Presented by: Shawn Carr, P.Eng
Audit Funding Program Update
TODAY’S OBJECTIVES
Audit Funding Goals and Results
The What and Why of Energy Audits
Review Audit Funding incentives, eligibility, and application
process
Engage our Panelists with questions on Audit Funding
Case Studies – Using audit funding incentives to uncover
your biggest savings potential!
Open for business
We need your continued
support
August 2015 until 2020
400GWh target within our
territory (7 billion KWh in ON)
2015 – 2020
CONSERVATION
FIRST FRAMEWORK
WHY ENERGY EFFICIENCY PROJECTS
ARE NOT COSTS BUT ASSETS TO BE
MANAGED
Lowering Operating Costs
Reducing GHG’s
Satisfying sustainability
initiatives
Green Building Certification
and Labelling Systems
Improving tenant comfort
Demonstrating Leadership
through benchmarking
Emulating Best Practices in
other buildings
Responding to a mandate
Preparing for mandatory
disclosure
Productivity Impact
OPTIMIZING RESULTS
Occupant UseBuilding
Operations
Building
Systems
Savings
Savings
Savings
ESA: Tenant
Energy Audits
System
Optimization
ESA: Building
Energy Audit
Retro-
commissioning
Focuses on
Operations
-Complicated
systems/controls
-Troubleshooting
required
-Has BAS
Energy Audits Focus on
Equipment
- Renewal
- Simple systems and controls
- Typically no BAS analysis
Content provided by WSP
Audit Stats since 2011
250 Audit Funding Applications
$1,200,000 incentives issued
60+% of sites audited so far have
applied for Retrofit Incentives
Incentives to Owners for completing building
energy audits, RCx studies, and Building
System Audits.
Incentives to Tenants of facilities for
completing energy audits within their space.
AUDIT
FUNDING
AUDIT FUNDING PROGRAM OVERVIEW
Incentives for
Energy Studies
Audit Funding
Program
Four levels of
incentives
Electricity Survey
& Analysis for
Owners
For Energy Audits on
Entire Building
Electricity Survey
& Analysis for
Tenants
For Energy Audits of
Tenant Spaces
Building System
Audit
For optimizing
existing system
performance
Detailed Capital
Intensive
Modifications
For deeper analysis
on capital projects
identified in ESA
Existing Building
Commissioning
For Rcx your Chilled
Water System
Process &
Systems
For customers running
complex systems
AUDIT FUNDING AND
EB COMMISSIONING
PROGRAM CHANGES
Changes being considered for
2016 and beyond:
EB Commissioning to expand
beyond chilled water to include
other electricity consuming
building systems
Detailed Analysis of Capital
Intensive Modifications may
be discontinued
AUDIT FUNDING OBJECTIVES
Help you achieve Greater Energy Efficiency
Investigate Benchmark Implement Measure
ASHRAE LEVEL AUDITS
LEVEL 1: WALK-THROUGH
SURVEY
LEVEL 2: ENERGY SURVEY
AND ANALYSIS (ESA)
LEVEL 3: DETAILED ANALYSIS
OF CAPITAL-INTENSIVE
MODIFICATIONS (DCIM)
BUILDING OWNERS AND TENANTS
ELECTRICITY SURVEY
AND ANALYSIS
• Connected to the LDC’s distribution system, classified as non-residential.
• Own or lease the building
• Not eligible if the facility has already received a ESA.
• Auditor must be a P.Eng, CEM, or Building Assessment Professional (ASHRAE)
• Meets ASHRAE Level 2 requirements
• Commitment to implement no/low cost measures (<$1,000 and <1 year payback)
Applicant Building Size Incentive
Building Owner Up to 30,000
sq.ft
$0.10/sq.ft to a maximum of 50%
Building Owner Larger than
30,000 sq.ft
$3000 for 30,000 sq.ft and
$0.05/sq.ft thereafter up to
$25,000 or 50% of audit costs
Tenant Any Size $0.03/sq.ft up to $7,500 or 50%
of audit costs
BUILDING OWNERS
BUILDING
SYSTEM AUDIT
• Analysis of energy savings by optimizing existing building systems (Ventilation,
chilled water distribution, DHW distribution, Controls/BAS, AHU’s, etc)
• One incentive per building system to a maximum of $50,000
• Can be used to evaluate design options/repair strategies through an energy lens
• Excludes lighting systems
Building Size Incentive
Any 50% of audit costs up to
$5,000
BUILDING OWNER
EXISTING
BUILDING CX
• Incentives to evaluate and increase chilled water system efficiency.
• Equipment older than 3 years and not had a major overhaul in last 2 years
• No planted overhaul or replacement in next 2 years
• Refer to participant agreement and report requirements for more details.
