SlideShare a Scribd company logo
How Can We Improve the Quality and
Efficiency of Home Care Provision in the
Absence of Regulation
National Healthcare Conference 2015
Social Care budget 2015 - €3B
Elder Care budget 2015 - €1.27B
Fair Deal Scheme - €948M
HSE Funded Home Care - €325M
 Home Help - €195M
 Home Care Package Scheme - €130M
Privately funded care - €20M
Older Persons Services
Home Care Market 2014
HSE
Not-For-
Profit
Private
Home Help Home Care
Packages
Private
Customers
€142m
€53m
€33m
€54m
€175m
€107m
€63m€43m
HSE Funded
€20m
€195m €130m €20m
€345m
Structural Issues Holding the Home Care Sector Back
 Unregulated - Scandals
 Dominated by State – Purchaser and provider
 Strategic Engagement
 Funding Silos
 Poor cousin of Healthcare Sector – Lack of Confidence
 Poor Transparency and Accountability
Lack of Regulation
State Dominance
Strategic Engagement
Funding Silos
Weak Link
Transparency & Accountability
Waste
Examples of What is Wrong
 5 Hour rule
 Paying providers in advance of delivering care
 One price for all cases
 Regional monopolies - Lack of Choice and Clients not Empowered
 Price based tenders
 PHN’s over worked – assessors, supervisors, administrators, advocates
Solutions
Tender Structure
What Does Good Commissioning Achieve?
 Drives quality provision
 Brings efficiencies without affecting quality
 Promotes cohort of quality providers
 Promotes healthy & safe competition
 Provides transparency and accountability
 Brings fairness
Key Question
What Does a Good Commissioning
Process Look Like?
Internal Reference Price Model
 Emphasises on quality
 Licensing not contracting
 HSE set internal price for home care
 Justified
 Per Lot
 Latitude for special cases
 PHN assessment
 Outline
 Hours
 State contribution is ........
 Tax relief
 Private top up
Internal Reference Price Model
 Client discusses with provider directly
 Care Plan
 Customised price
 PHN role - supervision and support where needed
Internal Reference Price Model
 Advantages
 HSE know exact exposure
 Promotes idea of contribution
 Each individual case properly costed
 Takes advantage of local conditions
 Helps recruitment and retention
 Drives quality through client choice
 Promotes quality providers willing to invest
 Move up acuity scale
 Better integration with acute sector
Home Care Needs to Play a More Important Role
Let Money Follow the Patient – End Silos
Use Procurement as a Driver of Quality Provision
and Quality Providers
 Commissioning Policy
Extensive
Transparent
Quality based
Summary
How Can We Improve the Quality and
Efficiency of Home Care Provision in the
Absence of Regulation
National Healthcare Conference 2015

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

1520 declan o neil activity based funding comparisons
1520 declan o neil activity based funding   comparisons1520 declan o neil activity based funding   comparisons
1520 declan o neil activity based funding comparisonsinvestnethealthcare
 
1450 brenda dooley national healthcare conference may28 2015
1450 brenda dooley national healthcare conference may28 20151450 brenda dooley national healthcare conference may28 2015
1450 brenda dooley national healthcare conference may28 2015
investnethealthcare
 
1145 leo kearns healthcare conference may 2015 final.v1
1145 leo kearns healthcare conference may 2015 final.v11145 leo kearns healthcare conference may 2015 final.v1
1145 leo kearns healthcare conference may 2015 final.v1
investnethealthcare
 
1530 surewash e health pres pathway to success
1530 surewash e health pres pathway to success1530 surewash e health pres pathway to success
1530 surewash e health pres pathway to success
investnethealthcare
 
1420 bleddyn rees
1420 bleddyn rees1420 bleddyn rees
1420 bleddyn rees
investnethealthcare
 
1545 eilish mc auliffe nhc 28-5-15 emc
1545 eilish mc auliffe nhc   28-5-15 emc1545 eilish mc auliffe nhc   28-5-15 emc
1545 eilish mc auliffe nhc 28-5-15 emc
investnethealthcare
 
1200 clare sanderon hse ireland
1200 clare sanderon hse ireland1200 clare sanderon hse ireland
1200 clare sanderon hse ireland
investnethealthcare
 
1215 austin warters integrated care how innovation can improve services edit
1215 austin warters integrated care   how innovation can improve services edit1215 austin warters integrated care   how innovation can improve services edit
1215 austin warters integrated care how innovation can improve services edit
investnethealthcare
 
1100 richard corbridge
1100 richard corbridge1100 richard corbridge
1100 richard corbridge
investnethealthcare
 
