SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Edan Carignan, Caroline Rashidi, Shane Nath
Enterprise Resource Planning Computer System Upgrade
Sponsor: Mr. Gary Radine
Agenda
❖ Company Summary

❖ Project Summary

❖ Project Constraints

❖ Financing The Project
Using 100% Cash

❖ Maximum Debt
❖ Delayed Completion

❖ Delayed Layoffs

❖ Re-Upgrade of Project

❖ Possible Outcomes

❖ Recommendation

❖ Q&A
Company Summary
❖ Non-profit organization founded in 1954

❖ Largest dental plan system in the US

❖ 39 members covering all 50 states

❖ Enrollment and gross revenues doubled
by CEO Mr. Gary Radine
Project Summary
❖ Best method of implementing ERP system

❖ 35 page report

❖ 5 detailed scenarios

❖ Possible outcomes of each scenario

❖ Recommendation to Delta Dental
Delay of ERP
Implementation
Edan
All Cash Max Debt
Delayed
Layoffs
Shane
Re-Upgrade
Possible
Outcomes
Caroline
Project Constraints
❖ Cash surplus cannot go below $200
million

❖ Only method of raising capital is a 3-
year loan

❖ Loan amount limited to $80 million

❖ $20 million annual cash inflow

❖ Management prefers the funding to be
from cash flow from operations and
borrowings from the bank
Financing using 100% Cash
❖ Policy to not go below $200
million in cash reserves

❖ $106 million project cost

❖ Risks

❖ Leverage will decrease $75
$150
$225
$300
C
ash
Surplus
ProjectC
ost
Cash Surplus
Project Cost
Cash Reserve Limit
Financing using 100% Cash
Comparable Companies Leverage Ratio (L/A)
United Healthcare (UNH) 0.61
Wellpoint (WLP) [acquired by Anthem] 0.63
Aetna (AET) 0.72
CIGNA Corp. (CI) 0.80
Humana (HUM) 0.60
Centene Corp. (CNC) 0.70
Health Net, Inc. (HNT) 0.71
WellCare Health Plans (WCG) 0.67
Healthspring (HS) [acquired by Cigna] 0.47
Molina Healthcare (MOH) 0.77
Average 0.67
0.18
0.35
0.53
0.70
Delta Dental Top 10
0.67
0.54
Maximum Debt
Pros
❖ More Liquid Cash

❖ Current Low Interest
Rates

Cons
❖ Risk of Default

❖ Drop in Credit Rating
Maximum Debt
A.M Bests’ BCAR Model
❖ Business Profile

❖ Operating Performance

❖ Balance Sheet Strength
Delayed Completion of Project
59%
41%
Exceed Budget
53%
47%
Take Longer
49% 51%
Receive Anticipated
Benefits
Delayed Completion of Project
ERP Evaluation Team
Poorly Defined
Requirements
Change in Management
During Implementation
Choosing a Vendor Based
Solely On Sales Pitch
Lack of Employee
Training
Reason Solution
Involve more employees
than ERP Evaluation Team
Spend time understanding
your specific needs
Invest in comprehensive
training programs
Delayed Layoffs
Scenario
❖ Originally 400 layoffs in
year 4

❖ Delay of 200 employees
for 2 extra years
Reasons
❖ Project delayed

❖ System is not as efficient

❖ Employee adjustment time
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
Cash Surplus $300,000 $397,850 $417,850 $369,500 $403,750 $433,250
Cash from Operations $20,000 $20,000 $20,000 $20,000 $20,000 $20,000
Borrowed Capital $33,216 -$33,216
FTE Reductions $9,500 $14,250 $9,500 $4,750
Total $353,216 $417,850 $414,134 $403,750 $433,250 $458,000
Delayed Layoffs
Short Term Effects
❖ Pay extra $28.5 million

