NVH	
  foam	
  equipment	
  for	
  automo1ve	
  applica1ons
                                                          	
  
                                    	
  

                        RAFAEL	
  ORTIZ	
  
                   Solu/ons	
  Group	
  Manager	
  
                        @rafaelor/z00     	
  
                                  	
  
Voice	
  of	
  the	
  customer
                             	
  
 Noise:	
  percep/on	
  is	
  everything	
  




                                          Source:	
  J.D.	
  Powers	
  2006	
  New	
  Car	
  Buyer	
  Survey	
  
Quietness	
  and	
  quality	
  
                                                                          Overall	
  vehicle	
  sa1sfac1on	
  directly	
  correlates	
  to	
  overall	
  interior	
  quietness	
  sa1sfac1on.	
  	
  


                                                                     10                                                                                                               9,66



                                                                      9                                                                                           8,89
                        Ra/ng	
  Vehicle	
  Overall	
  Quality	
  




                                                                                                                                                 8,25

                                                                      8                                                  7,67


                                                                                                    7,07
                                                                      7

                                                                               6,25

                                                                      6


                                                                      5
                                                                                <5                    6                    7                       8                9                  10
                                                                                                                Ra/ng	
  Overall	
  Interior	
  Quietness	
  
Source:	
  J.D.	
  Powers	
  2006	
  New	
  Car	
  Buyer	
  Survey	
  
NVH	
  percep/on	
  


“The	
  noise,	
  vibra/on	
  and	
  
harshness	
  (NVH)	
  reduc/on	
  
bring	
  to	
  the	
  customer	
  not	
  
only	
  the	
  percep/on	
  of	
  quality	
  
but	
  durability,	
  solidity	
  and	
  
higher	
  general	
  sa/sfac/on”	
  
                  Source:	
  J.D.	
  Powers	
  2006	
  New	
  Car	
  Buyer	
  Survey	
  
NVH	
  applica/on	
  
                                          	
  


Resonance	
   occurs	
   within	
   the	
   car
                                              	
  
sec/ons:	
  pillars,	
  cowl	
  bars,	
  wheel	
  
wells	
  &	
  side	
  panels.	
  
 	
  
Many	
  automo/ve	
  manufacturers	
  use	
  acous/cal	
  foam	
  to	
  minimize	
  
noise	
  coming	
  from	
  /res,	
  wind,	
  exhaust	
  and	
  engine.	
  
 	
  
NVH	
  foam	
  cavity	
  filling	
  




             Baffles	
                                      Injected	
  foam	
  


Two-­‐component	
   polyurethane	
   foams.	
   Close	
   cell                  	
  
formula/on	
   1	
   to	
   5	
   pcf	
   density	
   range.	
   Designed	
   to	
  
block	
   noise,	
   water	
   &	
   wind,	
   forming	
   a	
   high           	
  
performance	
  acous/cal	
  seal	
  and	
  preven/ng	
  the	
  noise            	
  
from	
  resona/ng.	
  	
  
 	
  
Acous/c	
  baffles
                                                  	
  

                                                    Specific	
  tooling	
  for	
  each	
  
                                                    part	
  
Low-­‐up	
  front	
  capital	
                      	
  
	
                                                  Unreliable	
  expansion	
  	
  
Simple	
  approach	
                                	
  
	
                                                  Sealing	
  performance	
  
Licle	
  in-­‐plant	
  space	
                      	
  
constraints	
                                       Specific	
  baffle	
  per	
  
                                                    vehicle,	
  many	
  part	
  
                                                    numbers,	
  high	
  inventory	
  
                                                    &	
  slow	
  /me	
  to	
  market	
  
Acous/c	
  baffles
                                     	
  




Baffles	
  are	
  costly	
  to	
  design,	
  manufacture	
  &	
  install	
  and	
  oeen	
  
                 result	
  in	
  a	
  less	
  than	
  op/mal	
  solu/on	
  
Injected	
  foam	
  
3D,	
  robust	
  seal	
  and	
  
improved	
  NVH	
  	
  
	
  
Flexible:	
  used	
  on	
  mul/ple	
  
                                                      High	
  up-­‐front	
  capital	
  
vehicle	
  lines	
  and	
  carry	
  
                                                      costs	
  
over	
  to	
  future	
  lines	
  
                                                      	
  
	
  	
  
                                                      Poten/al	
  facili/es	
  space	
  
Low	
  material	
  cost	
  and	
  
                                                      constraints	
  
reduced	
  or	
  eliminated	
  
                                                      	
  
tooling	
  costs	
  
                                                      Cost	
  of	
  ownership	
  	
  
	