1115 aine carroll clinical leaders forum nhc integrated care turning healthca...
1115 aine carroll clinical leaders forum nhc integrated care turning healthca...1115 aine carroll clinical leaders forum nhc integrated care turning healthca...
1115 aine carroll clinical leaders forum nhc integrated care turning healthca...
investnethealthcare
 
1455 ed marsden slides 050315
1455 ed marsden slides   0503151455 ed marsden slides   050315
1455 ed marsden slides 050315
investnethealthcare
 
1200 colm henry voluntary hospital forum final draft may 2015
1200 colm henry voluntary hospital forum final draft may 20151200 colm henry voluntary hospital forum final draft may 2015
1200 colm henry voluntary hospital forum final draft may 2015
investnethealthcare
 
1410 prof james raftery nhc2015
1410 prof james raftery nhc20151410 prof james raftery nhc2015
1410 prof james raftery nhc2015
investnethealthcare
 
1145 paul ellingstad the builders perspective national health conference dubl...
1145 paul ellingstad the builders perspective national health conference dubl...1145 paul ellingstad the builders perspective national health conference dubl...
1145 paul ellingstad the builders perspective national health conference dubl...
investnethealthcare
 

Viewers also liked (15)

1520 declan o neil activity based funding comparisons
1520 declan o neil activity based funding   comparisons1520 declan o neil activity based funding   comparisons
1520 declan o neil activity based funding comparisons
 
1450 brenda dooley national healthcare conference may28 2015
1450 brenda dooley national healthcare conference may28 20151450 brenda dooley national healthcare conference may28 2015
1450 brenda dooley national healthcare conference may28 2015
 
1145 leo kearns healthcare conference may 2015 final.v1
1145 leo kearns healthcare conference may 2015 final.v11145 leo kearns healthcare conference may 2015 final.v1
1145 leo kearns healthcare conference may 2015 final.v1
 
1530 surewash e health pres pathway to success
1530 surewash e health pres pathway to success1530 surewash e health pres pathway to success
1530 surewash e health pres pathway to success
 
1420 bleddyn rees
1420 bleddyn rees1420 bleddyn rees
1420 bleddyn rees
 
1545 eilish mc auliffe nhc 28-5-15 emc
1545 eilish mc auliffe nhc   28-5-15 emc1545 eilish mc auliffe nhc   28-5-15 emc
1545 eilish mc auliffe nhc 28-5-15 emc
 
1200 clare sanderon hse ireland
1200 clare sanderon hse ireland1200 clare sanderon hse ireland
1200 clare sanderon hse ireland
 
1215 austin warters integrated care how innovation can improve services edit
1215 austin warters integrated care   how innovation can improve services edit1215 austin warters integrated care   how innovation can improve services edit
1215 austin warters integrated care how innovation can improve services edit
 
1100 richard corbridge
1100 richard corbridge1100 richard corbridge
1100 richard corbridge
 
1115 aine carroll clinical leaders forum nhc integrated care turning healthca...
1115 aine carroll clinical leaders forum nhc integrated care turning healthca...1115 aine carroll clinical leaders forum nhc integrated care turning healthca...
1115 aine carroll clinical leaders forum nhc integrated care turning healthca...
 
1455 ed marsden slides 050315
1455 ed marsden slides   0503151455 ed marsden slides   050315
1455 ed marsden slides 050315
 
1200 colm henry voluntary hospital forum final draft may 2015
1200 colm henry voluntary hospital forum final draft may 20151200 colm henry voluntary hospital forum final draft may 2015
1200 colm henry voluntary hospital forum final draft may 2015
 
1410 prof james raftery nhc2015
1410 prof james raftery nhc20151410 prof james raftery nhc2015
1410 prof james raftery nhc2015
 
1145 paul ellingstad the builders perspective national health conference dubl...
1145 paul ellingstad the builders perspective national health conference dubl...1145 paul ellingstad the builders perspective national health conference dubl...
1145 paul ellingstad the builders perspective national health conference dubl...
 
1415 margaret swords
1415 margaret swords1415 margaret swords
1415 margaret swords
 

Similar to 1100 michael harty final hcci national healthcare conference 2015

Cma care home_sector_report
Cma care home_sector_reportCma care home_sector_report
Cma care home_sector_report
Jonathan Johnson
 
Action4Advocacy Demonstrating Value workshop
Action4Advocacy Demonstrating Value workshopAction4Advocacy Demonstrating Value workshop
Action4Advocacy Demonstrating Value workshopCROA Not for profit
 
Epp gabbia filippo 2019
Epp gabbia filippo 2019Epp gabbia filippo 2019
Epp gabbia filippo 2019
Filippo Gabbia
 
