Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Complete, creative solutions for developers
and manufacturers of rapid assays
Seminar on Business and Innovation in Biotechnology
INOVATEC
Belo Horizonte, Brazil. October 5th, 2010
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• Brief introduction to DCN
• State of the art in applied rapid assay technology
– Standard formats for standard applications
– More advanced formats for quantification, high
sensitivity and digital interpretation
• Market Opportunities and Market Demands
• Market Driven Innovation: Meeting market demand
– Materials and reagents
– Cassette and sample handler design
– Reader development
• System development case studies
Agenda
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Key Points
1. Rapid testing is a dynamically growing, readily accessible market
with opportunities available in numerous market segments
2. Assays can be developed to handle almost any reasonable market
condition, based on existing technology
– Simple, low cost lateral flow assays for simple, qualitative low
resolution applications
– More complex, more expensive lateral flow systems for high
sensitivity, more quantitative, difficult applications
– These two types of assay are very different in how they are
developed and manufactured
– Other approaches to high performance rapid testing are
possible, but with a much longer outlook.
3. All of the elements needed to manufacture high performance tests
are available today, so while technological innovation is ongoing, we
can also choose to innovate in terms of where we apply
these technologies
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Introduction to DCN
• Based in Carlsbad, California
• Founded in 2003 with the purpose of assisting companies in
developing, manufacturing and commercializing rapid tests for
any application.
• Our primary platform technologies are lateral flow, flow
through, microfluidic, dipstick (chemistry) and rapid ELISA,
using visual, fluorescent or paramagnetic detection systems
• We work in any market segment where these technologies can
be applied
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Primary Services and Products
Consulting
on any aspect of rapid assay development
and commercialization
Rapid assay development and manufacturing
From Feasibility and Prototyping to full Development and
Manufacturing Transfer
Education and training courses in rapid assay technology
Learn how to develop and manufacture rapid tests
Custom conjugation services
protein – particle, protein-protein, small molecule etc
Products
Materials starter kits
Gold conjugation kits
Latex conjugation kits
Colloidal gold
All related lateral flow materials
Lateral flow reader systems: Fluorescent and visual
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• Fully equipped for the manufacture of lateral flow, flow through,
and other rapid assay formats
• 8000 square feet, containing 3000 square feet of wet lab, housed in
a class 10,000 capable cleanroom, and an associated controlled
humidity room
• ISO 9001:2008 compliant, with EN 13485 by end 2010
• Development staff of 14 industrially experienced assay development
scientists
Facility and Personnel
Reagent Prep Area
Main Lab (Class 10,000 capable
cleanroom)
Component
Processing Area
(Temperature /
Humidity
Controlled)
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Our Markets
Medical Diagnostics
Veterinary Diagnostics
Agricultural /
Environmental
Food Testing
OTC/Consumer
Pharmaceutical
Biowarfare
Law enforcement /
Forensics
Microbiology
Nucleic Acid Testing
Industrial Health
and Safety
Our market is
international and
spread over multiple
application areas.
Approximately 40% of
our assay development
programs are US-
based, 40% are
European and 20% are
spread among Asia and
Latin America
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Representative Clients
• Johnson and Johnson (UK)
• Novozymes (Denmark)
• Amic (Sweden)
• ICP Bio (Australia)
• Rockeby (Australia)
• Government of Thailand NIH (Thailand
• Pacific Biotech (Thailand)
• Span Diagnostics (India)
• Daiichi Fine Chemical (Japan)
• Elixir Biosciences (China)
• MARS/Masterfoods (UK)
• Laboratorio Silanes (Mexico)
• Mintek (South Africa)
• Biosensia (Ireland)
• BioRad (US/EU)
• Chiron Corporation (US)
• Amgen (US)
• Abbott (US)
• Genzyme Diagnostics (US)
• Becton Dickinson (US)
• Church and Dwight (US)
• 3M (US)
• Whatman /GE (US / Europe)
• Aspen BioPharma (US)
• Genetic Testing Institute (GTI) (US)
• Cibavision (US)
• CDC (US)
• NIH (US)
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Simple Devices for Rapid Testing
Standard Lateral Flow Strip
Sample addition
Conjugate
solubilization
Capillary flow;
antibody binding
Membrane clearing;
optical reading
Step 1
Step 2
Step 3
Step 4
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Sample addition
Optional wash
Conjugate addition; antibody binding
Final wash; membrane clearing;
optical reading
Simple Devices for Rapid Testing
Standard Flow – through device
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Evolution in Point of Care Assays
Drivers for Innovation and Market Growth
• Early POC devices were designed for qualitative applications
• Earliest applications in the 1980s were pregnancy tests,
growing in the 1990’s to include drugs of abuse and
infectious disease tests
• Market has grown steadily at a minimum CAGR of 10% since
the late 1990’s
• Market demand for tests in non-traditional areas has
expanded to include quantitative, high sensitivity
applications using difficult matrices, driving development
• Intellectual property issues have driven technological
innovation strongly in the past decade
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Innovative Applications
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Why lateral flow assays dominate the
(non glucose) POC market
• Ease of use: Minimal operator dependent steps and
interpretation
• Can handle small volumes of multiple sample types
• Can have high sensitivity, specificity, good stability
• Good Manufacturability and Scalability
• Minimal market and user education required
• Market presence and acceptance
• Short development cycle – once reagents are developed, the
timeline to manufacturing transfer and approval is short
relative to other biotech products
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• Sensitivity
• Control of user interpretation
• Reproducibility (CV)/ Quantification
• Multiplexing is difficult
Typical performance challenges in standard rapid assays
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Application Requirements are Driving the
Technology Forward
•The requirements that the major rapid test markets are demanding
include:
• Speed to result: 2-10 minutes
• Sensitivity: high picogram/ml to low nanogram/ml
• Ability to handle difficult sample matrices
• Quantification
• Multiplexing
• Removal of interpretation issues
• Control of data
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Evolution in Rapid Test Technology:
An Exercise in Market Driven Innovation
Development in rapid diagnostic testing incorporates elements of use
inspired basic research (application development) and pure applied
research (technology development)
Clients provide use
inspired basic research
DCN and partners provide
the applied element
Pasteur's Quadrant describes scientific research that both seeks
fundamental understanding of scientific problems, and, at the same
time, seeks to be eventually useful.
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• Product Requirements Development
• Concept Refinement
• Feasibility and prototyping of all system elements
• Product development and system integration
• Transfer to manufacturing
• Commercialization
Bridging the Concept Gap
DCN
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Medical Diagnostics
89
Veterinary
9
Food and
Beverage
1
Pharmceuticals
0.6
Envionmental
0.2
Water
0.2
Percent of Market by Application
Total Market 2007: USD $2.3 billion
Total Market 2012: USD $$3.7 billion
Medical Diagnostics
Veterinary
Food and Beverage
Pharmceuticals
Envionmental
Water
High Performance Allows for New Applications
Rapid Test Market Penetration and Opportunities
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Major Rapid Test Market Opportunities
1. Medical Diagnostics
35%
20%
21%
13%
7% 4%
% market 2007
Pregnancy Infectious diseases Cardiac markers
Cholesterol/lipds Drugs of abuse Other
24%
27%
26%
15%
5% 3%
predicted market 2012
Pregnancy Infectious diseases Cardiac markers
Cholesterol/lipds Drugs of abuse Other
•Growth opportunities exist in all
medical segments
•Growth will be driven by
reimbursement in US and EU markets
•Requires performance improvements
in quantification, sensitivity,
reproducibility and multiplexing
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Major Rapid Test Market Opportunities
2. Veterinary Diagnostics
• Market was $205 million (USD) in 2007
• 9% CAGR to 2012 predicts a $310 million market by 2012
• Highly fragmented, price sensitive market, split among small
animals and livestock
• Major segments are infectious disease testing, metabolic
testing (cancer), diabetes and fertility/pregnancy
•Small animal tests tend to be paid for by owners and are non-
regulated for the most part. Large animal testing tends to be
government mandated and is regulated
•Growth driven by acceptance in large animal testing for
infectious disease and fertility, and control of antibiotic use and
in small animals by cancer and infectious disease testing
•Requires performance improvements in quantification,
sensitivity, reproducibility and multiplexing
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Major Rapid Test Market Opportunities
3. Food and beverage testing
• Worldwide market of about $30 million in 2007
•Expected CAGR of 15% predicts $60 million by 2012
•Market is under-penetrated by rapid tests due to the
preponderance of microbiological testing (slow, traditional
technology largely used)
•Combinations of molecular and immunological testing may be
important to this market
•Growth will be driven by increased awareness of rapid
formats coupled with sampling and performance
improvements that can generate appropriate sensitivity
•Requires performance improvements in quantification,
sensitivity, reproducibility and multiplexing
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Major Rapid Test Market Opportunities
4. Water Testing and Environmental Remediation
• Worldwide market of about $5 million in 2007.
• Expected CAGR of 4% predicts $6 million by 2012.
