This document discusses biodiesel, an alternative fuel made from renewable sources like vegetable oils and waste cooking oil. It is produced through a process called transesterification and has several advantages over petroleum diesel, such as being less toxic, producing lower emissions, and providing an opportunity to decrease foreign oil dependence. The document proposes a pilot program to produce biodiesel using waste cooking oil and implement its use in the vehicles of the City of Fort Worth. A five-stage plan is outlined to eventually expand regional biodiesel production and use.
2. What is biodiesel?
Biodiesel is a clean burning alternative diesel fuel, produced
from domestic, renewable sources. Biodiesel contains no
petroleum, is simple to use, biodegradable, and non-toxic.
Produced by a process called transesterification
Fatty acid methyl esters
Requires only a few ingredients
Feedstock oil
Methanol
Catalyst
4. Advantages of biodiesel
Biodegrades as fast as sugar
Less toxic than table salt
Reduces emissions
Any diesel vehicle can run biodiesel
Made from renewable resources
Sourced locally
Decreases foreign oil dependence
5. Advantages of biodiesel
Can be made from waste cooking oil
3 billion gallons of waste oil produced per year
Contains no sulfur
Increases lubricity
Can be used as heating fuel
Biodiesel is the only alternative fuel to have fully completed
and satisfied the health effects testing requirements of the
1990 Clean Air Act Amendments.
6. Why do we need it?
94% of all goods in the United States are transported by
vehicles powered by diesel engines
A renewable, clean-burning diesel replacement
Reduces U.S. dependence on foreign oil
Creates new jobs
Made from an increasingly diverse mix of resources such as
agricultural oils, recycled cooking oil and animal fats, that does
not compete with the food supply
7. Why do we need it?
Biodiesel results in
significantly lower
emissions of particulate
matter, carbon
monoxide, toxic
contaminants, sulfur
dioxide, hydrocarbons,
visible smoke and
noxious odors than
petroleum diesel.
8. Biodiesel feedstock sources
Unlike ethanol, the highest yield sources
of vegetable oil are not chiefly food crops.
Top five: Open pond algae, Millettia
pinnata, Copaifera langsdorffii, oil palms,
and the Chinese tallow tree.
Bottom five: Maize (corn), cashew nut,
oats, lupin, and kenaf.
Chinese tallow tree is actually considered
invasive in the U.S., accounting for 23% of
all trees in the Houston area.
9. For whom do we need it?
Financial, Ethical, and Ecological Stakeholders
Public and private freight operators
Municipalities
Taxpayers
Consumers
Vehicle manufacturers
Oil and gas companies
Soil & Water: the environment and everything it contains
10. Required expertise
Agriculturalist – identifies and cultivates regionally appropriate feedstock
Mineralogist – identifies local reserves of necessary catalyst minerals
Chemist – investigates new methods of extraction and production
Logistics Expert – explores most efficient & practical methods of delivery
Transportation Planner – examines existing infrastructure and trends
City Manager – negotiates code and coordinates with local politicians/orgs
Economist – examines local/regional/national/global trends in fuel use
Political Scientist – interpret the political climate and legislative feasibility
11. Implementation: Stage 1
Identify potential market
City of Fort Worth and her diesel fleet
Code Compliance
Fire
42 stations
8,066 calls taken in November of 2011
Housing and Economic Development
Parks and Community Services
Planning and Development
Police
Transportation and Public Works
12. Implementation: Stage 2
Assess political will and funding potential
The City of Fort Worth has taken steps to curb fuel costs since
2002, when it established the Fort Worth Fuel Consortium.
The Consortium coordinated purchasing efforts across departments,
providing for reduced rates.
Interest in the Consortium grew, and the City welcomed adjacent
cities and other agencies to join the cooperative.
Monthly fuel budget for the City is nearly $1 million.
Over $40,000 was saved by the FWWC scheme in 2010.
We believe much more can be saved by embracing biodiesel.
13. Implementation: Stage 3
Pilot project proposal
Onsite production by the City’s Equipment Services Dept.
Springboard BioPro 380 Processor [$14,995.00]
Producing 750 gallons per month (half capacity)
Reclaimed cooking oil [Free + cost of transport]
Methanol [$2.85/gal]
Sulfuric acid [$6.00 for 380ml]
Electricity [$0.15/kWh for 50kWh]
Water [$0.09/gal for 90gal]
Return on investment: 275 days
14. Implementation: Stage 4
Expansion to other departments
Maintain onsite production
whenever possible
Establishment of grease
abatement and collection
program, similar to Cease the
Grease in Dallas
Coordinate with area farmers to
acquire locally produced
vegetable oils
15. Implementation: Stage 5
Evaluate cost savings and
reassess outlook
Invest in centralized biodiesel
processing facility
Establish strategic reserve
Transform the Fort Worth Fuel
Consortium into a regional
biodiesel marketplace and
cooperative—the first of its
kind in the United States.
16. Projected timeline
Such a proposal could theoretically be completed within a
period of 3-5 years, however, the timeline is highly contingent
on a number of variables:
Political expediency
Is the Fuel Consortium a friend or a foe?
Progressive political climate?
A willingness to invest?
Economic outlook
Anticipated tax revenues
Fuel price (petroleum diesel)
Materials price (lye, methanol, sulfuric acid, etc.)
17. Other factors to consider
Biodiesel production is on the rise, correlating with the rise in
price of conventional petroleum based diesel.
The National Biodiesel Board has released the following
production volume estimates for the U.S., per calendar year:
2011 802 million gallons
2010 315 million gallons
2009 545 million gallons
2008 691 million gallons
2007 500 million gallons
2006 224 million gallons
2005 112 million gallons
18. Other factors to consider
802 million gallons for 2011 is a record high.
A result of the federal tax incentive for biodiesel that was
reinstated this year (H.R. 2238).
In danger of expiring on December 31, 2011 without
congressional action.
19. Other factors to consider
Public–Private Partnership
Texas ranks first in the country for biodiesel production
More than 20 commercial biodiesel plants, with more under
construction, producing over 100 million gallons each year
Texas ranks first among the fifty states for railroad miles, with
over 14,006 miles of track in use (Primarily diesel engines)
Texas is also home to the highest number of owner-operator
independent truck drivers in the country, with 14,634. (OOIDA)
Meaningfully integrating all of these private sector industries,
from agriculture to freight logistics, is key to a successful
regional biodiesel initiative.
20. Program Evaluation
Key performance indicators for success
Social
Overall community satisfaction with initiative
Psychosocial metrics: self-affirmation and contentment with
workforce (being a part of the solution, rather than the problem)
Environmental
Air quality: emission levels
Risk aversion
Economic
Taxpayer investment return
Municipal investment return
Efficiency and overall cost-savings
21. Conclusion
A City of Fort Worth biodiesel initiative could serve as an
extraordinary model for the benefits of regionalized energy self-
sufficiency, and could be easily adaptable to other communities
throughout the world.
Having demonstrated previous leadership with the Fuel
Consortium, we hope that the City of Fort Worth will embrace
our proactive framework for deploying biodiesel in our
community and beyond.
22. Questions/ Contacts?
John Bell john.bell@mavs.uta.edu
http://2011sustainability.blogspot.com/
George Hornung george.hornung@mavs.uta.edu
http://georgetx.blogspot.com/
Chris Intharansy chanthala.intharansy@mavs.uta.edu
http://blog.uta.edu/~cci8940/
Kyle Miller kyle.miller@mavs.uta.edu
http://kylemillermsis.wordpress.com/