The Supreme Court of India ruled that all entries in an employee's annual confidential report must be communicated to the employee, not just adverse entries. This is because non-communication of any entry violates principles of natural justice and is arbitrary under Article 14 of the Indian Constitution. Specifically, the Court held that:
1) The appellant's "good" entry for 1993-94, which made him ineligible for promotion, should have been communicated as it was effectively an adverse entry.
2) All entries, not just adverse ones, must be communicated so employees can represent to upgrade entries, as this may affect their chances of promotion or other benefits.
3) Rules or orders saying only adverse entries need be communicated are
This document is a Supreme Court of India judgment regarding whether all entries in an employee's annual confidential report (ACR), or only adverse entries, must be communicated to the employee. The Court held that all entries, not just adverse entries, must be communicated so that the employee has an opportunity to make representations and request upgrades if they feel an entry is unjustified. Not communicating an entry was found to violate principles of natural justice and be arbitrary under Article 14 of the Constitution. Therefore, rules or policies stating only adverse entries need be communicated were found to be illegal.
Migrant workers in malaysia & protection under domestic lawnazuzila
The document discusses migrant worker rights and protections under Malaysian domestic law. It makes three key points:
1) Malaysian laws like the Constitution and Employment Act provide protections for both documented and undocumented migrant workers, guaranteeing them equal treatment and non-discrimination. However, in practice migrant workers face barriers in accessing justice systems.
2) While migrant workers have the legal right to join unions, some laws discriminate by prohibiting them from holding union leadership roles. Several laws also permit the "Foreign Workers First Out" discriminatory retrenchment policy.
3) Migrant workers need better support systems when pursuing legal claims to prevent employers from cancelling permits. The government should implement recommendations to allow workers to remain
The document provides an overview of termination of employees laws and challenges in Malaysia presented by Miss Loh Sub Mui. It discusses:
- The rights of employers and employees. Employers have the right to promote, transfer, and determine workforce size while employees have rights to security, safe working conditions, and union participation.
- Key statutory provisions around termination from the Employment Act 1955 including requiring notice periods of 4-8 weeks depending on length of service and allowing termination without notice by paying indemnity.
- Challenges around proving just cause for termination such as misconduct, negligence, poor performance, and managing probationary periods. Proper documentation of warnings and opportunities for improvement is important.
Presentation on Employment Law in Malaysia - for Masters class @ UniRazakKevin Koo
This document provides an outline and summary of a presentation on employment laws in Malaysia given by two students, Adnan Seman and Kevin Koo Seng Kiat, at Universiti Tun Abdul Razak. The presentation covers several key topics related to employment laws in Malaysia, including hiring processes and requirements, classifications of workers, rights and responsibilities of employees, minimum standards for wages and benefits, and regulations regarding termination of employment.
CONTRACT OF BAILMENT
Section 148 of the Indian Contract Act states that, Bailment is the delivery of goods by one person to another for some purpose, upon a contract that they shall, when the purpose is accomplished, be returned or otherwise disposed of according to the directions of the person delivering them.
BDL- Bharat Dynamics Limited has 3 units, at Knachanbagh, Hyderabad/ Telangana/ Vishakhapatnam. Now Application are invited for the various vacancies in BDL
The document announces job openings at Deccan Grameena Bank for the positions of Officer Scale-I and Office Assistant (Multipurpose). It provides details on the application process such as dates, fees, eligibility criteria including educational qualifications and age limits, and the selection process which will involve an exam conducted by IBPS and an interview. A total of 76 positions are available for Officer Scale-I and 77 for Office Assistant, with reservations for SC, ST, OBC, and physically disabled candidates. The pay scales and probation periods are also specified.
This document discusses the place of supply under the GST regime. It provides details on the determination of place of supply for goods and services under various circumstances. For intra-state and inter-state supplies of goods and services, the document specifies whether CGST/SGST or IGST will be applicable based on whether the location of supplier and place of supply are within the same state or in different states. It also discusses in detail the sections of IGST Act which determine the place of supply for various categories of goods and services, both when the supplier and recipient are within India and outside India.
This document is a Supreme Court of India judgment regarding whether all entries in an employee's annual confidential report (ACR), or only adverse entries, must be communicated to the employee. The Court held that all entries, not just adverse entries, must be communicated so that the employee has an opportunity to make representations and request upgrades if they feel an entry is unjustified. Not communicating an entry was found to violate principles of natural justice and be arbitrary under Article 14 of the Constitution. Therefore, rules or policies stating only adverse entries need be communicated were found to be illegal.
Migrant workers in malaysia & protection under domestic lawnazuzila
The document discusses migrant worker rights and protections under Malaysian domestic law. It makes three key points:
1) Malaysian laws like the Constitution and Employment Act provide protections for both documented and undocumented migrant workers, guaranteeing them equal treatment and non-discrimination. However, in practice migrant workers face barriers in accessing justice systems.
2) While migrant workers have the legal right to join unions, some laws discriminate by prohibiting them from holding union leadership roles. Several laws also permit the "Foreign Workers First Out" discriminatory retrenchment policy.
3) Migrant workers need better support systems when pursuing legal claims to prevent employers from cancelling permits. The government should implement recommendations to allow workers to remain
The document provides an overview of termination of employees laws and challenges in Malaysia presented by Miss Loh Sub Mui. It discusses:
- The rights of employers and employees. Employers have the right to promote, transfer, and determine workforce size while employees have rights to security, safe working conditions, and union participation.
- Key statutory provisions around termination from the Employment Act 1955 including requiring notice periods of 4-8 weeks depending on length of service and allowing termination without notice by paying indemnity.
- Challenges around proving just cause for termination such as misconduct, negligence, poor performance, and managing probationary periods. Proper documentation of warnings and opportunities for improvement is important.
Presentation on Employment Law in Malaysia - for Masters class @ UniRazakKevin Koo
This document provides an outline and summary of a presentation on employment laws in Malaysia given by two students, Adnan Seman and Kevin Koo Seng Kiat, at Universiti Tun Abdul Razak. The presentation covers several key topics related to employment laws in Malaysia, including hiring processes and requirements, classifications of workers, rights and responsibilities of employees, minimum standards for wages and benefits, and regulations regarding termination of employment.
CONTRACT OF BAILMENT
Section 148 of the Indian Contract Act states that, Bailment is the delivery of goods by one person to another for some purpose, upon a contract that they shall, when the purpose is accomplished, be returned or otherwise disposed of according to the directions of the person delivering them.
BDL- Bharat Dynamics Limited has 3 units, at Knachanbagh, Hyderabad/ Telangana/ Vishakhapatnam. Now Application are invited for the various vacancies in BDL
The document announces job openings at Deccan Grameena Bank for the positions of Officer Scale-I and Office Assistant (Multipurpose). It provides details on the application process such as dates, fees, eligibility criteria including educational qualifications and age limits, and the selection process which will involve an exam conducted by IBPS and an interview. A total of 76 positions are available for Officer Scale-I and 77 for Office Assistant, with reservations for SC, ST, OBC, and physically disabled candidates. The pay scales and probation periods are also specified.
This document discusses the place of supply under the GST regime. It provides details on the determination of place of supply for goods and services under various circumstances. For intra-state and inter-state supplies of goods and services, the document specifies whether CGST/SGST or IGST will be applicable based on whether the location of supplier and place of supply are within the same state or in different states. It also discusses in detail the sections of IGST Act which determine the place of supply for various categories of goods and services, both when the supplier and recipient are within India and outside India.
OBJECTIVE
The place of supply in GST determines the taxable jurisdiction where the tax should reach and ascertains whether the supply is inter-state supply or intra-state supply. This webinar shall deal with the place of supply with regards to various types of goods and services. It shall also throw some light on the valuation criteria in certain cases.
