SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Aspirin Plus Clopidogrel Therapy Increases Early Venous Graft Patency After
 Coronary Artery Bypass Surgery: A Single-Center, Randomized, Controlled
                                    Trial
        Ge Gao, Zhe Zheng, Yi Pi, Bin Lu, Jinguo Lu, and Shengshou Hu
                   J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 2010;56;1639-1643
                        doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2010.03.104
                This information is current as of March 20, 2012
 The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is
                        located on the World Wide Web at:
             http://content.onlinejacc.org/cgi/content/full/56/20/1639




                  Downloaded from content.onlinejacc.org by on March 20, 2012
Journal of the American College of Cardiology                                                                                               Vol. 56, No. 20, 2010
© 2010 by the American College of Cardiology Foundation                                                                                   ISSN 0735-1097/$36.00
Published by Elsevier Inc.                                                                                                          doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2010.03.104




      Aspirin Plus Clopidogrel Therapy
      Increases Early Venous Graft Patency
      After Coronary Artery Bypass Surgery
      A Single-Center, Randomized, Controlled Trial

      Ge Gao, MD,* Zhe Zheng, MD,* Yi Pi, MD,* Bin Lu, MD,† Jinguo Lu, MD,† Shengshou Hu, MD*
      Beijing, The People’s Republic of China

             Objectives                We sought to evaluate the effect of aspirin plus clopidogrel versus aspirin alone on saphenous vein graft occlu-
                                       sion at 3 months after coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG).

             Background                Prevalence of graft occlusion is high after CABG. Aggressive antiplatelet therapy is expected to improve early
                                       post-operative graft patency.

             Methods                   From December 2007 through December 2008, 249 consecutive patients undergoing elective CABG at Fuwai
                                       Hospital were randomly assigned to 2 groups: 124 received aspirin (100 mg) plus clopidogrel (75 mg) daily (AC
                                       group), and 125 received aspirin (100 mg) alone daily (A group). Antiplatelet therapies were initiated when post-
                                       operative chest tube drainage was Յ30 cc/h for 2 h. All participants were invited for clinical follow-up and 64-
                                       slice multislice computed tomography angiography (MSCTA) analysis at 3 months post-operatively. Generalized
                                       estimating equations analysis was used to determine predictors of graft patency.

             Results                   One participant, from group A, died before 3-month follow-up. Of the remaining 248 patients, 224 (90.3%) un-
                                       derwent MSCTA. Participants had similar pre-operative and intraoperative characteristics at baseline. No signifi-
                                       cant differences were observed in intraoperative transit-time flow measurement findings or major adverse
                                       cardiac-related events. Three-month MSCTA follow-up revealed that saphenous vein graft patency was 91.6%
                                       (219 of 239) in the AC group versus 85.7% (198 of 231) in the A group (p ϭ 0.043). In multivariate analysis,
                                       combined antiplatelet therapy independently increased venous graft patency (p ϭ 0.045).

             Conclusions               Aspirin plus clopidogrel is more effective in venous graft patency than aspirin alone in the short term after
                                       CABG, but further, long-term study is needed. (The Clopidogrel and Aspirin After Surgery for Coronary Artery
                                       Disease; NCT00776477) (J Am Coll Cardiol 2010;56:1639–43) © 2010 by the American College of Cardi-
                                       ology Foundation




There is a high prevalence of venous graft closure within 3                               Clopidogrel is a promising antiplatelet agent; its clinical
months after coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) sur-                                  efficacy at reducing ischemic events and mortality in patients
gery (1). The main mechanism at this stage is graft                                       with coronary and vascular disease has been demonstrated in
thrombosis, which sets the stage for graft stenosis and                                   several large clinical trials (3,4). To date, however, no trial
occlusion. Despite its established comprehensive clinical use                             has prospectively evaluated the synergistic effects of aspirin
and benefit in patients with coronary heart disease, aspirin                               plus clopidogrel on saphenous vein graft (SVG) disease after
therapy has limitations, including failure to arouse a com-                               CABG. Therefore, we conducted a randomized controlled
plete antiplatelet response in 5% to 10% of patients (2).                                 trial comparing aspirin plus clopidogrel with aspirin alone in
                                                                                          CABG patients revascularized with at least 1 saphenous vein.
                                                                                          The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of combined
From the *Department of Surgery, Cardiovascular Institute and Fu Wai Hospital,            antiplatelet therapy 3 months after CABG on SVG patency
Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences & Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, The
People’s Republic of China; and the †Center of Imageology, Cardiovascular Institute and   and also the major adverse cardiac-related events.
Fu Wai Hospital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences & Peking Union Medical
College, Beijing, The People’s Republic of China. This study was supported by the Key     Methods
Project in the National Science & Technology Pillar Program during the 11th 5-Year
Plan Period (2006BAI01A09). The authors have reported that they have no relationships     Patients. The study was a prospective randomized con-
to disclose. The first 3 authors contributed equally to this work.
   Manuscript received November 9, 2009; revised manuscript received February 22,         trolled trial. All patients referred for isolated surgical coronary
2010, accepted March 18, 2010.                                                            revascularization from December 2007 to December 2008
                                                Downloaded from content.onlinejacc.org by on March 20, 2012
1640        Gao et al.                                                                                                                              JACC Vol. 56, No. 20, 2010
            Aspirin Plus Clopidogrel for Venous Graft Patency                                                                                      November 9, 2010:1639–43


  Abbreviations            with at least 1 SVG at Fuwai
                                                                                 of the A and Pre-Operative
                                                                                 Pre-OperativeAC Groups Clinical Characteristics
                                                                                                Clinical Characteristics
  and Acronyms             Hospital were screened accord-                          Table 1
                                                                                              of the A and AC Groups
                           ing to the inclusion criteria. This
  CABG ‫ ؍‬coronary artery                                                                                                 A Group                 AC Group
  bypass grafting          study was approved by the local                              Characteristic                  (n ‫)111 ؍‬                (n ‫)311 ؍‬              p Value
  MACE ‫ ؍‬major adverse
                           ethical committee with patient                          Age (yrs)                           59.8 Ϯ 7.92              57.9 Ϯ 8.25              0.096
  cardiac events           informed consent.                                       Female                                18 (16.2)                20 (17.7)              0.767

  MSCTA ‫ ؍‬multislice
                           Inclusion criteria. Patients under-                     BMI (kg/m2)                         25.4 Ϯ 3.60              25.9 Ϯ 2.69              0.195
  computed tomography      going primary isolated CABG,                            Hypertension                          63 (56.8)                70 (61.9)              0.429
  angiography              with or without cardiopulmonary                         Diabetes                              45 (40.5)                45 (39.8)              0.913
  SVG ‫ ؍‬saphenous vein     bypass, were eligible for inclusion                     Hyperlipidemia                        44 (39.6)                40 (35.4)              0.512
  graft                    in the study.                                           History of smoking                    66 (59.5)                59 (52.2)              0.275
                                                                                   CHD family history                    16 (14.4)                14 (12.4)              0.656
                           Exclusion criteria. Patients with
                                                                                   Previous PCI                          18 (16.2)                12 (10.6)              0.219
an abnormal quantity of platelets before operation (Ͻ100 ϫ
                                                                                   Previous MI                           49 (44.1)                56 (49.6)              0.417
109/l or Ͼ300 ϫ 109/l); previous CABG or other cardiac                             Previous CVA                           8 (7.2)                  3 (2.7)               0.115
surgery; need for concomitant valve surgery or aneurysm                            Pre-operative LVEF (%)             59.83 Ϯ 7.87             60.64 Ϯ 7.71              0.502
resection; serum creatinine Ͼ130 ␮mol/l; left ventricular                          OPCAB                                 59 (53.2)                72 (63.7)              0.109
ejection fraction Ͻ30% on pre-operative ultrasound; liver
                                                                                 Values are mean Ϯ SD or n (%).
disease; clopidogrel or aspirin intake within 7 days of                             A ϭ aspirin alone; AC ϭ aspirin plus clopidogrel; BMI ϭ body mass index; CHD ϭ coronary heart
operation; need for perioperative warfarin; active gastrodu-                     disease; CVA ϭ cerebrovascular accident; LVEF ϭ left ventricular ejection fraction; MI ϭ myocardial
                                                                                 infarction; OPCAB ϭ off-pump coronary artery bypass grafting; PCI ϭ percutaneous coronary
odenal ulcer or post-operative gastrointestinal bleeding;                        intervention.
profuse post-operative pleural effusion (drainage Ͼ200 ml/h
for 2 h or more); need for secondary thoracotomy to stop                         dynamic support (more than 2 inotropes for more than 24 h
bleeding for cardiac tamponade; postoperative low cardiac                        and/or intra-aortic balloon pump); and clinical instability,
output syndrome or requirement for high levels of hemo-                          such as perioperative myocardial infarction or malignant
                                                                                 tumor, were excluded from the study.
                                                                                 Sample size. According to previous studies, single-aspirin
                                                                                 protocol has a venous graft occlusion rate of 15% 3 months
                                                                                 after surgery. As for dual antiplatelet protocol, the rate is
                                                                                 10%. We found that a 5% difference between 2 arms can be
                                                                                 reliably detected under a power of 80%, if we have 270
                                                                                 venous grafts in each arm (significance level ϭ 0.05).
                                                                                 Surgical procedures. All patients underwent either off-
                                                                                 pump or on-pump CABG, according to surgeon discretion
                                                                                 on the basis of anatomic and clinical findings. Before chest
                                                                                 closure, mean flow values and pulsatile index were obtained
                                                                                 with transit-time flow measurement (Medi-stim Butterfly
                                                                                 flowmeter, Medi-stim AS, Oslo, Norway). If mean flow
                                                                                 values were Ͻ10 ml/min, pulsatile index was Ͼ5.0, or any
                                                                                 possible graft kinking or compression needed to be detected,
                                                                                 the anastomosis was redone. Patients were excluded from
                                                                                 the study if remeasurement results remained unsatisfactory.
                                                                                 Administration of antiplatelet agents. Patients with suc-
                                                                                 cessful CABG surgery were randomly assigned to 2 groups:
                                                                                 group A, receiving aspirin 100 mg daily; group AC, receiv-
                                                                                 ing aspirin 100 mg plus clopidogrel 75 mg daily. Antiplate-
                                                                                 let agents were given orally when clinical stability was
                                                                                 ensured and chest tube output was Ͻ30 ml/h for at least 2 h.
                                                                                 Both antiplatelet therapies should be administered within
                                                                                 48 h. All patients received antiplatelet therapy for 3 months
                                                                                 after operation.
 Figure 1      Flow Chart of the Study
                                                                                 Primary and secondary end point. The primary objective
                                                                                 was to determine the effect of dual antiplatelet therapy on
 Flow chart of the study, including deaths, numbers, and reasons for loss to     the incidence of graft occlusion at 3 months after bypass
 follow-up and numbers contributing to analyses. GroupA ϭ aspirin alone group;
                                                                                 surgery, as assessed by multislice computed tomography
 GroupAC ϭ aspirin plus clopidogrel group; MACE ϭ major adverse cardiac-
 related events; MSCTA ϭ multislice computed tomography angiography.             angiography (MSCTA). A secondary objective was to assess
                                                                                 the effect of treatment on the occurrence of major adverse
                                            Downloaded from content.onlinejacc.org by on March 20, 2012
JACC Vol. 56, No. 20, 2010                                                                                                                              Gao et al.      1641
November 9, 2010:1639–43                                                                                        Aspirin Plus Clopidogrel for Venous Graft Patency


