SlideShare a Scribd company logo
English as MOI (medium of
instruction ) in Hong Kong

     Linguistic imperialism
               Or
        Cultural capital?
Source:

Talbot. M. M., Atkinson, K., & Atkinson D.
 (2003). Extracts from Reading 5.1 in
 Language and power in the modern world.
 Edinburgh University Press. pp. 272-281

   (Study Guide, Unit three, pp. 18-23)
The premise:

 “This paper suggests that linguistic imperialism
 might be a useful concept in denoting the
 language situation in the earlier days of the
 colonial administration of Hong Kong, but it
 provides an inadequate account of the role of
 English in its most recent and post-colonial
 situation”. (p.18)
“Linguistic imperialism concerns the
 intention to dominate” (p.18)

And so…

 “Linguistic imperialism cannot provide a
 full explanation of for English as the MOI
 in Hong Kong, as Hong Kong Chinese
 have always wanted English”. (Boyle
 1997, p. 176)
Let’s look at the facts
Evidence for linguistic imperialism:

• In the 1970s and early 1980 English enjoyed a
  higher status than Chinese
• Climbing the social ladder and having a well-
  paid job required proficiency in English
• The colonial administration was the largest and
  predominant employer
• English became the predominant medium for
  trade and administration, science and
  technology
“The British administration’s concern was to use
the schooling system to select a local elite to
work for the colonial government (Boyle, 1995).
In this sense the notion of linguistic imperialism
in using English in the service of colonial
domination is perhaps useful”. (p. 20)



“The language policy helped to perpetuate
British power in a society at the expense of the
quality of education of large sections of the local
population”. (p. 21)
Most importantly…


“The colonial education system produced
a largely disempowered populace who
simply could not find their voice in English
and whose voice (Aronovitz & Giroux,
1986) in Chinese was denied”. (p. 22)
On the other hand…
Evidence for cultural capital:

• English provided entry into lucrative careers in
  an increasingly competitive job market
• All interviews for government or large business
  corporations were conducted in English
• A good pass in English was essential for
  university entrance
• HK parents sent their children to EMI schools in
  the pursuit of enhanced life chances for them
So…                        …
 “Hong Kong Chinese have always wanted English”
 (p.18)

And

 “English has been instrumental in the prosperity of Hong
 Kong” (p.19)

Because

 “it provides access to cultural and economic capital; this
 ensures the economic survival of HK and its citizens and,
 as Bordieu suggests, economic capital it at the root of all
 other types of capital”. (p.19)
Conclusions?

• Educational policies borne out of imperialistic tendencies
  give citizens the opportunity to gain cultural capital and
  so to improve their life chances

• however, they also reproduce and augment inequalities
  of power in favour of the already dominant group(s).

• and can have dire consequences for the maintenance
  and survival of one’s native/heritage language and
  culture
In the end…
As advantageous as it might turn out to
be, is learning an ideologically imposed
language ever a completely FREE choice?

More Related Content

What's hot

English as a global language
English as a global languageEnglish as a global language
English as a global language
هارئ Kya-Habib Nadia-Dayyan
 
The possible future of english
The possible future of englishThe possible future of english
The possible future of english
Christina-Jennifer Kulle-Gutoskie
 
English, an international language 2
 English, an international language 2 English, an international language 2
English, an international language 2
gepoteriko
 
The future of english as a global language
The future of english as a global languageThe future of english as a global language
The future of english as a global language
Cantitinha
 
English as a global language grace
English as a global language graceEnglish as a global language grace
English as a global language grace
Pao Plastina
 
World english
World englishWorld english
World english
Muhammad Altaf
 
Kachrus three circle model
Kachrus three circle modelKachrus three circle model
Kachrus three circle model
G.P.G.C Mardan
 
English as Global Language
English as Global LanguageEnglish as Global Language
English as Global Language
Ali Soomro
 
ENGLISH AS A GLOBAL LANGUAGE BY IRFAN
ENGLISH AS A GLOBAL LANGUAGE BY IRFANENGLISH AS A GLOBAL LANGUAGE BY IRFAN
ENGLISH AS A GLOBAL LANGUAGE BY IRFAN
mohammed irfanulla khan
 