• Highly regulated markets, with local or governmental agencies
setting requirements for testing, often in association with AOAC
(Association of Official Analytical Chemists International)
• Most testing is performed in certified laboratories by approved
methods
• Rapid tests are typically performed as spot checks between
mandated test periods
• Also used for household and industrial testing of water quality in
certain markets
• Growth will be driven by increased awareness of rapid formats
coupled with performance improvements
•Requires performance improvements in quantification,
sensitivity, reproducibility and multiplexing
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• Option 1: Develop completely new platform technologies
based on microfluidics and alternative detection technologies
e.g. lab on a chip,
• Option 2: Improve the existing technology platform
Market – Driven Innovation
Making test performance meet market demands
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
A System Approach
• Rapid lateral flow and flow through assays can meet many
of the market’s requirements, but a different approach to
the assay is needed
• High performing rapid assays need to be approached in the
same way as high performance laboratory based systems
• Key system elements:
1) A properly developed assay made using
1) High quality materials
2) High quality reagents
3) Highly sensitive label for sensitive analyte detection
2) A well designed sample device and housing for the test
3) A controlled method for result interpretation
4) A well designed and controlled manufacturing process
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
1. Assay
Materials
• Analytical procedures usually require multiple steps
• Fluidics minimize number of steps in a test and increase ease of use
• In most POC devices these steps are performed using treated porous
matrices
• Fluid flow in POC devices usually relies on capillary flow
• Fluidic elements are usually designed to be disposable, and are
therefore made from low cost materials
• Suppliers must be of the highest quality. Lowest cost materials will not
support higher specified applications
Test Line
Control Line
Particle Conjugate
on conjugate pad
Wick
Sample Pad
Nitrocellulose Membrane
Backing
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
1. Assay
Reagents
• Recognition is generally Ab-Ag or Ab-Ab based
• Different characteristics are required for high performance in a
lateral flow system than in an ELISA, for instance, due to the
mechanics of the system:
– The method chosen for screening is important
• Important Parameters:
– Specificity
– Dissociation Constant (Kd)
– High Affinity (High Binding Rate Constant (kon))
– Antibody Class (subtype: IgG1, IgG2A, IgG3, etc.)
– Monoclonals typically preferred, but high purity
polyclonals can also be used effectively
77
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
1. Assay
Labels
• Colloidal gold
– Typically 20-40nm
– Low cost, difficult to control passive conjugations, one color,
relatively sensitive. Most common in qualitative applications
• Latex: Colored, Fluorescent, Paramagnetic
– Typically 100-300nm
– Low cost, covalent conjugations, variety of chemistries, well
controlled, stable, variety of particles and labels. Most common for
high sensitivity, quantitative applications (fluorescent,
paramagnetic)
• Others
– Upconverting phosphors
– Colloidal carbon
– Direct labeling using fluorophores and enhancers
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Commonly used fluorescent labels in POC Applications
• We love fluorescence for high end applications!
• DCN’s Experience:
– Dark Red Labels (660-680nm) give good results due to lack of
background fluorescence in biological fluids in that spectral area
– Europium: Highly sensitive and commonly used due to broad
Stokes’ shift and stability (300 – 625nm)
– Direct labeling of antibodies using fluorescent dyes is also an
option – sensitivity an issue – requires customization of system
components.
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
2. Readers
The use of readers in lateral flow assay systems
Detection of the signal generated
by the reagents, translation into a
numerical or alphanumerical
output, and delivery of that
output
Use of readers allows for:
• Improved sensitivity
• Reduction in user interpretation
issues
• Data capture, analysis and
storage
• Connectivity
• Quantification
• New applications
Negative Positive
100% Visually
Negative
100% Visually
Positive
Operator Dependent Negative or Positive
Critical features:
• Hardware
• Algorithms for data processing,
• Signal to noise reduction,
• Measurement and data distribution
• Calibration methods
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Reader Supply Partners
• Off-the-shelf readers are available that can be readily modified
for any development program
• DCN represents two suppliers: LRE and Qiagen Lake Constance
(formerly ESE)
– Provide a base platform from which to start
– Have a history of development of this type of product
– Have experience of regulatory and technical requirements
– Can advise on important technical design considerations
– May be faster to market
– Generally have dedicated manufacturing capability
• Readers can be custom designed by experienced designer such
as Source Scientific, Polygenesis, Omnica (all DCN partners)
– Slower and more expensive route in return for a
custom solution
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• Sensitive
• Affordable
• Simple to operate
• Small, Mobile and Robust
• Documented Results
• Objective Results
• Quantitative Results
ESE Quant
DCN’s Reader Partners: Handheld and Benchtop Readers
DCN distributes both ESE and LRE readers
DCN acts as the assay integration partner for both suppliers for
customers worldwide
LRE POC Reader
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400
Data points
Intensity
[mV]
Scan1
Scan2
Scan3
Scan4
Scan5
Scan6
Scan7
Scan8
Scan9
Scan10
Scan11
Scan12
Scan13
Scan14
Scan15
Scan16
Scan17
Scan18
Scan19
Scan20
Control
Test
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Comparison of gold and fluorescent labels
LF Tuberculosis Fluorescent Assay
• Based on a dark red dye (latex particle based)
• Monoclonal sandwich assay
• Compared directly to a colloidal gold method
• Results read digitally using the ESE-Quant reader
Dark Red Dye (Latex)
ex 660 em 680
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
500 550 600 650 700 750
Wavelength (nm)
Rel.
Intensity
Excitation
Emission
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
LF Tuberculosis Fluorescent Assay
Gold vs. Fluorescent Latex
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
0 0.1 0.5 0.75 1 1.25 5
Peak
Height
(pixel
units)
Peak
Height
(mV)
Concentration (ng/ml)
Sensitivity in TB Protein Assay:
Gold vs Dark Red FlourescentLatex
FlourescentLatex Gold
• Sensitivity greater than 0.2 ng/mL.
• Using same antibody / antigen combination, the assay
developed using a Dark Red fluorescent particle is >10 fold
more sensitive than the assay developed using gold.
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Anthrax Protective Antigen Assay
• Assay for a recombinant
Anthrax protein
• Quantitative &
qualitative results
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
0.00
1.00
2.00
3.00
4.00
5.00
6.00
7.00
8.00
9.00
10.00
11.00
1 10 100 1000 10000
Signal
/
Noise
Ratio
Ng/mL rPA
Gold vs. Latex Comparison - Lateral Flow
Anthrax Protective Antigen Assay
Gold
Fluorescent
Anthrax Protective Antigen Results
• Fluorescent assay sensitive to
2 ng/mL. Approximately 60-
fold better sensitivity than
comparable gold assay
• Visual or reader based
results
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
3. Device Design
The importance of device design in test performance
• Cassette design plays an integral role in the
performance of the assay
• Early integration of cassettes with sample delivery
elements and with strips is a critical element of
the design process
• If a reader is to be used, design device with this
in mind – off the shelf cassettes will rarely work
• Novelty in approach can lead to major benefits
e.g. separation of sample handling and conjugate mixing from the
remainder of the device can significantly improve CV’s
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
The SymbioSysTm Program
• Rapid diagnostics have historically had less emphasis on
engineering than other industries. (ie. Medical Device)
• Typical approach: Develop the strip, then find or try to design a
cassette that works with it
– highly inefficient and counter-productive.
• With current demands for ease of use, precision, quantification,
low cost of goods and reduced time to market, this method is
no longer acceptable.
• Concurrent engineering, assay development and user needs
development is required to achieve this level of performance.
• DCN and Symbient developed the SymbioSys program to
address this demand.
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
DCN’s Design Partner: Symbient Product Development
• Established in 2004.
• Focus on development of single use diagnostic devices.
• Product Types:
– Lateral Flow Cartridges
– Fluidic Cartridges with Integrated Functions
– Sample Delivery Systems - pipettes, lancet devices,
urine cups.
– Instrument Driven Systems
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
CONFIDENTIAL
Services Provided
• Mechanical Product Design
• Industrial Design
• 3D Solid Modeling (Solidworks)
• Program Management
• Precision Prototype Machining
• Rapid Prototype Tooling and Molding
• LIM Silicone Molding
• Product Testing and Test Method Development.
• Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA)
• Process Development
• Manufacturing Transition
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Sample Handling Device and Cartridge Design
• DCN and Symbient have
designed and developed
several devices for collecting
and processing samples for
diagnostic testing.
• Sample types include saliva,
whole blood, fecal matter,
urine, mucous and surfaces.
• Methods include integrated
buffers, mixing, filtering and
metering.
• DCN and Symbient have
developed various
diagnostic cartridges
including single test strip,
multiple test strip and
specialty housings.
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Device
Optical Reader
Example: Sample handling in a quantitative
agricultural test
• Vertical flow assay
• Rapid and quantifiable
• Increased sensitivity with
integrated pre-incubation
• Particulate samples do not cause
flow problems
1. PRE-INCUBATION
2. FLOW THROUGH
3. RESULT
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Alpha Amylase Detection in Wheat
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
srw170 srw138 srw139 cbh2.7 cbh2.8
Falling
Number
Wheat Sample
Comparisonof Values from Device andTrue Falling
NumberValues
True FN
DiagnostIQ AvgFN
DiagnostIQ Avg
[Amylase]
Hagberg Falling Numbers are determined by dropping a ball through a tube of
ground wheat. The time it takes in seconds for it to reach the bottom correlates
inversely to the amount of alpha-amylase in the wheat. High falling numbers
indicate low concentrations of alpha-amylase, and low falling numbers indicate a
high concentration of alpha-amylase.
Falling Number
True
FN
avg
amyl
conc.
