Bitcoin




                          http://www.flickr.com/photos/31119160@N06/8007585111/


Vesa Linja-aho — T-76.5753 Law in Network Society
About me
 Vesa Linja-aho, M. Sc. in electrical and electronics
  engineering.
 Professional background:
   7 years at Aalto university (research and teaching)
   1 year in Computerworld Finland magazine (editor)
   3 years at Metropolia, senior lecturer
      Electronics and electric safety
      Accounting and economics
      Open educational resources
      Everything new 
   http://www.google.com/#q=vesa+linja-aho



                                                   2
Bitcoin = open source cryptocurrency
 Bitcoin = distributed accounting system
   No central authority -> does not depend on
    trust to single or couple of institutions.
 Like cash, but for the internet
 1 bitcoin = 50 euros (20th of Mar 2013).
 Created by pseudonym Satoshi Nakamoto
 Based on a peer-to-peer network of
  computers running the bitcoin software.
   The transactions are verified by proof-of-
    work system of computers running a mining
    software.


                                                 3
Pros
 No unpredictable inflation by ”printing more
  money” by political decision.
 Transactions travel instantly
   Send money in seconds to anyone with internet
    access – with zero transaction costs.
 Highly anonymous, in certain conditions
   Every transaction is public, though!
 If you memorize your private key, the only way
  to steal your bitcoins (even for the authorities)
  is to torture you (or spy or hack your computer).
 Easy to use
   You can choose the tool (usability / security)

                                               4
Cons
 Bitcoin is rather new and its still in marginal
  use -> high volatility.
   BTC money supply:           500,000,000 €
   EUR money supply: 5,000,000,000,000 €
 It’s currency for the internet – take down the
  internet, and you cannot use bitcoins.
   Perhaps not suitable for any country’s official
    currency.
 Lose your private key -> lose your bitcoins.
   No means to cancel the transaction!



                                                 5
Someone’s pro is someone’s con!




                                  6
Stupid arguments against bitcoin
 People buy guns and drugs with it!
   But it proves it works!
   And people use plain cash for the same.
 Early adopters benefit too much
   Is it really a problem?
 Bitcoin has actually no value
   Same applies to euros and dollars.
   They only have value because people believe
    they have value.




                                                  7
Good or at least considerable arguments
against bitcoin
 The value is unstable.
 There might be a bubble!
 Bitcoin can be replaced with a similar product.
 The government can shut it down.
   Or at least try to, by making it illegal to use
    bitcoins.
 The slowness of transaction verification (about
  10 minutes per block).
 The scalability: the current version can not
  handle the transactions if everyone in the world
  used bitcoins.
 MtGox handles most of the trade -> raid it -> ?
                                                8
Is there a bubble?
 Media attention will inspire people to buy
  bitcoins
 Media attention will inspire companies to
  accept bitcoins (and vice versa)
 The price of bitcoins rise -> media attention
 The circle is ready.

 As long as the price rises together with the use
  of bitcoin, there is (probably) no bubble.
   I emphasize the word probably. The
    circulation speed of bitcoin is low if
    compared to regular money.

                                                  9
How it works
 Every ”account” consists of the public key (=
  bitcoin address) and the private key.
 Anyone who knows your public key, can send
  you bitcoins.
 To spend bitcoins, you have to know the
  private key.
   The transaction is broadcasted to the bitcoin
    network.
   The miners confirm the transactions




                                                10
The addresses
 An example of a bitcoin address:
   14nRKoXJAUpKYYbzw6Yrqh9gW2p26zerpW
   2 160 (about 10 48)possible addresses
 The corresponding private key:
   5HuEupX3DNFJ7UypjFtXDTm4BVuAwZtAgY
    f94sMALPyakgafVnU
   256 bits
   About 10 77 possible private keys




                                       11
Confirmations
 In the process called mining, all transactions
  are collected in a block. A new block is mined
  in about every 10 minutes.
 For small payments or with payments with
  trusted peer, 0 confirmations is usually ok.
 For large amounts, 6 confirmations is
  considered safe.




