Content Feedback Methods DocTrain East October 31, 2008 Mirhonda Studevant & Jennifer Shankle
Overview “ Information breeds confidence. Silence breeds fear.”  -The West Wing Importance Challenges  Methods Process Costs
Content is… Both information and communication… Discourse as comprehended or received by its intended audience. The glue that makes a website “sticky” – makes visitors return and keeps them from leaving. -BusinessDictionary.com
Let’s Play The Feud! 37 documentation professionals surveyed. Top four answers are on the board…
Customer Feedback is Important RoperASW reports word of mouth as the best source of product information. It  exploded from 67% in 1977 to 93% in 2001. BizRate found that 59% of their users considered customer reviews more valuable than expert reviews.
Customer Feedback is Important Journal of Database Marketing & Customer Strategy article (June 2008) showed that companies who adopted customer feedback program (CFP) business practices, had 17% higher customer loyalty percentage rankings.
Customer Feedback is Important Quality and Voice of the Customer Customer Satisfaction and Retention Product Development Application within Documentation
Challenges to Obtaining Feedback Writer/Requestor Perceptions Time/Resources Ineffective Methods Reader/Respondent Perceptions Time Complexity Effects
The Continuum High High Medium User Forums/Groups (virtual)  11 High Low Low Listing an email address for users to forward comments  10 High Medium Low Feedback Link directly within online documentation (single question)  9 High Medium Medium Online Surveys (multiple questions)  8 High High High Formal usability studies  7 Low High Medium Informal usability studies  6 Low Low Low Impromptu customer comments  5 Low High High User Forums/Groups (face-to-face)  4 Low Low Low Listing a telephone number for users to forward comments  3 Low Medium Low Rating question directly within documentation (single question)  2 Low Medium Medium Paper-based Surveys (multiple questions)  1 Tech Level Complexity Cost Method #
The Continuum
Your Place on The Continuum Leverage  existing  resources Justify future investments Maximize automation Promote results
Content Feedback Case Studies Ceridian Low-tech High-tech Combination Other Industries Low-tech High-tech Combination From the Audience?
Content Feedback Process Determining Your Approach SWOT analysis Understanding your audience Establishing goals Identifying constraints
Content Feedback Process Developing Your Mechanism Assigning roles Developing questions Capturing data Compiling results
Content Feedback Process Analyzing Your Data Identifying trends Recommending improvements Promoting findings Evaluating process/mechanism effectiveness
Keys to Content Feedback Acknowledgement Awareness Alertness Budget Time Promotion Accountability
Content Feedback Exercise Group recommendations for: Scenario 1: “Outnumbered, Outgunned” Scenario 2: “Lone Writer” Scenario 3: “New Era” Scenario 4: “The Intern”
Closing Thoughts “What lies behind us and what lies before us are tiny matters compared to what lies within us”  –Ralph Waldo Emerson
Resources Survey Design www.surveymonkey.com www.raosoft.com www.polldaddy.com www.questionpro.com www.surveygizmo.com Customer Relationship Management www.customerthink.com www.bryanfoss.com Usability and Documentation Testing www.techsmith.com/morae.asp http://www.stc.org/ConfProceed/2003/PDFs/STC50-106.pdf Content Feedback Programs http://www.sun.com/bigadmin/hubs/icat/examples/index.jsp http://www.aiga.org/resources/content/2/4/6/6/documents/AIGA_Formal_Feedback_Programs.pdf http://www.cnn.com/feedback/
Contact Me Knowledge Base Content Developer Ceridian [email_address] Mirhonda Jennifer
Paper-Based Survey Customers without online access Missing user contact info (email or phone) Users more comfortable with paper
Rating Question Evaluates effectiveness of content Usually electronic format Automatic data compilation
Telephone Feedback Assessing market feasibility of a new offering Compare perceptions of strengths/weaknesses Usually strongly associated with technical or specialized functions
User Forums Customer Meetings (product, client, or customer based) Local – frequent; Distant - seldom
Impromptu Customer Comments In conjunction with other activities Establishes goodwill; good customer relationship management
Informal Usability Studies Less intimidating than formal labs Can be managed as individual or group activity Varying degrees of specialized equipment
Formal Usability Studies Automatically captures multiple streams of data Robust analysis features
Online Surveys Web-based or electronic Customizable with automatic data compilation PDF survey sample
Links Within Online Doc
Direct Email to Forward Comments Perceived as more personal and direct Inexpensive to establish
User Forums/Groups (Virtual) Various options for level and method of interaction Relatively cheap to operate Permits diverse opinion across broader demographic
Knowledge Base Feedback 1 2 3
Online Documentation Feedback Form

Content Feedback Methods

  • 1.
    Content Feedback MethodsDocTrain East October 31, 2008 Mirhonda Studevant & Jennifer Shankle
  • 2.
    Overview “ Informationbreeds confidence. Silence breeds fear.” -The West Wing Importance Challenges Methods Process Costs
  • 3.
