SlideShare a Scribd company logo
JUNE 2014 
Securing the Global Pharmaceutical 
Supply Chain against the Threat of 
Counterfeit Drugs.
With a fully integrated GxP-compliant transport, storage and distribution system in place 
and over 140 wholly owned ISO 9001 - certified offices in more than 50 countries, WORLD 
COURIER, an AmerisourceBergen® company, is the world’s largest and most experienced 
provider of specialty courier services. It is uniquely positioned to meet the most demanding 
industry requirements for managing the global distribution of time - and temperature-sensitive 
2 
pharmaceutical products and IMPs used commercially or in clinical trials. 
Securing the Global 
Pharmaceutical Supply 
Chain against the Threat of 
Counterfeit Drugs 
In 2012, counterfeit versions of the cancer drug 
Avastin were found in 19 American treatment 
centers. The impostor drug lacked the active 
ingredient, rendering it virtually useless for 
treatment purposes. The same year, counterfeits 
of Viagra and Cialis smuggled into the U.K. were 
found to contain undeclared active ingredients 
that posed potentially serious health risks to 
consumers. One year earlier, almost 3,000 patients 
in Kenya were affected by a falsified batch of 
the antiretroviral therapy Zidolam-N, used in the 
treatment of HIV/AIDS. And in 2009, counterfeits of 
a traditional anti-diabetic medicine killed two and 
hospitalized nine in China before it was determined 
that the fraudulent drug contained six times the 
normal dose of glibenclamide, a chemical used to 
lower blood sugar1. 
Isolated incidents? Sadly, no. Instead, 
according to world health officials, this is just 
the tip of the iceberg as falsified and counterfeit 
drugs take on a life of their own in burgeoning grey 
markets and increasingly slip into the 
legitimate supply chain. 
Diagnosis: History and Scope of 
the Problem 
According to the World Health Organization 
(WHO), the prevalence of spurious, falsely-labelled, 
falsified, or counterfeit medicines, or SFFC 
medicines as they are known − medicines that are 
deliberately and fraudulently produced, packaged 
and/or mislabeled − is a growing trend worldwide 
which threatens both patient safety as well as 
public confidence in the health systems and 
regulatory bodies designed to provide oversight 
and control. 
SFFC medicines are found everywhere in the 
world. They range from random mixtures of 
harmful toxic substances to inactive, ineffective 
preparations. Some contain a declared, active 
ingredient and look so similar to the genuine 
product that they deceive health professionals 
as well as patients. But in every case, the source 
of a SFFC medicine is unknown and its content 
unreliable. SFFC medicines are always illegal. 
They can result in treatment failure or even death. 
Eliminating them is a considerable public 
health challenge2. 
1 “Medicines: spurious/falsely-labelled/falsified/counterfeit (SFFC) medicines”, World Health 
Organization, Fact sheet No.275, May 2012 
2Ibid.
3 
About Counterfeit Drugs 
First identified as an issue in the mid-1980s when 
counterfeiters began reproducing soft “lifestyle” 
drugs used to combat obesity and baldness, etc., 
the replication of mass market prescription drugs 
such as birth control, medications for erectile 
dysfunction, diabetes, hypertension and high 
cholesterol as well as vaccines, antibiotics and 
antimalarials soon followed. 
More than 25 years later, the scope of falsified 
drugs has mushroomed to include high-value 
drugs in high demand as well as life-saving 
drugs used to treat cancer, HIV/AIDS, serious 
cardiovascular disease and even those used 
to support organ transplants. None of today’s 
drugs or therapeutic treatments is exempt from 
unauthorized replication. Targeted medicines 
now include both branded and generic drugs and 
run the full gambit − everything from low-cost 
generic painkillers and antihistamines to high-value 
blockbuster drugs and specialty medicines used to 
treat life-threatening conditions. Even injectables 
and medical devices have not been spared. 
According to WHO statistics3 collected in 2000: 
• 32.1% of identified counterfeit drugs 
contained no active ingredient 
• 20.2% had incorrect quantities of 
active ingredients 
• 21.4% contained the wrong ingredients 
• 5.6% had correct ingredients, 
but fake packaging 
• 8.5% contained high levels of impurities 
• 1% were copies of an original product 
The impact on patients from using fraudulent drugs 
can range dramatically: from failure to treat minor 
symptoms to failure to treat critical illnesses to 
drug resistance caused by long-term exposure 
to reduced amounts of active ingredients to 
death. Each year between 100,0004 and as many 
as 1 million5 people die from counterfeit drugs 
according to varying statistics. Produced in sub-standard 
facilities with little to no quality control, 
these fraudulent medicines contain an array of 
questionable ingredients including, among other 
things, caffeine, rat poison, starch, chalk, gypsum, 
flour, sugar and even acetaminophen, used to 
lower fevers and promote the belief that the 
drug is working. 
3World Health Organization, “General information on counterfeit medicines”, 2000 
4 Bate, Roger, “The deadly world of falsified and substandard medicine”, American Enterprise 
Institute, October 15, 2012 
5Southwickz, Natalie, “Counterfeit Drugs Kill 1Mn People Annually: Interpol”, InSightCrime.org, 
October 24, 2013.
In 2013, for instance, through joint international law enforcement 
and the efforts of almost 100 countries, over 10 million potentially 
dangerous medicines worth some $36 million were seized, 
resulting in 213 arrests worldwide. 
4 
6 Grogan, Kevin, “One in five Europeans buying fake drugs − Pfizer survey”, PharmaTimes online, 
Februrary 16, 2010 
7 “Counterfeit Drugs: Fighting Illegal Supply Chains”, a report by Lev Kubiak, Director National 
Intellectual Property Rights Coordination Center, Homeland Security Investigations, U.S. 
Immigration and Customs Enforcement, February 27, 2014 
and where law enforcement is more aggressive 
− the occurrence of counterfeiting is statistically 
reduced to 1% or less. 
Although the percentage may seem negligible, 
actual numbers help to put the situation into 
better perspective. In the United States alone, 
more than 4 billion prescriptions were issued in 
2011, equating to over 40 million prescriptions 
that were filled using counterfeit medicines. A 
survey conducted in 14 European countries by 
Pfizer in 2010 estimated that 
more than €10.5 billion (U.S. $14 billion) was 
spent each year on illicitly-sourced prescription 
drugs including those used for weight loss, 
influenza and erectile dysfunction; many of 
these drugs were counterfeit. The study further 
notedthat the number of counterfeit drugs 
uncovered at EU borders increased from 560,598 
articles in 2005 to 4,081,056 in 20076. 
By all accounts, the situation promises to 
intensify and although global recognition of the 
problem now exists, controlling it has 
been daunting. In 2013, for instance, through 
joint international law enforcement and the 
efforts of almost 100 countries, over 10 million 
potentially dangerous medicines worth some 
$36 million were seized, resulting in 213 
arrests worldwide. 
In addition, almost 14,000 websites hosted by 
illegal online pharmacies were identified and shut 
down and more than 530,000 packages were 
inspected by customs and regulatory authorities. 
Of these, almost 42,000 packages − containing 
everything from antibiotics, cancer medication 
and anti-depressants to erectile dysfunction 
medication and dietary supplements − 
were seized7. 
Prevalence and Geographical Reach of 
Counterfeit Drugs 
In today’s globalized pharmaceutical industry, it is 
thought that 10% of all drugs distributed globally are 
counterfeit. An estimated 80% of these counterfeits 
are produced overseas, with China and India 
identified as the leading suppliers. Worldwide sales 
of counterfeit drugs are estimated by WHO to be in 
excess of $75 billion annually, with some sources 
approximating annual market value to be as high as 
$200 billion. As one might expect, accurate data is 
hard to come by. 
Developing nations have historically been prime 
targets for counterfeits, in part because of a 
weaker import and regulatory infrastructure, but 
also due to sheer economics and the inability 
of large populations to widely access expensive 
drugs. While Asia, with over 60% of the world’s 
population, currently represents the largest market 
for counterfeits, Africa, Latin America and politically 
and economically destabilized regions are all 
similarly attractive targets for those distributing rogue 
products. Based on WHO estimates, approximately 
30% of the drugs distributed in these geographies 
are counterfeit. Some estimates for specific countries 
are as high as 60%. Adding to this, the growth of 
Internet-based commercial drug sales − both for 
products destined to as well as those emanating 
from developing nations − has merely exacerbated 
the problem. 
In industrialized nations like the U.S., Canada, 
most EU countries, Australia, New Zealand and 
Japan − where median income is higher, where the 
pharmaceutical supply chain is better protected by 
stronger customs, import and regulatory oversight,
5 
According to recent WHO studies: 
• Some 10% of all pharmaceuticals distributed 
world wide are counterfeit 
• Between 30% and 60% of drugs distributed in 
developing countries are counterfeit 
• Approximately 1% of counterfeit drugs have 
penetrated the supply chain in 
developed countries 
• Over 50% of drugs purchased online from sites 
that conceal their physical addresses 
are countefeit 
• Worldwide sales of counterfeit drugs is in excess 
of $75 billion annually 
Prevention: Technological and 
Regulatory Countermeasures 
With the escalation of drug counterfeiting in 
the mid-1990s, a number of technological, 
regulatory, industry-driven and national initiatives 
were launched to help combat the problem. 
Clearly it must continue to be a collective effort 
if inroads are to be made in controlling the 
occurrence of counterfeit drugs. 
Packaging Innovation 
Over time, pharmaceutical packaging has 
evolved to provide better protection for both 
product and patient. In the past decade, steps 
were taken to securitize and authenticate 
pharmaceuticals initially by adding visible and/or 
hidden security features such as hologram 
labels and other brand protection features to the 
packaging. Although these measures provided 
some deterrents, those same technologies have 
also fallen prey to counterfeiting and, as such, 
have not successfully eliminated the problem in 
any meaningful way. 
The newest technologies now being utilized 
include 2D barcodes applied directly to the 
packaging which retain considerably more data 
than previous barcodes, and Radio Frequency 
ID (RFID) tags which create an electronic record 
of chain of custody from point of manufacture to 
point of dispensing. While many pharmaceutical 
companies are already using forms of these 
technologies, pending regulatory changes are 
slated to move these solutions into the global 
supply chain in the coming years, with more 
onus being put on the verification of individual 
medicines at the patient dispensing level.
6 
International Collaboration 
In 2006, the International Medical Products 
Anti-Counterfeiting Task Force (IMPACT), a 
partnership involving 193 WHO Member States, 
a variety of international and non-governmental 
organizations, law enforcement agencies, 
pharmaceutical manufacturing associations and 
drug and regulatory authorities was formed. Its 
mandate has been to work with countries and the 
industry to better detect and safeguard against the 
widespread distribution of fraudulent drugs and 
to minimize criminal activity through stronger and 
more collaborative international law enforcement. 
Regulatory Reform 
On a regional basis and as might be expected, the 
U.S. and the EU are leading the way with regulatory 
solutions to help circumvent the problem. 
Falsified Medicines Directive (2011/62/EU) 
The European Commission’s Falsified Medicines 
Directive (2011/62/EU) was written into law in 2011, 
amending former legislation aimed at preventing 
falsified medicinal products from entering the 
legitimate supply chain. This legislation strengthens 
controls and checks on products moving through 
the supply chain and includes stricter controls 
on the sourcing of active product ingredients and 
excipients, especially those originating from non- 
EU countries. 
It also calls for new or extended obligations on 
the part of importers and distributors of active 
substances, brokers, product manufacturers 
and wholesalers while mandating legal online 
pharmacies to display a common EU-wide logo 
on company websites. An additional requirement 
now demands that an obligatory authentication 
and safety feature appears on the outer packaging 
(unique pack identification). 
Member states were required to transpose the 
directive into national law by January 2, 2013 
while provisions related to the importation of 
active substances from third countries came into 
effect July 1, 2013. Specific legislation on the 
implementation of safety features (unique identifier) 
is due in 2014, with mandatory application of 
this identifier and medicinal product verification 
expected in the EU by 2017. 
In anticipation of upcoming regulatory changes, 
two product verification initiatives are already in 
use in Europe. The European Stakeholder Model 
(ESM) is a cloud-based point-of-dispensing 
verification system that uses 2D data matrix 
barcodes to authenticate medicines and ensure 
that patients are receiving a genuine product. Data 
matrix codes are affixed by the manufacturer (if 
necessary, the product is verified and repackaged 
by the parallel distributor with a new number) and 
then uploaded to a central European database. 
This number may also be verified by both the 
wholesaler and pharmacy. Data includes the 
product number, batch number, expiry date and 
a unique serial number, with unregistered codes 
sending an immediate alert that the product 
may have been falsified. This system will be 
overseen by the European Medicines Verification 
Organization (EMVO), a non-profit organization that 
will manage the European Hub which links national 
systems throughout Europe. Launched in 2012, the 
system has been successfully tested in Sweden. 
Germany’s securPharm verification system was 
integrated with the ESM model in 2013 and the 
proposed European Hub is expected to be fully 
operational by mid-2014. 
Also launched in 2012, the European Directorate 
for the Quality of Medicines and Healthcare 
(EDQM) eTACT program is similarly a track-and-trace 
system that relies on unique identification 
numbers adhered to individual packaging to verify 
the authenticity of a medication. This number is 
affixed by the manufacturer and can be used by 
all legitimate supply chain members to verify the 
product. A final verification must be performed at 
the dispensing location. Unique to this system, 
however, patients themselves are able to trace