                                               12
Double spend elimination
 Because bitcoin has no central authority, one
  of the main security problems is eliminating a
  double spend fraud (wherein the same money
  is spent twice).
 The main innovation in bitcoin is the
  blockchain. Each full node (= computer
  running the bitcoin program) in the network
  has a copy of all mined blocks.
 Disrupting the system would need enormous
  computing power.




                                             13
Anonymity
 Understand how bitcoin works
   Every transaction from address to address is
    public.
   How much and when = public, who owns the
    address = not public (can be
    analyzed, though).
 Create a new address for every transaction
 Use mixing services
 The larger the transactions, the easier it is to
  carry out traffic analysis




                                                 14
Who accepts bitcoins?
 Namecheap
 Wordpress
 Many nonprofits accept bitcoin donations
   Archive.org
 Bitpay (= simple interface for merchants)
 Bitspend.net (order anything with bitcoins)




                                                15
16
Legal stuff
 In Finland, the Board of Accounting recognizes
  bitcoin:
   treated like stocks
   or if selling and buying bitcoins is the core
    business of the company, they are put in the
    current assets.
 Its completely legal to use bitcoins as money
  (as it is legal to use potatoes or gold as
  money)
 Anti-terrorism and money laundering law:
  selling bitcoins for > 15 000 € -> ask for ID.


                                               17
Bitcoin and taxes
 I asked the tax authorities about bitcoin: 'we
  have a group of experts working on it’.
 Currently, VAT 24% is imposed on selling
  bitcoins.
 Exchanging bitcoins for a customer is VAT 0%
   That is, the dealer buys the bitcoins for the
    customer.




                                                18
Bitcoin and taxes?




                     19
Worth reading
 http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin
 http://bitcoin.it/
 https://blockchain.info/tx/8b555a4399797c78
  4033863dda38abef7b8adcaf6748e9519dcb1
  75fb1d04ee0
 http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/09/07
  /golden-cyberfetters/
 https://twitter.com/carsonj/status/314382483
  468713984