Bill Taylor, Changing approach and behaviour in service delivery: a provider'...
Bill Taylor, Changing approach and behaviour in service delivery: a provider'...Bill Taylor, Changing approach and behaviour in service delivery: a provider'...
Bill Taylor, Changing approach and behaviour in service delivery: a provider'...
LandorLINKS
 
PfH Live 2016 Rising to the challenge - Steve Malone
PfH Live 2016 Rising to the challenge - Steve MalonePfH Live 2016 Rising to the challenge - Steve Malone
PfH Live 2016 Rising to the challenge - Steve Malone
Procurement For Housing
 
Carewise West Sussex Funding Advice Scheme
Carewise West Sussex Funding Advice SchemeCarewise West Sussex Funding Advice Scheme
Carewise West Sussex Funding Advice Scheme
Think Local Act Personal
 
Working to deliver better member outcomes
Working to deliver better member outcomesWorking to deliver better member outcomes
Working to deliver better member outcomes
Henry Tapper
 
Eddie Ritson / Jim O'Donogue - ECCH/TF3/S3 Group
Eddie Ritson / Jim O'Donogue - ECCH/TF3/S3 GroupEddie Ritson / Jim O'Donogue - ECCH/TF3/S3 Group
Eddie Ritson / Jim O'Donogue - ECCH/TF3/S3 GroupCASALA CENTRE
 
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-ReadPrimary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
The King's Fund
 
Stephen McComb - PA Consulting
Stephen McComb - PA ConsultingStephen McComb - PA Consulting
Stephen McComb - PA ConsultingCASALA CENTRE
 
Resource Allocation and Purchasing: What do we need to know and why?
Resource Allocation and Purchasing: What do we need to know and why?Resource Allocation and Purchasing: What do we need to know and why?
Resource Allocation and Purchasing: What do we need to know and why?
HFG Project
 
16221
1622116221
16221
prem9865
 
Telepsychiatry
TelepsychiatryTelepsychiatry
Katie brennan - integrated approach for mental health services
Katie brennan - integrated approach for mental health servicesKatie brennan - integrated approach for mental health services
Katie brennan - integrated approach for mental health services
NHS Improving Quality
 
Maxine Pott Funding and Contract Review
Maxine Pott  Funding and Contract ReviewMaxine Pott  Funding and Contract Review
Maxine Pott Funding and Contract Review
mckenln
 
Panel Session: Innovative sourcing for better outcomes
Panel Session: Innovative sourcing for better outcomes Panel Session: Innovative sourcing for better outcomes
Panel Session: Innovative sourcing for better outcomes
Procurement For Housing
 
Dr. Lemeneh Tefera
Dr. Lemeneh TeferaDr. Lemeneh Tefera
Webinar_Dangerous_Trends_James_Muir_Jan2015V6
Webinar_Dangerous_Trends_James_Muir_Jan2015V6Webinar_Dangerous_Trends_James_Muir_Jan2015V6
Webinar_Dangerous_Trends_James_Muir_Jan2015V6James Muir
 
Rural Accountable Care: Here to There
Rural Accountable Care: Here to ThereRural Accountable Care: Here to There
Rural Accountable Care: Here to TherePYA, P.C.
 
Employee Engagement: Your Tool for Tackling Heath Care Costs
Employee Engagement: Your Tool for Tackling Heath Care CostsEmployee Engagement: Your Tool for Tackling Heath Care Costs
Employee Engagement: Your Tool for Tackling Heath Care Costs
Digital Measures
 

Similar to 1100 michael harty final hcci national healthcare conference 2015 (20)

Cma care home_sector_report
Cma care home_sector_reportCma care home_sector_report
Cma care home_sector_report
 
Action4Advocacy Demonstrating Value workshop
Action4Advocacy Demonstrating Value workshopAction4Advocacy Demonstrating Value workshop
Action4Advocacy Demonstrating Value workshop
 
Epp gabbia filippo 2019
Epp gabbia filippo 2019Epp gabbia filippo 2019
Epp gabbia filippo 2019
 
Bill Taylor, Changing approach and behaviour in service delivery: a provider'...
Bill Taylor, Changing approach and behaviour in service delivery: a provider'...Bill Taylor, Changing approach and behaviour in service delivery: a provider'...
Bill Taylor, Changing approach and behaviour in service delivery: a provider'...
 