The DQSA is a progressive law that has many milestones which 
must be met by the pharmaceutical industry, with the end goal of 
having a full traceability solution in place by 2023. 
National Initiatives 
At the international level, countries are 
implementing their own strategies to combat the 
growing threat of counterfeit drugs. 
China is the world’s top producer of both legitimate 
and counterfeit drugs. In 2001, the existing Drug 
Administration Law of the PRC was amended 
to increase penalties on the production and sale 
of falsified drugs. Since then other laws have 
been enacted to control counterfeit activities by 
regulating API manufacturers, for instance, a key 
to controlling counterfeit activities. While the State 
Food and Drug Administration (SFDA) has also 
increased routine inspection and sampling as 
well as enacted new labeling laws, enforcement 
remains weak and the system cumbersome. 
Technological solutions including 2D data matrix 
bar-coding and RFID tags remain expensive 
to implement. 
As one of the world’s top manufacturers of generic 
and patent drugs, India has taken steps to limit 
counterfeit drug production nationally following a 
2005 estimate that some 75% of falsified drugs 
distributed globally have some origins in that 
country8. Although this estimate has been hotly 
disputed and never proven, India’s Directorate 
General of Foreign Trade (DGFT) amended labeling 
requirements in 2011, making it mandatory 
for every drug manufactured in that country 
designated for export to bear a Unique Product 
Identification Code (GTIN) as well as 1D or 2D 
bar-coding on primary, secondary and 
tertiary packaging. 
Meanwhile in Africa, the newly launched mPedigree 
Network, an SMS-based technology developed by 
7 
and verify the safety of the medication, potentially 
strengthening public confidence. EDQM is a public, 
inter-governmental organization that promotes 
quality standards for the safe use of 
medicines worldwide. 
Drug Quality and Security Act (DQSA) 
In the U.S., the newly-enacted Drug Quality 
and Security Act (DQSA) was signed into law in 
November 2013 by President Obama, effectively 
preempting all existing state laws and regulations 
related to pedigree. The DQSA is a progressive law 
that has many milestones which must be met by 
the pharmaceutical industry, with the end goal of 
having a full traceability solution in place by 2023. 
The federal DQSA aims to incorporate drug 
transactional information into a new electronic 
traceability system that will allow health systems, 
hospitals and pharmacies to trace prescription 
drugs through the supply chain. 
Required transactional information will include the 
name of the drug, its strength, quantity, dosage, 
National Drug Code (NDC), lot number, container/ 
packaging size, date of transaction, date of 
shipment and name and address of both shipper 
and consignee, all of which will provide additional 
business value. Included in the legislation are 
federal licensure standards for third-party logistics 
providers (3PLs) and wholesale distributors. In 
addition, manufacturers will be required to apply 
a 2D barcode that contains a product identifier, 
serial number, lot number and expiration date by 
November 2017. Wholesaler drug distributors must 
follow suit by November 2019 and dispensers by 
November 2020. The full traceability solution is set 
to be implemented by November 2023.
8 
Ghanaian entrepreneur Bright Simons, began its 
roll-out in Nigeria in 2013 when the system became 
accessible to over 50 million mobile subscribers. 
The technology allows patients to authenticate 
their medicine by sending a free text message 
to a special hotline and receiving an immediate 
OK or NO response. The reply is accompanied 
by the name of the medication and a picture of 
the packaging for visual comparison. Patients 
need only scratch off a panel on the prescription 
packaging to reveal the unique ID number. This 
technology is now being tested in Ghana and being 
considered by other African states. Patients in 
Africa have been highly vulnerable to the negative 
effects of counterfeit drugs, with as many as 
700,000 deaths per year linked to sub-standard 
malaria drugs and tuberculosis vaccines. 
Moving Forward 
The cost associated with counterfeit drugs is 
staggering − both in human and commercial terms. 
In some cases, patients are deprived of treatment 
for diseases and conditions that range from mild to 
severe to life-threatening. In other cases, they are 
harmed by dangerous substances in the product, 
or become resistant to traditional therapeutic 
treatments or vaccines. In all cases, the public 
loses confidence in the companies that develop 
these drugs and in the very agencies that have 
been established to protect them. 
For the pharmaceutical industry, the prevalence of 
counterfeit drugs can represent loss of reputation, 
loss of valuable R&D efforts and intellectual 
property, loss of revenue and increased costs. 
Many companies, for instance, now operate their 
own anti-counterfeit units to police their product 
lines and reduce the impact of counterfeiting on 
the organization. Despite these efforts, the growth 
of counterfeit drugs is only expected to increase 
within the parameters of a globalized industry, 
especially as the cost of healthcare 
spirals worldwide. 
What can pharmaceutical professionals do to 
ensure that their organizations and the patients 
they serve are not impacted by counterfeit drugs? 
The answer is to identify their highest risk products 
and shipments and to secure their supply chain to 
the fullest extent possible. 
In the falsified Avastin case referenced at the 
beginning of this article, it was later found that 
the vials were sourced in Turkey and shipped 
to Switzerland, then Denmark and finally to the 
U.K. before being exported to a U.S. wholesale 
distributor hired by a Canadian company which 
was ultimately owned by an online retail pharmacy. 
In another case, counterfeit product was slipped 
into an existing shipment of legitimate drugs 
destined for a hospital simply by adding an 
extra zero to the unit count on the paperwork. 
In yet another case, a legitimate shipment of 
temperature-controlled drugs was hijacked, with 
the product later re-introduced into the supply 
chain without the benefit of quality assurance. 
8Lal, Neeta, “Fake drugs a bitter pill for India”, Asia Times online, June 7, 2008.
Virtually every medicinal product is a target in today’s world. Although all pharmaceutical shipments are 
important, pharmaceutical professionals should evaluate the severity of risks associated with a specific 
product prior to shipping, and consider prioritizing its journey through the supply chain as required. 
• Does the provider have experience/expertise in 
managing high-value pharmaceutical shipments? 
What type of track record/reputation does he 
have with clients, airlines, regulatory and 
customs agencies? 
• Is the scope of operation global or regional? 
• Does the company employ staff worldwide or 
utilize the services of third-party providers? If the 
latter, what specific locations are not managed 
by company employees? Do these destinations 
appear in your distribution portfolio? 
9 
• Do operatives in all locations act in strict 
accordance with documented 
company-wide SOPs? 
• Is the organization GxP-compliant in all locations, 
or in select locations? ISO certified? 
• Is there a quality management/quality assurance 
policy and team in place? 
• Does it function independently from the 
operational side of the organization? 
• How is quality oversight managed in the 
field? Is there an SOP for incidence reporting? 
• Are suitable security procedures in place with 
respect to employee verification and screening? 
• Are all security procedures and verification 
consistent in all locations? 
• Can the service provider clearly demonstrate that 
policies and practices are enacted rigorously and 
consistently from origin to destination for each 
elected locations? 
Identifying High Risk Shipments 
Questions to consider include: 
• Who is the targeted patient group? Is it an 
at-risk group like infants or the elderly who are 
more susceptible to a counterfeit product? 
• How will the drug be used? Will it be used to treat 
a chronic condition? Does a single dose have the 
potential to kill? 
• How is it administered? By a healthcare 
professional? By the patient? 
• What is the patient impact if the medication 
contains no active ingredient? An excess of 
active ingredients? 
• Does the product require cold chain handling to 
maintain stability/efficacy? 
• How much annual revenue does the product 
generate? What role does it play in the 
product portfolio? 
• Is the product a flagship brand? A blockbuster? 
• How attractive is the product to counterfeiters (i.e. 
high unit price? Product shortage? 
High volume usage?) 
• What region is the shipment destined for? What 
regional risk factors exist with respect to 
counterfeit drugs? 
• Does the provider offer a full suite of services 
(i.e. packaging, temperature control, transport, 
storage, local delivery), or will services be handled 
piecemeal by multiple suppliers?
The best strategy to ensure full supply chain compliance is by partnering 
with and building a long-term relationship with a single closed-loop 
logistics provider able to manage all aspects of the transport and storage 
of bulk high-value pharmaceutical shipments worldwide. 
10 
Tightening the Supply Chain 
As today’s global pharmaceutical supply 
chain grows increasingly longer and more 
complex, each link provides added opportunity 
for counterfeiters. While pending regulatory 
changes promise to tighten the supply chain with 
respect to production and distribution entities 
and new packaging technologies will make the 
identification of counterfeit products easier, the 
logistics of global distribution remains a weak 
link. How can the pharmaceutical shipper ensure 
the security of the supply chain over thousands 
of miles and extended periods of time when the 
product is no longer in his possession? 
The best strategy to ensure full supply chain 
compliance is by partnering with and building a 
long-term relationship with a single closed-loop 
logistics provider able to manage all aspects 
of the transport and storage of bulk high-value 
pharmaceutical shipments worldwide. 
Benefits include: 
• Enhanced control from a proven, 
trusted source 
• Clear chain of custody at all points 
during transit 
• Elimination of unnecessary third-party risk 
• Local representation and accountability in 
complex and often unpredictable geographies 
By utilizing the services of a GxP-compliant 
logistics supplier, pharmaceutical shippers can 
automatically ensure that they conform to all 
current regulatory requirements as they relate to 
the transport of their high-value pharmaceutical 
products. Equally important, they can be assured 
that the same standard operating procedures 
(SOPs) are employed worldwide to ensure 
product security to the greatest extent possible. 
Shippers may also consider utilizing a local 
warehousing solution in emerging or strategic 
locations to reduce the costs and peril associated 
with multiple bulk shipments and to shorten 
distribution timelines. A fully-integrated logistics 
provider able to accommodate packaging, cold 
chain, transport, storage and local in-country 
or regional distribution is a practical solution for 
maintaining security in challenging locations. 
As a word of caution, however, all logistics 
providers are not created equal, so 
pharmaceutical shippers should be prepared to 
carefully qualify all contenders. 
Identifying a logistics provider with trained staff, 
a well-maintained infrastructure and network-wide 
processes in place at the global level 
will go a long way toward securing the supply 
chain and protecting the interests of both the 
pharmaceutical company and its patients, 
particularly in those areas of the world at greatest 
risk or where local representation is lacking.
Dr. Rüdiger Lomb is Global Director, Quality & Technical Compliance for World Courier, an 
AmerisourceBergen® company. Since joining World Courier in 2008, Dr. Lomb has brought his 
considerable technical expertise to bear on shaping and refining the company’s Quality Assurance 
program. Dr. Lomb was formerly Group Head and Director of the Global Logistics Clinical Supplies 
Division for Bayer Schering Pharma AG in Germany where he was responsible for the auditing and 
qualification of depot and transportation service providers. Dr. Lomb is a licensed pharmacist and 
holds a Ph.D. in pharmaceutical bio-chemistry. 
11 
For contact information visit 
www.worldcourier.com 
Bibliography 
Ali (Dr.), Shaukat, “Growing Counterfeit in Medicine Worldwide and its Impact on Health and World 
Economy,” ABHINAV International Monthly Refereed Journal of Research in Management & Technology, 
ISSN − 2320-0073, Volume II, June 2013 
Bate, Roger, “The deadly world of falsified and substandard medicine”, American Enterprise Institute, 
October 15, 2012 
Daigle, Lisa A., M.A., “Following Pharmaceutical Products Through the Supply Chain”, ASHP Policy 
Analysis, American Society of Health-System Pharmacists®, August 2012 
Grogan, Kevin, “One in five Europeans buying fake drugs − Pfizer survey”, PharmaTimes online, 
Februrary 16, 2010 
Kubiak, Lev, “Counterfeit Drugs: Fighting Illegal Supply Chains”, report by the Director, National 
Intellectual Property Rights Coordination Center, Homeland Security Investigations, U.S. Immigration 
and Customs Enforcement, February 27, 2014 
Lal, Neeta, “Fake drugs a bitter pill for India”, Asia Times online, June 7, 2008 
McKeon, Owen J., “Counterfeit Drugs The Challenges of a Deadly Global Epidemic”, FOCUS on the 
New Jersey Chapter, Association of Corporate Counsel, New Jersey (NJCCA) Chapter, June 2013 
Rice, Andy, “Fighting Africa’s fake-drug monster”, dailymaverick.co.za, June 23, 2013
12 
Southwick, Natalie, “Counterfeit Drugs Kill 1 Mn People Annually: Interpol”, InSightCrime.org, 
October 24, 2013 
Sun, Lei, “Anti-counterfeiting Situation in China”, Bureau of Inspection, SFDA of China, 2010-2012 
Trent, Christopher and Moyer, Douglas C., Ph.D., CPP, “Assessing the Risks of Counterfeiting and Illicit 
Diversion for Health Care Products”, A-CAPP Paper Series, Michigan State University, Center for Anti- 
Counterfeiting and Product Protection, November 2013 
Woodcock, Janet, M.D., “Securing our Nation’s Prescription Drug Supply Chain”, statement of the 
Director, Center for Drug Evaluation and Research, Food and Drug Administration, April 25, 2013 
“Counterfeiting in the Pharmaceutical Industry; a look at the Bitter Pill in China”, 
© Baker & McKenzie 2013 
“General information on counterfeit medicines”, World Health Organization, © WHO 2014 
“Growing threat from counterfeit medicines”, Bulletin of the World Health Organization, Volume 88, 
Number 4, April 2010, 241-320 
“Medicines: spurious/falsely-labelled/falsified/counterfeit (SFFC) medicines”, World Health Organization, 
Fact sheet No275, May 2012 
“Rx-360 Supply Chain Security White Paper: Cargo Risk Assessment”, Rx-360, An International 
Pharmaceutical Supply Chain Consortium, May 2, 2012

