Dr. Kirtan Vyas (M. S.- Obs/ Gyn)
Asst. Professor
P.D.U. Medical College, Rajkot
# 98254 07702
KNOWS ALL
Dr. Kirtan Vyas(M.S.-Ob/Gy)
•Gujarat Uni. First-Gold medallist
•Gujarat Public Service Commission(GPSC) first
•Fellow in Gynec Endoscopy(Mumbai)
•Fellow in Ultrasonography(FOGSI)
•Publications in various International Journals
•Presented Scientific Papers and Chaired Sessions at State and
National conferences.
•Faculty at State and National Conferences
•Local Joint Secretary of SOGOG 2015-Gujarat State Org of Ob/Gy
•Organising Secretary for the First Rajkot Obstetrics and Gynec
Society Annual Conference 2015 and Committee Member at State and
National conferences
•Organizing secretary for the West Zone Yuva Fogsi 2016, Rajkot
Scientific Committee member at Mid Term SOGOG 2016, Diu
At present working as an Assistant Professor at P.D. U. Medical College
and Hospital, Rajkot
WHO IS DR. GOOGLE?
• Most famous doctor on
the planet
• Your Major Competitor
• Almost every one of
your patients consults
with Dr. Google before
they contact you
• Dr. Google only
performs house calls and
is open 24/7/365
4
DR. GOOGLE
CONSULTATION HOURS: 24 X 7
• When patient get sick, she
visits the doctor
• Proper Check-up &
medication
• She will take the
prescription to the
Pharmacy
• Then she hopes the
medicine will have a fast
effect on her
• Patient surfs anything that
pops-up in her head
• Helps her find information,
or give her a “pathfinder” to
trace the information
• Dr. Google offers many ways
to cure her needs
• Let’s find out which will
work
WHO’S DR. GOOGLE?
• Consultation at home
without fees
• Advice changes every time
on surfing
• Never pinpoints what is
wrong
• Patient Guesses and self-
diagnoses
• Patients trust what
Google says and they are
not seeing doctors because
of the same 6
SELF DIAGNOSIS
Dr. Google will never know a
patient nor care as much as a
physician will do
DR. GOOGLE DOESN’T KNOW
THE PATIENT
• can’t see or talk with the patient
• can’t hear patient story
• can’t smell
• can’t touch
It doesn’t have intuition or gut feelings
about patient
THE INTERNET BREEDS CYBER
CHONDRIA IN SOME AND FALSE
REASSURANCE IN OTHERS
• The more complex the problem, the more
likely your self-diagnosis is wrong
• ovarian cancer with expert consultation
diagnosed as a uterine fibroid
• Opposite may be true, and you could use the
Internet to convince yourself that there is
nothing wrong when you actually do have
cancer
GOOGLE INCREASES THE RISK
OF CONFIRMATION BIAS
• This bias occurs when a patient comes in looking for
evidence to support a pre-conceived opinion, rather
than actually listening for information that might
prove her wrong
• “I know that I have an ovarian cyst, so there is no reason
for my doctor to ask me any other question. He’s not
listening to me, I know that I have an ovarian cyst”
• Unfortunately, patient stopped listening because Dr.
Google says she has a cyst, and she is looking for
confirmation
DR. GOOGLE CAN SOLIDIFY AN
ANCHORING BIAS
• When a physician settles on a diagnosis too
early and then disregards other important
clues that don’t fit that diagnosis
• The patient can also have an anchoring bias
when they know what’s wrong with them, so
they leave out important details and dispute
any information from the physician that
doesn’t fit their diagnosis
DR. GOOGLE IS WRONG 59% OF
THE TIME
• According to the Pew Research Center’s
Internet and American Life Project, 35% of
respondents had researched a medical
condition in 2012 and of that group only 41%
of patients who diagnosed themselves online
said a medical provider confirmed their
suspicions
In the exam room, your story matters
more than your research
• Don’t let Dr. Google
get between you
and your patient
• If patient has already decided on treatment
and the physician disagrees, then she may
set up an adversarial relationship
Patient is only two clicks away from
garbage medical advice and junk
science
• Who is behind the “expert” Internet advice?