Long Term Effects
❖ Fear of layoffs

❖ Employee Morale
Decreases

❖ Workplace Productivity
Decreases
Outcome
❖ Layoffs are necessary

❖ Extra money is spent

❖ Fear within employees is set
$28.5
million
Re-Upgrade of Project
Technological Revolution
❖ Significant investments in computer upgrades 

❖ Opportunities in infrastructure and application development

To Stay Competitive
❖ Keep and increase market share 

❖ Appropriate response to competitors
Possible Outcomes
❖ Invest in marketing

❖ Invest in mobile platform

❖ Invest in research and risk management

❖ Lower insurance premiums

❖ Invest in money-market securities
Recommendation
❖ Balloon payment and FTE
layoffs happen concurrently

❖ Strict layoff policy

❖ ERP Evaluation Team

❖ After successful project,
Delta Dental should invest
in the previously mentioned
possible outcomes
68%
32%
Debt Cash
Questions?
Thank You

More Related Content

What's hot

Member Business Lending: Growth and Risk Management
Member Business Lending: Growth and Risk ManagementMember Business Lending: Growth and Risk Management
Member Business Lending: Growth and Risk Management
Libby Bierman
 
Analyzing solvency of companies
Analyzing solvency of companiesAnalyzing solvency of companies
Analyzing solvency of companies
Dhrumil Shah
 
Public slides
Public slidesPublic slides
Public slides
public_group12
 
ATAVA Benchmark Summary
ATAVA Benchmark Summary ATAVA Benchmark Summary
ATAVA Benchmark Summary
Water Street Partners
 
Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)
Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)
Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)
Lauren Eisdorfer
 
Stopping the Race to the Bottom - Thomas Kmak
Stopping the Race to the Bottom - Thomas KmakStopping the Race to the Bottom - Thomas Kmak
Stopping the Race to the Bottom - Thomas Kmak
BPAS
 
Hiring the Right Auditor for your Benefit Plan
Hiring the Right Auditor for your Benefit PlanHiring the Right Auditor for your Benefit Plan
Hiring the Right Auditor for your Benefit Plan
Clark Schaefer Hackett
 
2015-06-09 Four Steps to Successful Retirement Plan Management
2015-06-09 Four Steps to Successful Retirement Plan Management2015-06-09 Four Steps to Successful Retirement Plan Management
2015-06-09 Four Steps to Successful Retirement Plan Management
Raffa Learning Community
 
Review your service
Review your serviceReview your service
Review your service
Johnson Fleming Limited
 
Cuna Committee Presentation
Cuna Committee PresentationCuna Committee Presentation
Cuna Committee Presentation
CorporateOne
 
Accountants Guide to Workers Compensation & Health Benefits
Accountants Guide to Workers Compensation  & Health BenefitsAccountants Guide to Workers Compensation  & Health Benefits
Accountants Guide to Workers Compensation & Health Benefits
ADP, LLC
 
Relationship-Based Banking: Balancing Relationships & Risk
Relationship-Based Banking: Balancing Relationships & RiskRelationship-Based Banking: Balancing Relationships & Risk
Relationship-Based Banking: Balancing Relationships & Risk
Libby Bierman
 
Fee Policy Statement Kit: Best Practices for Managing Plan Expenses - Brian B...
Fee Policy Statement Kit: Best Practices for Managing Plan Expenses - Brian B...Fee Policy Statement Kit: Best Practices for Managing Plan Expenses - Brian B...
Fee Policy Statement Kit: Best Practices for Managing Plan Expenses - Brian B...
BPAS
 
Bryson Wealth Management Capabilities - 2013
Bryson Wealth Management Capabilities - 2013Bryson Wealth Management Capabilities - 2013
Bryson Wealth Management Capabilities - 2013
Bryson Financial
 
2013 AESC Compensation Survey Summary Final
2013 AESC Compensation Survey Summary Final2013 AESC Compensation Survey Summary Final
2013 AESC Compensation Survey Summary Final
Lukáš Havlín
 
