Ali’s Khilafah The Difficult Years 35-40 A.H.
Uthman was killed Friday 18 th  Zi Al-Hijah, 35 H Five days later, Ali was given Bay’a under the pressure of the rebels Madina is under rebel control Sahaba and Ali differ regarding priorities for the new Khalifah
Iraq Misr Shaam
Rebels came from mostly 3 territirries
Madina is in turmoil and under control of rebels
Sahaba ask Ali to punish the murderers
Ali wanted to stabilize and restore order to the territories (Amsar)
Ali appoints new Governors.  Before Bay’a
Ali appoints new Governors.  Before Bay’a  Uthman bin Hunayf
Ali appoints new Governors.  Before Bay’a  Uthman bin Hunayf
Ali appoints new Governors.  Before Bay’a  Ubaydullah bin Abbas to Yemen Uthman bin Hunayf
Ali appoints new Governors.  Before Bay’a  Abu Musa Uthman bin Hunayf Kays  bin Saad
Ali appoints new Governors.  Before Bay’a  Abu Musa Kharabta Uthman bin Hunayf Kays  bin Saad
Ali appoints new Governors.  Before Bay’a  Abu Musa Kharabta Sahl bin Hunayf Uthman bin Hunayf Kays  bin Saad
Mu’away and Ali  Abu Musa Kharabta Uthman bin Hunayf Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Talha and Al-Zubayr  Abu Musa Kharabta Uthman bin Hunayf Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Army of Mecca Abu Musa Kharabta Uthman bin Hunayf Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Army of Mecca to Basra Abu Musa Kharabta Uthman bin Hunayf Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Ali moves to Al-Shaam Abu Musa Kharabta Uthman bin Hunayf Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Ali changes direction to catch up with Army of Mecca Abu Musa Kharabta Uthman bin Hunayf Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Uthman bin Hunayf Abu Musa Mecca Army Ali’s Army
Uthman bin Hunayf Abu Musa Mecca Army Ali’s Army Events of Al-Basra Rabi II 36 A.H.
Uthman bin Hunayf Abu Musa Mecca Army Ali’s Army Events of Al-Basra Rabi II 36 A.H.
Abu Musa Mecca Army Ali’s Army Events of Al-Basra Rabi II 36 A.H.
Abu Musa Mecca Army Ali’s Army Ali moves to Kufa
Mecca Army Ali’s Army
Mecca Army Ali’s Army Ali moves to Basra
Mecca Army Ali’s Army Ali moves to Basra
Mecca Army Ali’s Army Battle of Al-Jamal (Camel) 10 Jumada II 36 A.H.
Ali’s Army Battle of Al-Jamal (Camel) 10 Jumada II 36 A.H.
Ali controls most Islamic states exept Shaam. Jumada II 36 A.H. Kharabta Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Ali and Mu’aweya Mu’aweya is asked by Na’yla* to retaliate for Uthman* Mu’aweya* refuses to follow Ali* before  ALL  those participated in the revolution against Uthman are executed.  Estimated ~2500 in all. Ali refuses to kill or surrender the rebels: Not all rebels are involved in the murder plot (like Ammar* bin Yaser*) Just and fair trials have to take place The Khalifah has to restore order first, then deliver justice according to Islamic Shari’a *May Allah be pleased with them and all of the Sahaba
Ali and Mu’aweya Amr* bin Al-A’as joins Mu’aweya* Abdullah* bin Abi As-Sarh joins Mu’aweya Shurahbil bin As-Samt  (Hims) calls for Mu’aweya to become Khalifa.  Since there has to be a Khalifa among Muslims on Muaweya’s side. Ali* sees in deviding the Muslim Ummah a worse Fitna than the murder of Uthman.  Decides to move with his army to Al-Shaam to restore order and unity *May Allah be pleased with them and all of the Sahaba
Ali moves to Shaam and reaches Seffeen in Zi Al-Hija 36 A.H. 120,000 fighters Kharabta Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Mu’aweya reaches Seffeen in Zi Al-Hija 36 A.H. 90,000 fighters Kharabta Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Ali sends Mu’aweya messengers in Zi Al-Hija 36 A.H. Kharabta Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Skirmishes start in Zi Al-Hija 36 A.H. Kharabta Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Fighting halts for Muharam 37 A.H. Negotiations restart Kharabta Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Battle of Seffeen starts Wednesday, 1 st  Safar 37 A.H. Kharabta Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Battle of Seffeen continues Thursday, 7th Safar 37 A.H. Ammar is killed Kharabta Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Battle of Seffeen ends friday, 8th Safar 37 A.H. Quran on the spears. Kharabta Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya 70,000 Muslim are killed 25,000 from Ali’s army 45,000 from Mu’aweya’s