St
Dev %CV
304 1.54 6.4 1.77%
244 21.82 3.56 1.27%
223 36.02
16.8
4 6.77%
142 144.05 6.57 4.77%
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Intellectual Property – Driven Innovation
Rapiplex: A Novel Multiplex Rapid Assay Platform
• RapiPlex: An integrated Point-of-Care in vitro diagnostic platform;
• Unique intellectual property position
• Multiplex, Quantitative and/or Qualitative, Versatile, Portable
• Three integrating technologies to provide a robust platform
• Fluidics
• Immunodiagnostic assay systems
• Integrated fluorescent reade
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
+
Fluidic Chip
• Proprietary fluidic strip & chip not constrained by lateral flow IP
• Disposable oriented in the vertical position when an assay is run
• No overlapping capillary materials – gaps between materials
• Enables simultaneous multiplex analysis from a single sample
• Defined individual channels in which sample flow can be controlled
• Individual channel entry ports for each channel
• Flow control zone ensures accurate and controlled flow in each
channel
• Injection molded – High Impact Polystyrene
• Suitable for all assay formats and multiple biological fluid sample
types – demonstrated on saliva, serum and whole blood to date
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
0
100,000
200,000
300,000
400,000
500,000
600,000
700,000
800,000
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
Avg.
Peak
Height
(RFU)
Myoglobin Conc. (ng/ml)
Biosensia Myoglobin
Error Bars – 95% Confidence
Myoglobin assay
Representative DCN Data
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
0
50,000
100,000
150,000
200,000
250,000
300,000
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Avg.
Peak
Height
(RFU)
Myoglobin Conc. (ng/ml)
Biosensia Myoglobin – Low End
Error Bars – 95% Confidence
Myoglobin assay
Representative DCN Data
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Myoglobin Conc. (ng/ml) 95% Confidence Limits
5 16,661 10,504
10 37,698 22,495
25 82,432 41,144
50 145,149 106,220
100 295,043 183,477
350 764,314 483,319
Myoglobin Assay
Current DCN Sensitivity Data
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Myoglobin Dilution Series (N=12)
R² = 0.9985
R² = 1
0
100,000
200,000
300,000
400,000
500,000
600,000
700,000
800,000
900,000
10 100 1000 10000
Avg.
Peak
Height
(RFU)
log Myoglobin Conc. (ng/ml)
Biosensia Myoglobin
Before
After
Poly. (Before)
Poly. (After)
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Summary
• Solved major mechanical design issues
• Assay CV’s controlled
• Good Slope of Dose Response
• Clinically relevant sensitivity (~5 ng/ml)
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Manufacturing Process Design
Membrane Conjugate Pad
Dispense test and control lines
Block membrane if necessary
Pre-treat pad
Dispense / dip conjugate
Sample Pad
Pre-treat pad
Assemble membrane, conjugate pad, sample pad, wick and backing into cards
Cut cards into strips
Assemble strips into cassettes
Package cassettes
Dry
Dry Dry
Dry
Dry
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Process Control
Batch Vs Continuous Processes
XYZ 3050 dispenser with
BioJets and AirJets
Clamshell benchtop laminator
Manual Dip Tray
CM 4000 Guillotine Cutter
Dispensing Dipping
Lamination Cutting
Drying
Forced Air Oven
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Reel-to-reel web handling and
dispensing platform
Equipment and Processes
Batch Vs Continuous
Dispensing, Dipping,
Drying
Lamination, Cutting
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
In-line processing provides for greater process control and equivalent
processing
10
15
20
25
1
64
127
190
253
316
379
442
505
568
631
694
757
820
883
946
1009
1072
1135
1198
1261
1324
Pixels
Mean Pixel Width Std Dev %CV
17.57 0.89 5.1
In line camera and bad part
marking system on a BioDot
RTR 4500 inline dispensing
system
Output from a quality control camera
system on a RTR 4500. Dispensing run
over a 50m dispense length, 50mm/s,
human IgG at 1mg/ml, 0.8ul/cm on
nitrocellulose
Equipment and Processes
Batch Vs Continuous
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
All the elements of an integrated device
are available over the counter
• High quality test development
• Reader development
• Device development
• Manufacturing equipment
• A partnering approach is generally required to bring
the specialized expertise and components into the
assay
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
DCN’s Network Partners
DCN’s Network of Affiliates is a group of closely knit companies
that work together to provide all of the key elements necessary to
design, develop manufacture and commercialize point of care
diagnostic systems. Member companies include:
• Manufacturing equipment suppliers
• Cassette and device designers
• High volume molding companies
• Materials converters
• Reader developers and manufacturers
• Contract manufacturers
• Platform technology suppliers
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
A reader based semi quantitative serological assay:
Rapid Assay for anti-PF4:Heparin in human plasma (HIT)
• Fluorescent, reader based, integrated RFID tag and novel cassette
• ESEQuant fluorescent reader from Qiagen Lake Constance
• Threshold assay, with Positive/Negative reporting
• Predicate ELISA in market. Rapid assay must be as sensitive.
• No known standards
• Intended for the professional clinical laboratory market
• Will be labeled as an IVD :developed under full design controls
• Assay and device developed for large scale manufacturing
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Major Challenges
• Highly charged specific molecule
• Total immunoglobulin assay imparts formatting requirement
– sample and conjugate cannot mix prior to interaction with
test line
• High sensitivity needed
• Lack of standards, so establishment of cutoff requires
comparison to performance of predicate ELISA =
Requirement for high correlation to ELISA result.
• Requirement for tight CVs
• Integration of novel device design elements for IP generation
• Predicate rapid assays in the field require multiple
additions, timing steps and have poor user interface. The aim
of the program is to generate a device without these
attributes
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Comparative results of lateral flow and ELISA
data on all clinical samples
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
Test
Line
Peak
Height
(RFU)
ELISA OD
OD vs Test Line Peak Height
(All Data)
OD vs TL
• A panel of 83 samples, characterized by predicate ELISA
• All samples came from patients who had received heparin
• Testing in triplicate / quadruplicate if adequate volume
• Average values shown.
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Cutoff: Comparative
0.000
0.100
0.200
0.300
0.400
0.500
0.600
0.700
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
TL/CL
ELISA OD
OD vs TL/CL (OD <1.0)
OD vs TL/CL
0.3 od Cutoff
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
True Positive = Samples with OD > cutoff and detected as positive
False negative= Samples with OD > cutoff and detected as negative
True Negative= Samples with OD < cutoff and detected as negative
False Positive= Samples with OD < cutoff and detected as positive
OD = 0.3
ELISA TL/CL TL
True positives 41 39 37
False Negative 0 2 4
True Negatives 42 42 42
False Positive 0 0 0
n 83 83 83
PPV 100.00 100.00 100.00
NPV
100.00 95.45 91.30
Sensitivity
100.00 95.12 90.24
Specificity
100.00 100.00 100.00
Collated Testing Results:
ELISA vs LFIA using various cutoffs
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
R² = 0.9989
-500
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00
Peak
Height
(rfu)
ELISA OD
Peak Test Line Height Relative to ELISA OD, n=5
5-14 serum
TL Ht
Poly. (5-14
serum TL
Ht)
Dilution Series: High positive Diluted in Negative
R² = 0.9975
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00
TL/CL
Ratio
ELISA OD
TL/CL Ratio Relative to ELISA OD, n=5
TL/CL ratio
Poly. (TL/CL ratio)
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Integrated System Development
Using the DCN Network to develop complete assay systems
• Project Management
• System requirement definition
• Product specification
• Cassette design
• Rapid prototyping
• Mold design and development
• Mechanical engineering design
• Reader development
• GUI design
• Reagent Development
• Assay design and development
• Calibration system development
• Documentation
• Manufacturing process design
• Regulatory consulting
• Quality system management
• FMEA / Risk analysis
• High volume plastic molding • Manufacturing equipment
supply
• Manufacturing facility setup
• Scale-up and manufacturing transfer
• Reagent manufacture
• Gap manufacturing
Program Setup
and
Management
System
Development
Commercialization
• Market research
• Board level advice
• Networking to finance
• Branding
• Troubleshooting
• Patent Landscaping
Manufacturing
Transfer
The client provides the innovation in reagents and application area
DCN provides the rest
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Key Points
1. Opportunities are available in numerous market segments for
rapid assays with the right level of performance
2. Assays can be developed to handle almost any reasonable
market condition, based on existing technology
– Simple, low cost lateral flow assays for simple, qualitative
low resolution applications
– More complex, more expensive lateral flow systems for
high sensitivity, more quantitative, difficult applications
– These two types of assay are very different in how they
are developed and manufactured
– Other approaches to high performance rapid testing are
possible, but with a much longer outlook.
3. All of the elements needed to develop and manufacture
high performance tests are available today
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Acknowledgements
• DCN
– Roy Chung
– Jerrold Loo
– Wendy Mendiola
– Michael Fiechtner
• Symbient Product Development
– John Zeis
– Scott Castenon
• Shara Rosen for marketing information
• Thanks to GTI and Biosensia for use of data
• Thanks to Cynthia Rocha, Camila Resende Duarte,
Gislaine Silva, Regina Fernandes from SECTES and
Christiane Contigli from CETEC and all who
helped to coordinate my attendance at
INOVATEC
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
www.dcndx.com
Contact :
Brendan O’Farrell at
bofarrell@dcndx.com
Diagnostic Consulting Network Inc
6354 Corte del Abeto, Suite B-C
Carlsbad, CA 92011
Tel: 760-804-3886
Fax: 760-804-3866
Contact Information
Please email to receive copies of the slides
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• Quickly develop and commercialize rapid assays for any application
• Experienced with fluorescent, visual (colloidal gold / latex) and
paramagnetic labels
– From concept to commercialized assay in under 12 months
– ELISA conversion to rapid assay formats in short timeframes
– Reagent sourcing and development
– Rapid prototyping
– Feasibility studies
– Complete development
– Manufacturing transfer
We can develop assays for you:
Assay Development Services
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• The plastic devices used in these assays can determine their ability to
perform in demanding applications and need to be custom developed
in virtually any high performance application
• DCN partners with product designers, such as Symbient Product
Development and molding companies such as HK Plastics to integrate
new cassettes and novel device designs into programs for clients
• Partners can be contracted through DCN, and DCN will manage the
entire development program on behalf of the client
We can design and develop your plastic devices:
Cartridge and Device Design Service
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• DCN partners with the major suppliers of readers to the point of care
marketplace to provide reader solutions for our customers.