PfH Live 2016 Rising to the challenge - Steve Malone
PfH Live 2016 Rising to the challenge - Steve MalonePfH Live 2016 Rising to the challenge - Steve Malone
PfH Live 2016 Rising to the challenge - Steve Malone
 
Carewise West Sussex Funding Advice Scheme
Carewise West Sussex Funding Advice SchemeCarewise West Sussex Funding Advice Scheme
Carewise West Sussex Funding Advice Scheme
 
Working to deliver better member outcomes
Working to deliver better member outcomesWorking to deliver better member outcomes
Working to deliver better member outcomes
 
Eddie Ritson / Jim O'Donogue - ECCH/TF3/S3 Group
Eddie Ritson / Jim O'Donogue - ECCH/TF3/S3 GroupEddie Ritson / Jim O'Donogue - ECCH/TF3/S3 Group
Eddie Ritson / Jim O'Donogue - ECCH/TF3/S3 Group
 
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-ReadPrimary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
 
Stephen McComb - PA Consulting
Stephen McComb - PA ConsultingStephen McComb - PA Consulting
Stephen McComb - PA Consulting
 
Resource Allocation and Purchasing: What do we need to know and why?
Resource Allocation and Purchasing: What do we need to know and why?Resource Allocation and Purchasing: What do we need to know and why?
Resource Allocation and Purchasing: What do we need to know and why?
 
16221
1622116221
16221
 
Telepsychiatry
TelepsychiatryTelepsychiatry
Telepsychiatry
 
Katie brennan - integrated approach for mental health services
Katie brennan - integrated approach for mental health servicesKatie brennan - integrated approach for mental health services
Katie brennan - integrated approach for mental health services
 
Maxine Pott Funding and Contract Review
Maxine Pott  Funding and Contract ReviewMaxine Pott  Funding and Contract Review
Maxine Pott Funding and Contract Review
 
Panel Session: Innovative sourcing for better outcomes
Panel Session: Innovative sourcing for better outcomes Panel Session: Innovative sourcing for better outcomes
Panel Session: Innovative sourcing for better outcomes
 
Dr. Lemeneh Tefera
Dr. Lemeneh TeferaDr. Lemeneh Tefera
Dr. Lemeneh Tefera
 
Webinar_Dangerous_Trends_James_Muir_Jan2015V6
Webinar_Dangerous_Trends_James_Muir_Jan2015V6Webinar_Dangerous_Trends_James_Muir_Jan2015V6
Webinar_Dangerous_Trends_James_Muir_Jan2015V6
 
Rural Accountable Care: Here to There
Rural Accountable Care: Here to ThereRural Accountable Care: Here to There
Rural Accountable Care: Here to There
 
Employee Engagement: Your Tool for Tackling Heath Care Costs
Employee Engagement: Your Tool for Tackling Heath Care CostsEmployee Engagement: Your Tool for Tackling Heath Care Costs
Employee Engagement: Your Tool for Tackling Heath Care Costs
 

More from investnethealthcare

Charlotte McArdel
Charlotte McArdelCharlotte McArdel
Charlotte McArdel
investnethealthcare
 
1515 david toohey syncrophi systems ltd nhc 2015
1515 david toohey syncrophi systems ltd  nhc 20151515 david toohey syncrophi systems ltd  nhc 2015
1515 david toohey syncrophi systems ltd nhc 2015
investnethealthcare
 
1405 john swords investnet winning-tenders-may-2015- 16 9 ratio
1405 john swords investnet winning-tenders-may-2015- 16 9 ratio1405 john swords investnet winning-tenders-may-2015- 16 9 ratio
1405 john swords investnet winning-tenders-may-2015- 16 9 ratio
investnethealthcare
 
1115 gary mooney national health-conference-eire-may15
1115 gary mooney national health-conference-eire-may151115 gary mooney national health-conference-eire-may15
1115 gary mooney national health-conference-eire-may15
investnethealthcare
 
1440 sheila presentation v2
1440 sheila presentation v21440 sheila presentation v2
1440 sheila presentation v2
investnethealthcare
 
1230 susie clarke healthcare conference may 2015
1230 susie clarke healthcare conference may 20151230 susie clarke healthcare conference may 2015
1230 susie clarke healthcare conference may 2015
investnethealthcare
 
1200 nadine henningsen ireland international conference - home care in cana...
1200 nadine henningsen ireland   international conference - home care in cana...1200 nadine henningsen ireland   international conference - home care in cana...
1200 nadine henningsen ireland international conference - home care in cana...
investnethealthcare
 
1130 john sweeney hci homecarepres169
1130 john sweeney hci homecarepres1691130 john sweeney hci homecarepres169
1130 john sweeney hci homecarepres169
investnethealthcare
 
1115 bridget warr home and community care ireland conference dublin - may 2...
1115 bridget warr home and community care ireland conference   dublin - may 2...1115 bridget warr home and community care ireland conference   dublin - may 2...
1115 bridget warr home and community care ireland conference dublin - may 2...
investnethealthcare
 
1435 jerome coffey nhc
1435 jerome coffey nhc1435 jerome coffey nhc
1435 jerome coffey nhc
investnethealthcare
 