                                                                                                     tomotic site, and main trunk). Both of these latter findings
Graft Characteristics of Patients of Patients
 Table 2    Graft Characteristics
                                                                                                     were considered together and referred to as occlusion in the
                                       Group A               Group AC                                analysis. Discrepancies in patency definition were reviewed
         Parameters                   (n ‫)111 ؍‬              (n ‫)311 ؍‬            p Value            by a third investigator and resolved by consensus.
  Distal anastomosis (n)                416                     427
                                                                                                     Statistical analysis. Clinical baseline characteristics and
    LAD                                 110                     112                  NS
                                                                                                     post-operative outcomes were compared statistically. The
    Diagonal                              56                      61                 NS
                                                                                                     Student t test and chi-square test were used to analyze
    LCx system                          131                     133                  NS
    RCA system                          119                     121                  NS
                                                                                                     continuous and categorical variables, respectively. A non-
    Per person                    3.75 (416/111)          3.78 (427/113)             NS              parametric test was used to compare graft flow and pulsation
  Graft type (n)                        345                     359                                  indexes of the 2 groups. In univariate analyses, means and
    LIMA                                109                     112                  NS              SDs were used for continuous variables, and frequencies and
    RA                                     3                       5                 NS              percentages were used for categorical variables. Multivari-
    SVG                                 233                     242                  NS              able generalized estimating equations analysis was used to
    Sequential bypass                     70                      68                 NS              examine independent risk factors related to vein graft
  Number of grafts (n)                  111                     113                                  patency. In all cases, a p value Ͻ0.05 was considered as
    2                                      6                       5                 NS
                                                                                                     statistically significant. All analyses were performed with
    3                                     87                      83                 NS
                                                                                                     SPSS statistical software version 11.0 (SPSS, Inc., Chicago,
    4                                     18                      25                 NS
    Grafts/patients               3.11 (345/111)          3.18 (359/113)             NS
                                                                                                     Illinois).

A ϭ aspirin alone; AC ϭ aspirin plus clopidogrel; DA ϭ diagonal artery; LAD ϭ left anterior
descending coronary artery; LCx ϭ left circumflex coronary artery; LIMA ϭ left internal mammary       Results
artery; RA ϭ radial artery; RCA ϭ right coronary artery; SVG ϭ saphenous vein graft.

                                                                                                     Two-hundred forty-nine cardiac surgery candidates were
cardiac events (MACE), defined as follows: 1) cardiogenic                                             randomized to group A (n ϭ 125) or group AC (n ϭ 124).
death; 2) myocardial infarction (hospital visit for myocardial                                       Of the 249 participants, 1 (0.4%) (from group A) died at 6
infarction reported by patient or hospital admission for                                             weeks after CABG surgery. Of the remaining 248 patients,
myocardial infarction reported by cardiologist); and 3) the                                          239 (96.4%) completed a 3-month follow-up, and 224
need for revascularization (repeat operation or angioplasty                                          (90.3%) underwent MSCTA. Deaths, numbers and reasons
reported by patient or cardiologist) through 3 months after                                          for loss to follow-up, and numbers contributing to analyses
CABG.                                                                                                are shown in Figure 1. The patient demographic, disease
Graft patency by 64-slice MSCTA. All patients were                                                   entity, and comorbidity data were collected prospectively
scheduled for a systematic MSCTA at 3 months after                                                   and are summarized in Table 1. Participants had character-
                                                                                                     istics at baseline similar to the entire randomized cohort. No
surgery with the 64-slice MSCTA scanner (GE Healthcare,
                                                                                                     significant difference was found between the 2 groups in
Milwaukee, Wisconsin). The images were transferred to a
                                                                                                     terms of MACE. Graft characteristics including number of
stand-alone workstation (Deep Blue, ADW4.3, GE
                                                                                                     distal anastomosis at different sites, number of different graft
Healthcare) and evaluated with dedicated analysis software.
                                                                                                     types, number of grafts and grafts/patients were compared;
The results of MSCTA were independently reviewed by 2                                                no significant difference was found (Table 2). Intraoperative
radiologists blinded to randomized allocation. Each graft                                            transit-time flow measurement findings were also similar in
was classified as patent (flow visible), occluded, or not                                              both groups (Table 3).
analyzable (e.g., because the graft was obscured by a metal                                             At 3-month MSCTA follow-up, patency was studied in
ligature clip or because the image quality was poor). When                                           704 grafts of 224 patients; 11 (1.6%) grafts were deemed
a conduit did not fill with contrast at all, it was considered                                        nondiagnostic by 2 radiologists. Overall, 58 (8.4%) of 693
occluded and was included with string sign found in any                                              grafts were classified as occluded after disagreements were
segment (including proximal anastomotic site, distal anas-                                           reconciled—23 (6.5%) in the AC group versus 35 (10.3%)


Mean Graft Flow and Pulsation Index by Intraoperative TTFM in A and AC in A and AC Groups
 Table 3   Mean Graft Flow and Pulsation Index by Intraoperative TTFM Groups

                                                                              Graft Flow (ml/min)                                          Pulsation Index
                                 Graft Number
                                                               A Group                  AC Group                            A Group              AC Group
                                A             AC           25th, 50th, 75th          25th, 50th, 75th                   25th, 50th, 75th      25th, 50th, 75th
     Graft Position           Group          Group           Percentiles               Percentiles          p Value       Percentiles           Percentiles          p Value
  LIMA: anterior wall           109            112        21, 32, 33.5               18.5, 29, 32.75         0.054         1.7, 2.0, 2.2      1.625, 2.15, 2.375     0.176
  Aorta: anterior wall           26             30        22, 34, 37                 20, 29, 31.75           0.256         1.5, 1.9, 2.2      1.85, 2.0, 2.175       0.261
  Aorta: lateral wall            97            102        30, 39, 49.5               27.75, 39.5, 50         0.573         1.5, 1.9, 2.1      1.6, 1.9, 2.2          0.577
  Aorta: inferior wall          110            110        24, 37.5, 49.25            24, 36.5, 49            0.702         1.4, 2.0, 2.5      1.4, 1.9, 2.125        0.153

TTFM ϭ transit-time flow measurement; other abbreviations as in Tables 1 and 2.