                                            20
Tools for beginners (and everyone)
 http://easywallet.org
 http://blockchain.info/
 https://www.bitaddress.org/




                                     21

Bitcoin - the Basics

  • 1.
    Bitcoin http://www.flickr.com/photos/31119160@N06/8007585111/ Vesa Linja-aho — T-76.5753 Law in Network Society
  • 2.
    About me  VesaLinja-aho, M. Sc. in electrical and electronics engineering.  Professional background:  7 years at Aalto university (research and teaching)  1 year in Computerworld Finland magazine (editor)  3 years at Metropolia, senior lecturer  Electronics and electric safety  Accounting and economics  Open educational resources  Everything new   http://www.google.com/#q=vesa+linja-aho 2
  • 3.
    Bitcoin = opensource cryptocurrency  Bitcoin = distributed accounting system  No central authority -> does not depend on trust to single or couple of institutions.  Like cash, but for the internet  1 bitcoin = 50 euros (20th of Mar 2013).  Created by pseudonym Satoshi Nakamoto  Based on a peer-to-peer network of computers running the bitcoin software.  The transactions are verified by proof-of- work system of computers running a mining software. 3
  • 4.
    Pros  No unpredictableinflation by ”printing more money” by political decision.  Transactions travel instantly  Send money in seconds to anyone with internet access – with zero transaction costs.  Highly anonymous, in certain conditions  Every transaction is public, though!  If you memorize your private key, the only way to steal your bitcoins (even for the authorities) is to torture you (or spy or hack your computer).  Easy to use  You can choose the tool (usability / security) 4
  • 5.
    Cons  Bitcoin israther new and its still in marginal use -> high volatility.  BTC money supply: 500,000,000 €  EUR money supply: 5,000,000,000,000 €  It’s currency for the internet – take down the internet, and you cannot use bitcoins.  Perhaps not suitable for any country’s official currency.  Lose your private key -> lose your bitcoins.  No means to cancel the transaction! 5
  • 6.
    Someone’s pro issomeone’s con! 6
  • 7.
    Stupid arguments againstbitcoin  People buy guns and drugs with it!  But it proves it works!  And people use plain cash for the same.  Early adopters benefit too much  Is it really a problem?  Bitcoin has actually no value  Same applies to euros and dollars.  They only have value because people believe they have value. 7
  • 8.
    Good or atleast considerable arguments against bitcoin  The value is unstable.  There might be a bubble!  Bitcoin can be replaced with a similar product.  The government can shut it down.  Or at least try to, by making it illegal to use bitcoins.  The slowness of transaction verification (about 10 minutes per block).  The scalability: the current version can not handle the transactions if everyone in the world used bitcoins.  MtGox handles most of the trade -> raid it -> ? 8
  • 9.
    Is there abubble?  Media attention will inspire people to buy bitcoins  Media attention will inspire companies to accept bitcoins (and vice versa)  The price of bitcoins rise -> media attention  The circle is ready.  As long as the price rises together with the use of bitcoin, there is (probably) no bubble.  I emphasize the word probably. The circulation speed of bitcoin is low if compared to regular money. 9
  • 10.
    How it works Every ”account” consists of the public key (= bitcoin address) and the private key.  Anyone who knows your public key, can send you bitcoins.  To spend bitcoins, you have to know the private key.  The transaction is broadcasted to the bitcoin network.  The miners confirm the transactions 10
  • 11.
    The addresses  Anexample of a bitcoin address:  14nRKoXJAUpKYYbzw6Yrqh9gW2p26zerpW  2 160 (about 10 48)possible addresses  The corresponding private key:  5HuEupX3DNFJ7UypjFtXDTm4BVuAwZtAgY f94sMALPyakgafVnU  256 bits  About 10 77 possible private keys 11
  • 12.
    Confirmations  In theprocess called mining, all transactions are collected in a block. A new block is mined in about every 10 minutes.  For small payments or with payments with trusted peer, 0 confirmations is usually ok.  For large amounts, 6 confirmations is considered safe. 12
  • 13.
    Double spend elimination Because bitcoin has no central authority, one of the main security problems is eliminating a double spend fraud (wherein the same money is spent twice).  The main innovation in bitcoin is the blockchain. Each full node (= computer running the bitcoin program) in the network has a copy of all mined blocks.  Disrupting the system would need enormous computing power. 13
  • 14.
    Anonymity  Understand howbitcoin works  Every transaction from address to address is public.  How much and when = public, who owns the address = not public (can be analyzed, though).  Create a new address for every transaction  Use mixing services  The larger the transactions, the easier it is to carry out traffic analysis 14
  • 15.
    Who accepts bitcoins? Namecheap  Wordpress  Many nonprofits accept bitcoin donations  Archive.org  Bitpay (= simple interface for merchants)  Bitspend.net (order anything with bitcoins) 15
  • 16.
  • 17.
    Legal stuff  InFinland, the Board of Accounting recognizes bitcoin:  treated like stocks  or if selling and buying bitcoins is the core business of the company, they are put in the current assets.  Its completely legal to use bitcoins as money (as it is legal to use potatoes or gold as money)  Anti-terrorism and money laundering law: selling bitcoins for > 15 000 € -> ask for ID. 17
  • 18.
    Bitcoin and taxes I asked the tax authorities about bitcoin: 'we have a group of experts working on it’.  Currently, VAT 24% is imposed on selling bitcoins.  Exchanging bitcoins for a customer is VAT 0%  That is, the dealer buys the bitcoins for the customer. 18
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Worth reading  http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin http://bitcoin.it/  https://blockchain.info/tx/8b555a4399797c78 4033863dda38abef7b8adcaf6748e9519dcb1 75fb1d04ee0  http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/09/07 /golden-cyberfetters/  https://twitter.com/carsonj/status/314382483 468713984 20
  • 21.
    Tools for beginners(and everyone)  http://easywallet.org  http://blockchain.info/  https://www.bitaddress.org/ 21