SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Bidding Price
Capabilities Performing the Contract
Technical Proposals Evaluation
USD$
USD$B
KONEPS
$25B $30B
COMPARISON
ICT Experts
Committee Pool
Superior Companies
Contract Officers
Computer System / DB
Prompt Response
Evaluation Entities
*Resources
Benefits
VS
Corruption
Self-purification
Expertise
How to Deliver good Result
*RBL (Result Based Lending)
Incorrect Data
Training & Education
Linking Systems
Ability to perform contract
*Problems
*Requirement
Importance
*Point of View
VS
10
KONEPS
14
15
Pre Qualification in Advance of Bidding
Public Notice Bid
BiddersProcure Entities
Request-Form PQAccept Request-Form PQ
K
Request-Form PQ
Public Notice
Accept Request-Form PQ
Process Assessment
Notice Score of PQ
Raising Appeal
Confirm Score of PQ
Bidding
Pre Qualification in Advance of Bidding
Unit KRW Million
Comprehensive Evaluation
Closing Bidding
BiddersProcure Entities
Confirm NOTICENotice Selected Tenders
Request-Form AssessmentAccept Request-Form
K
Review Appeal
Process Assessment
Notice Score of Assessment
Raising Appeal
Confirm Score of Assessment
Selecting Tender
Request-Form AssessmentAccept Request-Form
Opening Bidding Price
Bid Price
Capability
in imple-
mentation
Capable construction firm conduct construction at reasonable price
Expected Effects
50
Construction
execution
Capability
Professional
Past delivery performance(or personnel)
Professional skills in relevant construction
Dispatched technicians 10 11
Capability
Construction evaluation score 15 15
Construction capability by size 3 -
Composition of joint supply 2 2
Social
responsibility
(Plus 1point)
Employment of construction labor 0.2 0.2
Safety of construction 0.2 0.2Social
responsibility
(Plus 1point)
Safety of construction 0.2 0.2
Fair trade 0.2 0.2
Contribution to local economy 0.4 0.4
50
Bid price
Appropriateness of
price calculation
(take off points)
Evaluation of unit price
Evaluation of sub-contracting plan
Quality evaluation (take off/add points)
Evaluation of construction execution
Credibility for
contract(take off
points)
Breach of technicians dispatch plan Point cut Point cut
Breach of sub-contracting management plan Point cut Point cut
Exceed the sub-contracting price adjustment bottom line Point cut Point cut
Breach of construction plan Point cut Point cut
Past delivery
performance
Credit ratingCredit rating
Past delivery
performance
Technical
Capability
Credit rating
Capability for
supply of
contracted
products
Past performance
Equivalent or more qualified products to contracted one
Equivalent products
Technical capability Technology level
Management status Credit rating
Refer to overage score
calculation equation
Bid price Bid price
Refer to overage score
calculation equation
Credit rating
Quality
management
Degree of trust
Ultrahigh certification, green, general certificates, women-
owned, disabled, SMEs, job creation, joint venture
Reasons for
disqualification
Relevant products
Delivery completion
Capability
Reasons for
Disqualification
It is judged that contract completion is seen as difficult for
some reasons like bankruptcy (except, court decides for
receivership, authorization on completion)
Limited Competition (exceeding KRW 1 billion) to Manufacturers for Supply of Manufacturing Products
RFP Bidding Proposal Evaluation Negotiation Selecting Tender Contract
Projects are necessary for ensuring the expertise
or technical capacity in performing a contract
Items of Evaluation and Score
Negotiations
Define Equality Review
Key Features of Negotiation Contract of PPS
• Efficient• Fairness
Entrusting
Evaluation
Service
On-line
Proposal
Evaluation
K
• Expertis
e
• Transpar
ency
Entrusting
Evaluation
Service
On-line
Proposal
Evaluation
Committee
Experts
Pool
Committee
Member
Selection
System
ICT Project
Proposal
Evaluation
Committee
Regulation
Consist of
ICT Project
Proposal
Evaluation
Committee
Scale of the pool
Members of committees
Call for members
Method of Committee
Electronic Documents Auto Calling System
Contract Officer Audit Officer Specialists
Selecting appropriate
ICT Groups
Operating CMSS Attending
the committeeManagementPool
6,000 Experts
Selecting appropriate
ICT Groups
Operating CMSS Attending
the committeeManagementPool
6,000 Experts
31
Strategy and method
Comprehension on project, strategies, applicable technologies, standard frame work
application and method for development
Skills and functions
System requirements, update of function, security request, data request, system
operation
Skills and functions
System requirements, update of function, security request, data request, system
operation
Performance and
quality
Performance, quality requests, interface request, and green sector contribution
Project management Management method, implementation plan, equipment for development
Project support
Quality endorsement, test operation, training, maintenance, confidentiality, contingency
plan
Co-existence and sub-
contracting
Co-existence, sub-contracting appropriateness
Impact of e-Procurement
Increased Transparency
600
700
800
900
250,000
300,000
350,000
400,000
USD Billion
-
100
200
300
400
500
-
50,000
100,000
150,000
200,000
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Public Private Biddings Smart APP Scale of Bidding
600,000
700,000
800,000
900,000
1,000,000
-
Transaction Cost Savings
- KONEPS in 2012-
- Reduced lead-time
- Streamlined Process
We have to stride forward to tran
sparent public procurement in or
der to make a difference in the As
ia and Pacific region.
What we are doing here will be r
ecorded as meaningful and practi
cal case studies.
The outcome of APP e-PN’s initi
ative will be used by other countr
ies across the world.
-
100,000
200,000
300,000
400,000
500,000
600,000
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
Public Private Smart APP Scale of Bidding Biddings
- Reduced lead-time
- Streamlined Process
We have to stride forward to tran
sparent public procurement in or
der to make a difference in the As
ia and Pacific region.
What we are doing here will be r
ecorded as meaningful and practi
cal case studies.
The outcome of APP e-PN’s initi
ative will be used by other countr
ies across the world.
36
Legal Framework
Governing Laws
Integrated
e-GP
System
Choosing e-GP Model
Integrated
e-GP
System
000-000-0000