Bryson Wealth Management - Capabilities
Bryson Wealth Management - CapabilitiesBryson Wealth Management - Capabilities
Bryson Wealth Management - Capabilities
Bryson Financial
 
Renrollment a fiduciary imperative
Renrollment a fiduciary imperativeRenrollment a fiduciary imperative
Renrollment a fiduciary imperative
Richard Davies
 
The Finalists Presentation: Presenting our Partnership - Paul Neveu & Liz Kaido
The Finalists Presentation: Presenting our Partnership - Paul Neveu & Liz KaidoThe Finalists Presentation: Presenting our Partnership - Paul Neveu & Liz Kaido
The Finalists Presentation: Presenting our Partnership - Paul Neveu & Liz Kaido
BPAS
 
Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)
Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)
Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)
Lauren Eisdorfer
 
TEI of Glance Networks Circular Economics Brief
TEI of Glance Networks Circular Economics BriefTEI of Glance Networks Circular Economics Brief
TEI of Glance Networks Circular Economics Brief
Liberteks
 

What's hot (20)

Member Business Lending: Growth and Risk Management
Member Business Lending: Growth and Risk ManagementMember Business Lending: Growth and Risk Management
Member Business Lending: Growth and Risk Management
 
Analyzing solvency of companies
Analyzing solvency of companiesAnalyzing solvency of companies
Analyzing solvency of companies
 
Public slides
Public slidesPublic slides
Public slides
 
ATAVA Benchmark Summary
ATAVA Benchmark Summary ATAVA Benchmark Summary
ATAVA Benchmark Summary
 
Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)
Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)
Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)
 
Stopping the Race to the Bottom - Thomas Kmak
Stopping the Race to the Bottom - Thomas KmakStopping the Race to the Bottom - Thomas Kmak
Stopping the Race to the Bottom - Thomas Kmak
 
Hiring the Right Auditor for your Benefit Plan
Hiring the Right Auditor for your Benefit PlanHiring the Right Auditor for your Benefit Plan
Hiring the Right Auditor for your Benefit Plan
 
2015-06-09 Four Steps to Successful Retirement Plan Management
2015-06-09 Four Steps to Successful Retirement Plan Management2015-06-09 Four Steps to Successful Retirement Plan Management
2015-06-09 Four Steps to Successful Retirement Plan Management
 
Review your service
Review your serviceReview your service
Review your service
 
Cuna Committee Presentation
Cuna Committee PresentationCuna Committee Presentation
Cuna Committee Presentation
 
Accountants Guide to Workers Compensation & Health Benefits
Accountants Guide to Workers Compensation  & Health BenefitsAccountants Guide to Workers Compensation  & Health Benefits
Accountants Guide to Workers Compensation & Health Benefits
 
Relationship-Based Banking: Balancing Relationships & Risk
Relationship-Based Banking: Balancing Relationships & RiskRelationship-Based Banking: Balancing Relationships & Risk
Relationship-Based Banking: Balancing Relationships & Risk
 
Fee Policy Statement Kit: Best Practices for Managing Plan Expenses - Brian B...
Fee Policy Statement Kit: Best Practices for Managing Plan Expenses - Brian B...Fee Policy Statement Kit: Best Practices for Managing Plan Expenses - Brian B...
Fee Policy Statement Kit: Best Practices for Managing Plan Expenses - Brian B...
 
Bryson Wealth Management Capabilities - 2013
Bryson Wealth Management Capabilities - 2013Bryson Wealth Management Capabilities - 2013
Bryson Wealth Management Capabilities - 2013
 
2013 AESC Compensation Survey Summary Final
2013 AESC Compensation Survey Summary Final2013 AESC Compensation Survey Summary Final
2013 AESC Compensation Survey Summary Final
 
Bryson Wealth Management - Capabilities
Bryson Wealth Management - CapabilitiesBryson Wealth Management - Capabilities
Bryson Wealth Management - Capabilities
 
