AGILE TESTING 
CELEBRATE BUG PREVENTION 
INSTEAD OF BUG DETECTION 
MICHAEL PALOTAS 
AGILE BODENSEE, KONSTANZ 
2. October 2014
WHO AM I? 
Michael Palotas 
Founder 
GRIDFUSION SOFTWARE SOLUTIONS 
Email: michael.palotas@gridfusion.net 
@michael_palotas 
Head of Productivity & Test Engineering 
eBay International 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
EBAY FROM THE TOP 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
GRIDFUSION FROM THE TOP 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
EBAY FACTS 
Founded in 1995 
Based in San Jose, California 
35000 employees worldwide 
>100 million active buyers and sellers worldwide 
3000 USD transaction volume every second 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
EBAY FACTS 
2 billion page views every day 
75 billion database calls every day 
>200 million downloads of eBay Inc’s mobile apps 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
TESTERS 
RAISE 
YOUR 
HANDS 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
DEVELOPERS 
RAISE 
YOUR 
HANDS 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
AGILE PEOPLE 
RAISE 
YOUR 
HANDS 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
WHAT I AM GOING TO TELL YOU HAS 
NOTHING TO DO WITH AGILE 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
SOME SELF REFLECTION 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
TEST CYCLES 
Traditional model - 6 months 
Development Test 
Agile - 2 weeks 
Development Test 
Development Test Development Test 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
THE IDEAL MIX? 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR 
QUALITY? 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
THE BI(U)G HUNT 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
BUG PREVENTION? 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
TESTING OF THE FUTURE? 
Non-Stop Testing 
Parallel to Development 
All test levels are done within the sprint 
Testing is the job of the entire team 
Testers are engineers with specific 
“superpowers” 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
CORE PRINCIPLES 
A team is only complete with an embedded 
tester 
Focus on prevention, not detection 
Early involvement 
Lightweight approach 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
HORIZONTAL / VERTICAL SUPPORT 
HORIZONTAL SUPPORT 
VERTICAL VERTICAL VERTICAL 
TEAM 1 TEAM 2 TEAM 3 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
VERTICAL SUPPORT 
Manual testing: Very very very very important 
Rapid testing / exploratory approach 
Focus on fast feedback 
Focus on primary work artifacts 
Domain knowledge 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
HORIZONTAL SUPPORT 
Architecture 
Infrastructure 
Tools 
TDD 
Automation 
Continuous Integration 
DevOps 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
HOW TEAMS EVOLVE 
PO 
UX 
DEV 
DEV 
DEV 
DEV 
DEV 
PO 
UX 
DEV 
DEV 
DEV 
DEV 
DEV 
SET 
PO 
UX 
DEV 
DEV 
DEV 
DEV 
DEV 
SET 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
EBAY AGILE TESTING MANIFESTO 
We believe that... By that we mean... 
1 our main work product is 
information relevant to people who 
matter 
We give feedback about the product as early as possible in a lean way, asking questions and providing 
information during pair programming to prevent bugs.We report truthfully, concisely, allowing stakeholders 
to make informed decisions.We rapidly uncover and report significant risks to the project. 
2 we as testers explore the 
differences between perception, 
desire and reality 
We understand that things can be different. Sometimes those differences are important. We uncover what 
those differences are and where they may lead to problems. We discover new information by the skilled 
application of exploratory testing. 
3 testing is a collaborative endeavor Testing is not delegated to testers only, but should also be done by everyone else in the team. The 
expertise of both testers and developers enables a broader testing coverage. We closely collaborate with 
developers and work side-by-side every day. 
4 learning about the domain is crucial 
to doing a good job 
No one has all the answers up front. Project requirements evolve over time. Rather than follow a rote 
plan, we learn as we test and we use what we learn to guide what we test next. We aim to understand 
eBay systems and share our knowledge with our peers. 
5 ignorance about the domain is not 
a reason not to test 
We don't wait for a complete set of documentation and instructions before we start testing, but we apply 
good testing practices at any given time. 