  
Can	
  adjust	
  foam	
  volume	
  
and	
  shot	
  loca/ons	
  as	
  
required	
  
Manual	
  applica/on	
  
 Automa/c	
  applica/on	
  
NVH	
  equipment	
  challenges
                             	
  

               High	
  up-­‐front	
  capital	
  costs	
  
               Custom-­‐designed	
  polyurethane	
  processing	
  
               equipment	
  for	
  NVH	
  foam	
  is	
  expensive	
  
               	
  
               Poten1al	
  facili1es	
  space	
  constraints	
  	
  
               These	
  sizeable	
  polyurethane	
  processing	
  
               machines	
  take	
  up	
  a	
  large	
  amount	
  of	
  space	
  
               	
  
               Cost	
  of	
  ownership	
  
               Custom	
  repair	
  parts	
  are	
  expensive.	
  
               Specialized	
  technicians	
  usually	
  travel	
  to	
  
               conduct	
  on-­‐site	
  maintenance	
  and	
  repairs	
  
NVH	
  Solu/ons	
  –	
  Betacell	
  
                        Specialized	
  custom	
  design	
  
                        	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  Long	
  lead	
  /mes,	
  specialized	
  service	
  parts	
  
                        	
  	
  	
  	
  Costly	
  repairs	
  
                        Complicated	
  for	
  plant	
  personnel	
  
                                        	
  Longer	
  trouble	
  shoo/ng	
  for	
  repairs	
  
                                       	
  More	
  down	
  /me	
  
     	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  Controls	
  are	
  customized	
  by	
  cell,	
  longer	
  training	
  
                         	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  Specialized	
  maintenance	
  
                         	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  Difficult	
  to	
  service	
  in	
  field	
  
                                        Foot	
  print	
  must	
  be	
  considered	
  
	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  Variable	
  ra/o:	
  rotary/linear	
  pumps	
  	
  
     	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  Automa/cally	
  adjusts	
  for	
  wear	
  
     	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  Risk	
  of	
  dispensing	
  out	
  of	
  ra/o	
  tolerance	
  	
  
     	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  Different	
  pump	
  types	
  –	
  more	
  repair	
  parts	
  
     	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  
                        	
  
                        	
  
HFR	
  
The	
  Graco	
  HFR	
  metering	
  system	
  is	
  a	
  standard	
  
modular	
  design	
  with	
  precision	
  dispensing	
  
capabili/es.	
  
	
  
Advanced	
  &	
  reliable:	
  High	
  quality	
  meter,	
  mix	
  
and	
  dispense	
  system	
  that	
  offers	
  more	
  
technology	
  and	
  func/onality.	
  
	
  
Affordable:	
  a	
  low	
  ini/al	
  investment	
  allows	
  
you	
  to	
  use	
  acous/cal	
  foam	
  applica/ons	
  
where	
  it	
  may	
  not	
  have	
  been	
  possible	
  before.	
  
Lower	
  price	
  than	
  tradi/onal	
  custom	
  systems.	
  	
  
	
  
Global	
  distribu1on	
  
	
  
Installa/on	
  size	
  

       BetaCell	
  
       Machine:	
                      	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   141”W	
   x	
   40”D	
   x	
   103”H	
  
       Control	
   Panel:	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   95”W	
   x	
   20”D	
   x	
   56”H      	
  




       HFR	
  	
  
       Machine:	
               	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   48"W	
   x	
   34"D	
   x	
   59"H       	
  
       Tanks	
   Stands        	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   26"W	
   x	
   35"D	
   x	
   70"H        	
  
       Mix-­‐head	
  Power	
  Pack	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
  26"W	
  x	
  20"D	
  x	
  57“H	
  
Reducing	
  maintenance	
  costs
                                           	
  


ROTARY	
  TECHNOLOGY	
                           PISTON	
  TECHNOLOGY	
  
Rotary	
  rebuilds	
  are	
  expensive	
         HFR	
  offers	
  Z	
  series	
  pumps	
  
and	
  require	
  circula/ng	
  mix	
            Rebuild	
  at	
  the	
  facility	
  
heads	
  to	
  mantain	
  pressure.	
            Elimina/on	
  rebuilds	
  
8.000	
  –	
  12.000	
  €	
  investment.	
       No	
  need	
  of	
  back-­‐up	
  pumps	
  