The Supreme Court of India heard a contempt petition filed by the National Federation of the Blind alleging willful disobedience of the court's 2013 order in a case regarding reservation of jobs for disabled persons. After hearing arguments from both sides, the court:
1) Noted that the government had taken steps to fill over 15,000 identified vacancies for disabled persons and committed to filling remaining vacancies, showing there was no willful disobedience.
2) Clarified that the 2013 order did not provide for reservation in promotions as the issue was not part of the questions before the court at that time.
3) Dismissed the contempt petition based on the government's efforts to fill vacancies and its clar
This document contains information submitted by a group to a professor regarding eligibility certificates issued by the Directorate General Resettlement (DGR) for ex-servicemen. It discusses that the DGR issues certificates to identify qualified ex-servicemen candidates for job opportunities under the defense category. However, the final selection is left to the decision of the hiring organization. The document also summarizes a court case where a certificate issued by the DGR for one location was questioned for use in selecting a candidate for a different location. The court upheld the validity of the DGR certificate and selection process.
The document summarizes a job posting for 65 Scale I Officer positions with General Insurance Corporation of India. It provides details on the qualifications, experience, and skills required for various disciplines including insurance, human resources, finance, engineering, IT, legal, statistics, and medical. The compensation package includes a basic pay of Rs. 17,240 per month plus allowances totaling around Rs. 38,500 per month. The selection process will involve a written exam to be held in Mumbai, Chennai, Kolkata, or Delhi followed by a group discussion and interview.
The Indian government has withdrawn an exemption for transportation of goods by vessel to an Indian customs station, making such import cargo transportation services taxable under service tax. The liability to pay this tax now falls under reverse charge on the person completing customs formalities for goods clearance. Clarifications have provided that trans-shipment cargo is still exempt, and the relevant notifications and circular on these changes are referenced.
The document summarizes job openings at the National Buildings Construction Corporation Limited (NBCC), a Government of India enterprise. It is seeking to fill positions of Management Trainee (Marketing) and Deputy Manager (Marketing) on a regular basis. The summary includes the job titles, pay scales, number of vacancies, required qualifications and experience. Candidates are advised to apply by the deadline of February 10, 2015 along with the application fee. The selection process will involve shortlisting, group discussion, personal interview or written tests.
This document provides information about recruitment of 1434 administrative officers across four public sector general insurance companies in India. It lists the company names and number of posts, and provides eligibility criteria including nationality, important dates, educational qualifications and age limits. The recruitment will fill various disciplines like finance, marketing, engineering, IT, legal and generalist roles. Reservation policies for scheduled castes, tribes and other categories will apply as per government rules.
United India Insurance Company LTD Recruitment Notice 2014 - ExamPunditTeamExamPundit
United India Insurance Company is a leading public sector general insurance company owned by the Government of India with over Rs. 10,000 crores in gross premiums. It has over 1600 offices throughout India and is recruiting young candidates for 323 positions of Administrative Officer across its offices. The positions are for both generalist and specialist disciplines like finance, automobile engineering, and legal. Candidates must have specific educational qualifications depending on the discipline and fall within the age range of 21-30 years, with relaxations for certain categories. Shortlisted candidates will be posted primarily in southern and western parts of India.
This document contains lecture notes on the Hindu Marriage Act 1955, Muslim Marriage Act, Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act 1956, Hindu Minority Guardianship Act 1956, and Special Marriage Act 1954 from Chanderprabhu Jain College. It discusses the essential elements, ceremonies, dissolution, and grounds for divorce under the different marriage laws. It also summarizes the provisions related to adoption, maintenance, guardianship, and emerging trends in marriage and family law like surrogacy, live-in relationships, and same-sex marriage.
Madhya Bharat Gramin Bank is inviting applications for Officer Scale-I and Office Assistant positions. The application period is from October 18 to November 18, 2010. Written exams will be held on January 23, 2011 for Officer Scale-I and January 30, 2011 for Office Assistant. Selection will be based on performance in the written exam and interview. The written exam will test candidates on reasoning, numerical ability, general knowledge and English/Hindi.
51 career pdf1_advertisement%20of%20executive-%202014DHARMENDERRAJ
The document provides information about job openings at Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL) Accessories Division in Lucknow. It lists openings for Senior Medical Officers specializing in Ophthalmology and Physician, a Security Officer, and Assistant Engineers specializing in Russian Translation/Interpretation. For each role, it provides the grade, qualifications required, experience needed, job responsibilities, and selection process. It also gives general eligibility criteria, application process details, and terms of employment. In summary, HAL is inviting applications from qualified professionals for medical, security and engineering jobs in its Accessories Division in Lucknow.
United India Insurance - Recruitment of Assistants 684 Vacancies - ExamPunditTeamExamPundit
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. is a leading Public sector General insurance company wholly owned by
Government of India with a gross premium of about Rs.10, 000 Crores. A rapidly growing company with more
than 1600 offices, highest network in the non life insurance industry throughout the country.
Company proposes to recruit young and dynamic candidates for its Offices all over India. Applications are
invited from eligible Indian citizens for the post of ASSISTANT.
Kaveri Grameena Bank Recruitment Office & Office Assistant- 14-2015(http://na...DHARMENDERRAJ
The document announces job openings at Kaveri Grameena Bank for various officer and assistant positions. Only candidates who studied Kannada in 10th standard or higher education up to graduation can apply for Officer Scale-I and Office Assistant positions. It provides details on the number of vacancies, pay scales, eligibility criteria including educational qualifications and experience required for each role, and application process and dates. The last date for online registration is January 6, 2015.
CONTRACT OF INDEMNITY AND GUARANTEE
Indemnity is defined in Section 124 of Indian Contract Act, 1872, while in Section 126, Guarantee is defined.
In the contract of indemnity, one party makes a promise to the other that he will compensate for any loss occurred to the other party because of the act of the promisor or any other person. In the contract of guarantee, one party makes a promise to the other party that he will perform the obligation or pay for the liability, in the case of default by a third party.
In indemnity, there are two parties, indemnifier and indemnified but in the contract of guarantee, there are three parties i.e. debtor, creditor, and surety.
The document summarizes key provisions around the place of supply under the Indian GST law. It explains that the place of supply determines whether a transaction is intra-state or inter-state, and which taxes (IGST, CGST, SGST) apply. For goods, the place of supply generally depends on where the goods are delivered or installed. For services, the place of supply may be where the services are performed or where the recipient is located, depending on the type of service and whether the recipient is registered. Specific rules are provided for various services like immovable property, transportation, banking, and telecommunications.
RITES Limited, a government of India enterprise, is recruiting 4 Engineer (S&T) positions. Candidates must have a BE/BTech in electronics or related engineering and 2 years of relevant experience. The job involves working on signal and telecommunication construction projects. Selection will involve a written test and interview. The position offers a salary of Rs. 40,000-1,40,000 per month along with other benefits. Interested and qualified candidates must apply online by June 25, 2019.
The document discusses the rules for determining the place of supply under the proposed GST law. It outlines separate principles for goods and services. For goods, the location and movement of goods determines the place of supply. For services, the document examines 12 specific service categories and determines the place of supply based on the location of the service, object, performance, recipient or supplier. It also includes a residual category. The place of supply rules aim to distinguish intra-state and inter-state supplies but may increase complexity for service providers.
This material is for PGPSE / CSE students of AFTERSCHOOOL. PGPSE / CSE are free online programme - open for all - free for all - to promote entrepreneurship and social entrepreneurship PGPSE is for those who want to transform the world. It is different from MBA, BBA, CFA, CA,CS,ICWA and other traditional programmes. It is based on self certification and based on self learning and guidance by mentors. It is for those who want to be entrepreneurs and social changers. Let us work together. Our basic idea is that KNOWLEDGE IS FREE & AND SHARE IT WITH THE WORLD
This document discusses promoting prevention and treatment of diarrhea through increased availability and use of oral rehydration salts (ORS) and zinc. It provides an overview of diarrhea as a major killer of children globally and in India. It outlines the components of effective diarrhea management using ORS and zinc, and discusses field challenges around low treatment rates with ORS and zinc in Uttar Pradesh. It then describes interventions being implemented in Uttar Pradesh to improve diarrhea management, including capacity building, supply chain strengthening, and a social marketing initiative in Lalitpur district.
