 are available
Unprotected Speech
• Sedition: urges resistance
  to lawful authority or
  government overthrow
• Defamatory speech: false
  speech; damages character
  or reputation
   – Libel (written)
   – Slander (spoken)
   – Public official? OK
• Fighting words: violent
  reaction
• Student speech: can be
  regulated
The Court's Test
        • Evolution of established
          limits:
            1. Clear and present
               danger (immediate
               danger)
            2. Bad Tendency Doctrine
               (Restricted if it tended
               to lead to an illegal
               action)
            3. Preferred Position
               Doctrine (These are
               fundamental rights; will
               assume law is
               unconstitutional)
Freedom of Religion
• “Congress shall make
  no law…respecting
  the establishment of
  religion…[or]
  prohibiting the free
  exercise of religion…”
• Establishment Clause
• Free Exercise Clause
Separationof Church and State
              • Establishment Clause
              • No state-sponsored religion
              • Wall of separation: how
                high?
                 – Pledge of Allegiance
                 – Money
              • Everson v. Board of Ed (1947)
                 – New Jersey
                 – Public $ used to bus
                 – Upheld (furthered
                   education, not religion)
Lemon Test
• Lemon v. Kurtzman (1971)
• State aid to church is legal as along as:
   1. Have a non-religious purpose
   2. Can’t advance or inhibit religion
   3. Avoid excessive government entanglement in
      religion
• Engel v. Vitale (1962)
• Teaching of Intelligent Design?
Free Exercise Clause
• Polygamy (Reynolds v. US)
• Amish & compulsory
  education laws (Wisconsin
  v. Yoder)
• Jehovah’s Witnesses must
  salute the flag (West
  Virginia State Board of
  Education v. Barnette)
• Using peyote
  (Employment Division v.
  Smith)

First Amendment

  • 1.
  • 2.
  • 3.
    Rights From AmendmentI • Speech • Press • Religion • Assembly • Petition the Government
  • 4.
    Freedom of Speech •“Congress shall make no law …abridging the freedom of speech…” • Pure speech v. symbolic speech • Is this an absolute right? • When can it be LEGALLY taken away – Endangering public safety – Advocating illegal activity Overthrow of Government (esp. wartime) • Alien & Sedition Acts (1787) • Espionage Act (1917) • Schenck v. United States
  • 5.
    When Can ItBe Regulated? • Flag burning in a protest? – YES (Texas v. Johnson) • Burning Draft Card? – No (US v. O'Brien) • Picketing a private residence? – NO (Frisby v. Schultz) • Three part test to uphold: – Within powers of government – Regulation must be unrelated to free speech – Other channels of speech are available
  • 6.
    Unprotected Speech • Sedition:urges resistance to lawful authority or government overthrow • Defamatory speech: false speech; damages character or reputation – Libel (written) – Slander (spoken) – Public official? OK • Fighting words: violent reaction • Student speech: can be regulated
  • 7.
    The Court's Test • Evolution of established limits: 1. Clear and present danger (immediate danger) 2. Bad Tendency Doctrine (Restricted if it tended to lead to an illegal action) 3. Preferred Position Doctrine (These are fundamental rights; will assume law is unconstitutional)
  • 8.
    Freedom of Religion •“Congress shall make no law…respecting the establishment of religion…[or] prohibiting the free exercise of religion…” • Establishment Clause • Free Exercise Clause
  • 9.
    Separationof Church andState • Establishment Clause • No state-sponsored religion • Wall of separation: how high? – Pledge of Allegiance – Money • Everson v. Board of Ed (1947) – New Jersey – Public $ used to bus – Upheld (furthered education, not religion)
  • 10.
    Lemon Test • Lemonv. Kurtzman (1971) • State aid to church is legal as along as: 1. Have a non-religious purpose 2. Can’t advance or inhibit religion 3. Avoid excessive government entanglement in religion • Engel v. Vitale (1962) • Teaching of Intelligent Design?
  • 11.
    Free Exercise Clause •Polygamy (Reynolds v. US) • Amish & compulsory education laws (Wisconsin v. Yoder) • Jehovah’s Witnesses must salute the flag (West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette) • Using peyote (Employment Division v. Smith)