Brief history of english language in sri lanka new
Brief history of  english language  in sri lanka  newBrief history of  english language  in sri lanka  new
Brief history of english language in sri lanka new
thabitha jeyarajan
 
The importance of English in Mexico and the world
The importance of English in Mexico and the worldThe importance of English in Mexico and the world
The importance of English in Mexico and the world
Citlali González
 
Questionnaire
QuestionnaireQuestionnaire
Questionnaire
Marianela Depetris
 
English As A ‘World Language’
English As A ‘World Language’English As A ‘World Language’
English As A ‘World Language’
lizboyden
 
Possibilities and Challenges of Implementing EIL in Sri Lanka : Attitudes of ...
Possibilities and Challenges of Implementing EIL in Sri Lanka : Attitudes of ...Possibilities and Challenges of Implementing EIL in Sri Lanka : Attitudes of ...
Possibilities and Challenges of Implementing EIL in Sri Lanka : Attitudes of ...
Amaali Boralugoda
 
Anglès comunicació global
Anglès comunicació globalAnglès comunicació global
Anglès comunicació global
SoniaPrats
 
Diversity Romney
Diversity RomneyDiversity Romney
Diversity Romney
Aiden Yeh
 
South Asian Englishes
South Asian EnglishesSouth Asian Englishes
South Asian Englishes
Maria Raja Tahir
 
Slideshare
SlideshareSlideshare
Libraries in Uganda
Libraries in UgandaLibraries in Uganda
Categorizing English world
Categorizing English worldCategorizing English world
Categorizing English world
Amna Fayyaz
 

What's hot (20)

English as a global language
English as a global languageEnglish as a global language
English as a global language
 
The possible future of english
The possible future of englishThe possible future of english
The possible future of english
 
English, an international language 2
 English, an international language 2 English, an international language 2
English, an international language 2
 
The future of english as a global language
The future of english as a global languageThe future of english as a global language
The future of english as a global language
 
English as a global language grace
English as a global language graceEnglish as a global language grace
English as a global language grace
 
World english
World englishWorld english
World english
 
Kachrus three circle model
Kachrus three circle modelKachrus three circle model
Kachrus three circle model
 
English as Global Language
English as Global LanguageEnglish as Global Language
English as Global Language
 
ENGLISH AS A GLOBAL LANGUAGE BY IRFAN
ENGLISH AS A GLOBAL LANGUAGE BY IRFANENGLISH AS A GLOBAL LANGUAGE BY IRFAN
ENGLISH AS A GLOBAL LANGUAGE BY IRFAN
 
Brief history of english language in sri lanka new
Brief history of  english language  in sri lanka  newBrief history of  english language  in sri lanka  new
Brief history of english language in sri lanka new
 
The importance of English in Mexico and the world
The importance of English in Mexico and the worldThe importance of English in Mexico and the world
The importance of English in Mexico and the world
 
Questionnaire
QuestionnaireQuestionnaire
Questionnaire
 
English As A ‘World Language’
English As A ‘World Language’English As A ‘World Language’
English As A ‘World Language’
 
Possibilities and Challenges of Implementing EIL in Sri Lanka : Attitudes of ...
Possibilities and Challenges of Implementing EIL in Sri Lanka : Attitudes of ...Possibilities and Challenges of Implementing EIL in Sri Lanka : Attitudes of ...
Possibilities and Challenges of Implementing EIL in Sri Lanka : Attitudes of ...
 
Anglès comunicació global
Anglès comunicació globalAnglès comunicació global
Anglès comunicació global
 
Diversity Romney
Diversity RomneyDiversity Romney
Diversity Romney
 
South Asian Englishes
South Asian EnglishesSouth Asian Englishes
South Asian Englishes
 
Slideshare
SlideshareSlideshare
Slideshare
 
Libraries in Uganda
Libraries in UgandaLibraries in Uganda
Libraries in Uganda
 
Categorizing English world
Categorizing English worldCategorizing English world
Categorizing English world
 

Similar to Arianna's Presentation

World English-chapter 5-part2
World English-chapter 5-part2World English-chapter 5-part2
World English-chapter 5-part2
Ecem Ekinci
 
Group-5_PHILIPPINE-ENGLISH.pptx
Group-5_PHILIPPINE-ENGLISH.pptxGroup-5_PHILIPPINE-ENGLISH.pptx
Group-5_PHILIPPINE-ENGLISH.pptx
RaizaLainahMiano1
 