This document outlines AIESEC India's marketing strategy for 2013 with a focus on three areas: brand evolution, engagement, and organizational reputation building. It discusses activities and key performance indicators (KPIs) in each area. The brand evolution section covers redesigning marketing materials and messaging. Engagement involves online efforts like social media and blogs as well as offline activities like campus events. Reputation building centers on partnerships, media coverage, and recognition. The overall goals are to increase awareness, leads and promoters through growth on social platforms and more contacts generated from events and recommendations.
OBJECTIVE
The place of supply in GST determines the taxable jurisdiction where the tax should reach and ascertains whether the supply is inter-state supply or intra-state supply. This webinar shall deal with the place of supply with regards to various types of goods and services. It shall also throw some light on the valuation criteria in certain cases.
The Supreme Court of India heard a contempt petition filed by the National Federation of the Blind alleging willful disobedience of the court's 2013 order in a case regarding reservation of jobs for disabled persons. After hearing arguments from both sides, the court:
1) Noted that the government had taken steps to fill over 15,000 identified vacancies for disabled persons and committed to filling remaining vacancies, showing there was no willful disobedience.
2) Clarified that the 2013 order did not provide for reservation in promotions as the issue was not part of the questions before the court at that time.
3) Dismissed the contempt petition based on the government's efforts to fill vacancies and its clar
This document contains information submitted by a group to a professor regarding eligibility certificates issued by the Directorate General Resettlement (DGR) for ex-servicemen. It discusses that the DGR issues certificates to identify qualified ex-servicemen candidates for job opportunities under the defense category. However, the final selection is left to the decision of the hiring organization. The document also summarizes a court case where a certificate issued by the DGR for one location was questioned for use in selecting a candidate for a different location. The court upheld the validity of the DGR certificate and selection process.
The document summarizes a job posting for 65 Scale I Officer positions with General Insurance Corporation of India. It provides details on the qualifications, experience, and skills required for various disciplines including insurance, human resources, finance, engineering, IT, legal, statistics, and medical. The compensation package includes a basic pay of Rs. 17,240 per month plus allowances totaling around Rs. 38,500 per month. The selection process will involve a written exam to be held in Mumbai, Chennai, Kolkata, or Delhi followed by a group discussion and interview.
The Indian government has withdrawn an exemption for transportation of goods by vessel to an Indian customs station, making such import cargo transportation services taxable under service tax. The liability to pay this tax now falls under reverse charge on the person completing customs formalities for goods clearance. Clarifications have provided that trans-shipment cargo is still exempt, and the relevant notifications and circular on these changes are referenced.
The document summarizes job openings at the National Buildings Construction Corporation Limited (NBCC), a Government of India enterprise. It is seeking to fill positions of Management Trainee (Marketing) and Deputy Manager (Marketing) on a regular basis. The summary includes the job titles, pay scales, number of vacancies, required qualifications and experience. Candidates are advised to apply by the deadline of February 10, 2015 along with the application fee. The selection process will involve shortlisting, group discussion, personal interview or written tests.
This document provides information about recruitment of 1434 administrative officers across four public sector general insurance companies in India. It lists the company names and number of posts, and provides eligibility criteria including nationality, important dates, educational qualifications and age limits. The recruitment will fill various disciplines like finance, marketing, engineering, IT, legal and generalist roles. Reservation policies for scheduled castes, tribes and other categories will apply as per government rules.
United India Insurance Company LTD Recruitment Notice 2014 - ExamPunditTeamExamPundit
United India Insurance Company is a leading public sector general insurance company owned by the Government of India with over Rs. 10,000 crores in gross premiums. It has over 1600 offices throughout India and is recruiting young candidates for 323 positions of Administrative Officer across its offices. The positions are for both generalist and specialist disciplines like finance, automobile engineering, and legal. Candidates must have specific educational qualifications depending on the discipline and fall within the age range of 21-30 years, with relaxations for certain categories. Shortlisted candidates will be posted primarily in southern and western parts of India.
This document contains lecture notes on the Hindu Marriage Act 1955, Muslim Marriage Act, Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act 1956, Hindu Minority Guardianship Act 1956, and Special Marriage Act 1954 from Chanderprabhu Jain College. It discusses the essential elements, ceremonies, dissolution, and grounds for divorce under the different marriage laws. It also summarizes the provisions related to adoption, maintenance, guardianship, and emerging trends in marriage and family law like surrogacy, live-in relationships, and same-sex marriage.
Madhya Bharat Gramin Bank is inviting applications for Officer Scale-I and Office Assistant positions. The application period is from October 18 to November 18, 2010. Written exams will be held on January 23, 2011 for Officer Scale-I and January 30, 2011 for Office Assistant. Selection will be based on performance in the written exam and interview. The written exam will test candidates on reasoning, numerical ability, general knowledge and English/Hindi.
51 career pdf1_advertisement%20of%20executive-%202014DHARMENDERRAJ
The document provides information about job openings at Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL) Accessories Division in Lucknow. It lists openings for Senior Medical Officers specializing in Ophthalmology and Physician, a Security Officer, and Assistant Engineers specializing in Russian Translation/Interpretation. For each role, it provides the grade, qualifications required, experience needed, job responsibilities, and selection process. It also gives general eligibility criteria, application process details, and terms of employment. In summary, HAL is inviting applications from qualified professionals for medical, security and engineering jobs in its Accessories Division in Lucknow.
United India Insurance - Recruitment of Assistants 684 Vacancies - ExamPunditTeamExamPundit
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. is a leading Public sector General insurance company wholly owned by
Government of India with a gross premium of about Rs.10, 000 Crores. A rapidly growing company with more
than 1600 offices, highest network in the non life insurance industry throughout the country.
Company proposes to recruit young and dynamic candidates for its Offices all over India. Applications are
invited from eligible Indian citizens for the post of ASSISTANT.
Kaveri Grameena Bank Recruitment Office & Office Assistant- 14-2015(http://na...DHARMENDERRAJ
The document announces job openings at Kaveri Grameena Bank for various officer and assistant positions. Only candidates who studied Kannada in 10th standard or higher education up to graduation can apply for Officer Scale-I and Office Assistant positions. It provides details on the number of vacancies, pay scales, eligibility criteria including educational qualifications and experience required for each role, and application process and dates. The last date for online registration is January 6, 2015.
CONTRACT OF INDEMNITY AND GUARANTEE
Indemnity is defined in Section 124 of Indian Contract Act, 1872, while in Section 126, Guarantee is defined.
In the contract of indemnity, one party makes a promise to the other that he will compensate for any loss occurred to the other party because of the act of the promisor or any other person. In the contract of guarantee, one party makes a promise to the other party that he will perform the obligation or pay for the liability, in the case of default by a third party.
In indemnity, there are two parties, indemnifier and indemnified but in the contract of guarantee, there are three parties i.e. debtor, creditor, and surety.
The document summarizes key provisions around the place of supply under the Indian GST law. It explains that the place of supply determines whether a transaction is intra-state or inter-state, and which taxes (IGST, CGST, SGST) apply. For goods, the place of supply generally depends on where the goods are delivered or installed. For services, the place of supply may be where the services are performed or where the recipient is located, depending on the type of service and whether the recipient is registered. Specific rules are provided for various services like immovable property, transportation, banking, and telecommunications.
RITES Limited, a government of India enterprise, is recruiting 4 Engineer (S&T) positions. Candidates must have a BE/BTech in electronics or related engineering and 2 years of relevant experience. The job involves working on signal and telecommunication construction projects. Selection will involve a written test and interview. The position offers a salary of Rs. 40,000-1,40,000 per month along with other benefits. Interested and qualified candidates must apply online by June 25, 2019.