More Related Content

What's hot

Prem George resume 2016
Prem George resume 2016 Prem George resume 2016
Prem George resume 2016
prem george
 
Experience and Qualifications
Experience and QualificationsExperience and Qualifications
Experience and QualificationsApril_B_White
 
KSFs of Aviation Industry
KSFs of Aviation Industry KSFs of Aviation Industry
KSFs of Aviation Industry
Rakeeb Ashraf
 
Writing Effective Technical Specifications
Writing Effective Technical SpecificationsWriting Effective Technical Specifications
Writing Effective Technical Specifications
Mike Purdy
 

What's hot (9)

ResumeJune2015
ResumeJune2015ResumeJune2015
ResumeJune2015
 
Prem George resume 2016
Prem George resume 2016 Prem George resume 2016
Prem George resume 2016
 
JMC Resume V13
JMC Resume V13JMC Resume V13
JMC Resume V13
 
Etendering
EtenderingEtendering
Etendering
 
Experience and Qualifications
Experience and QualificationsExperience and Qualifications
Experience and Qualifications
 
LMA 2 9 16 a
LMA 2 9 16 aLMA 2 9 16 a
LMA 2 9 16 a
 
KSFs of Aviation Industry
KSFs of Aviation Industry KSFs of Aviation Industry
KSFs of Aviation Industry
 
Samer Madanat 1
Samer Madanat 1Samer Madanat 1
Samer Madanat 1
 
Writing Effective Technical Specifications
Writing Effective Technical SpecificationsWriting Effective Technical Specifications
Writing Effective Technical Specifications
 

Similar to 2016_10_10_APPePN_Korea-e_Evaluation_Final_Public

Kamel Badawy- Exploring e-tendering Arab HEUG Conference
Kamel Badawy- Exploring e-tendering Arab HEUG ConferenceKamel Badawy- Exploring e-tendering Arab HEUG Conference
Kamel Badawy- Exploring e-tendering Arab HEUG ConferenceKamel Emad
 
DC Buys 2018 - Information Technology (IT Pipeline) - Full Presentation (Apri...
DC Buys 2018 - Information Technology (IT Pipeline) - Full Presentation (Apri...DC Buys 2018 - Information Technology (IT Pipeline) - Full Presentation (Apri...
DC Buys 2018 - Information Technology (IT Pipeline) - Full Presentation (Apri...
DC Office of Contracting & Procurement (OCP)
 