Being a celebrity does not make you a
medical expert
• NIH, ACOG,
• RCOG, PUBMED-Reputed
DR. GOOGLE DOESN’T REALLY
CARE ABOUT PATIENT HEALTH
• The Internet will never
replace human interaction
• It can’t show the patient
compassion, empathize with
them, give them a shoulder
to lean on, hold their hand,
rejoice with them or grieve
with them
“Just because
someone says
something, we
should not
believe its true”
Always Ask “Where is the Evidence ?”
Evidence Based Medicine is an Evolving
Science…...Life-long Self-directed learning……..
“The conscious, explicit & judicious use of
current the best available evidence in making
decisions about the care of the individual
patient.” *
Standardized care in Scientific way
Improves patient safety by eliminating unsound
practices
Keeps knowledge up to date
*Sacket DL, Evidence based medicine; BMJ 1996;312:71-2
EVIDENCE BASED MEDICINE
 Improves understanding of research
and its methods
 Confidence in managing clinical
situations
Better communication with the
patients
Prevents wasteful practices
Improves computer literacy and data
searching skills
Allows group problem solving and
teaching
Improves our reading habit
Goal of EBM
 Active management of the
third stage of labor(Ω)
 Antibiotics for asymptomatic bacteriuria in pregnancy(π)
 Single dose antibiotic prophylaxis for caesarean section(€)
 Magnesium sulfate for eclampsia(∑)
 Early initiation of oral fluid and food after caesarean
section(√)
EFFECTIVE EBM
×Pubic shaving, Enemas (∞)
× Routine episiotomy (£)
× Multiple micronutrient supplementation
during pregnancy (@)
× Micronised Progesterone for
threatened abortions (*)
× Tocolytics for Preterm Labor (©)
× Abuse of Oxytocin (®)
× Excessive use of Ultrasound, BT (Ø)
PRACTICES - NEED TO BE ELIMINATED
 Clinical research is constantly producing new findings that
may contribute to effective and efficient patient care
 Putting them in to practice is vital *
 Without current best evidence , practice-risks becoming
rapidly out of date , to the detriment of patient $
* Grimshaw. Oxford handbook of public health
$ Sacket 1996
 Clinical decision should be based on
best available scientific evidence,
informed by epidemiological and
biostatical reasoning
 (Ω) Maughan KL, Am Fam Physician;2006:15-73,1025-8
 (π) Varma R Eur j Obstet Gynecol 2006,Jan 1:124-1
 (€) Hopkins l, Cochrane Database 2000,(2): CD001136
 (∑) Duley Cochrane Database Syst Rev2001;(1);CD002960
 (√) Mangesi L Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2002,(3): CD001136
 (∞) WHO, C57-C76: August 2006
 (£) Cochrane Database syst Rev 2009,(3): CD001136
 (@) Merialdi M, RCT,J Nutr 2003;May 133:1626 s-1631 s
 (©) Sanchez-Ramos L, Clin Perinatol 2003, Dec; 30(4),841-854
 (Ø) J Ultrasound Med 1988 Sep;7(9 Suppl):S1-38
REFERENCESREFERENCES
T
H
A
N
K
Y
O
U

Dr. Google- Knows all

  • 2.
    Dr. Kirtan Vyas(M. S.- Obs/ Gyn) Asst. Professor P.D.U. Medical College, Rajkot # 98254 07702 KNOWS ALL
  • 3.
