1
Direct Fusion Drive
for distributed terrestrial power
Michael Paluszek and Stephanie Thomas
PFRC-­‐2	
  Experiment	
  at	
  PPPL	
  
3/26/15
DFD Terrestrial
3
DFD: Small AND Clean
3/26/15
!  A 1-20 MW reactor is the size of a mini-van
!  Low radioactivity
-  Little shielding required to prevent neutron escape
-  Disposal at end of life is to move the DFD to a disposal site
!  Mass produced in a factory
!  Come with fuel for their design life
!  Multiple units provide higher power
!  Fixed base or portable units
4
DFD Fuel
3/26/15
!  Selected fuel is D + 3He (deuterium and helium-3)
-  Low neutron reactions (low radiation), aka aneutronic
!  Terrestrial helium-3 production enough for
100 MW power generation/year
!  Additional sources
-  Plenty of 3He on the moon
-  An operating DFD would spur lunar mining
-  D-D breeding reactors
!  Option is to use just deuterium
-  More neutrons but there may be ways of minimizing the
increase
5
PFRC Ongoing Research
3/26/15
!  Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory performing experiments with DOE
funding
-  Concluded PFRC-1 a, b, c in 2011; breakthrough achieved in FRC electron heating
methods
-  PFRC-2 operating now; goal is to demonstrate keV plasmas with pulse lengths to 0.3 s
-  MNX studies on plasma detachment via nozzle
!  Princeton Satellite Systems performing mission and trajectory design,
space balance of plant studies under IR&D
-  Four joint PPPL/PSS patents
6
DFD Phased Development
3/26/15
!  Complete PFRC-2
experiments – ion heating
!  Design PFRC-3 and conduct
experiments
-  Fast Track – design PFRC-3
subsystems to production
standards
!  Design and build PFRC-4
-  Burning plasma reactor
-  Would produce fusion power
!  Build prototype power reactor
!  Production
!  Roughly $50M to get to 3B
3/26/15
Nuclear Fusion Background
8
Magnetic Fusion Energy Background
3/26/15
!  Fusion power has been produced in D-T tokamaks
-  PPPL Tokamak Fusion Test Reactor (TFTR) 10.7 MW
-  Joint European Torus (JET) 16.1 MW
with a fusion energy gain (Q) of 0.6
-  Japanese JT-60 has effective Q (if DT were used) of 1.25
!  ITER will develop the engineering needed for baseload
power generation from D-T tokamaks
-  Prototype D-T reactor DEMO would follow ITER
!  Several other D-T-fueled configurations under study
-  Stellarators, spherical tokamaks, etc
9
Comparison of Reactors
ITER research reactor:
60 m tall
PFRC reactor: 8 m long
10
PFRC: Small and Clean
3/26/15
ITER PFRC
!  1-10 MW
!  Separatrix radius 30 cm
!  1e-3 volume and mass
!  5e-4 radioactivity (0.2
MW)
!  Tritium exhausted
!  Simple solenoid and no
breeding blanket
!  Ordinary materials
!  0.5 GW
!  Separatrix radius 8 m
!  Machine 60 m tall
!  400 MW radiation
!  Tritium fuses,
producing high-energy
neutrons
!  Complex coils and T
breeding blanket
!  Hazardous lithium
➨ ~1/1000	
  cost	
  
11
Fusion Core: D-3He (low level of neutrons)
3/26/15
!  Field Reversed Configuration (FRC)
-  Simple geometry
!  Heating with odd-parity rotating magnetic fields
-  Limits size to 20 MW
!  Confinement with high temperature superconducting coils
!  Burns D and 3He
-  Could use just D for terrestrial power
!  Field Reversed Configuration is a toroidal plasma with
closed magnetic fields
-  Small FRC not prone to tilt instabilities
!  Odd-parity rotating magnetic fields heat the plasma
-  The symmetry of this heating method improves confinement
3/26/15
What is Next?