    Content is… Bothinformation and communication… Discourse as comprehended or received by its intended audience. The glue that makes a website “sticky” – makes visitors return and keeps them from leaving. -BusinessDictionary.com
  • 4.
    Let’s Play TheFeud! 37 documentation professionals surveyed. Top four answers are on the board…
  • 5.
    Customer Feedback isImportant RoperASW reports word of mouth as the best source of product information. It exploded from 67% in 1977 to 93% in 2001. BizRate found that 59% of their users considered customer reviews more valuable than expert reviews.
  • 6.
    Customer Feedback isImportant Journal of Database Marketing & Customer Strategy article (June 2008) showed that companies who adopted customer feedback program (CFP) business practices, had 17% higher customer loyalty percentage rankings.
  • 7.
    Customer Feedback isImportant Quality and Voice of the Customer Customer Satisfaction and Retention Product Development Application within Documentation
  • 8.
    Challenges to ObtainingFeedback Writer/Requestor Perceptions Time/Resources Ineffective Methods Reader/Respondent Perceptions Time Complexity Effects
  • 9.
    The Continuum HighHigh Medium User Forums/Groups (virtual) 11 High Low Low Listing an email address for users to forward comments 10 High Medium Low Feedback Link directly within online documentation (single question) 9 High Medium Medium Online Surveys (multiple questions) 8 High High High Formal usability studies 7 Low High Medium Informal usability studies 6 Low Low Low Impromptu customer comments 5 Low High High User Forums/Groups (face-to-face) 4 Low Low Low Listing a telephone number for users to forward comments 3 Low Medium Low Rating question directly within documentation (single question) 2 Low Medium Medium Paper-based Surveys (multiple questions) 1 Tech Level Complexity Cost Method #
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Your Place onThe Continuum Leverage existing resources Justify future investments Maximize automation Promote results
  • 12.
    Content Feedback CaseStudies Ceridian Low-tech High-tech Combination Other Industries Low-tech High-tech Combination From the Audience?
  • 13.
    Content Feedback ProcessDetermining Your Approach SWOT analysis Understanding your audience Establishing goals Identifying constraints
  • 14.
    Content Feedback ProcessDeveloping Your Mechanism Assigning roles Developing questions Capturing data Compiling results
  • 15.
    Content Feedback ProcessAnalyzing Your Data Identifying trends Recommending improvements Promoting findings Evaluating process/mechanism effectiveness
  • 16.
    Keys to ContentFeedback Acknowledgement Awareness Alertness Budget Time Promotion Accountability
  • 17.
    Content Feedback ExerciseGroup recommendations for: Scenario 1: “Outnumbered, Outgunned” Scenario 2: “Lone Writer” Scenario 3: “New Era” Scenario 4: “The Intern”
  • 18.
    Closing Thoughts “Whatlies behind us and what lies before us are tiny matters compared to what lies within us” –Ralph Waldo Emerson
  • 19.
    Resources Survey Designwww.surveymonkey.com www.raosoft.com www.polldaddy.com www.questionpro.com www.surveygizmo.com Customer Relationship Management www.customerthink.com www.bryanfoss.com Usability and Documentation Testing www.techsmith.com/morae.asp http://www.stc.org/ConfProceed/2003/PDFs/STC50-106.pdf Content Feedback Programs http://www.sun.com/bigadmin/hubs/icat/examples/index.jsp http://www.aiga.org/resources/content/2/4/6/6/documents/AIGA_Formal_Feedback_Programs.pdf http://www.cnn.com/feedback/
  • 20.
    Contact Me KnowledgeBase Content Developer Ceridian [email_address] Mirhonda Jennifer
  • 21.
    Paper-Based Survey Customerswithout online access Missing user contact info (email or phone) Users more comfortable with paper
  • 22.
    Rating Question Evaluateseffectiveness of content Usually electronic format Automatic data compilation
  • 23.
    Telephone Feedback Assessingmarket feasibility of a new offering Compare perceptions of strengths/weaknesses Usually strongly associated with technical or specialized functions
  • 24.
    User Forums CustomerMeetings (product, client, or customer based) Local – frequent; Distant - seldom
  • 25.
    Impromptu Customer CommentsIn conjunction with other activities Establishes goodwill; good customer relationship management
  • 26.
    Informal Usability StudiesLess intimidating than formal labs Can be managed as individual or group activity Varying degrees of specialized equipment
  • 27.
    Formal Usability StudiesAutomatically captures multiple streams of data Robust analysis features
  • 28.
    Online Surveys Web-basedor electronic Customizable with automatic data compilation PDF survey sample
  • 29.
  • 30.
    Direct Email toForward Comments Perceived as more personal and direct Inexpensive to establish
  • 31.
    User Forums/Groups (Virtual)Various options for level and method of interaction Relatively cheap to operate Permits diverse opinion across broader demographic
  • 32.
  • 33.