21. WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN LEADING AND MANAGING?
Table 14.1 Characteristics of Managers and Leaders.
Sources: Adapted from the following sources: P. Lorenzi, “Managing for the Common Good: Prosocial Leadership,” Organizational Dynamics, Vol. 33, No. 3 (2004), p. 286; J. P. Kotter, ”What Leaders Really Do,”
Harvard Business Review, December 2001, pp. 85–96; the role of leadership within organizational change is discussed in J. P. Kotter, Leading Change (Boston: Harvard Business School Press, 1996); managing in
the world of complexity is discussed in G. Sargut and R. G. McGrath, “Learning to Live with Complexity,” Harvard Business Review, September 2011, pp. 68–76; M. J. Mauboussin, “Embracing Complexity,” Harvard
Business Review, September 2011, pp. 88–92.
BEING A MANAGER MEANS... BEING A LEADER MEANS…
Planning, organizing, directing, controlling Being visionary (berwawasan)
Executing plans and delivering goods and services Being inspiring, setting the tone, and articulating (pronounce (something)
clearly and distinctly) the vision
Managing resources Managing people
Being conscientious (teliti) Being inspirational (charismatic)
Acting responsibly Acting decisively
Putting customers first—responding to and acting for customers Putting people first—responding to and acting for followers
Mistakes can happen when managers don’t appreciate people are the key
resource, underlead by treating people like other resources, or fail to be held
accountable
Mistakes can happen when leaders choose the wrong goal, direction, or
inspiration; overlead; or fail to implement the vision
Coping with complexity (difficulties) —complex organizations are chaotic
without good management
Coping with change—organizations need leadership to direct the constant
change necessary for survival in today’s dynamic business landscape
22. MANAGERIAL LEADERSHIP: CAN YOU BE BOTH A MANAGER AND A
LEADER?
• Managerial leadership includes:
• Influencing followers to internalize,
• Committing to a set of shared goals, and facilitating the group and individual
work that is needed to accomplish those goals.
• Managerial leadership may be demonstrated by managers and also
by those who exercise leadership on a daily basis.
Instructor Note: Asking students to individually think through a warm-up reflection may be a more feasible approach for large online courses.
Review objectives.
An argument can be made for each of the answers, although (c) seems most practical.
Organizational effectiveness means providing a product or service that customers value. Organizational efficiency is based on amount and cost of resources necessary for producing a given volume of output. Efficiency and effectiveness can both be high in the same organization.
The ultimate responsibility of managers is to achieve high performance, which is the attainment of organizational goals by using resources in an efficient and effective manner.
SOURCE: Adapted from Henry Mintzberg, The Nature of Managerial Work (New York: Harper & Row, 1973), pp. 92–93; and Henry Mintzberg, “Managerial Work: Analysis from Observation,” Management Science 18 (1971), B97–B110.Informational Roles
Monitor: Seek and receive information; scan Web, periodicals, reports; maintain personal contacts
Disseminator: Forward information to other organization members; send memos and reports, make phone calls
Spokesperson: Transmit information to outsiders through speeches, reports
Interpersonal Roles
Figurehead: Perform ceremonial and symbolic duties such as greeting visitors, signing legal documents
Leader: Direct and motivate subordinates; train, counsel, and communicate with subordinates
Liaison: Maintain information links inside and outside the organization; use e-mail, phone, meetings
Decisional Roles
Entrepreneur: Initiate improvement projects; identify new ideas, delegate idea responsibility to others
Disturbance Handler: Take corrective action during conflicts or crises; resolve disputes among subordinates
Resource Allocator: Decide who gets resources; schedule, budget, set priorities
Negotiator: Represent team or department’s interests; represent department during negotiation of budgets, union contracts, purchases
(d) Is correct because all other answers contain one or more of the informational and interpersonal roles
Decisional Roles
Entrepreneur: Initiate improvement projects; identify new ideas, delegate idea responsibility to others
Disturbance Handler: Take corrective action during conflicts or crises; resolve disputes among subordinates
Resource Allocator: Decide who gets resources; schedule, budget, set priorities
Negotiator: Represent team or department’s interests; represent department during negotiation of budgets, union contracts, purchases
Interpersonal Roles
Figurehead: Perform ceremonial and symbolic duties such as greeting visitors, signing legal documents
Leader: Direct and motivate subordinates; train, counsel, and communicate with subordinates
Liaison: Maintain information links inside and outside the organization; use e-mail, phone, meetings
Informational Roles
Monitor: Seek and receive information; scan Web, periodicals, reports; maintain personal contacts
Disseminator: Forward information to other organization members; send memos and reports, make phone calls
Spokesperson: Transmit information to outsiders through speeches, reports
SOURCE: Based on information from A. I. Kraut, P. R. Pedigo, D. D. McKenna, and M. D. Dunnette, “The Roleof the Manager: What’s Really Important in Different Management Jobs,” Academy of Management Executive 3(1989), 286–293.
Leaders inspire others, provide emotional support, and try to get employees to rally around a common goal. Leaders also play a key role in creating a vision and strategic plan for an organization.
Managers typically perform functions associated with planning, investigating, organizing, and control, and leaders focus on influencing others. Managers, in turn, are charged with implementing the vision and plan. We can draw several conclusions from this division of labor.
Good leaders are not necessarily good managers, and good managers are not necessarily good leaders.
Managers conduct planning, organizing, directing, and control.
Leaders inspire, encourage, and rally others to achieve great goals.
Managers implement a company’s vision and strategic plan.
Leaders create and articulate that vision and plan.
Instructors should encourage students to complete the Self-Assessment 14.1 Assessing Your Readiness to Assume the Leadership Role and reflect on these questions:
What is your level of readiness? Are you surprised by the results? Looking at the three highest- and lowest-rated items in the survey, what can you do to increase your readiness to lead? Think of specific actions you can take right now. What things might you say during an interview to demonstrate that you are ready to lead?
In dealing with the emergence of the factory system, managers faced issues regarding structure, training, scheduling operations, and dissatisfaction of workers. The tools needed for this new era of management are emphasized in the subfields of classical management.
Scientific management is a subfield of the classical perspective.
Bureaucratic organizations are another subfield of the classical perspective.
SOURCE: Adapted from Max Weber, The Theory of Social and Economic Organizations, ed. and trans. A. M. Henderson and Talcott Parsons,(New York: Free Press, 1947), pp. 328–337.
Administrative principles are a subfield of the classical perspective.
Management science is a subfield of the classical perspective.
A study involves one experimental group and one control group, but only the control group knows they are being observed
(d) is correct because it is the only option to mention study participants knowing that they are being observed.
SOURCE: Douglas McGregor, The Human Side of Enterprise (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1960), pp. 33–48.
Theory Y suggests that organizations can take advantage of the imagination and intellect of all their employees. It assumes that employees will exercise self-direction and self-control to contribute to organizational goals when given the opportunity.
Option (b) seems most likely for a Theory Y manager, but arguments can be made for the other options as well.