13
Challenges of Direct Fusion Drive
3/26/15
!  Need to demonstrate a burning plasma
-  PFRC-3A or PFRC-4
!  Need to get or breed helium-3
-  Not that much needed, terrestrial sources have enough to support small-
scale implementation
-  Moon and gas giants, D-D breeding are future sources
!  Need all the supporting hardware to be have high reliability
-  Minimal maintenance
!  Radiation shielding
-  Neutrons (but not too many)
-  Bremsstrahlung – x-rays
-  Synchrotron
14
Ongoing Work
3/26/15
!  Numerical plasma models using LSP
-  PIC code
!  Ion heating experiment in PFRC-2
-  Expect additional grad students this year
!  Design of RF heating system
Growing commitments
15
For More Information
3/26/15
Michael Paluszek
map@psatellite.com
Stephanie Thomas
sjthomas@psatellite.com
Dr. Samuel Cohen
scohen@pppl.gov
Princeton Satellite Systems
6 Market St. Suite 926
Plainsboro, NJ 08536
(609) 275-9606
http://www.psatellite.com
15
3/26/15
Additional Information
17 3/26/15
Possible Fusion Reactions
3/26/15
p +11
B !3 4
He + 8.7 MeV
D +3
He !4
He (3.6 MeV) + p (14.7 MeV)
D + T !4
He (3.5 MeV) + n (14.1 MeV)
D + D !T (1.01 MeV) + p (3.02 MeV)
D + D !3
He (0.82 MeV) + n (2.45 MeV)
D-3He reactors will also have D-D reactions,
hence D-T reactions, unless the T fusion products
are quickly removed.
Boron - proton produces very few neutrons
DFD
T0kamak
18 3/26/15
Reaction Rates
3/26/15
Princeton Satellite Systems
Reaction Rates
10
0
10
1
10
2
10
3
10
−40
10
−38
10
−36
10
−34
10
−32
10
−30
10
−28
10
−26
10
−24
10
−22
10
−20
MeanSigmaV(m3
/sec)
Temperature (KeV)
D−D−n
D−D−p
D−T
D−He3
p−B11
D-T
D-3He
D-D
p-11B
x x x
Reactor operating
temperatures
19
Rotating Magnetic Fields
3/26/15
!  Parity refers to the RMF
dipole vector symmetry
!  Odd means it flips at z=0
!  Frequency is a fraction of the
ion cyclotron frequency for
the helium-3
!  Provides all the startup
power and a fraction of the
heating power during
operation
!  Would be 0.6 to 6 MHz
!  Antennas shown to the right
20
Reactor Crosssection
3/26/15
15 cm 10B4C shielding
Hi-T superconducting
M. Walsh,
K. Griffin

DFD Terrestrial

  • 1.
    1 Direct Fusion Drive fordistributed terrestrial power Michael Paluszek and Stephanie Thomas PFRC-­‐2  Experiment  at  PPPL  
  • 2.
  • 3.
    3 DFD: Small ANDClean 3/26/15 !  A 1-20 MW reactor is the size of a mini-van !  Low radioactivity -  Little shielding required to prevent neutron escape -  Disposal at end of life is to move the DFD to a disposal site !  Mass produced in a factory !  Come with fuel for their design life !  Multiple units provide higher power !  Fixed base or portable units
  • 4.
    4 DFD Fuel 3/26/15 !  Selectedfuel is D + 3He (deuterium and helium-3) -  Low neutron reactions (low radiation), aka aneutronic !  Terrestrial helium-3 production enough for 100 MW power generation/year !  Additional sources -  Plenty of 3He on the moon -  An operating DFD would spur lunar mining -  D-D breeding reactors !  Option is to use just deuterium -  More neutrons but there may be ways of minimizing the increase
  • 5.
    5 PFRC Ongoing Research 3/26/15 ! Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory performing experiments with DOE funding -  Concluded PFRC-1 a, b, c in 2011; breakthrough achieved in FRC electron heating methods -  PFRC-2 operating now; goal is to demonstrate keV plasmas with pulse lengths to 0.3 s -  MNX studies on plasma detachment via nozzle !  Princeton Satellite Systems performing mission and trajectory design, space balance of plant studies under IR&D -  Four joint PPPL/PSS patents
  • 6.
    6 DFD Phased Development 3/26/15 ! Complete PFRC-2 experiments – ion heating !  Design PFRC-3 and conduct experiments -  Fast Track – design PFRC-3 subsystems to production standards !  Design and build PFRC-4 -  Burning plasma reactor -  Would produce fusion power !  Build prototype power reactor !  Production !  Roughly $50M to get to 3B
  • 7.
  • 8.