The document discusses the rules for determining the place of supply under the proposed GST law. It outlines separate principles for goods and services. For goods, the location and movement of goods determines the place of supply. For services, the document examines 12 specific service categories and determines the place of supply based on the location of the service, object, performance, recipient or supplier. It also includes a residual category. The place of supply rules aim to distinguish intra-state and inter-state supplies but may increase complexity for service providers.
This material is for PGPSE / CSE students of AFTERSCHOOOL. PGPSE / CSE are free online programme - open for all - free for all - to promote entrepreneurship and social entrepreneurship PGPSE is for those who want to transform the world. It is different from MBA, BBA, CFA, CA,CS,ICWA and other traditional programmes. It is based on self certification and based on self learning and guidance by mentors. It is for those who want to be entrepreneurs and social changers. Let us work together. Our basic idea is that KNOWLEDGE IS FREE & AND SHARE IT WITH THE WORLD
This document discusses promoting prevention and treatment of diarrhea through increased availability and use of oral rehydration salts (ORS) and zinc. It provides an overview of diarrhea as a major killer of children globally and in India. It outlines the components of effective diarrhea management using ORS and zinc, and discusses field challenges around low treatment rates with ORS and zinc in Uttar Pradesh. It then describes interventions being implemented in Uttar Pradesh to improve diarrhea management, including capacity building, supply chain strengthening, and a social marketing initiative in Lalitpur district.
This document outlines AIESEC India's marketing strategy for 2013 with a focus on three areas: brand evolution, engagement, and organizational reputation building. It discusses activities and key performance indicators (KPIs) in each area. The brand evolution section covers redesigning marketing materials and messaging. Engagement involves online efforts like social media and blogs as well as offline activities like campus events. Reputation building centers on partnerships, media coverage, and recognition. The overall goals are to increase awareness, leads and promoters through growth on social platforms and more contacts generated from events and recommendations.
This document proposes an intervention to reduce diarrheal disease in rural southern India through a water filtration and ORS education campaign. The intervention includes installing water filters to provide safe drinking water and training community health workers to educate mothers on proper ORS use. The water filtration campaign will include an awareness campaign, training maintenance workers, installing filters, and maintaining filters. Its impact will be evaluated through a retrospective cohort study measuring reported diarrhea cases. The ORS education campaign will design a curriculum, identify mothers, train community health workers, and administer ORS education. Its impact will be evaluated through a pre-post test measuring ORS knowledge, attitudes and behaviors. The intervention aims to reduce under-five diarrhea incidence and mortality by providing safe water and
Social marketing aims to change behaviors to improve public health and economic well-being by considering people as customers rather than beneficiaries. Sanitation, hygiene, and water harvesting are essential for public health and wealth in urban areas. The document discusses social marketing strategies used in India for total sanitation campaigns, including hygiene promotion, sanitation product promotion, and awareness campaigns using TV commercials, mobile apps, and brand ambassadors. It provides examples of innovative community-led sanitation projects in India and case studies of successful rainwater harvesting programs in states like Tamil Nadu, Rajasthan, and Kerala that have improved water access and quality.
The document discusses creating a command line interface (CLI) in the cloud using the WadRobotFramework (WRF). WRF allows creating robots on Google Wave more quickly than the normal API. The presentation demonstrates using WRF to build robots on Google App Engine/Java that act as commands and compose a language to manage a website or use GAE/J as a personal computer from anywhere through access via chat, email, etc. Some benefits mentioned are ad-hoc software, 24/7 Java hosting, and browser access.
The document contains instructions and templates for a PowerPoint presentation. It includes templates for titles, diagrams, cycles, charts, and tables. It also includes a tip about how to apply a logo to all slides using the slide master. The templates can be customized by adding text or changing images.
Chemical energy is stored in the bonds between compounds and particles and allows for transformations when energy is absorbed. Mechanical energy is the energy of moving objects and potential energy from gravity. Radiant energy travels in waves like light from the sun to provide warmth. Electrical energy is the movement of electrons along conductors to power devices. Nuclear energy is stored in atom nuclei and released during fission or fusion with heat and radiation.
The marketing plan outlines the agent's strategy for selling a home. It involves pre-marketing activities like taking photos and videos, informing other agents of the upcoming listing, and preparing ads. The plan then discusses MLS marketing, ongoing marketing reviews, negotiating strategy, and post-offer support through closing. The document emphasizes representing the homeowner, obtaining the best price and terms, and ensuring a successful sale.
El documento proporciona instrucciones en 5 pasos para ingresar a la plataforma educativa SCOLARTIC, incluyendo usar el navegador Google Chrome, hacer clic en las barras indicadoras, ingresar el correo electrónico y contraseña, y si se olvidó la contraseña, hacer clic en "olvide mi contraseña" y seguir los pasos para restablecerla.
This document provides details about the Montevalle Community Park project located in Chula Vista, California. As the project manager and landscape architect, I oversaw the design and construction of the 29-acre park which included multiple recreational amenities like fields, courts, a skate park, playground, and dog parks that reflected the site's agricultural history. I was responsible for the project from schematic design through construction administration.
The document provides a summary of important legal judgments, compliance requirements, and news related to labour laws in India for April and May 2015. Some key points include:
- The Supreme Court ruled that civil courts cannot decide labour disputes and termination is void without following proper procedures.
- High Courts provided judgments on issues like transfers not being challenges under the I.D. Act, financial difficulties justifying waiver of EPF damages, and outsourcing leading to retrenchment.
- The compliance calendar outlines mandatory contribution remittance dates for PF, ESI, and other schemes in April and May.
- EPFO launched initiatives to improve services like an office for large employers and replacing old forms.
The document summarizes an employment grievance case between Segran Nair and Carpenters Fiji Limited regarding Nair's summary dismissal from his role as a Supervisor at Carpenters Motors. The dismissal was made on July 16, 2010 for alleged gross misconduct and neglect of duties, including buying and selling vehicles in conflict with the company's core business, failing to control staff which led to unaccounted stock, and failing to prevent staff from pocketing money from old tire sales. The Employment Relations Tribunal was tasked with determining if the dismissal was lawful and fair or unjustified. In hearings, the employer provided evidence from an auditor who conducted a company-wide audit in 2010, including of Nair's department, to
Proposed Amendments to the Apprentices Act, 1961ADP India
ADP presents newsletter on Apprentice Act. The Apprentices Act, 1961 was enacted with the objective of regulating the program of training of apprentices in the industry by utilizing the facilities available therein for imparting on-the-job training. The Act makes it obligatory for employers to engage apprentices in designated trades to impart apprenticeship training on the job in industry to school leavers and ITI pass outs, Graduates engineer, Diploma holder and Certificate in 10+2 vocational stream to develop skilled manpower.
Read More at: http://www.adp.in/resources/newsletters/Strictly-Statutes-July-14.pdf
- The Consumer Protection Act was enacted to better protect consumer interests in India. It applies to all of India except Jammu and Kashmir. Different chapters of the Act came into force at different times between 1987-2003.
- A consumer is defined as any person who buys goods or avails services for consideration. Consideration can be fully paid, partially paid or promised to be paid. Legal heirs of a deceased consumer are also considered consumers.
- However, a person who buys goods or services for commercial purposes, like resale, is not considered a consumer. An exception is made for persons who buy goods for commercial use but through self-employment for their livelihood.
- The document
The document discusses key aspects of the Consumer Protection Act 1986 including:
- The Act was enacted to better protect consumer interests and applies across India except Jammu and Kashmir.
- A consumer is defined as any person who buys goods or avails services for consideration. Legal heirs are also considered consumers.
- The Act excludes those who buy goods or services for commercial resale purposes. However, those who buy for commercial use and livelihood are considered consumers.
- The hierarchy of consumer forums is District Forum, State Commission, National Commission and Supreme Court. Pecuniary and territorial jurisdiction rules are also outlined.