    Dr. Kirtan Vyas(M.S.-Ob/Gy) •GujaratUni. First-Gold medallist •Gujarat Public Service Commission(GPSC) first •Fellow in Gynec Endoscopy(Mumbai) •Fellow in Ultrasonography(FOGSI) •Publications in various International Journals •Presented Scientific Papers and Chaired Sessions at State and National conferences. •Faculty at State and National Conferences •Local Joint Secretary of SOGOG 2015-Gujarat State Org of Ob/Gy •Organising Secretary for the First Rajkot Obstetrics and Gynec Society Annual Conference 2015 and Committee Member at State and National conferences •Organizing secretary for the West Zone Yuva Fogsi 2016, Rajkot Scientific Committee member at Mid Term SOGOG 2016, Diu At present working as an Assistant Professor at P.D. U. Medical College and Hospital, Rajkot
  • 4.
    WHO IS DR.GOOGLE? • Most famous doctor on the planet • Your Major Competitor • Almost every one of your patients consults with Dr. Google before they contact you • Dr. Google only performs house calls and is open 24/7/365 4
  • 5.
    DR. GOOGLE CONSULTATION HOURS:24 X 7 • When patient get sick, she visits the doctor • Proper Check-up & medication • She will take the prescription to the Pharmacy • Then she hopes the medicine will have a fast effect on her • Patient surfs anything that pops-up in her head • Helps her find information, or give her a “pathfinder” to trace the information • Dr. Google offers many ways to cure her needs • Let’s find out which will work
  • 6.
    WHO’S DR. GOOGLE? •Consultation at home without fees • Advice changes every time on surfing • Never pinpoints what is wrong • Patient Guesses and self- diagnoses • Patients trust what Google says and they are not seeing doctors because of the same 6 SELF DIAGNOSIS
  • 7.
    Dr. Google willnever know a patient nor care as much as a physician will do
  • 9.
    DR. GOOGLE DOESN’TKNOW THE PATIENT • can’t see or talk with the patient • can’t hear patient story • can’t smell • can’t touch It doesn’t have intuition or gut feelings about patient
  • 10.
    THE INTERNET BREEDSCYBER CHONDRIA IN SOME AND FALSE REASSURANCE IN OTHERS • The more complex the problem, the more likely your self-diagnosis is wrong • ovarian cancer with expert consultation diagnosed as a uterine fibroid • Opposite may be true, and you could use the Internet to convince yourself that there is nothing wrong when you actually do have cancer
  • 11.
    GOOGLE INCREASES THERISK OF CONFIRMATION BIAS • This bias occurs when a patient comes in looking for evidence to support a pre-conceived opinion, rather than actually listening for information that might prove her wrong • “I know that I have an ovarian cyst, so there is no reason for my doctor to ask me any other question. He’s not listening to me, I know that I have an ovarian cyst” • Unfortunately, patient stopped listening because Dr. Google says she has a cyst, and she is looking for confirmation
  • 12.
    DR. GOOGLE CANSOLIDIFY AN ANCHORING BIAS • When a physician settles on a diagnosis too early and then disregards other important clues that don’t fit that diagnosis • The patient can also have an anchoring bias when they know what’s wrong with them, so they leave out important details and dispute any information from the physician that doesn’t fit their diagnosis
  • 14.
    DR. GOOGLE ISWRONG 59% OF THE TIME • According to the Pew Research Center’s Internet and American Life Project, 35% of respondents had researched a medical condition in 2012 and of that group only 41% of patients who diagnosed themselves online said a medical provider confirmed their suspicions
  • 16.
    In the examroom, your story matters more than your research • Don’t let Dr. Google get between you and your patient • If patient has already decided on treatment and the physician disagrees, then she may set up an adversarial relationship
  • 18.
    Patient is onlytwo clicks away from garbage medical advice and junk science • Who is behind the “expert” Internet advice? Being a celebrity does not make you a medical expert • NIH, ACOG, • RCOG, PUBMED-Reputed
  • 19.