• We can provide readers for:
– Visual labels
– Fluorescent labels
– Paramagnetic labels
• Our primary partners for off the shelf and custom reader supply are QLC
(formerly ESE) and LRE (Esterline), and we distribute for both companies in the
US.
• We also work with custom reader design and development houses including
Source Scientific and Polygenesis.
We can help you develop reader systems for your assays
Reader Development and Integration
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• DCN can develop and
commercialize all aspects of
a point of care diagnostics
platform, through our in-
house capabilities and our
Network of Affiliates
• Custom design and
integration for high
performance assays our
specialty
We can design and develop your complete assay system
Integrated System Design and Development
Cartridge top housing
Desiccant
RF id tag
Cartridge bottom housing
Strip and Assay
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
We can connect you to all of the best suppliers:
The Network of Affiliates
DCN’s Network of Affiliates is a group of closely knit companies
that work together to provide all of the key elements necessary to
design, develop manufacture and commercialize point of care
diagnostic systems. Member companies include:
• Manufacturing equipment suppliers
• Cassette and device designers
• High volume molding companies
• Materials converters
• Reader developers and manufacturers
• Contract manufacturers
• Platform technology suppliers
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• Learn how to develop and manufacture lateral flow assays
• Customized one-on-one courses held at DCN’s core facility in
Carlsbad, California
• Scheduled on demand
• Duration 3 – 5 days
• Theoretical and practical elements dealt with
• Bring your reagents and optimize an assay during the course
We can teach you to develop and make your own assays
Education and Training Services
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
We can help with any aspect of commercialization
Consulting Services
DCN has over 20 consultants on staff that can provide a wide range of
services related to the point of need diagnostics or detection business:
• Regulatory Affairs
• Project management
• Risk assessment
• Intellectual property landscaping
• Manufacturing process development
• Assay troubleshooting
• Quality system establishment for diagnostic companies
• Device design
• Facility setup
• Equipment specification and procurement
• Market evaluation
• Technology evaluation
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• DCN’s facility is completely equipped for manufacture of lateral flow, flow through, and
other format point of need assays
• The facility:
– 8000 square feet, containing 3000 square feet of wet lab, housed in a class 10,000
capable cleanroom, and an associated controlled humidity room
– Currently ISO 9001:2008 compliant and will complete EN 13485 by end Q4 2010
• Manufacture non-FDA regulated product for several clients in the US and Europe, and
components and reagents for clients in the US and outside
• DCN partners with several dedicated contract manufacturers to whom
it can transfer product for manufacturing.
We can manufacture your tests for you
Contract Manufacturing
Reagent Prep Area
Main Lab (Class 10,000 capable
cleanroom)
Component
Processing Area
(Temperature /
Humidity
Controlled)
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• DCN provides everything needed to develop or manufacture lateral flow or
flow through assays
– Colloidal gold, colored and fluorescent latex beads and conjugates
– Assay materials: membranes, pads, backing, cassettes wicks, etc
– Antibodies and antigens
– Small molecule conjugates
– Test strip readers: Handheld and benchtop
• Kits of materials and reagents
– Colloidal gold
– Material Starter Kit
– Colloidal gold conjugation kit
– Latex conjugation kit
– Gold conjugation kit
We can supply you with key components
Materials, Reagents and Kits
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
We can make the critical reagents for you
Custom Conjugate Development and Manufacture
• Expertise in covalent conjugations
– Protein / peptide /small molecule –Particle
• Colored, fluorescent or paramagnetic latex, gold, quantum dots,
etc.
– Protein – Protein
• Full optimization process
• Full QC including binding
assays where reagents are
available
• For diagnostics or separations (magnetic latex)
• Small to full prep scale
Streptavidin Bead #2
-0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
0 5 10 15 20 25
ng Biotin
OD
Strep #2 (1X)
Strep #2 (10X)
Strep #2 (20X)
Merck Strep REC/1.0um
Candidat 2
Merck Strep C-REC/ 1.0um
Candidat 4
Merck Strep TREC/1.0um
Candidat 4
Merck Strep 0.2umCandidat 1
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• Dr Roy Chung: Over 25 years of assay development and manufacturing
experience. Previously Lead Scientist at Nanogen
• Dr Hans Boehringer: Over 20 years of assay development and manufacturing
experience. Most recently Scientific Director at Genzyme Diagnostics
• Dr Brendan O’Farrell: 20 years of assay development, manufacturing,
equipment and manufacturing process development. Previously VP of
Technology Development at BioDot Inc and Director of R&D and Manufacturing
at SDS Inc.
• Michael Surmanian: 20 years of biotech technology development experience.
Formerly President of BioDot Inc.
• Assay Development Team of 10 scientists, all of whom worked for major
human and veterinary diagnostic companies. Minimum of 5 years of experience
Consulting Group.: Over 25 industry experts available. Examples:
• Dr Judith Howard: Ex VP of Quality, Regulatory at Inverness Medical
Innovations
• Dr David Boudreau: Ex Director of Operations, Nanogen Inc
• Michael Weinholt: President of Regulatory Consulting Inc
Our People
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Our Strengths
• Expertise in reagent development, assay development, device design
and reader integration
• Experience in all aspects of system development, regulation,
commercialization and manufacturing
• Modular menu of services, allowing for flexible project execution –
select only the services you need
• Parallel development strategies for device and assay development –
science and engineering combined
• Networked to all of the partners you will need to get to market
• Full design controls and documentation.
• Full support for registration activities
• Speed to commercialization
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
1) Assay
• Materials for fluid movement and reaction matrices
• Biological recognition reagents (antibodies/antigens)
• Signal generation reagents (labels)
2) Reader system
• Technology
• Supplier
3) Device
• Sample collection and processing
• Conjugate handling and mixing
• Cassettes
4) Manufacturing process design
Challenges in Designing and Manufacturing
High Performance POC Assays
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Market Penetration by Application
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Medical
Diagnostics
Veterinary Food and
Beverage
Pharmceuticals Envionmental Water
% of Available Market, 2007
(compared to lab based immunoassays that have a rapid segment)
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
Percentage of Available Market by
Geographical Region
US
EU
ROW
Market Penetration by Geographical Region
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
• Sensitivity:
• Fluorescence based tests can be more sensitive than colorimetric
• Higher sensitivity allows new applications and markets
• Control
• Fluorescent assays are based on latex particles which can be
coupled covalently. Colloidal gold conjugation is passive.
• This allows for better control of the conjugates and improved CV‘s
• Availability
• High quality, high performance beads available
• Multiple sizes, chemistries
• Availability of off-the shelf readers
• Makes development easy and low cost
• Makes fluorescence a comparatively open system
Why we like fluorescent labels
for reader based applications
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Device Design Trends and Implications
• IP considerations have driven a trend towards novel device design:
– clear pathways to designing non-infringing devices exist
• For many applications, sample handling, sample preparation,
extraction and delivery to devices need to be performed
– E.g. Tests for agriculture, biowarfare, food pathogen testing,
environmental testing involve handling difficult samples, treating
them and delivering them to devices in difficult field conditions.
– Devices can be designed and integrated to cassettes to perform
these functions
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Myoglobin Conc.
(ng/ml)
n
Avg Peak
Height
CV
0 15 0 na
5 15 13,583 11.3%
10 15 30,097 12.6%
25 15 61,788 16.7%
50 15 125,685 7.7%
100 15 239,260 11.7%
350 15 623,817 11.3%
Myoglobin assay data
Representative DCN Data
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Prototyping Capabilities
CNC Machining
Prototype Mold Fabrication Injection Molding
Steriolithography (SLA)
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Assembly and Testing
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Myo Conc. (ng/ml) N Avg. TL pk ht TL %CV
25 12 64,948 11.0%
50 12 118,659 5.9%
100 12 229,002 10.4%
250 12 457,563 4.1%
500 12 749,168 6.9%
Myoglobin Dilution Series (N=12)
Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays
Overall Conclusion
• Doing so requires careful design of all aspects of the
product and the integration of high quality fluorescent
label, cassette and reader technologies
• The design and development of products of this nature is a
highly specialized task
• That is where a company like DCN, with specialist
knowledge and experience, comes into the picture
• How can we help you?........