Agreement of Tahkeem (Judgment) is reached 13 or 15 th  Safar 37 A.H.  Kharabta Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Agreement of Tahkeem (Judgment) is reached 13 or 15 th  Safar 37 A.H. Kharabta Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya Dumat Al-Jandal
Tahkeem Ali realizes the trick from Mu’aweya and Amr, but his army is sharply divided over the issue.  Ali accepts against his own judgment. Abu Musa is to represent Ali, and Amr is to represent Mu’aweya Contract of Judgment written in Safar 37 A.H.  Actual meeting is to take place in Ramadhan 37H in Dumat Al-Jandal
Tahkeem 12,000 of Ali’s army are angered by the Tahkeem. They leave the army to Harura’. This is the beginning of  Al-Khawarej . Abdullah bin Abbas and Ali convince them to return to Ali’s side. (temporarily)
Tahkeem Amr and Abu Musa meet in Dumat Al-Jandal in Ramadhan 37 A.H.  A group of Sahaba is present. Tahkeem events.  (Common historical myths, not supported by good references or common sense)
Tahkeem Ali refuses to accept the ruling: Still no agreement on a Khalifa. Not based on Quran or Sunna. Ali’s speech in Kufa to resume fighting against Mu’aweya Khawarej leave Ali’s camp and ask for his Tawbah
Fighting Khawarej Ali prepared his army to invade Al-Shaam. Al-Basra army show lack of support.  3,200 fighters show up out of 60,000. Kufa army responds, but demands dealing with Khawarej first. Ali has 68,000 fighters.
Fighting Khawarej Khawarej were strict and diligent worshipers with  misguided interpretation of religion.  They lacked support of any Sahabi. (none in their camp, in contrast to Ali’s and Mu’aweya’s) Some hated the dominance of Quraysh over Khilafa Crimes of Khawarej: Abdulla bin Khabbab.  Takfeer. Ali decides to deal with Khawarej first. Ali fights Khawarej and defeats them in  Al-Nahrawan .
Ali’s army waekens: Many killed in Seffeen Not enough support from Basra Many Khawarej among their clans Tired of consecutive battles Confused by division and Fitna Events of Egypt: further weakness and division
Events of Egypt 38-39 A.H. Kharabta Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Kays bin Saad deos not want to fight in Kharabta Kharabta Kays  bin Saad Mu’awya
Muhammad bin Abu Bakr becomes Governor of Egypt Kharabta Muhammad bin Abu Bakr Mu’awya
Muhammad bin Abu Bakr fights in Kharabta and defeated. Kharabta Muhammad bin Abu Bakr Mu’awya
Al-Ashatar is murdered on his way to Egypt Kharabta Muhammad bin Abu Bakr Mu’awya
Mu’aweya sees an opportunity to capture rich Egypt Kharabta Muhammad bin Abu Bakr Mu’awya
Mu’aweya sends Amr to conquer Egypt Kharabta Muhammad bin Abu Bakr Mu’awya
Egypt falls to Mu’aweya and Muhammad bin Abu Bakr is killed Kharabta Muhammad bin Abu Bakr Mu’awya
Egypt falls to Mu’aweya and Muhammad bin Abu Bakr is killed Mu’awya
Mu’aweya is stronger.  Sends armies to raid and capture more territories Mu’awya Busr bin Ata’a Sufian bin Awf Dhahak bin Kays
Mu’aweya controls most Muslim teritorries Mu’awya
Assassination Plot  Khawarej meet to plot and revenge from Ali. Abdur-Rahaman bin Muljam and his co-conspirators. Ali is assassinated on Friday Ramadhan 15 th , 40 A.H.;  Dies Ramadhan 17 th . Al-Hasan becomes the Fifth Khalifa. Then, six months later, he gives Bay’a to Muaweya to end Fitnah. Al-Fitnah Al-Kubra is over.

Ali Fitna

  • 1.
    Ali’s Khilafah TheDifficult Years 35-40 A.H.
  • 2.
    Uthman was killedFriday 18 th Zi Al-Hijah, 35 H Five days later, Ali was given Bay’a under the pressure of the rebels Madina is under rebel control Sahaba and Ali differ regarding priorities for the new Khalifah
  • 3.
  • 4.
    Rebels came frommostly 3 territirries
  • 5.