Phase Incentive Requirement
Scoping Study Up to $2,500 or 100% of cost -Commissioning Agent
must have certain
credentials
Investigation $6/ton for data logging equipment (up to 75%
of costs)
$18/ton for preparing Cx report (up to 75% of
costs)
Up to a maximum of $30,000
Data Acquistion System
installed to log
performance data
Project M&V plan
Implementation Up to $5,000 or 100% of cost for
implementation report
Implement measures
with simple payback <2
years
Hand-off/Completion Up to $2,500 or 100% of cost for completion
report
Analysis of yearly
energy
consumption/savings
BUILDING OWNER
PROCESS &
SYSTEMS
• Different payment terms and M&V requirements depending on Incentive Stream
Phase Incentive Requirement
Investigation Preliminary Engineering Study (PES): Up to
$10,000
Detailed Engineering Study (DES): Up to
$50,000
- 100 MWh of
Annualized
Savings
Delivered
- - 3rd party
review of report
Project
Implementation –
Behind the Meter
Generation Projects
(i.e: Combined Heat
and Power, Waste
Energy Recovery)
- Compressed air
systems
Three Incentive Streams:
Small Capital Incentives (<$1,000,000)
- Up to 70% of project cost or $200/MWh
Large Capital Incentives (>$1,000,000)
- Up to 70% of project cost or $200/MWh
Retrofit Program
-Up to 50% of project cost
HOW TO PARTICIPATE?
Establish Eligibility
Apply to Program
Obtain Pre-Approval
Receive Cheque
Engage us early to
determine best funding
path based on your needs
Submit Application & Participant
Agreement and review audit report
requirements before beginning your
audit
Refer to Post-Project
Evaluation Checklist
Submit Post-Project
Documentation
LDC reviews report and
meets with you to discuss
implementation plans and
deliver cheque
http://cdm.hydroottawa.com/support-
centre/worksheets-and-forms
Bentall Kennedy - Sun Life Financial Centre
• Electricity Survey and Analysis Audit with some Rcx
• Building Simulation
• Design Systems Analysis for Cooling Plant
• Audit Project Cost: $49,000
• Audit Incentive Paid: $24,500
• Led to $2,000,000 capital upgrade of cooling plant
• $536,000 retrofit incentive from Hydro Ottawa
• Projected Annual Savings: $185,000
QUESTIONS?
Shawn Carr
Shawncarr@hydroottawa.com
613-738-5499 ext. 7474

Audit Funding Program Update

  • 1.
    Presented by: ShawnCarr, P.Eng Audit Funding Program Update
  • 2.
    TODAY’S OBJECTIVES Audit FundingGoals and Results The What and Why of Energy Audits Review Audit Funding incentives, eligibility, and application process Engage our Panelists with questions on Audit Funding Case Studies – Using audit funding incentives to uncover your biggest savings potential!
  • 3.
    Open for business Weneed your continued support August 2015 until 2020 400GWh target within our territory (7 billion KWh in ON) 2015 – 2020 CONSERVATION FIRST FRAMEWORK
  • 4.
    WHY ENERGY EFFICIENCYPROJECTS ARE NOT COSTS BUT ASSETS TO BE MANAGED Lowering Operating Costs Reducing GHG’s Satisfying sustainability initiatives Green Building Certification and Labelling Systems Improving tenant comfort Demonstrating Leadership through benchmarking Emulating Best Practices in other buildings Responding to a mandate Preparing for mandatory disclosure Productivity Impact
  • 5.
    OPTIMIZING RESULTS Occupant UseBuilding Operations Building Systems Savings Savings Savings ESA:Tenant Energy Audits System Optimization ESA: Building Energy Audit Retro- commissioning Focuses on Operations -Complicated systems/controls -Troubleshooting required -Has BAS Energy Audits Focus on Equipment - Renewal - Simple systems and controls - Typically no BAS analysis Content provided by WSP
  • 6.
    Audit Stats since2011 250 Audit Funding Applications $1,200,000 incentives issued 60+% of sites audited so far have applied for Retrofit Incentives
  • 7.
    Incentives to Ownersfor completing building energy audits, RCx studies, and Building System Audits. Incentives to Tenants of facilities for completing energy audits within their space. AUDIT FUNDING
  • 8.
    AUDIT FUNDING PROGRAMOVERVIEW Incentives for Energy Studies Audit Funding Program Four levels of incentives Electricity Survey & Analysis for Owners For Energy Audits on Entire Building Electricity Survey & Analysis for Tenants For Energy Audits of Tenant Spaces Building System Audit For optimizing existing system performance Detailed Capital Intensive Modifications For deeper analysis on capital projects identified in ESA Existing Building Commissioning For Rcx your Chilled Water System Process & Systems For customers running complex systems
  • 9.