6 the space between automation and 
manual testing is a continuum 
Humans excel at qualitative analysis - we notice things. Machines do quantitative analysis very well - 
rapidly making boolean choices. Our approach combines the two, ensuring that machines are employed 
for what they do best (automation, repetition and tooling), while the rest is left to humans. 
7 developing tools for the benefit of 
all teams supports overall 
productivity 
We can be more effective if shared tools are in place to optimize repetitive tasks and avoid solving the 
same problem multiple times. Those tools can either be sourced from outside or built in-house. 
8 metrics are a way to start a 
conversation and not to end it 
Sometimes metrics are selected simply because they are easily available and not because their construct 
validity has been established. Misapplied metrics can cause a lot of harm. We use metrics to help us 
achieve results, hence we value inquiry metrics over evaluation metrics. http://www.developsense.com/ 
blog/2009/01/meaningful-metrics/ 
9 we are not the gatekeepers of 
quality 
We provide information to allow others to make informed decisions, including "ship" / "no ship" decisions. 
We highlight risks. It is up to our stakeholders to decide what to do based on that information. 
10 our approach is applicable eBay 
wide 
We believe that an agile, embedded approach fosters close working relationships between testers and 
other roles. It helps deliver more value more quickly and reduces unnecessary overhead.
HOW TO BE THIS MAGIC PERSON? 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
MAKE IT WORK 
Be part of the team 
Involve yourself right from the start 
Act as a bridge 
Pair 
Educate 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
ATLASSIAN 
Source: Andrew Prentice, Atlassian, Sydney May 2014 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
THE BIG GOAL 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
THANK YOU! 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
REFERENCES 
http://weekendreflection.blogspot.ch/ 
http://perfectplate.com/ 
http://www.jamshid-ibrahim.net/ 
http://simplehomemade.net/ 
http://npr.org 
http://creatia2013.wordpress.com/ 
www.kaushik.net 
Sackmesser.ch 
http://betterafter50.com 
http://estonianfreepress.com/ 
MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE

Agile bodensee - Agile Testing: Bug prevention vs. bug detection

  • 1.
    AGILE TESTING CELEBRATEBUG PREVENTION INSTEAD OF BUG DETECTION MICHAEL PALOTAS AGILE BODENSEE, KONSTANZ 2. October 2014
  • 2.
    WHO AM I? Michael Palotas Founder GRIDFUSION SOFTWARE SOLUTIONS Email: michael.palotas@gridfusion.net @michael_palotas Head of Productivity & Test Engineering eBay International MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 3.
    EBAY FROM THETOP MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 4.
    GRIDFUSION FROM THETOP MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 5.
    EBAY FACTS Foundedin 1995 Based in San Jose, California 35000 employees worldwide >100 million active buyers and sellers worldwide 3000 USD transaction volume every second MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 6.
    EBAY FACTS 2billion page views every day 75 billion database calls every day >200 million downloads of eBay Inc’s mobile apps MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 7.
    TESTERS RAISE YOUR HANDS MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 8.
    DEVELOPERS RAISE YOUR HANDS MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 9.
    AGILE PEOPLE RAISE YOUR HANDS MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 10.
    WHAT I AMGOING TO TELL YOU HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH AGILE MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 11.
    SOME SELF REFLECTION MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 12.
    TEST CYCLES Traditionalmodel - 6 months Development Test Agile - 2 weeks Development Test Development Test Development Test MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 13.
    THE IDEAL MIX? MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 14.
    WHO IS RESPONSIBLEFOR QUALITY? MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 15.
    THE BI(U)G HUNT MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 16.
    BUG PREVENTION? MICHAELPALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 17.
    TESTING OF THEFUTURE? Non-Stop Testing Parallel to Development All test levels are done within the sprint Testing is the job of the entire team Testers are engineers with specific “superpowers” MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 18.