More Related Content

What's hot

Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other ProductsDetection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Nancy Sperling
 
Counterfeit monitoring licensing
Counterfeit monitoring licensingCounterfeit monitoring licensing
Counterfeit monitoring licensing
Javis Von Onias
 
Counterfeit Drugs in America: 2017 Overview
Counterfeit Drugs in America: 2017 OverviewCounterfeit Drugs in America: 2017 Overview
Counterfeit Drugs in America: 2017 Overview
The Partnership For Safe Medicines
 
Counterfeits Kill
Counterfeits KillCounterfeits Kill
Counterfeits Killcmebahamas
 
Toc project roll no
Toc project  roll no Toc project  roll no
Toc project roll no
pdf uploader
 
Provisions for drug registration CFDA
Provisions for drug registration CFDAProvisions for drug registration CFDA
Provisions for drug registration CFDA
Croxxmore Medical Device Consulting Service
 
Health economics pharma lab ppt
Health economics pharma lab pptHealth economics pharma lab ppt
Health economics pharma lab ppt
Ton Mausisa
 
Principles of mgmt ppt
Principles of mgmt pptPrinciples of mgmt ppt
Principles of mgmt pptSaurabh wani
 
Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs
Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit DrugsMultiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs
Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugsguest696d96
 
Philadelphia Dropping The Gavel On Counterfeit Drugs
Philadelphia Dropping The Gavel On Counterfeit DrugsPhiladelphia Dropping The Gavel On Counterfeit Drugs
Philadelphia Dropping The Gavel On Counterfeit Drugs
Chris Miller
 
Pharma Regulatory Affairs in Argentina 2013
Pharma Regulatory Affairs in Argentina 2013Pharma Regulatory Affairs in Argentina 2013
Pharma Regulatory Affairs in Argentina 2013María Inés Guaia
 
What is an orphan drug?
What is an orphan drug?What is an orphan drug?
What is an orphan drug?
Peder S. Andersen
 
Pharmaceutical industry
Pharmaceutical industryPharmaceutical industry
Pharmaceutical industry
Apurv Singh
 
Pharmaceutical Regulations in GCC countries
Pharmaceutical Regulations in GCC countriesPharmaceutical Regulations in GCC countries
Pharmaceutical Regulations in GCC countries
Iman Ajami
 
US, EU & Japan GMP Requirements: Practical ICH Area Differences & Healthcare ...
US, EU & Japan GMP Requirements: Practical ICH Area Differences & Healthcare ...US, EU & Japan GMP Requirements: Practical ICH Area Differences & Healthcare ...
US, EU & Japan GMP Requirements: Practical ICH Area Differences & Healthcare ...
AudioEducator
 
Global Pharma Market
Global Pharma MarketGlobal Pharma Market
Global Pharma Market
Philip Corsano
 
Clinical Trials In Latin America
Clinical Trials In Latin America Clinical Trials In Latin America
Clinical Trials In Latin America
BrazilPharmaNews.com
 
Kuwait
KuwaitKuwait
Kuwait
Vinod Raj
 

What's hot (19)

Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other ProductsDetection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
 
Counterfeit monitoring licensing
Counterfeit monitoring licensingCounterfeit monitoring licensing
Counterfeit monitoring licensing
 
Counterfeit Drugs in America: 2017 Overview
Counterfeit Drugs in America: 2017 OverviewCounterfeit Drugs in America: 2017 Overview
Counterfeit Drugs in America: 2017 Overview
 
Counterfeits Kill
Counterfeits KillCounterfeits Kill
Counterfeits Kill
 
Toc project roll no
Toc project  roll no Toc project  roll no
Toc project roll no
 
Provisions for drug registration CFDA
Provisions for drug registration CFDAProvisions for drug registration CFDA
Provisions for drug registration CFDA
 
Health economics pharma lab ppt
Health economics pharma lab pptHealth economics pharma lab ppt
Health economics pharma lab ppt
 
Principles of mgmt ppt
Principles of mgmt pptPrinciples of mgmt ppt
Principles of mgmt ppt
 
Rogowsky
RogowskyRogowsky
Rogowsky
 
Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs
Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit DrugsMultiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs
Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs
 
Philadelphia Dropping The Gavel On Counterfeit Drugs
Philadelphia Dropping The Gavel On Counterfeit DrugsPhiladelphia Dropping The Gavel On Counterfeit Drugs
Philadelphia Dropping The Gavel On Counterfeit Drugs
 
Pharma Regulatory Affairs in Argentina 2013
Pharma Regulatory Affairs in Argentina 2013Pharma Regulatory Affairs in Argentina 2013
Pharma Regulatory Affairs in Argentina 2013
 
What is an orphan drug?
What is an orphan drug?What is an orphan drug?
What is an orphan drug?
 