- The Consumer Protection Act was enacted to better protect consumer interests in India.
- It applies to all of India except Jammu and Kashmir. Different chapters came into force at different times between 1987-2003.
- A consumer is defined as any person who buys goods or avails services for consideration. Consideration can be fully paid, partially paid or promised to be paid.
- Commercial purchases of goods or services are excluded unless for livelihood through self-employment. Legal heirs of deceased consumers are also considered consumers.
- The hierarchy of consumer forums is District Forum, State Commission, National Commission and Supreme Court.
This document provides information about the Consumer Protection Act 1986. Some key points:
- The Act was enacted to better protect consumer interests and applies to all of India except Jammu and Kashmir.
- A consumer is defined as any person who buys goods or avails services for consideration. Consideration can be fully or partially paid or promised.
- Goods or services bought for resale or commercial purposes are excluded from the definition of a consumer.
- The hierarchy of consumer forums is District Forum, State Commission, National Commission, and Supreme Court.
- Jurisdiction is determined by where the opposite party resides or carries business, or where the cause of action arises.
- Timelines are
This document summarizes a court case in Sri Lanka regarding whether an individual was an employee or independent contractor for purposes of contributing to an employee provident fund. The key points are:
1) The Assistant Commissioner of Labour held that the individual was an employee and ordered contributions to be made to the fund, but did not provide reasons for the decision.
2) The court examined whether reasons must be provided for non-appealable decisions like this one. While not strictly required, there is a trend that reasons should be provided to ensure transparency and prevent arbitrary decisions.
3) Since no reasons were provided, the court could not determine if the decision that the individual was an employee was lawful or not. The
State of karnataka vs ameerbi judgmentZahidManiyar
This 3 sentence summary provides the key details from the document:
The document discusses a case regarding whether Anganwadi workers, who implement the Integrated Child Development Services program in India, should be considered holders of civil posts. The Supreme Court of India examines the scheme which appoints Anganwadi workers and helpers to implement welfare programs, pays them honorariums rather than salaries, and does not consider them to hold sanctioned posts. The Court reviews arguments on whether they should be recognized as civil servants based on their role and relationship with the State.
The Uttar Pradesh Janhit Guarantee Adhiniyam, 2011 is a law passed by the state of Uttar Pradesh to provide time-bound delivery of public services to citizens. It aims to make government services more accessible, provide services within stipulated timeframes, increase transparency, and reduce corruption. The act covers 123 key public services across sectors like birth certificates, ration cards, electricity connections, and property records. It establishes mechanisms for citizens to file appeals if services are denied or delayed, and allows for penalties to be imposed on negligent officials. The overall goal is to ensure prompt and efficient delivery of services to the public.
Weekly Tax Newsletter 07-06-2020- N Pahilwani & AssociatesNitin Pahilwani
The document discusses self-invoicing under the GST regime. Self-invoicing is required when goods or services are purchased from an unregistered supplier and the liability to pay tax is under reverse charge. Since the unregistered supplier cannot issue a GST invoice, the recipient must issue a self-invoice for documenting the tax liability and availing input tax credit. The key details are:
1. Self-invoicing is required for purchases covered under reverse charge as per Sections 9(3), 9(4) of the CGST Act and Sections 5(3), 5(4) of the IGST Act.
2. The recipient must issue an invoice within 30 days for goods and 60 days for services from
Panel 3 :Tax Litigation - A Government / Revenue Perspectivetaxsutra
This document discusses tax litigation from the perspective of government counsel. It summarizes key cases and guidelines for government tax officials. The CBDT chairman's circular emphasizes that meeting revenue collection targets is the highest priority for tax officials and will impact their performance reviews. The Supreme Court in UOI v KK Dhawan set out criteria for determining when vigilance actions against tax officials are warranted. The Bombay High Court criticized the practice of lower officials filing frivolous appeals against tribunal decisions and wasting public funds, stating that costs would be recovered from responsible officers.
This document summarizes several writ petitions filed in the Supreme Court of India challenging orders issued under the Disaster Management Act during the COVID-19 lockdown directing employers to make full wage payments. The petitioners argue the orders violate constitutional rights and will bankrupt businesses. Intervenors supporting the orders argue wages are a pre-existing right and the orders help protect livelihoods. The court considers arguments on both sides and notes the central government has since withdrawn the challenged orders.
The document discusses proper service of notices under the Income Tax Act of 1961. It outlines that service must be done according to the methods specified in the Act to be valid. Specifically, it examines several cases where service was deemed improper, such as when notices were served to unauthorized individuals, past the scope of a power of attorney, or without following the specified procedures. The key takeaway is that acquisition of knowledge about a notice alone is not equivalent to proper service; the notice must be served using one of the approved methods in the Act for an assessment to be valid.
This document is a court document summarizing a case between Vinod Pathak and American Express Bank Ltd. Pathak filed a lawsuit seeking declarations, injunctions, and damages after claiming he was forced to resign from his job at the bank. The court notes that as a private employment, public policy principles do not apply. It also notes Pathak's employment contract allowed termination with one month's notice or pay. Therefore, even if wrongful termination was found, Pathak's maximum entitlement would be one month's salary as damages. The court finds Pathak's suit is not maintainable and denies the claims for reinstatement and ongoing salary/benefits.
Indirect tax latest judicial precedents december 2015Ashish Chaudhary
The document provides a summary of recent indirect tax judicial precedents from December 2015.
Three key cases are summarized:
1. The High Court held that credit of duty paid for installing telecommunication towers is not eligible as the towers are considered immovable property.
2. The High Court dismissed a writ petition claiming film actors should receive the same tax exemption as native artists, finding the two categories are distinct.
3. The High Court held that recovery proceedings cannot be initiated before an adjudication order determines the demand amount.
The Supreme Court of Pakistan heard a petition regarding the promotion of civil servants from grade 20 to 21. The petitioner argued that promotions were not being given based on transparent, objective criteria, and instead were subject to political pressures. The court summarized that while several officers met qualifications for promotion, their cases were deferred without clear reasons. The court questioned whether deferrals were meant to favor other candidates rather than reward honest work. It ordered promotions be based solely on merit as outlined in previous court judgments.
This document summarizes key cases related to the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 in India. It discusses the Allahabad Bank case, where the court held that retired employees are entitled to receive both pension and gratuity. It also summarizes the Y.K. Singla case, where the court ruled that an employee whose gratuity was withheld is entitled to interest on delayed payments if acquitted of charges. Finally, it discusses the University of Delhi case, where the court found that the Payment of Gratuity Act takes precedence over other statutes in providing more beneficial terms to employees.
1. The State of Maharashtra filed writ petitions challenging orders from the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal that directed the state to allow transgender individuals to apply for police constable positions and to create an option to identify transgender applicants on all application forms.
2. The court dismissed the writ petitions and directed the state to frame rules by February 2023 to protect transgender rights as mandated by law. It also allowed the two transgender applicants until December 15th to apply either online or offline, once the application format is modified, and stayed the written examination until the physical examination can be conducted for all applicants under the new rules.
3. The court encouraged the tribunal to promptly decide the underlying cases on their merits regarding reservations and other issues for
it describes the bony anatomy including the femoral head , acetabulum, labrum . also discusses the capsule , ligaments . muscle that act on the hip joint and the range of motion are outlined. factors affecting hip joint stability and weight transmission through the joint are summarized.
हिंदी वर्णमाला पीपीटी, hindi alphabet PPT presentation, hindi varnamala PPT, Hindi Varnamala pdf, हिंदी स्वर, हिंदी व्यंजन, sikhiye hindi varnmala, dr. mulla adam ali, hindi language and literature, hindi alphabet with drawing, hindi alphabet pdf, hindi varnamala for childrens, hindi language, hindi varnamala practice for kids, https://www.drmullaadamali.com
Main Java[All of the Base Concepts}.docxadhitya5119
This is part 1 of my Java Learning Journey. This Contains Custom methods, classes, constructors, packages, multithreading , try- catch block, finally block and more.