Dcn inovatec presentation final

  • 1.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Complete, creative solutions for developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Seminar on Business and Innovation in Biotechnology INOVATEC Belo Horizonte, Brazil. October 5th, 2010
  • 2.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • Brief introduction to DCN • State of the art in applied rapid assay technology – Standard formats for standard applications – More advanced formats for quantification, high sensitivity and digital interpretation • Market Opportunities and Market Demands • Market Driven Innovation: Meeting market demand – Materials and reagents – Cassette and sample handler design – Reader development • System development case studies Agenda
  • 3.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Key Points 1. Rapid testing is a dynamically growing, readily accessible market with opportunities available in numerous market segments 2. Assays can be developed to handle almost any reasonable market condition, based on existing technology – Simple, low cost lateral flow assays for simple, qualitative low resolution applications – More complex, more expensive lateral flow systems for high sensitivity, more quantitative, difficult applications – These two types of assay are very different in how they are developed and manufactured – Other approaches to high performance rapid testing are possible, but with a much longer outlook. 3. All of the elements needed to manufacture high performance tests are available today, so while technological innovation is ongoing, we can also choose to innovate in terms of where we apply these technologies
  • 4.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Introduction to DCN • Based in Carlsbad, California • Founded in 2003 with the purpose of assisting companies in developing, manufacturing and commercializing rapid tests for any application. • Our primary platform technologies are lateral flow, flow through, microfluidic, dipstick (chemistry) and rapid ELISA, using visual, fluorescent or paramagnetic detection systems • We work in any market segment where these technologies can be applied
  • 5.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Primary Services and Products Consulting on any aspect of rapid assay development and commercialization Rapid assay development and manufacturing From Feasibility and Prototyping to full Development and Manufacturing Transfer Education and training courses in rapid assay technology Learn how to develop and manufacture rapid tests Custom conjugation services protein – particle, protein-protein, small molecule etc Products Materials starter kits Gold conjugation kits Latex conjugation kits Colloidal gold All related lateral flow materials Lateral flow reader systems: Fluorescent and visual
  • 6.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • Fully equipped for the manufacture of lateral flow, flow through, and other rapid assay formats • 8000 square feet, containing 3000 square feet of wet lab, housed in a class 10,000 capable cleanroom, and an associated controlled humidity room • ISO 9001:2008 compliant, with EN 13485 by end 2010 • Development staff of 14 industrially experienced assay development scientists Facility and Personnel Reagent Prep Area Main Lab (Class 10,000 capable cleanroom) Component Processing Area (Temperature / Humidity Controlled)
  • 7.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Our Markets Medical Diagnostics Veterinary Diagnostics Agricultural / Environmental Food Testing OTC/Consumer Pharmaceutical Biowarfare Law enforcement / Forensics Microbiology Nucleic Acid Testing Industrial Health and Safety Our market is international and spread over multiple application areas. Approximately 40% of our assay development programs are US- based, 40% are European and 20% are spread among Asia and Latin America
  • 8.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Representative Clients • Johnson and Johnson (UK) • Novozymes (Denmark) • Amic (Sweden) • ICP Bio (Australia) • Rockeby (Australia) • Government of Thailand NIH (Thailand • Pacific Biotech (Thailand) • Span Diagnostics (India) • Daiichi Fine Chemical (Japan) • Elixir Biosciences (China) • MARS/Masterfoods (UK) • Laboratorio Silanes (Mexico) • Mintek (South Africa) • Biosensia (Ireland) • BioRad (US/EU) • Chiron Corporation (US) • Amgen (US) • Abbott (US) • Genzyme Diagnostics (US) • Becton Dickinson (US) • Church and Dwight (US) • 3M (US) • Whatman /GE (US / Europe) • Aspen BioPharma (US) • Genetic Testing Institute (GTI) (US) • Cibavision (US) • CDC (US) • NIH (US)
  • 9.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Simple Devices for Rapid Testing Standard Lateral Flow Strip Sample addition Conjugate solubilization Capillary flow; antibody binding Membrane clearing; optical reading Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4
  • 10.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Sample addition Optional wash Conjugate addition; antibody binding Final wash; membrane clearing; optical reading Simple Devices for Rapid Testing Standard Flow – through device
  • 11.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Evolution in Point of Care Assays Drivers for Innovation and Market Growth • Early POC devices were designed for qualitative applications • Earliest applications in the 1980s were pregnancy tests, growing in the 1990’s to include drugs of abuse and infectious disease tests • Market has grown steadily at a minimum CAGR of 10% since the late 1990’s • Market demand for tests in non-traditional areas has expanded to include quantitative, high sensitivity applications using difficult matrices, driving development • Intellectual property issues have driven technological innovation strongly in the past decade
  • 12.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Innovative Applications
  • 13.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Why lateral flow assays dominate the (non glucose) POC market • Ease of use: Minimal operator dependent steps and interpretation • Can handle small volumes of multiple sample types • Can have high sensitivity, specificity, good stability • Good Manufacturability and Scalability • Minimal market and user education required • Market presence and acceptance • Short development cycle – once reagents are developed, the timeline to manufacturing transfer and approval is short relative to other biotech products
  • 14.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • Sensitivity • Control of user interpretation • Reproducibility (CV)/ Quantification • Multiplexing is difficult Typical performance challenges in standard rapid assays
  • 15.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Application Requirements are Driving the Technology Forward •The requirements that the major rapid test markets are demanding include: • Speed to result: 2-10 minutes • Sensitivity: high picogram/ml to low nanogram/ml • Ability to handle difficult sample matrices • Quantification • Multiplexing • Removal of interpretation issues • Control of data
  • 16.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Evolution in Rapid Test Technology: An Exercise in Market Driven Innovation Development in rapid diagnostic testing incorporates elements of use inspired basic research (application development) and pure applied research (technology development) Clients provide use inspired basic research DCN and partners provide the applied element Pasteur's Quadrant describes scientific research that both seeks fundamental understanding of scientific problems, and, at the same time, seeks to be eventually useful.
  • 17.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • Product Requirements Development • Concept Refinement • Feasibility and prototyping of all system elements • Product development and system integration • Transfer to manufacturing • Commercialization Bridging the Concept Gap DCN
  • 18.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Medical Diagnostics 89 Veterinary 9 Food and Beverage 1 Pharmceuticals 0.6 Envionmental 0.2 Water 0.2 Percent of Market by Application Total Market 2007: USD $2.3 billion Total Market 2012: USD $$3.7 billion Medical Diagnostics Veterinary Food and Beverage Pharmceuticals Envionmental Water High Performance Allows for New Applications Rapid Test Market Penetration and Opportunities
  • 19.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Major Rapid Test Market Opportunities 1. Medical Diagnostics 35% 20% 21% 13% 7% 4% % market 2007 Pregnancy Infectious diseases Cardiac markers Cholesterol/lipds Drugs of abuse Other 24% 27% 26% 15% 5% 3% predicted market 2012 Pregnancy Infectious diseases Cardiac markers Cholesterol/lipds Drugs of abuse Other •Growth opportunities exist in all medical segments •Growth will be driven by reimbursement in US and EU markets •Requires performance improvements in quantification, sensitivity, reproducibility and multiplexing
  • 20.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Major Rapid Test Market Opportunities 2. Veterinary Diagnostics • Market was $205 million (USD) in 2007 • 9% CAGR to 2012 predicts a $310 million market by 2012 • Highly fragmented, price sensitive market, split among small animals and livestock • Major segments are infectious disease testing, metabolic testing (cancer), diabetes and fertility/pregnancy •Small animal tests tend to be paid for by owners and are non- regulated for the most part. Large animal testing tends to be government mandated and is regulated •Growth driven by acceptance in large animal testing for infectious disease and fertility, and control of antibiotic use and in small animals by cancer and infectious disease testing •Requires performance improvements in quantification, sensitivity, reproducibility and multiplexing
  • 21.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Major Rapid Test Market Opportunities 3. Food and beverage testing • Worldwide market of about $30 million in 2007 •Expected CAGR of 15% predicts $60 million by 2012 •Market is under-penetrated by rapid tests due to the preponderance of microbiological testing (slow, traditional technology largely used) •Combinations of molecular and immunological testing may be important to this market •Growth will be driven by increased awareness of rapid formats coupled with sampling and performance improvements that can generate appropriate sensitivity •Requires performance improvements in quantification, sensitivity, reproducibility and multiplexing
  • 22.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Major Rapid Test Market Opportunities 4. Water Testing and Environmental Remediation • Worldwide market of about $5 million in 2007. • Expected CAGR of 4% predicts $6 million by 2012. • Highly regulated markets, with local or governmental agencies setting requirements for testing, often in association with AOAC (Association of Official Analytical Chemists International) • Most testing is performed in certified laboratories by approved methods • Rapid tests are typically performed as spot checks between mandated test periods • Also used for household and industrial testing of water quality in certain markets • Growth will be driven by increased awareness of rapid formats coupled with performance improvements •Requires performance improvements in quantification, sensitivity, reproducibility and multiplexing
  • 23.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • Option 1: Develop completely new platform technologies based on microfluidics and alternative detection technologies e.g. lab on a chip, • Option 2: Improve the existing technology platform Market – Driven Innovation Making test performance meet market demands
  • 24.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays A System Approach • Rapid lateral flow and flow through assays can meet many of the market’s requirements, but a different approach to the assay is needed • High performing rapid assays need to be approached in the same way as high performance laboratory based systems • Key system elements: 1) A properly developed assay made using 1) High quality materials 2) High quality reagents 3) Highly sensitive label for sensitive analyte detection 2) A well designed sample device and housing for the test 3) A controlled method for result interpretation 4) A well designed and controlled manufacturing process
  • 25.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays 1. Assay Materials • Analytical procedures usually require multiple steps • Fluidics minimize number of steps in a test and increase ease of use • In most POC devices these steps are performed using treated porous matrices • Fluid flow in POC devices usually relies on capillary flow • Fluidic elements are usually designed to be disposable, and are therefore made from low cost materials • Suppliers must be of the highest quality. Lowest cost materials will not support higher specified applications Test Line Control Line Particle Conjugate on conjugate pad Wick Sample Pad Nitrocellulose Membrane Backing
  • 26.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays 1. Assay Reagents • Recognition is generally Ab-Ag or Ab-Ab based • Different characteristics are required for high performance in a lateral flow system than in an ELISA, for instance, due to the mechanics of the system: – The method chosen for screening is important • Important Parameters: – Specificity – Dissociation Constant (Kd) – High Affinity (High Binding Rate Constant (kon)) – Antibody Class (subtype: IgG1, IgG2A, IgG3, etc.) – Monoclonals typically preferred, but high purity polyclonals can also be used effectively 77
  • 27.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays 1. Assay Labels • Colloidal gold – Typically 20-40nm – Low cost, difficult to control passive conjugations, one color, relatively sensitive. Most common in qualitative applications • Latex: Colored, Fluorescent, Paramagnetic – Typically 100-300nm – Low cost, covalent conjugations, variety of chemistries, well controlled, stable, variety of particles and labels. Most common for high sensitivity, quantitative applications (fluorescent, paramagnetic) • Others – Upconverting phosphors – Colloidal carbon – Direct labeling using fluorophores and enhancers
  • 28.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Commonly used fluorescent labels in POC Applications • We love fluorescence for high end applications! • DCN’s Experience: – Dark Red Labels (660-680nm) give good results due to lack of background fluorescence in biological fluids in that spectral area – Europium: Highly sensitive and commonly used due to broad Stokes’ shift and stability (300 – 625nm) – Direct labeling of antibodies using fluorescent dyes is also an option – sensitivity an issue – requires customization of system components.