Pharmaceutical industry
Pharmaceutical industryPharmaceutical industry
Pharmaceutical industry
 
Pharmaceutical Regulations in GCC countries
Pharmaceutical Regulations in GCC countriesPharmaceutical Regulations in GCC countries
Pharmaceutical Regulations in GCC countries
 
US, EU & Japan GMP Requirements: Practical ICH Area Differences & Healthcare ...
US, EU & Japan GMP Requirements: Practical ICH Area Differences & Healthcare ...US, EU & Japan GMP Requirements: Practical ICH Area Differences & Healthcare ...
US, EU & Japan GMP Requirements: Practical ICH Area Differences & Healthcare ...
 
Global Pharma Market
Global Pharma MarketGlobal Pharma Market
Global Pharma Market
 
Clinical Trials In Latin America
Clinical Trials In Latin America Clinical Trials In Latin America
Clinical Trials In Latin America
 
Kuwait
KuwaitKuwait
Kuwait
 

Viewers also liked

Accountability In The Medicines Supply Chain
Accountability In The Medicines Supply ChainAccountability In The Medicines Supply Chain
Accountability In The Medicines Supply Chain
MeTApresents
 
International logistics and transportation
International logistics and transportationInternational logistics and transportation
International logistics and transportationTim Feemster
 
Glenmark pharma ppt final
Glenmark pharma ppt finalGlenmark pharma ppt final
Glenmark pharma ppt finalSuraj Warthy
 
Final supply chain in pharma
Final supply chain in pharmaFinal supply chain in pharma
Final supply chain in pharmaJai Verma
 
Supply Chain Management Glenmark Pharma
Supply Chain Management Glenmark PharmaSupply Chain Management Glenmark Pharma
Supply Chain Management Glenmark PharmaAbhishek Dhamankar
 
The Pharmaceutical Supply Chain
The Pharmaceutical Supply ChainThe Pharmaceutical Supply Chain
The Pharmaceutical Supply Chain
Ann McGee
 
Supply chain issues in Pharma industry
Supply chain issues in Pharma industrySupply chain issues in Pharma industry
Supply chain issues in Pharma industry
Jaimeen Rana
 
Pharmaceutical Supply Chain
Pharmaceutical Supply ChainPharmaceutical Supply Chain
Pharmaceutical Supply ChainDivya Kumar
 

Viewers also liked (8)

Accountability In The Medicines Supply Chain
Accountability In The Medicines Supply ChainAccountability In The Medicines Supply Chain
Accountability In The Medicines Supply Chain
 
International logistics and transportation
International logistics and transportationInternational logistics and transportation
International logistics and transportation
 
Glenmark pharma ppt final
Glenmark pharma ppt finalGlenmark pharma ppt final
Glenmark pharma ppt final
 
Final supply chain in pharma
Final supply chain in pharmaFinal supply chain in pharma
Final supply chain in pharma
 
Supply Chain Management Glenmark Pharma
Supply Chain Management Glenmark PharmaSupply Chain Management Glenmark Pharma
Supply Chain Management Glenmark Pharma
 
The Pharmaceutical Supply Chain
The Pharmaceutical Supply ChainThe Pharmaceutical Supply Chain
The Pharmaceutical Supply Chain
 
Supply chain issues in Pharma industry
Supply chain issues in Pharma industrySupply chain issues in Pharma industry
Supply chain issues in Pharma industry
 
Pharmaceutical Supply Chain
Pharmaceutical Supply ChainPharmaceutical Supply Chain
Pharmaceutical Supply Chain
 

Similar to Securing the Global Pharmaceutical Supply Chain against the Threat of Counterfeit Drugs.

IJPBA_2058_23_20230707_V1.pdf
IJPBA_2058_23_20230707_V1.pdfIJPBA_2058_23_20230707_V1.pdf
IJPBA_2058_23_20230707_V1.pdf
BRNSS Publication Hub
 
Counterfeit drugs: an organized crime
Counterfeit drugs: an organized crimeCounterfeit drugs: an organized crime
Counterfeit drugs: an organized crime
iosrjce
 
Monarchy of counterfeit drugs towards global health care terrorism
Monarchy of counterfeit drugs towards global health care terrorismMonarchy of counterfeit drugs towards global health care terrorism
Monarchy of counterfeit drugs towards global health care terrorism
Alexander Decker
 
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other ProductsDetection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Nancy Sperling
 
Patient advocate townhall: keeping patients safe from counterfeit drugs
Patient advocate townhall: keeping patients safe from counterfeit drugsPatient advocate townhall: keeping patients safe from counterfeit drugs
Patient advocate townhall: keeping patients safe from counterfeit drugs
The Partnership For Safe Medicines
 
Please read below case and individually take the role of “NGOsAdvoc.pdf
Please read below case and individually take the role of “NGOsAdvoc.pdfPlease read below case and individually take the role of “NGOsAdvoc.pdf
Please read below case and individually take the role of “NGOsAdvoc.pdf
pallavi953613
 
White paper stopping counterfeit pharmaceuticals 0309
White  paper stopping counterfeit pharmaceuticals 0309White  paper stopping counterfeit pharmaceuticals 0309
White paper stopping counterfeit pharmaceuticals 0309NEW Momentum
 
TOC PROJECT PPT
TOC PROJECT PPTTOC PROJECT PPT
TOC PROJECT PPT
pdf uploader
 
25 Amazing-and-Disturbing-Facts-About-The-Hidden-History-of-Medicine
25 Amazing-and-Disturbing-Facts-About-The-Hidden-History-of-Medicine25 Amazing-and-Disturbing-Facts-About-The-Hidden-History-of-Medicine
25 Amazing-and-Disturbing-Facts-About-The-Hidden-History-of-MedicineJVGAJJAR
 
Buss. ethic
Buss. ethicBuss. ethic
International Journal of Business and Management Invention (IJBMI)
International Journal of Business and Management Invention (IJBMI)International Journal of Business and Management Invention (IJBMI)
International Journal of Business and Management Invention (IJBMI)
inventionjournals
 
Trade in Counterfeit Pharmaceutical Products
Trade in Counterfeit Pharmaceutical ProductsTrade in Counterfeit Pharmaceutical Products
Trade in Counterfeit Pharmaceutical Products
OECD Governance
 
A partnership model for the control of unethical marketing of medical drugs i...
A partnership model for the control of unethical marketing of medical drugs i...A partnership model for the control of unethical marketing of medical drugs i...
A partnership model for the control of unethical marketing of medical drugs i...
Alexander Decker
 
Counterfeit medicines
 Counterfeit medicines Counterfeit medicines
Counterfeit medicines
Sumitha Arumugam
 
2 the-need-of-pharmacovigilance
2 the-need-of-pharmacovigilance2 the-need-of-pharmacovigilance
2 the-need-of-pharmacovigilanceMohammed Alshakka
 
A Bird's-Eye View of the Rare Disease Landscape
A Bird's-Eye View of the Rare Disease LandscapeA Bird's-Eye View of the Rare Disease Landscape
A Bird's-Eye View of the Rare Disease Landscape
Pharma Intelligence
 
Using Medicine
Using MedicineUsing Medicine
Using Medicinecamphuong
 
Using Medicine
Using MedicineUsing Medicine
Using Medicine
camphuong
 
Falsified Medicines and the Global Public's Health
Falsified Medicines and the Global Public's HealthFalsified Medicines and the Global Public's Health
Herbal products in canada how safe are they
Herbal products in canada how safe are theyHerbal products in canada how safe are they
Herbal products in canada how safe are they
Nazeer Mohd
 

Similar to Securing the Global Pharmaceutical Supply Chain against the Threat of Counterfeit Drugs. (20)

IJPBA_2058_23_20230707_V1.pdf
IJPBA_2058_23_20230707_V1.pdfIJPBA_2058_23_20230707_V1.pdf
IJPBA_2058_23_20230707_V1.pdf
 
Counterfeit drugs: an organized crime
Counterfeit drugs: an organized crimeCounterfeit drugs: an organized crime
Counterfeit drugs: an organized crime
 
Monarchy of counterfeit drugs towards global health care terrorism
Monarchy of counterfeit drugs towards global health care terrorismMonarchy of counterfeit drugs towards global health care terrorism
Monarchy of counterfeit drugs towards global health care terrorism
 
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other ProductsDetection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
 
Patient advocate townhall: keeping patients safe from counterfeit drugs
Patient advocate townhall: keeping patients safe from counterfeit drugsPatient advocate townhall: keeping patients safe from counterfeit drugs
Patient advocate townhall: keeping patients safe from counterfeit drugs
 
Please read below case and individually take the role of “NGOsAdvoc.pdf
Please read below case and individually take the role of “NGOsAdvoc.pdfPlease read below case and individually take the role of “NGOsAdvoc.pdf
Please read below case and individually take the role of “NGOsAdvoc.pdf
 