Linguistic Imperialism
Linguistic ImperialismLinguistic Imperialism
Linguistic Imperialism
Aiden Yeh
 
Post Brexit EU and the position of English - Robert Phillipson
Post Brexit EU and the position of English - Robert PhillipsonPost Brexit EU and the position of English - Robert Phillipson
Post Brexit EU and the position of English - Robert Phillipson
rceluoa
 
Linguistic Imperialism in the Globalized World: Examining English Dominance ...
Linguistic Imperialism in the Globalized World: Examining English  Dominance ...Linguistic Imperialism in the Globalized World: Examining English  Dominance ...
Linguistic Imperialism in the Globalized World: Examining English Dominance ...
Faiz Ullah
 
Linguistics imperialism
Linguistics imperialismLinguistics imperialism
Linguistics imperialism
Sajid Ali Lashari
 
Linguistic imperialism, cultural integrity, and EIL
Linguistic imperialism, cultural integrity, and EILLinguistic imperialism, cultural integrity, and EIL
Linguistic imperialism, cultural integrity, and EIL
IELTS Council
 
Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire
Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire
Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire
Rocio Villoria
 
Lobianco World Language Education
Lobianco World Language EducationLobianco World Language Education
Lobianco World Language Education
Center for Global Education at Asia Society
 
Linguistic Imperialism
Linguistic ImperialismLinguistic Imperialism
Linguistic Imperialism
Giovanna Moggia
 
English 345 week 13
English 345 week 13English 345 week 13
English 345 week 13
lisyaseloni
 
TIRF - Chinese Perspective on English: Current Status and Future Trends
TIRF - Chinese Perspective on English: Current Status and Future TrendsTIRF - Chinese Perspective on English: Current Status and Future Trends
TIRF - Chinese Perspective on English: Current Status and Future Trends
The International Research Foundation for English Language Education (TIRF)
 
Why the Medium of English Has Become a Linguistic Tool of Necessity for Spani...
Why the Medium of English Has Become a Linguistic Tool of Necessity for Spani...Why the Medium of English Has Become a Linguistic Tool of Necessity for Spani...
Why the Medium of English Has Become a Linguistic Tool of Necessity for Spani...
Tolgay Ilbay
 
540 week 2
540 week 2540 week 2
540 week 2
lisyaseloni
 
Sustaining Linguistic Diversity within the Global Cultural Eco.docx
Sustaining Linguistic Diversity within the Global Cultural Eco.docxSustaining Linguistic Diversity within the Global Cultural Eco.docx
Sustaining Linguistic Diversity within the Global Cultural Eco.docx
mattinsonjanel
 
Critical languagepedagogy kumaravadivelu2003
Critical languagepedagogy kumaravadivelu2003Critical languagepedagogy kumaravadivelu2003
Critical languagepedagogy kumaravadivelu2003
Nelly Zafeiriades
 
englishasagloballanguage-121123193913-phpapp01.pptx
englishasagloballanguage-121123193913-phpapp01.pptxenglishasagloballanguage-121123193913-phpapp01.pptx
englishasagloballanguage-121123193913-phpapp01.pptx
NURFAIZAHNURFAIZAH2
 
Kachru
KachruKachru
Americanization in South Korea
Americanization in South KoreaAmericanization in South Korea
Americanization in South Korea
Jamie McClure
 
Thesis Abstract and Background
Thesis Abstract and BackgroundThesis Abstract and Background
Thesis Abstract and Background
James Porcelli
 

Similar to Arianna's Presentation (20)

World English-chapter 5-part2
World English-chapter 5-part2World English-chapter 5-part2
World English-chapter 5-part2
 
Group-5_PHILIPPINE-ENGLISH.pptx
Group-5_PHILIPPINE-ENGLISH.pptxGroup-5_PHILIPPINE-ENGLISH.pptx
Group-5_PHILIPPINE-ENGLISH.pptx
 
Linguistic Imperialism
Linguistic ImperialismLinguistic Imperialism
Linguistic Imperialism
 
Post Brexit EU and the position of English - Robert Phillipson
Post Brexit EU and the position of English - Robert PhillipsonPost Brexit EU and the position of English - Robert Phillipson
Post Brexit EU and the position of English - Robert Phillipson
 
Linguistic Imperialism in the Globalized World: Examining English Dominance ...
Linguistic Imperialism in the Globalized World: Examining English  Dominance ...Linguistic Imperialism in the Globalized World: Examining English  Dominance ...
Linguistic Imperialism in the Globalized World: Examining English Dominance ...
 