Rovi Business Solutions
Rovi Business Solutions Rovi Business Solutions
Rovi Business Solutions
William Francis
 
Driving Growth and Profitability through Customer Experience & Process Trans...
Driving Growth and Profitability through Customer Experience & Process Trans...Driving Growth and Profitability through Customer Experience & Process Trans...
Driving Growth and Profitability through Customer Experience & Process Trans...
Brad Power
 
Sourcing Gurus Profile
Sourcing Gurus ProfileSourcing Gurus Profile
Sourcing Gurus Profile
Systems Plus Solutions
 
Implementation of ShipManagement Systems Project Management
Implementation of ShipManagement Systems Project ManagementImplementation of ShipManagement Systems Project Management
Implementation of ShipManagement Systems Project Management
Lana Al-Salem, PMI-ACP, PSM I, PSPO I
 
Shipmanagement System Selection Process
Shipmanagement System Selection ProcessShipmanagement System Selection Process
Shipmanagement System Selection Process
Lana Al-Salem, PMI-ACP, PSM I, PSPO I
 
Service Leaders Network - Introduction
Service Leaders Network - IntroductionService Leaders Network - Introduction
Service Leaders Network - Introduction
Si2 Partners
 
CPQ - Configure, Price and Quoting Excellence
CPQ - Configure, Price and Quoting ExcellenceCPQ - Configure, Price and Quoting Excellence
CPQ - Configure, Price and Quoting Excellence
BearingPoint
 
E governance project conceptualisation to implementation
E governance project conceptualisation to implementationE governance project conceptualisation to implementation
E governance project conceptualisation to implementation
Anirban Mukerji
 
Think tank presentation pmi
Think tank presentation pmiThink tank presentation pmi
Think tank presentation pmi
Tanmoy Paul
 
RoadmapERP Brochure
RoadmapERP BrochureRoadmapERP Brochure
RoadmapERP Brochure
Roadmap ERP
 
Bpm lecture 1 students
Bpm lecture 1 studentsBpm lecture 1 students
Bpm lecture 1 students
Leo Yuvaraj
 
IFMA's World Workplace: Perspectives on the FM Market Development
IFMA's World Workplace: Perspectives on the FM Market DevelopmentIFMA's World Workplace: Perspectives on the FM Market Development
IFMA's World Workplace: Perspectives on the FM Market Development
ISS Group
 
Outsource.ppt
Outsource.pptOutsource.ppt
Outsource.ppt
Sampath Sredharran
 
Guidelines for preparation of a RFP for e governance projects
Guidelines for preparation of a RFP for e governance projectsGuidelines for preparation of a RFP for e governance projects
Guidelines for preparation of a RFP for e governance projects
Anirban Mukerji
 
Proposals that Create High Impact
Proposals that Create High Impact Proposals that Create High Impact
Proposals that Create High Impact
Amit Kumar Das
 
CC&B SMECO Success Story
CC&B SMECO Success StoryCC&B SMECO Success Story
CC&B SMECO Success Story
vijaikrishnan
 
PACE Sourcing & Business Advisory june2020_vf
PACE Sourcing & Business Advisory june2020_vfPACE Sourcing & Business Advisory june2020_vf
PACE Sourcing & Business Advisory june2020_vf
Ajay Garg
 

Similar to 2016_10_10_APPePN_Korea-e_Evaluation_Final_Public (20)

Kamel Badawy- Exploring e-tendering Arab HEUG Conference
Kamel Badawy- Exploring e-tendering Arab HEUG ConferenceKamel Badawy- Exploring e-tendering Arab HEUG Conference
Kamel Badawy- Exploring e-tendering Arab HEUG Conference
 
DC Buys 2018 - Information Technology (IT Pipeline) - Full Presentation (Apri...
DC Buys 2018 - Information Technology (IT Pipeline) - Full Presentation (Apri...DC Buys 2018 - Information Technology (IT Pipeline) - Full Presentation (Apri...
DC Buys 2018 - Information Technology (IT Pipeline) - Full Presentation (Apri...
 