White paper stopping counterfeit pharmaceuticals 0309
White  paper stopping counterfeit pharmaceuticals 0309White  paper stopping counterfeit pharmaceuticals 0309
White paper stopping counterfeit pharmaceuticals 0309
 
TOC PROJECT PPT
TOC PROJECT PPTTOC PROJECT PPT
TOC PROJECT PPT
 
25 Amazing-and-Disturbing-Facts-About-The-Hidden-History-of-Medicine
25 Amazing-and-Disturbing-Facts-About-The-Hidden-History-of-Medicine25 Amazing-and-Disturbing-Facts-About-The-Hidden-History-of-Medicine
25 Amazing-and-Disturbing-Facts-About-The-Hidden-History-of-Medicine
 
Buss. ethic
Buss. ethicBuss. ethic
Buss. ethic
 
International Journal of Business and Management Invention (IJBMI)
International Journal of Business and Management Invention (IJBMI)International Journal of Business and Management Invention (IJBMI)
International Journal of Business and Management Invention (IJBMI)
 
Trade in Counterfeit Pharmaceutical Products
Trade in Counterfeit Pharmaceutical ProductsTrade in Counterfeit Pharmaceutical Products
Trade in Counterfeit Pharmaceutical Products
 
A partnership model for the control of unethical marketing of medical drugs i...
A partnership model for the control of unethical marketing of medical drugs i...A partnership model for the control of unethical marketing of medical drugs i...
A partnership model for the control of unethical marketing of medical drugs i...
 
Counterfeit medicines
 Counterfeit medicines Counterfeit medicines
Counterfeit medicines
 
2 the-need-of-pharmacovigilance
2 the-need-of-pharmacovigilance2 the-need-of-pharmacovigilance
2 the-need-of-pharmacovigilance
 
A Bird's-Eye View of the Rare Disease Landscape
A Bird's-Eye View of the Rare Disease LandscapeA Bird's-Eye View of the Rare Disease Landscape
A Bird's-Eye View of the Rare Disease Landscape
 
Using Medicine
Using MedicineUsing Medicine
Using Medicine
 
Using Medicine
Using MedicineUsing Medicine
Using Medicine
 
Falsified Medicines and the Global Public's Health
Falsified Medicines and the Global Public's HealthFalsified Medicines and the Global Public's Health
Falsified Medicines and the Global Public's Health
 
Herbal products in canada how safe are they
Herbal products in canada how safe are theyHerbal products in canada how safe are they
Herbal products in canada how safe are they
 

More from Yasmin AbdelAziz

Research Gate: Sun Tzu
Research Gate: Sun TzuResearch Gate: Sun Tzu
Research Gate: Sun Tzu
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
Strategic Performance Index- OnStrategy
Strategic Performance Index- OnStrategyStrategic Performance Index- OnStrategy
Strategic Performance Index- OnStrategy
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
Pharma IQ Serialization Deadlines Updated
Pharma IQ Serialization Deadlines UpdatedPharma IQ Serialization Deadlines Updated
Pharma IQ Serialization Deadlines Updated
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
The Internet of Things – Good, Bad or Just Plain Ugly?
The Internet of Things – Good, Bad or Just Plain Ugly?The Internet of Things – Good, Bad or Just Plain Ugly?
The Internet of Things – Good, Bad or Just Plain Ugly?
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
Developing Emotional Intelligence for Healthcare Leaders
Developing Emotional Intelligence for Healthcare LeadersDeveloping Emotional Intelligence for Healthcare Leaders
Developing Emotional Intelligence for Healthcare Leaders
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
A Theoretical Framework (Modelling) for International Business Management
A Theoretical Framework (Modelling) for International Business ManagementA Theoretical Framework (Modelling) for International Business Management
A Theoretical Framework (Modelling) for International Business Management
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
WHO Report, the third meeting of the Member State mechanism on substandard/sp...
WHO Report, the third meeting of the Member State mechanism on substandard/sp...WHO Report, the third meeting of the Member State mechanism on substandard/sp...
WHO Report, the third meeting of the Member State mechanism on substandard/sp...
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
Social media impact on freedom of expression and privacy
Social media impact on freedom of expression and privacySocial media impact on freedom of expression and privacy
Social media impact on freedom of expression and privacy
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
Patheon meaningful metrics_whitepaper
Patheon meaningful metrics_whitepaperPatheon meaningful metrics_whitepaper
Patheon meaningful metrics_whitepaper
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
Who oct 2014
Who oct 2014Who oct 2014
Who oct 2014
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
2014 october newsletter
2014 october newsletter2014 october newsletter
2014 october newsletter
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
Managing OEE o optimize factory performance
Managing OEE o optimize factory performanceManaging OEE o optimize factory performance
Managing OEE o optimize factory performance
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
Riskmitigationwhitepaperweb 1
Riskmitigationwhitepaperweb 1Riskmitigationwhitepaperweb 1
Riskmitigationwhitepaperweb 1Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
How to Increase the Value of the PMMMs as a Business-oriented Framework
How to Increase the Value of the PMMMs as a Business-oriented FrameworkHow to Increase the Value of the PMMMs as a Business-oriented Framework
How to Increase the Value of the PMMMs as a Business-oriented Framework
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
Di 27 1
Di 27 1Di 27 1
Cmrgo wp prd_fordvlpmnt_4pnl_sml
Cmrgo wp prd_fordvlpmnt_4pnl_smlCmrgo wp prd_fordvlpmnt_4pnl_sml
Cmrgo wp prd_fordvlpmnt_4pnl_sml
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
Women's rights in the middle east and noth africa, gulf edition
Women's rights in the middle east and noth africa, gulf editionWomen's rights in the middle east and noth africa, gulf edition
Women's rights in the middle east and noth africa, gulf edition
Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
Sf guide moving_mountains_us_02
Sf guide moving_mountains_us_02Sf guide moving_mountains_us_02
Sf guide moving_mountains_us_02Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
3960 alkermes case_study8_fa7
3960 alkermes case_study8_fa73960 alkermes case_study8_fa7
3960 alkermes case_study8_fa7Yasmin AbdelAziz
 
Africa Supply Chain April 2012
Africa Supply Chain April 2012Africa Supply Chain April 2012
Africa Supply Chain April 2012Yasmin AbdelAziz
 

More from Yasmin AbdelAziz (20)

Research Gate: Sun Tzu
Research Gate: Sun TzuResearch Gate: Sun Tzu
Research Gate: Sun Tzu
 
Strategic Performance Index- OnStrategy
Strategic Performance Index- OnStrategyStrategic Performance Index- OnStrategy
Strategic Performance Index- OnStrategy
 
Pharma IQ Serialization Deadlines Updated
Pharma IQ Serialization Deadlines UpdatedPharma IQ Serialization Deadlines Updated
Pharma IQ Serialization Deadlines Updated
 
The Internet of Things – Good, Bad or Just Plain Ugly?
The Internet of Things – Good, Bad or Just Plain Ugly?The Internet of Things – Good, Bad or Just Plain Ugly?
The Internet of Things – Good, Bad or Just Plain Ugly?
 
Developing Emotional Intelligence for Healthcare Leaders
Developing Emotional Intelligence for Healthcare LeadersDeveloping Emotional Intelligence for Healthcare Leaders
Developing Emotional Intelligence for Healthcare Leaders
 
A Theoretical Framework (Modelling) for International Business Management
A Theoretical Framework (Modelling) for International Business ManagementA Theoretical Framework (Modelling) for International Business Management
A Theoretical Framework (Modelling) for International Business Management
 
WHO Report, the third meeting of the Member State mechanism on substandard/sp...
WHO Report, the third meeting of the Member State mechanism on substandard/sp...WHO Report, the third meeting of the Member State mechanism on substandard/sp...
WHO Report, the third meeting of the Member State mechanism on substandard/sp...
 
Social media impact on freedom of expression and privacy
Social media impact on freedom of expression and privacySocial media impact on freedom of expression and privacy
Social media impact on freedom of expression and privacy
 
Patheon meaningful metrics_whitepaper
Patheon meaningful metrics_whitepaperPatheon meaningful metrics_whitepaper
Patheon meaningful metrics_whitepaper
 
Who oct 2014
Who oct 2014Who oct 2014
Who oct 2014
 
2014 october newsletter
2014 october newsletter2014 october newsletter
2014 october newsletter
 
Managing OEE o optimize factory performance
Managing OEE o optimize factory performanceManaging OEE o optimize factory performance
Managing OEE o optimize factory performance
 
Riskmitigationwhitepaperweb 1
Riskmitigationwhitepaperweb 1Riskmitigationwhitepaperweb 1
Riskmitigationwhitepaperweb 1
 
How to Increase the Value of the PMMMs as a Business-oriented Framework
How to Increase the Value of the PMMMs as a Business-oriented FrameworkHow to Increase the Value of the PMMMs as a Business-oriented Framework
How to Increase the Value of the PMMMs as a Business-oriented Framework
 
Di 27 1
Di 27 1Di 27 1
Di 27 1
 
Cmrgo wp prd_fordvlpmnt_4pnl_sml
Cmrgo wp prd_fordvlpmnt_4pnl_smlCmrgo wp prd_fordvlpmnt_4pnl_sml
Cmrgo wp prd_fordvlpmnt_4pnl_sml
 
Women's rights in the middle east and noth africa, gulf edition
Women's rights in the middle east and noth africa, gulf editionWomen's rights in the middle east and noth africa, gulf edition
Women's rights in the middle east and noth africa, gulf edition
 
Sf guide moving_mountains_us_02
Sf guide moving_mountains_us_02Sf guide moving_mountains_us_02
Sf guide moving_mountains_us_02
 
3960 alkermes case_study8_fa7
3960 alkermes case_study8_fa73960 alkermes case_study8_fa7
3960 alkermes case_study8_fa7
 
Africa Supply Chain April 2012
Africa Supply Chain April 2012Africa Supply Chain April 2012
Africa Supply Chain April 2012
 

Recently uploaded

CMHPSM Regional Compliance Training 2024
CMHPSM Regional Compliance Training 2024CMHPSM Regional Compliance Training 2024
CMHPSM Regional Compliance Training 2024
JColaianne
 