                                                     Downloaded from content.onlinejacc.org by on March 20, 2012
1642          Gao et al.                                                                                                                                  JACC Vol. 56, No. 20, 2010
              Aspirin Plus Clopidogrel for Venous Graft Patency                                                                                          November 9, 2010:1639–43


                           Prevalence of Graft Occlusion in Occlusion in A and AC Groups
                            Table 4    Prevalence of Graft A and AC Groups

                                                        A Group                                    AC Group
                                                                                                                                      Relative Risk
                              Type      Total/Evaluable       Occluded n (%)        Total/Evaluable     Occluded n (%)   p Value        (95% CI)
                             LIMA           109/106                 1 (0.9)              112/110               2 (1.8)   0.583     0.519 (0.048–5.638)
                             RA                3/3                  1 (33.3)                5/4                1 (25)    0.809     1.333 (0.129–13.743)
                             SVG            233/231               33 (14.3)              242/239              20 (8.4)   0.043     1.707 (1.010–2.886)
                             Total          345/340               35 (10.3)              359/353              23 (6.5)   0.073     1.580 (0.954–2.617)

                           CI ϭ confidence interval; other abbreviations as in Tables 1 and 2.



in the A group. Graft patency for SVGs was 91.6% (219                                                Discussion
of 239) in the AC group versus 85.7% (198 of 231) in the
                                                                                                     The primary reason for graft stenosis and occlusion after
A group (relative risk: 1.707; 95% confidence interval:
                                                                                                     CABG is formation of thrombus, which is related to
1.010 to 2.886; p ϭ 0.043) (Table 4). In the multivariate
                                                                                                     anastomotic technique, graft quality, and coagulation
analysis, combined antiplatelet therapy independently
                                                                                                     function in the perioperative period (5). Platelets play a
increased venous graft patency (relative risk: 1.996; 95%
                                                                                                     fundamental role in this process. Even with standard
confidence interval: 1.015 to 3.922; p ϭ 0.045). Other
                                                                                                     aspirin therapy, a significant proportion of patients
strong predictors of higher venous graft patency rate were
                                                                                                     present post-operatively with graft stenosis or occlusion,
larger distal runoff, higher mean graft flow, and lower
                                                                                                     especially with vein material, and seem to be at increased
pulsatile index (Table 5).
                                                                                                     risk for developing adverse vascular events (6). Many
                                                                                                     people are affected by aspirin resistance, defined as unde-
                                                                                                     tectable platelet inhibition after 1 week of therapy (7).
for Venous Graft Patency Analysis of RelativeCABG
Multivariate MultivariateRelative Risk FactorsRisk Factors
             Analysis of at 3 Months After
  Table 5
             for Venous Graft Patency at 3 Months After CABG                                         Clopidogrel is a thienopyridine antiplatelet agent that in-
                                                                                                     hibits adenosine diphosphate-dependent platelet activation
               Risk Factor                   Odds Ratio            95% CI           p Value          and aggregation, unlike aspirin, which mainly selectively
  Sex
                                                                                                     depresses platelet cycloxygenase-1 and interrupts the forma-
    Male                                      Reference
                                                                                                     tion of thromboxane A2. They work on different stages of
    Female                                       0.6          0.187–1.921             0.390
  Hyperlipidemia
                                                                                                     thrombosis, and therefore theoretically the combination of
    Yes                                       Reference                                              aspirin and clopidogrel should lead to superior potent
    No                                           1.096        0.511–2.353             0.814          synergistic antithrombotic effects compared with either
  Diabetes                                                                                           therapy alone (8).
    Yes                                       Reference                                                 The benefit of aspirin plus clopidogrel on the outcome of
    No                                           0.729        0.375–1.418             0.352          CABG has been demonstrated in several trials (3,9,10);
  History of smoking                                                                                 whether the combination of aspirin and clopidogrel is
    Yes                                       Reference
                                                                                                     superior to aspirin alone on graft patency is not yet resolved.
    No                                           1.032        0.420–2.540             0.945
                                                                                                     Our study is the first randomized controlled trial to examine
  Antiplatelet therapy
    Aspirin alone                             Reference
                                                                                                     graft patency as the primary end point, providing definitive
    Aspirin ϩ clopidogrel                        1.996        1.015–3.922             0.045          clinical data on the efficacy of combined antiplatelet therapy
  Anastomotic position of SVG                                                                        on SVG patency. The result of generalized estimating
    RCA                                       Reference                                              equation analysis demonstrates that SVG patency is affected
    LCx                                          1.505        0.683–3.316             0.311          by multiple patient-specific and procedure-specific features,
    LAD                                          0.836        0.293–2.382             0.737          and use of dual antiplatelet therapy is only 1 such factor.
  Sequential anastomosis
                                                                                                     The positive aspect of this study is the exploration of an
    Yes                                       Reference
                                                                                                     ideal antiplatelet protocol that can significantly improve
    No                                           1.092        0.423–2.817             0.856
                                                                                                     venous graft patency.
  CABG procedure
    On-pump                                   Reference
                                                                                                     Study limitations. It is important to remember that the
    Off-pump                                     1.076        0.509–2.275             0.849          current trials were carried out in a single center without
  Age                                            1.026        0.985–1.069             0.213          placebo control, which is the main limitation of this study.
  BMI                                            1.038        0.942–1.143             0.452          In addition to the MSCTA observers, the investigator and
  Mean graft flow                                 1.045        1.005–1.088             0.029          patients were not blinded to the randomized allocation.
  Pulsation index                                0.438        0.309–0.622           Ͻ0.001           However, the objective results of MSCTA would be hardly
  Runoff                                       24.159         3.685–158.395           0.001
                                                                                                     impaired by this shortcoming. Furthermore, we did not
  Proximal stenosis of target vessels            6.104        0.191–195.495           0.306
                                                                                                     evaluate platelet function; consequently, individual variabil-
CABG ϭ coronary artery bypass grafting; other abbreviations as in Tables 1 and 2.                    ity in the antiplatelet therapy was not taken into account. In
                                                       Downloaded from content.onlinejacc.org by on March 20, 2012
JACC Vol. 56, No. 20, 2010                                                                                            Gao et al.         1643
November 9, 2010:1639–43                                                      Aspirin Plus Clopidogrel for Venous Graft Patency


the current study, there was no significant difference be-        REFERENCES

tween the 2 groups on the end points of MACE, most                1. Lingaas PS, Hol PK, Lundblad R, et al. Clinical and angiographic
probably due to our relatively small sample size and short           outcome of coronary surgery with and without cardiopulmonary bypass: a
follow-up period. Longer follow-up and larger sample size            prospective randomized trial. Heart Surg Forum 2004;7:37– 41.
                                                                  2. Pamukcu B. A review of aspirin resistance; definition, possible mech-
might be warranted to reveal the effectiveness of dual               anisms, detection with platelet function tests, and its clinical outcomes.
antiplatelet therapy on the end point of clinical outcome.           J Thromb Thrombolysis 2007;23:213–22.
                                                                  3. Yusuf S, Zhao F, Mehta SR, Chrolavicius S, Tognoni G, Fox KK.
                                                                     Effects of clopidogrel in addition to aspirin in patients with acute
                                                                     coronary syndromes without ST-segment elevation. N Engl J Med
                                                                     2001;345:494 –502.
Conclusions                                                       4. CAPRIE Steering Committee. A randomised, blinded, trial of clopi-
                                                                     dogrel versus aspirin in patients at risk of ischaemic events (CAPRIE).
                                                                     Lancet 1996;348:1329 –39.
This study shows that the combination of aspirin plus             5. Goldman S, Copeland J, Moritz T, et al. Improvement in early
clopidogrel significantly increased venous graft patency at 3         saphenous vein graft patency after coronary artery bypass surgery with
months after CABG compared with aspirin alone. Com-                  antiplatelet therapy: results of a Veterans Administration cooperative
                                                                     study. Circulation 1988;77:1324 –32.
bined antiplatelet therapy, larger runoff, and higher mean        6. Al-Ruzzeh S, George S, Bustami M, et al. Effect of off-pump coronary
graft flow are independently correlated with elevated venous          artery bypass surgery on clinical, angiographic, neurocognitive, and
graft patency, whereas pulsatile index is an independent risk        quality of life outcomes: randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2006;
                                                                     332:1365.
predictor. No significant differences in MACE between the          7. Gum PA, Kottke-Marchant K, Welsh PA, White J, Topol E. A
2 groups were observed.                                              prospective, blinded determination of the natural history of aspirin
                                                                     resistance among stable patients with cardiovascular disease. J Am Coll
                                                                     Cardiol 2003;41:961–5.
                                                                  8. Cadroy Y, Bossavy JP, Thalamas C, Sagnard L, Sakariassen K, Boneu
Acknowledgments                                                      B. Early potent antithrombotic effect with combined aspirin and a
The authors wish to thank Drs. Wei Li, Yang Wang, and                loading dose of clopidogrel on experimental arterial thrombogenesis in
                                                                     humans. Circulation 2000;101:2823– 8.
Xin Yuan from the Biostatistical Unit, Cardiovascular             9. Fox KA, Mehta SR, Peters R, et al. Benefits and risks of the
Institute and Fu Wai Hospital for their assistance on the            combination of clopidogrel and aspirin in patients undergoing surgical
statistics.                                                          revascularization for non-ST-elevation acute coronary syndrome: the
                                                                     Clopidogrel in Unstable angina to prevent Recurrent ischemic Events
                                                                     (CURE) Trial. Circulation 2004;110:1202– 8.
Reprint requests and correspondence: Dr. Shengshou Hu, De-       10. Gurbuz AT, Zia AA, Vuran AC, Cui H, Aytac A. Postoperative
partment of Surgery, Cardiovascular Institute and Fu Wai Hos-        clopidogrel improves mid-term outcome after off-pump coronary
                                                                     artery bypass graft surgery: a prospective study. Eur J Cardiothorac
pital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences & Peking Union            Surg 2006;29:190 –5.
Medical College, 167A Beilishilu, Beijing 100037, The People’s
Republic of China. E-mail: shengshouhu@yahoo.com.                Key Words: antiplatelet therapy y clopidogrel y coronary artery bypass
                                                                 grafting y graft patency y multislice computed tomography angiography.