    Madina is inturmoil and under control of rebels
  • 6.
    Sahaba ask Alito punish the murderers
  • 7.
    Ali wanted tostabilize and restore order to the territories (Amsar)
  • 8.
    Ali appoints newGovernors. Before Bay’a
  • 9.
    Ali appoints newGovernors. Before Bay’a Uthman bin Hunayf
  • 10.
    Ali appoints newGovernors. Before Bay’a Uthman bin Hunayf
  • 11.
    Ali appoints newGovernors. Before Bay’a Ubaydullah bin Abbas to Yemen Uthman bin Hunayf
  • 12.
    Ali appoints newGovernors. Before Bay’a Abu Musa Uthman bin Hunayf Kays bin Saad
  • 13.
    Ali appoints newGovernors. Before Bay’a Abu Musa Kharabta Uthman bin Hunayf Kays bin Saad
  • 14.
    Ali appoints newGovernors. Before Bay’a Abu Musa Kharabta Sahl bin Hunayf Uthman bin Hunayf Kays bin Saad
  • 15.
    Mu’away and Ali Abu Musa Kharabta Uthman bin Hunayf Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 16.
    Talha and Al-Zubayr Abu Musa Kharabta Uthman bin Hunayf Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 17.
    Army of MeccaAbu Musa Kharabta Uthman bin Hunayf Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 18.
    Army of Meccato Basra Abu Musa Kharabta Uthman bin Hunayf Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 19.
    Ali moves toAl-Shaam Abu Musa Kharabta Uthman bin Hunayf Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 20.
    Ali changes directionto catch up with Army of Mecca Abu Musa Kharabta Uthman bin Hunayf Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 21.
    Uthman bin HunayfAbu Musa Mecca Army Ali’s Army
  • 22.
    Uthman bin HunayfAbu Musa Mecca Army Ali’s Army Events of Al-Basra Rabi II 36 A.H.
  • 23.
    Uthman bin HunayfAbu Musa Mecca Army Ali’s Army Events of Al-Basra Rabi II 36 A.H.
  • 24.
    Abu Musa MeccaArmy Ali’s Army Events of Al-Basra Rabi II 36 A.H.
  • 25.
    Abu Musa MeccaArmy Ali’s Army Ali moves to Kufa
  • 26.
  • 27.
    Mecca Army Ali’sArmy Ali moves to Basra
  • 28.
    Mecca Army Ali’sArmy Ali moves to Basra
  • 29.
    Mecca Army Ali’sArmy Battle of Al-Jamal (Camel) 10 Jumada II 36 A.H.
  • 30.
    Ali’s Army Battleof Al-Jamal (Camel) 10 Jumada II 36 A.H.
  • 31.
    Ali controls mostIslamic states exept Shaam. Jumada II 36 A.H. Kharabta Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 32.
    Ali and Mu’aweyaMu’aweya is asked by Na’yla* to retaliate for Uthman* Mu’aweya* refuses to follow Ali* before ALL those participated in the revolution against Uthman are executed. Estimated ~2500 in all. Ali refuses to kill or surrender the rebels: Not all rebels are involved in the murder plot (like Ammar* bin Yaser*) Just and fair trials have to take place The Khalifah has to restore order first, then deliver justice according to Islamic Shari’a *May Allah be pleased with them and all of the Sahaba
  • 33.
    Ali and Mu’aweyaAmr* bin Al-A’as joins Mu’aweya* Abdullah* bin Abi As-Sarh joins Mu’aweya Shurahbil bin As-Samt (Hims) calls for Mu’aweya to become Khalifa. Since there has to be a Khalifa among Muslims on Muaweya’s side. Ali* sees in deviding the Muslim Ummah a worse Fitna than the murder of Uthman. Decides to move with his army to Al-Shaam to restore order and unity *May Allah be pleased with them and all of the Sahaba
  • 34.
    Ali moves toShaam and reaches Seffeen in Zi Al-Hija 36 A.H. 120,000 fighters Kharabta Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 35.
    Mu’aweya reaches Seffeenin Zi Al-Hija 36 A.H. 90,000 fighters Kharabta Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 36.
    Ali sends Mu’aweyamessengers in Zi Al-Hija 36 A.H. Kharabta Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 37.
    Skirmishes start inZi Al-Hija 36 A.H. Kharabta Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 38.
    Fighting halts forMuharam 37 A.H. Negotiations restart Kharabta Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 39.
    Battle of Seffeenstarts Wednesday, 1 st Safar 37 A.H. Kharabta Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 40.