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima  SpaTop massage center in ajman chandrima  Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
Chandrima Spa Ajman
 
Time line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGY
Time line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGYTime line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGY
Time line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGY
DianaRodriguez639773
 
Under Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's Strategy
Under Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's StrategyUnder Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's Strategy
Under Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's Strategy
Kenneth Kruk
 
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured ApproachBringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Brian Frerichs
 
Dr. David Greene R3 stem cell Breakthroughs: Stem Cell Therapy in Cardiology
Dr. David Greene R3 stem cell Breakthroughs: Stem Cell Therapy in CardiologyDr. David Greene R3 stem cell Breakthroughs: Stem Cell Therapy in Cardiology
Dr. David Greene R3 stem cell Breakthroughs: Stem Cell Therapy in Cardiology
R3 Stem Cell
 
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdfCHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
Sachin Sharma
 
Cardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing student
Cardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing studentCardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing student
Cardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing student
fahmyahmed789
 
定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
khvdq584
 
Child Welfare Clinic and Well baby clinicin Sri Lanka.ppsx
Child Welfare Clinic and Well baby clinicin Sri Lanka.ppsxChild Welfare Clinic and Well baby clinicin Sri Lanka.ppsx
Child Welfare Clinic and Well baby clinicin Sri Lanka.ppsx
Sankalpa Gunathilaka
 
Feeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptx
Feeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptxFeeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptx
Feeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptx
SatvikaPrasad
 
Trauma Outpatient Center .
Trauma Outpatient Center                       .Trauma Outpatient Center                       .
Trauma Outpatient Center .
TraumaOutpatientCent
 
Professional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine Lecture
Professional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine LectureProfessional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine Lecture
Professional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine Lecture
DIVYANSHU740006
 
The positive impact of SGRT – The Berkshire Cancer Centre experience
The positive impact of SGRT – The Berkshire Cancer Centre experienceThe positive impact of SGRT – The Berkshire Cancer Centre experience
The positive impact of SGRT – The Berkshire Cancer Centre experience
SGRT Community
 
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference version 2.4.pdf
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference  version  2.4.pdfDRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference  version  2.4.pdf
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference version 2.4.pdf
Robert Cole
 
ABDOMINAL COMPARTMENT SYSNDROME
ABDOMINAL COMPARTMENT SYSNDROMEABDOMINAL COMPARTMENT SYSNDROME
ABDOMINAL COMPARTMENT SYSNDROME
Rommel Luis III Israel
 
HUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COM
HUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COMHUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COM
HUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COM
priyabhojwani1200
 
TEST BANK For Accounting Information Systems, 3rd Edition by Vernon Richardso...
TEST BANK For Accounting Information Systems, 3rd Edition by Vernon Richardso...TEST BANK For Accounting Information Systems, 3rd Edition by Vernon Richardso...
TEST BANK For Accounting Information Systems, 3rd Edition by Vernon Richardso...
rightmanforbloodline
 
Dimensions of Healthcare Quality
Dimensions of Healthcare QualityDimensions of Healthcare Quality
Dimensions of Healthcare Quality
Naeemshahzad51
 
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer RehabpptxCCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
Canadian Cancer Survivor Network
 

Recently uploaded (20)

CMHPSM Regional Compliance Training 2024
CMHPSM Regional Compliance Training 2024CMHPSM Regional Compliance Training 2024
CMHPSM Regional Compliance Training 2024
 
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima  SpaTop massage center in ajman chandrima  Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
 
Time line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGY
Time line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGYTime line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGY
Time line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGY
 
Under Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's Strategy
Under Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's StrategyUnder Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's Strategy
Under Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's Strategy
 
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured ApproachBringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
 
Dr. David Greene R3 stem cell Breakthroughs: Stem Cell Therapy in Cardiology
Dr. David Greene R3 stem cell Breakthroughs: Stem Cell Therapy in CardiologyDr. David Greene R3 stem cell Breakthroughs: Stem Cell Therapy in Cardiology
Dr. David Greene R3 stem cell Breakthroughs: Stem Cell Therapy in Cardiology
 
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdfCHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
 
Cardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing student
Cardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing studentCardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing student
Cardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing student
 
定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
 
Child Welfare Clinic and Well baby clinicin Sri Lanka.ppsx
Child Welfare Clinic and Well baby clinicin Sri Lanka.ppsxChild Welfare Clinic and Well baby clinicin Sri Lanka.ppsx
Child Welfare Clinic and Well baby clinicin Sri Lanka.ppsx
 
Feeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptx
Feeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptxFeeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptx
Feeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptx
 
Trauma Outpatient Center .
Trauma Outpatient Center                       .Trauma Outpatient Center                       .
Trauma Outpatient Center .
 
Professional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine Lecture
Professional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine LectureProfessional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine Lecture
Professional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine Lecture
 
The positive impact of SGRT – The Berkshire Cancer Centre experience
The positive impact of SGRT – The Berkshire Cancer Centre experienceThe positive impact of SGRT – The Berkshire Cancer Centre experience
The positive impact of SGRT – The Berkshire Cancer Centre experience
 
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference version 2.4.pdf
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference  version  2.4.pdfDRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference  version  2.4.pdf
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference version 2.4.pdf
 
ABDOMINAL COMPARTMENT SYSNDROME
ABDOMINAL COMPARTMENT SYSNDROMEABDOMINAL COMPARTMENT SYSNDROME
ABDOMINAL COMPARTMENT SYSNDROME
 
HUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COM
HUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COMHUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COM
HUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COM
 
TEST BANK For Accounting Information Systems, 3rd Edition by Vernon Richardso...
TEST BANK For Accounting Information Systems, 3rd Edition by Vernon Richardso...TEST BANK For Accounting Information Systems, 3rd Edition by Vernon Richardso...
TEST BANK For Accounting Information Systems, 3rd Edition by Vernon Richardso...
 
Dimensions of Healthcare Quality
Dimensions of Healthcare QualityDimensions of Healthcare Quality
Dimensions of Healthcare Quality
 
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer RehabpptxCCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
 

Securing the Global Pharmaceutical Supply Chain against the Threat of Counterfeit Drugs.