                                  Downloaded from content.onlinejacc.org by on March 20, 2012
Aspirin Plus Clopidogrel Therapy Increases Early Venous Graft Patency After
 Coronary Artery Bypass Surgery: A Single-Center, Randomized, Controlled
                                    Trial
        Ge Gao, Zhe Zheng, Yi Pi, Bin Lu, Jinguo Lu, and Shengshou Hu
                   J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 2010;56;1639-1643
                        doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2010.03.104
               This information is current as of March 20, 2012

Updated Information              including high-resolution figures, can be found at:
& Services                       http://content.onlinejacc.org/cgi/content/full/56/20/1639
Supplementary Material           Supplementary material can be found at:
                                 http://content.onlinejacc.org/cgi/content/full/56/20/1639/DC1
References                       This article cites 10 articles, 6 of which you can access for free
                                 at:
                                 http://content.onlinejacc.org/cgi/content/full/56/20/1639#BIB
                                 L
Citations                        This article has been cited by 7 HighWire-hosted articles:
                                 http://content.onlinejacc.org/cgi/content/full/56/20/1639#other
                                 articles
Rights & Permissions             Information about reproducing this article in parts (figures,
                                 tables) or in its entirety can be found online at:
                                 http://content.onlinejacc.org/misc/permissions.dtl
Reprints                         Information about ordering reprints can be found online:
                                 http://content.onlinejacc.org/misc/reprints.dtl




                  Downloaded from content.onlinejacc.org by on March 20, 2012

More Related Content

What's hot

Endovenous or surgical treatment of cvi
Endovenous or surgical treatment of cviEndovenous or surgical treatment of cvi
Endovenous or surgical treatment of cvi
uvcd
 
CONTROVERSIES FOR ASIAN PATIENTS
CONTROVERSIES FOR ASIAN PATIENTSCONTROVERSIES FOR ASIAN PATIENTS
CONTROVERSIES FOR ASIAN PATIENTS
SekretariatdrYudiHer
 
Laparoscopic aortic surgery
Laparoscopic aortic  surgeryLaparoscopic aortic  surgery
Laparoscopic aortic surgery
uvcd
 
Eluting balloons, the mechanism of action, indications for use Ivan. G. Horvath
Eluting balloons, the mechanism of action, indications for use Ivan. G. HorvathEluting balloons, the mechanism of action, indications for use Ivan. G. Horvath
Eluting balloons, the mechanism of action, indications for use Ivan. G. Horvath
Chaichuk Sergiy
 
Impact of contralateral carotid or vertebral artery occlusion in patients und...
Impact of contralateral carotid or vertebral artery occlusion in patients und...Impact of contralateral carotid or vertebral artery occlusion in patients und...
Impact of contralateral carotid or vertebral artery occlusion in patients und...
uvcd
 
Strive Teleconf Presentation Sept13 2006
Strive Teleconf Presentation Sept13 2006Strive Teleconf Presentation Sept13 2006
Strive Teleconf Presentation Sept13 2006MedicineAndHealthCancer
 
Fernando alfonso isr sec-2015
Fernando alfonso isr sec-2015Fernando alfonso isr sec-2015
Wyniki leczenia przezskónego asd - prof. Jacek Białkowski
Wyniki leczenia przezskónego asd - prof. Jacek BiałkowskiWyniki leczenia przezskónego asd - prof. Jacek Białkowski
Wyniki leczenia przezskónego asd - prof. Jacek Białkowskipiodof
 
Лечение пациентов с поражением ствола ЛКА, преимущества коронарной хирургии. ...
Лечение пациентов с поражением ствола ЛКА, преимущества коронарной хирургии. ...Лечение пациентов с поражением ствола ЛКА, преимущества коронарной хирургии. ...
Лечение пациентов с поражением ствола ЛКА, преимущества коронарной хирургии. ...
Chaichuk Sergiy
 
Novel paclitaxel coated balloon - dr Piotr Buszman
Novel paclitaxel coated balloon - dr Piotr BuszmanNovel paclitaxel coated balloon - dr Piotr Buszman
Novel paclitaxel coated balloon - dr Piotr Buszmanpiodof
 
Jose r lopez minguez novedades cierre laa
Jose r lopez minguez novedades cierre laaJose r lopez minguez novedades cierre laa
Jose r lopez minguez novedades cierre laa
SHCI - Sección de Hemodinámica y Cardiología Intervencionista
 
Manejo de la antiagregación ajustada a las pruebas de reactividad plaquetaria...
Manejo de la antiagregación ajustada a las pruebas de reactividad plaquetaria...Manejo de la antiagregación ajustada a las pruebas de reactividad plaquetaria...
Manejo de la antiagregación ajustada a las pruebas de reactividad plaquetaria...
SHCI - Sección de Hemodinámica y Cardiología Intervencionista
 
International Journal of Orthopedics: Research & Therapy
International Journal of Orthopedics: Research & TherapyInternational Journal of Orthopedics: Research & Therapy
International Journal of Orthopedics: Research & Therapy
SciRes Literature LLC. | Open Access Journals
 
Структура «Реперфузионной Сети» Чешской Республики. Первичное стентирование д...
Структура «Реперфузионной Сети» Чешской Республики. Первичное стентирование д...Структура «Реперфузионной Сети» Чешской Республики. Первичное стентирование д...
Структура «Реперфузионной Сети» Чешской Республики. Первичное стентирование д...
Chaichuk Sergiy
 
Koutouzis M - AIMRADIAL 2015 - Transradial and negative Allen test
Koutouzis M - AIMRADIAL 2015 - Transradial and negative Allen testKoutouzis M - AIMRADIAL 2015 - Transradial and negative Allen test
Koutouzis M - AIMRADIAL 2015 - Transradial and negative Allen test
International Chair on Interventional Cardiology and Transradial Approach
 
IFR - Instantenous wave free ratio
IFR - Instantenous wave free ratioIFR - Instantenous wave free ratio
IFR - Instantenous wave free ratio
Vishal Vanani
 
Seguimiento de pacientes con FA y SCA tras intervención coronaria percutánea....
Seguimiento de pacientes con FA y SCA tras intervención coronaria percutánea....Seguimiento de pacientes con FA y SCA tras intervención coronaria percutánea....
Seguimiento de pacientes con FA y SCA tras intervención coronaria percutánea....
Sociedad Española de Cardiología
 

What's hot (20)

Endovenous or surgical treatment of cvi
Endovenous or surgical treatment of cviEndovenous or surgical treatment of cvi
Endovenous or surgical treatment of cvi
 
CONTROVERSIES FOR ASIAN PATIENTS
CONTROVERSIES FOR ASIAN PATIENTSCONTROVERSIES FOR ASIAN PATIENTS
CONTROVERSIES FOR ASIAN PATIENTS
 
Laparoscopic aortic surgery
Laparoscopic aortic  surgeryLaparoscopic aortic  surgery
Laparoscopic aortic surgery
 
Eluting balloons, the mechanism of action, indications for use Ivan. G. Horvath
Eluting balloons, the mechanism of action, indications for use Ivan. G. HorvathEluting balloons, the mechanism of action, indications for use Ivan. G. Horvath
Eluting balloons, the mechanism of action, indications for use Ivan. G. Horvath
 
Impact of contralateral carotid or vertebral artery occlusion in patients und...
Impact of contralateral carotid or vertebral artery occlusion in patients und...Impact of contralateral carotid or vertebral artery occlusion in patients und...
Impact of contralateral carotid or vertebral artery occlusion in patients und...
 