    Battle of Seffeencontinues Thursday, 7th Safar 37 A.H. Ammar is killed Kharabta Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 41.
    Battle of Seffeenends friday, 8th Safar 37 A.H. Quran on the spears. Kharabta Kays bin Saad Mu’awya 70,000 Muslim are killed 25,000 from Ali’s army 45,000 from Mu’aweya’s
  • 42.
    Agreement of Tahkeem(Judgment) is reached 13 or 15 th Safar 37 A.H. Kharabta Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 43.
    Agreement of Tahkeem(Judgment) is reached 13 or 15 th Safar 37 A.H. Kharabta Kays bin Saad Mu’awya Dumat Al-Jandal
  • 44.
    Tahkeem Ali realizesthe trick from Mu’aweya and Amr, but his army is sharply divided over the issue. Ali accepts against his own judgment. Abu Musa is to represent Ali, and Amr is to represent Mu’aweya Contract of Judgment written in Safar 37 A.H. Actual meeting is to take place in Ramadhan 37H in Dumat Al-Jandal
  • 45.
    Tahkeem 12,000 ofAli’s army are angered by the Tahkeem. They leave the army to Harura’. This is the beginning of Al-Khawarej . Abdullah bin Abbas and Ali convince them to return to Ali’s side. (temporarily)
  • 46.
    Tahkeem Amr andAbu Musa meet in Dumat Al-Jandal in Ramadhan 37 A.H. A group of Sahaba is present. Tahkeem events. (Common historical myths, not supported by good references or common sense)
  • 47.
    Tahkeem Ali refusesto accept the ruling: Still no agreement on a Khalifa. Not based on Quran or Sunna. Ali’s speech in Kufa to resume fighting against Mu’aweya Khawarej leave Ali’s camp and ask for his Tawbah
  • 48.
    Fighting Khawarej Aliprepared his army to invade Al-Shaam. Al-Basra army show lack of support. 3,200 fighters show up out of 60,000. Kufa army responds, but demands dealing with Khawarej first. Ali has 68,000 fighters.
  • 49.
    Fighting Khawarej Khawarejwere strict and diligent worshipers with misguided interpretation of religion. They lacked support of any Sahabi. (none in their camp, in contrast to Ali’s and Mu’aweya’s) Some hated the dominance of Quraysh over Khilafa Crimes of Khawarej: Abdulla bin Khabbab. Takfeer. Ali decides to deal with Khawarej first. Ali fights Khawarej and defeats them in Al-Nahrawan .
  • 50.
    Ali’s army waekens:Many killed in Seffeen Not enough support from Basra Many Khawarej among their clans Tired of consecutive battles Confused by division and Fitna Events of Egypt: further weakness and division
  • 51.
    Events of Egypt38-39 A.H. Kharabta Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 52.
    Kays bin Saaddeos not want to fight in Kharabta Kharabta Kays bin Saad Mu’awya
  • 53.
    Muhammad bin AbuBakr becomes Governor of Egypt Kharabta Muhammad bin Abu Bakr Mu’awya
  • 54.
    Muhammad bin AbuBakr fights in Kharabta and defeated. Kharabta Muhammad bin Abu Bakr Mu’awya
  • 55.
    Al-Ashatar is murderedon his way to Egypt Kharabta Muhammad bin Abu Bakr Mu’awya
  • 56.
    Mu’aweya sees anopportunity to capture rich Egypt Kharabta Muhammad bin Abu Bakr Mu’awya
  • 57.
    Mu’aweya sends Amrto conquer Egypt Kharabta Muhammad bin Abu Bakr Mu’awya
  • 58.
    Egypt falls toMu’aweya and Muhammad bin Abu Bakr is killed Kharabta Muhammad bin Abu Bakr Mu’awya
  • 59.
    Egypt falls toMu’aweya and Muhammad bin Abu Bakr is killed Mu’awya
  • 60.
    Mu’aweya is stronger. Sends armies to raid and capture more territories Mu’awya Busr bin Ata’a Sufian bin Awf Dhahak bin Kays
  • 61.
    Mu’aweya controls mostMuslim teritorries Mu’awya
  • 62.
    Assassination Plot Khawarej meet to plot and revenge from Ali. Abdur-Rahaman bin Muljam and his co-conspirators. Ali is assassinated on Friday Ramadhan 15 th , 40 A.H.; Dies Ramadhan 17 th . Al-Hasan becomes the Fifth Khalifa. Then, six months later, he gives Bay’a to Muaweya to end Fitnah. Al-Fitnah Al-Kubra is over.