Renrollment a fiduciary imperative
Renrollment a fiduciary imperativeRenrollment a fiduciary imperative
Renrollment a fiduciary imperative
 
The Finalists Presentation: Presenting our Partnership - Paul Neveu & Liz Kaido
The Finalists Presentation: Presenting our Partnership - Paul Neveu & Liz KaidoThe Finalists Presentation: Presenting our Partnership - Paul Neveu & Liz Kaido
The Finalists Presentation: Presenting our Partnership - Paul Neveu & Liz Kaido
 
Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)
Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)
Retirement Annuity Accounts (RAAs)
 
TEI of Glance Networks Circular Economics Brief
TEI of Glance Networks Circular Economics BriefTEI of Glance Networks Circular Economics Brief
TEI of Glance Networks Circular Economics Brief
 

Similar to Delta Dental Analysis

AFP 2016 - What is your cash forecast costing you
AFP 2016 - What is your cash forecast costing youAFP 2016 - What is your cash forecast costing you
AFP 2016 - What is your cash forecast costing you
Craig Gross, CFA, CTP
 
Clothes R Us Situational analysis
Clothes R Us Situational analysisClothes R Us Situational analysis
Clothes R Us Situational analysis
Ajay Srinivasan Ravi
 
Resume
ResumeResume
Resume
Priya G N
 
Resume
ResumeResume
Resume
Priya G N
 
Cary Arrington Financial Professional Resume A
Cary Arrington Financial Professional Resume ACary Arrington Financial Professional Resume A
Cary Arrington Financial Professional Resume A
Cary Arrington
 
Regina_Fong_Resume_2015rev8
Regina_Fong_Resume_2015rev8Regina_Fong_Resume_2015rev8
Regina_Fong_Resume_2015rev8
Regina Yeo
 
Regina fong resume_2015rev8
Regina fong resume_2015rev8Regina fong resume_2015rev8
Regina fong resume_2015rev8
Regina Yeo
 
N122
N122N122
N122
N122N122
N122
N122N122
Saravanaraj Resume-29072016
Saravanaraj Resume-29072016Saravanaraj Resume-29072016
Saravanaraj Resume-29072016
SARAVANA RAJ
 
Mezzanine Finance for Independents: How to Keep Your Project Moving by Tom Ba...
Mezzanine Finance for Independents: How to Keep Your Project Moving by Tom Ba...Mezzanine Finance for Independents: How to Keep Your Project Moving by Tom Ba...
Mezzanine Finance for Independents: How to Keep Your Project Moving by Tom Ba...
Daniel Matranga
 
Brett Morris Resume
Brett Morris ResumeBrett Morris Resume
Brett Morris Resume
Brett Morris
 
Credit Readiness For Borrowers 072110 Jc Edits
Credit Readiness For Borrowers 072110 Jc EditsCredit Readiness For Borrowers 072110 Jc Edits
Credit Readiness For Borrowers 072110 Jc Edits
jc49
 
Benchmark webinar presentation
Benchmark webinar presentation Benchmark webinar presentation
Benchmark webinar presentation
Auxis Consulting & Outsourcing
 
Changing the PMO Status Quo with Frank La Rocca 051314
Changing the PMO Status Quo with Frank La Rocca 051314Changing the PMO Status Quo with Frank La Rocca 051314
Changing the PMO Status Quo with Frank La Rocca 051314
UMT360
 
You have the Money - Now What?
You have the Money - Now What? You have the Money - Now What?
You have the Money - Now What?
The Capital Network
 
Practical tips for compensation professionals
Practical tips for compensation professionalsPractical tips for compensation professionals
Practical tips for compensation professionals
HRsoft - Talent Management Software
 
Time to change? How to shape the profession for tomorrow
Time to change? How to shape the profession for tomorrowTime to change? How to shape the profession for tomorrow
Time to change? How to shape the profession for tomorrow
Association for Project Management
 