Strive Teleconf Presentation Sept13 2006
Strive Teleconf Presentation Sept13 2006Strive Teleconf Presentation Sept13 2006
Strive Teleconf Presentation Sept13 2006
 
The PulmoN
The PulmoNThe PulmoN
The PulmoN
 
Fernando alfonso isr sec-2015
Fernando alfonso isr sec-2015Fernando alfonso isr sec-2015
Fernando alfonso isr sec-2015
 
Wyniki leczenia przezskónego asd - prof. Jacek Białkowski
Wyniki leczenia przezskónego asd - prof. Jacek BiałkowskiWyniki leczenia przezskónego asd - prof. Jacek Białkowski
Wyniki leczenia przezskónego asd - prof. Jacek Białkowski
 
Лечение пациентов с поражением ствола ЛКА, преимущества коронарной хирургии. ...
Лечение пациентов с поражением ствола ЛКА, преимущества коронарной хирургии. ...Лечение пациентов с поражением ствола ЛКА, преимущества коронарной хирургии. ...
Лечение пациентов с поражением ствола ЛКА, преимущества коронарной хирургии. ...
 
Novel paclitaxel coated balloon - dr Piotr Buszman
Novel paclitaxel coated balloon - dr Piotr BuszmanNovel paclitaxel coated balloon - dr Piotr Buszman
Novel paclitaxel coated balloon - dr Piotr Buszman
 
Jose r lopez minguez novedades cierre laa
Jose r lopez minguez novedades cierre laaJose r lopez minguez novedades cierre laa
Jose r lopez minguez novedades cierre laa
 
Manejo de la antiagregación ajustada a las pruebas de reactividad plaquetaria...
Manejo de la antiagregación ajustada a las pruebas de reactividad plaquetaria...Manejo de la antiagregación ajustada a las pruebas de reactividad plaquetaria...
Manejo de la antiagregación ajustada a las pruebas de reactividad plaquetaria...
 
International Journal of Orthopedics: Research & Therapy
International Journal of Orthopedics: Research & TherapyInternational Journal of Orthopedics: Research & Therapy
International Journal of Orthopedics: Research & Therapy
 
Hahalis G - AIMRADIAL 2013 - Ulnar catheterization
Hahalis G - AIMRADIAL 2013 - Ulnar catheterizationHahalis G - AIMRADIAL 2013 - Ulnar catheterization
Hahalis G - AIMRADIAL 2013 - Ulnar catheterization
 
Структура «Реперфузионной Сети» Чешской Республики. Первичное стентирование д...
Структура «Реперфузионной Сети» Чешской Республики. Первичное стентирование д...Структура «Реперфузионной Сети» Чешской Республики. Первичное стентирование д...
Структура «Реперфузионной Сети» Чешской Республики. Первичное стентирование д...
 
Koutouzis M - AIMRADIAL 2015 - Transradial and negative Allen test
Koutouzis M - AIMRADIAL 2015 - Transradial and negative Allen testKoutouzis M - AIMRADIAL 2015 - Transradial and negative Allen test
Koutouzis M - AIMRADIAL 2015 - Transradial and negative Allen test
 
IFR - Instantenous wave free ratio
IFR - Instantenous wave free ratioIFR - Instantenous wave free ratio
IFR - Instantenous wave free ratio
 
Sgarboza
SgarbozaSgarboza
Sgarboza
 
Seguimiento de pacientes con FA y SCA tras intervención coronaria percutánea....
Seguimiento de pacientes con FA y SCA tras intervención coronaria percutánea....Seguimiento de pacientes con FA y SCA tras intervención coronaria percutánea....
Seguimiento de pacientes con FA y SCA tras intervención coronaria percutánea....
 

Similar to Aspirin and plavix

Scientific news march 2015 samir rafla
Scientific news march 2015 samir raflaScientific news march 2015 samir rafla
Scientific news march 2015 samir rafla
Alexandria University, Egypt
 
Left main disease pci vs cabg excel trial 2016
Left main disease   pci vs cabg excel trial 2016Left main disease   pci vs cabg excel trial 2016
Left main disease pci vs cabg excel trial 2016
Kunal Mahajan
 
Crest
CrestCrest
Crest
skbram
 
Triple therapy in acs
Triple therapy in acsTriple therapy in acs
Triple therapy in acs
amitsingh6990
 
Carotid stenosis journal club
Carotid stenosis journal clubCarotid stenosis journal club
Carotid stenosis journal club
NeurologyKota
 
The effects of_rosuvastatin_on_plaque_regression_i
The effects of_rosuvastatin_on_plaque_regression_iThe effects of_rosuvastatin_on_plaque_regression_i
The effects of_rosuvastatin_on_plaque_regression_i
19844
 
Antegrage cerebral perfusion
Antegrage cerebral perfusionAntegrage cerebral perfusion
Antegrage cerebral perfusion
mshihatasite
 
ACC 2011 research highlights: A slideshow presentation
ACC 2011 research highlights: A slideshow presentation ACC 2011 research highlights: A slideshow presentation
ACC 2011 research highlights: A slideshow presentation
theheart.org
 
Jic 2-174
Jic 2-174Jic 2-174
6 anatomy.pdf
6 anatomy.pdf6 anatomy.pdf
6 anatomy.pdf
Prabakaran Palanisamy
 
A technical modification of carotid endarterectomy experience with 400 pati...
A technical modification of carotid endarterectomy   experience with 400 pati...A technical modification of carotid endarterectomy   experience with 400 pati...
A technical modification of carotid endarterectomy experience with 400 pati...
uvcd
 
SYNTAX Score in Patients With Diabetes Undergoing Coronary Revascularization ...
SYNTAX Score in Patients With Diabetes Undergoing Coronary Revascularization ...SYNTAX Score in Patients With Diabetes Undergoing Coronary Revascularization ...
SYNTAX Score in Patients With Diabetes Undergoing Coronary Revascularization ...
vaibhavyawalkar
 
KOSCON_PAPER_final_pppppppppppppppot.pptx
KOSCON_PAPER_final_pppppppppppppppot.pptxKOSCON_PAPER_final_pppppppppppppppot.pptx
KOSCON_PAPER_final_pppppppppppppppot.pptx
Madhuri521470
 
Thromboectomy trial
Thromboectomy trialThromboectomy trial
Bypass graft intervention2
Bypass graft intervention2Bypass graft intervention2
Bypass graft intervention2
Dr Virbhan Balai
 
Femoropopliteal bypass for revascularization of chronic ischemia of lower lim...
Femoropopliteal bypass for revascularization of chronic ischemia of lower lim...Femoropopliteal bypass for revascularization of chronic ischemia of lower lim...
Femoropopliteal bypass for revascularization of chronic ischemia of lower lim...
Abdulsalam Taha
 
Journal Reading 2.pptx
Journal Reading 2.pptxJournal Reading 2.pptx
Journal Reading 2.pptx
nadiashabri2
 
Dissolution trial
Dissolution trialDissolution trial
Dissolution trial
Vishwanath Hesarur
 

Similar to Aspirin and plavix (20)

Scientific news march 2015 samir rafla
Scientific news march 2015 samir raflaScientific news march 2015 samir rafla
Scientific news march 2015 samir rafla
 
Left main disease pci vs cabg excel trial 2016
Left main disease   pci vs cabg excel trial 2016Left main disease   pci vs cabg excel trial 2016
Left main disease pci vs cabg excel trial 2016
 
Crest
CrestCrest
Crest
 
Triple therapy in acs
Triple therapy in acsTriple therapy in acs
Triple therapy in acs
 
Carotid stenosis journal club
Carotid stenosis journal clubCarotid stenosis journal club
Carotid stenosis journal club
 
The effects of_rosuvastatin_on_plaque_regression_i
The effects of_rosuvastatin_on_plaque_regression_iThe effects of_rosuvastatin_on_plaque_regression_i
The effects of_rosuvastatin_on_plaque_regression_i
 
Antegrage cerebral perfusion
Antegrage cerebral perfusionAntegrage cerebral perfusion
Antegrage cerebral perfusion
 
ACC 2011 research highlights: A slideshow presentation
ACC 2011 research highlights: A slideshow presentation ACC 2011 research highlights: A slideshow presentation
ACC 2011 research highlights: A slideshow presentation
 
Jic 2-174
Jic 2-174Jic 2-174
Jic 2-174
 
6 anatomy.pdf
6 anatomy.pdf6 anatomy.pdf
6 anatomy.pdf
 
A technical modification of carotid endarterectomy experience with 400 pati...
A technical modification of carotid endarterectomy   experience with 400 pati...A technical modification of carotid endarterectomy   experience with 400 pati...
A technical modification of carotid endarterectomy experience with 400 pati...
 
Tratamento IAo e IM - JACC
Tratamento IAo e IM -  JACCTratamento IAo e IM -  JACC
Tratamento IAo e IM - JACC
 
SYNTAX Score in Patients With Diabetes Undergoing Coronary Revascularization ...
SYNTAX Score in Patients With Diabetes Undergoing Coronary Revascularization ...SYNTAX Score in Patients With Diabetes Undergoing Coronary Revascularization ...
SYNTAX Score in Patients With Diabetes Undergoing Coronary Revascularization ...
 