  • 29.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays 2. Readers The use of readers in lateral flow assay systems Detection of the signal generated by the reagents, translation into a numerical or alphanumerical output, and delivery of that output Use of readers allows for: • Improved sensitivity • Reduction in user interpretation issues • Data capture, analysis and storage • Connectivity • Quantification • New applications Negative Positive 100% Visually Negative 100% Visually Positive Operator Dependent Negative or Positive Critical features: • Hardware • Algorithms for data processing, • Signal to noise reduction, • Measurement and data distribution • Calibration methods
  • 30.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Reader Supply Partners • Off-the-shelf readers are available that can be readily modified for any development program • DCN represents two suppliers: LRE and Qiagen Lake Constance (formerly ESE) – Provide a base platform from which to start – Have a history of development of this type of product – Have experience of regulatory and technical requirements – Can advise on important technical design considerations – May be faster to market – Generally have dedicated manufacturing capability • Readers can be custom designed by experienced designer such as Source Scientific, Polygenesis, Omnica (all DCN partners) – Slower and more expensive route in return for a custom solution
  • 31.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • Sensitive • Affordable • Simple to operate • Small, Mobile and Robust • Documented Results • Objective Results • Quantitative Results ESE Quant DCN’s Reader Partners: Handheld and Benchtop Readers DCN distributes both ESE and LRE readers DCN acts as the assay integration partner for both suppliers for customers worldwide LRE POC Reader 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 Data points Intensity [mV] Scan1 Scan2 Scan3 Scan4 Scan5 Scan6 Scan7 Scan8 Scan9 Scan10 Scan11 Scan12 Scan13 Scan14 Scan15 Scan16 Scan17 Scan18 Scan19 Scan20 Control Test
  • 32.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Comparison of gold and fluorescent labels LF Tuberculosis Fluorescent Assay • Based on a dark red dye (latex particle based) • Monoclonal sandwich assay • Compared directly to a colloidal gold method • Results read digitally using the ESE-Quant reader Dark Red Dye (Latex) ex 660 em 680 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 500 550 600 650 700 750 Wavelength (nm) Rel. Intensity Excitation Emission
  • 33.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays LF Tuberculosis Fluorescent Assay Gold vs. Fluorescent Latex 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 0 0.1 0.5 0.75 1 1.25 5 Peak Height (pixel units) Peak Height (mV) Concentration (ng/ml) Sensitivity in TB Protein Assay: Gold vs Dark Red FlourescentLatex FlourescentLatex Gold • Sensitivity greater than 0.2 ng/mL. • Using same antibody / antigen combination, the assay developed using a Dark Red fluorescent particle is >10 fold more sensitive than the assay developed using gold.
  • 34.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Anthrax Protective Antigen Assay • Assay for a recombinant Anthrax protein • Quantitative & qualitative results
  • 35.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays 0.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 11.00 1 10 100 1000 10000 Signal / Noise Ratio Ng/mL rPA Gold vs. Latex Comparison - Lateral Flow Anthrax Protective Antigen Assay Gold Fluorescent Anthrax Protective Antigen Results • Fluorescent assay sensitive to 2 ng/mL. Approximately 60- fold better sensitivity than comparable gold assay • Visual or reader based results
  • 36.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays 3. Device Design The importance of device design in test performance • Cassette design plays an integral role in the performance of the assay • Early integration of cassettes with sample delivery elements and with strips is a critical element of the design process • If a reader is to be used, design device with this in mind – off the shelf cassettes will rarely work • Novelty in approach can lead to major benefits e.g. separation of sample handling and conjugate mixing from the remainder of the device can significantly improve CV’s
  • 37.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays The SymbioSysTm Program • Rapid diagnostics have historically had less emphasis on engineering than other industries. (ie. Medical Device) • Typical approach: Develop the strip, then find or try to design a cassette that works with it – highly inefficient and counter-productive. • With current demands for ease of use, precision, quantification, low cost of goods and reduced time to market, this method is no longer acceptable. • Concurrent engineering, assay development and user needs development is required to achieve this level of performance. • DCN and Symbient developed the SymbioSys program to address this demand.
  • 38.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays DCN’s Design Partner: Symbient Product Development • Established in 2004. • Focus on development of single use diagnostic devices. • Product Types: – Lateral Flow Cartridges – Fluidic Cartridges with Integrated Functions – Sample Delivery Systems - pipettes, lancet devices, urine cups. – Instrument Driven Systems
  • 39.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays CONFIDENTIAL Services Provided • Mechanical Product Design • Industrial Design • 3D Solid Modeling (Solidworks) • Program Management • Precision Prototype Machining • Rapid Prototype Tooling and Molding • LIM Silicone Molding • Product Testing and Test Method Development. • Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) • Process Development • Manufacturing Transition
  • 40.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Sample Handling Device and Cartridge Design • DCN and Symbient have designed and developed several devices for collecting and processing samples for diagnostic testing. • Sample types include saliva, whole blood, fecal matter, urine, mucous and surfaces. • Methods include integrated buffers, mixing, filtering and metering. • DCN and Symbient have developed various diagnostic cartridges including single test strip, multiple test strip and specialty housings.
  • 41.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Device Optical Reader Example: Sample handling in a quantitative agricultural test • Vertical flow assay • Rapid and quantifiable • Increased sensitivity with integrated pre-incubation • Particulate samples do not cause flow problems 1. PRE-INCUBATION 2. FLOW THROUGH 3. RESULT
  • 42.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Alpha Amylase Detection in Wheat 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 srw170 srw138 srw139 cbh2.7 cbh2.8 Falling Number Wheat Sample Comparisonof Values from Device andTrue Falling NumberValues True FN DiagnostIQ AvgFN DiagnostIQ Avg [Amylase] Hagberg Falling Numbers are determined by dropping a ball through a tube of ground wheat. The time it takes in seconds for it to reach the bottom correlates inversely to the amount of alpha-amylase in the wheat. High falling numbers indicate low concentrations of alpha-amylase, and low falling numbers indicate a high concentration of alpha-amylase. Falling Number True FN avg amyl conc. St Dev %CV 304 1.54 6.4 1.77% 244 21.82 3.56 1.27% 223 36.02 16.8 4 6.77% 142 144.05 6.57 4.77%
  • 43.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Intellectual Property – Driven Innovation Rapiplex: A Novel Multiplex Rapid Assay Platform • RapiPlex: An integrated Point-of-Care in vitro diagnostic platform; • Unique intellectual property position • Multiplex, Quantitative and/or Qualitative, Versatile, Portable • Three integrating technologies to provide a robust platform • Fluidics • Immunodiagnostic assay systems • Integrated fluorescent reade
  • 44.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays + Fluidic Chip • Proprietary fluidic strip & chip not constrained by lateral flow IP • Disposable oriented in the vertical position when an assay is run • No overlapping capillary materials – gaps between materials • Enables simultaneous multiplex analysis from a single sample • Defined individual channels in which sample flow can be controlled • Individual channel entry ports for each channel • Flow control zone ensures accurate and controlled flow in each channel • Injection molded – High Impact Polystyrene • Suitable for all assay formats and multiple biological fluid sample types – demonstrated on saliva, serum and whole blood to date
  • 45.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays 0 100,000 200,000 300,000 400,000 500,000 600,000 700,000 800,000 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 Avg. Peak Height (RFU) Myoglobin Conc. (ng/ml) Biosensia Myoglobin Error Bars – 95% Confidence Myoglobin assay Representative DCN Data
  • 46.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays 0 50,000 100,000 150,000 200,000 250,000 300,000 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 Avg. Peak Height (RFU) Myoglobin Conc. (ng/ml) Biosensia Myoglobin – Low End Error Bars – 95% Confidence Myoglobin assay Representative DCN Data
  • 47.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Myoglobin Conc. (ng/ml) 95% Confidence Limits 5 16,661 10,504 10 37,698 22,495 25 82,432 41,144 50 145,149 106,220 100 295,043 183,477 350 764,314 483,319 Myoglobin Assay Current DCN Sensitivity Data
  • 48.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Myoglobin Dilution Series (N=12) R² = 0.9985 R² = 1 0 100,000 200,000 300,000 400,000 500,000 600,000 700,000 800,000 900,000 10 100 1000 10000 Avg. Peak Height (RFU) log Myoglobin Conc. (ng/ml) Biosensia Myoglobin Before After Poly. (Before) Poly. (After)
  • 49.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Summary • Solved major mechanical design issues • Assay CV’s controlled • Good Slope of Dose Response • Clinically relevant sensitivity (~5 ng/ml)
  • 50.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Manufacturing Process Design Membrane Conjugate Pad Dispense test and control lines Block membrane if necessary Pre-treat pad Dispense / dip conjugate Sample Pad Pre-treat pad Assemble membrane, conjugate pad, sample pad, wick and backing into cards Cut cards into strips Assemble strips into cassettes Package cassettes Dry Dry Dry Dry Dry
  • 51.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Process Control Batch Vs Continuous Processes XYZ 3050 dispenser with BioJets and AirJets Clamshell benchtop laminator Manual Dip Tray CM 4000 Guillotine Cutter Dispensing Dipping Lamination Cutting Drying Forced Air Oven
  • 52.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Reel-to-reel web handling and dispensing platform Equipment and Processes Batch Vs Continuous Dispensing, Dipping, Drying Lamination, Cutting