  • 1. JUNE 2014 Securing the Global Pharmaceutical Supply Chain against the Threat of Counterfeit Drugs.
  • 2. With a fully integrated GxP-compliant transport, storage and distribution system in place and over 140 wholly owned ISO 9001 - certified offices in more than 50 countries, WORLD COURIER, an AmerisourceBergen® company, is the world’s largest and most experienced provider of specialty courier services. It is uniquely positioned to meet the most demanding industry requirements for managing the global distribution of time - and temperature-sensitive 2 pharmaceutical products and IMPs used commercially or in clinical trials. Securing the Global Pharmaceutical Supply Chain against the Threat of Counterfeit Drugs In 2012, counterfeit versions of the cancer drug Avastin were found in 19 American treatment centers. The impostor drug lacked the active ingredient, rendering it virtually useless for treatment purposes. The same year, counterfeits of Viagra and Cialis smuggled into the U.K. were found to contain undeclared active ingredients that posed potentially serious health risks to consumers. One year earlier, almost 3,000 patients in Kenya were affected by a falsified batch of the antiretroviral therapy Zidolam-N, used in the treatment of HIV/AIDS. And in 2009, counterfeits of a traditional anti-diabetic medicine killed two and hospitalized nine in China before it was determined that the fraudulent drug contained six times the normal dose of glibenclamide, a chemical used to lower blood sugar1. Isolated incidents? Sadly, no. Instead, according to world health officials, this is just the tip of the iceberg as falsified and counterfeit drugs take on a life of their own in burgeoning grey markets and increasingly slip into the legitimate supply chain. Diagnosis: History and Scope of the Problem According to the World Health Organization (WHO), the prevalence of spurious, falsely-labelled, falsified, or counterfeit medicines, or SFFC medicines as they are known − medicines that are deliberately and fraudulently produced, packaged and/or mislabeled − is a growing trend worldwide which threatens both patient safety as well as public confidence in the health systems and regulatory bodies designed to provide oversight and control. SFFC medicines are found everywhere in the world. They range from random mixtures of harmful toxic substances to inactive, ineffective preparations. Some contain a declared, active ingredient and look so similar to the genuine product that they deceive health professionals as well as patients. But in every case, the source of a SFFC medicine is unknown and its content unreliable. SFFC medicines are always illegal. They can result in treatment failure or even death. Eliminating them is a considerable public health challenge2. 1 “Medicines: spurious/falsely-labelled/falsified/counterfeit (SFFC) medicines”, World Health Organization, Fact sheet No.275, May 2012 2Ibid.
  • 3. 3 About Counterfeit Drugs First identified as an issue in the mid-1980s when counterfeiters began reproducing soft “lifestyle” drugs used to combat obesity and baldness, etc., the replication of mass market prescription drugs such as birth control, medications for erectile dysfunction, diabetes, hypertension and high cholesterol as well as vaccines, antibiotics and antimalarials soon followed. More than 25 years later, the scope of falsified drugs has mushroomed to include high-value drugs in high demand as well as life-saving drugs used to treat cancer, HIV/AIDS, serious cardiovascular disease and even those used to support organ transplants. None of today’s drugs or therapeutic treatments is exempt from unauthorized replication. Targeted medicines now include both branded and generic drugs and run the full gambit − everything from low-cost generic painkillers and antihistamines to high-value blockbuster drugs and specialty medicines used to treat life-threatening conditions. Even injectables and medical devices have not been spared. According to WHO statistics3 collected in 2000: • 32.1% of identified counterfeit drugs contained no active ingredient • 20.2% had incorrect quantities of active ingredients • 21.4% contained the wrong ingredients • 5.6% had correct ingredients, but fake packaging • 8.5% contained high levels of impurities • 1% were copies of an original product The impact on patients from using fraudulent drugs can range dramatically: from failure to treat minor symptoms to failure to treat critical illnesses to drug resistance caused by long-term exposure to reduced amounts of active ingredients to death. Each year between 100,0004 and as many as 1 million5 people die from counterfeit drugs according to varying statistics. Produced in sub-standard facilities with little to no quality control, these fraudulent medicines contain an array of questionable ingredients including, among other things, caffeine, rat poison, starch, chalk, gypsum, flour, sugar and even acetaminophen, used to lower fevers and promote the belief that the drug is working. 3World Health Organization, “General information on counterfeit medicines”, 2000 4 Bate, Roger, “The deadly world of falsified and substandard medicine”, American Enterprise Institute, October 15, 2012 5Southwickz, Natalie, “Counterfeit Drugs Kill 1Mn People Annually: Interpol”, InSightCrime.org, October 24, 2013.
  • 4. In 2013, for instance, through joint international law enforcement and the efforts of almost 100 countries, over 10 million potentially dangerous medicines worth some $36 million were seized, resulting in 213 arrests worldwide. 4 6 Grogan, Kevin, “One in five Europeans buying fake drugs − Pfizer survey”, PharmaTimes online, Februrary 16, 2010 7 “Counterfeit Drugs: Fighting Illegal Supply Chains”, a report by Lev Kubiak, Director National Intellectual Property Rights Coordination Center, Homeland Security Investigations, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, February 27, 2014 and where law enforcement is more aggressive − the occurrence of counterfeiting is statistically reduced to 1% or less. Although the percentage may seem negligible, actual numbers help to put the situation into better perspective. In the United States alone, more than 4 billion prescriptions were issued in 2011, equating to over 40 million prescriptions that were filled using counterfeit medicines. A survey conducted in 14 European countries by Pfizer in 2010 estimated that more than €10.5 billion (U.S. $14 billion) was spent each year on illicitly-sourced prescription drugs including those used for weight loss, influenza and erectile dysfunction; many of these drugs were counterfeit. The study further notedthat the number of counterfeit drugs uncovered at EU borders increased from 560,598 articles in 2005 to 4,081,056 in 20076. By all accounts, the situation promises to intensify and although global recognition of the problem now exists, controlling it has been daunting. In 2013, for instance, through joint international law enforcement and the efforts of almost 100 countries, over 10 million potentially dangerous medicines worth some $36 million were seized, resulting in 213 arrests worldwide. In addition, almost 14,000 websites hosted by illegal online pharmacies were identified and shut down and more than 530,000 packages were inspected by customs and regulatory authorities. Of these, almost 42,000 packages − containing everything from antibiotics, cancer medication and anti-depressants to erectile dysfunction medication and dietary supplements − were seized7. Prevalence and Geographical Reach of Counterfeit Drugs In today’s globalized pharmaceutical industry, it is thought that 10% of all drugs distributed globally are counterfeit. An estimated 80% of these counterfeits are produced overseas, with China and India identified as the leading suppliers. Worldwide sales of counterfeit drugs are estimated by WHO to be in excess of $75 billion annually, with some sources approximating annual market value to be as high as $200 billion. As one might expect, accurate data is hard to come by. Developing nations have historically been prime targets for counterfeits, in part because of a weaker import and regulatory infrastructure, but also due to sheer economics and the inability of large populations to widely access expensive drugs. While Asia, with over 60% of the world’s population, currently represents the largest market for counterfeits, Africa, Latin America and politically and economically destabilized regions are all similarly attractive targets for those distributing rogue products. Based on WHO estimates, approximately 30% of the drugs distributed in these geographies are counterfeit. Some estimates for specific countries are as high as 60%. Adding to this, the growth of Internet-based commercial drug sales − both for products destined to as well as those emanating from developing nations − has merely exacerbated the problem. In industrialized nations like the U.S., Canada, most EU countries, Australia, New Zealand and Japan − where median income is higher, where the pharmaceutical supply chain is better protected by stronger customs, import and regulatory oversight,
  • 5. 5 According to recent WHO studies: • Some 10% of all pharmaceuticals distributed world wide are counterfeit • Between 30% and 60% of drugs distributed in developing countries are counterfeit • Approximately 1% of counterfeit drugs have penetrated the supply chain in developed countries • Over 50% of drugs purchased online from sites that conceal their physical addresses are countefeit • Worldwide sales of counterfeit drugs is in excess of $75 billion annually Prevention: Technological and Regulatory Countermeasures With the escalation of drug counterfeiting in the mid-1990s, a number of technological, regulatory, industry-driven and national initiatives were launched to help combat the problem. Clearly it must continue to be a collective effort if inroads are to be made in controlling the occurrence of counterfeit drugs. Packaging Innovation Over time, pharmaceutical packaging has evolved to provide better protection for both product and patient. In the past decade, steps were taken to securitize and authenticate pharmaceuticals initially by adding visible and/or hidden security features such as hologram labels and other brand protection features to the packaging. Although these measures provided some deterrents, those same technologies have also fallen prey to counterfeiting and, as such, have not successfully eliminated the problem in any meaningful way. The newest technologies now being utilized include 2D barcodes applied directly to the packaging which retain considerably more data than previous barcodes, and Radio Frequency ID (RFID) tags which create an electronic record of chain of custody from point of manufacture to point of dispensing. While many pharmaceutical companies are already using forms of these technologies, pending regulatory changes are slated to move these solutions into the global supply chain in the coming years, with more onus being put on the verification of individual medicines at the patient dispensing level.
  • 6. 6 International Collaboration In 2006, the International Medical Products Anti-Counterfeiting Task Force (IMPACT), a partnership involving 193 WHO Member States, a variety of international and non-governmental organizations, law enforcement agencies, pharmaceutical manufacturing associations and drug and regulatory authorities was formed. Its mandate has been to work with countries and the industry to better detect and safeguard against the widespread distribution of fraudulent drugs and to minimize criminal activity through stronger and more collaborative international law enforcement. Regulatory Reform On a regional basis and as might be expected, the U.S. and the EU are leading the way with regulatory solutions to help circumvent the problem. Falsified Medicines Directive (2011/62/EU) The European Commission’s Falsified Medicines Directive (2011/62/EU) was written into law in 2011, amending former legislation aimed at preventing falsified medicinal products from entering the legitimate supply chain. This legislation strengthens controls and checks on products moving through the supply chain and includes stricter controls on the sourcing of active product ingredients and excipients, especially those originating from non- EU countries. It also calls for new or extended obligations on the part of importers and distributors of active substances, brokers, product manufacturers and wholesalers while mandating legal online pharmacies to display a common EU-wide logo on company websites. An additional requirement now demands that an obligatory authentication and safety feature appears on the outer packaging (unique pack identification). Member states were required to transpose the directive into national law by January 2, 2013 while provisions related to the importation of active substances from third countries came into effect July 1, 2013. Specific legislation on the implementation of safety features (unique identifier) is due in 2014, with mandatory application of this identifier and medicinal product verification expected in the EU by 2017. In anticipation of upcoming regulatory changes, two product verification initiatives are already in use in Europe. The European Stakeholder Model (ESM) is a cloud-based point-of-dispensing verification system that uses 2D data matrix barcodes to authenticate medicines and ensure that patients are receiving a genuine product. Data matrix codes are affixed by the manufacturer (if necessary, the product is verified and repackaged by the parallel distributor with a new number) and then uploaded to a central European database. This number may also be verified by both the wholesaler and pharmacy. Data includes the product number, batch number, expiry date and a unique serial number, with unregistered codes sending an immediate alert that the product may have been falsified. This system will be overseen by the European Medicines Verification Organization (EMVO), a non-profit organization that will manage the European Hub which links national systems throughout Europe. Launched in 2012, the system has been successfully tested in Sweden. Germany’s securPharm verification system was integrated with the ESM model in 2013 and the proposed European Hub is expected to be fully operational by mid-2014. Also launched in 2012, the European Directorate for the Quality of Medicines and Healthcare (EDQM) eTACT program is similarly a track-and-trace system that relies on unique identification numbers adhered to individual packaging to verify the authenticity of a medication. This number is affixed by the manufacturer and can be used by all legitimate supply chain members to verify the product. A final verification must be performed at the dispensing location. Unique to this system, however, patients themselves are able to trace
