2.008x
Process Planning
and Performance
MIT 2.008x
Prof. John Hart
2.008x
Agenda
 Process plans for simple
and complex products.
 Process performance
attributes.
 Conclusion; activity on
your own.
2.008x
Process Planning:
Processes for simple
and complex products
2.008x
How was it made?
Image from http://www.storopack.us/en/products-solutions/flexible-protective-
packaging/airplusr-inflatable-void-fill-and-cushioning.html
Raw material
Finished
product
http://www.dailyimpact.net/2015/10/28/death-watch-in-the-
oil-patch/
2.008x
Process plan: air pack manufacturing
Raw material extraction
Plastic pellet production
Film extrusion/blowing
Printing
Sealing, inflation, cutting
Use in your package
Image from http://www.storopack.us/en/products-solutions/flexible-protective-
packaging/airplusr-inflatable-void-fill-and-cushioning.html
Finished
product
http://www.dailyimpact.net/2015/10/28/death-watch-in-the-
oil-patch/
2.008x
Air pack manufacturing
Raw material extraction
Plastic pellet production
Film extrusion/blowing
Printing
Sealing, inflation, cutting
Use in your package
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O7BLsexJn0c
2.008x
Air pack manufacturing
Raw material extraction
Plastic pellet production
Film extrusion/blowing
Printing
Sealing, inflation, cutting
Use in your package
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kUfiwgrsfhc
2.008x
How do we envision
the process plan?
 What are the key features of the
finished product?
 What processes are needed?
 What materials are involved?
 What are the key attributes for
use?
 Which attributes can be standard,
and which must be customized?
 Should all operations be
performed in the same location,
or not?
2.008x
How do we envision
the process plan?
 What are the key features of the
finished product?
 What processes are needed?
 What materials are involved?
 What are the key attributes for
use?
 Which attributes can be standard,
and which must be customized?
 Should all operations be
performed in the same location,
or not?
2.008x
How do we envision
the process plan?
 What are the key features of the
finished product?
 What processes are needed?
 What materials are involved?
 What are the key attributes for
use?
 Which attributes can be standard,
and which must be customized?
 Should all operations be
performed in the same location,
or not?
 What process sequence(s)
make sense?
2.008x
From https://smile.amazon.com/Amazon-Fire-7-Inch-Tablet-8GB/dp/B00TSUGXKE/
$50 Amazon Fire Tablet
2.008x
Glass LCD display
Front case
Battery
PCB + speaker
Back case
2.008x
Conceptual assembly plan
SCREEN
FRONT CASE FRONT ASSEMBLY
BOARD
BACK COST
BACK ASSEMBLY
BATTERY
BUTTONS
MODULES SUBASSEMBLIES
2.008x
Amazon Fire LCD display
Color filter
(rotated 45 deg)
1 mm
LCD
Display
LCD display
Glass + touch sensors
19
2.008x
Planning for a complex
product
 Customer needs and
preferences: size, color, price,
perception of quality!
 Design for manufacturing
 Standard vs custom parts
 Materials
 R&D required?
 Supply chain
 Supplier quality control
 Shipping distribution
 Seasonal dynamics
 Inventory cost, support
 etc...
2.008x
Process Planning:
Process performance
attributes
2.008x
How do we measure the performance of a
manufacturing process?
2.008x
Rate
2.008x
Cost
General relationship between manufacturing cost per part and production volume
2.008x
Quality
Variation and defects in m&m candies
Normal (Gaussian) probability density function
2.008x
Flexibility
Titanium brackets produced using conventional manufacturing (left) and
additive manufacturing (right). From General Electric 3D printing challenge
(http://www.gereports.com/post/77131235083/jet-engine-bracket-from-indonesia-wins-3d-printing/)
2.008x
Flexibility
http://www.conformis.com/customized-knee-implants/image-to-
implant-process/
What would be
ultimate flexibility?
Titanium brackets produced using conventional manufacturing (left) and
additive manufacturing (right). From General Electric 3D printing challenge
(http://www.gereports.com/post/77131235083/jet-engine-bracket-from-indonesia-wins-3d-printing/)
2.008x
Air packs: the four attributes
Image from: http://s3.amazonaws.com/ems.wf.net.au_production/assets/16865/web_image_article/CardiaBiohybridSealedAirFill-
AirR5Lo.jpg
2.008x
2.008x
Process Planning:
Conclusion
2.008x
What have we
learned?
 Process planning: selecting and
sequencing the operations needed
to manufacture a product.
 Most products require the
integration of multiple processes,
often in multiple locations.
 Four essential and interrelated
attributes: rate, cost, quality, and
flexibility.
 We can apply the same ‘lens’ at
different levels of detail, and build
both a broad and deep
understanding of manufacturing
fundamentals.
2.008x
Cookie manufacturing!
Excerpt from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CCbWyYr82BM
…Why do I have to wait so long for my cookies?
2.008x
Cookie manufacturing!
Excerpt from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CCbWyYr82BM
 What is the process plan
for making cookies in
your kitchen?
 How would cookies be
mass-manufactured?
 In both cases, what
influences rate, cost,
quality, and flexibility?
 How might you improve
the process?
…Why do I have to wait so long for my cookies?
2.008x
Size of
cookie?
Shape of
cookie?
Flavor of
Cookie?
Image from: http://henson.com/sesamestreet.php
Nutrition value
of cookie?!