Linguistics imperialism
Linguistics imperialismLinguistics imperialism
Linguistics imperialism
 
Linguistic imperialism, cultural integrity, and EIL
Linguistic imperialism, cultural integrity, and EILLinguistic imperialism, cultural integrity, and EIL
Linguistic imperialism, cultural integrity, and EIL
 
Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire
Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire
Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire
 
Lobianco World Language Education
Lobianco World Language EducationLobianco World Language Education
Lobianco World Language Education
 
Linguistic Imperialism
Linguistic ImperialismLinguistic Imperialism
Linguistic Imperialism
 
English 345 week 13
English 345 week 13English 345 week 13
English 345 week 13
 
TIRF - Chinese Perspective on English: Current Status and Future Trends
TIRF - Chinese Perspective on English: Current Status and Future TrendsTIRF - Chinese Perspective on English: Current Status and Future Trends
TIRF - Chinese Perspective on English: Current Status and Future Trends
 
Why the Medium of English Has Become a Linguistic Tool of Necessity for Spani...
Why the Medium of English Has Become a Linguistic Tool of Necessity for Spani...Why the Medium of English Has Become a Linguistic Tool of Necessity for Spani...
Why the Medium of English Has Become a Linguistic Tool of Necessity for Spani...
 
540 week 2
540 week 2540 week 2
540 week 2
 
Sustaining Linguistic Diversity within the Global Cultural Eco.docx
Sustaining Linguistic Diversity within the Global Cultural Eco.docxSustaining Linguistic Diversity within the Global Cultural Eco.docx
Sustaining Linguistic Diversity within the Global Cultural Eco.docx
 
Critical languagepedagogy kumaravadivelu2003
Critical languagepedagogy kumaravadivelu2003Critical languagepedagogy kumaravadivelu2003
Critical languagepedagogy kumaravadivelu2003
 
englishasagloballanguage-121123193913-phpapp01.pptx
englishasagloballanguage-121123193913-phpapp01.pptxenglishasagloballanguage-121123193913-phpapp01.pptx
englishasagloballanguage-121123193913-phpapp01.pptx
 
Kachru
KachruKachru
Kachru
 
Americanization in South Korea
Americanization in South KoreaAmericanization in South Korea
Americanization in South Korea
 
Thesis Abstract and Background
Thesis Abstract and BackgroundThesis Abstract and Background
Thesis Abstract and Background
 

Recently uploaded

Pollen and Fungal allergy: aeroallergy.pdf
Pollen and Fungal allergy: aeroallergy.pdfPollen and Fungal allergy: aeroallergy.pdf
Pollen and Fungal allergy: aeroallergy.pdf
Chulalongkorn Allergy and Clinical Immunology Research Group
 
Acute Gout Care & Urate Lowering Therapy .pdf
Acute Gout Care & Urate Lowering Therapy .pdfAcute Gout Care & Urate Lowering Therapy .pdf
Acute Gout Care & Urate Lowering Therapy .pdf
Jim Jacob Roy
 
How to choose the best dermatologists in Indore.
How to choose the best dermatologists in Indore.How to choose the best dermatologists in Indore.
How to choose the best dermatologists in Indore.
Gokuldas Hospital
 
NARCOTICS- POLICY AND PROCEDURES FOR ITS USE
NARCOTICS- POLICY AND PROCEDURES FOR ITS USENARCOTICS- POLICY AND PROCEDURES FOR ITS USE
NARCOTICS- POLICY AND PROCEDURES FOR ITS USE
Dr. Ahana Haroon
 
Local anesthetics 2024/ Medicinal Chemistry pdf
Local anesthetics 2024/ Medicinal Chemistry pdfLocal anesthetics 2024/ Medicinal Chemistry pdf
Local anesthetics 2024/ Medicinal Chemistry pdf
NarminHamaaminHussen
 