  • 7. The DQSA is a progressive law that has many milestones which must be met by the pharmaceutical industry, with the end goal of having a full traceability solution in place by 2023. National Initiatives At the international level, countries are implementing their own strategies to combat the growing threat of counterfeit drugs. China is the world’s top producer of both legitimate and counterfeit drugs. In 2001, the existing Drug Administration Law of the PRC was amended to increase penalties on the production and sale of falsified drugs. Since then other laws have been enacted to control counterfeit activities by regulating API manufacturers, for instance, a key to controlling counterfeit activities. While the State Food and Drug Administration (SFDA) has also increased routine inspection and sampling as well as enacted new labeling laws, enforcement remains weak and the system cumbersome. Technological solutions including 2D data matrix bar-coding and RFID tags remain expensive to implement. As one of the world’s top manufacturers of generic and patent drugs, India has taken steps to limit counterfeit drug production nationally following a 2005 estimate that some 75% of falsified drugs distributed globally have some origins in that country8. Although this estimate has been hotly disputed and never proven, India’s Directorate General of Foreign Trade (DGFT) amended labeling requirements in 2011, making it mandatory for every drug manufactured in that country designated for export to bear a Unique Product Identification Code (GTIN) as well as 1D or 2D bar-coding on primary, secondary and tertiary packaging. Meanwhile in Africa, the newly launched mPedigree Network, an SMS-based technology developed by 7 and verify the safety of the medication, potentially strengthening public confidence. EDQM is a public, inter-governmental organization that promotes quality standards for the safe use of medicines worldwide. Drug Quality and Security Act (DQSA) In the U.S., the newly-enacted Drug Quality and Security Act (DQSA) was signed into law in November 2013 by President Obama, effectively preempting all existing state laws and regulations related to pedigree. The DQSA is a progressive law that has many milestones which must be met by the pharmaceutical industry, with the end goal of having a full traceability solution in place by 2023. The federal DQSA aims to incorporate drug transactional information into a new electronic traceability system that will allow health systems, hospitals and pharmacies to trace prescription drugs through the supply chain. Required transactional information will include the name of the drug, its strength, quantity, dosage, National Drug Code (NDC), lot number, container/ packaging size, date of transaction, date of shipment and name and address of both shipper and consignee, all of which will provide additional business value. Included in the legislation are federal licensure standards for third-party logistics providers (3PLs) and wholesale distributors. In addition, manufacturers will be required to apply a 2D barcode that contains a product identifier, serial number, lot number and expiration date by November 2017. Wholesaler drug distributors must follow suit by November 2019 and dispensers by November 2020. The full traceability solution is set to be implemented by November 2023.
  • 8. 8 Ghanaian entrepreneur Bright Simons, began its roll-out in Nigeria in 2013 when the system became accessible to over 50 million mobile subscribers. The technology allows patients to authenticate their medicine by sending a free text message to a special hotline and receiving an immediate OK or NO response. The reply is accompanied by the name of the medication and a picture of the packaging for visual comparison. Patients need only scratch off a panel on the prescription packaging to reveal the unique ID number. This technology is now being tested in Ghana and being considered by other African states. Patients in Africa have been highly vulnerable to the negative effects of counterfeit drugs, with as many as 700,000 deaths per year linked to sub-standard malaria drugs and tuberculosis vaccines. Moving Forward The cost associated with counterfeit drugs is staggering − both in human and commercial terms. In some cases, patients are deprived of treatment for diseases and conditions that range from mild to severe to life-threatening. In other cases, they are harmed by dangerous substances in the product, or become resistant to traditional therapeutic treatments or vaccines. In all cases, the public loses confidence in the companies that develop these drugs and in the very agencies that have been established to protect them. For the pharmaceutical industry, the prevalence of counterfeit drugs can represent loss of reputation, loss of valuable R&D efforts and intellectual property, loss of revenue and increased costs. Many companies, for instance, now operate their own anti-counterfeit units to police their product lines and reduce the impact of counterfeiting on the organization. Despite these efforts, the growth of counterfeit drugs is only expected to increase within the parameters of a globalized industry, especially as the cost of healthcare spirals worldwide. What can pharmaceutical professionals do to ensure that their organizations and the patients they serve are not impacted by counterfeit drugs? The answer is to identify their highest risk products and shipments and to secure their supply chain to the fullest extent possible. In the falsified Avastin case referenced at the beginning of this article, it was later found that the vials were sourced in Turkey and shipped to Switzerland, then Denmark and finally to the U.K. before being exported to a U.S. wholesale distributor hired by a Canadian company which was ultimately owned by an online retail pharmacy. In another case, counterfeit product was slipped into an existing shipment of legitimate drugs destined for a hospital simply by adding an extra zero to the unit count on the paperwork. In yet another case, a legitimate shipment of temperature-controlled drugs was hijacked, with the product later re-introduced into the supply chain without the benefit of quality assurance. 8Lal, Neeta, “Fake drugs a bitter pill for India”, Asia Times online, June 7, 2008.
  • 9. Virtually every medicinal product is a target in today’s world. Although all pharmaceutical shipments are important, pharmaceutical professionals should evaluate the severity of risks associated with a specific product prior to shipping, and consider prioritizing its journey through the supply chain as required. • Does the provider have experience/expertise in managing high-value pharmaceutical shipments? What type of track record/reputation does he have with clients, airlines, regulatory and customs agencies? • Is the scope of operation global or regional? • Does the company employ staff worldwide or utilize the services of third-party providers? If the latter, what specific locations are not managed by company employees? Do these destinations appear in your distribution portfolio? 9 • Do operatives in all locations act in strict accordance with documented company-wide SOPs? • Is the organization GxP-compliant in all locations, or in select locations? ISO certified? • Is there a quality management/quality assurance policy and team in place? • Does it function independently from the operational side of the organization? • How is quality oversight managed in the field? Is there an SOP for incidence reporting? • Are suitable security procedures in place with respect to employee verification and screening? • Are all security procedures and verification consistent in all locations? • Can the service provider clearly demonstrate that policies and practices are enacted rigorously and consistently from origin to destination for each elected locations? Identifying High Risk Shipments Questions to consider include: • Who is the targeted patient group? Is it an at-risk group like infants or the elderly who are more susceptible to a counterfeit product? • How will the drug be used? Will it be used to treat a chronic condition? Does a single dose have the potential to kill? • How is it administered? By a healthcare professional? By the patient? • What is the patient impact if the medication contains no active ingredient? An excess of active ingredients? • Does the product require cold chain handling to maintain stability/efficacy? • How much annual revenue does the product generate? What role does it play in the product portfolio? • Is the product a flagship brand? A blockbuster? • How attractive is the product to counterfeiters (i.e. high unit price? Product shortage? High volume usage?) • What region is the shipment destined for? What regional risk factors exist with respect to counterfeit drugs? • Does the provider offer a full suite of services (i.e. packaging, temperature control, transport, storage, local delivery), or will services be handled piecemeal by multiple suppliers?
  • 10. The best strategy to ensure full supply chain compliance is by partnering with and building a long-term relationship with a single closed-loop logistics provider able to manage all aspects of the transport and storage of bulk high-value pharmaceutical shipments worldwide. 10 Tightening the Supply Chain As today’s global pharmaceutical supply chain grows increasingly longer and more complex, each link provides added opportunity for counterfeiters. While pending regulatory changes promise to tighten the supply chain with respect to production and distribution entities and new packaging technologies will make the identification of counterfeit products easier, the logistics of global distribution remains a weak link. How can the pharmaceutical shipper ensure the security of the supply chain over thousands of miles and extended periods of time when the product is no longer in his possession? The best strategy to ensure full supply chain compliance is by partnering with and building a long-term relationship with a single closed-loop logistics provider able to manage all aspects of the transport and storage of bulk high-value pharmaceutical shipments worldwide. Benefits include: • Enhanced control from a proven, trusted source • Clear chain of custody at all points during transit • Elimination of unnecessary third-party risk • Local representation and accountability in complex and often unpredictable geographies By utilizing the services of a GxP-compliant logistics supplier, pharmaceutical shippers can automatically ensure that they conform to all current regulatory requirements as they relate to the transport of their high-value pharmaceutical products. Equally important, they can be assured that the same standard operating procedures (SOPs) are employed worldwide to ensure product security to the greatest extent possible. Shippers may also consider utilizing a local warehousing solution in emerging or strategic locations to reduce the costs and peril associated with multiple bulk shipments and to shorten distribution timelines. A fully-integrated logistics provider able to accommodate packaging, cold chain, transport, storage and local in-country or regional distribution is a practical solution for maintaining security in challenging locations. As a word of caution, however, all logistics providers are not created equal, so pharmaceutical shippers should be prepared to carefully qualify all contenders. Identifying a logistics provider with trained staff, a well-maintained infrastructure and network-wide processes in place at the global level will go a long way toward securing the supply chain and protecting the interests of both the pharmaceutical company and its patients, particularly in those areas of the world at greatest risk or where local representation is lacking.
  • 11. Dr. Rüdiger Lomb is Global Director, Quality & Technical Compliance for World Courier, an AmerisourceBergen® company. Since joining World Courier in 2008, Dr. Lomb has brought his considerable technical expertise to bear on shaping and refining the company’s Quality Assurance program. Dr. Lomb was formerly Group Head and Director of the Global Logistics Clinical Supplies Division for Bayer Schering Pharma AG in Germany where he was responsible for the auditing and qualification of depot and transportation service providers. Dr. Lomb is a licensed pharmacist and holds a Ph.D. in pharmaceutical bio-chemistry. 11 For contact information visit www.worldcourier.com Bibliography Ali (Dr.), Shaukat, “Growing Counterfeit in Medicine Worldwide and its Impact on Health and World Economy,” ABHINAV International Monthly Refereed Journal of Research in Management & Technology, ISSN − 2320-0073, Volume II, June 2013 Bate, Roger, “The deadly world of falsified and substandard medicine”, American Enterprise Institute, October 15, 2012 Daigle, Lisa A., M.A., “Following Pharmaceutical Products Through the Supply Chain”, ASHP Policy Analysis, American Society of Health-System Pharmacists®, August 2012 Grogan, Kevin, “One in five Europeans buying fake drugs − Pfizer survey”, PharmaTimes online, Februrary 16, 2010 Kubiak, Lev, “Counterfeit Drugs: Fighting Illegal Supply Chains”, report by the Director, National Intellectual Property Rights Coordination Center, Homeland Security Investigations, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, February 27, 2014 Lal, Neeta, “Fake drugs a bitter pill for India”, Asia Times online, June 7, 2008 McKeon, Owen J., “Counterfeit Drugs The Challenges of a Deadly Global Epidemic”, FOCUS on the New Jersey Chapter, Association of Corporate Counsel, New Jersey (NJCCA) Chapter, June 2013 Rice, Andy, “Fighting Africa’s fake-drug monster”, dailymaverick.co.za, June 23, 2013
  • 12. 12 Southwick, Natalie, “Counterfeit Drugs Kill 1 Mn People Annually: Interpol”, InSightCrime.org, October 24, 2013 Sun, Lei, “Anti-counterfeiting Situation in China”, Bureau of Inspection, SFDA of China, 2010-2012 Trent, Christopher and Moyer, Douglas C., Ph.D., CPP, “Assessing the Risks of Counterfeiting and Illicit Diversion for Health Care Products”, A-CAPP Paper Series, Michigan State University, Center for Anti- Counterfeiting and Product Protection, November 2013 Woodcock, Janet, M.D., “Securing our Nation’s Prescription Drug Supply Chain”, statement of the Director, Center for Drug Evaluation and Research, Food and Drug Administration, April 25, 2013 “Counterfeiting in the Pharmaceutical Industry; a look at the Bitter Pill in China”, © Baker & McKenzie 2013 “General information on counterfeit medicines”, World Health Organization, © WHO 2014 “Growing threat from counterfeit medicines”, Bulletin of the World Health Organization, Volume 88, Number 4, April 2010, 241-320 “Medicines: spurious/falsely-labelled/falsified/counterfeit (SFFC) medicines”, World Health Organization, Fact sheet No275, May 2012 “Rx-360 Supply Chain Security White Paper: Cargo Risk Assessment”, Rx-360, An International Pharmaceutical Supply Chain Consortium, May 2, 2012