    DR. GOOGLE DOESN’TREALLY CARE ABOUT PATIENT HEALTH • The Internet will never replace human interaction • It can’t show the patient compassion, empathize with them, give them a shoulder to lean on, hold their hand, rejoice with them or grieve with them
  • 20.
    “Just because someone says something,we should not believe its true” Always Ask “Where is the Evidence ?” Evidence Based Medicine is an Evolving Science…...Life-long Self-directed learning……..
  • 21.
    “The conscious, explicit& judicious use of current the best available evidence in making decisions about the care of the individual patient.” * Standardized care in Scientific way Improves patient safety by eliminating unsound practices Keeps knowledge up to date *Sacket DL, Evidence based medicine; BMJ 1996;312:71-2 EVIDENCE BASED MEDICINE
  • 22.
     Improves understandingof research and its methods  Confidence in managing clinical situations Better communication with the patients Prevents wasteful practices Improves computer literacy and data searching skills Allows group problem solving and teaching Improves our reading habit
  • 23.
  • 24.
     Active managementof the third stage of labor(Ω)  Antibiotics for asymptomatic bacteriuria in pregnancy(π)  Single dose antibiotic prophylaxis for caesarean section(€)  Magnesium sulfate for eclampsia(∑)  Early initiation of oral fluid and food after caesarean section(√) EFFECTIVE EBM
  • 25.
    ×Pubic shaving, Enemas(∞) × Routine episiotomy (£) × Multiple micronutrient supplementation during pregnancy (@) × Micronised Progesterone for threatened abortions (*) × Tocolytics for Preterm Labor (©) × Abuse of Oxytocin (®) × Excessive use of Ultrasound, BT (Ø) PRACTICES - NEED TO BE ELIMINATED
  • 27.
     Clinical researchis constantly producing new findings that may contribute to effective and efficient patient care  Putting them in to practice is vital *  Without current best evidence , practice-risks becoming rapidly out of date , to the detriment of patient $ * Grimshaw. Oxford handbook of public health $ Sacket 1996  Clinical decision should be based on best available scientific evidence, informed by epidemiological and biostatical reasoning
  • 28.
     (Ω) MaughanKL, Am Fam Physician;2006:15-73,1025-8  (π) Varma R Eur j Obstet Gynecol 2006,Jan 1:124-1  (€) Hopkins l, Cochrane Database 2000,(2): CD001136  (∑) Duley Cochrane Database Syst Rev2001;(1);CD002960  (√) Mangesi L Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2002,(3): CD001136  (∞) WHO, C57-C76: August 2006  (£) Cochrane Database syst Rev 2009,(3): CD001136  (@) Merialdi M, RCT,J Nutr 2003;May 133:1626 s-1631 s  (©) Sanchez-Ramos L, Clin Perinatol 2003, Dec; 30(4),841-854  (Ø) J Ultrasound Med 1988 Sep;7(9 Suppl):S1-38 REFERENCESREFERENCES
  • 29.

Editor's Notes

  • #2 Before I commence my presentation I humbly pay tribute to the visionary mentor of mine Dr. Rakesh Sinha Sir who left us alone and whose deficit will always be felt in the huge world of Gynec endoscopy….
  • #3 I being the opening speaker of the last day of mega congress, would be jumping to the scientific part to remain time bound. i m here to share my views on impact of “Dr. Google” on medical practice. Dr. google knows all : how many of u agree? Let us see in next few minutes whether dr. google can really replace human mind ??
  • #11 Internet research can quickly overwhelm patient, causing cyber chondria; when a person becomes overly anxious and convinces themselves that they have an illness when in fact they don’t
  • #18 Patient’s opinion does matter but don’t lead with the Google diagnosis
  • #24 Clinical expertise is individual judgment and proficiency, while evidence is best research update.. Both are complimentary- without clinical knowledge the best evidence is also useless and if we don’t use best research then the best clinical knowledge may too become out of date…
  • #30 A day might come that we rely on a search engine, named GOD…because Google still doesn’t have all the answers…