    8 Magnetic Fusion EnergyBackground 3/26/15 !  Fusion power has been produced in D-T tokamaks -  PPPL Tokamak Fusion Test Reactor (TFTR) 10.7 MW -  Joint European Torus (JET) 16.1 MW with a fusion energy gain (Q) of 0.6 -  Japanese JT-60 has effective Q (if DT were used) of 1.25 !  ITER will develop the engineering needed for baseload power generation from D-T tokamaks -  Prototype D-T reactor DEMO would follow ITER !  Several other D-T-fueled configurations under study -  Stellarators, spherical tokamaks, etc
  • 9.
    9 Comparison of Reactors ITERresearch reactor: 60 m tall PFRC reactor: 8 m long
  • 10.
    10 PFRC: Small andClean 3/26/15 ITER PFRC !  1-10 MW !  Separatrix radius 30 cm !  1e-3 volume and mass !  5e-4 radioactivity (0.2 MW) !  Tritium exhausted !  Simple solenoid and no breeding blanket !  Ordinary materials !  0.5 GW !  Separatrix radius 8 m !  Machine 60 m tall !  400 MW radiation !  Tritium fuses, producing high-energy neutrons !  Complex coils and T breeding blanket !  Hazardous lithium ➨ ~1/1000  cost  
  • 11.
    11 Fusion Core: D-3He(low level of neutrons) 3/26/15 !  Field Reversed Configuration (FRC) -  Simple geometry !  Heating with odd-parity rotating magnetic fields -  Limits size to 20 MW !  Confinement with high temperature superconducting coils !  Burns D and 3He -  Could use just D for terrestrial power !  Field Reversed Configuration is a toroidal plasma with closed magnetic fields -  Small FRC not prone to tilt instabilities !  Odd-parity rotating magnetic fields heat the plasma -  The symmetry of this heating method improves confinement
  • 12.
  • 13.
    13 Challenges of DirectFusion Drive 3/26/15 !  Need to demonstrate a burning plasma -  PFRC-3A or PFRC-4 !  Need to get or breed helium-3 -  Not that much needed, terrestrial sources have enough to support small- scale implementation -  Moon and gas giants, D-D breeding are future sources !  Need all the supporting hardware to be have high reliability -  Minimal maintenance !  Radiation shielding -  Neutrons (but not too many) -  Bremsstrahlung – x-rays -  Synchrotron
  • 14.
    14 Ongoing Work 3/26/15 !  Numericalplasma models using LSP -  PIC code !  Ion heating experiment in PFRC-2 -  Expect additional grad students this year !  Design of RF heating system Growing commitments
  • 15.
    15 For More Information 3/26/15 MichaelPaluszek map@psatellite.com Stephanie Thomas sjthomas@psatellite.com Dr. Samuel Cohen scohen@pppl.gov Princeton Satellite Systems 6 Market St. Suite 926 Plainsboro, NJ 08536 (609) 275-9606 http://www.psatellite.com 15
  • 16.
  • 17.
    17 3/26/15 Possible FusionReactions 3/26/15 p +11 B !3 4 He + 8.7 MeV D +3 He !4 He (3.6 MeV) + p (14.7 MeV) D + T !4 He (3.5 MeV) + n (14.1 MeV) D + D !T (1.01 MeV) + p (3.02 MeV) D + D !3 He (0.82 MeV) + n (2.45 MeV) D-3He reactors will also have D-D reactions, hence D-T reactions, unless the T fusion products are quickly removed. Boron - proton produces very few neutrons DFD T0kamak
  • 18.
    18 3/26/15 Reaction Rates 3/26/15 PrincetonSatellite Systems Reaction Rates 10 0 10 1 10 2 10 3 10 −40 10 −38 10 −36 10 −34 10 −32 10 −30 10 −28 10 −26 10 −24 10 −22 10 −20 MeanSigmaV(m3 /sec) Temperature (KeV) D−D−n D−D−p D−T D−He3 p−B11 D-T D-3He D-D p-11B x x x Reactor operating temperatures
  • 19.
    19 Rotating Magnetic Fields 3/26/15 ! Parity refers to the RMF dipole vector symmetry !  Odd means it flips at z=0 !  Frequency is a fraction of the ion cyclotron frequency for the helium-3 !  Provides all the startup power and a fraction of the heating power during operation !  Would be 0.6 to 6 MHz !  Antennas shown to the right
  • 20.
    20 Reactor Crosssection 3/26/15 15 cm10B4C shielding Hi-T superconducting M. Walsh, K. Griffin