Full Handwritten notes of RA by Ayush Kumar M pharm - Al ameen college of pha...
Full Handwritten notes of RA by Ayush Kumar M pharm - Al ameen college of pha...Full Handwritten notes of RA by Ayush Kumar M pharm - Al ameen college of pha...
Full Handwritten notes of RA by Ayush Kumar M pharm - Al ameen college of pha...
ayushrajshrivastava7
 
Call Girls In Mumbai +91-7426014248 High Profile Call Girl Mumbai
Call Girls In Mumbai +91-7426014248 High Profile Call Girl MumbaiCall Girls In Mumbai +91-7426014248 High Profile Call Girl Mumbai
Call Girls In Mumbai +91-7426014248 High Profile Call Girl Mumbai
Mobile Problem
 
Patellar Instability: Diagnosis Management
Patellar Instability: Diagnosis  ManagementPatellar Instability: Diagnosis  Management
Patellar Instability: Diagnosis Management
Dr Nitin Tyagi
 
Giloy in Ayurveda - Classical Categorization and Synonyms
Giloy in Ayurveda - Classical Categorization and SynonymsGiloy in Ayurveda - Classical Categorization and Synonyms
Giloy in Ayurveda - Classical Categorization and Synonyms
Planet Ayurveda
 
What is Obesity? How to overcome Obesity?
What is Obesity? How to overcome Obesity?What is Obesity? How to overcome Obesity?
What is Obesity? How to overcome Obesity?
Healthmedsrx.com
 
Know the difference between Endodontics and Orthodontics.
Know the difference between Endodontics and Orthodontics.Know the difference between Endodontics and Orthodontics.
Know the difference between Endodontics and Orthodontics.
Gokuldas Hospital
 
CBL Seminar 2024_Preliminary Program.pdf
CBL Seminar 2024_Preliminary Program.pdfCBL Seminar 2024_Preliminary Program.pdf
CBL Seminar 2024_Preliminary Program.pdf
suvadeepdas911
 
Computer in pharmaceutical research and development-Mpharm(Pharmaceutics)
Computer in pharmaceutical research and development-Mpharm(Pharmaceutics)Computer in pharmaceutical research and development-Mpharm(Pharmaceutics)
Computer in pharmaceutical research and development-Mpharm(Pharmaceutics)
MuskanShingari
 
Medical Quiz ( Online Quiz for API Meet 2024 ).pdf
Medical Quiz ( Online Quiz for API Meet 2024 ).pdfMedical Quiz ( Online Quiz for API Meet 2024 ).pdf
Medical Quiz ( Online Quiz for API Meet 2024 ).pdf
Jim Jacob Roy
 
Cervical Disc Arthroplasty ORSI 2024.pptx
Cervical Disc Arthroplasty ORSI 2024.pptxCervical Disc Arthroplasty ORSI 2024.pptx
Cervical Disc Arthroplasty ORSI 2024.pptx
LEFLOT Jean-Louis
 
5 Effective Homeopathic Medicines for Irregular Periods
5 Effective Homeopathic Medicines for Irregular Periods5 Effective Homeopathic Medicines for Irregular Periods
5 Effective Homeopathic Medicines for Irregular Periods
Dr. Deepika's Homeopathy - Gaur City
 
PARASITIC INFECTIONS IN CHILDREN peads.pptx
PARASITIC INFECTIONS IN CHILDREN peads.pptxPARASITIC INFECTIONS IN CHILDREN peads.pptx
PARASITIC INFECTIONS IN CHILDREN peads.pptx
MwambaChikonde1
 
STUDIES IN SUPPORT OF SPECIAL POPULATIONS: GERIATRICS E7
STUDIES IN SUPPORT OF SPECIAL POPULATIONS: GERIATRICS E7STUDIES IN SUPPORT OF SPECIAL POPULATIONS: GERIATRICS E7
STUDIES IN SUPPORT OF SPECIAL POPULATIONS: GERIATRICS E7
shruti jagirdar
 
Hemodialysis: Chapter 5, Dialyzers Overview - Dr.Gawad
Hemodialysis: Chapter 5, Dialyzers Overview - Dr.GawadHemodialysis: Chapter 5, Dialyzers Overview - Dr.Gawad
Hemodialysis: Chapter 5, Dialyzers Overview - Dr.Gawad
NephroTube - Dr.Gawad
 