Rovi Business Solutions
Rovi Business Solutions Rovi Business Solutions
Rovi Business Solutions
 
Driving Growth and Profitability through Customer Experience & Process Trans...
Driving Growth and Profitability through Customer Experience & Process Trans...Driving Growth and Profitability through Customer Experience & Process Trans...
Driving Growth and Profitability through Customer Experience & Process Trans...
 
Sourcing Gurus Profile
Sourcing Gurus ProfileSourcing Gurus Profile
Sourcing Gurus Profile
 
Implementation of ShipManagement Systems Project Management
Implementation of ShipManagement Systems Project ManagementImplementation of ShipManagement Systems Project Management
Implementation of ShipManagement Systems Project Management
 
Shipmanagement System Selection Process
Shipmanagement System Selection ProcessShipmanagement System Selection Process
Shipmanagement System Selection Process
 
Service Leaders Network - Introduction
Service Leaders Network - IntroductionService Leaders Network - Introduction
Service Leaders Network - Introduction
 
CPQ - Configure, Price and Quoting Excellence
CPQ - Configure, Price and Quoting ExcellenceCPQ - Configure, Price and Quoting Excellence
CPQ - Configure, Price and Quoting Excellence
 
E governance project conceptualisation to implementation
E governance project conceptualisation to implementationE governance project conceptualisation to implementation
E governance project conceptualisation to implementation
 
Think tank presentation pmi
Think tank presentation pmiThink tank presentation pmi
Think tank presentation pmi
 
RoadmapERP Brochure
RoadmapERP BrochureRoadmapERP Brochure
RoadmapERP Brochure
 
Bpm lecture 1 students
Bpm lecture 1 studentsBpm lecture 1 students
Bpm lecture 1 students
 
IFMA's World Workplace: Perspectives on the FM Market Development
IFMA's World Workplace: Perspectives on the FM Market DevelopmentIFMA's World Workplace: Perspectives on the FM Market Development
IFMA's World Workplace: Perspectives on the FM Market Development
 
Chap02
Chap02Chap02
Chap02
 
Outsource.ppt
Outsource.pptOutsource.ppt
Outsource.ppt
 
Guidelines for preparation of a RFP for e governance projects
Guidelines for preparation of a RFP for e governance projectsGuidelines for preparation of a RFP for e governance projects
Guidelines for preparation of a RFP for e governance projects
 
Proposals that Create High Impact
Proposals that Create High Impact Proposals that Create High Impact
Proposals that Create High Impact
 
CC&B SMECO Success Story
CC&B SMECO Success StoryCC&B SMECO Success Story
CC&B SMECO Success Story
 
PACE Sourcing & Business Advisory june2020_vf
PACE Sourcing & Business Advisory june2020_vfPACE Sourcing & Business Advisory june2020_vf
PACE Sourcing & Business Advisory june2020_vf
 