Exploiting Artificial Intelligence for Empowering Researchers and Faculty, In...Dr. Vinod Kumar Kanvaria
Exploiting Artificial Intelligence for Empowering Researchers and Faculty,
International FDP on Fundamentals of Research in Social Sciences
at Integral University, Lucknow, 06.06.2024
By Dr. Vinod Kumar Kanvaria
A workshop hosted by the South African Journal of Science aimed at postgraduate students and early career researchers with little or no experience in writing and publishing journal articles.
This presentation was provided by Steph Pollock of The American Psychological Association’s Journals Program, and Damita Snow, of The American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), for the initial session of NISO's 2024 Training Series "DEIA in the Scholarly Landscape." Session One: 'Setting Expectations: a DEIA Primer,' was held June 6, 2024.
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP ModuleCeline George
In Odoo, the chatter is like a chat tool that helps you work together on records. You can leave notes and track things, making it easier to talk with your team and partners. Inside chatter, all communication history, activity, and changes will be displayed.
How to Manage Your Lost Opportunities in Odoo 17 CRMCeline George
Odoo 17 CRM allows us to track why we lose sales opportunities with "Lost Reasons." This helps analyze our sales process and identify areas for improvement. Here's how to configure lost reasons in Odoo 17 CRM
Strategies for Effective Upskilling is a presentation by Chinwendu Peace in a Your Skill Boost Masterclass organisation by the Excellence Foundation for South Sudan on 08th and 09th June 2024 from 1 PM to 3 PM on each day.
1. Supreme Court of India
Supreme Court of India
Dev Dutt vs Union Of India & Ors on 12 May, 2008
Author: M Katju
Bench: M Katju, H K Sema
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 7631 OF 2002
Dev Dutt .. Appellant -vs-
Union of India & Ors. ..
Respondents
JUDGMENT
Markandey Katju, J.
2
1. This appeal by special leave has been filed against the impugned judgment of the Gauhati High Court dated
26.11.2001 in Writ Appeal No. 447 of 2001. By the aforesaid judgment the Division Bench of the Gauhati
High Court dismissed the Writ Appeal of the appellant filed against the judgment of the Learned Single Judge
dated 21.8.2001.
2. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
3. The appellant was in the service of the Border Roads Engineering Service which is governed by the Border
Roads Engineering Service Group 'A' Rules, as amended. As per these rules, since the appellant was promoted
as Executive Engineer on 22.2.1988, he was eligible to be considered for promotion to the post of
Superintending Engineer on completion of 5 years on the grade of Executive Engineer, which he completed
on 21.2.1993. Accordingly the name of the appellant was included in the list of candidates eligible for
promotion.
4. The Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) held its meeting on 16.12.1994. In that meeting the
appellant was not held to be eligible for promotion, but his juniors were selected and promoted to the rank of
Superintending Engineer. Hence the appellant filed a Writ Petition before 3
the Gauhati High Court which was dismissed and his appeal before the Division Bench also failed. Aggrieved,
this appeal has been filed by special leave before this Court.
5. The stand of the respondent was that according to para 6.3(ii) of the guidelines for promotion of
departmental candidates which was issued by the Government of India, Ministry of Public Grievances and
Pension, vide Office Memorandum dated 10.4.1989, for promotion to all posts which are in the pay scale of
Rs.3700-5000/- and above, the bench mark grade should be 'very good' for the last five years before the
D.P.C.. In other words, only those candidates who had 'very good' entries in their Annual Confidential Reports
(ACRs) for the last five years would be considered for promotion. The post of Superintending Engineer
Dev Dutt vs Union Of India & Ors on 12 May, 2008
Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/801705/ 1
2. carries the pay scale of Rs.3700- 5000/- and since the appellant did not have 'very good' entry but only 'good'
entry for the year 1993-94, he was not considered for promotion to the post of Superintending Engineer.
6. The grievance of the appellant was that he was not communicated the 'good' entry for the year 1993-94. He
submitted that had he been communicated that entry he would have had an opportunity of making a 4
representation for upgrading that entry from 'good' to 'very good', and if that representation was allowed he
would have also become eligible for promotion. Hence he submits that the rules of natural justice have been
violated.
7. In reply, learned counsel for the respondent submitted that a 'good' entry is not an adverse entry and it is
only an adverse entry which has to be communicated to an employee. Hence he submitted that there was no
illegality in not communicating the 'good' entry to the appellant.
8. Learned counsel for the respondent relied on a decision of this Court in Vijay Kumar vs. State of
Maharashtra & Ors. 1988 (Supp) SCC 674 in which it was held that an un-communicated adverse report
should not form the foundation to deny the benefits to a government servant when similar benefits are
extended to his juniors. He also relied upon a decision of this Court in State of Gujarat & Anr. vs. Suryakant
Chunilal Shah 1999 (1) SCC 529 in which it was held:
"Purpose of adverse entries is primarily to forewarn the government servant to mend his ways and to improve
his performance. That is why, it is required to communicate the adverse entries so that the government servant
to whom the adverse entry is given, may have either opportunity to explain his conduct so as to show that the
5
adverse entry was wholly uncalled for, or to silently brood over the matter and on being convinced that his
previous conduct justified such an entry, to improve his performance".
On the strength of the above decisions learned counsel for the respondent submitted that only an adverse entry
needs to be communicated to an employee.
9. We do not agree. In our opinion every entry must be communicated to the employee concerned, so that he
may have an opportunity of making a representation against it if he is aggrieved.
10. In the present case the bench mark (i.e. the essential requirement) laid down by the authorities for
promotion to the post of Superintending Engineer was that the candidate should have 'very good' entry for the
last five years. Thus in this situation the 'good' entry in fact is an adverse entry because it eliminates the
candidate from being considered for promotion. Thus, nomenclature is not relevant, it is the effect which the
entry is having which determines whether it is an adverse entry or not. It is thus the rigours of the entry which
is important, not the phraseology. The grant of a `good' 6
entry is of no satisfaction to the incumbent if it in fact makes him ineligible for promotion or has an adverse
effect on his chances.
11. Hence, in our opinion, the 'good' entry should have been communicated to the appellant so as to enable
him to make a representation praying that the said entry for the year 1993-94 should be upgraded from 'good'
to 'very good'. Of course, after considering such a representation it was open to the authority concerned to
reject the representation and confirm the 'good' entry (though of course in a fair manner), but at least an
opportunity of making such a representation should have been given to the appellant, and that would only
have been possible had the appellant been communicated the 'good' entry, which was not done in this case.
Hence, we are of the opinion that the non-communication of the 'good' entry was arbitrary and hence illegal,
and the decisions relied upon by the learned counsel for the respondent are distinguishable.
Dev Dutt vs Union Of India & Ors on 12 May, 2008
Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/801705/ 2
3. 12. Learned counsel for the respondent submitted that under the Office Memorandum 21011/4/87 [Estt.'A']
issued by the Ministry of Personnel/Public Grievance and Pensions dated 10/11.09.1987, only an adverse
entry is to be communicated to the concerned employee. It is well settled that no rule or government
instruction can violate Article 14 or any 7
other provision of the Constitution, as the Constitution is the highest law of the land. The aforesaid Office
Memorandum, if it is interpreted to mean that only adverse entries are to be communicated to the concerned
employee and not other entries, would in our opinion become arbitrary and hence illegal being violative of
Article 14. All similar Rules/Government Orders/Office Memoranda, in respect of all services under the State,
whether civil, judicial, police, or other service (except the military), will hence also be illegal and are
therefore liable to be ignored.