Gregory Shireman PM 12 05 2016
Gregory Shireman  PM 12 05 2016Gregory Shireman  PM 12 05 2016
Gregory Shireman PM 12 05 2016
Greg Shireman
 

Similar to Delta Dental Analysis (20)

AFP 2016 - What is your cash forecast costing you
AFP 2016 - What is your cash forecast costing youAFP 2016 - What is your cash forecast costing you
AFP 2016 - What is your cash forecast costing you
 
Clothes R Us Situational analysis
Clothes R Us Situational analysisClothes R Us Situational analysis
Clothes R Us Situational analysis
 
Resume
ResumeResume
Resume
 
Resume
ResumeResume
Resume
 
Cary Arrington Financial Professional Resume A
Cary Arrington Financial Professional Resume ACary Arrington Financial Professional Resume A
Cary Arrington Financial Professional Resume A
 
Regina_Fong_Resume_2015rev8
Regina_Fong_Resume_2015rev8Regina_Fong_Resume_2015rev8
Regina_Fong_Resume_2015rev8
 
Regina fong resume_2015rev8
Regina fong resume_2015rev8Regina fong resume_2015rev8
Regina fong resume_2015rev8
 
N122
N122N122
N122
 
N122
N122N122
N122
 
N122
N122N122
N122
 
Saravanaraj Resume-29072016
Saravanaraj Resume-29072016Saravanaraj Resume-29072016
Saravanaraj Resume-29072016
 
Mezzanine Finance for Independents: How to Keep Your Project Moving by Tom Ba...
Mezzanine Finance for Independents: How to Keep Your Project Moving by Tom Ba...Mezzanine Finance for Independents: How to Keep Your Project Moving by Tom Ba...
Mezzanine Finance for Independents: How to Keep Your Project Moving by Tom Ba...
 
Brett Morris Resume
Brett Morris ResumeBrett Morris Resume
Brett Morris Resume
 
Credit Readiness For Borrowers 072110 Jc Edits
Credit Readiness For Borrowers 072110 Jc EditsCredit Readiness For Borrowers 072110 Jc Edits
Credit Readiness For Borrowers 072110 Jc Edits
 
Benchmark webinar presentation
Benchmark webinar presentation Benchmark webinar presentation
Benchmark webinar presentation
 
Changing the PMO Status Quo with Frank La Rocca 051314
Changing the PMO Status Quo with Frank La Rocca 051314Changing the PMO Status Quo with Frank La Rocca 051314
Changing the PMO Status Quo with Frank La Rocca 051314
 
You have the Money - Now What?
You have the Money - Now What? You have the Money - Now What?
You have the Money - Now What?
 
Practical tips for compensation professionals
Practical tips for compensation professionalsPractical tips for compensation professionals
Practical tips for compensation professionals
 
Time to change? How to shape the profession for tomorrow
Time to change? How to shape the profession for tomorrowTime to change? How to shape the profession for tomorrow
Time to change? How to shape the profession for tomorrow
 
Gregory Shireman PM 12 05 2016
Gregory Shireman  PM 12 05 2016Gregory Shireman  PM 12 05 2016
Gregory Shireman PM 12 05 2016
 