Caprie
CaprieCaprie
Caprie
 
KOSCON_PAPER_final_pppppppppppppppot.pptx
KOSCON_PAPER_final_pppppppppppppppot.pptxKOSCON_PAPER_final_pppppppppppppppot.pptx
KOSCON_PAPER_final_pppppppppppppppot.pptx
 
Thromboectomy trial
Thromboectomy trialThromboectomy trial
Thromboectomy trial
 
Bypass graft intervention2
Bypass graft intervention2Bypass graft intervention2
Bypass graft intervention2
 
Femoropopliteal bypass for revascularization of chronic ischemia of lower lim...
Femoropopliteal bypass for revascularization of chronic ischemia of lower lim...Femoropopliteal bypass for revascularization of chronic ischemia of lower lim...
Femoropopliteal bypass for revascularization of chronic ischemia of lower lim...
 
Journal Reading 2.pptx
Journal Reading 2.pptxJournal Reading 2.pptx
Journal Reading 2.pptx
 
Dissolution trial
Dissolution trialDissolution trial
Dissolution trial
 

Aspirin and plavix

  • 1. Aspirin Plus Clopidogrel Therapy Increases Early Venous Graft Patency After Coronary Artery Bypass Surgery: A Single-Center, Randomized, Controlled Trial Ge Gao, Zhe Zheng, Yi Pi, Bin Lu, Jinguo Lu, and Shengshou Hu J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 2010;56;1639-1643 doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2010.03.104 This information is current as of March 20, 2012 The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is located on the World Wide Web at: http://content.onlinejacc.org/cgi/content/full/56/20/1639 Downloaded from content.onlinejacc.org by on March 20, 2012
  • 2. Journal of the American College of Cardiology Vol. 56, No. 20, 2010 © 2010 by the American College of Cardiology Foundation ISSN 0735-1097/$36.00 Published by Elsevier Inc. doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2010.03.104 Aspirin Plus Clopidogrel Therapy Increases Early Venous Graft Patency After Coronary Artery Bypass Surgery A Single-Center, Randomized, Controlled Trial Ge Gao, MD,* Zhe Zheng, MD,* Yi Pi, MD,* Bin Lu, MD,† Jinguo Lu, MD,† Shengshou Hu, MD* Beijing, The People’s Republic of China Objectives We sought to evaluate the effect of aspirin plus clopidogrel versus aspirin alone on saphenous vein graft occlu- sion at 3 months after coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG). Background Prevalence of graft occlusion is high after CABG. Aggressive antiplatelet therapy is expected to improve early post-operative graft patency. Methods From December 2007 through December 2008, 249 consecutive patients undergoing elective CABG at Fuwai Hospital were randomly assigned to 2 groups: 124 received aspirin (100 mg) plus clopidogrel (75 mg) daily (AC group), and 125 received aspirin (100 mg) alone daily (A group). Antiplatelet therapies were initiated when post- operative chest tube drainage was Յ30 cc/h for 2 h. All participants were invited for clinical follow-up and 64- slice multislice computed tomography angiography (MSCTA) analysis at 3 months post-operatively. Generalized estimating equations analysis was used to determine predictors of graft patency. Results One participant, from group A, died before 3-month follow-up. Of the remaining 248 patients, 224 (90.3%) un- derwent MSCTA. Participants had similar pre-operative and intraoperative characteristics at baseline. No signifi- cant differences were observed in intraoperative transit-time flow measurement findings or major adverse cardiac-related events. Three-month MSCTA follow-up revealed that saphenous vein graft patency was 91.6% (219 of 239) in the AC group versus 85.7% (198 of 231) in the A group (p ϭ 0.043). In multivariate analysis, combined antiplatelet therapy independently increased venous graft patency (p ϭ 0.045). Conclusions Aspirin plus clopidogrel is more effective in venous graft patency than aspirin alone in the short term after CABG, but further, long-term study is needed. (The Clopidogrel and Aspirin After Surgery for Coronary Artery Disease; NCT00776477) (J Am Coll Cardiol 2010;56:1639–43) © 2010 by the American College of Cardi- ology Foundation There is a high prevalence of venous graft closure within 3 Clopidogrel is a promising antiplatelet agent; its clinical months after coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) sur- efficacy at reducing ischemic events and mortality in patients gery (1). The main mechanism at this stage is graft with coronary and vascular disease has been demonstrated in thrombosis, which sets the stage for graft stenosis and several large clinical trials (3,4). To date, however, no trial occlusion. Despite its established comprehensive clinical use has prospectively evaluated the synergistic effects of aspirin and benefit in patients with coronary heart disease, aspirin plus clopidogrel on saphenous vein graft (SVG) disease after therapy has limitations, including failure to arouse a com- CABG. Therefore, we conducted a randomized controlled plete antiplatelet response in 5% to 10% of patients (2). trial comparing aspirin plus clopidogrel with aspirin alone in CABG patients revascularized with at least 1 saphenous vein. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of combined From the *Department of Surgery, Cardiovascular Institute and Fu Wai Hospital, antiplatelet therapy 3 months after CABG on SVG patency Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences & Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, The People’s Republic of China; and the †Center of Imageology, Cardiovascular Institute and and also the major adverse cardiac-related events. Fu Wai Hospital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences & Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, The People’s Republic of China. This study was supported by the Key Methods Project in the National Science & Technology Pillar Program during the 11th 5-Year Plan Period (2006BAI01A09). The authors have reported that they have no relationships Patients. The study was a prospective randomized con- to disclose. The first 3 authors contributed equally to this work. Manuscript received November 9, 2009; revised manuscript received February 22, trolled trial. All patients referred for isolated surgical coronary 2010, accepted March 18, 2010. revascularization from December 2007 to December 2008 Downloaded from content.onlinejacc.org by on March 20, 2012
  • 3. 1640 Gao et al. JACC Vol. 56, No. 20, 2010 Aspirin Plus Clopidogrel for Venous Graft Patency November 9, 2010:1639–43 Abbreviations with at least 1 SVG at Fuwai of the A and Pre-Operative Pre-OperativeAC Groups Clinical Characteristics Clinical Characteristics and Acronyms Hospital were screened accord- Table 1 of the A and AC Groups ing to the inclusion criteria. This CABG ‫ ؍‬coronary artery A Group AC Group bypass grafting study was approved by the local Characteristic (n ‫)111 ؍‬ (n ‫)311 ؍‬ p Value MACE ‫ ؍‬major adverse ethical committee with patient Age (yrs) 59.8 Ϯ 7.92 57.9 Ϯ 8.25 0.096 cardiac events informed consent. Female 18 (16.2) 20 (17.7) 0.767 MSCTA ‫ ؍‬multislice Inclusion criteria. Patients under- BMI (kg/m2) 25.4 Ϯ 3.60 25.9 Ϯ 2.69 0.195 computed tomography going primary isolated CABG, Hypertension 63 (56.8) 70 (61.9) 0.429 angiography with or without cardiopulmonary Diabetes 45 (40.5) 45 (39.8) 0.913 SVG ‫ ؍‬saphenous vein bypass, were eligible for inclusion Hyperlipidemia 44 (39.6) 40 (35.4) 0.512 graft in the study. History of smoking 66 (59.5) 59 (52.2) 0.275 CHD family history 16 (14.4) 14 (12.4) 0.656 Exclusion criteria. Patients with Previous PCI 18 (16.2) 12 (10.6) 0.219 an abnormal quantity of platelets before operation (Ͻ100 ϫ Previous MI 49 (44.1) 56 (49.6) 0.417 109/l or Ͼ300 ϫ 109/l); previous CABG or other cardiac Previous CVA 8 (7.2) 3 (2.7) 0.115 surgery; need for concomitant valve surgery or aneurysm Pre-operative LVEF (%) 59.83 Ϯ 7.87 60.64 Ϯ 7.71 0.502 resection; serum creatinine Ͼ130 ␮mol/l; left ventricular OPCAB 59 (53.2) 72 (63.7) 0.109 ejection fraction Ͻ30% on pre-operative ultrasound; liver Values are mean Ϯ SD or n (%). disease; clopidogrel or aspirin intake within 7 days of A ϭ aspirin alone; AC ϭ aspirin plus clopidogrel; BMI ϭ body mass index; CHD ϭ coronary heart operation; need for perioperative warfarin; active gastrodu- disease; CVA ϭ cerebrovascular accident; LVEF ϭ left ventricular ejection fraction; MI ϭ myocardial infarction; OPCAB ϭ off-pump coronary artery bypass grafting; PCI ϭ percutaneous coronary odenal ulcer or post-operative gastrointestinal bleeding; intervention. profuse post-operative pleural effusion (drainage Ͼ200 ml/h for 2 h or more); need for secondary thoracotomy to stop dynamic support (more than 2 inotropes for more than 24 h bleeding for cardiac tamponade; postoperative low cardiac and/or intra-aortic balloon pump); and clinical instability, output