13. It has been held in Maneka Gandhi vs. Union of India & Anr. AIR 1978 SC 597 that arbitrariness violates
Article 14 of the Constitution. In our opinion, the non-communication of an entry in the A.C.R. of a public
servant is arbitrary because it deprives the concerned employee from making a representation against it and
praying for its up-gradation. In our opinion, every entry in the Annual Confidential Report of every employee
under the State, whether he is in civil, judicial, police or other service (except the military) must be
communicated to him, so as to enable him to make a representation against it, because non-communication
deprives the employee of the opportunity of making a representation against it which may affect his chances
of being promoted (or get some other benefits). 8
Moreover, the object of writing the confidential report and making entries in them is to give an opportunity to
a public servant to improve his performance, vide State of U.P. vs. Yamuna Shankar Misra 1997 (4) SCC
7. Hence such non-communication is, in our opinion, arbitrary and hence violative of Article 14 of the
Constitution.
14. In our opinion, every entry (and not merely a poor or adverse entry) relating to an employee under the
State or an instrumentality of the State, whether in civil, judicial, police or other service (except the military)
must be communicated to him, within a reasonable period, and it makes no difference whether there is a bench
mark or not. Even if there is no bench mark, non-communication of an entry may adversely affect the
employee's chances of promotion (or getting some other benefit), because when comparative merit is being
considered for promotion (or some other benefit) a person having a `good' or `average' or `fair' entry certainly
has less chances of being selected than a person having a `very good' or `outstanding' entry.
15. In most services there is a gradation of entries, which is usually as follows:
(i) Outstanding
9
(ii) Very Good
(iii) Good
(iv) Average
(v) Fair
(vi) Poor
Dev Dutt vs Union Of India & Ors on 12 May, 2008
Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/801705/ 3
4. A person getting any of the entries at items (ii) to (vi) should be communicated the entry so that he has an
opportunity of making a representation praying for its upgradation, and such a representation must be decided
fairly and within a reasonable period by the concerned authority.
16. If we hold that only `poor' entry is to be communicated, the consequences may be that persons getting
`fair', `average', `good' or `very good' entries will not be able to represent for its upgradation, and this may
subsequently adversely affect their chances of promotion (or get some other benefit).
17. In our opinion if the Office Memorandum dated 10/11.09.1987, is interpreted to mean that only adverse
entries (i.e. `poor' entry) need to be communicated and not `fair', 'average' or 'good' entries, it would become
arbitrary (and hence illegal) since it may adversely affect the incumbent's chances of promotion, or get some
other benefit. 10
18. For example, if the bench mark is that an incumbent must have `very good' entries in the last five years,
then if he has `very good' (or even `outstanding') entries for four years, a `good' entry for only one year may
yet make him ineligible for promotion. This `good' entry may be due to the personal pique of his superior, or
because the superior asked him to do something wrong which the incumbent refused, or because the
incumbent refused to do sycophancy of his superior, or because of caste or communal prejudice, or for some
other extraneous consideration.
19. In our opinion, every entry in the A.C.R. of a public servant must be communicated to him within a
reasonable period, whether it is a poor, fair, average, good or very good entry. This is because
non-communication of such an entry may adversely affect the employee in two ways : (1) Had the entry been
communicated to him he would know about the assessment of his work and conduct by his superiors, which
would enable him to improve his work in future (2) He would have an opportunity of making a representation
against the entry if he feels it is unjustified, and pray for its upgradation. Hence non-communication of an
entry is arbitrary, and it has been held by the Constitution Bench decision of this Court in Maneka 11
Gandhi vs. Union of India (supra) that arbitrariness violates Article 14 of the Constitution.
20. Thus it is not only when there is a bench mark but in all cases that an entry (whether it is poor, fair,
average, good or very good) must be communicated to a public servant, otherwise there is violation of the
principle of fairness, which is the soul of natural justice. Even an outstanding entry should be communicated
since that would boost the morale of the employee and make him work harder.
21. Learned counsel for the respondent has relied on the decision of this Court in U. P. Jal Nigam vs. Prabhat
Chandra Jain AIR 1996 SC 1661. We have perused the said decision, which is cryptic and does not go into
details. Moreover it has not noticed the Constitution Bench decision of this Court in Maneka Gandhi vs.
Union of India (supra) which has held that all State action must be non-arbitrary, otherwise Article 14 of the
Constitution will be violated. In our opinion the decision in U.P. Jal Nigam (supra) cannot be said to have laid
down any legal principle that entries need not be communicated. As observed in Bharat Petroleum
Corporation Ltd. vs. N.R. Vairamani AIR 2004 SC 4778 (vide para 9): 12
"Observations of Courts are neither to be read as Euclid's Theorems nor as provisions of the statute, and that
too, taken out of their context".
22. In U.P. Jal Nigam's case (supra) there is only a stray observation "if the graded entry is of going a step
down, like falling from 'very good' to 'good' that may not ordinarily be an adverse entry since both are a
positive grading". There is no discussion about the question whether such 'good' grading can also have serious
adverse consequences as it may virtually eliminate the chances of promotion of the incumbent if there is a
benchmark requiring 'very good' entry. And even when there is no benchmark, such downgrading can have
serious adverse effect on an incumbent's chances of promotion where comparative merit of several candidates
Dev Dutt vs Union Of India & Ors on 12 May, 2008
Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/801705/ 4
5. is considered.
23. Learned counsel for the respondent also relied upon the decision of this Court in Union of India & Anr. vs.
S. K. Goel & Ors. AIR 2007 SC 1199 and on the strength of the same submitted that only an adverse entry
need be communicated to the incumbent. The aforesaid decision is a 2- Judge Bench decision and hence
cannot prevail over the 7-Judge Constitution Bench decision of this Court in Maneka Gandhi vs. Union of
India (supra) in which it has been held that arbitrariness violates Article 14 13
of the Constitution. Since the aforesaid decision in Union of India vs. S.K. Goel (supra) has not considered the
aforesaid Constitution Bench decision in Maneka Gandhi's case (supra), it cannot be said to have laid down
the correct law. Moreover, this decision also cannot be treated as a Euclid's formula since there is no detailed
discussion in it about the adverse consequences of non-communication of the entry, and the consequential
denial of making a representation against it.
24. It may be mentioned that communication of entries and giving opportunity to represent against them is
particularly important on higher posts which are in a pyramidical structure where often the principle of
elimination is followed in selection for promotion, and even a single entry can destroy the career of an officer
which has otherwise been outstanding throughout. This often results in grave injustice and heart-burning, and
may shatter the morale of many good officers who are superseded due to this arbitrariness, while officers of
inferior merit may be promoted.
25. In the present case, the action of the respondents in not communicating the 'good' entry for the year
1993-94 to the appellant is in 14
our opinion arbitrary and violative of natural justice, because in substance the `good' entry operates as an
adverse entry (for the reason given above).
26. What is natural justice? The rules of natural justice are not codified nor are they unvarying in all
situations, rather they are flexible. They may, however, be summarized in one word : fairness. In other words,
what they require is fairness by the authority concerned. Of course, what is fair would depend on the situation
and the context.
27. Lord Esher M.R. in Voinet vs. Barrett (1885) 55 L.J. QB 39, 39 observed: "Natural justice is the natural
sense of what is right and wrong."
28. In our opinion, our natural sense of what is right and wrong tells us that it was wrong on the part of the
respondent in not communicating the 'good' entry to the appellant since he was thereby deprived of the right to
make a representation against it, which if allowed would have entitled him to be considered for promotion to
the post of Superintending Engineer. One may not have the right to promotion, but one has the right to be
considered for promotion, and this right of the appellant was violated in the present case.
15
29. A large number of decisions of this Court have discussed the principles of natural justice and it is not
necessary for us to go into all of them here. However, we may consider a few.