Delta Dental Analysis

  • 1. Edan Carignan, Caroline Rashidi, Shane Nath Enterprise Resource Planning Computer System Upgrade Sponsor: Mr. Gary Radine
  • 2. Agenda ❖ Company Summary ❖ Project Summary ❖ Project Constraints ❖ Financing The Project Using 100% Cash ❖ Maximum Debt ❖ Delayed Completion ❖ Delayed Layoffs ❖ Re-Upgrade of Project ❖ Possible Outcomes ❖ Recommendation ❖ Q&A
  • 3. Company Summary ❖ Non-profit organization founded in 1954 ❖ Largest dental plan system in the US ❖ 39 members covering all 50 states ❖ Enrollment and gross revenues doubled by CEO Mr. Gary Radine
  • 4. Project Summary ❖ Best method of implementing ERP system ❖ 35 page report ❖ 5 detailed scenarios ❖ Possible outcomes of each scenario ❖ Recommendation to Delta Dental Delay of ERP Implementation Edan All Cash Max Debt Delayed Layoffs Shane Re-Upgrade Possible Outcomes Caroline
  • 5. Project Constraints ❖ Cash surplus cannot go below $200 million ❖ Only method of raising capital is a 3- year loan ❖ Loan amount limited to $80 million ❖ $20 million annual cash inflow ❖ Management prefers the funding to be from cash flow from operations and borrowings from the bank
  • 6. Financing using 100% Cash ❖ Policy to not go below $200 million in cash reserves ❖ $106 million project cost ❖ Risks ❖ Leverage will decrease $75 $150 $225 $300 C ash Surplus ProjectC ost Cash Surplus Project Cost Cash Reserve Limit
  • 7. Financing using 100% Cash Comparable Companies Leverage Ratio (L/A) United Healthcare (UNH) 0.61 Wellpoint (WLP) [acquired by Anthem] 0.63 Aetna (AET) 0.72 CIGNA Corp. (CI) 0.80 Humana (HUM) 0.60 Centene Corp. (CNC) 0.70 Health Net, Inc. (HNT) 0.71 WellCare Health Plans (WCG) 0.67 Healthspring (HS) [acquired by Cigna] 0.47 Molina Healthcare (MOH) 0.77 Average 0.67 0.18 0.35 0.53 0.70 Delta Dental Top 10 0.67 0.54
  • 8. Maximum Debt Pros ❖ More Liquid Cash ❖ Current Low Interest Rates Cons ❖ Risk of Default ❖ Drop in Credit Rating
  • 9. Maximum Debt A.M Bests’ BCAR Model ❖ Business Profile ❖ Operating Performance ❖ Balance Sheet Strength
  • 10. Delayed Completion of Project 59% 41% Exceed Budget 53% 47% Take Longer 49% 51% Receive Anticipated Benefits
  • 11. Delayed Completion of Project ERP Evaluation Team Poorly Defined Requirements Change in Management During Implementation Choosing a Vendor Based Solely On Sales Pitch Lack of Employee Training Reason Solution Involve more employees than ERP Evaluation Team Spend time understanding your specific needs Invest in comprehensive training programs
  • 12. Delayed Layoffs Scenario ❖ Originally 400 layoffs in year 4 ❖ Delay of 200 employees for 2 extra years Reasons ❖ Project delayed ❖ System is not as efficient ❖ Employee adjustment time Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Cash Surplus $300,000 $397,850 $417,850 $369,500 $403,750 $433,250 Cash from Operations $20,000 $20,000 $20,000 $20,000 $20,000 $20,000 Borrowed Capital $33,216 -$33,216 FTE Reductions $9,500 $14,250 $9,500 $4,750 Total $353,216 $417,850 $414,134 $403,750 $433,250 $458,000
  • 13. Delayed Layoffs Short Term Effects ❖ Pay extra $28.5 million Long Term Effects ❖ Fear of layoffs ❖ Employee Morale Decreases ❖ Workplace Productivity Decreases Outcome ❖ Layoffs are necessary ❖ Extra money is spent ❖ Fear within employees is set $28.5 million
  • 14. Re-Upgrade of Project Technological Revolution ❖ Significant investments in computer upgrades ❖ Opportunities in infrastructure and application development To Stay Competitive ❖ Keep and increase market share ❖ Appropriate response to competitors
  • 15. Possible Outcomes ❖ Invest in marketing ❖ Invest in mobile platform ❖ Invest in research and risk management ❖ Lower insurance premiums ❖ Invest in money-market securities
  • 16. Recommendation ❖ Balloon payment and FTE layoffs happen concurrently ❖ Strict layoff policy ❖ ERP Evaluation Team ❖ After successful project, Delta Dental should invest in the previously mentioned possible outcomes 68% 32% Debt Cash