2016_10_10_APPePN_Korea-e_Evaluation_Final_Public

  • 1.
  • 2. Bidding Price Capabilities Performing the Contract Technical Proposals Evaluation
  • 3.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 8.
  • 10. COMPARISON ICT Experts Committee Pool Superior Companies Contract Officers Computer System / DB Prompt Response Evaluation Entities *Resources Benefits VS Corruption Self-purification Expertise How to Deliver good Result *RBL (Result Based Lending) Incorrect Data Training & Education Linking Systems Ability to perform contract *Problems *Requirement Importance *Point of View VS 10
  • 11.
  • 13.
  • 14. 14
  • 15. 15
  • 16. Pre Qualification in Advance of Bidding Public Notice Bid BiddersProcure Entities Request-Form PQAccept Request-Form PQ K Request-Form PQ Public Notice Accept Request-Form PQ Process Assessment Notice Score of PQ Raising Appeal Confirm Score of PQ Bidding
  • 17. Pre Qualification in Advance of Bidding Unit KRW Million
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21. Comprehensive Evaluation Closing Bidding BiddersProcure Entities Confirm NOTICENotice Selected Tenders Request-Form AssessmentAccept Request-Form K Review Appeal Process Assessment Notice Score of Assessment Raising Appeal Confirm Score of Assessment Selecting Tender Request-Form AssessmentAccept Request-Form Opening Bidding Price
  • 22. Bid Price Capability in imple- mentation Capable construction firm conduct construction at reasonable price Expected Effects
  • 23. 50 Construction execution Capability Professional Past delivery performance(or personnel) Professional skills in relevant construction Dispatched technicians 10 11 Capability Construction evaluation score 15 15 Construction capability by size 3 - Composition of joint supply 2 2 Social responsibility (Plus 1point) Employment of construction labor 0.2 0.2 Safety of construction 0.2 0.2Social responsibility (Plus 1point) Safety of construction 0.2 0.2 Fair trade 0.2 0.2 Contribution to local economy 0.4 0.4 50 Bid price Appropriateness of price calculation (take off points) Evaluation of unit price Evaluation of sub-contracting plan Quality evaluation (take off/add points) Evaluation of construction execution Credibility for contract(take off points) Breach of technicians dispatch plan Point cut Point cut Breach of sub-contracting management plan Point cut Point cut Exceed the sub-contracting price adjustment bottom line Point cut Point cut Breach of construction plan Point cut Point cut
  • 24. Past delivery performance Credit ratingCredit rating Past delivery performance Technical Capability Credit rating
  • 25. Capability for supply of contracted products Past performance Equivalent or more qualified products to contracted one Equivalent products Technical capability Technology level Management status Credit rating Refer to overage score calculation equation Bid price Bid price Refer to overage score calculation equation Credit rating Quality management Degree of trust Ultrahigh certification, green, general certificates, women- owned, disabled, SMEs, job creation, joint venture Reasons for disqualification Relevant products Delivery completion Capability Reasons for Disqualification It is judged that contract completion is seen as difficult for some reasons like bankruptcy (except, court decides for receivership, authorization on completion) Limited Competition (exceeding KRW 1 billion) to Manufacturers for Supply of Manufacturing Products
  • 26. RFP Bidding Proposal Evaluation Negotiation Selecting Tender Contract Projects are necessary for ensuring the expertise or technical capacity in performing a contract
  • 27. Items of Evaluation and Score Negotiations Define Equality Review
  • 28. Key Features of Negotiation Contract of PPS • Efficient• Fairness Entrusting Evaluation Service On-line Proposal Evaluation K • Expertis e • Transpar ency Entrusting Evaluation Service On-line Proposal Evaluation Committee Experts Pool Committee Member Selection System
  • 29. ICT Project Proposal Evaluation Committee Regulation Consist of ICT Project Proposal Evaluation Committee Scale of the pool Members of committees Call for members Method of Committee
  • 30. Electronic Documents Auto Calling System Contract Officer Audit Officer Specialists Selecting appropriate ICT Groups Operating CMSS Attending the committeeManagementPool 6,000 Experts Selecting appropriate ICT Groups Operating CMSS Attending the committeeManagementPool 6,000 Experts
  • 31. 31
  • 32. Strategy and method Comprehension on project, strategies, applicable technologies, standard frame work application and method for development Skills and functions System requirements, update of function, security request, data request, system operation Skills and functions System requirements, update of function, security request, data request, system operation Performance and quality Performance, quality requests, interface request, and green sector contribution Project management Management method, implementation plan, equipment for development Project support Quality endorsement, test operation, training, maintenance, confidentiality, contingency plan Co-existence and sub- contracting Co-existence, sub-contracting appropriateness
  • 33.
  • 35. 600 700 800 900 250,000 300,000 350,000 400,000 USD Billion - 100 200 300 400 500 - 50,000 100,000 150,000 200,000 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Public Private Biddings Smart APP Scale of Bidding
  • 36. 600,000 700,000 800,000 900,000 1,000,000 - Transaction Cost Savings - KONEPS in 2012- - Reduced lead-time - Streamlined Process We have to stride forward to tran sparent public procurement in or der to make a difference in the As ia and Pacific region. What we are doing here will be r ecorded as meaningful and practi cal case studies. The outcome of APP e-PN’s initi ative will be used by other countr ies across the world. - 100,000 200,000 300,000 400,000 500,000 600,000 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 Public Private Smart APP Scale of Bidding Biddings - Reduced lead-time - Streamlined Process We have to stride forward to tran sparent public procurement in or der to make a difference in the As ia and Pacific region. What we are doing here will be r ecorded as meaningful and practi cal case studies. The outcome of APP e-PN’s initi ative will be used by other countr ies across the world. 36
  • 37.