30. Thus, in A. K. Kraipak & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors. AIR 1970 SC 150, a Constitution Bench of this
Court held : "The concept of natural justice has undergone a great deal of change in recent years. In the past it
was thought that it included just two rules, namely (1) no one shall be a judge in his own cause (Nemo debet
csse judex propria causa), and (2) no decision shall be given against a party without affording him a
reasonable hearing (audi alteram partem). Very soon thereafter a third rule was envisaged and that is that
quasi-judicial enquiries must be held in good faith, without bias and not arbitrarily or
Dev Dutt vs Union Of India & Ors on 12 May, 2008
Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/801705/ 5
6. unreasonably. But in the course of years many more subsidiary rules came to be added to the rules of natural
justice".
(emphasis supplied)
31. The aforesaid decision was followed by this Court in K. I. Shephard & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors. AIR
1988 SC 686 (vide paras 12-15). It was held in this decision that even administrative acts have to be in
accordance with natural justice if they have civil consequences. It was also held that natural justice has
various facets and acting fairly is one of them. 16
32. In Kumaon Mandal Vikas Nigam Ltd. vs. Girja Shankar Pant AIR 2001 SC 24, this Court held (vide para
2):
The doctrine (natural justice) is now termed as a synonym of fairness in the concept of justice and stands as
the most accepted methodology of a governmental action".
(emphasis supplied)
33. In the same decision it was also held following the decision of Tucker, LJ in Russell vs. Duke of Norfolk
(1949) 1 All ER 109: "The requirement of natural justice must depend on the circumstances of the case, the
nature of the enquiry, the rules under which the tribunal is acting, the subject- matter that is being dealt with,
and so forth".
34. In Union of India etc. vs. Tulsiram Patel etc. AIR 1985 SC 1416 (vide para 97) a Constitution Bench of
this Court referred to with approval the following observations of Ormond, L.J. in Norwest Holst Ltd. vs.
Secretary of State for Trade (1978) 1, Ch. 201 : "The House of Lords and this court have repeatedly
emphasized that the ordinary principles of natural justice must be kept flexible and must be adapted to the
circumstances prevailing in any particular case". (emphasis supplied)
17
Thus, it is well settled that the rules of natural justice are flexible. The question to be asked in every case to
determine whether the rules of natural justice have been violated is : have the authorities acted fairly?
35. In Swadesh Cotton Mills etc. vs. Union of India etc. AIR 1981 SC 818, this Court following the decision
in Mohinder Singh Gill & Anr. vs. The Chief Election Commissioner & Ors. AIR 1978 SC 851 held that the
soul of the rule (natural justice) is fair play in action.
36. In our opinion, fair play required that the respondent should have communicated the 'good' entry of
1993-94 to the appellant so that he could have an opportunity of making a representation praying for
upgrading the same so that he could be eligible for promotion. Non-communication of the said entry, in our
opinion, was hence unfair on the part of the respondent and hence violative of natural justice.
37. Originally there were said to be only two principles of natural justice : (1) the rule against bias and (2) the
right to be heard (audi alteram partem). However, subsequently, as noted in A.K. Kraipak's case (supra) and
K.L. Shephard's case (supra), some more rules came to be added to the rules of 18
natural justice, e.g. the requirement to give reasons vide S.N. Mukherji vs. Union of India AIR 1990 SC 1984.
In Maneka Gandhi vs. Union of India (supra) (vide paragraphs 56 to 61) it was held that natural justice is part
of Article 14 of the Constitution.
Dev Dutt vs Union Of India & Ors on 12 May, 2008
Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/801705/ 6
7. 38. Thus natural justice has an expanding content and is not stagnant. It is therefore open to the Court to
develop new principles of natural justice in appropriate cases.
39. In the present case, we are developing the principles of natural justice by holding that fairness and
transparency in public administration requires that all entries (whether poor, fair, average, good or very good)
in the Annual Confidential Report of a public servant, whether in civil, judicial, police or any other State
service (except the military), must be communicated to him within a reasonable period so that he can make a
representation for its upgradation. This in our opinion is the correct legal position even though there may be
no Rule/G.O. requiring communication of the entry, or even if there is a Rule/G.O. prohibiting it, because the
principle of non-arbitrariness in State action as envisaged by Article 14 of 19
the Constitution in our opinion requires such communication. Article 14 will override all rules or government
orders.
40. We further hold that when the entry is communicated to him the public servant should have a right to
make a representation against the entry to the concerned authority, and the concerned authority must decide
the representation in a fair manner and within a reasonable period. We also hold that the representation must
be decided by an authority higher than the one who gave the entry, otherwise the likelihood is that the
representation will be summarily rejected without adequate consideration as it would be an appeal from
Caesar to Caesar. All this would be conducive to fairness and transparency in public administration, and
would result in fairness to public servants. The State must be a model employer, and must act fairly towards
its employees. Only then would good governance be possible.
41. We, however, make it clear that the above directions will not apply to military officers because the
position for them is different as clarified by this Court in Union of India vs. Major Bahadur Singh 2006 (1)
SCC 368. But they will apply to employees of statutory authorities, public sector 20
corporations and other instrumentalities of the State (in addition to Government servants).
42. In Canara Bank vs. V. K. Awasthy 2005 (6) SCC 321, this Court held that the concept of natural justice
has undergone a great deal of change in recent years. As observed in para 8 of the said judgment: "Natural
justice is another name for common-sense justice. Rules of natural justice are not codified canons. But they
are principles ingrained into the conscience of man. Natural justice is the administration of justice in a
common-sense liberal way. Justice is based substantially on natural ideals and human values".
43. In para 12 of the said judgment it was observed: "What is meant by the term "principles of natural justice"
is not easy to determine. Lord Summer (then Hamilton, L.J.) in R. v. Local Govt. Board (1914) 1 KB 160:83
LJKB 86 described the phrase as sadly lacking in precision. In General Council of Medical Education &
Registration of U.K. v. Spackman (1943) AC 627:
(1943) 2 All ER 337, Lord Wright observed that it was not desirable to attempt "to force it into any
Procrustean bed".
44. In State of Maharashtra vs. Public Concern for Governance Trust & Ors. 2007 (3) SCC 587, it was
observed (vide para 39): "In our opinion, when an authority takes a decision which may have civil
consequences and affects the rights 21
of a person, the principles of natural justice would at once come into play".
45. In our opinion, non-communication of entries in the Annual Confidential Report of a public servant,
whether he is in civil, judicial, police or any other service (other than the military), certainly has civil
consequences because it may affect his chances for promotion or get other benefits (as already discussed
Dev Dutt vs Union Of India & Ors on 12 May, 2008
Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/801705/ 7
8. above). Hence, such non-communication would be arbitrary, and as such violative of Article 14 of the
Constitution.
46. In view of the above, we are of the opinion that both the learned Single Judge as well as the learned
Division Bench erred in law. Hence, we set aside the judgment of the Learned Single Judge as well as the
impugned judgment of the learned Division Bench.
47. We are informed that the appellant has already retired from service. However, if his representation for
upgradation of the `good' entry is allowed, he may benefit in his pension and get some arrears. Hence we
direct that the 'good' entry of 1993-94 be communicated to the appellant forthwith and he should be permitted
to make a representation against the same praying for its upgradation. If the upgradation is allowed, the 22
appellant should be considered forthwith for promotion as Superintending Engineer retrospectively and if he
is promoted he will get the benefit of higher pension and the balance of arrears of pay along with 8% per
annum interest.
48. We, therefore, direct that the 'good' entry be communicated to the appellant within a period of two months
from the date of receipt of the copy of this judgment. On being communicated, the appellant may make the
representation, if he so chooses, against the said entry within two months thereafter and the said representation
will be decided within two months thereafter. If his entry is upgraded the appellant shall be considered for
promotion retrospectively by the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) within three months thereafter
and if the appellant gets selected for promotion retrospectively, he should be given higher pension with arrears
of pay and interest @ 8% per annum till the date of payment.
49. With these observations this appeal is allowed. No costs. .............................................J.
(H. K. Sema)
............................................J.
(Markandey Katju)
23
New Delhi;
May 12, 2008
Dev Dutt vs Union Of India & Ors on 12 May, 2008
Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/801705/ 8