  • 53.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays In-line processing provides for greater process control and equivalent processing 10 15 20 25 1 64 127 190 253 316 379 442 505 568 631 694 757 820 883 946 1009 1072 1135 1198 1261 1324 Pixels Mean Pixel Width Std Dev %CV 17.57 0.89 5.1 In line camera and bad part marking system on a BioDot RTR 4500 inline dispensing system Output from a quality control camera system on a RTR 4500. Dispensing run over a 50m dispense length, 50mm/s, human IgG at 1mg/ml, 0.8ul/cm on nitrocellulose Equipment and Processes Batch Vs Continuous
  • 54.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays All the elements of an integrated device are available over the counter • High quality test development • Reader development • Device development • Manufacturing equipment • A partnering approach is generally required to bring the specialized expertise and components into the assay
  • 55.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays DCN’s Network Partners DCN’s Network of Affiliates is a group of closely knit companies that work together to provide all of the key elements necessary to design, develop manufacture and commercialize point of care diagnostic systems. Member companies include: • Manufacturing equipment suppliers • Cassette and device designers • High volume molding companies • Materials converters • Reader developers and manufacturers • Contract manufacturers • Platform technology suppliers
  • 56.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays A reader based semi quantitative serological assay: Rapid Assay for anti-PF4:Heparin in human plasma (HIT) • Fluorescent, reader based, integrated RFID tag and novel cassette • ESEQuant fluorescent reader from Qiagen Lake Constance • Threshold assay, with Positive/Negative reporting • Predicate ELISA in market. Rapid assay must be as sensitive. • No known standards • Intended for the professional clinical laboratory market • Will be labeled as an IVD :developed under full design controls • Assay and device developed for large scale manufacturing
  • 57.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Major Challenges • Highly charged specific molecule • Total immunoglobulin assay imparts formatting requirement – sample and conjugate cannot mix prior to interaction with test line • High sensitivity needed • Lack of standards, so establishment of cutoff requires comparison to performance of predicate ELISA = Requirement for high correlation to ELISA result. • Requirement for tight CVs • Integration of novel device design elements for IP generation • Predicate rapid assays in the field require multiple additions, timing steps and have poor user interface. The aim of the program is to generate a device without these attributes
  • 58.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Comparative results of lateral flow and ELISA data on all clinical samples 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 Test Line Peak Height (RFU) ELISA OD OD vs Test Line Peak Height (All Data) OD vs TL • A panel of 83 samples, characterized by predicate ELISA • All samples came from patients who had received heparin • Testing in triplicate / quadruplicate if adequate volume • Average values shown.
  • 59.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Cutoff: Comparative 0.000 0.100 0.200 0.300 0.400 0.500 0.600 0.700 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 TL/CL ELISA OD OD vs TL/CL (OD <1.0) OD vs TL/CL 0.3 od Cutoff
  • 60.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays True Positive = Samples with OD > cutoff and detected as positive False negative= Samples with OD > cutoff and detected as negative True Negative= Samples with OD < cutoff and detected as negative False Positive= Samples with OD < cutoff and detected as positive OD = 0.3 ELISA TL/CL TL True positives 41 39 37 False Negative 0 2 4 True Negatives 42 42 42 False Positive 0 0 0 n 83 83 83 PPV 100.00 100.00 100.00 NPV 100.00 95.45 91.30 Sensitivity 100.00 95.12 90.24 Specificity 100.00 100.00 100.00 Collated Testing Results: ELISA vs LFIA using various cutoffs
  • 61.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays R² = 0.9989 -500 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 Peak Height (rfu) ELISA OD Peak Test Line Height Relative to ELISA OD, n=5 5-14 serum TL Ht Poly. (5-14 serum TL Ht) Dilution Series: High positive Diluted in Negative R² = 0.9975 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 TL/CL Ratio ELISA OD TL/CL Ratio Relative to ELISA OD, n=5 TL/CL ratio Poly. (TL/CL ratio)
  • 62.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Integrated System Development Using the DCN Network to develop complete assay systems • Project Management • System requirement definition • Product specification • Cassette design • Rapid prototyping • Mold design and development • Mechanical engineering design • Reader development • GUI design • Reagent Development • Assay design and development • Calibration system development • Documentation • Manufacturing process design • Regulatory consulting • Quality system management • FMEA / Risk analysis • High volume plastic molding • Manufacturing equipment supply • Manufacturing facility setup • Scale-up and manufacturing transfer • Reagent manufacture • Gap manufacturing Program Setup and Management System Development Commercialization • Market research • Board level advice • Networking to finance • Branding • Troubleshooting • Patent Landscaping Manufacturing Transfer The client provides the innovation in reagents and application area DCN provides the rest
  • 63.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Key Points 1. Opportunities are available in numerous market segments for rapid assays with the right level of performance 2. Assays can be developed to handle almost any reasonable market condition, based on existing technology – Simple, low cost lateral flow assays for simple, qualitative low resolution applications – More complex, more expensive lateral flow systems for high sensitivity, more quantitative, difficult applications – These two types of assay are very different in how they are developed and manufactured – Other approaches to high performance rapid testing are possible, but with a much longer outlook. 3. All of the elements needed to develop and manufacture high performance tests are available today
  • 64.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Acknowledgements • DCN – Roy Chung – Jerrold Loo – Wendy Mendiola – Michael Fiechtner • Symbient Product Development – John Zeis – Scott Castenon • Shara Rosen for marketing information • Thanks to GTI and Biosensia for use of data • Thanks to Cynthia Rocha, Camila Resende Duarte, Gislaine Silva, Regina Fernandes from SECTES and Christiane Contigli from CETEC and all who helped to coordinate my attendance at INOVATEC
  • 65.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays www.dcndx.com Contact : Brendan O’Farrell at bofarrell@dcndx.com Diagnostic Consulting Network Inc 6354 Corte del Abeto, Suite B-C Carlsbad, CA 92011 Tel: 760-804-3886 Fax: 760-804-3866 Contact Information Please email to receive copies of the slides
  • 66.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • Quickly develop and commercialize rapid assays for any application • Experienced with fluorescent, visual (colloidal gold / latex) and paramagnetic labels – From concept to commercialized assay in under 12 months – ELISA conversion to rapid assay formats in short timeframes – Reagent sourcing and development – Rapid prototyping – Feasibility studies – Complete development – Manufacturing transfer We can develop assays for you: Assay Development Services
  • 67.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • The plastic devices used in these assays can determine their ability to perform in demanding applications and need to be custom developed in virtually any high performance application • DCN partners with product designers, such as Symbient Product Development and molding companies such as HK Plastics to integrate new cassettes and novel device designs into programs for clients • Partners can be contracted through DCN, and DCN will manage the entire development program on behalf of the client We can design and develop your plastic devices: Cartridge and Device Design Service
  • 68.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • DCN partners with the major suppliers of readers to the point of care marketplace to provide reader solutions for our customers. • We can provide readers for: – Visual labels – Fluorescent labels – Paramagnetic labels • Our primary partners for off the shelf and custom reader supply are QLC (formerly ESE) and LRE (Esterline), and we distribute for both companies in the US. • We also work with custom reader design and development houses including Source Scientific and Polygenesis. We can help you develop reader systems for your assays Reader Development and Integration
  • 69.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • DCN can develop and commercialize all aspects of a point of care diagnostics platform, through our in- house capabilities and our Network of Affiliates • Custom design and integration for high performance assays our specialty We can design and develop your complete assay system Integrated System Design and Development Cartridge top housing Desiccant RF id tag Cartridge bottom housing Strip and Assay
  • 70.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays We can connect you to all of the best suppliers: The Network of Affiliates DCN’s Network of Affiliates is a group of closely knit companies that work together to provide all of the key elements necessary to design, develop manufacture and commercialize point of care diagnostic systems. Member companies include: • Manufacturing equipment suppliers • Cassette and device designers • High volume molding companies • Materials converters • Reader developers and manufacturers • Contract manufacturers • Platform technology suppliers
  • 71.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • Learn how to develop and manufacture lateral flow assays • Customized one-on-one courses held at DCN’s core facility in Carlsbad, California • Scheduled on demand • Duration 3 – 5 days • Theoretical and practical elements dealt with • Bring your reagents and optimize an assay during the course We can teach you to develop and make your own assays Education and Training Services
  • 72.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays We can help with any aspect of commercialization Consulting Services DCN has over 20 consultants on staff that can provide a wide range of services related to the point of need diagnostics or detection business: • Regulatory Affairs • Project management • Risk assessment • Intellectual property landscaping • Manufacturing process development • Assay troubleshooting • Quality system establishment for diagnostic companies • Device design • Facility setup • Equipment specification and procurement • Market evaluation • Technology evaluation