    CORE PRINCIPLES Ateam is only complete with an embedded tester Focus on prevention, not detection Early involvement Lightweight approach MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 19.
    HORIZONTAL / VERTICALSUPPORT HORIZONTAL SUPPORT VERTICAL VERTICAL VERTICAL TEAM 1 TEAM 2 TEAM 3 MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 20.
    VERTICAL SUPPORT Manualtesting: Very very very very important Rapid testing / exploratory approach Focus on fast feedback Focus on primary work artifacts Domain knowledge MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 21.
    HORIZONTAL SUPPORT Architecture Infrastructure Tools TDD Automation Continuous Integration DevOps MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 22.
    HOW TEAMS EVOLVE PO UX DEV DEV DEV DEV DEV PO UX DEV DEV DEV DEV DEV SET PO UX DEV DEV DEV DEV DEV SET MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 23.
    EBAY AGILE TESTINGMANIFESTO We believe that... By that we mean... 1 our main work product is information relevant to people who matter We give feedback about the product as early as possible in a lean way, asking questions and providing information during pair programming to prevent bugs.We report truthfully, concisely, allowing stakeholders to make informed decisions.We rapidly uncover and report significant risks to the project. 2 we as testers explore the differences between perception, desire and reality We understand that things can be different. Sometimes those differences are important. We uncover what those differences are and where they may lead to problems. We discover new information by the skilled application of exploratory testing. 3 testing is a collaborative endeavor Testing is not delegated to testers only, but should also be done by everyone else in the team. The expertise of both testers and developers enables a broader testing coverage. We closely collaborate with developers and work side-by-side every day. 4 learning about the domain is crucial to doing a good job No one has all the answers up front. Project requirements evolve over time. Rather than follow a rote plan, we learn as we test and we use what we learn to guide what we test next. We aim to understand eBay systems and share our knowledge with our peers. 5 ignorance about the domain is not a reason not to test We don't wait for a complete set of documentation and instructions before we start testing, but we apply good testing practices at any given time. 6 the space between automation and manual testing is a continuum Humans excel at qualitative analysis - we notice things. Machines do quantitative analysis very well - rapidly making boolean choices. Our approach combines the two, ensuring that machines are employed for what they do best (automation, repetition and tooling), while the rest is left to humans. 7 developing tools for the benefit of all teams supports overall productivity We can be more effective if shared tools are in place to optimize repetitive tasks and avoid solving the same problem multiple times. Those tools can either be sourced from outside or built in-house. 8 metrics are a way to start a conversation and not to end it Sometimes metrics are selected simply because they are easily available and not because their construct validity has been established. Misapplied metrics can cause a lot of harm. We use metrics to help us achieve results, hence we value inquiry metrics over evaluation metrics. http://www.developsense.com/ blog/2009/01/meaningful-metrics/ 9 we are not the gatekeepers of quality We provide information to allow others to make informed decisions, including "ship" / "no ship" decisions. We highlight risks. It is up to our stakeholders to decide what to do based on that information. 10 our approach is applicable eBay wide We believe that an agile, embedded approach fosters close working relationships between testers and other roles. It helps deliver more value more quickly and reduces unnecessary overhead.
  • 24.
    HOW TO BETHIS MAGIC PERSON? MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 25.
    MAKE IT WORK Be part of the team Involve yourself right from the start Act as a bridge Pair Educate MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 26.
    ATLASSIAN Source: AndrewPrentice, Atlassian, Sydney May 2014 MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 27.
    THE BIG GOAL MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 28.
    THANK YOU! MICHAELPALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE
  • 29.
    REFERENCES http://weekendreflection.blogspot.ch/ http://perfectplate.com/ http://www.jamshid-ibrahim.net/ http://simplehomemade.net/ http://npr.org http://creatia2013.wordpress.com/ www.kaushik.net Sackmesser.ch http://betterafter50.com http://estonianfreepress.com/ MICHAEL PALOTAS - AGILE BODENSEE