    AUDIT FUNDING AND EBCOMMISSIONING PROGRAM CHANGES Changes being considered for 2016 and beyond: EB Commissioning to expand beyond chilled water to include other electricity consuming building systems Detailed Analysis of Capital Intensive Modifications may be discontinued
  • 10.
    AUDIT FUNDING OBJECTIVES Helpyou achieve Greater Energy Efficiency Investigate Benchmark Implement Measure
  • 11.
    ASHRAE LEVEL AUDITS LEVEL1: WALK-THROUGH SURVEY LEVEL 2: ENERGY SURVEY AND ANALYSIS (ESA) LEVEL 3: DETAILED ANALYSIS OF CAPITAL-INTENSIVE MODIFICATIONS (DCIM)
  • 12.
    BUILDING OWNERS ANDTENANTS ELECTRICITY SURVEY AND ANALYSIS • Connected to the LDC’s distribution system, classified as non-residential. • Own or lease the building • Not eligible if the facility has already received a ESA. • Auditor must be a P.Eng, CEM, or Building Assessment Professional (ASHRAE) • Meets ASHRAE Level 2 requirements • Commitment to implement no/low cost measures (<$1,000 and <1 year payback) Applicant Building Size Incentive Building Owner Up to 30,000 sq.ft $0.10/sq.ft to a maximum of 50% Building Owner Larger than 30,000 sq.ft $3000 for 30,000 sq.ft and $0.05/sq.ft thereafter up to $25,000 or 50% of audit costs Tenant Any Size $0.03/sq.ft up to $7,500 or 50% of audit costs
  • 13.
    BUILDING OWNERS BUILDING SYSTEM AUDIT •Analysis of energy savings by optimizing existing building systems (Ventilation, chilled water distribution, DHW distribution, Controls/BAS, AHU’s, etc) • One incentive per building system to a maximum of $50,000 • Can be used to evaluate design options/repair strategies through an energy lens • Excludes lighting systems Building Size Incentive Any 50% of audit costs up to $5,000
  • 14.
    BUILDING OWNER EXISTING BUILDING CX •Incentives to evaluate and increase chilled water system efficiency. • Equipment older than 3 years and not had a major overhaul in last 2 years • No planted overhaul or replacement in next 2 years • Refer to participant agreement and report requirements for more details. Phase Incentive Requirement Scoping Study Up to $2,500 or 100% of cost -Commissioning Agent must have certain credentials Investigation $6/ton for data logging equipment (up to 75% of costs) $18/ton for preparing Cx report (up to 75% of costs) Up to a maximum of $30,000 Data Acquistion System installed to log performance data Project M&V plan Implementation Up to $5,000 or 100% of cost for implementation report Implement measures with simple payback <2 years Hand-off/Completion Up to $2,500 or 100% of cost for completion report Analysis of yearly energy consumption/savings
  • 15.
    BUILDING OWNER PROCESS & SYSTEMS •Different payment terms and M&V requirements depending on Incentive Stream Phase Incentive Requirement Investigation Preliminary Engineering Study (PES): Up to $10,000 Detailed Engineering Study (DES): Up to $50,000 - 100 MWh of Annualized Savings Delivered - - 3rd party review of report Project Implementation – Behind the Meter Generation Projects (i.e: Combined Heat and Power, Waste Energy Recovery) - Compressed air systems Three Incentive Streams: Small Capital Incentives (<$1,000,000) - Up to 70% of project cost or $200/MWh Large Capital Incentives (>$1,000,000) - Up to 70% of project cost or $200/MWh Retrofit Program -Up to 50% of project cost
  • 16.
    HOW TO PARTICIPATE? EstablishEligibility Apply to Program Obtain Pre-Approval Receive Cheque Engage us early to determine best funding path based on your needs Submit Application & Participant Agreement and review audit report requirements before beginning your audit Refer to Post-Project Evaluation Checklist Submit Post-Project Documentation LDC reviews report and meets with you to discuss implementation plans and deliver cheque http://cdm.hydroottawa.com/support- centre/worksheets-and-forms
  • 17.
    Bentall Kennedy -Sun Life Financial Centre • Electricity Survey and Analysis Audit with some Rcx • Building Simulation • Design Systems Analysis for Cooling Plant • Audit Project Cost: $49,000 • Audit Incentive Paid: $24,500 • Led to $2,000,000 capital upgrade of cooling plant • $536,000 retrofit incentive from Hydro Ottawa • Projected Annual Savings: $185,000
  • 18.