  • 73.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • DCN’s facility is completely equipped for manufacture of lateral flow, flow through, and other format point of need assays • The facility: – 8000 square feet, containing 3000 square feet of wet lab, housed in a class 10,000 capable cleanroom, and an associated controlled humidity room – Currently ISO 9001:2008 compliant and will complete EN 13485 by end Q4 2010 • Manufacture non-FDA regulated product for several clients in the US and Europe, and components and reagents for clients in the US and outside • DCN partners with several dedicated contract manufacturers to whom it can transfer product for manufacturing. We can manufacture your tests for you Contract Manufacturing Reagent Prep Area Main Lab (Class 10,000 capable cleanroom) Component Processing Area (Temperature / Humidity Controlled)
  • 74.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • DCN provides everything needed to develop or manufacture lateral flow or flow through assays – Colloidal gold, colored and fluorescent latex beads and conjugates – Assay materials: membranes, pads, backing, cassettes wicks, etc – Antibodies and antigens – Small molecule conjugates – Test strip readers: Handheld and benchtop • Kits of materials and reagents – Colloidal gold – Material Starter Kit – Colloidal gold conjugation kit – Latex conjugation kit – Gold conjugation kit We can supply you with key components Materials, Reagents and Kits
  • 75.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays We can make the critical reagents for you Custom Conjugate Development and Manufacture • Expertise in covalent conjugations – Protein / peptide /small molecule –Particle • Colored, fluorescent or paramagnetic latex, gold, quantum dots, etc. – Protein – Protein • Full optimization process • Full QC including binding assays where reagents are available • For diagnostics or separations (magnetic latex) • Small to full prep scale Streptavidin Bead #2 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 0 5 10 15 20 25 ng Biotin OD Strep #2 (1X) Strep #2 (10X) Strep #2 (20X) Merck Strep REC/1.0um Candidat 2 Merck Strep C-REC/ 1.0um Candidat 4 Merck Strep TREC/1.0um Candidat 4 Merck Strep 0.2umCandidat 1
  • 76.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • Dr Roy Chung: Over 25 years of assay development and manufacturing experience. Previously Lead Scientist at Nanogen • Dr Hans Boehringer: Over 20 years of assay development and manufacturing experience. Most recently Scientific Director at Genzyme Diagnostics • Dr Brendan O’Farrell: 20 years of assay development, manufacturing, equipment and manufacturing process development. Previously VP of Technology Development at BioDot Inc and Director of R&D and Manufacturing at SDS Inc. • Michael Surmanian: 20 years of biotech technology development experience. Formerly President of BioDot Inc. • Assay Development Team of 10 scientists, all of whom worked for major human and veterinary diagnostic companies. Minimum of 5 years of experience Consulting Group.: Over 25 industry experts available. Examples: • Dr Judith Howard: Ex VP of Quality, Regulatory at Inverness Medical Innovations • Dr David Boudreau: Ex Director of Operations, Nanogen Inc • Michael Weinholt: President of Regulatory Consulting Inc Our People
  • 77.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Our Strengths • Expertise in reagent development, assay development, device design and reader integration • Experience in all aspects of system development, regulation, commercialization and manufacturing • Modular menu of services, allowing for flexible project execution – select only the services you need • Parallel development strategies for device and assay development – science and engineering combined • Networked to all of the partners you will need to get to market • Full design controls and documentation. • Full support for registration activities • Speed to commercialization
  • 78.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays 1) Assay • Materials for fluid movement and reaction matrices • Biological recognition reagents (antibodies/antigens) • Signal generation reagents (labels) 2) Reader system • Technology • Supplier 3) Device • Sample collection and processing • Conjugate handling and mixing • Cassettes 4) Manufacturing process design Challenges in Designing and Manufacturing High Performance POC Assays
  • 79.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Market Penetration by Application 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 Medical Diagnostics Veterinary Food and Beverage Pharmceuticals Envionmental Water % of Available Market, 2007 (compared to lab based immunoassays that have a rapid segment)
  • 80.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 Percentage of Available Market by Geographical Region US EU ROW Market Penetration by Geographical Region
  • 81.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays • Sensitivity: • Fluorescence based tests can be more sensitive than colorimetric • Higher sensitivity allows new applications and markets • Control • Fluorescent assays are based on latex particles which can be coupled covalently. Colloidal gold conjugation is passive. • This allows for better control of the conjugates and improved CV‘s • Availability • High quality, high performance beads available • Multiple sizes, chemistries • Availability of off-the shelf readers • Makes development easy and low cost • Makes fluorescence a comparatively open system Why we like fluorescent labels for reader based applications
  • 82.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Device Design Trends and Implications • IP considerations have driven a trend towards novel device design: – clear pathways to designing non-infringing devices exist • For many applications, sample handling, sample preparation, extraction and delivery to devices need to be performed – E.g. Tests for agriculture, biowarfare, food pathogen testing, environmental testing involve handling difficult samples, treating them and delivering them to devices in difficult field conditions. – Devices can be designed and integrated to cassettes to perform these functions
  • 83.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Myoglobin Conc. (ng/ml) n Avg Peak Height CV 0 15 0 na 5 15 13,583 11.3% 10 15 30,097 12.6% 25 15 61,788 16.7% 50 15 125,685 7.7% 100 15 239,260 11.7% 350 15 623,817 11.3% Myoglobin assay data Representative DCN Data
  • 84.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Prototyping Capabilities CNC Machining Prototype Mold Fabrication Injection Molding Steriolithography (SLA)
  • 85.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Assembly and Testing
  • 86.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Myo Conc. (ng/ml) N Avg. TL pk ht TL %CV 25 12 64,948 11.0% 50 12 118,659 5.9% 100 12 229,002 10.4% 250 12 457,563 4.1% 500 12 749,168 6.9% Myoglobin Dilution Series (N=12)
  • 87.
    Complete, creative solutionsfor developers and manufacturers of rapid assays Overall Conclusion • Doing so requires careful design of all aspects of the product and the integration of high quality fluorescent label, cassette and reader technologies • The design and development of products of this nature is a highly specialized task • That is where a company like DCN, with specialist knowledge and experience, comes into the picture • How can we help you?........

Editor's Notes

  • #10 Shown here are drawings of these simple devices. Both are based on the binding of the test substance (the analyte) by antibodies immobilized on a porous membrane. In a flow-through immunoassay, the role of the membrane is primarily to concentrate the reactants. This immunoconcentration brings reactants into the matrix of the membrane, where the diffusional distances are short enough so that the kinetics of binding closely approach the kinetics of binding in a solution. To get a high capacity for immobilizing the immunoreactants, the membrane should have a large surface area and therefore a small-pore size structure. As a consequence, the sensitivity may be higher than that of large pore membranes. While flow-through immunoassays are generally believed to be less sensitive than lateral flow immunoassays, this difference can be offset by the fact that much larger volumes of sample can be be applied to a flow-through device.
  • #11 In a flow-through immunoassay the sample is applied to the surface of a membrane containing immobilized antibodies. These can be in an area defined as a simple spot, or a more elaborate design, such as a plus sign. The sample flows through the membrane. Liquid is absorbed by a porous pad in contact with the opposite side of the membrane. If desired, an intermediate wash step can be employed. After the sample is added a detector is added. In the simplest embodiment, this detector is a solution of visible particles which are conjugated to antibodies to the test substance. These detectors bind to any analyte previously captured on the membrane by the immobilized antibodies and are observed visually. A final wash to remove background may or may not be necessary, depending on the specific nature and design of the test.
  • #27 Overall assay performance is affected by a number of variables including antibody quality. This includes such obvious parameters as antigen specificity and affinity (as defined by the dissociation constant). However, more important may be things like the binding rate constant, which is typically not measured during antibody screening and selection, and antibody classes. Some subtypes are easier to conjugate or fragment, and can pose special challenges with respect to purification, solubility and long-term storage. IgG3 for example, is not bound very well by Protein A, and tends to precipitate during freezing. Of course the quality of the membrane materials and assembly are critical, as is the often overlooked contribution of the plastic housing to assay performance. Oh, and did I mention antibody quality?
  • #46 Comparison of assay results before and after CVs have been reduced and the dynamic range increased
  • #47 Comparison of results at lower concentrations
  • #48 Sensitivity after DCN/SPD improvements. Sensitivity has been lowered to 5 ng/ml from 1000 ng/ml through a combination of improved reproducibility and increased dynamic range. Efforts continue to reduce CVs in the 5-10% range
  • #58 Customer wanted to convert ELISA to detect Human Immunoglobulins into a fluorescent based lateral flow. Objective was to produce a lateral flow assay that was equal or better than their ELISA. (CAN WE MENTION GTI)? After several months of development feasibility testing was conducted with 84 characterized serums. Negative samples may actually contain immunoglobulins but are below the detectable limit of the ELISA.
  • #59 Scatter plot of Test Line Peak Height against ELISA OD of all data
  • #84 DCN in conjunction with Symbient implemented multiple changes to the device and reagents. CVs in the clinically relevant range have been reduced by 50%