1405 todd manning
1405 todd manning1405 todd manning
1405 todd manning
investnethealthcare
 
1445 thaddeus o'mac krell owens & minor irish nhs conference - may 2015
1445 thaddeus o'mac krell owens & minor   irish nhs conference - may 20151445 thaddeus o'mac krell owens & minor   irish nhs conference - may 2015
1445 thaddeus o'mac krell owens & minor irish nhs conference - may 2015investnethealthcare
 
1430 david duffy nhc presentation 28.5.15 final
1430 david duffy nhc presentation 28.5.15 final1430 david duffy nhc presentation 28.5.15 final
1430 david duffy nhc presentation 28.5.15 finalinvestnethealthcare
 
1405 loretto callaghan novartis hmi presentation
1405 loretto callaghan novartis hmi presentation1405 loretto callaghan novartis hmi presentation
1405 loretto callaghan novartis hmi presentationinvestnethealthcare
 

More from investnethealthcare (14)

Charlotte McArdel
Charlotte McArdelCharlotte McArdel
Charlotte McArdel
 
1515 david toohey syncrophi systems ltd nhc 2015
1515 david toohey syncrophi systems ltd  nhc 20151515 david toohey syncrophi systems ltd  nhc 2015
1515 david toohey syncrophi systems ltd nhc 2015
 
1405 john swords investnet winning-tenders-may-2015- 16 9 ratio
1405 john swords investnet winning-tenders-may-2015- 16 9 ratio1405 john swords investnet winning-tenders-may-2015- 16 9 ratio
1405 john swords investnet winning-tenders-may-2015- 16 9 ratio
 
1115 gary mooney national health-conference-eire-may15
1115 gary mooney national health-conference-eire-may151115 gary mooney national health-conference-eire-may15
1115 gary mooney national health-conference-eire-may15
 
1440 sheila presentation v2
1440 sheila presentation v21440 sheila presentation v2
1440 sheila presentation v2
 
1230 susie clarke healthcare conference may 2015
1230 susie clarke healthcare conference may 20151230 susie clarke healthcare conference may 2015
1230 susie clarke healthcare conference may 2015
 
1200 nadine henningsen ireland international conference - home care in cana...
1200 nadine henningsen ireland   international conference - home care in cana...1200 nadine henningsen ireland   international conference - home care in cana...
1200 nadine henningsen ireland international conference - home care in cana...
 
1130 john sweeney hci homecarepres169
1130 john sweeney hci homecarepres1691130 john sweeney hci homecarepres169
1130 john sweeney hci homecarepres169
 
1115 bridget warr home and community care ireland conference dublin - may 2...
1115 bridget warr home and community care ireland conference   dublin - may 2...1115 bridget warr home and community care ireland conference   dublin - may 2...
1115 bridget warr home and community care ireland conference dublin - may 2...
 
1435 jerome coffey nhc
1435 jerome coffey nhc1435 jerome coffey nhc
1435 jerome coffey nhc
 
1405 todd manning
1405 todd manning1405 todd manning
1405 todd manning
 
1445 thaddeus o'mac krell owens & minor irish nhs conference - may 2015
1445 thaddeus o'mac krell owens & minor   irish nhs conference - may 20151445 thaddeus o'mac krell owens & minor   irish nhs conference - may 2015
1445 thaddeus o'mac krell owens & minor irish nhs conference - may 2015
 
1430 david duffy nhc presentation 28.5.15 final
1430 david duffy nhc presentation 28.5.15 final1430 david duffy nhc presentation 28.5.15 final
1430 david duffy nhc presentation 28.5.15 final
 
1405 loretto callaghan novartis hmi presentation
1405 loretto callaghan novartis hmi presentation1405 loretto callaghan novartis hmi presentation
1405 loretto callaghan novartis hmi presentation
 

Recently uploaded

Performance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing
Performance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility TestingPerformance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing
Performance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing
Nguyễn Thị Vân Anh
 
Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...
Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...
Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...
Guillermo Rivera
 
Navigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and Beyond
Navigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and BeyondNavigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and Beyond
Navigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and Beyond
Aboud Health Group
 
GURGAON Call Girls ❤8901183002❤ #ℂALL# #gIRLS# In GURGAON ₹,2500 Cash Payment...
GURGAON Call Girls ❤8901183002❤ #ℂALL# #gIRLS# In GURGAON ₹,2500 Cash Payment...GURGAON Call Girls ❤8901183002❤ #ℂALL# #gIRLS# In GURGAON ₹,2500 Cash Payment...
GURGAON Call Girls ❤8901183002❤ #ℂALL# #gIRLS# In GURGAON ₹,2500 Cash Payment...
ranishasharma67
 
Artificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular Therapy
Artificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular TherapyArtificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular Therapy
Artificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular Therapy
Iris Thiele Isip-Tan
 
Jaipur ❤cALL gIRLS 89O1183002 ❤ℂall Girls IN JaiPuR ESCORT SERVICE
Jaipur ❤cALL gIRLS 89O1183002 ❤ℂall Girls IN JaiPuR ESCORT SERVICEJaipur ❤cALL gIRLS 89O1183002 ❤ℂall Girls IN JaiPuR ESCORT SERVICE
Jaipur ❤cALL gIRLS 89O1183002 ❤ℂall Girls IN JaiPuR ESCORT SERVICE
ranishasharma67
 
BOWEL ELIMINATION BY ANUSHRI SRIVASTAVA.pptx
BOWEL ELIMINATION BY ANUSHRI SRIVASTAVA.pptxBOWEL ELIMINATION BY ANUSHRI SRIVASTAVA.pptx
BOWEL ELIMINATION BY ANUSHRI SRIVASTAVA.pptx
AnushriSrivastav
 
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdfCHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdf
Sachin Sharma
 
Immunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentation
Immunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentationImmunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentation
Immunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentation
BeshedaWedajo
 
Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...
Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...
Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...
Dr. David Greene Arizona
 
India Clinical Trials Market: Industry Size and Growth Trends [2030] Analyzed...
India Clinical Trials Market: Industry Size and Growth Trends [2030] Analyzed...India Clinical Trials Market: Industry Size and Growth Trends [2030] Analyzed...
India Clinical Trials Market: Industry Size and Growth Trends [2030] Analyzed...
Kumar Satyam
 
HEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptx
HEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptxHEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptx
HEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptx
priyabhojwani1200
 
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
Ameena Kadar
 
CANCER CANCER CANCER CANCER CANCER CANCER
CANCER  CANCER  CANCER  CANCER  CANCER CANCERCANCER  CANCER  CANCER  CANCER  CANCER CANCER
CANCER CANCER CANCER CANCER CANCER CANCER
KRISTELLEGAMBOA2
 
R3 Stem Cells and Kidney Repair A New Horizon in Nephrology.pptx
R3 Stem Cells and Kidney Repair A New Horizon in Nephrology.pptxR3 Stem Cells and Kidney Repair A New Horizon in Nephrology.pptx
R3 Stem Cells and Kidney Repair A New Horizon in Nephrology.pptx
R3 Stem Cell
 
What Are Homeopathic Treatments for Migraines.pdf
What Are Homeopathic Treatments for Migraines.pdfWhat Are Homeopathic Treatments for Migraines.pdf
What Are Homeopathic Treatments for Migraines.pdf
Dharma Homoeopathy
 
Anatomy and Physiology Chapter-16_Digestive-System.pptx
Anatomy and Physiology Chapter-16_Digestive-System.pptxAnatomy and Physiology Chapter-16_Digestive-System.pptx
Anatomy and Physiology Chapter-16_Digestive-System.pptx
shanicedivinagracia2
 
GLOBAL WARMING BY PRIYA BHOJWANI @..pptx
GLOBAL WARMING BY PRIYA BHOJWANI @..pptxGLOBAL WARMING BY PRIYA BHOJWANI @..pptx
GLOBAL WARMING BY PRIYA BHOJWANI @..pptx
priyabhojwani1200
 
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdfCHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
Sachin Sharma
 
VERIFICATION AND VALIDATION TOOLKIT Determining Performance Characteristics o...
VERIFICATION AND VALIDATION TOOLKIT Determining Performance Characteristics o...VERIFICATION AND VALIDATION TOOLKIT Determining Performance Characteristics o...
VERIFICATION AND VALIDATION TOOLKIT Determining Performance Characteristics o...
Nguyễn Thị Vân Anh
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Performance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing
Performance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility TestingPerformance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing
Performance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing
 
Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...
Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...
Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...
 
Navigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and Beyond
Navigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and BeyondNavigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and Beyond
Navigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and Beyond
 
GURGAON Call Girls ❤8901183002❤ #ℂALL# #gIRLS# In GURGAON ₹,2500 Cash Payment...
GURGAON Call Girls ❤8901183002❤ #ℂALL# #gIRLS# In GURGAON ₹,2500 Cash Payment...GURGAON Call Girls ❤8901183002❤ #ℂALL# #gIRLS# In GURGAON ₹,2500 Cash Payment...
GURGAON Call Girls ❤8901183002❤ #ℂALL# #gIRLS# In GURGAON ₹,2500 Cash Payment...
 
Artificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular Therapy
Artificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular TherapyArtificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular Therapy
Artificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular Therapy
 
Jaipur ❤cALL gIRLS 89O1183002 ❤ℂall Girls IN JaiPuR ESCORT SERVICE
Jaipur ❤cALL gIRLS 89O1183002 ❤ℂall Girls IN JaiPuR ESCORT SERVICEJaipur ❤cALL gIRLS 89O1183002 ❤ℂall Girls IN JaiPuR ESCORT SERVICE
Jaipur ❤cALL gIRLS 89O1183002 ❤ℂall Girls IN JaiPuR ESCORT SERVICE
 
BOWEL ELIMINATION BY ANUSHRI SRIVASTAVA.pptx
BOWEL ELIMINATION BY ANUSHRI SRIVASTAVA.pptxBOWEL ELIMINATION BY ANUSHRI SRIVASTAVA.pptx
BOWEL ELIMINATION BY ANUSHRI SRIVASTAVA.pptx
 
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdfCHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdf
 
Immunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentation
Immunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentationImmunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentation
Immunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentation
 
Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...
Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...
Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...
 
India Clinical Trials Market: Industry Size and Growth Trends [2030] Analyzed...
India Clinical Trials Market: Industry Size and Growth Trends [2030] Analyzed...India Clinical Trials Market: Industry Size and Growth Trends [2030] Analyzed...
India Clinical Trials Market: Industry Size and Growth Trends [2030] Analyzed...
 
HEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptx
HEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptxHEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptx
HEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptx
 
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
 
CANCER CANCER CANCER CANCER CANCER CANCER
CANCER  CANCER  CANCER  CANCER  CANCER CANCERCANCER  CANCER  CANCER  CANCER  CANCER CANCER
CANCER CANCER CANCER CANCER CANCER CANCER
 
R3 Stem Cells and Kidney Repair A New Horizon in Nephrology.pptx
R3 Stem Cells and Kidney Repair A New Horizon in Nephrology.pptxR3 Stem Cells and Kidney Repair A New Horizon in Nephrology.pptx
R3 Stem Cells and Kidney Repair A New Horizon in Nephrology.pptx
 
What Are Homeopathic Treatments for Migraines.pdf
What Are Homeopathic Treatments for Migraines.pdfWhat Are Homeopathic Treatments for Migraines.pdf
What Are Homeopathic Treatments for Migraines.pdf
 
Anatomy and Physiology Chapter-16_Digestive-System.pptx
Anatomy and Physiology Chapter-16_Digestive-System.pptxAnatomy and Physiology Chapter-16_Digestive-System.pptx
Anatomy and Physiology Chapter-16_Digestive-System.pptx
 
GLOBAL WARMING BY PRIYA BHOJWANI @..pptx
GLOBAL WARMING BY PRIYA BHOJWANI @..pptxGLOBAL WARMING BY PRIYA BHOJWANI @..pptx
GLOBAL WARMING BY PRIYA BHOJWANI @..pptx
 
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdfCHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
 
VERIFICATION AND VALIDATION TOOLKIT Determining Performance Characteristics o...
VERIFICATION AND VALIDATION TOOLKIT Determining Performance Characteristics o...VERIFICATION AND VALIDATION TOOLKIT Determining Performance Characteristics o...
VERIFICATION AND VALIDATION TOOLKIT Determining Performance Characteristics o...
 

1100 michael harty final hcci national healthcare conference 2015

  • 1. How Can We Improve the Quality and Efficiency of Home Care Provision in the Absence of Regulation National Healthcare Conference 2015
  • 2. Social Care budget 2015 - €3B Elder Care budget 2015 - €1.27B Fair Deal Scheme - €948M HSE Funded Home Care - €325M  Home Help - €195M  Home Care Package Scheme - €130M Privately funded care - €20M Older Persons Services
  • 3. Home Care Market 2014 HSE Not-For- Profit Private Home Help Home Care Packages Private Customers €142m €53m €33m €54m €175m €107m €63m€43m HSE Funded €20m €195m €130m €20m €345m
  • 4. Structural Issues Holding the Home Care Sector Back  Unregulated - Scandals  Dominated by State – Purchaser and provider  Strategic Engagement  Funding Silos  Poor cousin of Healthcare Sector – Lack of Confidence  Poor Transparency and Accountability
  • 11. Waste
  • 12. Examples of What is Wrong  5 Hour rule  Paying providers in advance of delivering care  One price for all cases  Regional monopolies - Lack of Choice and Clients not Empowered  Price based tenders  PHN’s over worked – assessors, supervisors, administrators, advocates
  • 15. What Does Good Commissioning Achieve?  Drives quality provision  Brings efficiencies without affecting quality  Promotes cohort of quality providers  Promotes healthy & safe competition  Provides transparency and accountability  Brings fairness
  • 16. Key Question What Does a Good Commissioning Process Look Like?
  • 17. Internal Reference Price Model  Emphasises on quality  Licensing not contracting  HSE set internal price for home care  Justified  Per Lot  Latitude for special cases  PHN assessment  Outline  Hours  State contribution is ........  Tax relief  Private top up
  • 18. Internal Reference Price Model  Client discusses with provider directly  Care Plan  Customised price  PHN role - supervision and support where needed
  • 19. Internal Reference Price Model  Advantages  HSE know exact exposure  Promotes idea of contribution  Each individual case properly costed  Takes advantage of local conditions  Helps recruitment and retention  Drives quality through client choice  Promotes quality providers willing to invest  Move up acuity scale  Better integration with acute sector
  • 20. Home Care Needs to Play a More Important Role Let Money Follow the Patient – End Silos Use Procurement as a Driver of Quality Provision and Quality Providers  Commissioning Policy Extensive Transparent Quality based Summary
  • 21. How Can We Improve the Quality and Efficiency of Home Care Provision in the Absence of Regulation National Healthcare Conference 2015