syndrome or requirement for high levels of hemo- such as perioperative myocardial infarction or malignant tumor, were excluded from the study. Sample size. According to previous studies, single-aspirin protocol has a venous graft occlusion rate of 15% 3 months after surgery. As for dual antiplatelet protocol, the rate is 10%. We found that a 5% difference between 2 arms can be reliably detected under a power of 80%, if we have 270 venous grafts in each arm (significance level ϭ 0.05). Surgical procedures. All patients underwent either off- pump or on-pump CABG, according to surgeon discretion on the basis of anatomic and clinical findings. Before chest closure, mean flow values and pulsatile index were obtained with transit-time flow measurement (Medi-stim Butterfly flowmeter, Medi-stim AS, Oslo, Norway). If mean flow values were Ͻ10 ml/min, pulsatile index was Ͼ5.0, or any possible graft kinking or compression needed to be detected, the anastomosis was redone. Patients were excluded from the study if remeasurement results remained unsatisfactory. Administration of antiplatelet agents. Patients with suc- cessful CABG surgery were randomly assigned to 2 groups: group A, receiving aspirin 100 mg daily; group AC, receiv- ing aspirin 100 mg plus clopidogrel 75 mg daily. Antiplate- let agents were given orally when clinical stability was ensured and chest tube output was Ͻ30 ml/h for at least 2 h. Both antiplatelet therapies should be administered within 48 h. All patients received antiplatelet therapy for 3 months after operation. Figure 1 Flow Chart of the Study Primary and secondary end point. The primary objective was to determine the effect of dual antiplatelet therapy on Flow chart of the study, including deaths, numbers, and reasons for loss to the incidence of graft occlusion at 3 months after bypass follow-up and numbers contributing to analyses. GroupA ϭ aspirin alone group; surgery, as assessed by multislice computed tomography GroupAC ϭ aspirin plus clopidogrel group; MACE ϭ major adverse cardiac- related events; MSCTA ϭ multislice computed tomography angiography. angiography (MSCTA). A secondary objective was to assess the effect of treatment on the occurrence of major adverse Downloaded from content.onlinejacc.org by on March 20, 2012
  • 4. JACC Vol. 56, No. 20, 2010 Gao et al. 1641 November 9, 2010:1639–43 Aspirin Plus Clopidogrel for Venous Graft Patency tomotic site, and main trunk). Both of these latter findings Graft Characteristics of Patients of Patients Table 2 Graft Characteristics were considered together and referred to as occlusion in the Group A Group AC analysis. Discrepancies in patency definition were reviewed Parameters (n ‫)111 ؍‬ (n ‫)311 ؍‬ p Value by a third investigator and resolved by consensus. Distal anastomosis (n) 416 427 Statistical analysis. Clinical baseline characteristics and LAD 110 112 NS post-operative outcomes were compared statistically. The Diagonal 56 61 NS Student t test and chi-square test were used to analyze LCx system 131 133 NS RCA system 119 121 NS continuous and categorical variables, respectively. A non- Per person 3.75 (416/111) 3.78 (427/113) NS parametric test was used to compare graft flow and pulsation Graft type (n) 345 359 indexes of the 2 groups. In univariate analyses, means and LIMA 109 112 NS SDs were used for continuous variables, and frequencies and RA 3 5 NS percentages were used for categorical variables. Multivari- SVG 233 242 NS able generalized estimating equations analysis was used to Sequential bypass 70 68 NS examine independent risk factors related to vein graft Number of grafts (n) 111 113 patency. In all cases, a p value Ͻ0.05 was considered as 2 6 5 NS statistically significant. All analyses were performed with 3 87 83 NS SPSS statistical software version 11.0 (SPSS, Inc., Chicago, 4 18 25 NS Grafts/patients 3.11 (345/111) 3.18 (359/113) NS Illinois). A ϭ aspirin alone; AC ϭ aspirin plus clopidogrel; DA ϭ diagonal artery; LAD ϭ left anterior descending coronary artery; LCx ϭ left circumflex coronary artery; LIMA ϭ left internal mammary Results artery; RA ϭ radial artery; RCA ϭ right coronary artery; SVG ϭ saphenous vein graft. Two-hundred forty-nine cardiac surgery candidates were cardiac events (MACE), defined as follows: 1) cardiogenic randomized to group A (n ϭ 125) or group AC (n ϭ 124). death; 2) myocardial infarction (hospital visit for myocardial Of the 249 participants, 1 (0.4%) (from group A) died at 6 infarction reported by patient or hospital admission for weeks after CABG surgery. Of the remaining 248 patients, myocardial infarction reported by cardiologist); and 3) the 239 (96.4%) completed a 3-month follow-up, and 224 need for revascularization (repeat operation or angioplasty (90.3%) underwent MSCTA. Deaths, numbers and reasons reported by patient or cardiologist) through 3 months after for loss to follow-up, and numbers contributing to analyses CABG. are shown in Figure 1. The patient demographic, disease Graft patency by 64-slice MSCTA. All patients were entity, and comorbidity data were collected prospectively scheduled for a systematic MSCTA at 3 months after and are summarized in Table 1. Participants had character- istics at baseline similar to the entire randomized cohort. No surgery with the 64-slice MSCTA scanner (GE Healthcare, significant difference was found between the 2 groups in Milwaukee, Wisconsin). The images were transferred to a terms of MACE. Graft characteristics including number of stand-alone workstation (Deep Blue, ADW4.3, GE distal anastomosis at different sites, number of different graft Healthcare) and evaluated with dedicated analysis software. types, number of grafts and grafts/patients were compared; The results of MSCTA were independently reviewed by 2 no significant difference was found (Table 2). Intraoperative radiologists blinded to randomized allocation. Each graft transit-time flow measurement findings were also similar in was classified as patent (flow visible), occluded, or not both groups (Table 3). analyzable (e.g., because the graft was obscured by a metal At 3-month MSCTA follow-up, patency was studied in ligature clip or because the image quality was poor). When 704 grafts of 224 patients; 11 (1.6%) grafts were deemed a conduit did not fill with contrast at all, it was considered nondiagnostic by 2 radiologists. Overall, 58 (8.4%) of 693 occluded and was included with string sign found in any grafts were classified as occluded after disagreements were segment (including proximal anastomotic site, distal anas- reconciled—23 (6.5%) in the AC group versus 35 (10.3%) Mean Graft Flow and Pulsation Index by Intraoperative TTFM in A and AC in A and AC Groups Table 3 Mean Graft Flow and Pulsation Index by Intraoperative TTFM Groups Graft Flow (ml/min) Pulsation Index Graft Number A Group AC Group A Group AC Group A AC 25th, 50th, 75th 25th, 50th, 75th 25th, 50th, 75th 25th, 50th, 75th Graft Position Group Group Percentiles Percentiles p Value Percentiles Percentiles p Value LIMA: anterior wall 109 112 21, 32, 33.5 18.5, 29, 32.75 0.054 1.7, 2.0, 2.2 1.625, 2.15, 2.375 0.176 Aorta: anterior wall 26 30 22, 34, 37 20, 29, 31.75 0.256 1.5, 1.9, 2.2 1.85, 2.0, 2.175 0.261 Aorta: lateral wall 97 102 30, 39, 49.5 27.75, 39.5, 50 0.573 1.5, 1.9, 2.1 1.6, 1.9, 2.2 0.577 Aorta: inferior wall 110 110 24, 37.5, 49.25 24, 36.5, 49 0.702 1.4, 2.0, 2.5 1.4, 1.9, 2.125 0.153 TTFM ϭ transit-time flow measurement; other abbreviations as in Tables 1 and 2. Downloaded from content.onlinejacc.org by on March 20, 2012