Annual	
  rebuild:	
  2.500	
  €	
  
Addi/onal	
  mix	
  head	
  to	
  maintain	
  
produc/on	
  while	
  mix	
  head	
  is	
  
rebuilt:	
  8.000	
  €	
  
Durability,	
  accuracy,	
  reliability	
  
•    Standardized	
  and	
  Modular	
  System	
  
      –  Closed	
  loop	
  metering	
  system	
  
      –  +/-­‐	
  1%	
  accuracy	
  
      –  1:1	
  –	
  24:1	
  ra/o	
  
      –  Up	
  to	
  50	
  lb/min	
  @	
  3000psi	
  

•    Graco	
  Control	
  Architecture	
  
      –  Standard	
  USB	
  Logs	
  
      –  Op/onal	
  Gateway	
  
              •  Discrete	
  I/O	
  
              •  Ethernet	
  IP	
  
              •  DeviceNet	
  
              •  Profibus	
  
              •  ProfiNet	
  
Shot	
  Accuracy	
  

                                         20 cc/s - 120 cc Shot                                                                                10 cc/s - 120 cc Shot

             190                                                                                                  185
             185                                                                                                  180
                                                          +1%
             180                                                                                                                                              +1%
                                                                                                                  175
             175
             170                                                                                                  170
Weight (g)




                                                                                                     Weight (g)
             165                                                                                                  165
             160                                                                                                  160
             155                                             -1%
                                                                                                                  155                                          -1%
             150
             145                                                                                                  150

             140                                                                                                  145
                   1   2   3    4    5     6     7       8         9   10   11   12   13   14   15                      1   2   3    4    5     6     7       8         9   10   11   12   13   14   15
                                                     Shot Number                                                                                          Shot Number

                               Xbar - 1%       Xbar       Shot         Xbar + 1%                                                    Xbar - 1%       Xbar       Shot         Xbar + 1%
Conclusions
                                        	
  
Customer	
  percep/on:	
  	
  
SILENCE	
  =	
  QUALITY	
  
	
  
NVH	
  solu/ons	
  are	
  a	
  trend	
  in	
  
automo/ve	
  industry	
  
	
  
New	
  HFR:	
  easy	
  to	
  use	
  &	
  mantain,	
  
affordable,	
  smaller,	
  flexible	
  and	
  
accurate.	
  
	
  
Becer	
  ROI	
  (injec/on	
  vs	
  baffles)	
  