Editor's Notes

  1. Improving economic times but important we ensure we are getting max out of existing resources before looking for more
  2. Overview of Elder care sector and give some context.
  3. Looks complicated but actually gives a good breakdown of home care funding. Interesting to see that private sector only accounts for about 18% of total market and only 13% of state funding.
  4. Want to look at the issues I think are holding sector back from playing its full role within the overall health sector.
  5. Most obvious obstacle Primetime scandals Should have been regulated before residential sector Dept. of Finance not wanting to create further entitlements Short term view as HC could bring significant long term savings EPS report calculated savings of €2B over 8 years – running sector more efficiently and allowing hc play a fuller role
  6. Another major obstacle Both purchaser and provider Not healthy Expensive - 30% Move towards how residential care sector looks 20/80 State should regulate and supervise not necessarily provide Role for the state but questionable if it needs to be of order of 80% Need strategic engagement with state
  7. Connected to State dominance is lack of engagement with stakeholders Threat to the sector Recruitment / retention
  8. Beaurocratic obstacle State loves silos, HSE loves silos. Allows them to channel funds how they want rather than in best and most efficient manner Create false demands i.e. residential care Protects poor providers Takes power away from client No difference between HH and HCP Antipathy of money follows the patient
  9. Issue providers need to address HC seen as weak link in continuum of care – not safe pair of hands Acute sector first reflex is for residential care / step down Need to promote cohort of professional operators willing to invest Move up acuity scale Organisations need Clear future = Investment with confidence HC underutilised
  10. One of most Important structural issue Lack of Section 39 funding prime example – no procurement process - €18M out of €60M Organisations receiving funds from multiple sources – no tracking Primetime scandals – 50% wastage Place for all types of organisations but no service is free Debunk myth of voluntary or NFP
  11. Lack of transparency and accountability lead to waste With increasing demand and scarce resources cant afford waste Eliminate waste before we ask for more funds
  12. 5 hour rule – 2 providers per case, anti social hours, multiple providers, undermines continuity, silos issue. Paying in advance – no accountability, cant assume army of Mother Theresas out there – Primetime Single price – companionship to late stage dementia commodity type care, incentivises cutting corners. More nuanced approach needed Regional monopolies – no incentive to provide great care, vulnerable people with low propensity to complain in first place. Competition good in health as people make decisions on quality not price Price based tenders – pushed down price of HC which pushes down wages and causes problems of recruitment and retention. Bedrock of providing quality care. Look at UK example. PHN’s – supervision should be primary role
  13. To paraphrase Bill Clinton “It’s commissioning stupid!” Most important tool available to shape sector Too important for just procurement department More input from ground staff and stakeholders – designed by stakeholders
  14. Structure based on price fine for commodities but elderly aren’t a commodity Last tender 100% price!! Should be based on quality and client choice Yes want value for money but more sophisticated and nuanced way to get there than just blunt price route
  15. Not about knocking down prices and encouraging providers to cut corners Trying to bring about efficiencies through a blunt instrument like price is a fools game Providers that are bringing real value added to table Transparency by ensuring all funding goes through a procurement process Fairness promotes partnership and collaboration lacking at the moment
  16. Why lock out good new providers? Taking into account training, supervision etc.
  17. Some providers may need to upskill to enable them to do proper assessments Selection from Approved provider list Price maybe taking into consideration that provider has work in the area already
  18. Improving economic times but important we ensure we are getting max out of existing resources before looking for more