  • 5. 1642 Gao et al. JACC Vol. 56, No. 20, 2010 Aspirin Plus Clopidogrel for Venous Graft Patency November 9, 2010:1639–43 Prevalence of Graft Occlusion in Occlusion in A and AC Groups Table 4 Prevalence of Graft A and AC Groups A Group AC Group Relative Risk Type Total/Evaluable Occluded n (%) Total/Evaluable Occluded n (%) p Value (95% CI) LIMA 109/106 1 (0.9) 112/110 2 (1.8) 0.583 0.519 (0.048–5.638) RA 3/3 1 (33.3) 5/4 1 (25) 0.809 1.333 (0.129–13.743) SVG 233/231 33 (14.3) 242/239 20 (8.4) 0.043 1.707 (1.010–2.886) Total 345/340 35 (10.3) 359/353 23 (6.5) 0.073 1.580 (0.954–2.617) CI ϭ confidence interval; other abbreviations as in Tables 1 and 2. in the A group. Graft patency for SVGs was 91.6% (219 Discussion of 239) in the AC group versus 85.7% (198 of 231) in the The primary reason for graft stenosis and occlusion after A group (relative risk: 1.707; 95% confidence interval: CABG is formation of thrombus, which is related to 1.010 to 2.886; p ϭ 0.043) (Table 4). In the multivariate anastomotic technique, graft quality, and coagulation analysis, combined antiplatelet therapy independently function in the perioperative period (5). Platelets play a increased venous graft patency (relative risk: 1.996; 95% fundamental role in this process. Even with standard confidence interval: 1.015 to 3.922; p ϭ 0.045). Other aspirin therapy, a significant proportion of patients strong predictors of higher venous graft patency rate were present post-operatively with graft stenosis or occlusion, larger distal runoff, higher mean graft flow, and lower especially with vein material, and seem to be at increased pulsatile index (Table 5). risk for developing adverse vascular events (6). Many people are affected by aspirin resistance, defined as unde- tectable platelet inhibition after 1 week of therapy (7). for Venous Graft Patency Analysis of RelativeCABG Multivariate MultivariateRelative Risk FactorsRisk Factors Analysis of at 3 Months After Table 5 for Venous Graft Patency at 3 Months After CABG Clopidogrel is a thienopyridine antiplatelet agent that in- hibits adenosine diphosphate-dependent platelet activation Risk Factor Odds Ratio 95% CI p Value and aggregation, unlike aspirin, which mainly selectively Sex depresses platelet cycloxygenase-1 and interrupts the forma- Male Reference tion of thromboxane A2. They work on different stages of Female 0.6 0.187–1.921 0.390 Hyperlipidemia thrombosis, and therefore theoretically the combination of Yes Reference aspirin and clopidogrel should lead to superior potent No 1.096 0.511–2.353 0.814 synergistic antithrombotic effects compared with either Diabetes therapy alone (8). Yes Reference The benefit of aspirin plus clopidogrel on the outcome of No 0.729 0.375–1.418 0.352 CABG has been demonstrated in several trials (3,9,10); History of smoking whether the combination of aspirin and clopidogrel is Yes Reference superior to aspirin alone on graft patency is not yet resolved. No 1.032 0.420–2.540 0.945 Our study is the first randomized controlled trial to examine Antiplatelet therapy Aspirin alone Reference graft patency as the primary end point, providing definitive Aspirin ϩ clopidogrel 1.996 1.015–3.922 0.045 clinical data on the efficacy of combined antiplatelet therapy Anastomotic position of SVG on SVG patency. The result of generalized estimating RCA Reference equation analysis demonstrates that SVG patency is affected LCx 1.505 0.683–3.316 0.311 by multiple patient-specific and procedure-specific features, LAD 0.836 0.293–2.382 0.737 and use of dual antiplatelet therapy is only 1 such factor. Sequential anastomosis The positive aspect of this study is the exploration of an Yes Reference ideal antiplatelet protocol that can significantly improve No 1.092 0.423–2.817 0.856 venous graft patency. CABG procedure On-pump Reference Study limitations. It is important to remember that the Off-pump 1.076 0.509–2.275 0.849 current trials were carried out in a single center without Age 1.026 0.985–1.069 0.213 placebo control, which is the main limitation of this study. BMI 1.038 0.942–1.143 0.452 In addition to the MSCTA observers, the investigator and Mean graft flow 1.045 1.005–1.088 0.029 patients were not blinded to the randomized allocation. Pulsation index 0.438 0.309–0.622 Ͻ0.001 However, the objective results of MSCTA would be hardly Runoff 24.159 3.685–158.395 0.001 impaired by this shortcoming. Furthermore, we did not Proximal stenosis of target vessels 6.104 0.191–195.495 0.306 evaluate platelet function; consequently, individual variabil- CABG ϭ coronary artery bypass grafting; other abbreviations as in Tables 1 and 2. ity in the antiplatelet therapy was not taken into account. In Downloaded from content.onlinejacc.org by on March 20, 2012
  • 6. JACC Vol. 56, No. 20, 2010 Gao et al. 1643 November 9, 2010:1639–43 Aspirin Plus Clopidogrel for Venous Graft Patency the current study, there was no significant difference be- REFERENCES tween the 2 groups on the end points of MACE, most 1. Lingaas PS, Hol PK, Lundblad R, et al. Clinical and angiographic probably due to our relatively small sample size and short outcome of coronary surgery with and without cardiopulmonary bypass: a follow-up period. Longer follow-up and larger sample size prospective randomized trial. Heart Surg Forum 2004;7:37– 41. 2. Pamukcu B. A review of aspirin resistance; definition, possible mech- might be warranted to reveal the effectiveness of dual anisms, detection with platelet function tests, and its clinical outcomes. antiplatelet therapy on the end point of clinical outcome. J Thromb Thrombolysis 2007;23:213–22. 3. Yusuf S, Zhao F, Mehta SR, Chrolavicius S, Tognoni G, Fox KK. Effects of clopidogrel in addition to aspirin in patients with acute coronary syndromes without ST-segment elevation. N Engl J Med 2001;345:494 –502. Conclusions 4. CAPRIE Steering Committee. A randomised, blinded, trial of clopi- dogrel versus aspirin in patients at risk of ischaemic events (CAPRIE). Lancet 1996;348:1329 –39. This study shows that the combination of aspirin plus 5. Goldman S, Copeland J, Moritz T, et al. Improvement in early clopidogrel significantly increased venous graft patency at 3 saphenous vein graft patency after coronary artery bypass surgery with months after CABG compared with aspirin alone. Com- antiplatelet therapy: results of a Veterans Administration cooperative study. Circulation 1988;77:1324 –32. bined antiplatelet therapy, larger runoff, and higher mean 6. Al-Ruzzeh S, George S, Bustami M, et al. Effect of off-pump coronary graft flow are independently correlated with elevated venous artery bypass surgery on clinical, angiographic, neurocognitive, and graft patency, whereas pulsatile index is an independent risk quality of life outcomes: randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2006; 332:1365. predictor. No significant differences in MACE between the 7. Gum PA, Kottke-Marchant K, Welsh PA, White J, Topol E. A 2 groups were observed. prospective, blinded determination of the natural history of aspirin resistance among stable patients with cardiovascular disease. J Am Coll Cardiol 2003;41:961–5. 8. Cadroy Y, Bossavy JP, Thalamas C, Sagnard L, Sakariassen K, Boneu Acknowledgments B. Early potent antithrombotic effect with combined aspirin and a The authors wish to thank Drs. Wei Li, Yang Wang, and loading dose of clopidogrel on experimental arterial thrombogenesis in humans. Circulation 2000;101:2823– 8. Xin Yuan from the Biostatistical Unit, Cardiovascular 9. Fox KA, Mehta SR, Peters R, et al. Benefits and risks of the Institute and Fu Wai Hospital for their assistance on the combination of clopidogrel and aspirin in patients undergoing surgical statistics. revascularization for non-ST-elevation acute coronary syndrome: the Clopidogrel in Unstable angina to prevent Recurrent ischemic Events (CURE) Trial. Circulation 2004;110:1202– 8. Reprint requests and correspondence: Dr. Shengshou Hu, De- 10. Gurbuz AT, Zia AA, Vuran AC, Cui H, Aytac A. Postoperative partment of Surgery, Cardiovascular Institute and Fu Wai Hos- clopidogrel improves mid-term outcome after off-pump coronary artery bypass graft surgery: a prospective study. Eur J Cardiothorac pital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences & Peking Union Surg 2006;29:190 –5. Medical College, 167A Beilishilu, Beijing 100037, The People’s Republic of China. E-mail: shengshouhu@yahoo.com. Key Words: antiplatelet therapy y clopidogrel y coronary artery bypass grafting y graft patency y multislice computed tomography angiography. Downloaded from content.onlinejacc.org by on March 20, 2012
  • 7. Aspirin Plus Clopidogrel Therapy Increases Early Venous Graft Patency After Coronary Artery Bypass Surgery: A Single-Center, Randomized, Controlled Trial Ge Gao, Zhe Zheng, Yi Pi, Bin Lu, Jinguo Lu, and Shengshou Hu J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 2010;56;1639-1643 doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2010.03.104 This information is current as of March 20, 2012 Updated Information including high-resolution figures, can be found at: & Services http://content.onlinejacc.org/cgi/content/full/56/20/1639 Supplementary Material Supplementary material can be found at: http://content.onlinejacc.org/cgi/content/full/56/20/1639/DC1 References This article cites 10 articles, 6 of which you can access for free at: http://content.onlinejacc.org/cgi/content/full/56/20/1639#BIB L Citations This article has been cited by 7 HighWire-hosted articles: http://content.onlinejacc.org/cgi/content/full/56/20/1639#other articles Rights & Permissions Information about reproducing this article in parts (figures, tables) or in its entirety can be found online at: http://content.onlinejacc.org/misc/permissions.dtl Reprints Information about ordering reprints can be found online: http://content.onlinejacc.org/misc/reprints.dtl Downloaded from content.onlinejacc.org by on March 20, 2012