The document discusses critical thinking and provides guidelines for evaluating when critical thinking is occurring. It defines critical thinking as relying on reason over emotion, requiring evidence, and following evidence to its conclusion. The document outlines several aspects of critical thinking: being rational, self-aware of biases, honest about motives, open-minded to alternatives, disciplined in one's thinking, and able to properly judge evidence and perspectives. It emphasizes that critical thinking involves avoiding snap judgments and remaining precise while considering multiple viewpoints.