Demystifying Fallopian Tube Blockage- Grading the Differences and Implication...
Demystifying Fallopian Tube Blockage- Grading the Differences and Implication...Demystifying Fallopian Tube Blockage- Grading the Differences and Implication...
Demystifying Fallopian Tube Blockage- Grading the Differences and Implication...
FFragrant
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Pollen and Fungal allergy: aeroallergy.pdf
Pollen and Fungal allergy: aeroallergy.pdfPollen and Fungal allergy: aeroallergy.pdf
Pollen and Fungal allergy: aeroallergy.pdf
 
Acute Gout Care & Urate Lowering Therapy .pdf
Acute Gout Care & Urate Lowering Therapy .pdfAcute Gout Care & Urate Lowering Therapy .pdf
Acute Gout Care & Urate Lowering Therapy .pdf
 
How to choose the best dermatologists in Indore.
How to choose the best dermatologists in Indore.How to choose the best dermatologists in Indore.
How to choose the best dermatologists in Indore.
 
NARCOTICS- POLICY AND PROCEDURES FOR ITS USE
NARCOTICS- POLICY AND PROCEDURES FOR ITS USENARCOTICS- POLICY AND PROCEDURES FOR ITS USE
NARCOTICS- POLICY AND PROCEDURES FOR ITS USE
 
Local anesthetics 2024/ Medicinal Chemistry pdf
Local anesthetics 2024/ Medicinal Chemistry pdfLocal anesthetics 2024/ Medicinal Chemistry pdf
Local anesthetics 2024/ Medicinal Chemistry pdf
 
Full Handwritten notes of RA by Ayush Kumar M pharm - Al ameen college of pha...
Full Handwritten notes of RA by Ayush Kumar M pharm - Al ameen college of pha...Full Handwritten notes of RA by Ayush Kumar M pharm - Al ameen college of pha...
Full Handwritten notes of RA by Ayush Kumar M pharm - Al ameen college of pha...
 
Call Girls In Mumbai +91-7426014248 High Profile Call Girl Mumbai
Call Girls In Mumbai +91-7426014248 High Profile Call Girl MumbaiCall Girls In Mumbai +91-7426014248 High Profile Call Girl Mumbai
Call Girls In Mumbai +91-7426014248 High Profile Call Girl Mumbai
 
Patellar Instability: Diagnosis Management
Patellar Instability: Diagnosis  ManagementPatellar Instability: Diagnosis  Management
Patellar Instability: Diagnosis Management
 
Giloy in Ayurveda - Classical Categorization and Synonyms
Giloy in Ayurveda - Classical Categorization and SynonymsGiloy in Ayurveda - Classical Categorization and Synonyms
Giloy in Ayurveda - Classical Categorization and Synonyms
 
What is Obesity? How to overcome Obesity?
What is Obesity? How to overcome Obesity?What is Obesity? How to overcome Obesity?
What is Obesity? How to overcome Obesity?
 
Know the difference between Endodontics and Orthodontics.
Know the difference between Endodontics and Orthodontics.Know the difference between Endodontics and Orthodontics.
Know the difference between Endodontics and Orthodontics.
 
CBL Seminar 2024_Preliminary Program.pdf
CBL Seminar 2024_Preliminary Program.pdfCBL Seminar 2024_Preliminary Program.pdf
CBL Seminar 2024_Preliminary Program.pdf
 
Computer in pharmaceutical research and development-Mpharm(Pharmaceutics)
Computer in pharmaceutical research and development-Mpharm(Pharmaceutics)Computer in pharmaceutical research and development-Mpharm(Pharmaceutics)
Computer in pharmaceutical research and development-Mpharm(Pharmaceutics)
 
Medical Quiz ( Online Quiz for API Meet 2024 ).pdf
Medical Quiz ( Online Quiz for API Meet 2024 ).pdfMedical Quiz ( Online Quiz for API Meet 2024 ).pdf
Medical Quiz ( Online Quiz for API Meet 2024 ).pdf
 
Cervical Disc Arthroplasty ORSI 2024.pptx
Cervical Disc Arthroplasty ORSI 2024.pptxCervical Disc Arthroplasty ORSI 2024.pptx
Cervical Disc Arthroplasty ORSI 2024.pptx
 