Rafael Ortiz - NVH foam equipment for automotive applications

  • 1.
    NVH  foam  equipment  for  automo1ve  applica1ons     RAFAEL  ORTIZ   Solu/ons  Group  Manager   @rafaelor/z00    
  • 3.
    Voice  of  the  customer   Noise:  percep/on  is  everything   Source:  J.D.  Powers  2006  New  Car  Buyer  Survey  
  • 4.
    Quietness  and  quality   Overall  vehicle  sa1sfac1on  directly  correlates  to  overall  interior  quietness  sa1sfac1on.     10 9,66 9 8,89 Ra/ng  Vehicle  Overall  Quality   8,25 8 7,67 7,07 7 6,25 6 5 <5 6 7 8 9 10 Ra/ng  Overall  Interior  Quietness   Source:  J.D.  Powers  2006  New  Car  Buyer  Survey  
  • 5.
    NVH  percep/on   “The  noise,  vibra/on  and   harshness  (NVH)  reduc/on   bring  to  the  customer  not   only  the  percep/on  of  quality   but  durability,  solidity  and   higher  general  sa/sfac/on”   Source:  J.D.  Powers  2006  New  Car  Buyer  Survey  
  • 7.
    NVH  applica/on     Resonance   occurs   within   the   car   sec/ons:  pillars,  cowl  bars,  wheel   wells  &  side  panels.     Many  automo/ve  manufacturers  use  acous/cal  foam  to  minimize   noise  coming  from  /res,  wind,  exhaust  and  engine.    
  • 8.
    NVH  foam  cavity  filling   Baffles   Injected  foam   Two-­‐component   polyurethane   foams.   Close   cell   formula/on   1   to   5   pcf   density   range.   Designed   to   block   noise,   water   &   wind,   forming   a   high   performance  acous/cal  seal  and  preven/ng  the  noise   from  resona/ng.      
  • 9.
    Acous/c  baffles   Specific  tooling  for  each   part   Low-­‐up  front  capital       Unreliable  expansion     Simple  approach       Sealing  performance   Licle  in-­‐plant  space     constraints   Specific  baffle  per   vehicle,  many  part   numbers,  high  inventory   &  slow  /me  to  market  
  • 10.
    Acous/c  baffles   Baffles  are  costly  to  design,  manufacture  &  install  and  oeen   result  in  a  less  than  op/mal  solu/on  
  • 11.
    Injected  foam   3D,  robust  seal  and   improved  NVH       Flexible:  used  on  mul/ple   High  up-­‐front  capital   vehicle  lines  and  carry   costs   over  to  future  lines         Poten/al  facili/es  space   Low  material  cost  and   constraints   reduced  or  eliminated     tooling  costs   Cost  of  ownership       Can  adjust  foam  volume   and  shot  loca/ons  as   required  
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
    NVH  equipment  challenges   High  up-­‐front  capital  costs   Custom-­‐designed  polyurethane  processing   equipment  for  NVH  foam  is  expensive     Poten1al  facili1es  space  constraints     These  sizeable  polyurethane  processing   machines  take  up  a  large  amount  of  space     Cost  of  ownership   Custom  repair  parts  are  expensive.   Specialized  technicians  usually  travel  to   conduct  on-­‐site  maintenance  and  repairs  
  • 15.
    NVH  Solu/ons  –  Betacell   Specialized  custom  design            Long  lead  /mes,  specialized  service  parts          Costly  repairs   Complicated  for  plant  personnel    Longer  trouble  shoo/ng  for  repairs    More  down  /me                      Controls  are  customized  by  cell,  longer  training            Specialized  maintenance            Difficult  to  service  in  field   Foot  print  must  be  considered                      Variable  ra/o:  rotary/linear  pumps                      Automa/cally  adjusts  for  wear                    Risk  of  dispensing  out  of  ra/o  tolerance                        Different  pump  types  –  more  repair  parts                      
  • 16.
    HFR   The  Graco  HFR  metering  system  is  a  standard   modular  design  with  precision  dispensing   capabili/es.     Advanced  &  reliable:  High  quality  meter,  mix   and  dispense  system  that  offers  more   technology  and  func/onality.     Affordable:  a  low  ini/al  investment  allows   you  to  use  acous/cal  foam  applica/ons   where  it  may  not  have  been  possible  before.   Lower  price  than  tradi/onal  custom  systems.       Global  distribu1on    
  • 17.
    Installa/on  size   BetaCell   Machine:                 141”W   x   40”D   x   103”H   Control   Panel:                   95”W   x   20”D   x   56”H   HFR     Machine:                         48"W   x   34"D   x   59"H   Tanks   Stands                       26"W   x   35"D   x   70"H   Mix-­‐head  Power  Pack                          26"W  x  20"D  x  57“H  
  • 18.
    Reducing  maintenance  costs   ROTARY  TECHNOLOGY   PISTON  TECHNOLOGY   Rotary  rebuilds  are  expensive   HFR  offers  Z  series  pumps   and  require  circula/ng  mix   Rebuild  at  the  facility   heads  to  mantain  pressure.   Elimina/on  rebuilds   8.000  –  12.000  €  investment.   No  need  of  back-­‐up  pumps   Annual  rebuild:  2.500  €   Addi/onal  mix  head  to  maintain   produc/on  while  mix  head  is   rebuilt:  8.000  €  
  • 19.
    Durability,  accuracy,  reliability   •  Standardized  and  Modular  System   –  Closed  loop  metering  system   –  +/-­‐  1%  accuracy   –  1:1  –  24:1  ra/o   –  Up  to  50  lb/min  @  3000psi   •  Graco  Control  Architecture   –  Standard  USB  Logs   –  Op/onal  Gateway   •  Discrete  I/O   •  Ethernet  IP   •  DeviceNet   •  Profibus   •  ProfiNet  
  • 20.
    Shot  Accuracy   20 cc/s - 120 cc Shot 10 cc/s - 120 cc Shot 190 185 185 180 +1% 180 +1% 175 175 170 170 Weight (g) Weight (g) 165 165 160 160 155 -1% 155 -1% 150 145 150 140 145 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Shot Number Shot Number Xbar - 1% Xbar Shot Xbar + 1% Xbar - 1% Xbar Shot Xbar + 1%
  • 21.
    Conclusions   Customer  percep/on:     SILENCE  =  QUALITY     NVH  solu/ons  are  a  trend  in   automo/ve  industry     New  HFR:  easy  to  use  &  mantain,   affordable,  smaller,  flexible  and   accurate.     Becer  ROI  (injec/on  vs  baffles)