Conceptual assembly plan Process Planning Presentation.pptx

  • 1.
  • 2.
    2.008x Agenda  Process plansfor simple and complex products.  Process performance attributes.  Conclusion; activity on your own.
  • 3.
    2.008x Process Planning: Processes forsimple and complex products
  • 4.
    2.008x How was itmade? Image from http://www.storopack.us/en/products-solutions/flexible-protective- packaging/airplusr-inflatable-void-fill-and-cushioning.html Raw material Finished product http://www.dailyimpact.net/2015/10/28/death-watch-in-the- oil-patch/
  • 5.
    2.008x Process plan: airpack manufacturing Raw material extraction Plastic pellet production Film extrusion/blowing Printing Sealing, inflation, cutting Use in your package Image from http://www.storopack.us/en/products-solutions/flexible-protective- packaging/airplusr-inflatable-void-fill-and-cushioning.html Finished product http://www.dailyimpact.net/2015/10/28/death-watch-in-the- oil-patch/
  • 6.
    2.008x Air pack manufacturing Rawmaterial extraction Plastic pellet production Film extrusion/blowing Printing Sealing, inflation, cutting Use in your package https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O7BLsexJn0c
  • 7.
    2.008x Air pack manufacturing Rawmaterial extraction Plastic pellet production Film extrusion/blowing Printing Sealing, inflation, cutting Use in your package https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kUfiwgrsfhc
  • 8.
    2.008x How do weenvision the process plan?  What are the key features of the finished product?  What processes are needed?  What materials are involved?  What are the key attributes for use?  Which attributes can be standard, and which must be customized?  Should all operations be performed in the same location, or not?
  • 9.
    2.008x How do weenvision the process plan?  What are the key features of the finished product?  What processes are needed?  What materials are involved?  What are the key attributes for use?  Which attributes can be standard, and which must be customized?  Should all operations be performed in the same location, or not?
  • 10.
    2.008x How do weenvision the process plan?  What are the key features of the finished product?  What processes are needed?  What materials are involved?  What are the key attributes for use?  Which attributes can be standard, and which must be customized?  Should all operations be performed in the same location, or not?  What process sequence(s) make sense?
  • 11.
  • 12.
    2.008x Glass LCD display Frontcase Battery PCB + speaker Back case
  • 13.
    2.008x Conceptual assembly plan SCREEN FRONTCASE FRONT ASSEMBLY BOARD BACK COST BACK ASSEMBLY BATTERY BUTTONS MODULES SUBASSEMBLIES
  • 14.
    2.008x Amazon Fire LCDdisplay Color filter (rotated 45 deg) 1 mm LCD Display LCD display Glass + touch sensors 19
  • 15.
    2.008x Planning for acomplex product  Customer needs and preferences: size, color, price, perception of quality!  Design for manufacturing  Standard vs custom parts  Materials  R&D required?  Supply chain  Supplier quality control  Shipping distribution  Seasonal dynamics  Inventory cost, support  etc...
  • 16.
  • 17.
    2.008x How do wemeasure the performance of a manufacturing process?
  • 18.
  • 19.
    2.008x Cost General relationship betweenmanufacturing cost per part and production volume
  • 20.
    2.008x Quality Variation and defectsin m&m candies Normal (Gaussian) probability density function
  • 21.
    2.008x Flexibility Titanium brackets producedusing conventional manufacturing (left) and additive manufacturing (right). From General Electric 3D printing challenge (http://www.gereports.com/post/77131235083/jet-engine-bracket-from-indonesia-wins-3d-printing/)
  • 22.
    2.008x Flexibility http://www.conformis.com/customized-knee-implants/image-to- implant-process/ What would be ultimateflexibility? Titanium brackets produced using conventional manufacturing (left) and additive manufacturing (right). From General Electric 3D printing challenge (http://www.gereports.com/post/77131235083/jet-engine-bracket-from-indonesia-wins-3d-printing/)
  • 23.
    2.008x Air packs: thefour attributes Image from: http://s3.amazonaws.com/ems.wf.net.au_production/assets/16865/web_image_article/CardiaBiohybridSealedAirFill- AirR5Lo.jpg
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
    2.008x What have we learned? Process planning: selecting and sequencing the operations needed to manufacture a product.  Most products require the integration of multiple processes, often in multiple locations.  Four essential and interrelated attributes: rate, cost, quality, and flexibility.  We can apply the same ‘lens’ at different levels of detail, and build both a broad and deep understanding of manufacturing fundamentals.
  • 27.
    2.008x Cookie manufacturing! Excerpt from:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CCbWyYr82BM …Why do I have to wait so long for my cookies?
  • 28.
    2.008x Cookie manufacturing! Excerpt from:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CCbWyYr82BM  What is the process plan for making cookies in your kitchen?  How would cookies be mass-manufactured?  In both cases, what influences rate, cost, quality, and flexibility?  How might you improve the process? …Why do I have to wait so long for my cookies?
  • 29.
    2.008x Size of cookie? Shape of cookie? Flavorof Cookie? Image from: http://henson.com/sesamestreet.php Nutrition value of cookie?!

Editor's Notes

  • #16 -- Given the significant number of materials, parts, and processes involved with creating a complex device like a tablet, the challenge of process planning can quickly become overwhelming -- However, the following considerations can help organize the considerations needed to understand the trade-offs of first designing a complex device and planning its manufacturing process plan -- First, for design considerations -- standard vs custom parts–a good rule of thumb is to always use standardized parts to get both shorter lead times and better prices. Furthermore, use standard high-volume materials like plastics over more high end materials like titanium to avoid bottlenecks both in sourcing materials and equipment to manufacture -- Second, for supply chain considerations – it is critical to understand the standard and “peak-season” lead times for all the components of your device. For example – near-holiday lead times can be significantly higher/or not even possible for devices related to consumer goods. To reduce the potential of getting delayed – it is also important consider error detection at the many stages of part creation/integration. A good example of the value of in-place error detection can be found in the present GM recall situation – where faulty ignition switches (that cost only a few dollars to manufacture) have resulted in both fatalities and >$900MM recalls.
  • #26 Today..
  • #30 Connect the process physics to the output…