5 Effective Homeopathic Medicines for Irregular Periods
5 Effective Homeopathic Medicines for Irregular Periods5 Effective Homeopathic Medicines for Irregular Periods
5 Effective Homeopathic Medicines for Irregular Periods
 
PARASITIC INFECTIONS IN CHILDREN peads.pptx
PARASITIC INFECTIONS IN CHILDREN peads.pptxPARASITIC INFECTIONS IN CHILDREN peads.pptx
PARASITIC INFECTIONS IN CHILDREN peads.pptx
 
STUDIES IN SUPPORT OF SPECIAL POPULATIONS: GERIATRICS E7
STUDIES IN SUPPORT OF SPECIAL POPULATIONS: GERIATRICS E7STUDIES IN SUPPORT OF SPECIAL POPULATIONS: GERIATRICS E7
STUDIES IN SUPPORT OF SPECIAL POPULATIONS: GERIATRICS E7
 
Hemodialysis: Chapter 5, Dialyzers Overview - Dr.Gawad
Hemodialysis: Chapter 5, Dialyzers Overview - Dr.GawadHemodialysis: Chapter 5, Dialyzers Overview - Dr.Gawad
Hemodialysis: Chapter 5, Dialyzers Overview - Dr.Gawad
 
Demystifying Fallopian Tube Blockage- Grading the Differences and Implication...
Demystifying Fallopian Tube Blockage- Grading the Differences and Implication...Demystifying Fallopian Tube Blockage- Grading the Differences and Implication...
Demystifying Fallopian Tube Blockage- Grading the Differences and Implication...
 

Arianna's Presentation

  • 1. English as MOI (medium of instruction ) in Hong Kong Linguistic imperialism Or Cultural capital?
  • 2. Source: Talbot. M. M., Atkinson, K., & Atkinson D. (2003). Extracts from Reading 5.1 in Language and power in the modern world. Edinburgh University Press. pp. 272-281 (Study Guide, Unit three, pp. 18-23)
  • 3. The premise: “This paper suggests that linguistic imperialism might be a useful concept in denoting the language situation in the earlier days of the colonial administration of Hong Kong, but it provides an inadequate account of the role of English in its most recent and post-colonial situation”. (p.18)
  • 4. “Linguistic imperialism concerns the intention to dominate” (p.18) And so… “Linguistic imperialism cannot provide a full explanation of for English as the MOI in Hong Kong, as Hong Kong Chinese have always wanted English”. (Boyle 1997, p. 176)
  • 5. Let’s look at the facts Evidence for linguistic imperialism: • In the 1970s and early 1980 English enjoyed a higher status than Chinese • Climbing the social ladder and having a well- paid job required proficiency in English • The colonial administration was the largest and predominant employer • English became the predominant medium for trade and administration, science and technology
  • 6. “The British administration’s concern was to use the schooling system to select a local elite to work for the colonial government (Boyle, 1995). In this sense the notion of linguistic imperialism in using English in the service of colonial domination is perhaps useful”. (p. 20) “The language policy helped to perpetuate British power in a society at the expense of the quality of education of large sections of the local population”. (p. 21)
  • 7. Most importantly… “The colonial education system produced a largely disempowered populace who simply could not find their voice in English and whose voice (Aronovitz & Giroux, 1986) in Chinese was denied”. (p. 22)
  • 8. On the other hand… Evidence for cultural capital: • English provided entry into lucrative careers in an increasingly competitive job market • All interviews for government or large business corporations were conducted in English • A good pass in English was essential for university entrance • HK parents sent their children to EMI schools in the pursuit of enhanced life chances for them
  • 9. So… … “Hong Kong Chinese have always wanted English” (p.18) And “English has been instrumental in the prosperity of Hong Kong” (p.19) Because “it provides access to cultural and economic capital; this ensures the economic survival of HK and its citizens and, as Bordieu suggests, economic capital it at the root of all other types of capital”. (p.19)
  • 10. Conclusions? • Educational policies borne out of imperialistic tendencies give citizens the opportunity to gain cultural capital and so to improve their life chances • however, they also reproduce and augment inequalities of power in favour of the already dominant group(s). • and can have dire consequences for the maintenance and survival of one’s native/heritage language and culture
  • 11. In the end… As advantageous as it might turn out to be, is learning an ideologically imposed language ever a completely FREE choice?